[000:00:00;00] i could dream of myself, i don't care about war, war is a disaster, without a doubt, why can we stay, but since we have not had the chance to inform how to make the most of it , there is no reason to be in the year 91. and now it has reasons to be one of the most successful states in europe. tried to do before the war. i believe that he was in the right place . they kissed when we can still do this. reforms that we were not able to do and i believe that we are already mature enough to do it and once it becomes obvious here and it is not possible for anyone to do it by themselves, no state without foreign aid, and here we have help from nato , the european union, the marshall plan, that is, the milk of the stars agree which agree on the fact that you know that for 10-15 years we talk with you about what everyone else about something is very boring about her

and that i really wish for myself thank you mr. yaroslav for an interesting conversation i will remind you that there was a famous ukrainian historian on the espresso channel publicist, philosopher, professor of the ukrainian catholic university yaroslav hrytsak stay with our channel i feel chained to a chair everything is starting to annoy me there is no convenient moment for pain but there is a yellow cream dolgit cream dolgit helps to eliminate pain and has an anti-inflammatory effect dolgits the only yellow cream for joint pain and for convulsions m muscle tablets dolgit antispasmodics for relaxing muscles and threads

cinema television sports music education free people have a choice choose what you want on megogo weekly saturday political club helps to understand processes taking place in ukraine and the world, vitaly portnikov, host of espresso and invitations, experts based on facts give their assessment and forecast of the development of events, want to understand how our today will affect our tomorrow, watch saturday's political club, what's on saturdays on espresso, watch this week's program judicial control with tatyana shustrova the competition for the higher qualification commission of judges as kernes's lawyer from the defender of drunk drivers are rushing for a high position did i know gennady kernes this is how

i knew him and where did the children's valuable property come from son's candidates have a scholarship. congratulations, this is judicial control and i am tetyana shustrova. the largest competition in the history of the judicial system is underway in ukraine. the new composition of the higher qualification commission of judges of the body responsible for the formation of the entire judicial corps is being elected. we continue to closely monitor the candidates for its composition. today we will tell you about a lawyer kernes and the judge in the savior that does not prosecute drivers who drive while intoxicated, but first the head of the higher anti-corruption court to the news appointed judge vira mykhaylenko, the corresponding decision was made at the general meeting of judges in this position. mykhaylenko replaced judge vaks with the longest experience, oleg pavlyshyn, who was the head of the court since may 7, 2022. vira

mykhaylenko is from kyiv. was a judge and speaker of the higher anti-corruption court has the title of candidate of legal sciences in odesa security service of ukraine detained a judge's assistant who warned suspects about searches the cost of such illegal services established from 100 to one thousand dollars, the amount depended on the importance of the case and the terms of the procedural measures, among the main clients there were members of criminal gangs regarding which investigations are ongoing. anton vlasenko, a former judge of the sapa city district court

of crimea, was appointed as the occupier of the kherson regional court in 2014 after occupation of the peninsula. he went over to the side of the enemy in ukraine. vlasenko is accused in criminal proceedings for high treason. the supreme council of justice terminated the life imprisonment of four former judges who were convicted of bribery and abuse of influence. the judge of the severodonetsk city court of luhansk oblast, olena horbatenko, was accused of extorting and receiving a bribe. to receive two and a half thousand dollars for a lenient sentence for the spouses of drug dealers, the court sentenced her to 5 years in prison and with a probationary term of three in 2016, the judge of the kovel city district court of the volyn region, oleg vasylyuk, was found guilty of abuse of influence and sentenced to two years in prison. the judge of the malinovsky

district court of odesa, oleksiy buran, was arrested in 2016 on suspicion of accepting a bribe of half a million hryvnias for issuing a decision in the case of collecting a debt of one and a half million hryvnias. when detectives searched his house, buran fired a gun at them in may 2022, wagx found him guilty, but thanks to a plea deal , the court ordered three years of probation in the kivertsi district court of the volyn region, ivan podgorny was sentenced for receiving a bribe in the amount of three and a half thousand hryvnias . podgorny was under investigation for more than 10 years. numerous facts of receiving bribes were investigated in relation to him, in particular ivan podgorny did not shy away from taking bribes from his son with strawberries and household appliances. of the higher qualification commission of judges continues

, this is an important body of the judicial system that is responsible for the formation of the judicial corps , the transfer of judges from one court to another and also for ensuring their proper level, in particular through the qualification assessment, the powers of the previous members of the higher qualifications commission were terminated three years ago, since then the body has not been functioning, meanwhile ukraine lacks more than two and a half thousand judges whose selection it is impossible to carry out without the higher qualifications commission is currently ongoing the stage of interviews with applicants, based on the results of which the selection commission will recommend 32 candidates for appointment , the supreme council of justice will appoint 16 of them, and

we continue to introduce you to the most desperate applicants who dream of a high position despite a dubious reputation, a not-so-crystal biography and fortunes that cannot be explained by official income are serhiy mokhonchuk, he is a teacher and professor at the national law university named after yaroslav the wise in kharkiv and has the talent to save tens of thousands of dollars and probably buy expensive real estate with a rather modest official income serhii mukhonchuk held the position of head of the main department of justice in the kharkiv region from 2010 to 2016 during the term of office of the city mayor gennady kernes in 2008, makhanchuk received from him a power of attorney for the representation of interests for a period of three years , despite the fact that at that time makhanchuk did not even have a lawyer's license, the candidate for the communist party of ukraine

assures that he participated in only one meeting , it was a power of attorney issued for my representation of his flights in a criminal case in general, there are quite a lot of publications on the internet describing alleged schemes of illegal enrichment that were implemented in the kharkiv city hall during the time when serhiy mohochuk worked there as the head of the main the department of justice, in particular, from accusations against him regarding possible participation in such schemes, mokhanchuk was the head of the main department of justice in the kharkiv region from 2010 to 2016, precisely at the time when gennady kernes was the acting mayor of kharkiv, then and and the mayor of kharkiv, and the publication says that during the time of the head of the department of justice, serhiy mikhalchuk was one of the organizers of

the enrichment scheme thanks to the registration service, we organize frauds in public procurement and received kickbacks from them. actually improved his material condition at the interview mokhonchuk commented on this information yes if you ask me did i know gennady kernes yes i knew him if you ask me did i communicate with him yes i communicated with him not as presented by the mass media but we were acquaintances if you ask me whether he influenced me in making any decisions, i will say no, he did not. it is interesting that it was during this period in 2014 that the 20-year-old son of a candidate for the higher qualifications commission, bohdan mohonchuk, became the owner an apartment with an area of ​​83 square meters in the center of kharkiv and two parking spaces, the value of this property reaches over

one and a half million hryvnias, according to the kharkiv anti-corruption center, the apartments in this building are among the best in kharkiv , judges, law enforcement officials, officials , doctors and many other famous kharkiv residents settled here in 2016 2015, bohdan mokhonchuk also became the owner of a honda car worth uah 200,000, and the most interesting thing about these acquisitions of 20-year-old bohdan mokhonchuk is that according to his father's declaration for 2015, the only the source of his income was a 30,000 hryvnia scholarship and a 12,000 pension until 2020. he was not officially engaged in entrepreneurial activities, so it is unlikely that bohdan mohonchuk could afford such an expensive shopping spree and most likely it was carried out by the parents of the declaration that the only income of serhiy

bohdan's son is a scholarship and it is obvious that the purchase of this property took place at the expense of but uh hmm even judging by the incomes of serhiy and his wife, there are doubts about the ability to purchase such property with the official income of the president for the position of a member of the highest qualification commission of judges serhiy mokhonchuk worked his entire legal career in educational institutions and the territorial administration of justice where the salary does not reach millions of hryvnias, his wife also did not carry out entrepreneurial activities according to the declaration we made for 2015, 16, 17 and 19 years, she received only passive interest income, nevertheless, even after the alleged expenses on real estate, serhii makhonchuk in the declaration for 2015 reflected

the family's savings in the amount of almost 87 thousand dollars and 16 euros, a possible candidate for the higher qualification commission he was able to save even before he received his legal education, we thought, but it is also doubtful, mokhonchuk worked as a radio mechanic and served in the military during the interview, the candidate gave a simply magical explanation of his savings, you know, i really don’t like this method of calculating the amounts i earned, but there is no other i ask that the honorable members of the competition commission accept the fact that our salary has always been tied to the exchange rate of the dollar for foreign

currency during the period you were talking about, sir. somewhere between 2005 and 2010, it is about 60,000 dollars, and for the period from 2010 to 2015, it is almost 96 or 97 thousand dollars, it is logical that serhiy mohonchuk could really save if he did not eat, did not feed his children, did not buy clothes did not pay utility bills and did not spend millions on real estate. in 2012, the second son of serhiy mohonchuk was presented with a house of 202 m² in the kharkiv region . the declared value is almost one and a half million hryvnias. serhiy mohonchuk was then the head of the main office of justice in the kharkiv region, and why did he make such an expensive gift? it should be noted that part of the interview

by serhiy mykhanchuk was closed at the request of the candidate due to the discussion of confidential information. the twenty-year-old unemployed son, a student , was able to buy himself an expensive car and an apartment in an elite building in the center of kharkiv. currently , the decision of the commission regarding further participation in sergey mohochuk's competition is unknown, but our experts are unanimous from the competition commission. he could not dispel the doubts that were about his integrity. and now we will introduce you to the next candidate for the judge of the novomoskovsk city district court of the dnipropetrovsk region

. victoria berezyuk is also applying for a position in the higher qualification commission of judges of ukraine and unfortunately has short memory, contrary to anti-corruption legislation, did not declare an apartment with an area of ​​74 square meters and forgot to indicate six acres of land in property claim to the communist party of ukraine was very lucky with his relatives, father-in-law mykhailo berezyuk in 2010 was a local deputy from the party of regions and in 2015 from the opposition bloc. and here is the husband of the candidate in general. he has the superpower to sell land three times more than the market value. in 2021, he sold real estate for almost 170,000 uah, however, according to the declaration, the only immovable property that a man could sell is land plots that

as of 2017 were worth only 45 and a half thousand uah. there are also doubts about the professional suitability of the judge who claims for a position in the higher qualification commission, in particular, berezyuk closed cases of drunken driving at least 13 times under the influence of the statute of limitations and without adequate justification why it was impossible to consider them in time. judges have a large number of such exercises that are actually not so difficult, there are a lot of judges who specially abuse the consideration of such cases and, as a result, what is the abuse because the case is closed for

deadlines and accordingly the person is not punished, also the de jure foundation jumped victoria berezyuk at her own expense in her dissertation, she used 80% of the text of her article and probably as with the property, she simply forgot to indicate that this is a citation of a previous work, at the moment the work on the dissertation study of the defense in me is completed was appointed for march, the month of 2022, but due to the full-scale invasion of e-e, it did not take place. compliance and integrity of judges and candidates in the court berezyuk sees the integrity check as yes, the criterion of integrity should be checked with the help of special checks organized by the higher qualification commission by checking the declaration and also from those documents that

are provided directly by the candidate and also with the help of uh, interviews with him well, uh, maybe uh, some other uh-uh means are very interesting, and berezyuk herself, taking into account all the dubious facts of her judicial biography, passed such a check from the commission for the selection of members of the communist party of the soviet union, they satisfied their explanation to the court, we will see about the decision for today, i had all this under judicial control, i am tetyana shustrova. if you know the facts of corruption in the courts or you have encountered illegal proceedings , let us know, write to me on facebook or to my e-mail, her address you now you see it on the screen good luck, see you in exactly

a week and a very important message airborne alarm sounding almost all over the territory of ukraine, we are just starting, actually, that's great news, uh, the russians don't have time to announce that they will give us an air alarm no we manage to receive these messages right away. the second repulse is already uh once in a day, some kind of frivolous uh behavior of our enemies , it is obvious that they have something uh, a little bit wrong with their rockets, the pickets say that it seems to be over, this is good news it's nice that it's like that once and for all, we hope that there are no arrivals there and at least there is nothing in the news so far well, but in the kherson region , unfortunately, unfortunately, two people died as a result of a mine explosion near the village of dobryanka of the vysokopil community, this happened, these are farmers

uh, they went out to start field work uh, but as the kherson ova also warns, uh , don't rush until the territory is fully examined for the presence of explosives, because it can actually turn into uh, uh, these are the consequences, so please don't ignore those warnings which you have and receive from your military administrations . well, in the meantime , our interlocutors are already ready for a conversation. now let's talk a little about international politics in the context of ukraine, we welcome you, gentlemen, to our broadcast. greetings, here we can immediately go to the interview about fop, which is on the abc tv channel, where he said several interesting things, in particular, that ukraine does not

need f16 on the present moment well, there are also certain doubts that ukraine will be able to regain crimea in the near future, time said that this would happen and not so in the long term, but we have to wait until then , how should we comment on it? heard from president biden, he confirmed those things and repeated those things that were talked about before and the wars and representatives of the american government in general, uh, we have to be extremely calm about this, because we understand that in the context of, for example, the provision of airplanes , the negotiations are going on now, they are largely closed and according to them, well, their results are already known, probably then, when will you reach a principled principled position, a principled agreement on how the planes will be provided to ukraine, in what way, what planes they will be, how quickly we will get them. here is more

other things that the united states does in the context of, for example, the training of our pilots, the allocation of funds for the training of these pilots, or negotiations with other countries that in a sufficiently short period of time can still supply us with soviet-built aircraft that are, in principle , modernized to a certain extent, are valuable er are in working condition and what our pilots can be without any special training, the same is more expensive for the technical staff because when we talk about airplanes and make this topic key and focus on the new main attention forgets about one very simple thing that the plane is extremely difficult to maintain, much more difficult than a tank or any artillery system, and here we must talk not only about the plane itself and the pilots, but also about the huge team that will serve it, prepare for departures and so on, on the other hand, it seemed to me that in this interview, if you analyze it in detail, look, and again there were certain messages or messages towards the russian federation that, er, the united states and ukraine, they will help

as much as needed, and the issue, for example, of the supply of certain types of weapons, it can be decided at any moment in favor of ukraine if the united states believes that everything is necessary for victory and to force russia to get out of ukraine. conditions that ukraine will put forward, let 's address the same question to a certain screen as well . as far as i understand, she commented that half of the exports that still exist will be cut back to the russian federation or stopped, as you know, quite soon with mr. igor here in addition. also, regarding airplanes , it is really more important here at the moment that it is the practice

that is and uh, for example, yesterday and the president of ukraine, who spoke about the fact that there are specific agreements regarding the training of pilots , for example, it was specifically about the agreement with the prime minister of poland about what he opened, it was specifically said that we do not open the training of pilots for the f-16 i i think that in fact some progress has already been made in this regard, because we saw in the summer of last year some information about the visits of ukrainian pilots to american bases, and we can say that probably some kind of preparation was also taking place. again, there is cooperation specifically in aviation sphere, because at the same rammstein base, well, at least according to the reports of the western press, it was said

that there is such a working group in front of which is a gray wolf, which coordinates aid specifically to the ukrainian air force, and it and this assistance is material and methodical and methodological, which will sum up the experience of ukraine that is emerging. that is, it is what is already there, so i think that there may be news that the training of both pilots and kyiv ground personnel has already been completed. very quickly, yes, that's why this is one such moment, and uh, i wouldn't unequivocally perceive what is being talked about in a negative way, hmm, and the interview of the president of the united states, uh, regarding sanctions. i think that there is certainly

a prospect for their expansion and again ukraine is constantly working in this direction, he emphasizes, but there are several such moments, which, until now, we have entered the sanctions mechanism . well, for example, this situation with the atomic energy industry is about satom, which is a specific culture, what is terrorism, cooperation with terrorists. well, no. what does it cooperate? yes, it participates in state russian nuclear terrorism in energodar in particular . but it is clear that too many of these energy projects in the world are tied to russian nuclear energy, and not only in hungary, where dew is building there. not only on asian projects and the production of nuclear fuel with which the united states of america cooperates, and therefore it is clear that this will

drag on. although this is a very important step, because the atomic energy of the russian federation is one of the few high-tech clusters there and one of such there are few e-e examples of such well, well, with the priority of the russian yes and prestige, therefore, here and there, e-e, i am too cautiously optimistic about oil, which will really be a practice e-e for greece, for example, not to participate in bloodshed e- e of russian oil with its tankers and regarding the atomic bomb that he will be subject to a full-fledged sanction here of course there are certain nuances that yesterday, er , we all expected some missiles from vladimir putin on the occasion of the anniversary of the full-scale

invasion, meanwhile, he did not prepare anything for us and spent the evening in because he spoke with the self-proclaimed president of belarus and now also lukashenko, in addition to all that he spends the evenings talking, he says that these conversations with putin are very nice, he is going to go to china on an invitation and why why and what could they talk about with putin yesterday? well, i don't rule out that putin could, in principle, ask lukashenko to talk about something with everyone, order a word about russia separately . well, of course, they discussed some current affairs related to the cooperation between belarus and the russian federation . i would say the military-technical and partly economic cannibalism of this country, well, since lukashenko does not give this last order about the direct participation of the belarusian military in the war against ukraine, then russia

stretches all the equipment, ammunition that is there in the warehouses, actively uses training grounds in belarus to train its military, well, that is, it tries to the maximum to get at least something from this country in the context of the war against ukraine, but regarding lukashenko's visit to china, it seems to me that these things that i read about it. for example, in some russian news outlets or in russian publications that they wrote that it is almost there , they are chasing putin, who will go with some position there, will represent it , agree on something, ask for help or in general talking about the fact that china is starting to manufacture something on the territory of belarus and it will be directly supplied there to russia. i don't think it's worth talking about it now , because lukashenka has his relations with china and china has his relations directly with belarus, they have been working there for a long time, there are enough of them invested in this country. they have certain interests there, and these interests largely do not coincide with the interests of, for example, the russian federation, because it must be understood that china does not want to have any intermediaries in cooperation with these or other countries you have seen if these