[000:00:00;00] this has always been one of the trends in the crimean economy, as far as agriculture is concerned, on the one hand, they are trying to continue and support the development of agriculture, on the other hand, they are digging trenches and this also applies because they are digging trenches not only along the perimeter, they are digging digs supposedly only along the perimeter of crimea itself, the crimean peninsula, but they also dig trenches along the perimeter of e-e settlements. well, the third component of the crimean economy is really a recreational economy, because here when we we are talking about the recreational area, they left only the excavated coast , it is in the south. and as for whether there will be any holiday season. what do you want? russia has not

come anywhere. no, most russians are going to oanapa. that's why now -e occupation on the administrator is trying to calm people down about things that will be compensated financially well, i don't believe it , it's a pity we won't see funny posts on the topic again, you had a good rest, mr. squadrons thank you very much eskanderberiv, head of the crimean tatar resource center, members the consultant people were with us after the advertisement, we will return to our next child inflammation of the gums and the solution was so simple problems with the gums lacalut active lacalut active actively overcomes bleeding gums, protects against periodontitis and visibly tightens clear lacalut active action that you feel

immediately the novelty of lacalut active plus more a more active defense is one fourth of the champions league matches man city vs. bayern and real vs. and louder matches exclusively on megogo fm halychyna but radio fm halychyna tried to break into the airwaves and it was also reflected, well, february will strike at your cyber attack, radio fm galicia has prepared its response and we heard that our armed forces promised a spring counteroffensive to the occupier, so radio fm galicia will be in the formation of an informational spring counterattack, you will hear and even see life continues, the war is going on in galicia to the russians

for ukrainians, usual tasks become unreal, heavy bags are not suitable for my back pain from back pain try dolgit cream dolgit cream relieves pain, reduces swelling and improves joint mobility with dolgit cream what do you want i will lift dolgit the only yellow cream for joint and back pain the us state department officially recognized the ukrainian mass media as partially free in its annual report the us state department condemned the disconnection of three ukrainian tv channels from the t2 digital network a year ago espresso was illegally disconnected from the t2 digital network without reason explanations, no one is responsible for our disconnection, not why we cannot speak , and most importantly, when we will be returned to the digital air

espresso, keep working for the victory we did not betray ukraine to our viewers, our journalists became laureates of state awards and the winner of the shevchenko prize bianka zalevska was awarded the order of princess olga espresso is quoted by the most influential world media we continue to dismantle russia's crimes against ukraine and fight street propaganda , freedom of speech is one of the main requirements of ukraine's membership in the eu cannot be limited even during war, well, listen, is there freedom of speech in a country where independent mass media are deprived of broadcasting. the authorities must correct their mistakes and not to harm the european integration of ukraine, we demand that espresso be returned to the digital air, we return to ethene, we continue our marathon and now we will actually talk about freedom of speech about freedom of speech and also in general, definitely

about and also about the person about the person rather because exactly today is exactly 20 years since the death of oleksandr kryvenko or sashka kryvenko in a car accident. hmm, ukrainian, you say up for many journalists, a person who is difficult to describe in a few words, this is very good wrote 7 years ago by oksana khvorostina, a ukrainian publisher and cultural expert who says that every time she has to explain in a few words why sashko kryvenko is important, why it is important to remember him, and it is always difficult to do so, we can say that he is the first founder and publisher of the first non-soviet non- soviet and a non-partisan newspaper that was printed in lithuania in general and the first copies were delivered on the first days by train to lviv and from there it spread, this is

a legendary progress and then a post-waste reincarnation. unfortunately, two people who stood near the origins of this first ukrainian journalist, who is no longer among us, neither oleksandr kryvenko nor andrii ketkovskyi is among us very early , somehow, such people go from life , well, now we are already including yevhen hlibovytskyi in the conversation. of the day well, he actually addresses that's how this question was formulated by oksana khvorostina about how difficult it is to explain in a few words how important kryvenko is, his character and why it is important to remember him. i think that kryvenko was one of those people who actually created a vision of the ukraine in

which we can live today, he was not ready to accept ukraine only in its post-soviet state, he actually wrote about the fact that independence was given to ukraine as a result of a very special turn of historical events when the interests of the communists who controlled the power in the ukrainian ssr coincided with the nationalists and as a result we risked getting a country that is formally ukrainian but which does not value freedom and does not value its citizens and probably his most famous work popular and often quoted ukraine is my marginal actually he talks about the fact that he loves a different ukraine that is the ukraine of his dreams and kryvenko in those hundreds of students he educated in those texts he wrote in those

interactions he had publicly politically and so on and he actually made a huge contribution so that today we could be in something that we actually consider a given, that we consider to be the natural development of ukraine, and actually the irony is that if we are talking about human development, then it is just not natural the natural state is the decline, uh, actually, referring to marginal ukraine, 30 years have passed already, 30 years have passed by whom this text was written, and when uh , the large-scale, especially russian invasion began a year ago, yes, uh, i think about what uh, can there are these words that it's a pity or how funny it is for our family, it's so funny, it's funny, it's funny to sing rifle songs when you yourself don't understand well, and i've only seen that red viburnum in the picture often, but i thought that it's all

a little bit not about us anymore because it's again there wasn't some new hmm reality of relevance does this mean that little by little we are overcoming that state of marginal ukraine because it seems to me that by well, i don't know, maybe by the 19th to the 21st to the 22nd, that's all that was a very relevant text. it seems to me that kryvenko is actually starting to become a historical figure, one of my friends on facebook wrote that those we knew become the streets, and actually kryvenko is one of those who, ah, now you are less understandable without a translation, because his texts need an act in that context in which they were written and ukraine is mine the marginal one he wrote today has become mainstream if we are talking about the red viburnum or if we are talking about rifle

songs, they sounded in a completely new way , they sounded in new contexts, they were actually original and of course kryvenko could not predict what exactly such developed events that uh, this is exactly how it will all happen. i also never in my life would have thought that once i heard pink floyd play the red viburnum, that is, it probably happened. but nevertheless , he laid the foundation of this improbability because he is from one on the one hand, he criticized the state of things that existed in ukraine in the 90s. he severely criticized this post-soviet ukraine or ukraine, which was a country that had just fallen out of perestroika and remained somewhere in it in its contexts and understandings, and on the other hand he actually tried to create this new ukraine by establishing such institutions as public radio or by spending time with his students or by spending

time trying to convince important partners that they should one way or another adjust their activities as if sashko kryvenko lived to the present day in principle not such an old man would be uh and now he would look at that ukraine his ukraine uh at the time of the full-scale invasion of the great war now he would look at the ukrainian media at the state of freedom of speech so that he would like it in this ukraine in 2023 and if he didn't like it well, he wouldn't have been frozen in time, that is, it wouldn't have been kryvenko of the 90s who found himself in the future, he would have evolved with us , and i think that what exactly would have happened would be an incredible irony of his for sure the strongest

he was a fantastically ironic man who very appropriately and very aptly used ah i think the only other person who can match him is les podervyanskyi and they were actually very close in all this and i think that a pig today would be witty, would be smart and would be terribly sharp-tongued. especially since we have enough reasons to be ironic or reasons to laugh, including , first of all, at ourselves and we are in a culture where there is enough freedom to to be the most ironic and in that sense. i think that kryvenko would naturally pull away. and uh, i look at such very, how to say it, uh , the first and uncertain steps of ukrainian stand-up. i think that sashkov's columns would

most likely add to his difficulties and they gave me the opportunity to be happy about that and how we can be strong by being ironic about myself, ivan, since i now have such an opportunity . i also mentioned, for example, kryvenka recently, and it was not a big surprise, but no one knew who it was, to a certain extent , it should have been compensated for by the fact that no one knew who the pikhovshik was , that is, none of them mentioned it i.e. it would seem that until recently, until the 14th year, there was some value even in the professional environment, but on the other hand, i thought about the fact that he could still come back. he is not somewhere

far away, he still has the option to perform theoretically somewhere at least on some on a nationwide channel on some nationwide airwaves maybe i'm exaggerating, of course, but this moment , well, conditionally, that's what you can do with sentiments, but it's good. also, this is formulated by the new e-e minister of education, who says, which is formulated differently as a desire to punish unpunished evil as a desire for all- to restore justice to a certain person. so how can we deal with the fact that kryvenko is forgotten in general, that he is not important , you seem to think that relatively speaking well, just like looking somewhere, observing the streets of kryvenko, but i just decided to see if there is somewhere in ukraine there is at least one sashka kryvenko street, well, google didn't show me, i don't know, maybe he doesn't know something, maybe he's wrong somewhere , but i didn't see the sashka kryvenko street. and i

think that well, first of all, you and i know that uh, there is uh- hmm, it is not necessarily a fair assessment of history, that is, very often history does not remember those who made a gigantic contribution in the proportion that reflects the magnitude of this contribution. i would also like students to know kryvenko. but it seems to me that it is more important for kryvenko himself it would be if in fact the changes were such that uh uh would reflect exactly what he wanted to achieve . which happened somewhere in the year 90, if i am not mistaken, when

taras stetskiv returned from the united states and was supposed to come to the office of the lev society to tell about some forgotten hero about whom we did not know about a certain pavlyk relyshin because he is in the states stetskiv heard about him and came he told about this pavlyk rylyshyn only after 15-20 minutes, a large part of the people understood that he was talking about pablo krylyshyn, in fact, in that sense, the question is the form or the content that we need . i would like to have both, but in fact i think that is more important that we have freedom of speech is more important that we have the opportunity to protect civil liberties it is more important that we live in a democracy and will sashka or the name with you or someone else be remembered well, sooner

or later we will all transform factor some forgotten of history it's just possible that in our case it will have a longer digital footprint, in the end i'll ask you very briefly if we are, or if this is the only marathon, the only news, is this not a threat to freedom of speech, and is it not delayed a little, this is the format of ukrainian information of society about what is happening in the country, ah, technically , i would say that this is a threat, but let's also remember the causes and the consequences . the cause is the war, and the biggest threat to freedom of speech is the war, which can drag on and in that sense it is also a question not only to the ukrainian government, although a lot depends on the ukrainian government. when i say the government, i mean, rather , from the administration, from the entire government. but it also depends on our democratic partners, if they want to see ukraine

as a democracy, it is very important that this democracy was not exhausted because if we have to defend our own and some other interest, having not enough for us to be able to bring this security function to the table, i am afraid that at a certain point the situation may return to the side that no one will like. thank you, mr. yevhen yevhen hlebovetskyi. company manager , speech, public figure, nester group expert , was with us. and here our viewers are reacting to the infantryman, whose surname they say is a quiet traitor . no one disputes this, of course, but knowing him and knowing what he did for journalism and with negative journalism of course it is for those people who study journalism who want to be journalists it is important to explain for me it was just important to show

just this story can be told by a journalist, a person who was someone in journalism and a person who was completely discredited during his activity. although there is evidence that pikhovshik may have had some contacts with the kgb in many participants of the movement of the 90s and the end of the 80s for independence well, that's another story , but it was important for me to emphasize here that pihovsha says that he doesn't have any court that recognized him as a traitor, there isn't any kind of p- i don't know repression or persecution or investigation what would force him, for example, to leave now even ukraine knows he is in ukraine , in kyiv, he is quite enjoying himself with how much well, i could be wrong here, of course, to be honest , i do not follow him at all and almost with them and almost with them at the beginning of the season before this year, the sbu began an investigation into tv presenter diana panchenko this

she's already hm, a journalist, a journalist of a new age, but i think it's interesting when diana panchenko is checked, why don't they check and find out where pikhovshik is now ? well, well, we're moving on. now let's talk a little about the russian passport, which turned out to be metropolitan onuphrius of the moscow patriarchate in ukraine, as well as many leaders of this church, girls. i would like all of us to watch one video today, when epiphanius enters the temple of the kiev-pechersk lavra on the occasion of the fact that palm sunday was christmas this year . saying the question, today i congratulated all the christian brothers of the western rite of the western tradition with the easter holidays and with the resurrection of christ so we see so here you are looking at the name of palm sunday yes so let's take a look a little

of this video, and then we will talk about it and everything that happens around the uoc mp what happened this week around its priests from our next guests well, don't come closer, they are controlling at this time somewhere is biting elbows or legs who is wearing a bracelet, vladyka pavel, then which one pasha mercedes must be watching this video, how is epiphanius lyudmila filippovich walking, epiphany lyudmila filippovich , of course, it is strange for philosophers to measure, so to speak , the church by the length of the beard, but i like

that epiphanius has the longest beard among his color, you know it somehow correctly but in a different way that's less less less, well, forever, some, some, i don't know where they got their beards from, you know, it's just funny , ludmila filippovich philosophy of religion, you know , doctor of philosophy, let's get in touch , ms. ludmila, we congratulate you good afternoon, ms. ludmila, actually we have such a wonderful holiday and we have well, i would say two holidays in one, firstly, palm sunday and secondly, that in the kiev-pechersk lavra, representatives of the orthodox church of ukraine, the local orthodox church, uh, um, the service of god for us is a holiday, of course, but but for supporters of the uoc mp, it is a great tragedy, this was the only church, and it is not that they took away the last of them, many churches in kyiv. i recently looked at the map, and the vast majority

do not even have documents for the right to own those or other plots on which they arbitrarily erected these temples, then we have a lot of work waiting for them, with the fact that you will bring the temple, the earth, into compliance with the state authorities , so that it is not taken away, because everything must be according to the law . well, it is clear that the upper laurel will be lost. and now , slowly, the lower laurel is colossal losses and i think that they are being realized, but you know there are processes that cannot be reversed , which will continue anyway, so our task now is for the lavra to continue to fulfill its main function of being the center of spiritual growth of the spiritual life of the ukrainian people , and the fact that this will happen already in novy within the framework of a new church, well, this happened in

history when one was replaced by another , uh, you know, god doesn’t care. in the grand scheme of things, in what form does it happen, he wants people to praise him, to turn to him? well it is desirable for the people of god that it should be in their native language, although god hears, you understand that he hears the language of the heart, the language of the soul, so let's see how events will develop there, but let it not only on holidays, but let the laurel be filled with faithful believers on ordinary days who understand the historical significance of this monument and that we convey this feeling to our children in one word long live the kyiv-pechersk lavra, someone very aptly remarked that vladyka pavlo or pavel

is correct, for sure pavel, he is pyotr peter the swan and he already managed to curse everyone who wore that bracelet to him and so on and the like, but despite all this he never once cursed or did not condemn in any way , for example, the russian army and so on, the invasion of the invaders, what is there really, too such an interesting moment, but it is also about whether these are people who have been found to have russian citizenship, how should we treat this , that metropolitan onufriy lied from the very beginning, how does it turn out that he does not have citizenship, then when it became clear that citizenship, he began to justify himself with some strange excuses, saying that he was automatically given a passport in 1991 , he did not even notice that he has it. for example, this is an obvious lie, because we understand that it is impossible, but he could not have it, for example, a soviet passport in a strange way

to turn into a citizen's passport plot with two murlom well, simply, well, this is an obvious lie, or is it? well, it should have some consequences not only there before god, well, like that or well, but also in some specific dimension to the legal self i would say, you know. today i looked at the year of birth of the head of the church, if i'm not mistaken, he was born in the 44th year, that is, next year he will be 80 years old. well , his growth and his formation as a person and as a churchman, as a theologian , it happened you understand, in soviet times, and since in ukraine, by the way, he said about this that there were not enough places to study and so on. and so on. in fact, in ukraine at that time there was only one odessa seminary, and the point is not that it was there did not take a the fact is that everyone still wanted to study

in moscow in the center of orthodoxy at that time , and moscow and the russian orthodox church were perceived as the center of the spiritual life of all this post-soviet suffering , so we understand that it is a product of upbringing, products of education, a product of education, a product of communication of that particular moscow tradition. well, 30 years of seeing was not enough for a person, but in fact, since 2014, he has been leading the church in order to change this internal matrix that was laid for him, and that is not only his problem. i think that this is the problem of many ukrainians who still perceive themselves as soviet people, and even he, yes, the loss

of loved ones, the loss of their home, not all . for those apartment bills with cheap gas and electricity. i'm not talking about sausage, these are very complicated processes . well, one could expect such leaders of public opinion, and here of church opinion. what is metropolitan onufriy, but you know, any church is still ki people mainly zhdenufria, you know, i’m not even convinced that he personally went to some diplomatic offices and issued these documents for himself. well, his friends probably did it for him, you know, as a gift for some birthday. is

it possible for him on some church holiday before that, he is very far from these things and and maybe even five passports. well, it is very profitable to tolerate one of them in the queues at the time when he was a member of the holy synod of the russian orthodox church, you know, you come, once you pull out your passport, they start the as as your own well, you enjoy completely different rights on the territory of this state, first of all, ukraine must figure out to grant, recognize, double do not recognize, do you think that only now did it become known that onufriy and that 20 high-ranking officials, as we say, in this church structure, had russian

passports? i think that our sbushniks definitely knew about it, but you see, they were silent until now because the church was in a special status , it was already repeated many times, you know, she was such a favorite child of the government of ukraine and they never touched her i used the rights of such privileged couples with abrupt rights, do you want to build a church on your land free of charge, do you want one hectare on your land, 20 hectares and so on, it is up to a democratic country to imagine such preferences in relation to some churches, it is very difficult. i still stand by the principles if it is written in our constitution, in our law, on the principles of equality of all citizens of all religious organizations

. to our orthodox catholics and some protestants, we remember all this, but you know it does not give you any special privileges in