they hit something while they were flying, but there is such a thing as air debris, ah, it's when you're on the radar or on the map or with your eyes. or they attacked - they attacked on the roof there are internet wires that are distributed or there are repeaters of some kind of mobile phone that they installed, you don't have time to fix it, but it is a few meters still on the roof and when you calculate that something has arrived and you are clinging well there well, the chassis clings to it some uh, well, that's why i'm saying well, there may be something behind these thoughts and facts voiced on the air, yuriy nikolov, project editor, our money, uh, we 're moving on. about the suspicion of the ex-head of naftogaz ukraine andrii koval,

they decided to do such a cleanup, we remember that andrii kobolev was like this, he is suspected of having taken possession of millions of hryvnias in the form of a bonus, 230 million then we remember, we wrote out a bonus not only to him, but also to other employees of the nac after naftogaz won in the stockholm arbitration, let's remember this whole story, let's continue the high-profile embezzlement and finally the suspicion. the specialized anti-corruption prosecutor's office together with nabu detectives took up the investigation of exorbitant bonuses in naftogaz. the former head of naku, andriy kobolev, was already suspected of violating the law in 2018. almost $10 million is how the former official assessed his merits in the case regarding the contract with russian gazprom when the ukrainian side won in the stockholm arbitration as

established by the law enforcement officers, in 2017 kobolev had already written out a bonus for these extraordinary achievements, it was 12.5 million hryvnias, but the head of the naku decided not to stop and rewarded himself again in the current equivalent , the amount of state losses for this episode alone is almost half a billion hryvnias since the 15th we tried to prove that the kobelyaks supported the mk. where did they pull over naftogaz ? it led to enormous damage to the energy security of the country. they also report that during the investigation of kobolev's bonuses, the anti-corruption authorities encountered significant obstacles from the former management of the state-owned company, the officials tried to hide the circumstances of the bonuses and even blocked the investigation's access to the relevant

documentation, and this is far from the first criminal case about embezzlement in the oil and gas industry with the participation of andriy kobelev, last year in february, investigators of the dbr searched the office of the joint-stock company ukrtransgaz, a number of private enterprises and the house of the former chairman of the board of naftogaz, according to data kobolev may have been involved in the illegal removal of large volumes of natural gas from state property for the benefit of fictitious companies. investigators are conducting a pre-trial investigation into the illegal alienation of 35 million cubic meters of natural gas by officials of ukrtransgaz naftogaz of ukraine with the complicity of other persons. ukraine's debt to commercial structures, which arose more than 20 years ago at the end of 1999, a private company ukrenergozbut handed over

418 million cubic meters of fuel to the state ukrtransgaz for transportation to its consumers, ukrtransgaz did not fulfill its obligations and 305 million cubic meters of gas simply disappeared, the question of returning the resource was not resolved until suddenly at the end of 2020 the commercial court of the city of kyiv approves a settlement agreement between four companies behind ukrenergozbut pjsc ukrtransgaz and two unknown companies, finnvest and profigaz, the last i became the owner of three hundred and five million cubic meters of natural gas, investigative journalists established that these companies were fictitious small businesses and constantly changed their registration addresses and managers. at that time, the director of profigaz, anna burova , did not even know that she suddenly became the heir to an astronomical resource, the value of which at the

current exchange rate is over uah 3 billion. i'll go later. well, don't call. the former head of naftogaz, now a suspect in the award case, andriy kobolev, was a direct participant in the gas scheme. he ordered it. lend the subsidiary company ukrtransgaz 305 million cubic meters of state fuel for the transfer to a fictitious company, which legalized the arrangement, and it was after this order that the settlement agreement was activated by the management of naftogaz. in a few months, they resold fuel stolen from the state and threw the ends into the water, law enforcement officers

investigated the device for more than a year, until in in february 2022, they did not visit kobolev with searches, and this case has not yet been brought to court, instead, the investigation was interested in other abuses by the ex-head of naftogaz, including astronomical bonuses in the amount of almost half a billion hryvnias, kobolev himself stated on his social media page that he is now forced to return from abroad back to ukraine regarding the news about the suspicion, understanding that its preparation is taking place, when i was abroad , i immediately returned to ukraine so as not to give a reason for accusations, or did i run away somewhere or i am hiding, i am not going to do this, but i am going to prove my excuse and whether kobolev will be able to prove his innocence this time, when the law enforcement officers finally admitted that by declaring the company’s billion-loss loss every year , the management of naftogaz could withdraw

these same billions to fictitious companies and for exorbitant rewards, the incriminated article 191 of the criminal code of embezzlement embezzlement or possession of property by abuse of official position involves imprisonment for a term of up to 12 years, so the specialized anti-corruption prosecutor's office requires taking the former chairman of the board of naftogaz is in custody, the relevant petition regarding kobolev has already been sent to the anti-corruption court, you mentioned the story with andriy kobolev and now we will discuss it with mark savchuk, the head of the public control council, nabu mark, i congratulate you on your topic, you constantly monitored it, please comment on the story that tetyana showed us shustrov's investigation by journalists - investigation by journalists regarding the work of e-e on naftogaz during the period of andriy kobolev's leadership well, actually, what the

company is accusing him of now devastating and became the most profitable in the history of ukraine, was the largest budget donor , won gazprom in the stockholm arbitration for $ 4.5 billion, here is the result of the arbitration. this is a consequence of our understanding of the management, the new management came and said that the companies that buy gas from naftogaz are not obliged to provide a bank guarantee, and oblgaz izbytyh irtasha bought gas for 2 billion dollars they didn't give money, profits turned out, literenko came out and said that the war started on february 24. the companies bought gas in the winter. well, you can see what the result was. and these are the efficient companies that transferred the money to naftogaz, but

in fact later it turned out that they there were no economic activities, well, in fact , they were created precisely in order to transfer this money there, so look, eh, this is not a business, eh, to me, when they called here , they asked for business deals and premiums, so i am ready to comment on this business, i don’t know i know that since 2018-2018, there have been ongoing cases in which there was no suspicion, yes , the topic is that i will now receive premiums, yes, the premiums are 200,230 million, which were written out based on the results of the stockholm arbitration, this was a great victory, i agree here, but still 230 million e-e were taken as bonuses, and now they say that it is illegal, but you don't consider it illegal, but look, i don't have any case materials in order to tell you the laws

, or it wasn't, well, like, i have more there is no text of the accusation and such as what are the facts in a-a to the prosecutors what? well, there are no documents yet. we can't judge, you can't make a professional assessment, but in essence, in the essence of the case, it absolutely does a-a in fact, it raises three questions three questions a-a the first is what you said in the story that the petition was was sent to the court about what a-a in order to give an arrest. for some reason, the journalist forgot to say that the petition was sent to the deputy behind nimchenko, vasyl ivanovich, who was a deputy, that we a-a demands to the constitutional court to cancel the declaration, that they canceled the declaration, in the end , that's it. there were 11 deputies who in the 18th year are shown there was a law that was voted in the parliament on the recognition of ukrainian sovereignty in donetsk and luhansk regions and this deputy voted against it in the story for some reason they decided not to say

more about it there is time for the 111th article of the state amendment because they fixed the next year, the next step, yes, and the next step is that the premiums have been completed , and because this is the achievement of the entire company, there is one more person in who, according to the detectives and prosecutors , is the highest premium of this limit , which , according to them, is fixed in the law, this is yury vytrenko, and he has a situation that is absolutely identical to that of andrey kobolev , but for some reason he is also among the suspects no, although once again i repeat the situation is absolutely identical, well, like they are absolutely identical, it raised huge questions when i talked with the detective and it turned out that they did not know this, and it was

very interesting because it seems to me that when charges are issued to a person, you need understand the case, it is absolutely obvious that this well, it was as strange as possible, people are in an absolutely identical situation , one suspect, the second is calmly playing, and the third, and this case was investigated for five years , five years, and for some reason, they decided to release the suspicion . when in ukraine there is a competition for members of the supervisory board of naftogaz, and we know that maksymchuk obviously has problems with communication with us, marko, can you hear us ? hello, changes. the previous team, they now participate in the competition for a-a members of the candidate council

. moment, especially for actions on the council. after all, it was the decision of the council to give us bonuses or not to give it. this is not a management decision. this is a decision for us. five years and suspicion was given exactly at the moment when the competition was taking place, this is a few months ago, this is amazing, marko, but the bottom line is that 230 million were taken as bonuses, and the production of our own gas did not increase, although we were promised to increase it, but now it is spilled into us into a national danger because energy security is the key, that's how you see it . you see how she said that if the guys don't do anything, there will be a catastrophe and the government. see we discussed it 350 times. i am very happy

about this in the media because people are told that if you kill and, er, rejoice in populism, there will be trouble. hello, trouble. here, in 2016, he gathered all the gas workers in the cabinet of ministers and said, ok, guys, we are going to raise gas production. they made a long document. on which it was said that the cabinet of ministers will simplify access to licenses, the taxation will be simpler, while we have time to finish this topic, we will continue to observe that from kovalivtsi, the cabinet of ministers, i understood. thank you, mark savchuk was with us project our money, today the national center of the ukrainian house will hold a farewell to the leadership and employees of the ministry of internal affairs of ukraine who died while performing official duties in brovary. the farewell will begin at 11 o'clock

. observe all the events of the farewell ceremony and involve guests involve our journalists with a report from the ukrainian house and watch how it all happens remember the day of the disaster the day of the tragedy and remember those people who unfortunately they have already left us, this is a great loss for ukraine because the leadership of the minister of internal affairs was actually very professional, the people who were there understood what they were doing and what they would have had previous experience for, powerful not just and many people are now writing about what handed them in personally well, in fact, this is a huge loss and minister denys monastyrskyi and his deputies are a bright memory today at 11 a.m. there will be a farewell and a special espresso broadcast, join us, we will remember these people together and hmm, watch the farewell ceremony for now, we continue the cycle

documentaries babylon 13 let's watch together be with the press i like kyiv like this it has become more quiet even in the mysterious melancholic yes because the crowds of people have disappeared many large numbers of cars have disappeared there are no crowds there are no traffic jams you can drive freely you can walk freely in the parks and but i am only confused the price we pay for this silence, yes. what are there soldiers somewhere? they brought all

this stuff on their backs. they are guarding it so that we can live so freely. for example, i tell my students that we are there during the war. opened 15 exhibitions and abroad that we have never in my life, no western galleries, no one would have opened these exhibitions for us yes and everything here magically the doors opened, but i am a student, i mean what is the fee for this yes these soldiers are soldiers’ lives the armed forces of the armed forces of ukraine there yes we all we pay here. that's why i like kyiv, but for sure i don't want it to be such a cruel price. now we're approaching a fantastic place. there's such a photo . this is kyrylivskaya 117. crushed the trolleybus

trolleybuses here are not seen, the windows are broken, they blew out the windows in the library too yes, and it’s march it seems like it was march 14, so well, it’s not so warm and how is the heating by the way, you can see a lot of glass in these houses it is broken, yes. even this one still has fragments of glass here. this one is not completely cleaned. i asked the director of the library. there is such a one. valentina nikitovych. well, how is it? well, she is hoping that the district will allocate some funds. probably after the war but here it is, the reality show of the herd is broken the glass and here are the storefronts well, something has probably been changed here, it was hammered there, it flew away, but from inside our posters

hang student ones, here, please , you have the internet and here people come to use the internet, can you ? well, i want to please you that the exhibition moves to the museum of the history of kyiv, and then the posters are transferred to the archives of the museum of the history of kyiv as a historical fact of such student and artistic resistance toured now the

tour in australia is starting, it has already started in sydney yes, i am grateful to you for your support students and insult our humble ones, well, i don't always say that, i'm sorry, i can see that people are leaving. well, in order not to agree on anything, here we just have a carkalon situation of history, well , that is, it's easter, yes, he's a student, i can't say his name, he's written as nouneim yes, he himself is from mariupol and he disappeared just at the beginning in march, everything just broke up with him, well, and we students in the chat rooms published his

photos, asking, well, we were looking for him, we called to find him, this student was not around for several months, but i, then he er came out of the basement, and here he went into the basement near ukraine , and he came out already in the dnr there under the occupation authorities, but thanking god he is alive, he is my mother, brother, they are alive, well, they are there, uh, well, at least they somehow live there, and he reflected his feelings to me told that how they lived, he earned money by chopping firewood for the mariupol people for heating and cooking, yes and they gave him some pennies well, because he had no family, there were no sources of income yes, and this is also a good situation because in we have one more one very

we have such a strange case. we have a student named nataliya akimova. she disappeared in mariupol since march and nothing is known about her. the association of traveling exhibitions. our exhibition is traveling around the world and in kyiv. now it is moving to a new place, and my car is like a gypsy stagecoach. like a gypsy camp, we are moving, yes, we are moving, yes , she arrived in kraków, she is a research assistant at the vernadskyi library, such a famous art critic, she is from kyiv, she writes about the poster of olena donets. well, she arrived in kraków and called me that i was here what, what can we do, you poster artists, i

heard about the poster and i have it from the first day in my grandfather's gallery, as a pure driver, i say go to him yes, say that budnyk andriy is there, he was exhibited there in the whole gallery there in 90 in the 1990s, when i was studying at the stuppeiking academy in kraków, yes, and she went to him, he said, well, i have a small gallery , and the rent there is very expensive. cooler yes, that's market square there, that's it like yes, but he suggested a newly formed gallery, there are young ambitious people who were promoting themselves and, uh, i made a presentation and directed this deer. she went to the gallery, she called the bell and they say and you can put a product for development there, let's say, within two weeks, for promotion yes, i can. yes , well, a little bit in polish, then a little bit in ukrainian

, and they started to put ducks. yes, they have a young gallery, they want to enter the market there . video from students to tell about their posters well, i, uh, how about students, what can be gathered, but how to force a girl who is sitting in the basement and into the bomb shelter, she can't put on any make-up there, do her hair there, make decent clothes, well, in some jackets-hats, yes, how it is possible well, this kind of work has started there, i tell the girls, the girls are there well, be a weasel there somehow shoot there well, let it be in the bomb shelters, but that’s the way it is yes, we lived part of our lives in these bomb shelters yes , even after all the poster exhibitions they decided to make one exhibition, they called it a shelter, ukr is written in latin, well, that is, i am

here as a shelter. the place where we work , well, in the basement there, yes, and a shelter as ukr-ukrai, which protects europe from this abomination from the invasion, and by the way, we have on the posters there are qr-codes, they send to the site and there is an explanation with a translation in ukraine in yellow, it will be in yellow, but it was a separate block that we lived in, well, i think that was the first time to think about it, so then your task is

to hang up friends, wait, i will do it again now and this putin too but no, well, if until there would have been another putin, we would have hung him uhu, well, he is just strong and technically he is under my control and there she told me more and there should be such posters that are slapped from a great distance yes, let's assume volodka is there, the poster is nice but well, it doesn't work at all from a distance, but here you see an approach here, 20 meters, there 10-15, yes, and they should work at a distance, well, it seems normal. well, the one above is not possible, yes, this ball

. well, everything is fine, let's get dressed my work was already there i say i didn't make it to kyiv and my work was already present at the second part of this exhibition in the library on kirillivska andriy viktorovych 117 i am a librarian i remembered that i have such a book in the library i found it and i really liked it this is a lithography, probably some kind of 60s, i didn’t know, but here you see, here are the motifs, somehow, the legs, i tried there , i had the first ones, now here in the gallery, here are my first such sketches, she is here even more, i don’t know, i’m alive and did everything

still more graphic and now who do you see on april 12, it was still only in the project and this is what was already coming out, i already made a more graphic sketch and was inspired by such classic ones, you see, i took some elements with such classic drawings, which are guardian angels i really liked it at school, i remembered what we did there. yes, when i was at the opening, i generally gave interviews and already after. well, it was already then, then i really felt this impulse of how people write to me and say thank you and such what are we thank you for support, because it turned out to be really important for me, this is a creative process, i'm in it constantly, these posters, it's like, uh, it happens to us all the time, i think what's going on with this, and people were really delighted that i'm saying that art exists during the war that we

try to encourage and support and it really helps. that's the best thing because when you're a designer, you understand that i'm not going to go to the front with a machine gun, there's zero point in me trying to help, and here's your help . everyone has to do what they can and that's the most important thing this here can be dropped behind there you can put such ears on them and then it will be more even, how much fun there is 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 well, actually, in the first days of the war, i was probably one of the initiators of the creation of creative resistance in this student association and which is engaged in anti-war activities, you can say crying . first, i have a master's degree.

it's about dante, about hell, and then they appeared during the war sometime in march. here's this work during the occupation. there are such bright stories in my head that maybe will be in the future implemented, as i already said. i lived near chernobaivka, 2 km from chernobaivka, and every time i saw a warehouse as a child. so it's hard, it's hard after what you've been through , especially as a person who came from the occupation. i can't quite react calmly and tell certain events and all the more so to show them on the fortress on paper is like art