[000:00:00;00] it's all a good discussion, it's the parliament, it's correct, please, the next amendment is the ninth dear mr. chairman, you haven't convinced me. and this is the text in our draft laws that you don't bring to the hall, that's why i'm sorry, we support our initiatives here and with regard to ms. roksolana, well, no, no however, it is only the work of the committee members . you determine the distribution of these funds and in the previous amendment there is a new fund , i generally understand according to the previous amendment that these initiatives under dso-2 should be spent decentralized and in the regions where this tax is paid .

in general, we could not understand the content of the ninth amendment, that even there you proposed ruslan andriivna, please explain so that everyone understands, we have a so-called aviation fund in the state budget, which is financed from the state aviation service, you know that it used to be the revenue of a special fund and it was financed from fees paid by every plane that flew through the territory of ukraine, every civil plane, unfortunately, now there is no passenger air service and the state aviation service is deprived of this funding, we allocated about 50 million uah in this year in support of their activities, but this unfortunately , it is not enough because the employees of the air service are very highly qualified specialists

eurocontrol international organization offered to support the state aviation service of ukraine and the employees of this service with irrevocable aid, we prescribe the norm that it is possible to temporarily finance the state aviation service from the eurocontrol grant dear colleagues, the ninth amendment authored by kisyl , a people's deputy, it is partially taken into account by the committee, at the same time, not on petrovna yuzhanina asks that such a decision of the committee be confirmed and hall, therefore, i put the ninth amendment of yury hryhorovych kisil, which is partially taken into account in the editorial, which is taken into account in part, for confirmation, i ask the people's deputies

vote for the 295th amendment, confirmed by the hall in the editorial office, which is partially taken into account. proposed in the version of the draft law for the first reading, please comment on the 12th amendment and confirm it , the position of the committee, please roksolana dear colleagues, i would like to please note that this is an amendment submitted by deputies from all factions and the first author is the author from the homeland of mr. ivanychi korolko. and this amendment says that the remainder of the 2021 subvention of all subventions that were provided to local bodies by the self-government of the local self-government can be used in 2023. likewise

as in 2022 it was for measures to ensure territorial defense and or evacuation of the civilian population. i see no problem in supporting this amendment. i think that it will even be correct and will create additional funds for local self-government bodies that they can use for defense. thank you, dear colleagues. the 12th amendment is the authorship of krulka and other people's deputies . it is partially taken into account. the southern woman asks to put such a decision of the committee as confirmation, so i put the 12:00 amendment , which is partially taken into account in the editorial board as it is taken into account by the committee for confirmation

, please vote 296 for the decision made thank you, please, next amendment 13, mrs. roksolana, all these articles that you are now explaining, if it is good, are direct by violating article 116 of the regulation, this is a law, you are violating one law and motivating it with some kind of positive. you cannot act like this, i am trying to tell you about it. and you are repeating the same thing again. the 13th amendment concerns what i would like to draw attention to here. it seems to me that here the conclusion of one committee was not enough. because here we are talking about directing local borrowing from international financial organizations to current expenditures of local budgets. who worked and studied these

contracts. who knows what the conditions are and whether they are there as a guarantor of some obligations, our state is asking please comment on this item why did you include it if it seems to me in the first reading that we have some basic articles on the use of them internationally , please, the position of the committee, the deputies supported the amendment on the return of surcharges to the military which was also submitted in violation of article 116 of the regulations, let's not change the essence of the form, thank you dear colleagues, i apologize for the 13th amendment of the people's deputy of kiselev, it is taken into account editorially , the southern woman asks for such a decision regarding taking into account the editorial for confirmation in the hall, i put the 13th amendment in the editorial office, which was taken into account by the editorial committee for

confirmation, i ask you to vote for 294, the following decisions were made. in every project of the law, contrary to article 116, you submit 99% of the content of the amendment law, you opened it because you used it yesterday. and a couple of violations of 116 voted to return

30,000, which means that it is your fault, you are responsible for this guilty and we will now also submit amendments to the violation of 116. i'm sorry, you are now generally criminally responsible for many very things and someday you will be responsible for it. so how is it, how is it playing with the rules nina petrovna let's put 72 , then let's put it yes, if 17 is not put 72 and it's final, don't look , you can't just talk for a minute and not come to a decision, that's why i put 72 dear colleagues you gave me the list you gave me the list dear colleagues, i am going according to list 72 authorship of zarembsky, it is taken into account nina petrivna, according to the previous letter to me, i am asking to put her such a decision for confirmation, i am putting the 72nd final amendment, i am asking to vote, after

that, we move on to voting for the law as a whole, i ask you to vote dear colleagues, for 301, the decision has been taken, we are moving on to the adoption of the law as a whole with the necessary technical legal amendments, the draft law on amendments to chapter six of the final and transitional provisions of the budget code of ukraine on the use of funds from accounts for the support of ukraine , registration number 8433, i ask the people

's deputies to vote in favor of 299 decisions. the law was adopted as a whole. thank you, colleagues. thank you, roksolana andriivna. thank you, dear colleagues. the next draft law we have is a draft law on amendments to some legislative acts of ukraine regarding the improvement of the procedure for withdrawing the bank from the market in the conditions of martial law 9107 and 9107 with the icon one as an alternative, i put the proposal to include these draft laws in the agenda of the session of the people 's deputies to vote dear colleagues , please vote. this is your main job, please vote for 271 decisions have been made. thank you , colleagues, i put the proposal to consider this issue for by abbreviated procedure, i ask

the people's deputies to vote for 258 , the decision has been made, please danylo oleksandrovych hetmantsev he and from the authors from the committee four minutes and then two for two against and please vote for the new ones oleksandr thank you dear colleagues, some of those present in the hall today did not support the inclusion of this draft law on the agenda, and it is a pity because it is a very important draft law . have signs of insolvency, today the situation has changed somewhat and the legislation again needs to be clarified, the fact is that in accordance with the memorandum with the international monetary fund

, the national bank will conduct a complex assessment of the quality of banks' assets and analysis of their solvency, taking into account the potential impact of military actions on the capital of banks, and accordingly, decisions will be made based on the results of such a procedure to ensure the restoration of the capital of banks , however, if the owner of this bank is on the sub-sanctions list, that is, sanctions are applied to him, then in accordance with the capitalization will be impossible, and even negotiations with such a person will be sufficiently complicated, therefore the sanctioned persons will be removed from the specified process and this will lead to to the loss of depositors' trust in such banks to the deterioration of the quality of credit partners and to the gradual deterioration of the quality of bank management, which in the case of systemic banks can have catastrophic consequences for the e-e

market as a whole for our depositors. and we must understand and remember that we regulate banking relations , first of all, in the interests of depositors , first of all, in the interests of our fellow citizens, in view of the above, relevant changes to banking legislation were developed and the committee recommends adopting the corresponding draft law, which was not in the working groups before that, and this is how the draft law with the icon one alternative appeared, so adopt this alternative draft law as a basis and in general, and in this way ensure the stability of the banking system and ensure the interests of depositors. and the most important thing is to make a decision for the benefit of the people of ukraine and not for the benefit of the sanctioned persons to whom sanctions are applied in accordance with the current

legislation, please support thank you to oleksandrovych dear colleagues, just write 22 against and discuss this draft law, please andrii mykhailovych gerus faction of the political party, servant of the people thank you, we heard a speech by oleksandrovich, who explained the importance of this draft law, therefore i call on everyone to support the vote for the relevant draft law, thank you, thank you , please, yaroslav romanovych yurchyshyn, faction of the political party, please cast your vote a word to halyna vasylchenko, please vasylchenko halyna halyna vasylchenko faction goal dear

colleagues, of course we will support this draft law, it is important and has definitely been for a long time times, i would say even reviewed, but please tell me why the cabinet of ministers was so actively convincing us a few months ago that it is simply necessary to immediately adopt a similar bill which was never signed and which never came into force, uh, just waste, waste of money time, i want to appeal to the subjects of the legislative initiative to take a responsible approach when preparing such important bills, so that we are not forced to rewrite everything again after a few weeks or months and again alone and oh

of the same subject of giving draft laws to be resubmitted thank you ivanovych fraction group form for life and peace thank you dear mr. chairman i think that this question does not need any additional discussion it is absolutely clear we understand in what period of time we adopt this draft law can be disputed what happened to the previous ones bills, but a decision must be made . now we will support this bill . thank you for your attention. janini yujanina dear colleagues, first of all, this draft law required a broad discussion of professional opinion, because with such minor actions it is possible to break the financial system 's stability and return it to the state

it was in before the 14th year, and then start again to clean this entire banking system like this i want to tell you that this draft law does not apply to the previous one, because it is about the withdrawal from the market of system banks that are solvent, this is the analysis and deprivation of the license of any ukrainian bank, if in relation to its owner, who has a significant stake, a decision of the national security and defense council will be made to impose sanctions on a citizen of ukraine, for which it has not been proven that his actions related to ties with the russian federation or the financing of terrorism there, we can see now . how many such decisions are made? that is, we asked at all working groups at the meetings of the committee that this law should specify that if there is a court decision regarding such natural persons that has already entered into

force that the person is related to such individuals actions, it seems to me that the commitments undertaken as part of the agreement with the imf regarding the assessment of the stability of 30 banks, which will begin immediately after the adoption of this draft law, will really lead to the fact that we will have fluctuations in the banking sector again. we cannot e to support this draft law. and we ask to hold mandatory meetings with the heads of the national bank before the second reading in order to clearly understand which documents will be the basis for their decision-making, whom they already plan to deprive of their licenses, and how will be reflected on the citizens of ukraine on their deposits in the banks of ukraine. thank you, dear colleagues, we have finished discussing this

issue. i ask you to take your seats . we are going to vote. i ask the people's

deputies to vote on amendments to some legislative acts of ukraine regarding the improvement of the procedure for withdrawing a bank from the market under martial law registration number 91-07-1 for 274 decisions have been made dear colleagues in general by factions show whether in general and european solidarity against so good thank you and motherland yes i don't put it well then thank you but we have to fix it for the record dear colleagues let's move on to the next bill 8205 this is the second reading dear colleagues here we have a little i guess we will have to sit through the amendments , but let's say so, the homelands will have amendments, yes , let's go, then, what will we go into one by one, because i don't have a list of your amendments. razumkov does not insist on the second amendment gerasimov does not insist on the third gerasima does not insist on the fourth and it is taken into account

the fifth dubinsky does not insist on the seventh tymoshenko yulia volodymyrivna you insist not there but tymoshenko and tsymbalyuk please tsymbalyuk seventh amendment mykhailo tsymbalyuk homeland dear sir preside over colleagues actually we e- i am grateful to the committee for taking into account several of our important amendments, but a number of our important proposals remained unadopted . first, amendment number seven says that we we propose to change the name of the e-e edition. and we propose that in the procedure for the liquidation of the enterprise, instead, the termination of the enterprise involves its reorganization , i.e., merger, accession, division and transformation

, this is article 104, which is discussed in the draft only in the fourth and 16th paragraphs, therefore, we still propose to clarify the name according to our editorial, please set the exercise dear colleagues, the seventh amendment authored by tymoshenko and tsymbalyuk was rejected by the committee, please determine to vote for 108, the decision was not made, yes, the ninth settlement does not insist 12th dubinsky does not insist 13th tymoshenko or tsymbalyuk who tsymbalyuk please mykhailo tsymbalyuk homeland dear colleagues, the issue of creating activities, reorganization, transformation and liquidation of state-owned enterprises into joint-stock and joint-stock companies

with a state share of more than 50% is already determined by the economic code of ukraine and the civil code of ukraine by the code of ukraine on bankruptcy procedures, as well as the law of ukraine on the management of state-owned objects and the law of ukraine on joint-stock companies the liquidation procedure, the order and election and powers of the liquidator, the concepts proposed by the draft law are not consistent with the above-mentioned existing legislation of ukraine, in addition to the creation of a special trust fund and the financing of the termination and bankruptcy procedure, the payment of compensation to the liquidator is also not provided for by the specified codes and laws of ukraine, our correction is precisely dear colleagues 13 th amendment of tymoshenko tsymbalyuk, it was rejected by the cabinet, please

determine to stand for 85, the decision was not made, please 14 raschikovu does not insist 15 mashinets insists 16 gerasi they insist 17th generation they insist 19th dubinsky does not insist 22nd poziychuk does not insist that we have not yet reached your amendments iryna volodymyrivna everything in life begins with you, dear colleagues 22 poziychuk no insists for the 23rd time he does not insist and we insist i apologize on the 22nd poziychuk please and then it will be the 30th on which you have introduced me now thank you dear chairman dear colleagues andrii pozychuk faction of the homeland dear

colleagues let's talk about this the bill, however, the bill actually wants to create a scheme for withdrawing state property from state enterprises through bankruptcy during the war - this is a continuation of the schemes, and yesterday we considered a bill that planned to transfer enterprises of the agricultural sector from the management of the academy of agrarian sciences to the state property fund, and today it turns out that the enterprise which are in the sphere of management of the state property fund are in fact mr. krutami 's fund to bring the enterprise to bankruptcy and to date, i have a question for representative of the committee, mr. movchan, tell me how many such enterprises are planning to close the state-owned fund through bankruptcy. dear colleagues, 22 amendment of the loan by the auto

-rejection committee, i ask you to suffice and vote for 70 the decision was not made 23 geras they insist 25 burmich does not insist 26 tsimbalyuk tsimbalyuk tymoshenko please 26 thank you mykhailo tsymbalyuk homeland dear colleagues i continue to list the shortcomings of this draft law that we wanted to correct by introducing our professional rules proposed the provision of the draft law on the transfer of funds received from the sale of property of state enterprises to the specialized trust fund contradicts our

provisions of the budget code of ukraine, the content of the draft law and the explanatory note to it indicate that the key issue that needs to be resolved only in the procedure for the termination of economic entities of the state sector of the economy is attention to the financing of costs in the procedure for the termination of state-owned enterprises and economic companies in the authorized capital of which more than 50% of the shares belong to the state think about how the authors set the main task. dear colleagues, amendment number 26, authored by tymoshenko tsimbalyuk, was rejected by the committee. i ask the representative to vote for 70. the decision was not made. the next

28 insists on 31 gerasimum and 30 armies in novona . it is taken into account editorially. you insist that it is completely yes, please. taking into account this amendment in general, we now have to look at the ideology of this draft law, and the ideology of this draft law actually consists in the fact that you propose the liquidation of state-owned enterprises at least as it is written, but what is written today in this draft law is that it is terminated by the decision of the owner , etc. and throughout the text, this will mean that it will be non-liquidation, and according to the civil code, it can also be a merger , accession, division, transformation, and so on and so on that's where the greatest danger lies i'm running out of time now i'm just a-a

i want to explain why in my next amendments but it's an essential point and if we don't do it now we're opening pandora's box to actually rip apart state property dear colleagues, the 30th amendment the 30th amendment is taken into account editorially, uh, its author, people's deputy aryu, asks to take it into account in full, so i ask you to be determined , vote for 67, the decision has not been made, let's move on to the next amendment yes 36 tymoshenko tsymbalyuk tsymbalyuk please mykhailo tsymbalyuk homeland continuing our proposals to this

draft law, i would like to emphasize on the following a-a the existence of a moratorium on the use of forced sale of the property of state enterprises and business associations in authorized capital of which the state's share