[000:00:00;00] in particular, she expressed the representatives of the guru there, in particular, the deputy head of the gur, general skibytskyi, of course, this is one of the tools and in the future of our security , mr. mykola. thank you for your comments and for your time, for your inclusion, and i will remind our viewers that there was a serviceman of the armed forces on the air of the espresso channel forces of ukraine , spokesman for the international community of napalm information, mykhailo makaruk, and then i would like to sum up the results, they are that the situation is really related to the creation of new types of weapons and the construction combat operations on the battlefield remains extremely difficult and it requires joint attention from the state structure of institutions and from our experts and politicians, journalists who should pay more attention to all directions that can increase

the effectiveness of the use of our armed forces on the battlefield, stay tuned to the channel espresso, where will there be other news related to the life of ukraine and our armed forces? good afternoon. today we have such an unusual broadcast and its duration is also very unusual. the information war that is going on is not the first year actually against our country, let's talk about how it affects ukraine . we will also talk about how it changes the russian propaganda itself and what it has actually reached during this year, but first of all let's look at such a selection made by people unknown to me but definitely good people and which seems to me to be a very good result of this war for russia as you know, tanks are approaching kiev

, tanks are already in kiev, captain, already knots in kiev 3 5 maximum 8 march broy podnyim and ukraine

поймёт всё возлем киев и киев будет от программе so deeper three and a half days and 2 days later the fall of the city glory to ukraine also understand the incredibly disappointing consequences of this invasion and in general, the disappointing consequences of this year for them continue already an hour away from achieving the goals a huge number of dead united states of america and the whole the so-called collective west behaves as if we were not capable of any kind of retaliation we, in turn, are only demonstrating we continue to demonstrate peace-loving

still in white gloves and if i remember the phrase of the russian president that we didn’t start at this moment because we hadn’t started yet , the truth is that everything that could be used by conventional weapons, russia used them tomorrow, too, nothing works, that’s of course their problem. and what about them he has achieved this year and what russia has achieved, let's look at all the new messages and i don't believe my eyes . the collective mind says that we must defeat russia. and every personal president, prime minister, minister and minister of foreign affairs personally takes an oath and says that we must impose martial law on russia to some extent, this is somewhat similar to a meeting of the security council of russia

where vadym vladimir putin was asked personally and asked to express his opinion about the inclusion of the russian people's republic in the recognition of the dpr of the lpr. to give orders to people to burn when it was possible to see and here there is nothing , we don’t have one muscle on the face is not expensive mentioned how, on the eve of the invasion, putin polled his closest circle regarding the fact that it is necessary to annex the luhansk donetsk region, not necessary. you all understood that this would lead to further military actions and and actually this closest one the environment that understood that they were trying to make them accomplices and show it literally on live air that

look, everyone is participating in this, no one can be clean among the russian leaders, and actually they were not very happy about it, but this is at the same time and uh and after and what was interviewed and what everyone knew what was going on let's remember and how did you lie at all at the beginning of the war uh more precisely at the beginning of the invasion because the war has been going on since the 14th year in the 14th year, there was a major invasion for the first time when crimea was captured, so what actually happened in in the 22nd year, at the beginning of the year, for example, what was said and how it was said that they would not be attacked. for example, zakharova is the spokesperson of the ministry of foreign affairs. here, on the 19th , let's fill in this date: february 19, 22nd. what

did she say? fakes, disinformation, slander, ah, i don't know what lies are called, ah, i haven't seen them in a concentrated form for a long time. that's what the spokesman said the same days the kremlin, the spokesman for putin, piskun, urges us to ask ourselves the question in what sense russia is attacking someone . who was not attacked by russia, which has survived so many wars, this is the last

country in europe that wants to talk about history even when it is bad . more years before the war, the masses have been telling a completely different story - no, russia has never led a defensive war, it turns out that it was the majority, it was exactly attacks attacks on other countries, see well, one thing is defensive wars, the other thing is offensive . aleksandr suvorov did not participate in any of the wars of the electorate. here is a state that has won a huge number of victories, but call me some kind of mutton war in which suvorov somehow participated. that is, in the full sense of the word, he was never engaged there. and in the elephant, i am talking about the reflection of aggression. yes, we are also a little bit here, eh. it seems to me that when they shot there , they kiss the system of a well-founded, well, such a thing , when that is all volumes. why the pathos in relation to the great patriotic war, we are a little yes, too

they themselves rounded up this topic, that if we were attacked , that’s it , that’s right , there can be no second chance. there is a lot of nostalgia, which is not suitable for any kind of defensive wars at all. it is not suitable because it is needed by the national interests of russia , including because russia is ... on his neighbors and in general on everyone it is not clear, but you see no defensive wars, that is normal, that is, he is so very frank . i would say he is a propagandist, and this date , february 19, is interesting, it is worth knowing because , if you say so from well more comprehensively now, when we look back, i can say that there is a day when russia launched in its information space, in fact

, an open attack on ukraine. and this, in principle, there are enough confirmations for this , for example, you know what it's called, it came , it came at a time that was simply beautiful stories, for example, not so long ago, on the channel of the ministry of defense of the russian federation, they interviewed a volunteer from luhansk, who fought all this year , a young guy who even received some awards there, and here are his memories for him the war has started, well, in fact, this is an invasion and it's hot, so fa for wars, look, i can't give any objective, reasonable answer to the question when i came from school.

the head of the lpr, he means that he is talking about the fact that the military actions have been activated, that ukraine is bringing the troops to our borders. well, all 20 villages will be declared mobilized. that same evening, i gathered my things and in the morning at 9 pm i went to the assembly points. something has been announced, mobilization 21 has been announced in february, he was already at the collection point. and where was anyone at the collection point? well, there were probably some people somewhere, but i was not at the collection points . there was no mobilization in ukraine. they still thought that he would attack, he would not attack, and then listen to what he says, how he found out. now the donbass are constantly talking about the bombshells. it is because of this that the boy remembered at least once that he heard explosions and therefore understood how the war began. well, i don’t know for 60% of ukrainians how the phrase

began. at four in the morning five heard even this was heard even in the western regions of ukraine, it's not that i'm not saying this on the line of contact uh there luhansk donetska the guy turns out to have heard on tv from pasichnyk from the head of the uh occupation administration that someone is charging something there something is probably happening some actions have become more active and that's why we are announcing something there, that's all. because that's how it was, it was a legend. when the shelling of the ukrainian territory began on february 17, i talked about it, uh, at the end of the year. that's when i had such a final annual program who wants you can see, i told it further, how on february 17, er, the russian federation began shelling the contact line in luhansk, donetsk, there in luhansk, they kissed in the kindergarten, in the school, there was a miracle. no one

was hurt, no children died. it was just a big miracle, and then they probably expected there will be some answer that now a hundred ukrainian troops will start hitting something and they will then be able to say that something has started, everything is happening , nothing has happened ukrainian troops have not staged any such shelling of peaceful cities they were simply responding to the military objectives that existed at that time and that was all and that was it and it was more than that. again, i told this at the beginning of this heated phase until february 24. peaceful citizens who should have died yes. that is, they say that they were shelling donbas so, during these first two months of the 22nd year, exactly one person, myrna, died in the occupied territory, and he died because he was shot by some local bandits at a checkpoint, even all of them were the locals

who shot him there, and that was the only one victims at that time of civilians. and how many victims, tell me for this year in donetsk alone? well, i think there have been several dozen if not hundreds there for a long time, and this is the result . as they say, one of them is dmytro kulikov, uh, how he actually provided reliable support for the beginning of the great invasion, how he went to donetsk for this purpose, also on february 19, look unevenly on the 17th, uh, well, i think that it is necessary as if чититывать от время входжение эту месяция специальную er, er, military operation

on the 17th, then the shelling began, er, i think i already planned to go in alone, which i was there, we had 35 or 36 reports for the art, it turned out to be the first thing to do right away, so that you understand the atmosphere. only this is the 19th of the month of donbas, which means in donetsk. you have led the evacuation because information has been received about the bombing in donetsk itself. the donetsk palace of culture has left . a letter has arrived on the e-mail for 101. yes , even with shelling, with shelling i'm reminding you that it was just a week of supermining, so i'll explain the situation to you because there was nothing to show, because you walk around the center of donetsk, there was nothing, he says, everything is calm . well, the guy came, he has to do something , he came out right next to the hotel where he lives and decided to show what mining was and tell something

about it well, after that i went to show the mobilization, see on the same day i went to the assembly point because the mobilization was announced and here it is right there in donetsk on the evening of the 19th i thought about happiness, i thought about happiness, the waiter runs away, the waiter says that we are all leaving the hotel, but he didn’t give much. well , i managed to get to you

. well, actually, the very center of donetsk has already gathered beautifully . it's a pain because it's the same thing, it's the 20th in the morning, in my opinion, or the 19th, in the morning, at the airport. and the airport was already shelled on the 20th and the day of the appointment of the republics. that's what i met in donetsk, that's on square sasha kots yulia checherina point i'm happy that i came i'm saying thank you because it brought people there , well, some such distraction and the opportunity to talk to be photographed i went

to the kuibyshev district of the dk named after the kuibyshev bush where the departure point is one of the daughters bus departures there, the bus is almost fully equipped, and you know it, here is a large soviet climatograph, we often saw it in the cinema, the conductors are standing at the door of the bus, a guy and a girl say goodbye , the guy doesn't stay, she dries up well, in general the bus, the children are in the summer of 1941. yes, i also spoke with them and said that they are waiting for them in russia. finally, the heart breaks and you see, when i heard me , there was only one question. sergey, they say it’s time

when he’s vadimchik, that’s all. that’s it. well, that is, all these little pictures of hearts, all of this is so downright cute and it’s about time , it’s february 19, i’ll remind you, february 19, that is, a few more days, and here they are, these days, they just filmed there and told how it was. they are preparing to evacuate our people a month ago they were brought as if a month later, donetsk got better. well, well, they won't sit around all the time. there's nothing for them to sit there somewhere near muscovy . let them sit at home. let them go and fight so that the next thing will happen . well, actually, here is the result. now they say that they are now fighting, right? and it’s not with ukraine for a long time, although that’s the question. well, let’s see. i didn’t see it anywhere

, for example, the entire consolidation of the west and their support of our enemy. it ’s clear that we are the military of ukraine. that's what started, that's what started, that's all for everyone else, the other reality , the other special military operations, the war. no, this is a different reality. will say yes, yes, what happened, yes, you have to think about it, everything is not so clear-cut, but suddenly it didn’t happen like that, everything turned out to be clear here, you are definitely in a neighboring country, you are just aggressors, and probably you should be hit on the head for this, because it is impossible and it does not exist yes cannot be

to attack the neighboring countries and yet, they were very surprised at this well, i don't know who you have to be to be surprised by this well, the reality is that no matter how many people say that ukraine was defeated and now it is not known who they are fighting with , even i would say solovyov does not agree with her that defeated dnipropetrovsk kharkiv sumy-chernigov and eh i'm just what's the point i'm glad i learned all the geography of the very small cities of donbass but i'd like to go through a large population center to remember well i understand what is the second war? well, it's just somehow lower. why, how, how, why, how, how, why, they hit moscow, they sunk, what did russia respond to? in kiev

, they destroyed the decision-making center of the general staff of our defense . so far, russian territory has not been destroyed, how much is already shelled and the kursk belgorod region ukraine, the russians somehow responded harshly to this yes. not so much. well, the conflict with nato is understandable. well , if you ask me to describe in one sentence what path russian propaganda has taken in this year, it is the path from the desire to seize more territory of ukraine to just a desire to kill more people without any victory hopes for victory just kill more people this does not mean that they do not want to seize more territory of ukraine , of course they want but understand that this is a futile hope therefore, now all russian propaganda is aimed only at for one more murders, and it doesn’t matter if theirs is not theirs, and in fact, it is they who are preaching

now, we took kyiv in three days, kyiv was like that , masol sejjak, the ruins of hundreds of thousands of dead people, if not millions, and here on in an absolutely destroyed theater of military action, there was a statement saying, if we take the goal, this is an example of one city there, next to each other, the region, what else , clean it up, there is nothing left, if we say that you are there , kiev is the mother of the city, yes it is the mother of the city, russian well if it is necessary for kiev to remain ruined, our flag was standing on top, even on the ground. i think we should go for it like this, we are fighting everywhere

. well, you know, at first propaganda tried to come and tell us that they were liberating, then it turned out that there was a huge resistance of the population, no one felt anything about the liberating , everyone complained about it, after that they tried to demoralize the army, demoralize the population , tell us some horrors that everyone is being killed, that the soldiers at the front are being killed to somehow stimulate them to surrender as prisoners , this information company of the russians also failed, and the following is what they tried to do by shelling cities to lead to what is simply the population will begin to demand something there, well, it is not known that signing peace on any terms probably also did not work, and after that, when it was already clear that it would not work anyway, now it is just a matter of destroying everything, and when we struck a serious blow on energy, well, in kyiv, why is it the summer of energy it means that they didn’t carry dokatsa. but there exists

there , they have restaurants, and there they dance and sing everything else, and according to our data, you can read irises on every street. vysovyvat but definitely not from baidan there, i woke him up, let's move on to it, and while it's not enough, let's write how many months, an honest month will wait for two and two , let's wait. well, tolstov, there are two, the main thing is to just destroy it more. we see now, what will be the development of events, let's talk with oleksiy holobotsky, this is a political technologist, the deputy director of the situation modeling agency . congratulations, oleksiy, look. during this year, there was such an informational conflict that for you it was absolutely the same expectations and what, on the contrary, turned out to be a surprise well, while you are thinking, i will answer, but for me, for example, it was completely expected

that russian society would enter this war with readiness and without an opening, they will justify the atrocities of their army there , the murders of the civilian population, they will justify all this. but what for me it was not, well , just not so unexpected, and i was surprised that despite many years of funding and the traditions of propanding in russian there, they could not come up with anything bright, that is, they constantly cry that there is no support of this war that not even good songs can be created and that actually so far they have not falsified ideology, this is my impression, what is your impression , well, unexpectedly, well, nothing like that, i just remember the first month, for example, the broadcast, what were there and when we were constantly talking about something there, i listened to other experts this is unexpected for me. well, first of all, i agree with you about the russian

people. for me, this is absolutely my hope. i did not doubt it, but the russian elite doubted it, and the entire opposition is russian a lot. intellectuals of russian doubts, they thought that this would cause some opposition , i did not doubt it. it seems to me that one more person did not argue. well, this was inherent in the beginning, so now i will tell you about our perception, not about what russia talked about in three days, we still have a much more democratic country, but this is constantly a-a that russia will bend economically in the coming months that problems that i do not

it will be enough there for a long time and so on well, this is me, just like now, i will say that this is a surprise for me, putin in this regard, putin turned out to be a very pragmatic person and remains a pragmatic person, and the shine of his speech stan, which was dedicated to the economic part there of course, there are a lot of fantasies about everything else, but the main thing is that he considers it his personal point of view that the market economy is the best option for the existence of the state, and the market economy cannot become one, you see these idiots with hordes and epaulettes, they are all in the narrative of the soviet union, why didn't russia do what they demand, not because it is not so kind and good, because it is not the soviet union and it is not possible for them

, simply, simply, there is no possibility, yes. simply, if would putin think that a nuclear attack would bring him something tactically, he would have struck yes, he simply did not see at this stage that something positive could happen, everything else, they have already tested everything on us, they have tested everything. this is all that is currently available in the russian army with from the point of view of what we don't do , they can't bomb with mastite because they have very little of this height of accurate weapons, and it's very difficult to get across the bridge, let's put it this way. there is no total control over the airspace of ukraine, we all all the story about strengthened it about taking it in three days , by the way, he is there, well, it’s a lie, they don’t always ignore all these facts, but the mass was elected 9 months ago, even before his

sport began they gave a real opportunity to get out of this public population, this is how it will go, there were only militants left, who simply ran around the ruins of this en masse . well, they committed against uh, that's why you and this, again , it's all a lie, that is, everything possible, they just did, well, the state of the russian army on the present moment this is what we see if it were more possible in russia to destroy the entire system of army training and morale in general by involving these convicts in the military affairs by throwing them well why do it if everything, well , supposedly there is another mechanism means a lot there are no such mechanisms regarding propaganda, i watched the program at the beginning, well, it is obvious that the ideology is not there or there is no specific instruction, but there is simply no part of the instruction, we understand that we see