[000:00:00;00] there are still enough losses in wounded and killed, they operate a pattern. you understand, this is not the first formation, this is not exactly such trained military personnel , they really recruited people. i think they were not very well prepared, they had some equipment, but they fired such beautiful columns as at a parade and left we apparently had intelligence data unequivocally, and due to this data, such a very concentrated or highly accurate strike was ensured precisely because it was destroyed , demoralized. world war, so thank you mr. andriy andriy ryzhenko experts of the defense strategy center such questions of the first rank of the reserve of the armed forces of ukraine e-e thank you, they talked about how ukraine will liberate the crimean peninsula

e-e let me remind you what he thinks he will be able to do by the end of the year ben so that's all and also says that without control over the crimea, ukraine will be vulnerable, particularly economically, because the ways from the crimea were written by a viewer before our introduction of the second part, so about the mass of the oil woman. and she says that our grandmother and tatyana belik a line that her grandmother is from the sumy region . she doesn't remember in her childhood that buttercups and grandmothers were celebrated, not pancakes, but hell pancakes and pies. here's the testimony of a living person. pancakes well, now they will call us from canada and tell us that we love pancakes with maple syrup and everything provided here , in fact , they have pancakes. pancakes, what kind of pancake, damn pancake

, what kind of pancake is that? but nevertheless, you see, people say that there were no pancakes, there were fritters or something a little bit on er, these days, those who are now trying to make butter, so it’s not scary to have flatbread pancakes with us, i already think that in ukraine now, if you take the best russian pelmeni and only they exist in different ways well, for example, well, they think that everything is their type, they have become a chinese affair and compare how zakharova is at the beginning of their sfo that we don’t want to share borscht and now he didn’t want to leave silpo, take any, any dumplings that are medium appreciate cement, compare everything and now it will be clear that our reception is 100,500 times better , although it is not ours. well, not our dish is not ukrainian. well, but less, but we will do better than you. these new segments

will now be discussed with mykhailo frank, the first - this is the president of the chamber of commerce and industry of ukraine, although we are here with mr. mykhailo a little bit on the military topic, the price topic, but mr. mykhailo came in, we congratulate you. he said correctly, there were fritters, i especially liked fritters with poppy seeds, but this, er, if we are talking about dumplings, well, in our country, the world is now called a big village, that's how the interpenetration of cultures goes, but for example, traditional ukrainian cabbage rolls are a turkish dish, even an arab dish, let's say so there they wrapped only rice, meat and grape leaves. and when he got here to ukraine, there was no problem with grapes in ukraine, the lawyer did not have any, and this is already the late middle ages after

the ottomans flooded the former byzantium empires of the 16th-17th centuries when interpenetration began and instead of rice there was buckwheat or buckwheat grew, then when rice appeared this is how it went. slavic is purely turkic, remember how they are doing there, so the situation is normal , it is not ukrainian, it is not russian, it is generally borrowed, by the way, about borscht, when it was the 300th anniversary of the celebration of st. petersburg , the vice prime minister told me with which i worked vasylevich, they were at a solemn feast in st. petersburg, and the then president leonid danilovich kuchma was terribly indignant when the traditional russian dish borscht was written on the menu of the solemn feast. he said, well , what the hell is borscht, a traditional russian dish , well, muscovites have never distinguished themselves with modesty, but let's return to our questions

. actually, our questions are such that now defense customers must publish in the prozoro system the prices at which they buy goods for the military and other goods and services to ensure proposed by the current minister of defense of ukraine after the scandal with eggs, which are measured either in quantity or in kilograms, pluses, minuses, yes, this is the kind of approach a corrupt person has to cover his scheme , well, we're joking. i think so, i'm joking, but it you know, i'm saying that. well, what was left for them to do, how did they have to justify themselves? well, it won't take ten minutes, let's measure it in kilograms. well, he loads oranges in barrels . remember, the classic of soviet literature said the same here, but in reality it's a big

problem. and we're the fourth thing i have was a discussion with the head of the anti-corruption committee, anastasia er-e rud, the family, which and just as well, we talked actively on this topic , you know, on the one hand, this is ordinary looting, and for that, you should be prosecuted according to the laws of wartime, because people who shed their blood and scoundrels who profit from this on the other hand, it is definitely necessary to build such a system in which there would be competitive prices, high-quality goods , high-quality food, because no army in the world if it is not clothed a well-fed provision of ammunition victory will not be because of nutrition - this is one of the main things that a person in order to fight actively must receive a sufficient number of kilocalories, and from my point of view - this is a good option because this is the closure that was

, but well, this is the recurrence of the first days of the war , we things from this people's deputy were discussed on this topic, and not only about closed purchases by the ministry of defense. and you still remember that we closed e, including the declarations of civil servants of people's deputies about these registers. now they are closed, and they are declarations declarations are not made. in principle, this seems to be a question. opa, mr. mykhailo, disconnected our closed register of vat refunds, we made statements in the ukrainian radio business of the chamber of commerce and industry. questions, please separate it into a separate folder and write that this is closed information related to security defense and the rest should know because this is a competitive environment, this is accessibility so, coming back

to the procurement of the ministry of defense i am sure that the adoption of this draft law just moved from its place, but it is, but by the way, i spoke then and said that from the point of view of business, from the point of view of the chamber of the ukrainian business council, we support openness, but we are very cautious about such proposals what was there, why let's tie the price to the state comstat, well, the state comstat is called an average police station. i gave an example of it in october, potatoes in the territory of ukraine were sold in the chernihiv region for 3.50, and in privoza in odesa - 30 hryvnias, at what price? we will choose the average one, you understand, and in addition, the state comstat gives information - this is the one that was already available for the month that came, that is, a more flexible system will be needed here, for which the deputy told me that they took this into account and there will now be a separate mechanism that will be the cabinet of ministers, but there is more

one, what to buy, to buy a product or to buy a service, this is exactly what we joked with you at the beginning . who will prepare for them to go to the kitchen or go to combat training, it is obvious that this should be done by civilians, this should be done by specialists, then we will talk about the fact that we are buying a service and not a product . then everything will be fine, but there is little to buy, it is still necessary to prove, it is necessary to prepare, we still have a topic for discussion, i am still more inclined to the fact that especially body parts, especially where exactly by the way, there was a scandal there should still be to buy a service, not a product. i think that this will give our military an opportunity not to be distracted by everyday problems, but

to deal with what they are good at, beating the enemy in russia, and this week they classified the information of the state commissariat of russia regarding the fluctuation of prices for consumer products food - food, as far as i remember, teaching is connected with the fact that they , uh, well, it is classified because, well, because the secret is not classified with us, fortunately, and uh, that's why we see that we also have fluctuations although we do not have such a dramatic drop in the exchange rate, for example. well, we do not have a drop in the exchange rate of the hryvnia against the dollar at all. in the last few months, the hryvnia has even strengthened a little in russia . on the contrary, in just one month , their ruble has fallen by 20%, and this is probably happening in this country. also noted that prices have risen, that products are slightly more expensive, especially imported tomatoes

, and analysts from fruit will say that the price of tomatoes jumped by 16% literally in a couple of days, and this is connected with the fact that power outages and they don't store well, well, there are no more power outages. this is some kind of bad explanation for salad. it also became more expensive if you compare it with the prices a year ago, then it almost doubled in price, that is, if someone likes some arugula. or iceberg salad well, you have to save a little money from your pocket, do you want a comment from me? so why is it more expensive , what would someone say, the same herb, why is it more expensive, what is wrong with these tomatoes , what is wrong with tomatoes, because the logistics

became expensive, you remember we mainly export imports are 70% of what is currently going through the counters, now the railway is going now road transport but here it is a little different i would like to return to the dollar, we remember you and andriy about a month ago and i told you my forecast about what the dollar will be worth at the end of next year 36-38 you and i agreed that whoever loses will put up a bottle of whiskey yes, but so far my prediction is slowly coming true, the dollar from 45 is now already 39.5 is getting cheaper a little bit, so i hope that it will be just right and normal how many years are left until the bottle of whiskey remind me, yes , it's already not bad , already one and a half hryvnias left. andriy, i 'm already here. can you

burp you? about a month ago, two years ago, about the fact that the price of green lard increased, what did they understand, why did it increase in price , because it is easier to store, yes, it was settled, and it is regardless of whether it will be at room temperature or in the freezer lying down, nothing will happen, unlike meat, so lard was stuffed and salted, so it dropped in price by uah 10, and chicken increased, but some parts of the chicken increased by uah 2, those that became cheaper, so there is such a diverse tradition here. by the way, we now have a new move an onion appeared, it turns out bloomberg wrote that the world lacks onions, not only grain, but also onions. that's why journalists asked me to comment that in the philippines, onions are more valuable than a dollar. well, it's not impressive in the world, including in ukraine. we by the way

were one of the major exporters, including onions, especially the south of ukraine, onions and garlic - this is our traditional, there were articles and traditionally farmers grew a lot , especially korean garlic. onions, so i fully admit that we have a great variety of prices, i specially conducted marketing yesterday from 30 to 100 uah , depending on the type of onion in silpo, it was different in other stores, but it could be otaki deficit well, plus, the season is still coming to an end, traditionally, don't forget today, february 26, that since the fall we have been slowly eating up. and if we talk about meat, here is a very interesting story for me . polish pork producers have recently come out and offered deliveries of a large batch. they are worried that we will be with meat, i called back to a couple of retail chains. i say here, the poles offer pork. you need to know all

the practical retail chains that we refused for them. our frozen pork is bought on fire, he wants to eat chilled frozen meat, somehow you and i, ukrainians, don't want to eat anymore, we want to eat fresh. here's an example, yes, as we say, these don't grow, but their producer is enough, this shows exactly what, in principle, we we predicted with you a month ago, and of course there will be small features , but they will be within 10-15% of the threshold, there will be such fluctuations, something will grow, something will become cheaper, gasoline has become cheaper, which is definitely nice, although remember in the spring when you will be under it by the way generators. it's an interesting story. the market was saturated. they used to sell 30,000 units. now you can buy 90,000 units. that is, we have such a lively life in the post-no economy . something is constantly changing. the main thing is that it changes for the better, mr. mykhailo. and what will happen when

the price of electricity increases? well, i remember that the government undertook the obligation that electricity tariffs will not increase. i think that they will keep it until the end of the war, because electricity is a large component of practicality in all products and industrial in the spring, that is, very soon, i wonder who it will be, but if it suddenly rises in price, then all the prices will rise, we will look at the situation, it will depend on how much and under what conditions, because where there is less, there is more , for example, in agriculture, it depends more on gasoline and diesel fuel there depends more on such components there, energy-intensive, let's say in industry , it depends on that mechanical engineering, will it be or will it still be, let's say the production of other products will also depend, well, it will definitely lead to growth, but we will have hope

about the fact that the government will keep it as long as possible, because it is good in us, and to transfer to industry the times of kuchma, they transferred the costs that uh, it bore, so that industry for the population is now simply physically impossible, because industry will not withstand competition if there is hope that nothing will grow for the time being, we will pay according to the old payments, as mr. mykhailo, they added a little optimism, and optimism - this is a very cool thing in general for the economy, so actually. thank you, mykhailo, the first vice president of the chamber of commerce and industry of ukraine was also from by us well, we are here to make threads, you know frozen pork, what is borscht with lard and black bread, well, it is delicious, by the way, about borscht, which we have already mentioned here, i read it recently by olena braichenko - she is such a publisher who made a book about food and culture

where ukrainian history is told through ukrainian national dishes, because a lot of dishes were actually also destroyed, forgotten and supplanted by those soviet all kinds of eh olivier and what is there , what is it, what is interesting, a fashionable food blogger in the world who has one and a half million subscribers after as the ukrainian woman wrote to him, he decided to dedicate his blog to ukrainian borscht, but he doesn't just have it there , he tells how this borscht is prepared and what it is , and through this borscht, he tells about the history of the dish itself. well, also about the history country, and i skimmed through this video a little bit, it has already gained several hundred thousand views, and in this video, in particular , this blogger talks about the cossacks , obviously, how they cooked, you will have to listen to it in english. well, it

it is very interesting that this is such a trip through borscht to ukraine by this max miller, er, theist is called his youtube channel , you see, he tells where it is, i think i understand where it is possible correctly, a person makes the correct maps , and there also appear, er, all kinds of people who are for our history, it's also uh-uh iconic. well, i think it's uh-uh, it's interesting for foreigners , of course, who now have a huge demand for ukraine and for ukrainian publications in particular . well, it's also interesting and the same for us, besides that , this blogger recommends actually buy the ukraine book ukraine food and history, where ukrainian history is also told through dishes, some myths are debunked well, it is probably also told there, and in particular, about what was prepared at zapusti collodion, or buttermilk, and oleksa ocean, political scientist, head of the platform,

the only coordinating the center is glad to see you. good morning. it's already a day . i congratulate you. we've started. it's still going on in the morning . it's early. putin said that there are no ukrainians, this is a fictional nation and the ukrainian language, too, exactly one year after the large-scale invasion , president putin makes a shocking discovery that there are no russians. and if everything continues, then there will be muscovites. this is a quote from putin. who inhabit russia so it is to comment on what it means well, i am not even ready to comment on it seriously, let's say because it is clear that these are hallucinations putin uh, what

he has from time to time insights in them occur then again he walks in a historical hallucination but he is right here in what section a-a and by the way, this is a foreign car on the correct map of the football player, because it is correct for us there to the east, and the ethnic map of ukraine is correct , but politically it is now correct only to the east to the kuban why because when russia questioned the territorial integrity of ukraine and began to annex the territories of crimea, eastern ukraine, and the territories not under the control of kherson and zaporozhye , they broke their territorial integrity, they actually violated it, and today they have territorial claims against russia can nominate any states, because where the borders of russia are completed , they are not completed today, but not in the direction of expansion , but in the direction of reduction. the whole existence of russia

in today's form , in the form of the territorial system, in the form of the organization of today's understanding of the image of russia, there are cultural and economic, financial and other capabilities and its special service influences and geopolitical weight, and i can this the series can be endlessly continued, ending with its role in energy security and the world energy market , for example, all of this has been questioned and all of this is burning now, the wars have ended, so he is right, he started the process of destroying russia, and the longer this war lasts, the more severe the consequences for russia will be, the more catastrophic this will be there will be a war and it will end in such a case for russia with greater losses and greater defeat, then internal political , internal economic and further internal three -point processes, therefore he is right, yes, further to him

muscovites of the urals, whoever else, these are completely different social, economic, etc. fragments of russia, even if they are preserved as a single whole, they will have to go through the process of reassembly. that is, it will no longer be the process of the collapse of russia, it will de facto find itself in a half-collapsed state, because even if you take just its unity, it is maintained on the one hand by propaganda, which understood that at the moment of the war, it will weather away as soon as ernst's towers are turned off , there will be inertia. but nevertheless, all this flora is artificial, it will weather away right before our eyes and the second is the square-nest method of a-a quartering of the power block. look at the situation, let's take, i don't know, some country , france. for example, if the gendarmerie police disappears tomorrow in france , there will be a complete increase in banditry, disturbances may be certain, etc., but

the state remains a state, its borders do not go anywhere and it does not spread marseille does not separate and paris does not become autonomous and further on the list in russia if we remove tomorrow and the police factor of the special services what will happen to russia will that is, parts of the law enforcement system there are not law enforcement, there the police special service system is binding. if you are talking about scraps of russia, they really have two propaganda and a power block of internal violence, as soon as they disappear, everything will fall apart and, accordingly, we will have to assemble. and here the question is how many resources will remain in russia and the need and opportunity to ensure our integrity through the provision of this process of assembly and accordingly transformation or we will see the slippage of these parts in different directions, and here putin is absolutely right, he himself accelerated this process, he

himself now put absolutely everything into code, but i want to go a little deeper . hope for the best, but plan real actions based on pessimistic scenarios, and there is a pessimistic scenario that he discussed at the munich security conference that russia can theoretically fight with its mobilization potential until 2030 and this war until the last one, the russian had a pump and so on. and it’s not a fact that this can happen, but this is the worst-case scenario we’re talking about now, and here i ’ll also allow myself to quote michael kaufman , one of the well- known military analysts of the united states, who says that in the war

to exhaustion, which has been going on for the second year , the decision is always made when the war ends . it is not the side that wins, but the one that loses, and even if it is the side of russia, relatively speaking. already you win a golden bridge for him so that you don't actually have to fight to the last russian and we have an optimistic scenario - it's now a super successful counteroffensive in spring summer autumn okay and that will simply shake russia's russian army and lead to some kind of capture of this empire, we see that so was in its history or we have not so optimistic options and in this case we have to think about what to do in order not to fight with them to the last russian until the 30th year, which could be this golden muscovite

retreat for putin, or at least for the russians, well, look, there is already a whole series of a-and, first of all, for putin and the russians, these are two different bridges, because now on the scales of the scales, on the one hand, they found themselves in this russia that everyone is used to seeing, and on the other, why schalke there are friends, putin and bolivar will not pull both of them out, now russia is in the mode of saving putin and the putin regime due to the burning of russia's strategic reserve a-a a-a more and more certain processes are appearing that tell us that there are forces that understand this about this is what they are trying to do to tip the scales in the other direction in order to save russia at the expense of burning putin and the regime, for example, a recent article in one of the western publications about the fact that putin alone allegedly made decisions there, his advisers are catherine peter i of another and everyone who is no longer

in this world and that lavrov i didn't know that the invasion would take place there, i found out literally an hour before it. well, that's all for me. well , first of all, it's obvious that they knew, that is, under many different circumstances, we can say affirmatively about it. second, what exactly is that? the article appears and is symptomatic of the fact that part of the elites are now trying to expose putin to extremes and are already preparing for themselves a congress of the fact that if they were in charge, this would not have happened, but they were the first to be taken prisoner, putin took them prisoner and they are not to blame , of course they are responsible, but they are not responsible, so let's put putin out of kovrenov, let's leave everything as it is, they are trying to create this situation for themselves, this speaks of the processes of destruction that the regime itself may not withstand this long, long war, a war of demographic attrition. there is potential, and reserves there are certain resources in russia, but there is no management and administrative reserve to ensure this, today's racism is a kind of chinese forgery that crossed

german nazism and soviet bolshevism, and that's where racism was born, but it is a chinese forgery, it is neither ethical, nor political, nor resourceful it is not even close to stalinism and cannot act with those mechanisms and will not be able to deploy itself in this direction and it needs to turn 180° into air and this is impossible, therefore it can crumble even in these processes and will turn out to be a rather rotten colossus, but they answer that, of course, it is necessary to prepare for the worst according to the scenario, and of course , ukraine should understand that this war can drag on and there may be unfavorable conditions that can drag on and strengthen the situational russia, but at the same time, let's say , get out it is definitely not worth rejecting completely optimistic scenarios and losing hope, as the practice on the maidan always shows. alone at home , he was thinking in the right direction, the wind is in

naf and our winters are warm, while it is they are needed warm, and in russia they are icy at the moment when they need them warm. therefore, it is obvious that very often the stars line up in the right constellation, we have every chance so that it will not be a protracted war of attrition and the processes in russia, even the internal ones , are moving where the world appreciates it faster than today, thank you too oleksa lukyan, political scientist, head of the platform, the single coordination center, was with us, and we also want to tell you about the fact that we are reminding you about the urgent collection for a thermal imaging sight for the defenders of the fighters of europe in the name of our budget chief in of the 2nd 51st battalion of the 241st brigade, and