[000:00:00;00] they need success, which they can call their success, and this success should be post-war ukraine becoming ukraine, this is wonderful, mr. sniper . my last question to you today is what will be the historical responsibility of russia, not putin, but russia, for everything it did during the war, this is wonderful question because i believe that responsibility is a key term in international politics and this is related to what you said about the law, that is, maybe we want putin to be arrested, but it is important for us to say that you are responsible we believe that you are responsible for everything . we believe in responsibility, but one of the problems of russia is a whole culture of impunity, they do something bad and then something even worse, and so they stop believing in these rules and

we are not punished, of course in the country a person tries to violate rules, but another matter. if we say that there are no rules, that nothing matters, and this is exactly the situation russia is in, that is why, first of all, it is very important that russian assets are used for the restoration of ukraine, for this it is necessary to find a way and secondly from the point of view of historical responsibility i am not saying now as a historian people should think about how russian history was written as we all thought about russia when people obviously one of the reasons for this war was that many of us believed for too long in a certain story about what russia really was then russia invaded ukraine before we understood that the story about russia that we believe does not allow us to understand some other historical realities ukraine is one of these historical realities it is a bone

respons the world very historical responsibility is also the actual responsibility for the reconstruction of european history or the history of the west in such a way that ukraine fits into it, and the most interesting thing is that european or western history will become much more interesting and make much more sense because of this. i don't want to talk only about russians, there are things that we also should be done, but then people should be tried, there should be long, boring trials in which people are found guilty, and then it will be possible to talk about relations with the russians, we are all united by a common problem we are looking at history we say that we have always been innocent , that we have never done anything bad, ukrainians can say that, americans can also say that, russia shows us what happens when you push putin to extremes in this regard - putin's gray hair is that russians are always innocent, always guilty

, here the other was always the germans the austrians the jews brussels berlin washington it was always someone else uh we never did anything wrong and even so tovarbentrop never existed we never did anything wrong decent russia, i will now talk about things that do not depend on us. but in order for the renewal of russia to take place, they will have to admit that there is a concept of historical responsibility. i say this because the word responsibility is very important. but we cannot force someone to be responsible. we can try to hold others accountable. that there is a law and you you no, we have a lot of money, we can do it with russia, but in the end the responsibility is also something internal, something that needs to be felt we can't do it instead of russia but we can for myself, thank you very much, mr. snyder. thank you for agreeing to talk, for answering my questions and sharing your thoughts about

the past, the future and about our victory . thank you very much. well, it was timothy snyder , a professor of history at the lille university . they obviously talked about ukraine and russia with him. about the past, about the future and, obviously, about victory, see you this week in the judicial control program, sky-high fortunes and trips with his ex-wife, for the merits of which pavlo gorbasenko was re-elected head of the state court of the kyiv region drew attention to a possible fictitious divorce and whether gorbasenko maintains ties with relatives in the occupied crimea thank you for your questions continue in that you are watching judicial control i am tetyana shustrova judicial reform in ukraine

is currently in progress , the competition for the higher qualification commission is approaching judges of the supreme body of the judicial system , which is responsible for the formation of the judicial corps and ensuring the appropriate level , in particular, through the qualification assessment of the composition qualification commission is fully updated in accordance with international standards. while it is not yet formed, unscrupulous judges multiply their fortunes, which cannot be explained by official income, today we will tell you about the head of the economic court of the kyiv region, pavlo gorbasenko, but first , the news of the competitive commission for the selection of members of the higher qualification commission of judges announced a list of 32 recommended candidates, including ten judges, six

lawyers and 16 representatives of other profiles , now out of 32 selected during the competition applicants, the supreme council of justice must elect 16 members of the central committee of the communist party of ukraine, eight of whom must be judges, 8 non-judges, so one of the key bodies, after more than three years of lack of authority, will finally start work we have received hundreds of judicial documents about 1,500 property declarations and many more 13,000 documents that our commission received and had to process, we fulfilled what we promised to the people of ukraine, we recommended the best of the best among those who submitted their

applications and documents to our commission, we will remind it was the largest competition of those held in the judicial system of ukraine, 301 candidates participated in it ukrainian judiciary is attacked by hackers from russia state enterprise is under threat information judicial systems hackers attack e-mail systems specialists do everything possible to normalize work and protect servers supreme court of appeals of the anti-corruption court acquitted the judge of the kyiv district administrative court oleksandra bragina, who was previously found guilty of intentionally not submitting an electronic declaration for the year 2020 in january 2023, vaks imposed a penalty in the form of a fine of uah 51,000 with the deprivation of the right to hold certain positions according to the indictment, despite the opportunity to submit

a declaration for the year 2020, the judge did not do this because she did not receive an electronic signature, allegedly due to religious beliefs . the panel of judges of the appeals chamber annulled the verdict of the higher anti-corruption court and closed the criminal proceedings due to the lack of a criminal offense in early march in the commercial court of the kyiv region held a meeting of judges at which the head of the court was elected by secret ballot. pavlo gorbasenko was again not the best candidate for such a responsible position, and now we will tell you why pavlo gorbasenko, one of the most scandalous judges and one of the most influential people in kyiv region, is the current

head of the economic court the court of the kyiv region has a wonderful family, a house was given to him by the judge's father , an entrepreneur, and he has a large business in the territory of the occupied crimea, where pavlo also lives gorbasenko was lucky with his ex-wife. but after the divorce, the couple managed to maintain a warm relationship so warm that a few years after the divorce , they had a child together. that's how they remained friends, but let's go in order. gorbasenko was appointed a judge of the commercial court of the kyiv region by presidential decree in 2010. remained and after the revolution of dignity until now, the judge managed to get into several scandals and make a living, or

his mother helped him in this with a small number of square meters a housewife, according to gorbasenko, she gave her son two apartments of 116 and 136 m², in an elite area on the obolonskyi embankment in kyiv . she also received a gift contract from her mother in the 12th year in the court of gorbasenko. experts told us the head of the all-ukrainian association of automaidan , kateryna budko, we drew attention to him when he went through the qualification evaluation a few years ago that holosenko received a negative conclusion of the public integrity council and this conclusion was primarily based on the fortunes of the candidate a-a because he has quite a lot of them, having given apartments to his son for himself

, pavlo gorbasenko's mother built a house of more than 800 m², in the village of lebedivka near kyiv, next to a picturesque green forest on a huge private territory of more than half a hectare, there is a two-story building, a swimming pool, a gazebo, all this good is surrounded by a high fence and closed from prying eyes in this house, the judge likes to spend his weekends, says the head in general, do you live in the village? i only live on weekends. it probably happens. where does the housewife’s mother get the money for such a big house ? pavlo gorbasenko assures all the money is the wealth of his father, a businessman. my father has been working in the private sector since 1998.

he is engaged in business, mainly in the construction business. invests in it is a general contracting organization, that is, it builds and puts into operation , sales is and designs both for and to this day. limited liability companies sevelena construction and yuk-invest of the commercial court of the kyiv region conducts business in the occupied territory and pays taxes to the country of the terrorist, the father is currently not in the country of time volodymyr gorbasenko petroria of the occupied peninsula here in this apartment of more than 300 square meters on the yalta embankment purchased in april 2014, already after the occupation, taking into account the transfer of business to

russian legislation, taking into account the payment of taxes to the russian federation, it seems that his father may be in the occupied territory, well, at least it could have been at the time when this interview took place. it is interesting that the construction and housing rental business is similar to my father’s. the alleged ex-wife of pavlo gorbasenko, hanna svyridenko, also had a lot of real estate, land plots, and residential buildings registered on the territory of crimea. i'm just explaining that it doesn't really look like a residential building, it's more like shacks built from foam blocks. my wife bought her own plots of land and built on them. certain such together again with her partner certain such shacks and

they rented them out such was the activity now she still has some plots of land left in the crimea, by the way they cost uah 26,000 uah 38,000 and plots of land and houses as well as some plots of land in crimea - these are four non-residential premises in the gazpro located under yalta. and several more plots of land in sudak and a house of more than 300 square meters. she is associated with the odious prosecutor and land tycoon yuri krivobok for a long time, she worked in the law firm of his father, vasyl krivobok, and the relationship was probably so close that the law firm itself was registered in the apartment that belonged to anna sviridenko, sviridenko was also

seen in the privatization scandal lands near kyiv together with the kryvoboks. apparently , by coincidence, this case was considered in the court where pavlo gorbasenko works in 2009. they took advantage of the right to free land privatization in sofiyivska borshchagivka, near kyiv, and received as many as 16.6 hectares of fields, which is significantly more than is generally allowed by law. part of this land was given to a private developer, and svidarenko also received land for farming free of charge, and then it was sold very quickly and the village council of sofiyivska borshchahivka sued the developers every year

of documents of hanna svyridenko, the ex-wife of the head of the economic court of the kyiv region, with gorbasenko, they allegedly divorced on december 24, 2014, however, they remained in excellent relations so much so that five days after the divorce, they went to europe together and were supposed to celebrate freedom. at that time, the wife was svyridenko hanna viktorivna , we broke up with her in the 14th year, and therefore in the future i did not specify her, but we continued our communication, two circumstances simply disappeared under which i have to declare her cohabitation and not being in court, gorbasenko and kanula's wife remained in the past only communication and it was apparently so fruitful that in february 2017, the former spouses

had a common child without roommates, that is, just in the 14th year, when we broke up, i took things and moved them to a neighboring apartment in the 17th year , we had a common child, but all the same , we did not live together because of this, we did not have such warm neighborly relations, however, it is too similar to the manipulation of the norms of the law , probably precisely in order not to declare property, the public council of integrity drew attention to the possible fictitious divorce of the judge. we also have reasons to believe that pavlo gorbasenko and hanna svirydenko could maintain their marital relationship, although in the declarations the head of the commercial court of the kyiv region no longer indicates his wife, and even after the divorce, they continued to spend vacations together, according to information according to our sources, over the past 5 years

, the former couple traveled abroad together 12 times, so in 2019 they flew to barcelona three times, once to greek salons and once once to dusseldorf, where are the trips? hanna sredenko recorded this photo on her instagram. a member of the kyiv city council published this photo when she was in greece. but in this photo , the ex-wife of a judge in boryspil is waiting for a flight to germany, from where she probably went to strasbourg for a work conference. were accompanied by her ex, nor a couple from the mouth, the new year is 2020 , the former spouses apparently celebrated together in spain, probably a mysterious man with a glass of champagne in this video from

anna sviridenko's instagram is pavlo gorbasenko at least according to our sources, the couple left the plane in barcelona together on 2/21. gorbasenko and sviridenko meet together in hurghada, and then the former spouses return to spain three times and fly to paris once. in the photo from anna sviridenko's instagram, we see catalonia square in barcelona and this is one of the biggest avenues of barça basei ot degrassia here are the most expensive boutique hotels and architectural masterpieces of antonio gaudi and finally 2022 the year of the war in ukraine a few weeks before a full-scale invasion the couple flew together again to hurghada, and on december 24, on the eve of catholic christmas, gorbasenko and sviridenko left for europe together by train kyiv-warsaw, who knows, maybe

they just traveled as volunteers for humanitarian aid, whatever it was, and all these joint trips and vacations spent together indicate that that the head of the economic court of the kyiv region can still maintain marital relations with the woman whom he allegedly deleted from his life according to the declaration , according to the documents of the spouses, the former lives in apartments that were allegedly donated by the judge's mother here one of the most expensive residential complexes in obolon with picturesque views of the dnipro and natalka park is a 3-minute walk away. businessmen, prosecutors, deputies, stars live in these houses , and even president volodymyr zelensky himself once lived, of course, all under cameras and with security. the price of apartments here starts at 100,000

dollars . for a simple one-room apartment, and the gorbasenko family actually has an entire floor. espresso tv channel, we have a few questions for you without prior agreement , and so that it does not look chaotic and that everything is thoroughly meaningful and objective, please contact us with your list of questions about the house, although explain or about the father in crimea, what do you support? if you want to talk about your mother's house, you can go to the cemetery at the forest cemetery. thank you for your questions . continue at home

. gorbasenko, in which they inquired about the relationship with his father in the occupied crimea and about the allegedly fictitious divorce and about traveling abroad in the conditions of martial law and at the time of preparing the program for broadcast, they did not receive such answers and did not receive cases that raise doubts about possible connections with the state of the alleged terrorist the intention to hide the real marital relationship and travel outside ukraine during the war, the legality of which the judge has not explained to us here. we are not even surprised that experts negatively assess the integrity of pavlo gorbasenko, considering the negative the conclusion of the public integrity council, of course. in my opinion, the judge who received such conclusions and has such a number of questions should

have been dismissed. he was even re-elected to the high position of the head of the commercial court of the kyiv region , as we can see, despite the positive developments in the judicial reform, the system as a whole is still too old, so ridding it of unworthy representatives is a key task that should be followed for reformers to decide on ukraine's path to the eu, for today i had all of this with the judicial control program and i am tetyana shustrova, if you have information about unscrupulous judges and facts of corruption in the judicial system, please let me know on facebook or by e-mail , the address of which you now see on the screen.

well see you in exactly a week can be called the first major victory of ukraine in the war with the russian invaders, however , the de-occupied settlements near the northern and western parts of the kyiv region suffered significant destruction a year ago, the residents of buchi lived in such conditions, there is no water, no light, no gas, there is no heat, degrees of heat in the apartment, and you are dressed like this, like that , we sleep, you see, you walk like homeless people, and everything is in our street in a similar way without any oksana buchanka survived the occupation in the village of mykhailivka-rubezhivka near buchi. she left the city a few days after the full-scale invasion. i

haven't eaten bread for years, probably since 10. bread itself is simple , and it was during the occupation that i really wanted it for some reason. bread, and we had the opportunity to collect flour from people, and the woman baked the bread herself on the fire. it was bread with sand, but it was the most delicious, but everyday inconveniences seemed like trifles compared to the crimes committed by the russian occupiers against civilians . people were in the information center almost all the time. in a vacuum, two weeks after the occupation, oksana completely lost contact with her relatives in buchi . to catch a connection literally a few words you are alive er what is there who is there ask about someone er well for a week there was no connection and then

after the 15th from march 15 the connection was disconnected until the end of the occupation until on the 31st, there was no internet or mobile communication after the deoccupation. the local residents saw the scale of the war crimes of the russian invaders. we are now on yablunska street . came here it was on march 31, yes, they saw these bodies. when you were in the occupation, did you know what was happening right next to you ? well, the nearest streets probably knew people in the nearest streets and a little further. as a rule, more in their yards, those who communicated with each other, were looking for where to get water, food, and so on

, they could know something, but uh, practically throughout bucha, people's bodies were on all the streets, namely that such atrocities had already been learned after the occupation, when an opportunity arose to move from the streets to the streets and people began to find out about their loved ones as of march 25 of this year , 1,374 bodies of civilians killed during the occupation were found in kyiv region, another 283 people are still missing due to hostilities, it was completely destroyed or more than 27,000 objects were damaged, mainly residential buildings, everyone who could rebuild began to rebuild sometime in may on their own, who could do something the first thing was installing doors in apartments because a

lot of apartments were broken into and taken away together with the doors of things and broken fences of broken houses and people who left far away and left for ukraine, they started to return already at the end of april at the beginning of may, well, apparently the return itself was so uh very symbolic that the children returned with their parents because how the rule is that well, it is necessary to insure the lives of children, and if there are already many children in the city. and bucha is considered a young city with many young families, then the most significant thing was when the children returned after the occupation, life is raging in the city of bucha vokzalna street, where on february 27, 2022, a column of russian military equipment was destroyed, 14 buildings are now under major reconstruction. another hundred

damages were completely destroyed here. charitable funds of many countries of the usa, in particular japan and european countries, joined in the reconstruction of vokzalna. local residents believe that the worst is behind us, then the occupation. we hoped and were even then convinced that ukraine would win, and when i was told if we would win, they said no, no, we should say when we will win, that is, as soon as the russians left here, there was already a conviction that they would not return, but thousands of families still remain abroad or in other regions of ukraine, many simply have nowhere to return to just to rebuild irpen , about 1 billion dollars are needed, so the final reconstruction of kyiv region will take more than one year, and the main record of society is currently to attract all russians guilty of crimes are to be held accountable 45 countries are currently working on the development of a mechanism to condemn and

bring to justice persons who have committed war crimes and other serious crimes in ukraine, first the invasion of the russian federation on our territory. glory to ukraine is a verdict program. my name is serhiy rudenko. good day and good health to all. today , april 6, is the 407th day of the heroic struggle of the ukrainian people against the russian occupiers. french president manuel macron met with ukraine in beijing. the leader of france is expected to discuss the future of ukraine with the leader of china. meanwhile, peace in ukraine the russian occupiers continue to lose manpower and equipment in ukraine