[000:00:00;00] an independent investigation, which is important and responsible european politicians are calling for this, we will talk about it with maksym palamarchuk, head of the center for foreign policy studies of the national institute of strategic studies and the author of the book naval copper and its limits, we congratulate you as much as possible glory to ukraine so we see you but we do not hear you p maxim can you try again good day can you hear me super super radio welcome you live on the espresso tv channel so well, let's start with what your there was an opinion, so to speak, with nord stream 1 and nord stream 2. russia too actively began to disperse, so to speak, the ukrainian version in quotation marks. we understand that they are ready to dump anything on us . it is unlikely that anyone will believe them. and they were preparing for their

last information launch. first, they involved an american journalist, a laureate of the police police prize, so, and now , so, so, so, so, so, so and so, the tipper went, well, the key task of the russian federation is strategic the termination or at least the weakening of western support for ukraine, it is clear that the ratio of the potentials of states without such western support for significantly complex ukrainian sports is not discredited for the sake of it. journalists to the point of sensationalism , but it seems that this is exactly the kind of false trail that was set up to discredit ukraine , first of all i want to note that these are all stories

about some private oligarch of divers yachts, they fit well in the movement of espionage fighters, but in fact, this sabotage took place in a rather deep-sea area, it is more than 80,100 m deep, you cannot dive there with a scuba diving star and dropped, er, dropping some kind of bomb, it requires very complex equipment, this object needs more than that what is the gas pipeline, as superficially noted by the ukrainian energy expert mykhailo gonchar, it is quite well protected technologically. that is, it is not some kind of language . he also says that there is a small pipe at the bottom of mine that can be easily damaged there, first of all, and the oldest ones from the pipes are quite powerful there and uh, they are covered with certain technological things from above, that is, uh, the story is about some team in the style of fighters who jump from a yacht there and detonate, make four explosions on the lawn

. well, it seems to me that this is precisely designed for lovers of sensationalism. and why they right now they are so animated with that well, because the explosions at nordstream happened a long time ago, but now they have begun to force the information space , so to speak. operation needs preparation, we see that in one day the american above american, german, british source came out in order to achieve such synchronicity and not just let some bangs from the sumy site , it is necessary to work significantly p. maxim, well , now it seems that the versions are different and they are thrown from a sick head to healthy

as they say, accusations against ukraine or its citizens connected or not connected with the government is a story of sorts defense minister oleksiy reznikov denies the involvement of ukrainian structures in blowing up gas pipelines they say that it would be a great it would be a great compliment to our special operations forces , the president's office declares that ukraine had no motive to sabotage the northern streams, instead, the obvious motive for undermining was in russia, and let's try to outline in general what russia gained from undermining the northern streams except that this is a favorable background for the manipulations that are currently taking place. well, in principle, speaking about the motive of ukraine , i want to emphasize once again that ukraine really had no motives to undermine these flows, he says ostensibly that this guarantees the protection of our energy system, that it remains

the only source of russian gas supply to europe , but since the date is even that, in fact, thanks to the impact on the streams , gas prices were sharply raised, which negatively affected the supply of our computer countries because uh, by and large, the result of this sabotage was the spread of panic, there was a spread of growth, according to uh, negative sentiments in europe. on the one hand, it was aimed at europe, this is pressure on europe to demonstrate its potential, because if it can blow it up , it will kill them. it can obviously attack some other infrastructure objects of the groups.

the situation is indicative that e gasogenic letters were entered completely, one branch remained, that is , theoretically, there could be such a proposal of a certain european main surrender i only gas, we will supply you, of course, according to the established on emotional well, and i think that in this operation had its own internal dimension. i think that a lot of people in the gas industry, who have supplied gas to europe all their lives, were by no means delighted with putin's policy because of the fact that the main gas consumer, on which they received huge money all my life and in order to show that there is no way back, we are all in the same boat, this is a certain analogue. i would say the burning of ships, er, ships after someone landed on the shore, yes, yes, of course

, it is interesting. thank you, maksym maksym palamarchuk head of the center for foreign policy studies of the national institute of strategic studies, author of the book naval power and its limits yes well, we will continue to monitor this extremely important story because, well, they exploded, they blew up , more precisely, two strategic lawns that russia invested billions of bucks in, there were huge negotiation negotiations and so on and then on some happy night, so to speak, it happened that you put them out of order. of course , now russia is trying to shift all the responsibility to someone, well, to us, that is, to everything that happens badly in the world they are trying, so to speak, to stick our responsibility, this is delusional, of course, but the key story here is, so to speak, why right now

? maybe they need to be extremely careful with that . yes, if they try to apply a similar practice, it can obviously work in some countries in the world, that is, in the family of ukraine, they they will never convince the united states and even in europe, no, but in some distant countries, you know, in bangladesh, well, ukraine, where they are trying to look for weapons or something. or i don’t know, we don’t know. yes, we understand , well, a lot depends on this in order to evaluate the policy of beijing regarding the russian invasion, and how seriously it is possible to take, for example, the official policy to a beijinger from this review, this is possible. russia is increasingly beginning to articulate , in my opinion, the terrorist nature of such activities of our country

for self-defense in incidents that are connected to locations far outside the borders of our country , even today's night missile attack, they are actually at the official level equated to an act of retaliation for what happened in the bryansk region and a few days ago, when the russian volunteer corps carried out certain actions, their purpose was unclear to me personally until the end, only about the consequence for a few thousand actually russian army men are now concentrating their attention on the nabryan region and the kursk region, and are building some fortifications there instead of being sent. well , for example, to one of the hot spots on our map... rhetors vozmezdie for what happened

in bryansk, this is all that we experienced that night, but we emphasize again that the air defense of our country worked at a high level of hitting, which is explained by the fact that russia used rockets and projectiles with which we still can't shoot down six daggers - it's quite a lot, in fact, and besides, it was nighttime before similar large-scale missile attacks. this is a rhetorical story, but here we simply need to consider, well, the whole premise, that is, how they will actually sell it or use it for their dirty purposes on the domestic russian market and on the foreign market , in particular, in the same countries. well, i don’t know which

make up almost half of humanity. well, speaking democratically, the graphic indicator is yes, that is, china, india. well, plus, there are many countries in asia that really poorly understand what is happening in ukraine. so, just like we in ukraine, we very poorly understand what is happening in those or other asian countries. that is, thank god, we can even know the name of the capital, but no more than bangladesh. what do we know about bangladesh and the current political events in bangladesh? it's normal , it's just a normal phenomenon for countries that think well, they use their own internal categories in order to evaluate their own problems. so, you can't escape from that here, the court case episode with tetyana shustrova, watch this week's program judicial control with tetyana shustrova, the competition for the highest qualification commission of judges, how the candidate's family bought real estate in the capital , we managed the joint budget in our family

my husband and atypical punishment why the odessa judge orders fraudsters to read frank and the frying pan we give them a chance to change their thinking and attitude i congratulate those around me. you are watching judicial control . i am tetyana shustrova. in ukraine, a competition is underway for one of the most important bodies of the judicial system, the high qualification commission of judges. she is responsible for the formation of the entire judicial corps . from who will be part of the central committee, will the judicial system remain or will it change ? we continue to introduce you to candidates

for high positions and today we will talk about the judge in whose declarations the debit and credit do not match at all, but first before the news, the supreme council of justice suspended the judge of the oleksandriv district court , pavlo ivchenko, who is accused of committing a corruption crime, the judge is accused of allegedly promising money to help a man who was to be sentenced for p the management of the official was detained while receiving a bribe of one thousand dollars in september of last year, he was informed of the suspicion, and within a week he was removed from the position of the head of the court, however, only now at the request of the specialized anti-corruption prosecutor's office, the supreme council of justice temporarily suspended judge ivchenko from conducting judicial proceedings, the suspension will continue until the court verdict becomes final or the criminal proceedings against the judge of the dobropil city district court of the donetsk region are closed. olena

zdrotytsa made a decision in the case of her old friend and received an administrative protocol from the national agency for the prevention of corruption the case is against a friend of the judge, a former people's deputy and mayor of dobropill andriy aksyonov of the donetsk region referred to the possible waste of budget funds, most likely a fictitious hospital mayor who, according to the documents, was allegedly ill, but was absent from the workplace and spent time in the territory of the occupied crimea. after confirming that the grounds for their issuance of a share certificate were given by the judge, the administrative protocol was completed by the competition

commission, which ends the stage of conducting interviews with candidates for the higher qualification commission of judges will soon present to the high council of justice 32 candidates who, in the opinion of experts, are worthy to hold a position in the supreme council of justice, take care of 16 of them until the competition is over. a candidate for the higher kovaliv commission of judges . she has a fortune that is difficult to explain with official incomes, and she bullies the abolition of the punishment of officials for illegal enrichment , however, she considers herself virtuous enough to

to take a high position in vikkax but we have doubts during my work , i always conscientiously fulfill my duties the ukrainian judge has no real estate of her own, all her husband yuriy, in 2009, yuriy omelyan became the owner of an apartment in kyiv with an area of ​​65 square meters and a cost of $98,000. for the previous 5 years, judge inna omelyan worked in the apparatus of the supreme court of ukraine her husband's income was insignificant, so how did he manage to purchase real estate in the capital in the declaration for 2016 and omelyan pointed out that her husband invested 554,000 hryvnias in an apartment in kyiv during the construction phase and the family managed to save half a million hryvnias and it would be nothing

if the total annual income of seven she did not make it three times less. the amount of savings and expenses for the apartment is only 325,000 uah, and if you take into account household expenses and maintenance of three daughters , somehow it is not included at all in the declaration for 2017, melyan declared new husband's investment in an apartment in kyiv in the amount of 580 one thousand hryvnias, the legality of the origin of the funds for the purchase of real estate raises doubts because the amount exceeds the total income of the family, when the competition commission asked ineomelyan about this for the first time, she answered that she did not know the origin of the funds because the husband refused to explain it and until the interview i had already prepared, i had analyzed our family

income for many, many years, that is , there is no problem with that. then i said that it was my husband, since i had no data about him income over the years to date, there are no problems. i analyzed the information that is in the competition commission, the arguments that were given by the tax authorities and i can explain that it is difficult to adequately evaluate these explanations, because even on omelyan i just started adding up sums and a one-room apartment with an area of ​​36.6 m². on investment it cost $21,000,700. the official family income for the photo from 2009 to 2015 of our family was set at 80.89 e-e, 89 e-e dollars, the value of property rights for the same

apartment was set at 21,700, so even these our family's income from 2009 to 2015 fully covered the costs of the specified housing, of course, the total income for six years covers the cost of one apartment, especially if you do n't eat, don't spend on living and don't have a family, and if you forget about another one purchased in 2009 real estate in the capital for $98,000, but inna omelyan does not dispute that the sums and figures do not really make up the joint budget for us in the family . my husband, since he is a person with an economic

education, is a financier. iniomelyan was submitted by judge viktor kryvenko of the constitutional court of ukraine for the competition to the higher qualifications commission of judges. he is a figure in the so-called vovka tapes of the head of the liquidated district administrative court of kyiv. in particular, vovka, when he flaunted his influence on the decision of the constitutional court of ukraine to cancel the punishment of officials for illegal enrichment, indicated that he communicated on this very issue with krivenko, who allegedly voted for this decision at the request of vovka , also viktor kryvenko, in addition to supporting the cancellation of the responsibility for illegal enrichment voted for the abolition of criminal liability for lying in declarations, i may have neglected the laws myself, in particular, the national agency for the prevention of corruption established that viktor kryvenko did not indicate in the declaration that he owns a plot of land in the temporarily

occupied crimea worth more than uah 4 million , automaidan experts believe that fact that omelyan turned to viktor kryvenko for a recommendation indicates that she does not consider the above facts to be shameful and explained it to omelyan as this person knew me personal and i knew him personally, then from 2013 to 2017 i worked under his leadership in the judicial chamber of administrative cases in the supreme court of ukraine. they were known to me, but according to the constitution of ukraine, they are mandatory to be implemented

throughout the territory of ukraine. this person made these decisions both personally and collegially, and to give an assessment of the decisions of the constitutional court in my opinion, it would be unethical on my part regarding information about uh, there are some actions of his others, i was completely ignorant during the interview to the higher qualification commission and repeatedly complained about omelyan 's criticism of the judicial system by society and offered a recipe as finally to get rid of her, first of all, it is necessary to cultivate in society respect for the law and for the court. when this respect is cultivated in society, then

there will be much less criticism. the commission of judges does not propose to anya to work more on eradicating corruption. anya on the professional training of judges, which is directly part of the duties of the vkks, no , in the candidate's opinion, it is necessary to educate society itself so that there will be less complaints, mrs. inno a can immediately introduce criminal liability for criticizing judges so that no one will be swayed we do not know the conclusions of the competition commission regarding inna omelyan , however, we hope that the biography of the judge and the probable sources of the fortune of the candidate for the higher qualification commission of judges were careful research and now we want to tell you about an atypical servant of themis read the works of frank and skovoroda twain and shevchenko such punishments are given to thieves and fraudsters by the malinovsky district court

of odesa oleksandr garsky from the sentence of a 35-year -old man from odessa who beat a stranger the court considers it necessary to recommend the accused to read the novel by the american writer eleanor porter pollyanna, which, although it is children's , is so spiritually large in content that it is able to teach all adults to be happy about little things to be kinder and happier regardless of difficult life circumstances in 2021 oleksandr garsky sentenced two boys who robbed cars in the parking lot to probation and reading works that, according to the judge, are designed to form good -hearted and non-malicious feelings in a child the adventures of tom sawyer and the adventures of huckleberry finn by mark twain b jack london and taras shevchenko's poems to another man for fraud, the judge ordered him to watch the movie of the 40s this is my

beautiful life and read the works of frank and skovoroda oleksandr galskyi for more than 17 years considers and announces verdicts exclusively in criminal cases why why does he punish criminals in the form of reading literary classics our journalist olena kononenko managed to arrange an interview with the judge so just look now you have become famous in ukraine for what you have done unusual for the decisions of our country , the children borrowed practice and the decisions were for the first time. in the united kingdom, the judge assigned the books, so it seemed to me that before our state and in our justice, the tests would have a certain meaning under certain circumstances under certain conditions and in relation to certain persons, it is possible to apply a milder punishment

and you know how mild it is, how merciful it is so that they understand that the state has heard them and that we will give them a chance to change their thinking and attitude towards others do you even remember your first such sentence to two persons who seemed to me to be adults yes, but according to their development i already said that they seemed to me to be such juvenile boys which well, poorly developed people poorly understand relationships between people yes and the most important thing is relationships and property rights and in a certain difficult hour, they decided in this way, violating these social relations, er, as if it was good for themselves to steal certain things there, but the very nature

of the crime was so rather stupid, their actions were so er, nefarious, and all this showed that they some, well, they did it by mistake more than they are ordinary criminals and what are you appointed appointed appointed as a famous mark twain to read yes tom sawyer tom sawyer and kelvin yes the white canine of jack london also seems to be a poem by taras hryhorovych shevchenko and how else you pick up books, well, you understand everything spontaneously, but very often they ask what decision you will make there, and it is impossible to say, but i cannot say that until i listen to the person, until i know all the circumstances . by the way, i even applied to the pedagogical university here in odessa to the head of the department, and she also helped me compile

a certain list of ukrainian literature that could be used in these cases. in the case of conditional releases, she will try to change, that is, we should try to change their thinking, here in practice there was a case when instead of a book you added watching a movie that was done and that is why the movie itself was about fraud and the person, uh, seemed to me to be a very educated person had no no well there are two two things of higher education when i started to ask about literature to find out about his features of life so he said that he reads how he decided to help him see in a certain way well some

other literature for him to choose well and within the literature, this film also appointed an american director based on the novel, he would be the director of this film, because it is not necessary to submit ours when you have a difficult life, do you remember the total number of such decisions of yours somewhere, i think there were already more than ten agreements where the girl stole the girl stole the mobile phone there from the latest iphones you appointed her there too er random book and what book yes oscar and the pink lady how much is your decisions about the form then article 75 76 76-a provides

an opportunity there part three paragraph six seems to provide an almost unlimited opportunity for the court to oblige a person to perform certain actions, reading books - this seems to me to be the best pastime, the best. therefore , it is from the point of view of form and from the point of view of morality and content - these are absolutely legal decisions for today i had all this with the judicial control program and i am tatyana shustrova, if you have information about unscrupulous judges and facts of corruption in the judicial system, let me know on facebook or to the e-mail address whose address you now see on the screen. all the best we will meet in exactly a week in