[000:00:00;00] medical services well, the deputy minister of health 16 to 19 years old ulyana suprun novels i congratulate you good day, mr. roman , i didn't want to . more broadly, so expand this question, the question of medicine, to what extent is it currently coping with new well, challenges, for which we definitely did not prepare, so challenges of war at all levels. how do you currently assess the state of medicine and its readiness to respond to these challenges in many countries and regions in ukraine, the situation of health care today is completely different. that is, we understand what medical care is now and the state of its provision in baku. for example, in kherson

, zaporizhzhia, kharkiv. for example, in kyiv , lviv, or chernivtsi. today or a completely destroyed e-e health care system or severely damaged and the information here is open , it actually varies a lot because we hear numbers from 300 to 800 medical facilities that today are actually either completely destroyed or so seriously damaged e- is at the same time, we are watching the fact that we have such a growing avalanche of people who have greatly injured their mental health, and the number of such people will be more and more, it will grow and how to deal with it in the future, well, for today, i think not yet everyone understands to the end, including in the central bodies of the executive power, we have a lot of

internal transfers of people today, which means that the capacities of health care institutions, let's say in the rear, which provide this medical care, are not always at 100 % there with they are managed, that is why most of such assistance is provided in such large cities, in large centers, and here in the city, er, in the rear , and in such large coordinated centers, the provision of medical assistance, well, it is extremely important. so, i am not really a fan of narratives about everything being lost or that it everything is bad i'm good because something is happening and i see that many of the processes that we started there four or five years ago are really working today well, not exactly according to the model that

we saw at that time in peacetime i i emphasize, but you didn't come to ask. we didn't succeed, they didn't give us the opportunity to finish it, but they started and the processes started, and the primary link of medicine was also reformed. how do you evaluate these changes, how much did they help the system to withstand and now respond to these challenges ? if compare be-be- this attack was there as early as 92,000 years ago, when there was still an old system of medicine there, and now, well, look , i am sure that if we were now fully guilty, we would have met many more today. even this despite the fact that on

today, in fact, well, our main idea that the money goes to the patient does not work properly. because in war conditions, funds are allocated for one 12 budget, and in fact, it slightly distorts this idea, which was, well, of course not completed, let's say the procedure of actually reforming health care institutions at the hospital level and this is of course well, if in the composition at the same time we understand that the minimum funding that we received today i will remind you that we laid one this year a little more a dollar, we can get some kind of qualified or high-quality medical care, well, it’s almost impossible to compare what you understood in the czech republic for one

thousand dollars, yes, 10 times more than thousands , see now the system has been exhausted for several years by covid, now the war, how can we keep it all so that it does not fall how do you do you evaluate it or vice versa? maybe these challenges are hardening and modernizing in flight. yes, it is 100%, it is happening because a new social demand is being formed, a new social contract is being formed, and i am sure that people will not want to see another day post-soviet medicine in the form they found it in, let's say, this pre-war period, that is, they will want changes even more here , they will want even more that what they see in the west succeed, and

they are convinced that in this case it will be easier for us, let's say, to implement changes in the clear they wanted to do with a connection, isn't it, roman, can you be there to fix the sound a little bit, we can't hear you, it seems that we heard better at the beginning, and of course the question about readiness of course i will repeat none of us was prepared for the horror that is now is happening, which was caused and started by muscovy, but this is our reality , in which we had to live, unfortunately for all our generation, our children, and we continue, we need to prepare for the fact that these challenges still remain , e.e. medicine has faced and doctors, our specialists, too, with what met before, these polytraumas are specific. yes, burns

are specific because, well, it is unlikely that at the medical university, someone was told how to save people who were injured from rockets , whether it was in a fire in a shopping center, that's why now it's price challenges and our doctors how difficult it is for them to cope with it and, in general, that we have specialists with such problems that it is difficult for everyone to cope with it. that is why we, like you, have now focused our main efforts, including myself, on the training of new staff of new doctors who will be useful as at the front as well as in the rear, and here it is important to divide the provision of this medical care, let's say the provision of this medical care, and let's say the emergency medical care that each of us can provide at the level of what happened , for example. for example, in brovary there or in some other city. in the military zone

action, but there really is something urgently needed to be done in order to save life until the time until the emergency medical help arrives. about the fact that hmm, the first is for all those willing and willing who, er, have a desire in this direction to acquire relevant knowledge, there are relevant courses and to pass them. he told me about this in front of me and if we talk about high specialized care , what you touched on is that today we have a lot of field injuries, that is, a person who is brought in and lies down on the operating table has damaged, let's say, the heart and liver, and there, let's say, lungs only internal

organs, and possibly limbs and a head injury , this is definitely, well, if it were to pose to our specialists, well, such quite serious challenges in terms of working with such polytraumas and providing qualified medical help, i will tell you because i know that our specialists cope with this very, very well, because according to the assessments of western specialists who, let's say, experts give this assessment, they say that these are extremely well-prepared people who, well, do not get lost in such in critical situations and correctly perform the treatment protocol, mr. roman, and i also want to ask about the training, clarify for whom the training is and i wanted to ask you if we should now put this topic a little higher and make this training

very massive so that every ukrainian is ready for situations that actually happen, yes, and medically, medically, this training at the community level, at the school level, for students of different classes, for teachers, in general, for everyone , this is such a general medical training. yours is from the practical side, well, for example, something similar to what happened in brovary happens and we are nearby, so the first reaction is to pass by, the second reaction is to simply watch what is happening, the third our reaction is to take part in the provision of this even before qualified medical assistance . well, until the ambulance arrives and it is possible to save a person's life . yes, what can we see

? we can see respiratory arrest, well, some kind of emergency condition in which we somehow had a very short time to learn how to do it today , there is a lot of it both on a volunteer basis and at medical institutions, etc. for example, at our lviv national medical university has relevant courses, there are relevant announcements on this topic, the only question here is how much a person has the desire to learn these things, but in the end, i will say for sure the most important thing, such a disaster can happen to your child and your wife and your nearest and dearest a person dear to you therefore, we must definitely look at this problem from this angle roman yalyk i thank you very much for joining the ex-deputy minister of health of ukraine, everyone should be ready, unfortunately, it can happen now

with everyone thank you for watching and this is a self-government program because our life and our salvation depends only on us be on demand cinema television port music education free people have a choice choose what you want on megogo join the community with a ukrainian view of the world become a sponsor of the youtube channel espresso and this is access to exclusive content, personal thanks, pinned comments , special icons and the possibility of personal communication with the espresso team, click

sponsor and become part of the community with from a ukrainian point of view, the war raised its head again in europe, reminding us of the darkest hours of our history. franz 24 constantly covers the events in ukraine. our team on the ground and in the studio will inform you about the dynamics of events. this is the most current news from franz 24 in ukrainian on espresso mykola veresen vitaly portnikov and the main topics of the week if god forbid really tactical nuclear weapons are used against ukraine, it will definitely change the world history, problems, analysis and personalities, we are waiting for john gerbs, the former ambassador to the united states in ukraine thank you for the invitation, you have questions, you will get answers, so the question is how to understand the sports of september every friday at 21:30 on espresso, watch this week

's program judicial control with tetyana shustrova why the congress of judges elected unscrupulous candidates to the vrp, i provided all the documents that confirm the legality of receiving money from the mother and how the newly elected members explain their connections with the terrorist state of the russian federation and my sister periodically goes there congratulations you are watching judicial control i am tatyana shustrova the supreme council of justice again the authorized key body of the judicial system, which is responsible for the professionalism, impartiality and integrity of the entire judicial corps, now has 15 members out of the required 21 and finally has a quorum, and therefore begins to perform its duties. the 19th congress of judges of ukraine appointed eight members of the council for with their quota and the names of those appointed

, they surprised us and some even shocked us . members of the supreme council of justice and how, despite their opaque fortunes and numerous scandals, they managed to get to the highest body of judicial governance, we will tell about all this today, but first, before the news, the heads of the representatives of the embassies of the g7 countries and the european union in ukraine gave the president's office recommendations on further steps in judicial reform in particular, they relate to the continuation of the reform, taking into account the unblocking of the work of the high council of justice and the restarting of the high qualification commission of judges, as a result of which seven expressed hope

that ukraine will make further progress in the judicial reform and congratulated the election and eight members of the supreme anti-corruption court announced the verdict of the judge of the kyiv administrative court oleksandra braginia. she was found guilty of intentional failure to declare property in 2020 and 21. the conviction cannot receive an electronic digital signature, and while approving dozens every day, bragina signed them with the same digital signature, the judge even submitted filed a lawsuit against the national agency for the prevention of corruption in the district administrative court of kyiv and demanded that declarations be accepted in paper form. at that time, the lawsuit was satisfied , however, the court appealed the decision in the court of appeal. in the end, the investigation came to the conclusion that, according to the law , reporting one's wealth in court is prevented by

non-religious beliefs and banal desire to hide property, now judge olexandra pragin has to pay a fine of uah 51,000 and is deprived of the right to hold positions for which mandatory submission of a declaration with on february 1, four courts in the kherson region, which were forced to stop working due to the temporary russian occupation , the supreme court of ukraine issued a corresponding order , so the work of the kherson court of appeal, as well as the belozersky velikolexandrivsky and novovorontsov district courts of the kherson region, despite the full-scale war , ukraine managed to hold a competition last year to the supreme council of justice, which

ten members left at once on the eve of the russian invasion what made one of the most important bodies of the judiciary powerless, and it was extremely untimely, in particular, due to the fact that the supreme court is the only body of the judicial system that is authorized to appoint and dismiss judges, including judges of traitors who in the temporarily occupied territories went over to the side of the enemy and until the moment of release continue to receive salary at the expense of ukrainian taxpayers. the supreme council of justice must also appoint a new composition of another important body of the higher qualification commission, so the integrity of the members of the supreme council of justice directly depends on whether corruption will be eradicated from the judicial system of ukraine, the chairman of the board of the de jure foundation, mykhailo zhirnakov, told us that it was necessary to hold a congress of judges to elect eight new members of the supreme council of justice.

and you did not form the council of justice . in this way, further progress in judicial reform and european integration would also fail , because among the requirements under number one related to our european integration , the higher judiciary consists of twenty-one ten members are elected by the congress of judges of ukraine, two are appointed by the president, two are elected by the verkhovna rada , two more are elected by the congress of lawyers, two are delegated by the all-ukrainian conference of prosecutors, and two more are elected by the congress of scientists and representatives of legal highers. the council of justice was evaluated by the ethical council, specially created based on the recommendations of international partners and in accordance with the requirements of the eu, consisting of three ukrainian judges nominated by the council of judges, as well as a judge

of the court of appeal of england and wales, a retired former judge of the supreme court of the state of massachusetts and a former prosecutor general of the republic of estonia, the ethics board checked all applicants for compliance with the criteria of professional ethics and integrity due to inconsistency , many candidates were screened from the back, but not all of them, some, despite their extremely dubious reputation, managed to break through and to take the coveted chair in the vrp , positions for the next four years were taken by yuliya bokova, alla kotlevets, olga popikova , oleksandr sasevich, hryhoriy usyk, tetyana bondarenko, olena cowboy and serhiy burlakov, the ethics council proposed a total of 16 people for appointment, and the congress of judges managed to choose the worst candidates, the participants in high-profile scandals, who have a dubious reputation and biography, as well as considerable fortunes that cannot be explained by official income, to name

all eight members as new. there are questions and rain about their property and about their e-e about other things, how successful it was to update the supreme council of justice can be judged by their first decisions and this is already a lot of things, this is the election of the deputy head, this is also the reaction to the state anti-corruption policy. this is a new member of the high council of justice, a judge of the civil court of cassation as part of the supreme court, serhiy burlakov . do you consider yourself virtuous? yes, i believe that it will be virtuous. because i meet all the criteria for integrity , the ethical council declared me virtuous, my standard of living corresponds to my income and expenses, however, the biography of a new

member of the vrp indicates the opposite, it is close are associated with kharkiv millionaire and deputy of the ninth convocation oleksandr feldman, a former member of the already banned pro-russian party opzh feldman is known for having voted for the dictatorial laws on january 16, 2014, which actually caused and led to the escalation of conflicts during the revolution of dignity in 17-18 years , burlakov actively cooperated with the offeng family and represented their interests, and from this we can also draw conclusions about the values ​​of this candidate , in particular, burlakov received powers of attorney from fe members of his family burlakov does not deny his ties to feldman, notes that he was his lawyer before he became a judge, the relationship was exclusively business when i practiced law before the suspension of my license to practice law, he was my client and members of his family were my

clients in us there was a relationship between a lawyer and a client in 2018, a new member of the supreme council of justice, serhiy burlakov, managed a bulgarian firm and, according to the declaration, received nothing for it, an expert of the anti -corruption center, halyna chyzhik, believes that the judge is possible hid his earnings, this is a very strange story, because in fact he agreed to provide serious services to manage the company, but he did it free of charge, or he was only listed in the register as a nominal manager, and this is also a question of integrity, or he actually received some funds, but hid them. therefore these are also the questions that the ethics council should have asked him, it is impossible to explain the wealth of the burlakov family, which does not match the official income, for example, the judge's mother

was able to purchase an apartment in 2018 with an area of ​​almost 40 m² in boryspil, kyiv region, having as of 2017 an income of uah 29,000 and another uah 217 in savings serhiy burlakov forgot to indicate the value of this apartment to his mother, however, we are sure that the real estate cost is definitely more expensive than uah 29,000, very often it is actually judge bosch, candidates in the court they do it in order not to explain where the money comes from. well, if there is no price , then no, there was no need to pay any money for this apartment, and burlakov also does not declare the value of a plot of land with an area of ​​more than 1,000 m² in ugar, kharkiv oblast, and more than 60,000 square meters in the kirovohrad region, which his wife acquired earlier, there are huge questions about where the money came from to buy this real estate. and

serhiy burlakov himself explains how this acquisition was made. the ethical council dealt with this issue. i provided all the documents that confirm the legality of the mother's receipt of money, this money was borrowed from the father, also the newly elected a member of the supreme council of justice was repeatedly noticed in the most likely manipulations with the value of his property in the declaration for 2017 as a candidate for the post of judge of the supreme court burlakov indicated in his ownership, the corporate rights of three enterprises, the value of only one of them reached over a hundred hryvnias , however, as required by the law, after being appointed to the position, burlakov got rid of them, he assures for 500,000 and 5,000 hryvnias, that is , he gave the practical one for nothing, it is difficult to believe in this, it looks like another attempt to hide

the real wealth of a the judge also receives very valuable gifts in 2018 the newly elected member of the people's party of ukraine was presented with an antique book parents and children of the judicial reform of 1914 and a painting by the ukrainian artist valentina samoyla kartyushchenko boats near the pier according to experts consider burlakov to be a creature of boris gulka, the head of the civil court of cassation as part of the supreme court, one of the most influential judges and a member of the so-called judicial mafia, which destroyed the judicial system of ukraine all these years. this is actually a continuation of all the negative practices we had in the past when the judicial mafia actually puts people to the positions of the urp and then controls the entire judicial system through them. it is also known that serhii burlakov visited russia several times after 2014. his father

is a pensioner and a citizen of the russian federation, if a person repeatedly travels and it is a judge of the supreme court or just a judge of another court in this is for sure well, the russian border guards and other representatives of the russian law enforcement agencies cannot help but know why they let this person go , how they let this person go, and for what, what did they exchange the guarantees for security, yes, and well. this is a huge question, because if the judge has information, the judge can cool down the judge's decision , the judge can have a lot of influence on others, and many other things to do. territory or directly on the territory of the russian federation, there is clearly some kind of agreement between this judge or this one and the russian federation , what is a person

who is a representative of the ukrainian state who makes decisions in the name of ukraine doing on the territory of our enemy. bondarenko she has a special judicial knack for buying cars cheaper than the market value , the judge owns a 2015 lexus car , which she allegedly bought for 750 thousand hryvnias. another lexus, which she bought a few months earlier for 420,000 uah, and this does not correspond to the market prices for premium class cars. in the declaration of integrity for 2021 , the judge hid the facts of administrative offenses while driving the car and also made decisions while not at work . so in december 2017, when bondarenko was studying in odesa and passed

a decision in a case that was being considered in mykolaiv . are the fortunes of the judge's daughter , the mother of three children, kateryna nevzorova vona, surprising? owns 45 real estates, most of them land plots in the kyiv region, however, where did the daughter's property come from? she works as a judge. she doesn't know tonka. she got married early . they don't tell me about her life and activities. the head of one of the departments of the prosecutor 's office of the kyiv region and, according to the information of our colleagues, underestimated the value of the two mercedes purchased, indicating only uah 149,000, which is a non-market value. at least four

times as likely. thus, the prosecutor could to try to avoid financial monitoring, which set a limit for cash payments of up to uah 150,000. if the amount is larger, it was necessary to explain the origin of the funds . by the federations, of course, leonardo even pretended to live in paradise in the city of novosibirsk under russian rights and has been living with the soviet people since the time of the soviet people with his brother. did not communicate like a person once on the phone when the aggression began