eh, the police, eh, because it significantly forces a circle of people and does not correspond to the meaning of this bill, eh, the european faction will abstain from voting on this bill in the first reading. and if this remark will be corrected before the second reading, then we will support it. thank you thank you for your attention, please serhiy mykolayovych yevtushok, the faction of the fatherland, passing the word to mykhailo mykhailovych tsymbalyuk, please , mykhaylenko mykhailo tsymbalyuk, the fatherland dear mr. chairman of the presidium, dear people's deputies, in principle, this is an initiative the ministry of internal affairs is correct and we really need to align the terminology and the understanding itself, and in fact when we talk about the narrowing of the very concept

of material responsibility of officials of the national police instead of representatives of the ministry of internal affairs, we must understand that material responsibility for inflicting damage to the state already applies to representatives of the national guard and the state emergency service, we are talking about what needs to be brought into line with the norms the law referred to by the ministry of internal affairs as a purely technical law. and those inaccuracies that were also discovered by our scientific expert administration. i am sure that we can add to the second reading, but taking into account the fact that today the national police performs and its functions are not inherent to this, we know that the creation of offensive brigades should support such an initiative of the ministry

of internal affairs , in fact today policemen are not only law enforcement officers , they are today part of the defense forces and in the near future and the offensive forces and honor and glory to those who are today bringing our great victory closer with their actions. i ask you to support this legislative initiative and the motherland will vote for it in the first reading . thank you , thank you , please. volodymyrovych thank you, mr. chairman dear colleagues the parliamentary group of trust believes that this draft law is sufficiently clear, let's say, this initiative of the cabinet of ministers is about the fact that everyone should be equal before the law and

everyone should be responsible for their actions , including for the material damage that they may cause as a result of such actions. yes, there are separate issues related to, as colleagues said, the narrowing of the categories that can fall under the influence of the draft law. it seems to me that we can work to settle certain issues in the village, we consider the first reading. it is necessary to support, thank you, thank you. dear colleagues, we are concluding the discussion of this issue. please prepare for the vote. i propose to adopt the draft law as a basis on the introduction of amendments to the law of ukraine on the financial responsibility of military personnel and persons equated to them for damage caused to the state in relation to the financial responsibility of policemen , the registration number

of the draft law is 8213. i am ready to vote. i ask the people's deputies to vote for 249. the decision has been made. thank you, colleagues. if there are still amendments, we will skip it and move on, no no, the next draft law is 91 56

please leave the procedure. dear members, dear colleagues. it is on the agenda, so if we move it somewhere, we must put this question to a vote of the hall and decide on it. no, i haven't finished it. and this is an important bill. and there are correct things in this law, so if the hall is determined, we will certainly be able to move it. please put it on the question for voting . if this draft law will be followed , see dear colleagues, let's not lead. okay, thank you, let's do the next one. 91:56, this is a draft law on making changes to some laws of ukraine on ensuring the inviolability of property rights, i put a proposal e-e 91-56 91 56-191 56d e -e i put a proposal to include these draft laws in the agenda of the session

, please. dear colleagues, for 267 decisions have been adopted. with a report with a report, yes, okay, let's go, then friz will report right away. yes, and there is the first

deputy minister of justice, yevhen mykolayovych horovets, please report and after that, the chairman of the friz committee and then 22 against draft law 91 56 developed by the cabinet of ministers to implement the decision of the constitutional court in the case of no violation of property rights, i will not take up all the time to talk about its advantages, because the main committee, the committee on legal policy, decided to support e-e committee bill 91:56d which takes into account the relevant comments we support this decision of the committee and ask to approve it immediately as a basis and as a whole and accordingly to reject our government draft law why it is important to adopt it immediately as a whole because on may 16, in compliance with the decision of the constitutional court, the ministry of justice will not have the opportunity to cancel the decision of state registrars this causes certain risks for the stability of the registration system , thank you for your attention

. pavlovich, please, as a committee, give four minutes, thank you. i will not take up four minutes of your time , i have already understood that i have already bored you so much today with my bills, but uh, colleagues, what is this bill for, so that you understand and support it as much as possible as you know, we have a law on the state registration of property rights to immovable property , which regulates all issues related to real estate registration, appeals against the actions of the registrar, the inaction of the registrars, that is, a set of laws related to registration real estate and another law that regulates issues related to the business registration of legal entities and everything related to this, in november 22, the constitutional court will consider the constitutional complaint and determined that

the provisions of article 37 of this law on state registration of real estate are unconstitutional in terms of appeals on stupid issues of e-e decisions made by the ministry of justice and canceling the state registration of real property rights and obliged you and me, the verkhovna rada, to adopt the relevant changes to this law, which would be constitutional as the first deputy minister will say, they submitted their draft law as a cabinet of ministers which, in their opinion, regulated the specified issue, there was an alternative opinion, the author of which is me, er, which regulates the issue of removing the administrative order in general and submitting it to the court for consideration, so that the specified decision is made on behalf of ukraine and they did not have any questions regarding the administrative procedure, but realizing that now during the war it is difficult to do this because, firstly , the courts are not ready, and secondly, we are introducing a completely new scheme, a new procedure and a new

process. i also agreed with the fact that we need to draft the committee bill that is being presented to you today. we from the legal policy department, together with the ministry of justice, the chief scientific experts of the verkhovna rada's advisory service, and the office of the ombudsman , found a structure that, in our opinion, opinion corresponds to the constitution, which, in our opinion , allows to continue the work of the anti-raider commission to ensure the rights of citizens and the security of their property from may 15. therefore, we need to support this draft law basis and in general and with your permission i, as a representative of the committee, note down the committee's decision to recommend to the verkhovna rada of ukraine that the draft law on amendments to certain laws of ukraine on ensuring the inviolability of property rights, prepared by people's deputies of ukraine by members of the committee based on the results of consideration in the first reading , be accepted as a basis and as a whole, as well as in the case

of its adoption as a law, instruct the committee together with the main legal department of the verkhovna rada of ukraine to carry out editorial and technical legal revision his file. in this regard, draft laws according to the register number 91-56 and 91:56 should be rejected and colleagues. i am sure that the state registration and appeal procedure that we proposed in the alternative draft law will find its solution through the courts, we will find an opportunity to freely recognize rights and freely to make decisions regarding the cancellation of these rights through a single judicial branch of government through ukraine and thereby additionally adding credibility to their work, thank you, thank you, igor pavlovych dear colleagues, please, let's sign up for two

two are against and we are creating a bill for this bill, please iron like yaroslav ivanovych faction vote colleagues let 's vote on all the freest laws as soon as possible because a person will not calm down until they have been voted on the bill we will support it please zadorozhny mykola mykolayovych faction of the political party, servant of the people, please give the floor to denys maslov please, unit vyacheslav thank you, colleagues, the activity of the anti-raider board is quite effective, we are now observing the growth of complaints, the possibility of raider captures if we do not we will vote on may 15 and the activity will simply stop and we will have inevitable

consequences, therefore i ask everyone to support this bill and vote , thank you, please, i give the floor to people 's deputy volodymyr viktorovych kabachenko , faction of the political party, all-ukrainian association, fatherland, god vlasenko, serhii volodymyrovych, please dear colleagues, in fact let's be honest, what is the purpose of this bill, the purpose of this bill is to close the hole that appears after may 15 in the work of the so-called anti-raider commission of the ministry of justice of ukraine. i remember how this anti -raider commission of the ministry of justice was created and everyone said then that this is a temporary phenomenon, that it is really necessary to transfer these powers to the judicial authorities, not to take away part of these powers and so on and so on and let the courts

regulate everything the question is, this commission has been working for several years and as they say, you know, there is nothing more permanent than something temporary, and the problem is actually not in this law. resolve their issues, but the problem is that, as of today, we have not received a complete comprehensive judicial reform. i want to remind you that thanks to the majority of the verkhovna rada of ukraine , the higher qualification commission of judges has not worked for three years , and the verkhovna rada has not worked for almost three years justice and this led to the absolute outflow of the judicial corps, according to the data of the state judicial administration, of the seven thousand necessary judges, we currently have about three thousand vacancies, and of course that

then some temporary artificial mechanisms are pushed in to solve certain state issues and state problems. but if we are a real state, we must do everything to ensure that these functions are transferred to the judicial authorities as soon as possible, not a year after the war, and the courts, as in any to another state , commercial disputes were resolved quickly, qualitatively and professionally, including those with signs of raiding . colleagues, in fact, our lawyers also say that even after such a long period of work of the temporary anti-raider commission, it would be necessary to make basic changes to the legislation so that this

temporary phenomenon, which i thought we had already overcome , turns out that the commission continues to work , it turns out that even now often, registrars allow such arbitrariness as raiding, so in fact, in order not to stop the work of the commission, it is necessary to extend its period of validity, but by the way, the draft law also includes other changes that have already relate to new challenges and new realities that exist today, this is the application of sanctions in accordance with the law on sanctions, the presence of this fact should make it impossible to carry out state registration of rights and it should be checked by state registrars, so it seems to me that we will now support the adoption of this draft law, but as our lawyers need to work on basic changes in order to, as the previous

speaker said, still lead to legal proceedings from e-e regarding this issue , because otherwise this commission of ours which is also not ideal, about which we have already been taught a lot, so that after all it is not the only one over the judicial body that resolves controversial issues . thank you, dear colleagues. the proposal to adopt as a basis the draft law on amendments to certain laws of ukraine on ensuring the inviolability of property rights , registration number 91 56-9 ready to vote , i ask people's deputies to vote for

279 decision adopted we agreed on the basis as a whole therefore i put in general i put the proposal to accept in general with the necessary technical legal amendments the draft law on amending some laws of ukraine on ensuring the inviolability of property rights registration number 91 56-9 ready to vote i ask the people's deputies vote for 280 decision made dear colleagues

, one second please motovylovets friends i ask to change the order of consideration of bills and only from the agenda bill 61-34 thank you put this question to a vote. thank you. dear colleagues, we really did not agree with the conciliation council by 61-34 and in order to remove it from the agenda. we must

vote . registration number 61 34 of today's agenda to be removed please vote thank you the decision has been made from the procedure please artur volodymyrovych i have only one request to all proposals voiced followed a single standard. this is the only such request, because really well, i believe that in this hall there should be one approach to each child, unlike the others. you were at the conciliation council today . i prefer the previous bill,

you and i are all together unanimously agreed on such a decision that if we have an issue raised, we will remove it from the agenda without discussion, it was a decision of the agreed council. i want to remind everyone about this regarding this bill. we did not have such a decision that's why this question was put to a vote in the hall. it's just so that everyone understands. please , dmytro oleksandrovich razumkov, also understand the procedures, please, dear ruslan oleksiyovych, if possible. i would like to address you as the chairman of the verkhovna rada, according to which article of the regulations is the concept of agreement at the conciliation council if it is possible to give such information, if not , then put the previous bill to the vote, as well as this one, it will be in accordance with the regulations, if everything is determined fairly, you can remove it if not, this means which article of the regulation allows the chairman of the verkhovna rada to independently change the order of consideration of issues at the plenary session

. thank you, i do not know, maybe because you are sitting far away , i answered this question before this, it is not my decision, it is the decision of the conciliation council and it reacts. the same article of the regulation that governs the agenda of the conciliation board is formed. i think you are a professional , a professional person, you can easily find that article for her. please, let's move on. dear colleagues, the next draft law is 64-75 64 75-1 64-75-2 64 75 d is a draft law on the promotion of assisted reproductive technologies and surrogate motherhood, i propose to consider these bills in a shortened procedure, i ask to vote for 216, the decision has been made dear colleagues with speakers, or at once two for two against two

for two against please then as speakers well, they want speakers, please, then i invite the first deputy minister of health of ukraine serhiy oleksandrovych dubrov , please, according to the first draft bill, the following will be given . this will be followed by wagner, and after that, two for two against, please, honorable chairman, honorable people's deputies, the draft law on assistive reproductive technologies and maternity replacement is a comprehensive draft law that takes into account both the realities of wartime and the post-war reconstruction of ukraine . which is extremely important , which clearly delimits the rights and responsibilities of the stakeholders in the process, regulates the issue of the nation of reproductive cells, establishes

to postulate the recognition of the export of reproductive cells to and from the territory of ukraine, thereby making trade in reproductive cells impossible the country has long needed this law the ministry of health supports the draft law 6475 revised thank you please i invite the people's deputy of ukraine danutso oleksandr anatoliyovych the author of the alternative bill please thank you as soon as possible the scandalous draft law 6475 d of course er please do not support it under any circumstances today er the attention of the world media is focused on this of the bill, including cnn is preparing a large material, bvc contacted me tomorrow, we were contacted by the times and such other questions about the bill, the question is that i have never seen how the bill could go like this in violation of the regulations, which i pointed out, he

was filmed again was submitted to this bill, there is no european integration expertise, which is about its european integration we were initially told that this bill does not have the conclusions of the ministry of social policy or any other committee relevant to this bill in addition to the two committees, the first is the national health committee and the second is the corruption committee, which directly indicates that this draft law does not meet the requirements of anti-corruption legislation, plus this draft law says that today we are depriving the right to a certain part of auxiliary reproductive technologies, heterosexual couples, and we allow it. we leave this right to homos for homosexual couples. we open the market of fictitious marriages and many other things. i have nothing against the lgbt community, but that this is not a matter of orientations, it is

the issue of huge money, therefore, the project 6475 d cannot be voted under any circumstances, thank you, please, i give the floor to the member of the committee on the health of the nation, medical care and health insurance, wagner viktoria oleksandrivni, please viktoria oleksandrivna four minutes ago, you are the authors of the committee dear dear colleagues , the draft law registration number 6475 d on the use of assisted reproductive technologies and replacement of maternity has been finalized in the committee on health of the nation in accordance with the requirements of part two article 110 of the regulations of the verkhovna rada of ukraine, taking into account the constructive provisions of alternative draft laws, the draft law was developed in view of the constant increase

in the use of ivf methods in the world, in particular in ukraine, as an effective tool for the treatment of infertility in the absence of national legislative regulation, it provides for the creation of a separate first law that will regulate the legal basis of application in ukraine drt and provision of services and surrogate motherhood with subsequent amendments to the criminal code regarding responsibility in the event of its violation, unlike alternative drafts, the pre-draft project takes into account the requirements of international law in the field of protection of human reproductive rights and also protects the rights and legal interests of a child born as a result of the use of surrogate motherhood services, in particular , appropriate safeguards are prescribed to prevent the abandonment of the child and the risks of child trafficking which concern precisely these e-e

moments of the adoption of this draft law is also necessary for the restoration of the demographic potential of ukraine, which is in the background war is steadily decreasing, despite the fact that in the 21st year we already had one of the lowest birth rates in the world , this is one and one-tenth of a child per woman in the 21st year. a catastrophic drop in the birth rate is predicted optimistically at the level of 08, while for recovery generations in ukraine, no woman should have at least three children, think about it, it should also be taken into account that a significant number of women with children went abroad due to the war and the prospects of their return due to hostilities are constantly is decreasing, and most importantly, the brutal war continues, which daily takes the majority of people who are people of reproductive age, and the reproductive

potential of the state is a factor of the national security of ukraine no less important than that of the crow of the country in connection with that during the period of martial law until within three years after its termination the final provisions prohibit foreigners and/or stateless persons from using the surrogacy service in ukraine, and also prohibit the export of reproductive cells and embryos outside the customs territory of ukraine with institutions of health care for this period, the bill was supported by the ministry of health of ukraine, the national service and health of ukraine, the office authorized by the verkhovna rada of ukraine on human rights, comments on the proposal from the deo, from the committees, from colleagues, we will work it out until the second reading, the committee considered the bill at its meeting on april 7, 2013, i recommend that the verkhovna rada of ukraine adopt the revised draft of the law of ukraine on the use of assisted reproductive technologies and

surrogate motherhood, registration number 6475d based on the results of consideration in the first reading as a basis, taking into account the requirements of the first part of article 116 of the regulations of the verkhovna rada of ukraine regarding the need to introduce changes to other legislative acts that were not considered in the first reading, please support the proposal of the committee and thank you for your attention. thank you , dear colleagues, we have passed the first stage reports on draft laws, now let's move on to the discussion, i'm asking my colleagues to sign up 22 against i'm asking the representatives of the faction of the groups to sign up , please stepan ivanovich kubi factions european solidarity