[000:00:00;00] and somewhere in the future, perhaps all acquaintances will be used to influence your work, but mr. kryvonos is in charge or was in charge - this is a challenge, this is a huge job, eh, it requires both leadership, managerial , and professional knowledge, if indeed mr. kryvonos is elected as a manager, i will buy from us we can only hope that you can hear us . i think i'm lost. well, there are already some conclusions . at this stage, representatives of international organizations who are also members of the commission say what they say about this involvement, well, the influence on there was no selection, but the conflict of interests is obvious, well, at least some personal connections, but this is a key position in

corrupt activities, as ak, the fight against corruption is for us a key element and a trump card in european integration, so this person is very important for all of us, and if there is conflict of interests well, later we will be poked into all this when we ask for money and weapons and everything, yes, this is an interesting question because we have three representatives of international and partners in the commission together with three ukrainian colleagues and, for example, one of representatives of e-e international organizations e-e members of the selection commission she made such a statement during the last meeting, you can say why she is not ready to vote for such a trio that she does not support e-e so such questions did she speak to all the members of the english commission or that is, she

actually abstained from voting . she was one of the three representatives of the international members of the commission. but why are there ukrainian scientists in the commission oleksiy savchuk also did not support, for example, this trio, i.e. the commission gathered a minimum number of votes for these three candidates in general in order to submit them to the government. i think that this is also an indicator in a certain way that not everyone was ready to vote for three candidates in this uh-uh formulation, or they did not specifically support all three, but believed that all three should be different or someone specific among these three candidates. well, this is already open to interpretation. i think that our international partners will primarily rely on

on the results of the work, no matter who is appointed from among the heads of the nabu, and it will be very quickly. i think it will be clear, because now the charge of our investigations is going to detectives, and in the near future there may be even more, and we will quickly see whether the new leader is ready to make difficult decisions or not. unfortunately, the results of that, if there is not a full diet, will also be quite serious for us. budget every month ms kateryna, thank you for your work. kateryna ryzhenko, deputy executive director of international ukraine for legal issues, what opportunities are waiting for us nazarii berbeka, a public figure, a member of the lviv city council, let's talk about ms. valevska's favorite topic of local

self-government, nazariya, we congratulate you. good health. greetings. have a good day. on the eve of the system, we started a little with the ideologue of the reform of our main and most successful local samovar, anatoly tkachuk, and this is what they presented. the council of europe presented research 76.5% of ukrainians believe that the reform of local self-government or decentralization , as it is called, and territorial authorities should be continued, and you even played a positive role in resisting the large-scale offensive of russia . what do you think, because now there are voices that say that now we we don't see well, there is no tunnel , we need to stop it all now, win and then see how to develop yes and develop further and yes, in fact, there are such conversations that the reform should

be suspended and even last year when there was forum of local self-government, many mayors talked about this with great concern that it would be a disaster for the city and there were proposals let's take the e-e part of personal income tax from the city that fills more than 65% of our budgets and let's take the taxes that pay military personnel to the city budgets but in reality nothing has changed this year, the city budget is filled as it was in previous years and is able to finance not only those things that are inherent to cities, but also cities today finance many things that they not inherent, well, in particular well, for example, in lviv, more than 500 million have been allocated to help the military, their requests for all the things that are connected with the war, therefore well, i think that this is catastrophic, we can't even

talk about it, but we also hear about curtailment decentralization, when we talk about the restoration of ukraine, there are often messages that, in general, there are two approaches to the restoration of destroyed cities, and the first one says, let 's do it very quickly, there are projects, we will quickly rebuild them now, we will not to ask the content and the main thing is speed, yes, and it also to some extent contributes to overall decentralization, hear the voice of agromat, what exactly would they like to see there, that's why decentralization reforms gave a great impetus to the development of communities, a great impetus to filling budgets, of course, funds are always not enough, but today, cities fulfill their function , both in terms of local self-preservation and to the extent that they are able to help the military

. well, because there is either constant shelling and business goes from there, people go, taxpayers go accordingly, these budgets are not filled, but in lviv , the budget is cut from relict businesses and private individuals , and how much is the budget of the city council. we cannot see statistics from relict businesses. and moreover, during the past year, it was possible to finance despite the fact that

there were large volumes of work, which were different within the limits of ten percent, perhaps, so to say well , first of all, we connect, well, 65 of the filling budget this is the personal income tax department, taxes on the income of individuals in lviv are also registered, and there are also several brigades of military personnel who receive salaries, large salaries, and they also pay additional large contributions to the development of the city to the city budget. these factors , of course, affect the city's income, but the budget was fulfilled last year and for this year, quite a lot of development funds were laid. you deal with the topic of reconstruction. how do you see the topic of reconstruction in general, this philosophy throughout the country? how should it be built and

look like? quite obvious and clear and a good example took place. last week, the lviv city council signed a declaration from the mariupol city council on the creation of a platform for the reconstruction of mariupol, mariupol. the essence of this declaration is the creation of a platform to which representatives of other cities , in particular, western europe, should join at the time of signing this declaration the city of gdańsk joined, and they quite correctly, as far as i am concerned, have their opinions of the odno-riupol city council. they are working, they have a strategy, they want to understand for whom they will rebuild this city, what competitive advantages can they offer to people like you? but compared to the cities where they live today, it is even more important to understand very well

that the competition between cities in our cities for our people is now not only internal ukrainian , but with foreign cities, foreign education, foreign medicine foreign infrastructure and when we approach the reconstruction to the reconstruction of cities we must clearly understand and have such a people-centric approach to involve a maximum of public organizations local architects local urban planners local business that all together should think about what competitive advantages we can use to encourage people to return, this approach is close to me and i think that in this case it will work because if we talk about other approaches that say this is the speed, let's take the standard the project let's build it already let's not ask anyone for a place, the main thing

is to restore the existing or former walls there but but but i am convinced that it will not work only by a joint conversation finding advantages, common opinions about how to compete, what is the city's strategy, at the expense of which it has to live in the future , what is it, what is the expense of which business, or often those cities that are destroyed now and the production is destroyed there and it is not always possible to restore those productions and it is not always well in principle, the possibility is the same. that is why it is such a complete rethinking, and not a reconstruction, to put in place those chairs that were here, this principle will definitely work, as it will not work for me, mr. nazariy. well, returning to mariupol, there is already and the russians, they also have their own vision for the reconstruction of mariupol, and they have a person responsible for it there, timur ivanov, the deputy minister of defense

, the sheygu, and the sheygu, they have been working there for a long time, even when he was the governor of the moscow region, he was responsible for building construction , this is the main money launderer for the shug for the ministry of defense and for the entire military leadership of russia i mean this timulvanov on well at inflated prices on kickbacks something else is happening there now they too i just saw how it is ivanov walking around mariupol and saying there will be a swimming pool here and there will be a sports hall. and here there will be a new residential complex and some work is being done there, that is, they are demolishing the old and there will be something new. what will we do with everything that will already be built - built before the deoccupation of mariupol? are you in this platform, the rebuilding of mariupol, please take this element into account, well, i don’t think that anyone there has a comprehensive approach and understanding of what mariupol needs and that it is necessary to rebuild those point things that

they at least show so the camera that they they rebuilt something, some houses seem to be walking along some road, well, this has nothing to do with reconstruction, this has nothing to do with the idea of ​​a development strategy, those buildings, if indeed some will be built, well, they can be adapted later in the future to eh already eh hm this plan that will be placed in the city but well, pay attention to this now. well, i think that it is not worth it and it is not worth even following it, because where is the truth and where is the lie? well, you understand that it is all covered with cancer. therefore, we need to think already today how mariupol city will be rebuilt the mayor of mariupol said that he relies on the words of zaluzhny, who has set the task of liberating this city this year, and the city council wants to come to the city with a ready plan and an understanding of how they will move further

there and back in relation to lviv as a construction for the western ukrainian capital, well, pace and volume changed during the year of the great invasion changed today, according to my calculations, the market is within 30% of the pre-war level during the past year all developers of 90 95 percent completed already started their projects before the great invasion everyone understood that it is necessary to fulfill obligations to investors to depositors and in fact many such projects have been completed and i am not mistaken, the construction of five new complexes in lviv was announced, two or three of them nevertheless began to be implemented, but all

the others - this is actually it was a continuation of what had already been started, although the market is quite er livelier now than it was er, it can be seen that people are adapting to military operations, because if in the spring there was a big missile attack, some kind of excavation, something else, the market was simply dying there on instead of time in the summer, this time was reduced to two weeks, in the fall it was reduced to 3-4 days, 3-4 days and vitaliy, people understand that you need to live further away to work, and the revitalization is happening because panza and briefly about the prices per square, then tell me about the price change, the price change, in fact, the cost increased in hryvnias and dollars, it remained mostly at the same level it was before. although it is profitable now, many

developers need funds to complete projects, those who have the ability to pay can catch the price on very attractive terms, but at this period, we are garbage we see that the price of the perfect will rise upwards because building materials are increasing, it is necessary to mix the wages of employees and so on, that is, the price will go up at what stage, even at the stage of a safer fact, at the stage of the reduction of vacant apartments that are already built today, but on this at this moment these will not grow somewhere. thank you nazariv. thank you for participating in our broadcast. nazarii berbeka , public figure, member of the lviv city council, was our guest. it's nine o'clock 46 on the clock oleksandr salizhenko joins

the parliamentary analyst of the honest movement oleksandr , we congratulate you good day well, let's talk about the news just from honestly, the head of the executive committee of the banned party of the opzzh and curtains in the case of terrorist financing serhii lyovochkin appeared on the anniversary of russia's full-scale invasion of ukraine in the verkhovna rada and even voted for you there to deprive your fellow party members of their mandates, let's remind you that voloshyna korolevska and malt, the husband of the royal it is known simply from the video of the movement. honestly, everything has been recorded. are there any details of this vote? we have recorded the video of the meetings that arrived. that millions of people, yes, he is the beginning of the victim's cake. there is a little bit of a microphone. we can't hear you well

. please, was there a message about what pandovych, the list is enough from and warm from ukraine and during the whole year he, uh, well, before i watched for him to appear automatically , although the people of the board assure that he was a oh a on the video of the meeting on the 24th, we saw it moreover, according to the results of the vote on the website of the verkhovna rada, he voted for the fact that earlier we analyzed the voting during the year and he was mostly absent during all meetings, and at this meeting he was also present when the parliament was considering the deprivation of the mandates of his ex- ha oleg and this is natalya of royal malt and oleg voloshin, he voted in the second er-er it was at the beginning of the meeting a-a after that he was absent again most likely he

left the meeting hall that's why we actually turned to such a rare bird, you can say so during this meeting, and how we remember lyovochkini as a participant in the investigation of the journalistic battalion of monaco, and all this time he lived as a male with his family on the electronic coast, but here he was in the parliament and there are already some consequences, well, have the law enforcement agencies dealt with it, or not, have you contacted the prosecutor 's office? well, at least i know, guys, that the law enforcement agencies have dealt with it, and well , in general, any additional information or additional information about lonely people at home only that he was in general and a voice. please tell us in general

what is happening in the upszh faction. well, what are these gestures of goodwill ? well, probably not. from a good life, deputies make mandates. they have already lost interest in parliamentary work, or do they do it under pressure, maybe they there they are threatening with some kind of criminal cases if they don't do it and why does someone put in mandates and someone doesn't, there is that zherevochki, the same shufrych, whom we often mention, not just a deputy, the head of the parliamentary committee, there are really three of them all you see in the committee is a trident, but all the same, he has an office, he has a secretary , he has two drivers, two cars are handed over to the committee, that is, everything is fine, he does not have a mandate, and there is some unfortunate queen's rich woman with a malt husband and oleg voloshy made up, what does it depend on the behavior of different members of the same faction, please yes, you are absolutely right, during the 17th

round, they stood up prematurely and lost the fantastic ones . so, most of them on their own initiative , that is, wrote a statement and became in the last case that some of them were deprived due to the loss of citizenship, for example, and most likely we assume that this is the same kind of goodwill - it's just that the deputies are taking a step ahead in order to avoid responsibility in europe or in russia or in the east, for example, there was information about the royal family that they are in dubai, and that is why such a trend is connected with the fact that we assume that the deputies are trying to avoid responsibility

to return to ukraine and it is easier for them to draw up a mandate er, his er, he will continue to be with him until the end of the term and er, deal with law enforcement agencies well, of course, some of the er part of the deputies were deprived of their powers due to the loss of citizenship. that's one out of 17 of them, this is oleksiy kovalev. well, he prematurely terminated his mandate due to the fact of his death, as we remember after his murder in the kherson region. and now , as of today, the parliament has the lowest number of deputies on record - 405. well , in general, most of all, of course, premature the representatives of the banned party of the obszh party lost data, although there are three deputies from the servant of the people and several non-factional deputies, well, there is an initiative to collect signatures to revoke

the mandates of all deputies from the obszh party, oleg dunda is doing this. it could be real, it seems that 50 signatures have been collected only at the current moment what do you know at the moment much more have already been collected over 150 but how many have been collected over 150 150 and there we are talking not only about the deprivation of the mandates of the deputies of the verkhovna rada, there we are also talking about the deputies of the local level if there are legal restrictions with the deputies of the verkhovna rada really during martial law , so because there is usually a list of early deprivation of powers to be considered hands honestly requires although if there is a legal restriction to correct their mandates although to remove them from leadership positions in

committees as you mentioned, for example, nestor shufrych and many others more than e-e 10 deputies almost 20 deputies videopsj they have the position of the committee, for example, the first deputy for or the secretary of the committee , moreover, they report on the activities of the committee during the past year, uh, how was the electric meat grinder? at that time, he was the deputy head of the election committees, and also, yes, we demand from the leadership of the parliament that at this time they began to remove these deputies from the leadership positions of the legislative there are no such restrictions. the verkhovna rada should simply vote on one resolution that will provide for exactly this. and who is blocking

it? you write what the hell master fedyuk is saying on your website. the information movement honestly declares that they are blocking the initiative just against the russian deputies. this is a deliberate blocking. is it just that? thank you. yes, the actual leadership in the parliament and david of the archangel majority, they constantly assure that there are regulations, there are some legal restrictions that they cannot carry because in the agenda is the question of whether to issue a resolution or, well, that is, they constantly appeal to legislative restrictions, although in our opinion this is not quite the case. of course , there is a lack of political will. in recent days, when there is a political will, it is resolved quite quickly, but in this case, of course, when these remnants of the communist party are present in

the next hall, they constantly vote in their overwhelming majority, which was not the case before the beginning of a full-scale invasion, then of course the parliament obviously is counting on which bands for their support at a critical moment. and here is what i want you to comment on the material honestly and investigate which deputies, or rather deputies from which political forces, are now protecting us at the front, so with weapons and who took up weapons. the most important thing is freedom, then the voice and the proposal. the eu is the servant of the people with a blow somewhere on the same level and the least number of deputies from the homeland. i understand that these are the deputies of local councils who went to the front , so what are some conclusions like that will be correlated with people's likes and support

the people of these political forces, or will we continue to tolerate the limousine on which he came from monaco to the verkhovna rada, uh, well, this is a study done by my colleagues, and it came out recently, it concerns the deputies of the place of control . well, after this article came out, representatives of some parties wrote to us that they actually had more of their deputies fighting. but we took into account the percentage composition because, of course , the servants of the people, for example , have the most deputies in terms of number, but if count the number the number of deputies, the percentage of which of them are fighting, this percentage is the largest in the freedom party, that is, the party's vote, although , for example, the party's vote is quite few

deputies, and the party did not provide clear data . so that they are not from personal parking on personal security issues wanted to reveal the number of city councils, but what is worth saying that in addition to this research, what we see , for example, the permanent inclusion of deputies from the svoboda party, it is the most difficult there, some of the most difficult directions are now with bakhmut soledar and e the party suffers a lot of losses. well, of course, its losses among the deputies of other parties, eh, but in eh, we know that svoboda, for example, has its own units that will be purchased many years ago, since the 14th year, and they are constantly in our field, well, and of course, as a parliamentary analyst, i have to say that people's deputies also

take part in fighting in their hands. well, for example, i can recognize roman kostenko from the street, so it seems to me that this is one of the people's deputies who, bravo, was in the russian special forces. if we talk about the parliament in that way, too the parliament has two manifestations of ukraine, mykhailo zabros from european solidarity, igor gerasimenko, these are paratroopers, but at the same time, the painful topic is again yuriy boyko, the third people's deputy with the title of hero of ukraine , who is so embedded in industrialism, but we also demand that this question be finally resolved because of the fact that over the last year, many military personnel have received this title posthumously, it was received by relatives and cannot be a combatant for the state, military personnel who receive

a state rank, have it as a fighter. and what rank does he have, hryvnias, mountains of ukraine thank you very much, oleksandr, this is an important topic. i think that now all these award titles, we need to radically revise the very approach to all this in connection with the latest scandals , too. thank you, a representative was with us , he will ask. thank you. of independent express journalism on our youtube channel or become a sponsor on patreon now we will be shown all qr-codes and routes how to do it you will get access to exclusive content of recordings in exclusive only closed to others the opportunity to put questions to our guests, the opportunity to ask questions to our presenters and establish direct contact with the espresso team, please join us, we will be very grateful to you. perhaps we will ask a question to our news presenter