[000:00:00;00] society that we can't, life extension has developed to 85 years and the pension is still at 60, so we have to feed pensioners for 25 years after the pension, well , no economy can withstand that. please explain to us, mr. maxim rich, that the french have a slightly different attitude towards work and life, let's say, than the same british or germans , they are not so focused on work. they like to rest. live beautifully. they like to go to restaurants. they respect their free time and they think that 62 years is absolutely enough to earn a decent pension and start living free from responsibilities

at work and start traveling as they have all their lives. trade unions, which are the main opponents of this reform, they hired, let's say, expert economists and those who understand this field, and they now they are proving that experts from their side show that the pension deficit is not so terrible in france and that there is no need to raise the retirement age now, that is, they also master the numbers, they master the opinions of other experts who are not government experts let's say ok, interesting, interesting, one more point about trade unions, there is such a theory, you can refute it or confirm that one of the problems is in the agreements between the government and the trade unions that in france there are a very large number of autonomous trade unions, even this is a joke in the government circles

of paris, they say that no, you can't negotiate because in front of you there will be only one minister of labor, well, conditional yes, or the prime minister or the president, and there will be 300 people sitting across from you, you cannot negotiate with three hundred people, and it's me, 300 trade unions, it's just difficult, he has only one interest other interests, third interests, 15-20 three hundred, is it true that the branching and the large number of trade unions simply make negotiations difficult? yes, it is true, and trade unions are cross-industry, that is, which unite employees of different industries, there are trade unions that specifically exist for certain industries, but in our case, if we take this pension reform , the trade unions united surprisingly easily, there are no misunderstandings among the trade unions

, mostly well, we take powerful and large trade unions, of which there are only 4-5 in france, yes let's say that all four conglomerates of trade unions have united and are now acting as a united front against the government reform, and in this plan the government will be able and easier to negotiate with the trade unions, but on the other hand , it will be more difficult because if there are contradictions, you can play on them. you can divide, you can negotiate with individual trade unions and to show that everything is wrong and that this reform is supported , for example, by two large trade unions, and not against this reform, all trade unions speak out at once, therefore, for the government, this is in principle complicates the situation, they cannot divide the trade unions now, and we can see this with the example of those strikes and sabotage and road blockades , for example, there are incinerators and

it works, that is, the government is facing serious problems now, it surprises me because, after all, in france there has always been capitalism at least during soviet times, i well remember that france was on the sidelines. well, if someone was given an incentive trip to a capitalist country , they would most likely give it to france, germany , england, or america, even more so that is, she was always from france, but we talked about auchan just the last time that auchan behaved badly in russia and there was some kind of investigation. and now it turns out that auchan is opening a new chain of stores in russia, this is just what it means the investigation investigation says that you know you make money on blood and you say and i say then if they say that to me if i am chief ashanu

i say and cover it so that you can make so much money on blood so i will open another network i will be even more on to earn blood to what extent is there a discussion in france about this auchan and about the behavior of french companies in russia? no, unfortunately, not at the level at which we ukrainians would like . we would like this discussion to exist. french, the french management of auchan said that it was not involved in this , they said that they conducted an internal investigation, these facts were not confirmed, although the investigation clearly showed that at least the french top management, which is present in of russia, who in principle should observe and supervise the russian actions of russian managers, he was present in the electronic correspondence and at least he knew about the fact that

such supplies of products and other things to the front line for russian soldiers were taking place, but here in france, in principle, after this news discussed and the head of the french office said that he has nothing to do with it, in principle, that's it, and that's it, as for the fact that information has now appeared that auchan is opening a new chain of stores in russia, then this the news did not cause any special interest at all. i found this news on the only regional news site on television, it was not discussed at all, and in principle, this news goes with a link to reuters, to the reuters agency, which published just this news. that is, it is not even french media , they are not did not have this information. and what about this news from the reuters agency ? yes, this is the initiative of the russian auchan, so to speak

, that is, the french auchan again denies this news. that is, it is not their initiative, as they say, and they claim that in general now the russians are as if a branch of the oshan, it is independent and it seems that the french do not receive any profits from the russian branch at all. although we know from all sources that the turnover of the russians, namely the russian oshans, it is 10% of the total total turnover of the world, this is a lot, in fact, it is almost 4 billion euros and that is why, unfortunately, i can only say here that , in principle, this characterizes the owners of aushan and its top managers in general, and if you need examples of why, you also ask

the question, why does he put money above moral principles? well, then i can tell you name examples from the history of auchan that will basically show you why he puts money above principles in 1981, the first socialist president mitterrand introduced a wealth tax in france and this gerard mullier, who was the owner is the owner of the auchan group, he moved part of his family to belgium in order not to pay this tax , that is, you see, in principle , he always had money in front of him, not only now, and in principle, there are many scandals with the management manager of auchan in france, this was all published by the press, for example , in one supermarket, the cashier that she was fired because she was short of 85 cents, i.e. the buyer did not have 85 cents, she forgave him and

for that she was fired, the trade unions intervened and only because of the uproar she was reinstated at work, another case was when a pregnant cashier was not allowed to toilet during work and she miscarried. she went to the hospital and the management of the store told her to go to work the next day, and because she did not come out because she was in the hospital, she was charged a week's weekly salary and was not paid she also had a judicial investigation. that is, all these examples can be characterized by these examples of the attitude of auchan's managers in general to morals, let's say in general, well, mr. maksym. now i understand why this may be the reason, well, it's a little ironic, that the french are going out to protest

against the increase in the pension age, because if i was treated the way jarar milieu was in france, then i wouldn't want to be treated like that for another two years, if people are treated at work as you have described then i wouldn't want to go to such a job. thank god i have another job, but it's true, now i can understand that if there really are such cases in france, then i would be very careful about continuing my work, well , this does not mean that these cases are by all by all enterprises in france, these are such blatant cases that were and were written about by the press, of course, at normal jobs at normal enterprises, and in general, the attitude of the french management is quite lenient towards employees because all understand that there are powerful trade unions, that is, the protection of workers in france always takes place through

the trade unions, they are very powerful and they go to court immediately and that is why, in principle, i apart from these cases with auchan, i did not specifically look at each enterprise, but i can say that these are rare cases, yes that is, this is not the reason why the french leave because they are beaten at work every day. no, they just want to retire before the age of 64. thank you very much maksym sokolov, the french journalistic people of political science. i am horrified to think how when i would retire i would simply be french, english , i would not retire at all i really love what i do thank you mr. maksym and i go to the answers to the questions means about the question about my envy to vitaly portnikov on the occasion of his laureate i have already expressed myself and the only thing i didn't finish then is because i have this moment of misunderstanding

of the relationship between journalists and the state. i don't know if ukraine wants not only journalists, but let's say artists to a certain extent. yes, i don't do i know if the singer wants to be a people's artist or a meritorious artist, or can he imagine that john lane is a meritorious artist, i don't know england or liverpool or elvis presley, a people's artist of the united states of america, i don't know . it seems to me that this is not to pay money, it was all invented in the soviet union in order to not to pay money and because elvis presley and his descendants live and live and live because it is fairly done so that for one song a person then receives royalties, i.e. compensation according to the performance of this song, all his life and his descendants can receive and in the soviet

union in front of you, we will give you the people's artist of the soviet union, you will have some kind of bronze medal, and you will have to pay some fees there, we will not be big, really big, the people 's people received more meetings than others in ukraine. is it necessary and so on and the like i don’t know i don’t have an answer to this question i’m not a critic but i don’t know if i would take it if it was handed to me i’ll definitely say that while i have such an idea that i don’t no i’ve already refused and i won't take it from a well-deserved award or from any awards . the only thing i have is temptation. i would take it if someone gave me the order of freedom . i just like the name, although this order is issued by the president, i'm not convinced that mr. zelensky will give such an order in september

, but just i like the name, i have tried to defend these various freedoms all my life and it would be nice for me, but on the other hand , someone from vasyu would come up to me and say mr. mykola, you said that you have nothing to do with the state and would be right, okay, putin has lost control, how do you assess the news that putin has lost control over the information field of the russian federation, what dangers and advantages does it bring for us, ms. olga, he has not lost control, this control is really weakened , i read this article, this is some foreign intelligence centers i read it. i thought about it even this morning a little bit tonight. i don't remember when i looked at it. it doesn't mean anything. you understand that there are cracks. they are small. we

pay attention to them because it hurts because in we are at war because we were attacked by the russians, so and so, the katsapas, but always before something big starts, such cracks come , but we all turn to adam, somewhere simonyan said something wrong, as she said the day before yesterday and a month ago. oh, skabeeva is saying something wrong president putin, the so-called president, said about the urals or the siberians , and if we did not give this and this such great importance that oh , he talked about separatism, or was there something else , or was there something, there was a fight between wagner and the general staff of the russian federation, that's all you know it's like in football, a stadium of 100,000 and there's an attack of the team that supports this one hundred thousand everyone, well, now. and a goal happens once in a while for 90 minutes, well, twice

, but they are like that. these cracks are piling up, piling up, how long they will be is unknown, it is indisputably clear that they will end in some kind of big, so to speak, with a tremor, but when it will happen is unknown. maybe tomorrow, maybe it has already happened . maybe we are running a program here and we don't know in moscow, there are already stabbings, something is happening there, we don't know, so keep in mind that these are not bad signs, these are signs of ill health, but it seems to me that the path to collapse is not close yet , borel claimed that

there are not many options for new sanctions for the russian federation, what do you think, are additional sanctions needed, or is it better direct efforts to ensure that the already introduced sanctions really work and there is no chance of them. well, there will always be chances to circumvent the sanctions , there will never be such a thing that this does not happen but it really always happens. you can't do anything you only have to do well, that's why there were slow sanctions because everyone understood that sanctions oda there is one wave there second third fifth tenth and next what and next comes the time of sanctions that are hitting europe or america itself will you want to introduce such sanctions for the sake of ukraine europe or america will not want iran to the truth of the russian federation. a large batch of artillery mortar shells, 40-mm grenades, anti-tank grenade launchers, not only this, as

the general publications write, or whether a joint measure is capable of, in what way, blocking at least this source of supplies partially or completely in which method there is no such method. they are also under the sanctions of ms. vita and they have been under sanctions for much longer than the russian federation as far back as the 79th year of 1900, that is, do the math yourself and the additional sanctions will not hit the tehran official in iran in persia, so i don't see anything. i see that these secondary sanctions, about which iborel said that there is nothing more to do. yes, these secondary sanctions can be tracked so that they do not violate the previous 10 waves. this is the only thing that can be done now, and they say that america is very, very, very, very actively engaged in this i do not know iran at all

because i don’t know if there is anything there that is not subject to sanctions, and secondly, they have a direct direct border , they can load it all to the caspian sea in the south , send it to the north there to astrakhan, and everything, and no one can influence it, that’s why keep in mind that in the last 10 days, information has again appeared about several downed racist planes and helicopters. why are the moscow pilots arrogant and flying into the affected area , confident that we have nothing to shoot them down? is this evidence of a new wave of the announced offensive? no i don't know why, for example, i am absolutely convinced that you have some kind of distorted information, ms. vita, because i'm not , i don't know any facts, it's really such a top, it 's 100% proven that they started flying where they shouldn't fly because they're really afraid of ukrainian

against the air force and the ukrainian air force, and that is why they do not fly where they can be hit, and they can be hit by a lot of people, but sometimes, well, first of all, no one forbids ukraine to test its missiles, there may have been a test of some kind rockets that are flying now further and maybe it is there somewhere somewhere they just saw that plane and decided to use it maybe something else i don't know i can't say anything khrestina polish tv channel tv n24 the investigation claims that in the 60s and 70s the krakow archix karol woitila, that is, the future pope paul ii knew about cases of pedophilia among the priests of his dioceses, and even more, poland, which considers him its own, stubbornly does not want to believe the facts, what do you think about this case, should we

question the actions of the canonized pope or still you need to know the truth regardless of your status, well, look, let me tell you what i think about this matter. society and the world community must be ready to receive this or that information. as i understand it, society is not yet ready, just as society a year ago was not ready to supply some kind of information weapons specific to ukraine, and just like now the whole community is not ready to hand over planes, i will give you one phrase. and i, a kolizhana , told me about a conversation with a german, she is in europe now. well, how many refugees and she simply says that he is russian-speaking, that is, he learned russian, he tells her well, when they argued that

the germans do not give tanks, the germans do not give tanks, it was there , i don’t know. in december, probably last year, and he tells her, do you understand that it cannot there is no way to get into a german's head when a german sees the following information in the news ukrainians are sitting in our german tank and shooting at russians aiming to defeat moscow after dozens of years of propaganda in 1945 , starting with what not we germans will never forgive

on excuse us for the invasion of the soviet union on what are they called sovetskaya russia invasion on soviet we are not we are to blame we are bad ai-ai-ai kaikie and it takes a moment when first the leadership first the people are some individuals then the leadership then more more people say give weapons for to fight against russia. how have you and your mother and your grandmother been told this for decades ? what do you think? from 33 to 45 years, keep hitler in power and we germans are looking for some small opposition, look for mine, but that one was against and this one was not in favor of that and was silent and this one did not shout let hitler and this one

also says something here no no everything is not yes, russia is not a fair and honest country that, together with the united nations, defeated terrible fascism. and this is a fascist country against which we must fight, what is going on in your head if you have been told this since childhood and your mother from childhood upwards and your grandmothers almost from childhood from youth when she is a young woman everything was not so easy to say, that's why it's the same in the catholic faith, well, how can you imagine in the 60s people won't believe, you understand, people won't believe today we can probably find a fair and honest prosecutor in ukraine or an honest judge even in russia if we do about we will show these feature films, people will not believe and you said such a thing cannot be

a lie, because such and such a moon is going around this echo, this is going around that there are no honest prosecutors in ukraine , there are no honest judges and so on and so on that's why you won't get anywhere like that. that's why a lot of time has passed now, gradually, very slowly, very gradually, and also because of feature films, when we see americans, hollywood began to make movies about the fact that there are pedophiles among canadians, a huge scandal because in the 50s and 60s there are children's homes where they were raped. these children are now beginning to apologize to the authorities and begin to try to somehow compensate or something, but these events are unknown which

year 65 ago it is a complicated story, sooner or later we will find out the further the saintly figure of john paul ii i am convinced that 20 years ago it was impossible he was still alive it seems to me that he was 20 years ago but after a year after two after five after 10 after his death it was not even possible to think about it now you already know that tvn 24 is already doing something some kind of investigation but such and such an echo of such a scandal so far there is none, but there will be, we will not get anywhere because of this. how do you feel about march 8? by the way , the question is very tangential to the past. what is this day for you

? was accepted what should we do with flowers for the girls here and there on february 23 ? but i can imagine if imagine mr. ivan that this discussion did not happen now, and in 1992 , a year after gaining independence , president kravchuk came out and said: let's cancel 95% of ukrainians are you a fool at all, and it is in such a language, in russian, how to cancel it, time has passed, this is about a discussion , russian troops attacked ukraine, everything became away from moscow, if russians say that we celebrate this holiday, that is why i automatically said

and if russians celebrate, we don’t celebrate for me personally the last years, the last 30 years or i don’t know how long i somehow didn’t pay attention to it and was always surprised when i went out and suddenly saw many women with flowers and then i don't mind mark what you want it's an individual problem or not a problem or everyone's holiday someone likes it someone doesn't like me i don't not mark me well i wouldn't say that i immediately that i will die here if if i see a girl with flowers he i see in our newsroom i see more flowers, maybe they are just the remnants of march 8, the yvroshe company offers russian women to emphasize russian beauty and smooth out non-russian anthropometry. well, i am not an expert in russian beauty at the yvroshe company in anthropometry to multiply pure russian beauty

and the best genes. i don't know, i can't, i'm not a geneticist i don't know what a russian is, well, i mean, i know, but somehow a small specialist in this field , perhaps there is a russian beauty for the french. i can even guess what kind of beauty this is, such a beauty with such an oriental accent. for europeans, russian beauty was when it was all mixed like that, and there were many such eastern accents, starting maybe even with the influx of mongol-tatars and these mixed ones, and then some such accents appear, quite interesting if you look closely at modern putin, he definitely has some, although some people who say that they just gave him injections and to improve him and smooth out these wrinkles, and that's why

he became like this a little bit it's beautiful, and i can't say it, maybe it's beautiful for the french, i don't know, i'm just looking at the deputy of the military bolgrad district in odesa region, a scandal got into the network, people got into the network, how he lights a fire at a party to russian songs , why is she everywhere, despite the war, still in the cultural field of the aggressor and i can also dance to the russian song of an alcoholic , maybe i wouldn’t dance to the song do they want russian wars, because the answer is clear. but if it’s an alcoholic, there are no questions about russians . it can and should be the opposite of this so-called culture to spread so that people understand what russian culture is, because if we do not know what russian culture is, then it is necessary to know your enemy well, and to