[000:00:00;00] tough doesn't want to fight in his so-called a wants to be a model with painted nails, pictures with painted hair well, actually, i don't think that this is any surprise to solovyov himself, who managed to rebuild all kinds of villas in spain , he lived very well before the war and actually -he lost two very much. well, there is no way back for him either. there is no way forward. europe is the only road for him. he understands everything himself , even i say this. let's join him in our conversation, we welcome him to our airwaves in a certain mr. messi, i wish you health. oh, we hear you, mr. messiah, you created an organization such as a human rights center for the military. the principle of what actually happened there, i don't

know the last drop. what did you decide, what is this? the center should be, you know, there are simply certain procedures that can make it easier for wounded soldiers to either return to the front or return home . well, when i met with this i saw certain problems, they actually existed very a long time ago however, it seems to me that it is easy enough to change, i just probably did not pay enough attention well, i think now it will be possible such things as, for example, to wait in line or transfer documents between military units of the military medical commission, these things can be solved quickly enough quickly, the only thing that there was a desire, it seems that the desire is actually an opportunity to obtain legal protection during the war, or could it not be some kind of thing that

would undermine discipline in the army and so on, in your opinion, as for a serviceman who i saw it in the middle, you know, it seems to me, well, it’s the opposite, it will strengthen it, including the fact that the military must take their rights when they lick their rights, they can defend them when they can defend their rights it means that they will respect these rights, because rights or something. it means that a person will feel safe in relation to the state, and the military protects this state, so in principle, well, the state should protect them in the same way, and it seems to me that now is the time to create convenient e- e sincerely services to the military is possible. that is, it is not about knowing how to remove the checkers and start doing everything so that everything is bad. the question is that everything is bad. the question is that it is necessary to change it . is it possible

? are the military already contacting you ? what personal stories. and the biggest issue is that there is no clarity in them as to how to act in this or that situation . whom to turn to, what rights they have and the whole part . what happened to when i woke up in the hospital, i woke up and i didn't know what i should do next . according to the documents, you imagine me. the first problem is whether my friends are alive . the second problem is that i lost something. and the biggest problem lies precisely in the lack of clarity

, they do not have an understanding of who to contact. no one has problems with or legal issues, they are afraid of it, why not because well, they are a certain bureaucracy and i understand them because , you know, i am a lawyer myself. well, it is possible for me more or less easier, but if i were in civilian life or most people are now in military civilian life life if i had these problems well, i would probably be a little depressed about this and so we will give them clarity about most of the problems associated with the fact that they do not know their rights and do not know how to act as teachers in this or that situation when in relation to them uh, it's complicated injustice begins this story is about the fact that uh, in the military , who after severe injuries, sometimes even rent some apartments for a few days for this, so they have to stand in line to confirm that they lost a limb there, for example, somewhere in battle, and so on and so on. it became known, including, in particular, that thanks to the fact that our colleague there, myroslav otkovich , wrote about it, and it is about him that there is a lot of attention, and it was he, i had a longer conversation with him about it,

just had such an opportunity here in lviv, where is he? he was on surgery and he said that in fact there are a lot of people in the army now who already know their rights and who came from some there. well, for example, journalists, lawyers , successful businessmen, and so on and so on . and they faced the fact that in the army, well, because the army also somehow existed before the invasion and until the 14th year. by the way, this is exactly this one from germany and from this turn. in fact , the army still has a lot of such rules that are ordimentary sovkovi and he says that well, we are not really ready with those by the rules of the law, eh, change, change and does this mean that there may also be some cases, eh, turnkey conditions, in other words, for legislators in order to fix something? yes , you know, eh, that is, what

the situation actually became until 2018, until 2022, ah, everyone problems also existed in the 14-15th year, now there are more wounded, objectively more, and there is a tear where the tonkonko, that is, these problems have appeared, there are more of them, and that is why now the legislators, together with the government, and we are now developing certain mechanisms in order to get the pain of the wounded first hand and so that legislators and government officials understand this not from the words of those people who work in the beams that you know us all well and to hear from those users and these specific cases, they point to problems that have not been solved for years now, these cases we are direct. so what is being written on social networks now, i am gathering everyone. we are trying to help with our own efforts. we understand that it is very difficult to change these things as a result, a lot of

resources are needed. it is easier not to allow 9 years of war. the ukrainian army also has these soviet traditions, respectively. even before that decades, how much time do you think it will take to break this system, and then to start working anew, so as not to disappoint it and not make promises, because i 'm definitely not a politician. for the military, well, it's three or four months, it's objective. maybe something can be done sooner, but you have to understand that in order to change it, you have to not harm it. and don't make it even worse, and now the analysis that's happening is that group of interns that was created, they are now working. many people are working i think so too that three months, three or four months, we will give at least some relief to the military. maybe it will

be possible sooner, but i think that 3-4 months is normal to implement such a reform . because of this, money is needed for this and it is impossible because we do not have money, this is not there. are they talking about the financial side of making it work in a humane way? do you know when we started to gather? we realized that the financial problem is so big, at least the whole state has it, because we have very large expenses for the war, but the procedures certain algorithms that need to be changed, they do not require large investments or, for example, providing digital military units with some kind of solutions in the majority, one way or another, there are some computer things, namely the digitalization of this history . well, it takes a little time, more human resources i haven't heard yet that it's impossible , i haven't heard that it requires very large investments, and

that's why we're putting it off, i haven't heard of such a thing, and considering what mykhailo fedorov is doing, it's really, well, a very cool story when they got involved realized and you know. there was no need to explain the problems twice. you are very kind, you are kind, in the sense that you yourself are a military man and have been seriously wounded in combat, and you also have a good one here, well, but i, but sometimes you can get something best out of the worst, and i have to breathe you also have such a very good track record , a very well-known lawyer, that is, you are a person who will definitely be trusted and it will be easier for the military to contact your center. but is your center, which is just being created, its own

kkpsiti, that is, it is possible that we need people for permanent work, i don’t know the working hours, etc. is being done and they are making their own funds to understand this, a large enough amount of money will be taken every month. i understand that it is possible that it will be, well, it will definitely be difficult when you always criticize someone or something, but we need lawyers and analysts who will become together with us and begin to find a solution, because our main goal is to make it easier for the wounded to become easier. joined forces and quickly changed it. look, this will immediately help the wounded soldiers . i don't know if they will realize it, but i am sure that more of them

will complain. god, you already had something else to do and it just left and flew off. thank you very much. a lawyer and a veteran of the russian-ukrainian war was with us. it was very nice to see massiv , who actually looks good and it’s great to know that he is returning to an active life . thank you thank you for being with us lesya vakulyuk andriy zaychuk worked in this studio for six hours today for you and thank you for staying with the press because there will be a judicial review so we invite you to watch it will be interesting watch this week in the program of judicial review with tatyana shustrova, the largest competition in history, how are members of the highest qualified commission of judges elected, 19 people per seat, in fact , what kind of property are the candidates hiding, i hear for the first time

that i should put a mark there, a gift , congratulations. and does not stop in the implementation of reforms, in particular judicial reform , the competition for the higher qualification commission continues and it is the largest of all that has ever taken place in the judicial system in it 301 candidates are taking part, 19 people for one seat and some of the applicants are simply amazing, we will introduce you to the brightest candidates, but first, to the news, another prison sentence for a bribe-taking judge, the higher anti-corruption court sentenced the head of the kharkiv district administrative court , olga panchenko, to 5 years in prison in september 2020 employees of the nabu exposed panchenko on transfers of bribes in the amount

of $3,000, other judges of the same court for this, the servant of themis had to make a decision in favor of panchenko's commercial company as well banned from holding the position of a judge for three years, however, she can appeal the decision in the appeals chamber of the higher anti-corruption court retired judges of the constitutional court can cut their pensions the corresponding bill providing for changes to the law on the constitutional court was submitted to the parliament at the end of last year and the other day the document has already received the conclusions of the authors note that the amount of monthly maintenance of such a judge exceeds 150,000 hryvnias, this is equivalent to the minimum pensions of 70 citizens, so the amount of pensions for judges the constitutional court is proposed to reduce the remuneration to 30%. the parliamentary committee on european integration in its conclusions

on the draft law noted that it does not contradict ukraine's international legal obligations . the committee on social policy supported the draft law. instead , the council of judges of ukraine categorically opposed its adoption, the kyiv-svyatoshyn court acquitted judge svitlana kushnir, who during the maidan days illegally sent people under police officer kushnir was charged with illegal detention, and the rest and the detention of innocent persons, according to the investigation, in january 2014, the judge of the solomyan district court, without any evidence, arrested two men who were stopped by the employees of the then traffic police in the center of kyiv and were accused of participating in mass riots, which were seen in transportation

of car tires, the prosecutor's office asked to impose a three -year prison sentence on kushnir, however, the head of the commission, myroslava omelchenko, acquitted judge maidana with her verdict. the most important body of the judicial system, its 16 members are responsible for the formation of the judicial corps, the transfer of judges from one court to another, as well as for ensuring their proper level, in particular, through qualification evaluation and recommendations to the high council of justice on the appointment of a candidate for the position of judge, extremely important for the judicial system, the commission does not function for almost three years, the powers of the previous composition were terminated in november 2019 after amendments were made to the law of ukraine on

the judiciary and the status of judges due to the russian the invasion of the competition to the higher qualification commission was able to start only at the end of last year, so far the competition commission has already started conducting interviews with candidates for the position based on their results, 32 candidates will be recommended to the supreme council of justice before appointing 519 people to the position, in fact, that is, i do not remember any judicial position the task of the competition commission is to determine the 32 finalists from all those who applied, which according to the law stipulate that there should be two for each place, and then the supreme council of justice has to approve the final composition of these 16 members of the higher division commission of judges at the beginning of spring, let's hope that we will receive a new full composition of the higher qualification commission of the court, this is olena korotun, a judge of the northern court of appeal and a candidate for membership in the higher

qualification commission for such a high position, reputation and biography judges must be impeccable, however, this is not something that olena korotun can boast about, but character and luck. perhaps the court and members of her family are quite lucky, they always win something and have wonderful relatives who give valuable gifts, houses, cars, jewelry, that my husband and i are independent and even in our student years we agreed that independence is the main attribute in the family. in 2011, olena korotun declared more than 330,000 hryvnias of income from the sale of movable and immovable property and more than 835,000 hryvnias in this way, the members of her family received, however, which property

the korotun family sold, the judge did not indicate in the declaration, and this is the most interesting thing, because the husband of the candidate for the higher qualification commission of judges is also a judge, and for the previous 10 years their the income was probably insignificant, almost uah 730,000, and at the exchange rate at that time, $ 92,000, the husband briefly gave it to his mother in 2011, who worked as a nurse in a polyclinic. it was a gift in accordance with the gift agreement dated 11.3.2011. accordingly, these funds, these funds were the funds of her family, her second husband, the judge's spouse, the korotuns, have a son, and of course they love him very much, for several million approximately, the judge indicates that her son

mykola, at the age of 19, purchased in kyiv region, two plots of 3.5 hectares for approximately $10,000. and in two years, another 2 hectares of land for 11.5 thousand dollars and planted about five thousand seedlings there, spending more than half a million hryvnias, all these acquisitions were probably financed by the parents according to the de jure foundation during 2017. they gave their son almost 120,000 dollars , more than 1 million hryvnias, the son received in the form of a bank loan, olena korotun assures , in fact, he took them only to hold in his hands , bought an apartment for my grandmother, i gave it to my

1 million uah to my mother when buying an apartment. my mother will be a pensioner. she lived in the village, respectively. my son, being a grandson and not a member of the family, accepted this gift from me on behalf of my mother. he bought this apartment for federal funds in 2013. the candidate’s husband bought a mitsubishi , but the cost of the car is in his declaration olena korotun did not specify in two years , she probably remembered and added uah 50,000, which is at least three times lower than the market price of such a used car, even today, 10 years after the purchase and a candidate for higher of the qualification commission, the explanation is standard again, the gift was already a gift to the mother, the mpeo expert did it to hide some value. it is noteworthy that in the declaration for 2019, the owner of the car of the same brand and

year of manufacture is the son of elena koroton, and the value of the car is already 300,000 uah or $12,000. well , very complicated calculations, several thousand dollars less, several thousand dollars more, who is not mistaken. interestingly , the judge calculates cash gifts more carefully and a little about the professional competence of elena korotun, who claims to sit in the seat of a member of the higher qualification commission of judges and conduct a qualification evaluation of the entire judicial corps from 2012 to 2019, 99 decisions made by it were canceled, or the number was small and very indicative, and here is one more candidate for the higher qualification commission of judges, the vice-rector of the mykolaiv national university of shipbuilding named after makarov oleg

dubynskyi, i can tell you about my work experience when i was the head of various commercial enterprises, we always worked with lawyers and advocates who were in our interests in the courts defended and definitely i was faced with the work of the courts to the fullest extent now for my positions it is under my control and uh i work completely with the legal service national strategy radio adding the name of the admiral is because i myself cooperate with the courts oleg dubynskyi not only believes that it is relevant experience in the system in order to hold a high position as a member of the highest qualification commission of judges, but he also very much hopes that the competition commission will not notice any dubious

facts from his biography, or any attempts to hide property, a true connoisseur of dubinsk real estate only in 2021, he and his wife managed to acquire ownership of all objects and residential buildings and plots of land, four of them were given to him by his father, for example, a house with an area of ​​more than 300 square meters and a plot of land, however, in the declaration of a doctor of legal sciences, a candidate for a high position a member of the supreme qualification commission of judges did not indicate this valuable and large gift, he assures that this is the first time he has heard of such a declaration, i did not know that he demanded a declaration. and now, if it is true, this is not the first time i have heard that i should put a mark there, the gift is his

mark as i have the right to ownership in 2021. it was a donation contract from my father to me and i entered it in the declaration. why didn’t i indicate the value? see what the situation is. the value of the donation contract is and i will tell you this value. i just saw it honestly. then when i sent you additional documents because i didn't look at the value well, of course , who is interested in the value of a house with more than 300 square meters, especially when you buy real estate yourself, you almost lose it , at least that's what they are trying to assure us dubinsky himself, for example, the family of the candidate allegedly managed to purchase a house of 140 m² and 5.5 acres of land in an elite residential complex of mykolaiv, and it all cost a little more than half a hryvnia, while

according to the developer, the minimum cost of a two-room apartment in this place reaches almost two by half a million if we assume that all the real estate purchased in 2021 really cost oleg dubynskyi only 776,000 uah, this still cannot be explained by official income according to the declaration in 2020. he from his wife earned a little more than uah 600,000 for the two of them in 2021, the total income amounted to uah 882,000 in total. oleg dubynskyi has considerable experience in purchasing property at a price below the market price, for example, he managed to purchase a ford ranger for uah 150,000 or five thousand dollars faster in 2.5 times cheaper than the real

value at that time. what can we assume is the case here? dubinsky's importation is not the case . in this way, a candidate for the higher qualifications commission of judges could possibly try to avoid financial monitoring, which obliges to indicate the origin of the funds if the amount of the purchase exceeds uah 150,000, according to experts, from 2016 to 2019, in the position of dean of the faculty of the kora blebud national university, oleg dubynskyi could probably influence the university's procurement if his brother was the winner, according to the de jure foundation, the educational institution concluded with him 19 contracts to us are almost uah 300,000. dubynsky rejects

the accusations. he had a relationship with the university and he is the head of some legal entities and he is a private entrepreneur and he is a candidate of legal sciences , this is his right, but i want to draw the attention of all commissions for the following, all these contracts were concluded before i became the vice-rector of the university as a dictation of the faculty that carries out the educational process. i did not even get into such a big relationship with my brother in 2019. in it , he referred to a number of supposedly his articles in scientific publications, noting that there were more than 60 of them in total. at the interview, the competition commission asked me to comment on one of them for

review. i have a large number of them there even today, if you count all of them, there are already almost 100 , but there are works that i tell you as it is, scientists should always take part in conferences, write certain articles, apply their views, but there are articles that can be really useful. and there are articles that a scientist should publish because he is a scientist well, there is one, to my great regret . you see what you have. well, today i have no inspiration to write . what is so interesting and useful, but that's how you know what you can write. you can write. but not all articles are like that, how to say it correctly good luck, in 2022 there is such a very interesting magazine, private and public law, and

i wrote some articles there, for example, i wrote an article related to education as such, soldiers, it is difficult to imagine how articles about education reflect the professional suitability of an applicant for the higher qualification commission of judges of ukraine, you , and with the article dubynskyi, which he refers to in his dissertation, neither we nor the experts of the publications already connected by him failed to reach the conclusions of the competition commission regarding the candidates oleg dubynskyi and elena korotun currently unknown, but we will continue to monitor their fate. and in the next issue, we will introduce you to other candidates for the high qualification commission of judges. for today, you all

watched judicial control. mail that can be seen on the screen or on my facebook, see you in exactly a week , join the community with a ukrainian view of the world, become a sponsor of the espresso youtube channel , and this is access to exclusive content personal thanks fixed comments special icons and the possibility of personal communication with the espresso team click to sponsor and become part of the community with a ukrainian perspective in ukraine 5:00 p.m. news release on the espresso tv channel in the studio of iryna koval