[000:00:00;00] and try to do it at home and that's why they will destroy it in this way. there's still 40% on top of that actually. well , there will be a lot of us. i hate a lot of pictures. always at this time we talk about money about finances about the economy andriyanytskyi on with everything i am familiar with only the topics of the program please announce andria thank you colleagues we will talk today about ukrainian recovery in particular about very an interesting analytical product that was presented in kyiv yesterday and will be presented in brussels today is a so-called cookbook of ukrainian recovery, which compares the process of recovery to cooking some delicious dish , economic news on the espresso tv channel, i am

the presenter andriy yanitsky, as always, with you at eight in the morning live if you watch us on youtube if this happened , be sure to like it comment send the link to your family and friends publish it in your social networks this is how more people learn about the latest economic news. since yesterday, thousands of citizens began to register online in the program . there is a recovery service. it is necessary to wait a little or to eliminate all shortcomings, the ministry of community development of the territory and infrastructure informs ukrainians can apply for action and receive funds

for repairs, the maximum amount is uah 200,000 the service is available if the housing is subject to restoration and has not been fully repaired under compensation and to allow a commission created by the local self-government bodies in order for them to record the damage . stage - it will be after may 22, when it will be possible to receive direct compensation for the destroyed housing , the sky will no longer trade with russia , chinese exports to russia in april reached from the record level of last month, it increased to 153%, i apologize for the fact that the opposite has become more trade, it is more than 9.5 billion dollars , it shows the increasingly close economic

relations of the two countries, unfortunately, against the background of western sanctions, china is increasing trade and not the other way around , as we would like it to be had not yet been recorded at the beginning of putin's full-scale invasion of ukraine, bloomberg analysts write, no more than china supplied cars and spare parts for them, in second place , electronics, third export position is occupied by industrial equipment, turkey postponed payments for russian gas, the kremlin allowed it to be done, we are talking about postponing it until 2024, paid 600 million dollars, the country is significantly dependent on foreign energy sources, and russia is the largest supplier of fuel , next week, or rather, this sunday, presidential elections will be held in turkey that us e-e elections , presidential polls show that the current

president erdoğan rj peredogan may lose the race, therefore any such concession is important for him, in particular among the reasons for his loss there may also be a sharp devaluation of the national lira currency and economic deterioration in turkey. the authorities of kazakhstan have decided to fight smuggling, in particular, they are closing the borders for suppliers of so-called parallel imports, and in fact, smuggling to russia , the commissar reports about this in local publications, so russians may later feel a shortage of equipment from such brands such as samsung bosch lg and electrolux, after strengthening the control over the transit of goods from their territory to the aggressor country, intermediaries began to look for new ways of supply, in particular

through china through kyrgyzstan through the united arab emirates such a complication of logistics can lead to an increase in the price of goods for end buyers, russians will now have to pay 10-12% more for household appliances than they pay for gas , experts say, well, now let's talk about the cookbook ukrainian recovery, about which i already spoke a little at the beginning of the program with us in connection with ihor borokovsky, head of the institute of economic research and political consultations, and oleksandra petlivska, a research associate of this of the institute. greetings, dear experts, let's start by defining the geography. who of you and where are you joining us now , mr. igor, where are you now ? i am currently in brussels. to talk about the main

achievements of our cookbook by mrs. oleksandra, i am at home in kyiv, kyiv , brussels, symbolic, today we have such a tv host, he says something about our foreign policy efforts, about our european integration, the cookbook of ukrainian recovery sounds very interesting, very clear, who invented such a format, how did such an idea come to the head of ms. oleksandr, what can you tell us about this story? and in our country, the nas institute works in a consortium of four organizations, it is also the center of economic strategy, dixie circle, and the institute of analytics and advocacy from poltava and when we talked about reconstruction and we have been talking about this for quite a long time in our concepts and we started talking about the fact that

we need to write something practical rather than general a lot of phrases that have already been written, something practical that is memorable, and they just started talking about recipes for reconstruction and so on , from here it came out with the word "ballok" and then maria rybko from the center for economic strategy and i wrote the basis for this book a cookbook, that is, the idea is that recovery in ukraine should be like a good restaurant, that is, one that you want to return to, that you want to use, and when there is a restaurant with a good, capable team, a restaurant where the recipes are clear, how long has it been like this a very visual approach and from a marketing point of view. it seems very successful to me. if it is possible to save it and bring it through the whole restoration, then we will finally be able to taste this dish, mr. igor, if you think about it in this way, that the restoration takes place according to some recipes, that it is some kind of restaurant and who else is our cook

? who is our assistant chef sushev? who works in this kitchen? well, to put it very simply , our one key principle, one of our key principles of activity, is ukrainian property, ukrainian property for reconstruction and that's why when we talk about the chef and the chef's request of course it's the ukrainian government of course it's the relevant international structures that cooperate with us directly and of course it's civil society so in this case we're talking about the fact that our kitchen is actually such a joint project and without such joint coordinated work , it is very difficult to talk about any specific results . well, there is another very important participant that we also talk about, this is the local government, whether we like it or not but it was the local government that received the most if you can say so the shock from the russian military aggression well, of course, this from the city, the city, the local government should be engaged in determining the priorities of reconstruction in

their territories. i want to call on all viewers to go to facebook page of the institute of economic research and political consultations there is a recording of yesterday 's presentation of the cookbook where it is very clearly presented in pictures how it all looks and i don't remember if there was any image of mr. shmogil in this chef's cap but in my head, it looks like this, i understand what is happening, but when preparing any dish , technological standards are very important, and it is very important that the kitchen is clean, so that the products do not spoil, alexander, who should monitor this, who should support this sanitary and hygienic control during the restoration of our such a restaurant in ukraine , and the first thing i want to say is that it is really important to define standards, our standards should

include inclusiveness and us in the green course and which is being talked about. that is, it is about sustainable restoration is what is called a build bag in english. that is, we rebuild better than it was, that is, it is not about the fact that we want to rebuild something as it was , that is, a hospital is the most effective, uh, a shack that needs to be heated, which is always cold. we want to rebuild something better, as a result, it is necessary will develop standards, partly these standards, we can really borrow from the european union, to which we are moving forward, we are really paralleling our recovery with a transparent kitchen, an open kitchen where everyone they see what is happening and we do it consciously because transparency is important today , especially for ukraine, and transparency leads to trust, and when we talk about transparency , i immediately want to emphasize the dream system. it is a system of responsible recovery. it was presented by the ministry

of recovery last friday. - and there is already a site like drym.cov.ua, it is a system of transparency on which all projects will be visible, how they are being rebuilt. that is, it is a system that follows the principle that everyone can see everything and all projects will be there, all financing is the system of which public organizations will be able to use, this is a system that can be used by donors-investors, and when we talk about public organizations, it is precisely public organizations that will be responsible for monitoring , in particular, how recovery is taking place and for control. is being rebuilt because it is being rebuilt precisely for citizens who will use the corresponding services. so, we have determined what it will be if we continue this analogy restaurant in such an open kitchen, many ukrainians in such establishments have seen that

everything is cooked in front of you and you can see what products are being thrown, what ingredients and what. oil, eh, we will be able to see all this as ordinary citizens, who and what kind of money is directed to the reconstruction, but here it is important and the recipes you mentioned what, ms. oleksandra, will be restored better than it was, but it can be done better in different ways, eh, maybe igor knows uh we have some already prescribed algorithms for restoration actions, that is why they destroyed the hospital, it will be restored according to such a project, or the destruction of the bridges will be built according to the dutch project or according to the german project, are there already any worked out routes for such restoration, well, i want to say right away that we are today in the state of precisely

determining the losses that we suffered as a result of russian aggression, therefore, by and large, this work, well, it will not speak , is at the beginning, but it continues and will still last a certain period of time, when we talk about recovery, from our point of view, it is not only our point of view , this recovery can be conventionally divided into two stages. compromises because it is already necessary to restore people's provision of e-e electricity , water supply, drainage, well, what are we with social services, and it is clear that here everything must be done very quickly in order for the economy to continue to function, that is, to invest in what is called economic sustainability well, in the medium and long term, projects will be implemented where such very high standards have already been established

. to lay down the principles not only of ecological restoration, but let's say perspective principles of the same spatial development, and it is in this sense that a great responsibility is placed on the local authorities because when we are talking about restoration, this is the restoration, first of all, of that ecosystem. if you can say that where people live, everything is done for people , everything will be done for years of people. well, of course , everything will be done in the name of people, that is , there is already a menu, but these items of this menu will be chosen it is precisely the heads of local self-government in the first place, and can citizens in some way still influence the decision of e-p. oleksandr. is there some mechanism of e-democracy that has been laid down so that such details have not yet been reached so that it is possible for the citizen to decide for himself where to direct the funds are primarily for the restoration of which element or for which

object, here are two points, the first thing we have now is a continuation of what ihor valentynovich said, uh, it is being created for the restoration agency headed by mustafa , and it is precisely the agency that is working on standardized tez restoration projects for rebuilding from scratch, let's say the fees of hospitals and e-e security institutions educational institutions e precisely because the capacity sometimes in places there is a lack in order to make such projects, these projects will already include energy efficiency, inclusiveness, and so on. this is a very important moment if we are talking about the possibility to influence e-e citizens , the bill has not yet been approved . the draft law on the fact that the guests of the state regional development fund will be developed this year according to the results of citizens' votes, that is, in action , to be honest, i do not really support this

mechanism, but it is currently proposed by the government and deputies, but there is generally a mechanism for voting on projects in the localities, e.e. , with the participation of the budget. that is, when citizens submit certain projects, they are really not very expensive, but these projects are very often . all communities must prepare such recovery plans and then money will be given for them. it is from the state budget in accordance with the determined priorities, that is, for us , citizens can and should be involved in the development of these recovery plans to do yes, i really heard criticism about this draft law that usually people

prefer to vote for some visual, beautiful things, for example , the construction of a new park or bike path . those who directly depend on this sewage system in this district, and residents of other districts do not think much about it, there is a flaw in the design of all this, i agree, but let's see what the deputies say, we already have this cookbook has been worked out and somehow we need to move from paper to concrete actions to the implementation of these rules of these recipes, mr. igor, are there any concrete steps you will present today in brussels and our donors will like everything , they will give money that what will be done next? well, what will be the first step of the restoration? well, as i

said, the restoration is already taking place because there are indeed certain objects that must be restored today and without them the economy can function, the social sphere can function on the sea is already directly there. we will just talk about the fact that we need funds both for long-term recovery and for current support for financing current projects . therefore, this process is already taking place and it is not one that should start tomorrow the day after tomorrow. well, there is one more question which we also talk about all the time and we talked about it in part to ms. oleksandr, we are talking about institutional capacity, let's be honest about the fact that today we will have to combine the development of constitutional the capacity of the government, the development of the constitutional capacity of local communities, and with the process of direct restoration. that is, it will be like, you know, as economists say, it is a matter where we learn in practical direct work. this is a very difficult situation because we can really write the best things, we can write the best plans and

so on, but then the question arises as to who will directly implement them, so we must again return to such things that we have forgotten a little, this is the reform of the state management and this is a certain help on the ground, because it is clear that the development of various kinds of plans, the development of, let's say, the same applications in order to receive money directly, is a very big job. and here it is that we offer certain tools to help local authorities do all these things and the end in the end , so as not to discredit the very idea of ​​post-war recovery. well, the last question is very short. unfortunately, oleksandr, if possible , literally in 30 seconds at the end , they bring the bill in the restaurant, how much will it cost recovery, are there already calculations? the world bank really did a calculation and today's estimate is 411 billion dollars, this is a need for recovery, this is a need not for recovery, according to this principle, we are rebuilding better, but unfortunately, this is not the final calculation, because it does not include

those territories that are still occupied today and which we we still have to release, that is, unfortunately, the account will grow, and that is why we need to rely not only on official financing, and on investments by foreign and ukrainian businesses. and for this government , it is necessary to do its homework on judicial reform, reform of law enforcement agencies and so on. thank you oleksandr batliy of the scientific cooperation institute for economic research and political consultations and ihor burakovsky, the head of this institute, were on our air . thank you, dear experts , in the morning. i don't hope so. we will also think about the restoration. we will return to this topic more than once. this is history. unfortunately , andriy yanivskyi

was with you for a long time with economic news on espresso. see you soon. tomorrow at 8 o'clock live on megogo we will win the semi-finals of the champions league together inter milan tamancity-real who will play in the decisive match find out on may 16 and 17 at 10 p.m. watch this week in the program judicial control with tatyana shustrava the war will write everything off how vrp reacted to the unreliable the declaration of the head of the economic court of the kyiv region, pavlo gorbasenko , did the national agency for the prevention of corruption receive a response, it gives carte blanche to violate the law

of unkindness, see thursday, may 11 at 4:40 p.m. the judicial control program with tetyana shustrova on the espresso tv channel, the war in ukraine is the main topic for ukrainians, victories and losses, analysis and forecasts, politics and geopolitics , serhiy rudenko and the guests of his program will talk about all this, people who have information and shape public opinion, people who defend ukraine and create the future right now the main and interesting thing in the program is the verdict by serhiy rudenko from monday to thursday at 1:00 p.m. repeat at 6:00 p.m. we continue our broadcast at 8:22 a.m. on the ihor schurinda watch khrystyna yatskiv with you today 11 may thursday, interesting information from the kursk region, this is the russian federation. roman starovoyd, his name is still russian

, the head of the governorate region, although they do not have a province, but for some reason i am the governor . roman starovoy claims that on the morning of may 10 , ukraine shelled the power plant in korshchyna early in the morning from the ukrainian side . according to the head of the region, as a result of the shelling , the power supply was partially disrupted. the day before, the same old man claimed that an unknown drone was shot down by podkutsk. well, not only in the kursk oblast, but also in the obryan oblast, the locals say that the drone fired at the military commissariat in shebek, automatic rounds were heard, they say that the drone was shot down . it could be related to the war, but there is no war, they are not fighting against ukraine. well, we already have yuriy fedorenko, company commander, sniper of the bpl

92, a separate mechanized brigade named after koshovo ataman ivan sirko, in direct contact. congratulations, sir. to yuri glory to ukraine glory to the heroes death to the enemies and how do you assess all the arrivals of unknown drones in the bryansk voronezh region of kursk, the effectiveness of the use of these uavs, it should be noted that the ukrainian side uses full armament exclusively on the territory of ukraine and on those territories of ukraine that are temporarily under occupation. the border is not conducted at the expense of unmanned aerial vehicles , accordingly, it is only necessary to note that the movement of resistance within the russian federation, as we can see , is developing stronger and stronger every day and various cities in the regions of the russian federation, there is the placement of military facilities, there is cotton, and this is a very, very good awareness that russia is committing an act

of aggression against another country, it will soon become clear to the society inside the russian federation, by the way, about one interesting incident here yesterday serhiy prytula he wrote on his page, you remember, last fall, a collection was organized for revenge , the result of which was the purchase of almost one and a half hundred kamikazes of various functions and flight ranges. i always emphasized writes prytula that if cotton appears on the territory of the country of vodka and shit, then our fund had nothing to do with it and has no relation to it on the territory of the illinsky refinery , krasnodar territory, as a result of an attack by unknown drones, several tanks with petroleum products and a processing plant were destroyed of petroleum products. of course, we traditionally have no relation to this case . for now, let's put it to someone. well, who else did i want to know about the drone that flew over moscow and

was covered over the kremlin, supposedly there were two of them explosion we saw a fire show, so the day before, there is this andriy kolesnikov, a businessman, a businessman, a journalist, he once wrote a book, i am putin's department, well, a close person, that is, a journalist of the kremlin pool, and he told yesterday that he talked to putin about this and said the following on vopros prodrom eh, on the question about the drone that flew past the dome of the kremlin a few days ago , kolesnikov said that putin told him that there is nothing special about this drone. it is made of wire and modern materials and that such home-made drones flew to the khmi-mim base in syria, and they are familiar to the russians, and what was in this drone. it seems that there was 400 g of twist, putin said to andrii kolesnikov. yuri is curious why the russians don’t show the drones on shyroky. there were two of them, one exploded, the other flew in. that is, it could

be caught somewhere and lifted from the ground, but no one saw them. these drones. how do you answer this question? let's build a conversation in a different way regarding the impression of the russian federation once again and also the kremlin directly aquafresh, which has such capabilities of unmanned aerial vehicles, which are accordingly piloted, most likely by those representatives from the middle of the russian federation who do not support the bloody regime of putin or any other persons , the ukrainian side uses all its capabilities, including long-range unmanned aerial vehicles of the shock type, exclusively on the territory of ukraine on military facilities , including those territories that are temporarily under occupation, this is a thesis that we

should all be aware of at the same time to realize, i sincerely thank everyone and everyone will support the defense force to donate on uavs because thanks to you, friends, we succeed not only effectively in combat missions, but also to additionally develop the industry of unmanned aerial systems thank you yuriy well, let's talk directly about the situation in your operational area how it is composed, let us remind you that this is the east of our country , where the occupiers are pressing actively, but allegedly not very effectively, in recent days, if we talk about the city of bakhmut itself, there is no record of any softening of the shock and assault action from the enemy but if we talk about the approaches to the city, then we can safely say that over the last three days, the defense forces not only held off the onslaught and not a single position was abandoned, but moreover , they managed to carry out a series of shock-assault operations to renew their position and push back

the enemy, which means the results, taking into account what the attack on the assault potential of the enemy is applied in the direction of bakhmut, it is also worth noting that part of the russian occupation forces is demoralized and now their leadership is trying to make a number of decisions in order to organize strike groups again and resume strike-assault operations with the onslaught that was 3-4 days ago, respectively, due to the activities of our unit , the 9:2 joint attack managed not only to destroy the occupiers, but also to capture one of them thanks to the uav , the group was destroyed by joint work with one of the five occupants fought back from the group and when he realized that death was certain to him, he threw his weapon to the side, raised his hands up and asked for farewell , after which it was decided to throw him a note from the copter, this note was

thrown where it was, there was an instruction, here we are, these shots you see surrender and accordingly follow the copter at the expense of our unmanned aerial vehicles, it was brought to the position where the defense forces are located, the guys from code 9:2 are sure that it does not pose a threat to our servicemen and was captured at the expense of this operation, it was possible to get not only a representative for the exchange fund to return our boys in time . we, mr. yuri, and this one got lost, the occupier who asked for mercy, he, uh, there is information about which russian occupation group he belongs to, that is, what kind of brigade is there, what is the army cargo, what a lucky unit , what is the only thing that can focus attention, what is it that is mobilized how do you passed special