[000:00:00;00] i will repeat that what is important is the inevitability of the punishment, because if we see these stories , well, let's be frank, we have seen many stories about the handing over of suspicion about uh about that, i don't know bribery in the literal sense of the word, specifically i you know, from a legal point of view, i understand that there are many aspects, many points. i don't understand that a person was directly taken with money. well, what else is there to prove, but believe me, our legislation is such that these courts will still be years away. five seven to go and he will get out and he will get out on bail that's all and he will sit at home and for people it will be a certain kind of insult that he got out he won't know all these subtleties and that's our biggest problem is that again after all, there are no people punished, and therefore if this soldier, for example, i do not know there is such a thing as the presumption of innocence, i do not accuse him of this, but if he really

committed an offense, then believe me, if nothing is done with him, the other military commissions will take a look. further and it will be the same in the courts the same will happen to dear places if he does not fight the punishment, because as we can see, there is already a judge who received how much there is under 700,000 hryvnias. by the way, i am absolutely a supporter of e-e raising wages e-e high because, again, first you have to give a certain motivation, but there should also be the other side, you know how the whipped gingerbread method is, again, not the reversibility of punishment, if you create punishments, you will definitely bear responsibility, and in our country, so far, we have partially followed the first path, but we cannot reach the second one. and we we have to come to that because once again we will simply return to such an old country where once again there will be a basic demand for justice where internal clashes will begin where one caste of people will live better than others and entrepreneurs who create jobs and

pay taxes will live civil servants will live, the punishment was formulated, by the way, back in the 18th century. was there such an italian lawyer like rebekaria, who was the marquis, by the way, but he was a supporter of greater rights for everyone, in particular, for the average enabling small business for the bourgeoisie, which was only posted at that time in italy, and actually he then proved that the police methods of eliminating knowledge, formal evidence bases, quick executions , and so on, they increase the punishment for what crimes they do not give results, but the result is precisely inevitability punishment and it has even been proven that the punishments are relatively smaller in size, but at the same time , their inevitability is that you will not be able to avoid this punishment. they work more efficiently. this is the glory of rostyslav smirnov as

the traitor of the minister of internal affairs of ukraine or with us, the audience is correcting us and thank you for your attention to matters in this video that we showed . it was not ksenia mishana or ksenia mishyna. photo and video in after those shellings that were here and it was voronov's ex-wife of some drug dealer in this video that we showed, so we correct it and do not distribute it . here without any, if not without images. what is, it is. but she is a popular blogger. well, that's how it is. well, bloggers now have color and taste. by the way , friends, we said that today is the same, except that it is vyshyvanok's day. this

holiday actually fell on now on may 18, but besides that, on may 18, we traditionally remember those crimean tatars who were deported in 1944 and the russians took them out of the crimea. and what is interesting is that they say that in the crimea of ​​programs , several wagons got off the railway, and it happened in the simferopol district of the crimea. there is some the explosion went down five wagons of grain, i wonder what kind of grain it was from, where it was going , where it was going. well, in the meantime, you probably also heard about this story that the russian fsb showed a video of the detention of a crimean tatar woman, a very young 25-year-old citizen of ukraine, lenie vnerova , who came that she came from ukraine , she would like to attend her sports event

, she traveled a long way through georgia or god knows how, because her father is sick with cancer, and now the russians are turning her into some kind of spy. a 25-year-old girl who was going to see her father, probably to say goodbye or to support him. well, i can only imagine what it was like when your relative was going through georgia , right at the georgian russian border, she was detained by the fsb. and already there in moscow , they took her to moscow there arrested and announced that she is a ukrainian spy . this is the story, well, there is a video where two such thugs with bags on their faces lead the girl, what is interesting, some wild story because

this girl was already released once and then she was again simply simply grabbed by some two unknown people ah hmm and taken to an unknown place in an unknown direction. well, then it turned out that it was in kyiv. it seems that it must be so similar to kyiv. well, in its own way, this is the story on march 16, 2023. they released her from the detention center for foreigners, but as soon as she came out, some unknown people grabbed her, put a bag on her head, and brought her to an unknown place, somewhere in some unfamiliar region of vladikavkaz . well, there she was again tried, and again she was found guilty, this is what happens russia is a strange country with some strange orders and the absence of normal justice. well, what else can

we tell you that is useful, and now we will talk to kander barium, the head of the crimean tatar resource center, a member of the interforest of the krytar people, mr. squadron , good morning. good morning glory to ukraine glory to the heroes today we see vyshyvanka day and celebrate vyshyvanka day because it is the kind of holiday that takes place on thursdays, but today it also coincided with the day of the genocide of the crimean tatar people and well, so what is this such a holiday or let's say yes, it's memorial day, but also with ukrainian colors, what's something like today, uh, what events can be held today , what can you say and what 's happening in crimea on this day well, first of all

, i really want to correct congratulations of ukrainians with vyshyvanka day indeed this year coincided, but vyshyvanka day and also the day of remembrance of the victims of the kraskotar people 's genocide, therefore, i tilt the tatar resource to the center and i personally call on all ukrainians to get diagnosed - to put on vyshyvankas today and attach the flag of the konsko-tatar people as possible. thus, the vyshyvanka is an element of preserving the identity that they tried in 1944 to erase the ethnic identity of the communists. to attach the krom-tatar flag

, it is also possible to do it, and on the website of the konsko-tatar resource center there is an instruction on how to do it in order to be on the internet in e-e in social networks to do such a flash mob in support of the konsko-tatar people by pulling on embroidered shirts. as for the events themselves today, the events have already been held for several days, and because these events are held not only in ukraine, they will also try to hold them in the territory of the temporarily occupied crimea and also at the international level, that is, in different countries where the ukrainian tatar diaspora lives compactly, and there is also a ukrainian diaspora, because the ukrainian diaspora is very active

in supporting the crimean tatars, for example in latvia and in ireland and in other countries. well, as far as the events are concerned. today, a round table will be held, which was initiated by an athlete of ukraine and also a number of public organizations at this round table. let's talk about the deportation, the consequences, and also to compare with that er with what is happening now a-and further er will be er tried yesterday there was an international prayer such a prayer online and in which the representatives of er-e silent and lithuania and er-e autonomous republic of crimea were chosen to participate here already in na the mainland of ukraine and turkey and romania and so on and so on and further such events will be held in various cities

of ukraine, i.e. zaporizhzhia and lviv and odessa and other cities of ukraine will be held there in flash mobs where there are productions where there is a demonstration of hayterm’s film of other e-e materials in addition to today a-a at the initiative of the crimean tabernacle consular center and they say with the support of local orders of local self-government a-a all likes are posted and bigboards with a theme, well, for example, well, well they tried to destroy uh, to assimilate yesterday, they tried to assimilate yesterday, and i’m continuing this, for example, or ah, well, they condemned yesterday, they are repeating themselves today, uh, there are two squares, one

criminal, and so on, that is, uh, ukrainians will be able to see all these posters that they remind us of the crime that took place in 1944 and continues today, mr. eskandari. this is an absolutely wild story, which i understand that there are probably many such stories. you can say more about it. went to crimea, and already during a full-scale invasion, here she is being led by two fsb employees, because in russia she is considered a spy, and she is a spy because she went to crimea because her father is sick, has cancer, why, why , why did they pick on this girl , why are they with her they are sculpting some kind of spy girl and how many such stories are now in crimea

, well, let's say that there are a lot of stories, for example , 168 people are now in the cities and freedoms, of which 118 are representatives of the indigenous circle of the tatar people. says that this story is only about those who are being prosecuted for criminal cases and are in the cities between the freedoms and there is already something in us that has separated from the master of the squadron is returning hello so-so performing we

hear and see you and a - and well, punishment, and when we talk about the dead line, we are really talking about a young, young girl who was on the mainland of ukraine, who in principle did not take a russian passport, and she really had to go home to her parents because father has cancer a disease and a shark when she tried to move through georgia to the side of the russian federation in order to then go to the crimea, and then in vladikavkaz, he was detained, she was held for more than 4 months, and in such filtration centers for foreign citizens , and then he was constantly provoked and a as if they are accusing her of what if she had donations in her phone in support

of the crimean battalion, and the fact that they gave her the rest of the admin several times for 15 days. viewers about the fact that in the left there are people who are accused of very special persons and serious charges, that is treason, treason, treason, and the russian federation, terrorism, etc. that is, we see here that a they are trying to do or a terrorist, or i don’t know some criminal out there who poses a threat to the russian federation. have you seen this video from crimea, some crimea, a warehouse where a russian woman came to rest, it’s obvious that

she really wanted to, she really wanted to sing the russian national anthem, and that’s how she there she started to shout like that let's watch this video. maybe you haven't seen it. maybe our viewers haven't seen it. and then i'm just curious about your reaction, do you know what kind of guy or restaurant this is? беременной 7 месяцев почему, i'm sorry for you, i can't sing with russia , answer me on the question, what are you based on, do you work at all , that your employees answer me, no , i'm waiting. tomorrow i'll file a police report, you know

, well, it's amazing that there wasn't any kind of swearing because he was thin, you know, i don't know, not even a teacher, some kind of warden from some prison, the first class came from russia to populate crimea after the annexation, i understand that well, what can i say about that, well, first of all, i can't say yet which cafe did this happen? but i think we will find out in the near future . well, first of all, i want to say that this is a provocation that they are doing , because this is really such a reaction when well , they all know about the fact that uh, in the cafe and in in various institutions and often a-a is used ukrainian songs, including the red viburnum, and this is not the first time, because

there were such people. well, in the summer of 2022 , it happened very often from sudak and in other places when russian soldiers came to the cafe and tried to there, well, to order such songs as for the donbass, and so on, and they were refused, told that such songs cannot be used here, and then they wrote statements to the law enforcement agencies in order to put pressure on the owners of this a-a establishment. that is, we see here that eh and eh no there is enough water and a propaganda machine that works and they try to demonstrate at various such and such and such and such and such and such and such and such and such and such and such and such and so and so in various institutions but let's say a-and i don't know my level there well, i am in a different way than khorosynism how is it

- that's nazism, i can't call it any other way, because in this way they are pressuring other people to act in the crimea , but they are already saying that the occupiers have admitted that there will be no holiday season . first of all, i want to say that ah-ah the crimean branch of the pct, i.e. the russian one there on the tour tutu manufacturers, and they turned to the russian government for the help of which uh in this in this in their appeal they clearly write that the season in crimea this year will be catastrophic and also they say about such trends, more

about such trends that ah, first of all, they are not sold at all, they are booked, ah, let's say, uh, hotels are not booked, vacation homes are only booked, uh, such are budget uh, establishments , and that at the expense of e-e federal funds e it says that russians are really not going to go to crimea to relax, they are more likely to buy a bro e-e home a-a vacation in the krasnodarkiv region and besides , it really says that they are informed about what is going on in crimea there is no dangerous place right now, this is the second time, and the fact that there are always explosions of c2 happening there, the third is that the coast there is primarily west and from the west of the west and the entrance to the crimea is located, they

are dug up and there really are trenches and also including a very similar case the fact that a mine was blown up in the luchynsk region , this is the southern coast, and a forty-five-year-old man was blown up, this indicates that russians are afraid to go to the crimea. and this is very true, it is very correct, and we want to say that ah, in terms of information, we need to continue so that the russians do not go to the crimea . thank you, mr. sskander, the barbarian cis joined us . let us remind you that today ukraine also celebrates the day of remembrance of the victims of the genocide of the crimean tatars, who were resettled by the mass authorities in 44 there are a lot of people from crimea this year

people died during this. well, let's move on. the head of the de jure foundation and lawyer, mr. mykhailo dobrogo, are with us. good morning . i congratulate you, mr. mykhailo. there were many such scandals, well, the main one, of course. this is probably the detention of the now former chairman of the supreme court, mr. knyazev he is charged with a huge bribe, and in a case that also involved a well-known famous person , this is one of the ukrainian billionaires and , by the way, one of the investors of this channel, it is also important to note that because we have what should we label our conflict of interests, and what conclusions can we draw from this story, because mr. knyazev was a person who came after all for a competition, which , for example, does not exist in many other areas , let me remind you state tax service state customs service bep, for example, the bureau of combating economic crime and so on and so on. these are all people appointed without competitions. it is not known who

is responsible for what, but those are the fears that you have already voiced. by the way, yurchyshyn is also a baker, isn’t it? will strike, in principle, on the judicial reform itself, about the idea that it is still necessary to pay large sums of money to people who are in positions of corruption, about the idea that these contests should be held, that public control over these contests is needed , what are the conclusions and really interesting ones there are many questions, let's see them in order first . not everything that is called a competition is a competition . yes, we and public organizations and the public council of integrity and public organizations that followed the process for 17-18 years understood and and were quite active in explaining, perhaps not active enough, that what was happening then, the selection to the supreme court no way, it is a competition - it is a screen

that was decided everything politically. opaque in the competition, the so-called competition had a lot of questions about how the points were calculated, how the winners were determined, and so on, we talked about it very actively then, and in fact already in the 19th year, already under the new government, it was the higher qualification commission of judges, which is the so-called competition and conducted it, that is, the society and the authorities have already given an assessment of the competition that allegedly took place, and now we are trying to change this situation , a new higher qualification commission of judges is being formed , the members decide at all times who should be the new member of the supreme council of justice ? there are some, well, with themselves, they do not necessarily testify to something, but there was probably some

kind of reading about this chairman, who said at the competition. on this, of course, it is very important that there is no such interference, that all doubts are cleared. therefore, now our appeal to the supreme council justice that forms this new you are a very important body to do everything as transparently as possible with an open vote by name in order to dispel any doubts that this time everything is happening with us as it should be and before that at least well it looked like everything was going well. and in fact, the list of 32 finalists is quite strong. from it, you can choose a really good, fair, honest higher education . in general, knyazev, for example, as a candidate, if we return to this story again , there were some complaints against him, for example, in the public community council because i yesterday i heard such an opinion that they said well, the princes did not have any complaints about him, the ideal candidate, what was the information from the public council of integrity, that is, you need to understand what is

two types of decisions that the public council of integrity passed or a conclusion of non-compliance when there was enough information that clearly indicated the candidate's non-compliance with the integrity criteria of professional ethics and information that could indicate dishonesty, then it must be understood that the public council of integrity is not we had the prosecutor's office and not the court. i was also a member. at that time, we had very limited opportunities. in fact, it is only the collection of information from open sources for everyone, and even for him, if you look at the composition of the court that decided this is the decision that is mentioned in the criminal case which is the subject of consideration, so out of 18 people, two-thirds either had a conclusion , three or had negative information about the public public council of integrity for nine years, that is, two-thirds of the people involved in making this decision if then the higher qualification commission of judges took this information seriously, which was provided by the public control, the public council of integrity, then it is very likely that it would not be easy for anyone to make this criminal

decision, that is how important it is the openness of the competition, how important is public participation and how important is the composition of those commissions, what is important is who makes the final decision, i had to hear a few years ago that sometime after the 19th year , when the portal returned to ukraine, there were some attempts to completely lethemize it and include it again in some complex structure, and where did such an opinion come from, which was popular even among my fellow journalists who said , of course, he is not a scoundrel, but some specialist is a very good lawyer in these stories with contests in this history when two and a half thousand judges will now be selected who must embody this principle of the inevitability of punishment

. but i no longer know who we can trust, how it is possible to implement it in principle . kryshtaleva, honest judges, no, i don't think that this is utopia. an example is the higher anti-corruption court, which just yesterday made an absolutely adequate decision in the knyazev case and already made a decision in the top corruption cases. there are none, but it is heaven and earth compared to the rest of the judicial system. that is precisely why the involvement of independent international experts is key to the selection of normal judges, in particular judges of the constitutional court, there is currently a huge the discussion continues, our government is somehow trying to seize power in the constitutional court and, at the same time, presenting it as european integration, well, this is unacceptable

and of course the people, by the way, 50% of ukrainian citizens believe that it is independent international experts who should have a decisive influence, a decisive vote on the selection of judges of the constitutional court courts, not ukrainian politicians . and in that regard, the virtuous are also competent . well, we don’t have to choose. the constitution gives a very direct answer to this, that judges have to be competent and honest and, believe me, we have a lot of such lawyers in the country, the main thing is that the selection procedure is normal, which really will not be a cover for a political choice, but a real process that will select the best for all positions and positions. by the way, there are currently 2,500 vacant positions in the ukrainian judicial system and this is a huge, huge opportunity to either update it qualitatively, quantitatively, or, well, to cement everything that is here for more than a generation ahead, well, actually, what valery the baker says that this story with the princes is

now the story with the election of these new judges she will determine our fate for generations to come , this is not an exaggeration . thank you very much. mykhailo zhornikov, the chairman of the board of the de-jurer foundation, was with us at this. a concert to raise money for the armed forces of ukraine, and we are also looking for a military serviceman ivan tymochka in our community, with whom we will talk about the situation at the front. well , we will also talk in an hour the founder of today's holiday is lesya voronyuk - it was eaten with a light hand . colleagues i congratulate you on the holiday unfortunately, the occupiers do not leave us alone ani on weekdays ani on