the purchase of other equipment is all that area, and in the energy industry today it is also unknown what is being purchased there, it is because of that that it is important that the government, which is empowered by law during martial law, understands its responsibility so that it, i emphasize once again, do not wait until the law enforcement officers poke their noses at what is going on or there are proceedings but i am sure that in the coming months, and maybe even weeks, we will hear a lot of interesting things, because many things have already begun to go beyond the limits of what is possible or everything is allowed or allowed because of that we see that searches were carried out in the regional administrations regarding humanitarian aid, it is unfortunately the fault of our officials that the wave of aid to ukraine is receding because many foreign partners simply sincerely see how it is inserted here, how it is

stored and distributed here, and people simply give up and everything falls on those volunteers who, at their own expense and at the expense of their connections, bring ukraine, help the front, help with internal displacement , etc., but about the guards they are doing their job here i think that the security service of ukraine, which is directly subordinate to the head of state as the supreme command, should not have been heard here, or do they also give certain information to the head of the president's office? i think that they draw conclusions and should act in advance, because if it does not reach someone, if someone thinks that during martial law, it is not possible to carry out operational measures or other measures, then they are deeply mistaken, and these last facts are a testimony to that. i think that against some persons who resigned or were recommended to write a statement, there will also be initiates criminal proceedings or they will be held in the near future, invitations to law enforcement agencies to

testify. this is also not excluded. oleksandr antonyuk, political expert, leading consultant of the analytical group of the main organizational management of the verkhovna rada apparatus, mr. oleksandr, congratulations, glory to ukraine , glory to the heroes, i wish you health, let's talk about personnel changes in the president's office directly eh. i probably didn't think 5 years ago that we would talk about eh exactly such rotations in exactly such an institution but nevertheless, we understand that the influence of individual representatives of the op in our country is quite large. let's be frank. and here president zelensky replaced the deputy head of the up kyryl tymoshenko. it could be that tymoshenko can head one of the regional military administrations in our country. maybe that's why he traveled around the ukrainian regions, looking, so to speak, for what he would like more, where he could realize himself more, but mr. oleksandr, what does this indicate in your opinion, that is, he could already

to accumulate such a level well, there is also toxicity for society somewhere, because many not very pleasant media stories were connected with tymoshenko. is it possible that there are other reasons why, after all, he was retired? i think that your question already has an answer, well, answering even about such rumors that he can lead something, well, it will probably be such a big nonsense, considering that this is one of these officials, uh, well, from the office of the president, that is, from the patronage service, who got into more than one uh, scandal from journalistic investigations, let's remember mykhailo mykhailovych mentioned the story for humanitarian aid. well, for example, let's remember the cars that the united states of america handed over in order for our servicemen to have the opportunity to carry out humanitarian missions. that is, this is one scandal, well, that is, about the undeclared

new porsche car there kayan, how is he there? what kind of person was he there? and one more story, plus an internal confrontation between uh-uh in the president's office, because it's no secret that he practically entered into a confrontation with head of the president's office andrii smak i think that in this context it is necessary to consider why kyrylo tymoshenko was dismissed today, well, we still call it dismissal, it is not a resignation, because the resignation here i have to quote valery chalogu, who clearly and correctly stated that the resignation is when a person announces that it is not according to the party line there, the team goes into the opposition of the fact that this is banal, they are fired, and i think that not without the participation of the national party, not without the participation of the nabu, because they are really active now and we see with you, how practically

the new season begins will be more corruption based on the principle of cleansing by the authorities regardless of whether they are representatives of the ruling team or some other, mr. oleksandr, i would like to ask you to tell us a little more about what kind of mutual relations there are in the office well, we thought yes , if there is a head office, and he appoints or advises the president from one or another of his deputies. in your opinion, what was tymoshenko's strength and how, in general, could this affect the internal ukrainian political palette? i think that as of today, the internal ukrainian political palette , in this case, it will definitely not be reflected, well, except perhaps for the next telegrams, i'm sorry for such an expression, but i certainly won't call it another way, that is, when some positive bloggers will pour dirt on other positive bloggers and, accordingly, tangential tangents to

one or another team, the first house. i think when and in personnel appointments and in financial flows, because i think to you, mykhailo, i have to lie, but tymoshenko was associated with the media space, that is, the formation of an occasional politicians, that is, even from uh, and the redaction policy of well-known news is from kyrylo tymoshenko's prosecutor's office, and if we also talk about his relationships there in the field of large-scale construction, that is, we understand which side we are looking at, which financial flows andriy uh, yarmak, he is after all demonstrates such skill, such professionalism, if the apparatchik of such games, that is, if tymoshenko worked with regional military administrations directly, then andriy yarmak is still such a virtuoso intriguer in cabinet intrigues, and in principle we can see that it is his another such victory for cleaning up your

competitors and for the sphere of influence. and i also assume it for personnel and financial flows . thank you for connecting with us on skype. deputy chairman of the verkhovna rada committee on social policy and protection of veterans' rights of ukraine, reserve lieutenant general of the militia, mr. mykhailov, talking about new trends. i want to refer to the arrestee, but he was almost the first to write a corresponding statement or was asked to write. that is, we understand that the internal review of the presidential team is starting, that is, the head of the regional administrations, the deputy head of the office, we do not know what will happen next. what do you think will happen now, in particular about consolidation or, on the contrary, mutual fear

of the internal team of the president, and how it can affect, for example, relations with the parliament. where is the truth and where is the lie, but this scandal proved that we lack tools that can, so to speak, balance the situation, because the committees of the verkhovna rada will be involved in the inspection of purchases . of the president demonstrates that some people have completed their tasks at some stage, and the president clearly indicates to all of them and society that there are no permanent people in one or another position, and this, in my opinion, is a positive signal that everything was done on time according to some

individuals is another matter, but i emphasize once again that this is a positive signal from the president of ukraine that he is ready to admit, including his mistakes, and to point out that he does not have his own. someone else has violated his own, come on, answer to the law, will it happen that everyone bears responsibility so that no matter what someone else's law, but everything is my own, i think i will show the investigation of criminal proceedings not only for me, but i emphasize that it seems to me to be the most distant from the current government and other law enforcement agencies, myself in front of the office the prosecutor general and the security services, who are still subordinate to the president according to the current legislation, that is why this is such a signal to all those who can still remember and did not set out on the path of violating the current law, this is

clear and very important for everyone else to understand. is this the last dismissal of course not, if we talk about the arrestee, well, he had the same position as the resignation, well, his mouth announced what the officials could not say, he coped, but it seems to me that for a certain period he began to play his game and uh, this game has been played sometimes and it’s a shame for the state , because of that he was fired, maybe too late. and all the others. well, i think that some ministers should have resigned, uh, the minister of energy, and this is being discussed today on the sidelines of uh, the government and the parliament maybe the minister of education, maybe the minister of sports, maybe the ministers of strategic industries, but it's all possible. yes, maybe, but in principle. today, if we speak comprehensively, the government, in most cases, has not succeeded in its task

. that's the main thing. we remember even before in february of last year, shmyga never presented the government's program in the parliament - this is the first such government. then a large-scale war began, and then he didn't fulfill another task, and what the conditions of the martial law require, the transfer of the entire economy to war rails, he did it of course not, but it's a matter of the monomajority - it's a matter of the president. apparently, he is so convenient, but some investigations may suggest that the prime minister of ukraine can be changed in our country. they walk around and are so audibly interesting. i would just like to follow fresh tracks, they say. read the reaction of the european union to the wave of resignations in ukraine against the background of accusations of corruption, the representative of the european commission anna pisoneru commented on the wave of resignations in the

ukrainian government, we took into account the message that the national anti-corruption bureau is investigating the cases. you know the general rule that we do not comment on ongoing investigation, but we welcome the fact that the ukrainian authorities are taking this seriously, at the same time, according to her, as part of the process of acquiring membership in the european union , further strengthening is expected from ukraine fight against corruption, in particular at the highest level, the representative of the european commission noted that after the publication of the eu opinion, ukraine took several measures in the field of anti-corruption, in particular , it is about the appointment of the head of the specialized anti- corruption prosecutor's office. first, by the makers more and more often well, and secondly , they become those who collect positive evaluations from our partners and we must give credit to the political expert

oleksandra antonyuk is on the phone with us. well, accordingly, i would like to ask mr. oleksandr if the clouds are really approaching and our prime minister is in seconds. oleksandr connects and the connection is like this, no , the situation is a little bit unstable, really, the government, the ukrainian government, we understand that many questions have accumulated, you know, we had a conversation with oleksiy orzhev, ex-minister of energy and environmental protection. well, we asked him questions . to what extent did the government do everything possible in the context of the energy crisis in the context of what is the path he chose to minimize all those consequences and to which oleksiy remarked that it was hardly about choosing a path, we are just trying to solve the problems that appear on the go oleksandr antonyuk is in touch with us oleksandr, you hear well, that's what we say about our government and its future fate , on the one hand, we understand that the government did

an extremely important mission , that is, the peacetime government entered the war and did not let the situation fall apart. we thank him for that, but now they appear, so to speak various scandals and so on. well, maybe you have some inside information on whether clouds are coming over the prime minister and in general. if so , what would be the configuration of the new government? well, i will say that it is obvious that the fate of the prime minister will depend on how the case should proceed according to lozynsky's plan, obviously because now the person does not have enough space , it is very seriously related to him and, accordingly, to this scandal. it may really cost, respectively, the career of the locals. is this one story, another story, we will see how much in general, most of the ministries will keep their students because if we see that in the

future such scandalous processes will continue, that is, what you and i have been observing in recent days, and they will acquire this resonance, then it is better to see that the question of the resignation of the government will absolutely arise again, it will simply be a question of his common sense . i think that even after these scandals, to be honest, i even thought that this question might come before the ukrainian parliament with the end of the result , even when i watched the video appeal volodymyr zelenskyi, it must be admitted that despite the fact that he was clearly preparing this appeal, but her emotions were felt, even this element of irritation was visible. i understand perfectly well that such scandals. they definitely do not strengthen our position regarding international support. they can definitely create several serious bureaucratic problems . prerequisites that may accordingly have later and

in the future, that is, take place in our further plans, not only there in the reconstruction plans in ukraine, first of all for this help that the front needs today. therefore of course, today's urgent issue is strengthened parliamentary control, and it is already visible that there must be an interaction between the parliament and the government, and i am convinced that if parliamentary control restores this somehow, as provided for in the constitution, this is also foreseen by the law on the status of a people's deputy, then we will succeed. the number of scandals is still students well, well, of course, history is so important, and they decided that during martial law, civil servants can travel outside of ukraine purely for business purposes is the business trip good or bad? who

will it concern, mr. mykhailo? of course. take a rest, excuse me , it turns out that there are such facts, that is, in addition to the conscience , some people still need to be whipped, that is, in this case, this is the decision of the national security council, which was legalized by the president of ukraine because, in my opinion, this is the right decision, the only one that should not they abused those who will approve the business trip of this or that official, because it is also, as they say, a double-edged sword, you can collect documents and the cabinet of ministers will refuse you, or you can ask for one, the old ones must also apologize to the cabinet, for example, comments must be submitted and formalized business trips according to the established model

, the leadership of the parliament, which will be at the end of the day, that is the way it is now, it's just that there are exceptions, and according to the current legislation, people's deputies are allowed to go abroad under martial law and in other matters because of that, i believe that this is the right decision . although it is late. thank you, mr. mykhailo oleksandr antonyuk, for contacting us. i would like to clarify, mr. oleksandr, in your opinion, what the new configuration of the stability of the government in our country could be. or other abuses, we do not know how far everything will go, but in any case, the situation must also be stabilized. well, in any case, that is, we are talking about a minimum reserve bench, yes. and if there really will be a new configuration of the government, what kind of plan are things? or

political expediency or how it should be right well, obviously, taking into account the crisis situation in which the government still finds itself, it is necessary to call things their gnomes, but i am still inclined to think that now it is necessary to find there are definitely such in ukraine and possibly previous ministers who worked in previous governments. well, let's remember the government of arseniy yatsenyuk, for example. there were a lot of meaningful and powerful personnel, and it was arseniy petrovych. one's political ambitions and the reality is to attract people from such and such a plan today and probably such to form this government, the government of martial law, we call it so because the task of the prime minister is also to have communications with his colleagues, other chickens, that's not

ruled out everything the president should have done. a similar situation should exist in the parliament. is there a small number of people's deputies in the parliament who conduct well, speak english well, and who , in principle, demonstrate their e-e the results are in line with these people, that is, these coalitions must be formed, i.e., each role and responsibility must be assigned, because today the task is to win this war, throw out the occupiers from the territory, and only then can we return to political schedules. today exactly in ukraine not to this policy and not to those runaways, but everyone involved in corruption, that is, in my opinion, it seems to me, taking into account that during martial law, it was canceled well, not necessarily the procedure for transparency, a lot of things that were laid and had these corruption risks, it is obvious for us, in general, for anti-corruption bodies today, there is a very large amount of work in order to check and almost everyone related to certain decisions to the question

of any contract or any paper at the time of e- corruption risks, because i would like to finish one thought, just understand that we are fighting an external enemy, but looting and corruption are no less, of course, an enemy for the ukrainian people. thank you, mr. oleksandr, briefly, mr. mykhailo. do you see prospects for the creation of some kind of government of mutual political trust, i don't know, maybe he is such a romantic and idealist as mr. oleksandr, but in fact, at the moment, i agree with him. that a government should be created from experts, regardless of political preferences , because today politics is postponed in side, as far as i am concerned, it should be experts, the government can be called national rescue, national unity or resistance, that is, because the challenge is the same for all of us, but this will not happen, and now the supreme commander, the

president of the state has full power and today there is no parliamentary control as such, because both the government and the parliament today are de jure and de facto subordinates of the president of the state, no matter how it looks in a parliamentary presidential republic, because of that everything depends on one person, it is important that the supreme commander is aware of the responsibility which today is titanic on him alone, i wish him that he coped with these challenges after all because the fate of our country depends on it thank you we thank oleksandr antoniuk, a political expert who joined our broadcast well, it's probably worth noting that january 24 is the international day of education, let's end our analytical hour on the link from the studio oleksandr kondratyuk, an expert on educational issues, the founder of the all-ukrainian educational company set stop, we congratulate oleksandr, glory to ukraine

, congratulations, we play the word well here i would like to start with the fact that history is not too mandatory in our school curriculum, there is such a huge question mark, what is this in the school curriculum, i will correct it a little at the time of admission to higher education, of course i apologize yes there is such a situation of the type of excellent mandatory from this story, but it is not yet certain why it is not certain, because in the last 5 months you will receive about 20 different news from official sources that directly contradict each other, for example, in september, they approved the mandatory order the external examination in november was about a multi-test, but out of the four mandatory subjects, then they said, let's do some kind of public discussion, where they say, like, three, we will offer, of course, people chose three subjects, and it's kind of like introducing what it actually means. first of all, there is an officially signed order dated february 26. about the four mandatory subjects, everything

else. what is happening now is only such proposals, and the only thing that is added from the proposal of seriousness is that there are several educational authorities who said this together that it is known for sure about the multitest, it will be the toughest of all exam times, that is, for all 15 years, this test will be the toughest, what is offered is a profile-level task, where, in contrast to last year, when there were essentially all standard classes, today there are four they offer four profile -level tasks in mathematics where there is no answer at all and it is written manually. six such tasks in physics, six in chemistry are offered in english , a total of 32 tasks. practically all of them will not be written by hand . won with what had passed a-and the same complication from history instead of the promised four hundred years will make up the period for which you need to know the history of hundreds of

years, that is, practically the entire course. thus, in in principle, this is definitely the most difficult exam. it is known that there will definitely be a limit for not passing. the minimum such score is at the level of 130. we all remember that the composition of the zno is difficult . and it was 100 points. well done, we congratulate those who passed such people. there were 31% in mathematics who did not pass. this limit was also drawn up, but which was canceled because it was only in the external examination. but in fact it was re-introduced under a different name and already last year 37% did not submit mathematics, which became a new record this year, the limit will also be called the minimum score for the meaning of submitting documents is the same, it’s just that once you needed 100 points, and now 100 is given to everyone, but it’s like 5 hryvnias in the past, when it was enough for you, 5 hryvnias and you bought a coca-cola, and now it’s just not enough and you need 20 for 2 hryvnias you could be completely happy

and for a long time, that is, friends dropped two hryvnias each and the evening was a success, but here the moment is such that we will have an average score on school certificates, the story is serious because school scores on the certificate have always been a motivator for that to support academic discipline in the school, and here we see that it will not be taken into account. am i wrong , school balls have never played a big role in the last five years, perhaps, and now they really won't play any role at all, so if you speak frankly, there is no connection of the school to the multitest does not exist in the same way as you asked the question from the very beginning about the obligation of history, ah, it is strange that in a country where there is a war, history is proposed to be made optional, but what is interesting is if someone took this news as a fact that there definitely will be no history mandatory and there will be only three disciplines with this kreuz test that i described, it’s still not so yesterday or

the day before yesterday, the minister of education said on the air of the tv channel that we were basically in favor of history. it’s just that the public didn’t want to raise these questions at all . back necessarily because it is clear to everyone that when this issue will be raised by the verkhovna rada, when the new proposed list will be considered, then of course someone will already raise the question why history is not necessary and most likely it is the people even the parents themselves believe that the entrants continue to prepare for history because everyone understands that with a high probability they will definitely do it again a-a therefore, this is a big question that confuses parents, these three subjects that i described are much tougher and with four profile in mathematics with an open answer, it is two minutes per question, it is four times less than in the external examination, and the difficulty will be accordingly. it is so serious this year, the president has definitely worse scores than in previous years, that is, you know, the people who developed it are probably very good

they are playing chess, they set traps , the public voted and said give us subjects and they fell into this trap because there are three subjects, this means that the 180 minutes offered will simply be divided not into four, but into three disciplines, which means that it will be much more difficult, more questions and much more difficult questions, oleksandr, we will ask our editors will contact you again in the near future, an extremely important and interesting topic oleksandr kondratyuk, an expert in educational programs, the founder of the all-ukrainian educational company setsat, was working now live mykhailo tsimbalyuk, people's deputy of ukraine, deputy chairman of the verkhovna rada committee on social policy and protection of veterans' rights, worked in our studio of the espresso tv channel. well, reminders. well, our colleagues will now remind us what exactly we are gathering for . i am iryna koval, mother, wife, presenter of the

espresso tv channel. and more i am a volunteer, our soldiers at the front need a lot of things every day, and that is why it is part of my life. today is helping the armed forces of ukraine, and i am very grateful to my colleagues for supporting me in this, of course, for a tv host the main job is to inform people as disgustingly as possible, as truthfully as possible, now it is mainly information about the war, the war has entered the lives of each of us, and we want one victory and are working towards victory with all our might. what you do with your own hands and it will go to the front line will save the lives of our soldiers each of you can help even a small contribution to support the army

saves the lives of our soldiers and brings our victory thank you for being with us for the whole second half of today, then the evening at espresso continues, our colleagues are now bringing to your attention the verdict serhiy rudenko glory to ukraine is a program verdict my name is serhiy rudenko good day and good health to all today january 24, 335 days of heroic against the ukrainian people to the russian occupiers, the deputy minister of defense of ukraine vyacheslav shapovalov resigned due to the scandal with the purchase of food for the ukrainian army, during the night the fighters of the armed forces of ukraine destroyed three russian k-52 helicopters and analysts of the american institute