[000:00:00;00] even from a small effort, fortunately - this is behind me feminost uro helped me thanks to natural ingredients feminost uro helps to restore control over urination in the melon at night now i feel confident feminost uro urination under control buy with a 10% discount in pharmacies pharmacy nt pharmacy penny and pharmacy shar there are moments when the body quickly loses fluid, which can lead to dehydration. but of course , there is not enough water. reo water for special medical purposes, my legs don't walk anymore, wait, there's no health. what kind of health is there, i thought so until i tried herovital, herovital plus phytovi, a tamin complex that takes care of the heart and strengthens the body, herovital plus, good health, active life, order on

the website of apteka 911.ua gerovital plus 700 ml with a 20% discount. congratulations, this is freedom. my name is vlad and lazur. the meeting of ukraine's allies in the rammstein format ended in brussels. the minister of defense of ukraine, oleksiy reznikov, said that he is satisfied with the results of the meeting , and the head of the pentagon, lloyd austin, said that there is no news regarding the planes. in fact, the ninth ramstein has ended for ukraine . and personnel changes in the ministry of defense, lieutenant general oleksandr pavlyuk , who after the russian invasion was responsible for the defense of the kyiv region, became the first deputy minister of defense oleksiy

reznikov, probably for this appointment the day before, volodymyr zelenskyi signed a decree allowing military personnel to hold positions in the ministry of defense because it is prohibited by law, what does such an appointment mean, and what other personnel changes will take place in the ministry of defense in the near future, svoboda life says today , there are no solutions regarding fighter jets for ukraine, or they will try to collect supplies as soon as possible. this is it i briefly told you the briefing of the us secretary of defense lloyd austin and the chairman of the joint chiefs of staff of the us, general mark mila based on the results the meeting of the contact group on the defense of ukraine in the rammstein format, which was held today in brussels at the nato headquarters, journalists asked them several times about fighter jets for ukraine, and each time the head of the pentagon answered that he had no news . here he slandered that, for example , poland, no one can

prohibit giving ukraine airplanes regarding airplanes i have no statements regarding airplanes today we are working with ukraine now on issues that are now the most urgent the usa has never stopped poland from providing weapons our position is that decisions must be made by the countries themselves. we cannot dictate our position to them as to whether we will provide f16 . i have no statements at the moment. the head of the pentagon, however, said that western countries will try to supply ukraine with as much ammunition as possible and as soon as possible. not much is produced outside of russia, according to the western press . recently, ukraine began to spend more shells of nato calibers, but their stocks are also running out. well, literally yesterday nato secretary general jen stoltenberg stated that the current level of expenditure on ammunition in ukraine

is many times higher than the level of their production in nato member states. regarding airplanes and here we are now showing how the minister of defense oleksiy reznikov arrived at the headquarters of the nato apartment this morning and demonstratively showed journalists a scarf with a print of airplanes, well, obviously. in this way he hinted at the fact that he expects a positive decision regarding the fighter jets. you see the fighter jets, from whom do you expect to receive them from the sky? oleksiy reznikov himself, after meeting with the allies in brussels, speaking about the results of this meeting, said that he was very satisfied with the results, this is literally a quote during a conversation with journalists on the sidelines , natureznikov said that he

heard clear messages from the allies about the full support of ukraine until the victory of the 9th ramstein, its consequences for ukraine, let's talk further , the minister of foreign affairs has already joined the broadcast pavlo klimkin of ukraine, 14-19 years old, my greetings to you please, i congratulate all my friends so, look, they agreed to supply ukraine with the maximum amount of ammunition as soon as possible , but they did not decide, at least we do not know about them, any decisions about the transfer of fighter jets and laziness several times today he said a clear no to planes. i briefly mentioned biden's statement about airplanes, they say, well, you heard what the president of the united states said, i have nothing to add, did you expect some other decision today , i hoped, but in fact, not expected, and there are several points here, the first is what was agreed and what was announced

, after all, as they say in odesa, there are two big ones, you know, of course, part of the agreement remains confidential, and it is absolutely correct, we emotionally all always wanted to know everything, but so during war doesn't work and actually we don't have to hope that many things that really have to be done confidentially this is the beginning of training - this is additional logistics and many more things we will know the second moment uh still rammstein sometimes we give him some of semi-sacred meaning, rammstein is a coordination mechanism, it is not a decision-making mechanism, and what austin said today, that each country makes its own decisions, he is certainly

deceiving here, and very deceiving, because without washington, no key decisions about weapons will be made. but nevertheless, such decisions will be e- this is a decision that must be made and announced by the leaders, which has a fundamental impact on the strategy. and thirdly , what nato secretary general stoltenberg austin talked about yesterday, he also talked about it today. the need er now er as quickly as possible and in the end er it sounds good now i really want it to be implemented establish on a regular basis the supply of ammunition so that there is really enough of them there are also logistics and certain problems with production well

and, of course, the means of transport. since we see the information, we see the information that around our borders, russia is trying to concentrate the means and air, in particular , helicopters , the press also writes a lot about this, and here it is very important to understand how we are leveling it in real time, that is, in i'm not disappointed by today's rammstein, i didn't expect anything critical , but i really, really hope that in the near future there will be pro-riffs not only on planes, but in particular on long-range missile weapons, because with planes, after all, it 's training, it's logistics, it's tactics, it's weapons, and long-range missiles can be used. well, if we receive them tomorrow, then literally

the day after tomorrow, well, or a few days ago , there are different priorities and you need to work on each of them separately, and not fixate on the planes, as you remember weeks ago, remember, she said all tanks tanks tanks i understand it emotionally but war is about everything war is about victory and here all weapons win now moments mr. klimkin i noticed that in fact nothing concrete was said today about long-range missiles, the most concrete thing is about ammunition everything else the second moment hung up. you noted that rammstein should not be endowed with a certain sacredness. well , it seemed to me that the ukrainian side endowed rammstein with a certain sacredness. was probably partly devoted to the expectations from rammstein and actually here i want to mention that you gave an example of tanks that the last

rammstein, which took place in the 20th of january , then they also expected tanks from him tanks, uh, loyd, that’s how it turned out, and he said that in i have no news for you, but five days have passed and the allies have given an answer about tanks , that is, there may be some such scenario here too , i don't know if you agree with the above, i don't think that the scenario will be quite similar, let's not count the days where 3d 5d 7 but i really hope that is agreements. of course, i cannot state this publicly here, and about training and everything that is needed to prepare for the fact that we will have planes, we know which planes we need, we know how to provide it, but we need political decisions regarding long-range weapons. well here, in fact, the situation is quite simple, even if these decisions are made, i do not think that

in this case they will be announced publicly, and this is connected, of course, with the effort of the west to avoid escalation and with the effort to understand how to work i started to hear you poorly i just think that we have some communication problems maybe we will try to redial or fix the connection can you hear us mr. klimkin i think that mr. klimkin can't hear us either, you can't hear us either i hope that we are now a second friend and will resume contact pavlo klimkin minister of foreign affairs of ukraine we are talking about the consequences of the 9th rammstein for ukraine today a meeting in the rammstein format, which usually takes place at the american

rammstein airbase in germany today it took place at nato headquarters in brussels, where the nato summit is taking place in parallel. well, two days in a row. today, on the first day , a ukrainian delegation went there and a meeting of nato allies was held. by the way , defense minister oleksiy reznikov noted among such positive news of this meeting the fact that the number of allies has increased and now their number is in 54 countries, 54 representatives pavlo klimkin joined our broadcast. i'm sorry, we had problems with communication, or did you, mr. klimkin, say that if there is a long-range solution rockets, it will not be announced publicly and not immediately. as of today, i think that in fact we do not need to announce all decisions publicly, and i say this because i would not want these decisions to be announced right now or

better for yesterday or the day before yesterday, but in fact some things are in the process of preparation since the strategic situation is constantly being analyzed and we, as allies, do not need to create a tornado of various rumors and so on for the sake of it. and i believe that this is again during the during the war that's right, because what we hoped to hear against the background of our expectations was rammstein, and the fact that for many , in fact, these expectations are actually an evening in this, there is no tragedy for me, the strategic picture is important to me , and it is important for me that our allies understand and say that we will support ukraine for as long as it will be necessary and as it will be necessary, but for me this is a key phrase and nuances well, of course, it is emotionally important for us to get airplanes now, just as

we got tanks, but, nevertheless, this is a question there are also strategies, and this is the question of imposing a strategy of military aid on general systemic pressure on russia, imposing sanctions on restrictions on oil products that are currently affecting the pro-russian budget , ultimately putting pressure on putin himself, it was not for nothing that it was absolutely on the record of his conversation with plotnytskyi, where he talks about the crash of the malaysian boeing, this is a complex story and all complex stories, everything must be in its place and on time, and it is again about justifying someone or saying that today we got or didn't get what we hoped that it is important to win the war and not to receive positive news at

every moment , although we would also really like positive news, this is true. he said to poland to hand over soviet planes to kiev. i understand that it was soviet mig-29 fighter jets. and you said that the usa is devious after all . poland will definitely look to washington in this matter, that is, today we have a situation when any systemic decision regarding the supply of weapons will be made from the input of washington. we understand perfectly well, because the first is a strategy, as i said , a military strategy, but not only a military strategy, and the second is logistics, this is support, this is the actual weapon that has hang on or on airplanes or on other elements and many other different things and pay attention. here he is not only

a hint about our polish friends, he said that we will not object to the transfer by other countries and how do you know for example, f-16 planes, which suit us in many ways, mine are produced very, very many around the world, several thousand and it is not only western countries, so how to get it is actually, of course, a political issue. but nevertheless, making a political decision by washington and its allies is the main the story is here, uh, that's why. it seems to me that we are again having some problems with the connection with stepan klimkin . i think that we will now redial him again. i will remind you again that we are talking about the consequences of the ninth ramstein for ukraine

. if not the final agreement with the numbers, dates and number of aircraft, then at least the readiness of the western partners, first of all, now it is about washington, the readiness to provide aviation, which kyiv is very much hoping for, although it is worth noting here that the issue of machines is not fully resolved, definitely kyiv received the agreement from a number of western countries about the supply of tanks, but the number of tanks that is not necessary for a full-fledged counteroffensive in ukraine is currently not available, the nearest they can appear is by the end of march. about what berlin and other western countries have repeatedly reported that they have agreed to supply ukraine with tanks, so aviation in this story is already the tip of the iceberg. what ukraine hopes for from western partners together with long-range aviation . the states stated that they are not against it, they themselves are not ready to provide aviation to ukraine, but they will not

object. if poland or some other countries make such a decision for themselves, it is obvious that if we are talking about f16, then it is aviation of american production and according to all the terms of the contracts, the rules, the rules are such that if some other country were to hand over to ukraine the same fighter jets as in 16 of american production, it would require the permission of washington because the fighter jets are american here are the news regarding rammstein i will remind you once again that while the minister of defense was at rammstein at rammstein in kyiv, personnel changes took place in the ministry of defense. we will also discuss them today at the first deputy minister of defense they appointed oleksandr pavlyuk, who was in charge of the defense of kyiv oblast and kyiv, in particular, at the beginning of the invasion. and this is another big topic for conversation, since the law of ukraine does not

stipulate that this position will be held by a military man. but now the law has changed and we will discuss all this literally in a few minutes on the air, we are still waiting for pavel klimkin to be on the phone, obviously there are problems with the connection, because for ukraine it is not a news problem with the connection, and now we are waiting for him to join us , at least by phone, i hope it will be successful also today, the american press, in particular for washington, for the washington post, reported that american officials allegedly informed the ukrainian authorities that now at this time and in this period , a critical moment is coming for changes in the trajectory of the war, and in washington they say they fear that by the summer of kyiv will exhaust the current budget of american aid, and after that it will be difficult to obtain new funding from the congress. if there are such risks, we will certainly discuss them today, but i understand that

we cannot reach pavlo klimkin yet. problem with communication , we apologize for that well, i announced to you another topic that we will talk about today - it is personnel changes in the ministry of defense , in fact, it can be stated that this is perhaps the largest personnel rotation since the beginning of the full-scale invasion, i will remind you that against the background of the scandal with by purchasing food for the ukrainian military at inflated prices, the minister of defense oleksiy reznikov almost lost his position, well , he hasn't lost his position yet, just the forecasts vary like this today, so far oleksiy reznikov was at the meeting in the rammstein format, he also reported that he submitted documents for the approval of three candidates for the positions of his deputies, and one of them was already appointed by the government today, as i already said , lieutenant general oleksandr pavlyuk, he became the first deputy minister of defense, he was the head of the kyiv military of the regional administration from march to may last year, he was responsible for the defense of the kyiv region of the kyiv region and before that for more than a year and a half he led the operation

of the joint forces in the donbass. general pavlyuk knows perfectly the problems of modern war and the needs of our army, he has the necessary leadership and management qualities, there will be even more synergy in interaction with the general staff. well, it seems that precisely for the sake of pavlyuk's appointment , president volodymyr zelenskyi the night before signed a decree according to which, during the period of martial law , a serviceman in the rank of first deputy minister of defense can be appointed lieutenant general or vice admiral because in the law on the approval of the regulation on the ministry of defense of ukraine it is clearly written that both the minister and his deputies, including the first deputy is appointed from among civilians, at the same time, two other candidates, who are different, he proposes to appoint as his deputies, they are precisely from among civilians, this is vitaly deinega, a volunteer, a public figure, the founder of a charitable fund, come back alive , most likely he will become the deputy minister of defense for digital transformation, he has already confirmed that he is currently very close before

the appointment to this position, andrii shevchenko was a people's deputy of the fifth, sixth and seventh convocations, the ambassador of ukraine in canada, and more incredibly, he will become a deputy minister defense on issues of european integration, well, that is, he will engage in military diplomacy if the government approves his appointment , unlike pavlyuk, the government has not yet approved the candidacy of the last two , but it is likely. next, people's deputy of ukraine and member of the committee on national security , defense intelligence serhii rahmanin joins the broadcast. personnel changes are your personal opinion. these personnel changes are for that . well, in connection with the fact that to extinguish the scandal that hung over the minister and to divert this negativity from the minister himself through procurement, did the ministry objectively need just such

an update, the reason for the inconsequential communications between the new personnel appointment and the previous scandals, they will be zero because , relatively speaking, if radio svoboda has problems with the sound, well, it will happen. the communication will appear on the air, disappear , appear. there will be a lack of sound and you will be appointed of the new chief accountant of the new editor, i will come to you with a question. well, how will the problems with the sound disappear? what will we answer that it has absolutely nothing to do with the procurement of the ministry of defense , completely different people were responsible for the open procurements. there, in general , certain measures were applied to them, if you know a deputy instead of these people, no one

has yet been appointed for closed procurement weapons-related weapons are responsible for the deputy shapovalov and gavrilov, they both worked and are still working. and with all my respect to all three newly appointed we are not yet appointed, but judging by everything , i know all of the newly appointed as deputies personally, someone longer than someone less has nothing to do with those scandals who were around the ministry of defense. they do not have a zone of responsibility, that is, there can be two options. the first option is to invite people who enjoy a certain level of respect for the war veterans. i share, let's say those who pleases these appointments, but for example, personally, they treat all three people who will appear in the ministry of defense with respect, but how will they be able to change the situation with procurement, for example, or in general with other problems, the directions in which the ministry of defense should exist, i do not know the second, that is , it is theoretically possible, just decided

this is a way to create, well, in a good sense, a pr situation that distracted from these scandals . maybe i don't know. this is a subjective explanation . objectively, maybe those directions will be , for example, for which they will be responsible, for example. pandas and negachepan shevchenko, well, they traded reinforcements, although this is news to me because representatives of the ministry of defense regularly appear at our committee, report there and share. i hear for the first time that they had problems in the integration direction and in the digital field . maybe i don't know something. maybe something has changed but just as they reported, they reported that in these areas everything corresponds to the plan and to the tasks that arise, so one can guess, but talk about the fact that these personnel appointments will significantly affect the situation around the ministry of defense. once emphasizes, with all personal respect for each of the three deputies, i do not have a second moment, which is very important

. by the way, attention has already been drawn to the law prohibiting the appointment of a military deputy minister. no presidential decree cancels the effect of the law, even under martial law. it is still a mystery to me. and i wanted to ask you about it . i concluded that, in fact, for the sake of this appointment, yesterday volodymyr zelenskyi signed a decree specifically for oleksandr pavlyuk. well, with this decree, in fact denied the law, or how to understand it? i understand it the same way, look at the commander-in-chief, he is already the president , he already signed the constitution , he could sign 99 decrees, the cabinet of ministers could adopt 106 resolutions about them, there is a constitution that has the highest legal force in the state and it says 19 articles within the limits of the constitution are already written there, and any regulatory act

must be subject to the constitution. attention, the law means that any not only by-law, but also a legislative act, such as a presidential decree, cannot be stronger than the law in the conditions of a state of martial law in the conditions of a state of emergency in the conditions of the attack of aliens in the conditions of i do not know that there is an earthquake the constitution has a law if it is written in the law that a military man cannot be a deputy, then the law must be changed if the law changes then a military man can be appointed if it is written in the law that he should be only a civilian , what happened now, unfortunately, they once again emphasized that it was directly personal to mr. pavlyuk , directly to the supreme commander-in-chief , what happened is called a violation of the law and the violation of the constitution, full stop. you know, i mentioned here that there was once a sociology in the first months of the invasion. and maybe not even for the first time, somewhere six months later, they did a sociology where

the majority of ukrainians said that well, if it is a good deed, then it is possible for the president to violate the law. well, just remind me in a specific case, the government well, now the bank can justify the fact that there is now a war and without a military man in this position, you have no idea if we go out now and ask if we should cancel taxes, 99 people will say let's cancel it the reason for canceling taxes. the government exists precisely to take into account the wishes of the population, to care less about the state, about its development, about filling the budget, about protecting the security of defense. that is why there are constitutions, laws, and for that , the president has a whole set of functions, one of them is called the guarantor of the constitution i emphasize the guarantor of the constitution, he is the first one who has to protect the constitution, he violated it once again today, i say with all due respect to the president, with all the things he did

and violated, there was a need, for example, from his point of view i don't see such a need. well, he knows something. what i don't know, there is an urgent need, an extreme need to appoint a person to the position of first deputy military president with a guarantor. as you can see, as a legislative commission, this means that he can submit a draft law. moreover, his draft law is being considered . the first priority obviously wanted to do it much faster than when the supreme service met, it was about what, for example, let's imagine, let's fantasize the situation, an unheard-of scandal appeared for example, with the equipment that he handed over in the field of supply , suddenly

, immediately , now it is necessary to appoint a person, and this person is a military man, there is no other option. will take place in another two weeks, taking into account the mechanism of what has been worked out there, nothing will change in any way, you said that representatives of the ministry of defense often came to the committee and you never heard from them that they have problems there digitization, that they want to manage it, that for this they need a first deputy or a deputy who will deal with diplomacy today, about the appointment of pavlyuk varshikov said the following: when he is appointed , there will be even more synergy in interaction with the general staff, or did the ministry of defense complain about the lack of synergy with the general staff before that well, first of all, i did not say that there are no problems, i said that there are no extraordinary problems, relatively speaking, there are problematic areas of the ministry of defense - this is a huge mechanism, this is huge, this is the state of the state, therefore, the minister of defense has more deputies than any other minister