[000:00:00;00] the families from my communication are very afraid to talk about it because everything is tracked by the special services of the russian federation, and even those of our places that we conduct show that even if there are parents with documents who take the child back to ukraine , they encounter obstacles blocking the removal of children from trees thank you mr. mykola koleba if the authorized representative of the president of ukraine on the rights of the child at 2:21 p.m. the founder of the mutual aid center , we will save ukraine at 4:29 p.m. to our country at least informational reasons related to i would like to believe this phenomenon has increased in recent weeks i have a connection from the studio olena shcherban lawyer of the anti-corruption center mrs. olena we welcome you glory to ukraine what is the anti-corruption center as

we understand the invited essay on labor in the context restarting the anti-corruption department of the ministry of defense and introducing a mechanism of public control , in particular because of this potentially corrupt scandal that happened in the ministry of defense , minister of defense oleksiy said about this reznikov p olena, what do you think of the dynamics after the information campaign , fair due to suspicion of corruption to the ministry of defense , please olena shcherban, contact us, a lawyer at the anti-corruption center, please excuse me, obviously power outages affect communication a-a in fact, the anti-corruption center, in principle, we were present at the meeting held by defense minister reznikov on saturday. i was personally

present, and there was also an offer to join certain councils and groups to the ministry of defense and to help rectify the situation, however, in fact, our main expectation from that meeting was, well, first of all, to hear and understand at what prices products, e.e., food are now supplied to the military, this question was heard not only from me, but from many journalists present at this answer, and it is necessary to say that at first the minister avoided a direct answer to this question several times and in the end said that he did not know at what prices products are supplied today, he only admitted that the one under the contract with which was made public by journalists is actually now supplying these products, but the prices are still being agreed and clarified, and in fact it caused such a certain indignation among us, because how can we talk about the actual correction of the situation

of the problems that the ministry of defense purchases when even there after the scandal after eh of the facts made public by journalists at that time cannot even give an answer to such a simple , elementary and, in fact, extremely important question . that is why he is at this meeting right before the start of the official invitation that we was sent to my e-mail. i had to announce that we do not really trust the ministry of defense in order to get involved and help, because both we, our organization , and journalists, and every time we encountered and saw, we noticed certain problems in the ministry of defense, and there are some there are a lot of directions, and in fact, until public scandals, these issues were actually ignored , no one invited no cooperation, ms. olena, i would just like you a little well, i don't know how to correct it, it's not their ministry

of defense, it's our joint ministry of defense and your task is your task, in particular, as anti-corruption fighters, to make mechanisms and help people to keep the situation under control, we understand how many worthy and decent people work in the ministry of defense , and because of these or other not very conscientious people, we do not want the ministry as such a shadow was falling well, accordingly, the mechanisms that, in your opinion , should be implemented in the ministry so that there are no such issues somewhere, somewhere later . communication, in particular, and the public question of the mechanisms. is it real and what should they be, taking into account the fact that some of them fall under the state secret , in fact, there are already such mechanisms, and one of such mechanisms is actually proposed in the parliament, a bill that will oblige

buyers not only the ministry of defense and other customers in the field of defense should publish information about the prices of goods without other details, of course , the publication of which may harm the security of the state, but information about prices is what citizens and journalists have the right to know. and actually in order to analyze in more detail information about purchases, prices and generally what is happening in the ministry. well, in fact , we understand that much more global steps need to be taken. i am personally concerned about the situation that the ministry is, in principle, a body that should shape policy and there is the question of foreign relations, to represent ukraine in this area . yes, but to date , in fact, the ministry of defense has disposed of almost half of our country's budget, and so on in my opinion, it is necessary to implement such changes here. it is known that

certain procurement agencies have been created under the ministry of defense. and actually, it would be advisable for procurement to be organized by structures separate from the ministry, because in this case in this case, it turns out to be such a closed circle when the ministry forms and requests to a large extent, regulates policies and at the same time disposes of funds and directly conducts procurement procedures . of course, i am convinced that some therefore, in procurement, it is necessary to translate the own e-e, regulate, set the rules, because well, on february 24, and it was justified in principle, the ministry was not guided by any , it was not forced to hold tenders, so the actual e-e happened what happened . these are the rules for certain types of procurement.

i think it is possible to return and still , er, to oblige not only to publish information on the effect, but also to carry out certain a-ah, perhaps simplified procurement procedures, so that there would be competition and so that the business could in an open field to understand what is happening. and in your opinion, would a mechanism be realistic, for example, involving representatives from various factions of the parliament, those people who have access to state secrets, so that they work in this corresponding monitoring monitoring committee or supervisory board of some kind? well, actually as of now , in my opinion, it is also important to carry out a truly independent audit of what is happening in order to accurately understand and

identify all the problems, to involve there are many different structures that can work, but first, you need a vision of a certain strategy, a vision of the ministry itself, how it should happen, and a vision of some kind of development , because when you understand, er, some specific powers, possibilities, then er, hmm, there is some sense er, to understand what can i get involved in? please tell me, ms. olena , the prozorro system will appear in our company in the context of public control and procurement for the ukrainian army in the context of food, for example, but in fact the transparent system can be quite effective, right? after our own scandals with the ministry of defense, journalists and activists reported cases when other state customers procured food through the system transparently. and actually

, there were absolutely no problems. therefore, we know that one of the steps may be the actual return of certain procedures e in some limited form with limited disclosure of information . the system is transparent, including but ms. olena, as far as we know, the system is transparent, at least recently there was such an idea, uh, well , to change something in the principle of its functioning in the context of uh, conducting auctions, not auctions, but bidding, in essence, yes, for providing this or that services, how does everything work now? olena shcherban, a lawyer at the anti-corruption center , is in touch with us or has been in touch with us , we will be able to renew the connection, colleagues. well, i think we will try, but as they say, we will see

. yes. in the meantime, the security service of ukraine exposed the scheme of black certificates and reported suspicions, and the suspicions concern high-ranking officials of the national union of architects of ukraine who illegally changed data in the state electronic system in the field of construction. therefore , cyber experts of the sbu worked on the case and gathered irrefutable evidence that they are officials of the national union of architects who de facto they were engaged in frauds maliciously malicious criminals issued new certificates certification of architects although they did not have the right to do so, but in order for the scheme to work, they illegally changed personal data of architects in previously issued certificates , etc. well, i would like to remind you that the national union of architects of ukraine is the same organization that criticized law 56-55, respectively

, if you remember. this is a law in particular and authorship , but not shulyak, the head of the party, the servant of the people. well, there we were talking about construction, in particular, in kyiv. olena shcherban, a lawyer, the anti -corruption center is in touch with us. olena, so very briefly and transparently, we still need an answer, we understand that tenders are now functioning in this very limited format on prozorro, that's right. that's right. can we count on the fact that transparent involvement in the procurement system for the ministry of defense will be effective at all? and it can be effective, but it must be understood that transparency is only a tool for procurement , and serious procedures must also be implemented, and audit control and proper in principle, delegation of functions of the purchaser from the ministry to professional organizations a-a , including the procurement involvement is possible

and even international organizations on certain stages in order to optimize these processes. thank you. anyway, about the national assembly of the union of architects of ukraine, which criticized the urban planning reform bill 56-55. and now the security service of ukraine is interested in them, which suspects officials of the national union of architects of fraud with certificates of certification of architects what is known about this case is very brief , in fact, it is very difficult to make preliminary conclusions based solely on the public position of the law enforcement agency. so, here we need to wait until the case is considered in court and then maybe the details will be clear, but it is clear that the law you mentioned will definitely have an important future for our country, including the post-war reconstruction, i am sure , which will be after our victory, so it is very

important to keep it such objectivity and yet the parliament should review the individual provisions of this draft law in order to avoid risks in these future processes . our affairs are extremely difficult. well, now khrystyna and i are solemnly handing over the baton to our colleagues, yes, sister, watch this week in the judicial control program with tatyana shustrova, the largest competition in history. since i have to deliver a note there , a gift, congratulations. you are watching judicial control and i am tatyana shusterova, the staff war points the way to the european union and does not stop at

the implementation of reforms, in particular, judicial reform the competition for the higher qualification commission is ongoing and it is the largest of all that has ever taken place in the judicial system, there are 301 candidates, 19 people for one place, and some of the applicants are simply amazing , we will introduce you to the brightest candidates, but first, to the news, another prison sentence of a bribe-taking judge the higher anti-corruption court sentenced the head of the kharkiv district administrative court , olga panchenko, to 5 years in prison. in september 2020, nabu employees exposed panchenko for transferring bribes in the amount of three thousands of dollars, other judges of the same court for this, the servant of themis had to make a decision in favor of the commercial company panchenko was also banned from holding the position of judge for three years

, but she can appeal the decision in the appeals chamber of the higher anti-corruption court retired judges of the constitutional court can cut their pensions the corresponding bill provides amendments to the law on the constitutional court were submitted to the parliament at the end of last year, and the other day the document has already received conclusions, the authors note that the size of the monthly the salary of such a judge exceeds uah 150,000, this is equivalent to the minimum pensions of 70 citizens, so it is proposed to reduce the amount of pension support for judges of the constitutional court to 30% of the remuneration. of social policy issues

, the draft law was supported by two ministries of economy and finance who reported that they also had no comments on the document, but instead categorically opposed its adoption the council of judges of ukraine, the kyiv-svyatoshyn court acquitted judge svitlana kushnir, who during the maidan era illegally sent people to custody, kushnir was charged with illegal detention, and the rest and the detention of innocent people, according to the investigation, in january 2014, the judge of the solomyan district court arrested her without any evidence two men who were stopped by the employees of the then traffic police in the center of kyiv were accused of participating in mass riots, which they saw in the transportation of car tires, the prosecutor's office requested

that kushnir be punished in the form of three years of imprisonment, however, the head of the commission, myroslava omelchenko, acquitted judge maidana with her sentence. the higher qualification commission is an important body of the judicial system . its 16 members are responsible for the formation of the judicial corps, the transfer of judges from one court to another, as well as for ensuring their proper level, in particular through qualification evaluation and recommendations to the higher of the council of justice on the appointment of a candidate for the post of judge, which is extremely important for the judicial system of the commission, has not been functioning for almost three years, the authority of the previous members were suspended in november 2019 after amendments were made to the law of ukraine on the judiciary and the status of judges due to the russian invasion, the competition for the higher qualification commission was able to start only at the end of last year, so far the competition commission has already started conducting interviews with

candidates for the position based on their results, 32 candidates will be recommended to the supreme council of justice for appointment, this is 19 people for the position in fact . that is, i do not remember such a competition for any judicial position, the task of the competition commission to determine the 32 finalists from all those who applied, which according to the law stipulates that there must be two finalists for each place, and then the supreme council of justice must approve the final composition of these 16 members of the supreme court commission of judges. let's hope that we will get a new one by the beginning of spring. the full composition of the higher qualification commission of judges is olena korotun, a judge of the northern commercial court of appeal and an applicant for membership in the higher qualification commission for such a high

position, the reputation and biography of the judge have being flawless, however, is not something that olena korotun can boast about, but with character and luck, perhaps the judge and her family members are quite lucky, they constantly win something and have wonderful relatives who give valuable gifts, houses, cars, jewelry that my husband and i are hmm and still in student years agreed that independence is the main attribute in the family in 2011 olena korotun declared more than 330,000 hryvnias of income from the alienation of movable and immovable property and more than 835,000 hryvnias. her family, however, which property was sold by the korotun family, the judge did not indicate in the declaration, and this is the most interesting thing, because the husband of the candidate for the higher qualification commission of judges is also a judge

, and in the previous 10 years their income was probably insignificant, almost uah 730,000, and at the exchange rate at that time, $92,000. husband in koroton in 2011, his mother, who worked as a nurse in a polyclinic, gave it as a gift. it was a gift in accordance with the contract dated 03.11.2011 . my husband's mother, el vera pavlivna , gave proton to her son and the corresponding mail these funds were the funds of her family, her second husband, the korotun judge couple has a son and of course they love him very much, about several million, the judge indicates that her son mykola, at the age of 19, purchased two plots of land with an area of ​​3.5 hectares in the kyiv region

for approximately $10,000 . and in two years, another 2 hectares of land for 11.5 thousand dollars and planted about 5,000 seedlings there, spending more than half a million hryvnias, all these acquisitions were probably financed by the parents according to the de jure foundation during 2017. they are sons almost 120,000 dollars, more than 1 million uah, my son received in the form of a bank loan, olena korotun assures, in fact, he only took them to hold in his hands, bought an apartment for my grandmother, i gave my mother 1 million uah when buying an apartment, my mother will be a pensioner, lived in the village, respectively my son, being a grandson or a member of the family, accepted this

gift from me on behalf of my mother. he bought this apartment for federal funds in 2013. the husband of the candidate bought a mitsubishi, but the value of the car in his declaration of olena korotun is not indicated in two years, probably remembered and added uah 50,000, this is less than three times lower than the market price of such a used car, even today , 10 years after the purchase and the candidate for the higher qualification commission , the explanation is standard, again a gift it was a gift, the evaluation report was made by an expert in mreo ago there was no purpose to hide any value. it is noteworthy that in the declaration for 2019 , the owner of the car of the same make and year of manufacture is the son of olena korotun, and the value of the car

is already 300,000 uah or 12 thousand dollars well, the calculations are very complicated, a few thousand dollars less, a few thousand dollars more. who is not mistaken, and the judge calculates cash gifts more carefully and a little about the professional competence of olena korotun, who claims to be a member of the higher qualification commission of judges and to conduct qualification evaluations of the entire judicial corps from 2012 to in 2019, 99 decisions made by her were canceled, which is a small number and very indicative, but here is another candidate for the higher qualification commission of judges for the rector of the city national university shipbuilding named after oleg dubynskiy, i can tell you about my work experience. when i headed various commercial

komer enterprises, we always worked with lawyers and advocates who defended our interests in court and absolutely . it is under my control and i work completely with the legal service, the national aesthetics of the radio, the addition of the name of admiral makar is because i myself cooperate with the courts oleg dubynskyi rai, what is the relevance of working with the judicial system in order to hold a high the position of a member of the higher qualification commission of judges, but he also very much hopes that the competition commission will not notice any dubious facts from his biography, any attempts to hide property, a real real estate connoisseur from dubinsky, only in 2021 he and

his wife managed to acquire ownership of all objects and residential buildings at once and plots of land, four of them were given to him by his father. for example, a house with an area of ​​more than 300 square meters and a plot of land, however, in the declaration of a doctor of legal sciences, an applicant for the high position of a member of the higher qualification commission the judges did not specify this valuable and large gift. i assure you that this is the first time i have heard of such a claim . this is the first time i have heard that i should mark

it as a gift. why didn't you indicate the cost? see what the situation is. the cost of the donation contract is there, and i will tell you honestly that i saw this cost only when i sent you additional documents because i didn't look at the cost. well, of course, who i am interested in the value of a house of more than 300 square meters, especially when you buy real estate yourself, it is almost impossible to sell, at least this is what dubinsky himself is trying to assure us, for example, the candidate's family allegedly managed to buy a house of 140 m² and 5.5 acres of land in an elite residential complex in mykolaiv, and it was all worth it in a little more than half a million hryvnias , while according to the developer, the minimum cost of a two-room apartment in this place reaches almost two and a half million, and

even if we assume that everything was purchased in in the 21st year, real estate really cost oleg dubynskyi only 776,000 uah, this still cannot be explained by official income according to the declaration in 2020. he and his wife earned a little more than 600,000 uah for the two of them in 2021, the total income was 882,000 in total oleg dubinskyi has considerable experience in purchasing property at a price below the market price, for example, he managed to purchase a ford ranger for uah 150,000 or five thousand dollars , at least 2.5 times cheaper than the real value at that time, however, we can assume that

in this case, if dubinsky was not imported in this way, the candidate for the higher qualification commission of judges could possibly try to avoid financial monitoring , which obliges to indicate the origin of funds if the purchase amount exceeds uah 150,000, according to experts, from 2016 to 2019 in the position of dean of the faculty of the national university of shipbuilding oleg dubinsky could probably influence the university's procurement so that his brother became the winner, according to the de jure foundation, the educational institution concluded 19 contracts with him worth almost uah 300,000 dubynsky denies the accusations, he had a relationship for this, he works for this, he pays taxes and he is the head of some legal entities and he is a private entrepreneur and he is a candidate of legal sciences, this is his right

, but i want to draw the attention of the entire commission to the following: all these contracts were concluded before i became the vice-rector of the university as a detante of the faculty that carries out the educational process. i did not even venture into such a big relationship with my brother in 2019 oleg dubynskyi defended his dissertation at obtaining the scientific degree of doctor of legal sciences, in it he referred to a number of supposedly his articles in scientific publications, he noted that there were more than 60 of them in total, at the interview, the competition committee asked me to comment on one of them for review. i have a large number of works, but there are works that i am telling you

as it is, scientists should always take part in the conference, write certain articles , express their views, but there are articles that can be really useful. and there are articles that a scientist should publish because he a scientist, well, there is one, to my great regret. you see what you have. well, today there is no inspiration to write what is so interesting and useful, but i know that you can write, you can write . but not all articles are like that . an interesting journal of private and public law, and i wrote some articles there , for example, i wrote an article about education as a fate, it is difficult to imagine how articles about education