[000:00:00;00] lisov's scheme was discovered only by some paragraphs. and actually, i know for sure that an intelligent person who has read something somewhere can even remember a paragraph that she remembered there quite well and then even accidentally describe it almost word for word, and to me it counts as plagiarism but this does not mean that he really took it and wrote it down, so if this is a question of some paragraph or two, well, a small part, then it is not something that should prevent us from appointing a new, potentially good minister of education, the question here is not how 99% virtuous he is or 100% it's all normal if, of course, there will be half written off, then he said he would give up his dissertation and this is quite such a good decision, he reacted to it with a letter and it is similar to the act of the right minister of education, that's why the situation in the country is like this and this is the same for the forest immediately said that he will pay a lot of attention to issues of economic integrity, this is also important and he will work on it, and as for his

work, i am inclined to the fact that no major plagiarism will be detected there and it will not become an obstacle, it will be within the limits, you know, somewhere remembered maybe some question so that it does not prevent him from actually proclaiming to adhere to new values, new standards because what was ok there 20 years ago, but now it does not look ok, he is similar to a person with values, so i think he will fight for them, we will see if he will fight he is the reformer's question in the first place, is it still possible that it will not succeed , let's hope that it will succeed, let's hope for it oleksandr kondratyuk , the founder of the all-ukrainian educational company set stop, was with us. thank you very much. and now we are moving to wisconsin. as far as i understand, this is because of the reports, our next interlocutor is yuriy rashkin, a political and public figure. yuriy good day. good day. thank you for the invitation. thanks to ukraine. we wanted

to ask you . we didn't like desantis . we don't want that. we don't want that. we don't want that. russia . we have to take into account that he somehow won his first statements, but now we are worried. will the americans choose between er trump and desantis in these next elections and what will happen then to the ukrainian diaspora , i don’t know that she has traditionally supported the republicans for the most part, you know yes i hope that now they are watching what is happening in ukraine and they understand that and также how do you know? in some sense, uh, jewish voters used to talk, well, sometimes

they talk now. and how is this for israel and everyone ? ukraine is the main point for it should be the main point for their voters for a long time, at least those who once lived and were born in ukraine, let's say that's why it's very important how different political parties of all the states react precisely to the help of ukraine and when you see that the luhansk party is not can decide if she is for ukraine or for hype , support with words, you know how china supports russia with words, but not with weapons. with weapons, i think that we are not ready, so, eh, now we see that the two main candidates are actually the main candidate of the res of the giant party, donald trump, and the paratrooper is already lousy, the sun hasn't even entered, you are choosing a strong race, and he already has a problem

, and the problem is that the electorate of the republican party is now quite tuned in, well, about trapovsky's ego, as if isolationist views are controlling the republican party now, and what is happening with the landing, when he first comes out, he says that uh, i'm against that, as if we interfered in this territorial sport, after that he gets his hands on it. we say so and change his point of view. ответы but you don't agree, you're wrong, i misunderstood you, and it's good. and this shows that he, er , how much trump dominates the republican party. because if you want to get

trump voters, you have to say that we will all leave europe solving this own problem, there is nothing for us to do here, but if you fight for these voters , they already have trump, we are no longer needed , so we need to look for some other ways, and here we see a division between isolationists e- eh, and in general , the poor and the whitest themselves are elected by all the republican party who support trump and who control the process. now trump’s support is close to fifty percent, and audi is somewhere around 25 because, on the one hand, he accuses trump of the fact that he will immediately add popularity because he is somehow such a holy martyr against the attack of the state , with which you see so much flour, you see it was a flag when he fights with the state , because now apparently the state is fighting with him this confirms him that it is necessary to pay around trump, and on the other side of the distance, he is trying to gather more than

adequate republicans, and this means that he says that vladimir puzin is a war criminal and how to show himself relative a realist because the republican party is a realist, it’s just that they don’t have a controlling package of shares, so he’s trying to mean himself to you, but it’s difficult for him, so it’s not clear where it will go further to the part of the democratic party , according to each effect they investigate and from the plane around and the president and the support of ukraine, so we know that approximately 50% is obtained immediately for ukraine. well, then the republican party is divided in half, so what is obtained as a result of two party support of ukraine e-e p yuri trump actually said that these are these investigations. he was just hunting a witch hunt and compared it all to the horrors of stalin's russia

. what is so terrible about stalin's russian ? it hasn't changed, they continue to call it what i like, uh , oldism, the gulag a-a so they somehow use these words, but at the same time a-a they say, as it were, almost opposite things because they support wars putin and they say that at this time the federal government wants to arrange a second hulak against them, how would you forgive me, how would you get confused. ah, he paid a porn star and didn't take it into account. you know how when the mobsters took a famous man for paying taxes . now they will remove trump from the local manhattan prosecutor because he impaled a porn star

, but at the same time he didn't specify how he did it. advised election campaigns and everyone says that he will pay if he is silent so that she does not speak because she is elected, well, as if we need to know if the person i will be remembered for the fact that he took documents from the white house that we did not trust a-a or because he influenced and tried to influence on the people in georgia, so that the one who counts the votes will recognize him as the winner, and gradually all these snowballs, snowballs prove his days, and he has a kind of opening, it's like death from a thousand wounds, or different prosecutors attack and of course, it's just an unfortunate victim. and that's why he's being attacked. here, please, just gulak. gulak, i don't know what it is. well , it's terrible, terrible, and the popularity of such

commentators as, for example, carlson on fox news . viewer, is it normal in principle what is happening in general with freedom of speech in the united states now, if there are in fact any partisan votes, or maybe we are exaggerating well, that's it fox news wasn't born yesterday, they have developed their line for a very long time, they created practically their own electorate , and when, for example, in the speech, there were problems in seven people who would have protected him because it was just the truth and it was n't enough for him, that's why they created over time, republicans , you have learned your lessons from the fact that the president behaves, let’s say, so illegally, support is needed, someone should say that he is right, someone would somehow support

him and conduct ideological work and be the fox channel was created and gradually they are not immediately overpopular but at some point there was a scandal, if i’m mistaken , it was a scandal with white clint little levinsky and during this scandal they broke up very old very popular and since carlson wandered for a long time in different channel and his outfits at the beginning he was a person from such a very rich family a-a and now he has become an absolute populist because this is the point of view that is being sold, and he is a real seller from the point of view, he sold it in the beginning of a butterfly, then a butterfly how would it become he was too long, he showed himself as if he was too rich, and that's why he changed it to a tie and changed his looks , as if he twisted his

nuts . about the elections, and how he lost, and some journalist who stayed on fox news reported about it, so carlson became and you, that this journalist was fired because the price of the company's shares was falling, how would he use it to prove that journalist what is the need to get rid of this person, that's why carlson is a seller of a point of view. unfortunately, the question is, how would it be ? management because they were sued. and how is a company that was not accredited because they called it a company that is considered to be counting votes in the elections, and as a result, they began to testify, leak testimony and you did that, too, because carlson hates trump until now i hope

that he will be able to stop talking soon, he writes in the texts of the matchmaker to other people who were published as part of this process. so it is clear that he is lying as if he is lying, and what is an intellectual lie called when he says something, but he understands a-a and that's it because carlson and how it would seem that after such a moment, what happened two months later, when it turned out that fox is not some kind of non-organization, i don't know that you, how do you change the opinion of the viewers, well, there is no viewer anyway the main thing is that they do not support whether they are democrats or not. the old man says something against trump , because then the audience leaves, and if they lie to them, then the audience, please, we are as if on the same page with this channel, and the audience is now dragging za seboi tv channel yuriy rashkin, a political and public figure from the united states of america, was with us and told us a little about how the election

campaign in america is going. ours is now gradually coming to an end. finally, important information for you. please take your phones. please set up the camera or take a pen and a piece of paper and carefully write down the card numbers or qr-codes because i remind you that we are now collecting for a car for the second time this week, actually, we have completed the collection for one of the cars and she has already gone to the defenders of the company named after nema, they have started dzhihan as part of the 251st battalion of the 241st brigade, we are now collecting for the second one, we already have more than half of the required amount, and we need to collect uah 500,000, so please, whoever can , join this collection as soon as possible

, we will close it, we will announce it soon good news faster why, let's start the next collection, how can you give and watch all those for a whole week well, someone couldn't stand it, he got annoyed in the same way in the comments. yes, someone said that you look like chekhov, this is a compliment , i don't know, friends, further in our etar is the conversation of our colleague, the economic columnist oleksandra marshavka with roman vashchuk, a businessman-butsman in ukraine and a former canadian diplomat, so please watch. for your attention . the interview is relevant, why is it relevant, because today in the issue we are talking about business, business that works in war conditions, business, fearless business that needs support at the same time, and the guest of the program is the well-known diplomat , business ombudsman, roman vashchuk, who holds this

position from january 1, 2022. i congratulate you mr. roman, thank you very much. i congratulate you and the audience. well , it is clear that the business that managed to save the jobs of its production can relax and find safe places to continue its activities. it can be called a heroic business. but at the same time entrepreneurs have a number of problems in relations with the authorities. not everything is so simple, there is no simplified regulatory system that should be in place for the functioning of european entrepreneurship in our country. well, here is one of the urgent problems that has arisen for ukrainian business, the blocking of tax invoices, well, in essence, it has turned into well, this system is such a manual mechanism. well, in fact , it deprives the business of working capital. well, what is the decision of your office of the business ombudsman and what is the recommendation to the ukrainian authorities. how to solve this problem well, last friday we presented our report, it is the result of several months of work

by our team of inspectors, we are already monitoring this risk assessment system , the so-called sm-cor, from the very beginning, we know it, so to speak, inside out, this system, and we came to the conclusion that when the system at the beginning, let's say, automatically caught three or four percent of the ukrainian business, because here it is also important, how to calculate, because the tax department very often says, look, there are hundreds of millions of these invoices, of which we stopped 2-3 million, well, that's a little less than one the percentage is a little more than one percent, but you know that, some kind of almost no percentage, but when in the 19th year it concerned three to four percent of ukrainian business, and already in

the fourth quarter of the 22nd year, 40 point four percent of the ukrainian business, e.e., felt the problem of blocking one or more tax invoices in the value-added tax system, then this already threatens to stop , in particular, medium-sized and smaller enterprises. why can large firms have their legal departments and accounting departments can reflect for smaller firms - this is a big the problem and the problem also arises due to the fact that the phenomenon is a kind of iral, in one word, they recognized the invoice, they stopped your invoice, maybe you were recognized as a risky firm, suddenly all your counterparties become potentially risky, and then it spreads from one yes that i would like more and more half of the business to feel some kind of tax stoppages just at the end of last year well, to what extent it

stopped it is possible that the schemes that were felt by the tax system were felt by tax officials is it not worth it i that the ukrainian average the business got rid of working capital in general. well, you know, from the very beginning of the introduction of the system, i think that the assessment of our specialists is that over the years, about 2/3 of the schemes and schemers were eliminated from the crust, this is without a doubt a success, but already what happened last year 2018, an attempt was made so widely to attack the city that it was then an automatic system , so that individual firms had to be manually sorted out.

the committee of the verkhovna rada, mr. hetmantsem said that, you know, it is necessary to return to the automated beginnings of, let's say, the algorithms of this system, to review the algorithms and really make an assessment of whether it is worth the shkuruz law, that is, to find some other smaller schemes, or whether it is worth stopping honest business because of this, and unfortunately , last year coincided exactly with the peak the beginning and peak of the russian company against ukrainian energy means that the load was increased. and to unlock one invoice , the business told us that we needed approximately the hours of their work are gossipy. by the way, yuriy, get someone else when your electricity is cut off, when there are problems with communications , it’s all one with the other, it doesn’t contribute to the development of business already in january and february, we see a downward trend, new decisions were made at the end of december and in february

we were promised that we submitted most of our recommendations, 10 main ones and about 20 more technical recommendations of the tax office, in particular, the memorial , which gives it such encouragement and guidelines, and takes it into work with the idea that they over the next few months, the improvement of the algorithm is an opportunity for entrepreneurs to see what are the indicators of their sector, whether they are approaching some red line, an opportunity to submit certain trial documents to see the mechanism works before, say, the blocking will be stopped. so, i think all this is promised to be implemented in the coming months. so here i think the attention of you as economic journalists and our business associations, of which there are five that supported

we also had a lot of support from tax bloggers who are expertly follow-up, that's all. so we, i think we are so together and we see that there is a good desire from the authorities as well in order to correct the mistakes, so that it still happened later on, in fact , the business for several months reproached the business association that the blocking of invoices, well, in fact, left many enterprises without a penny. so to speak , approach as per the principle of do no harm if the state does not have unlimited grant money to distribute to businesses, and it does not have clear reasons for it, i.e. not to harm and not to take working capital, there is no need for working capital, roman and here is a topic that has been essentially under the control of the office of the boatman's business for many years, this is the connection of business to the power grid

i know that a lot of work has been done, uh, certain regulation between uh , government bodies and business has already been simplified, but still entrepreneurs complain that it is very expensive , and we know you are one of the examples of a turkish investor, the amount was announced crazy well tell me what has been done now, i think. from what we can see, one of the problems is that the price of labor and services, particularly high-tech in this field, has increased in ukraine and the market price has become quite high . for e.e. state important investments, a certain regime of benefits in order to contribute both in time and in terms of funds to such an important project as, for example, this bairaktariv e-e. i think that the streamlining of relations and property and

administrative ones at oblenergo and other operators of this market, maybe with the stabilization of these companies, it will also become easier to solve these problems. but i think that there must be a certain mix of both market and, again, i want a lot of money from the state , but there are no subsidy mechanisms. i will give you an example of the relocation of a ukrainian company abroad, e.e. , the ajacks s systems company, a well-known manufacturer of security systems, was considering relocation to poland outside their new location in western ukraine. turkey, which was able to immediately lace up a package that included energy issues and tax and customs issues and access to engineering personnel , etc.

here, let's say this one for new investors. agencies such as ukraine west have now strengthened their expert side a bit. they could just take this issue of energy supply for new enterprises into account, and it's interesting. here we are talking about a company that is looking for uh a new safe place to work, but how to protect the business that works in ukraine during the war and tries to pay taxes on time, well, it tolerates the blocking of tax invoices, but what are the appeals to the office of the boatman now from entrepreneurs and how do you legally try to help establish relations connection with the power structures, well, this is exactly our role, and we , uh, since about last july, when state bodies started working again, they returned to many of their old habits, this is a

tax issue, first of all, the second is pressure from law enforcement officers, let's say, the concentration of economic issues in the new bureau of economic security did not take place. then there is a kind of competition between four-five-six different bodies of pre-trial investigation, each of which wants to show that it is she who works valiantly on this new one. and this proves also to crackdowns, so we work on such issues, such as they came and took away certain electronic or other means, they must be returned, we work before the courts and after the judges, that is, our role is to try it, so to speak -kindly resolve this between by the state by the enterprise until it reaches the court, and if the decision is legal, the state should execute it in such a way, because even here there is no automaticity that

can be hoped for in a state governed by the rule of law. well, it is clear that you mentioned the court decisions, judicial reform during the war must take place according to the essence and victory must be met in particular with honest courts , in particular business eh, which now has complaints , maybe specific examples, you can tell and some help from a business-budsman to a specific business, well, in general, what is happening there, you know there are situations paradoxically, it is not the way i think most people imagine, let's say, in tax or customs matters, courts mostly decide in 90-95% of cases in favor of business , this is pleasing that in favor of business , e. they corrected their administrative practice in accordance with judicial

practice. yes, that's one thing, but there is such an imbalance , there is no common understanding, no. and i have, uh, well, it seems that today the decision about the longlist has already arrived, so to speak, for the new the higher qualification commission of judges to which there are a lot of useful, worthy, useful rules for the list of rules. i mean useful for the cause of judicial reform, people and the higher levels of judges in ukraine have already been reformed to a large extent, but the first-instance appeal remained problematic it is just that if this new composition of the vikks will be able to bring worthy people to these lower positions of judges of the first instance and appeals during the next year, then this means that

the first touch of business is the first or ukrainian or a foreigner to the system will be balanced and correct, it will not be necessary to wait for the third appeal in order to find somewhere in kyiv justice can be found on the spot and i think that this should be the common goal of everyone in this system, mr. roman it is clear that ukraine has great prospects after the victory to attract foreign business, foreign investments in the government say , well, at least a few such strategic directions of capital investment - this is agriculture, the it sphere is clear that the defense industry, green energy, but what kind see our state after the victory, the businessmen themselves are foreign, what should be the platform for investing in various industries , you know, i would return to

ukrainian business for a moment, because there will not be a huge flow of foreign business if ukrainian business does not feel comfortable in ukraine. i think that investors can help to tie up the package, but they cannot be the protection of business against an unfavorable investment limit. so, without a happy ukrainian business, there cannot be a happy foreign business. indeed, i am in warsaw as well. were in london, er, now there are also part of the exhibition conference, where there are a lot of interested companies, in particular infrastructure companies, because it is clear that after the victory, ukraine will be the largest construction site not only in europe, but the truth of such a world, just think for yourself, just practically, if you are a manufacturer of windows, a manufacturer of doors, a manufacturer of any - what kind of things are needed to restore even a partially damaged house ukraine -

this is your big market of the future, not to mention the fact that, let's say, the largely destroyed or half-destroyed ukrainian the energy system will have to be more or less completely reconstructed and these are the sectors that are of great interest . we believe in the future, we believe in investments.