[000:00:00;00] we can say that now they will be taken away and they will go to serve. but maybe such trash is really not needed there. well, but listen in the armed forces , or rather in the defense forces, which do not have important cases , or rather unimportant cases , even simply, i do not know some goods, roughly speaking, even in the rear someone should also do this work, there will be advice for victories, so you don’t need to think that uh right away if you receive a summons, then you are already guaranteed to be in the middle of nowhere. of the armed forces, but there should be reserves, there should be men's units, which work should be carried out by someone, people, you understand what the matter is, so in this context, i am not inclined to consider, you know what , let's not give a hangman to anyone there at all, because it can be perceived as a punishment. no, let's shall we comply with the legislation

? i say a saying when you don't know how to act or not as required by the law and the law required to check whether the guys on other numbers arriving in lviv are registered accordingly it was checked by the military. by the way, they appeared at the military commissariat. there is no information about how their submission was. in fact, at the last moment, he did not apologize for anything. he is more and more sure that he is right and hid it. he gave in, did not apologize, and such people should be allowed in. andriy ot as far as i understand, you were talking about when the police, after such incidents, emphasize that such people were served with summonses. i found this message from the police of the lviv region and then really the last paragraph directly emphasizes that after the completion of all actions by the law enforcement officers, the driver and passengers and their friends received summonses from the military , you must have talked about exactly this when in the notification about the offense and the fact that the police paid attention to it,

they sorted out the incident at the end they add that we issued them with summonses, and after this report, one gets the impression that the police think that these trips are a punishment for the fact that they behaved in such a way led here i agree with mr. valentyn and confirm that the summons is not necessarily automatic mobilization the trip is also an invitation to the e-e selection center - it is such a joint venture for clarifying personal data and finding out whether a person is on military registration at all because against, but i heard that these guys who were in a range rover, that they are really from another region, that they are in front of the occupied territories, so check whether they are on the military register, because we must understand that if we change places

residence or place of stay in must inform the nearest central committee of the sp about updating their data, so to speak, and this will facilitate the work for further mobilization or vice versa , for example, a person does not fall under mobilization, we can also share such an option with friends i read in social networks or do i read news on various sites there, for example there and someone in a state of alcohol intoxication committed a road accident i read the reaction of people who write uh give him a summons and send him to the front right and i said about it that friends are serving in sumy defense in ukraine, this is not a punishment , it is a privilege . and if a person has committed a crime, he must be held accountable according to the law, and i really agree with valentine. are these people really on the military register and should there be an injury at

all ? aggression, although we understand that their home, their hometown , was threatened by the occupation of the occupied country, so we really need to write the version of these guys. but again, i call on the police or other authorities or even the citizens should not shout that they will be sent to the front or something , you know very well about the soviet army or the russian army, or the belarusian army, for example, they were used a lot by the russian, russian or soviet authorities as a method of repression as a method re-education in the russian empire was also used by the military for the purpose of punishment , and again, the suppression of repression against taras shevchenko , for example, in the army of the russian empire , he was ruled by the so-called there really

used the army as a repressive machine in if we want the armed forces of ukraine to fight for ukraine, fight for independence, fight for territorial integrity, you should change your perspective on the armed forces , the armed forces of ukraine - these are our defenders, they are the guarantor of our security and preservation of independence, not a repressive body. i think what for these guys, let's say, well, even for violating public order, for hooliganism , they could be threatened with correctional work, let's say. and if they swept the streets, it would be much more useful, and you don't need to try to scare someone armed forces of ukraine with mr. valentyn, i agree, we will get and hear the opinion of the language ombudsman, taras kremin, the authorized representative of the state language protection, with us on the communication of mr. taras, we congratulate and talk about, in particular, about these

two precedents that happened or incidents, because there were actually enough of them that happened in lviv, odesa, where first the young men , then the girls, listened to loud music, the music of russian artists banned from entering ukraine, who actively support russian aggression towards us, you, as an official, are you in why do you see conflicts here in the first place, how in general are incidents like this, it is best to resolve the incidents gently, or is it not necessary to be gentle, but rather to cut from the shoulder, in fact, share your opinion, thank you, thank you for your interest in this issue, in fact, i want to say that it is necessary to solve not only the problems that arose after the fire, but to be ready to actively promote ukrainian culture, spirituality , to protect the ukrainian language on all fronts throughout the territory of ukraine, that is why i am in

favor of the fact that regardless of whether it is lviv or this mykolaiv should this kharkiv work legislation should work actively authorities and local self-government bodies in order to control the actual implementation process of state policy and language and educational cultural and security including i look at this situation as a kind of growth of the generation that was born during the years of ukrainian independence, i want to remind you that in the hands of ukrainian independence there were 10 attempts to write a language law despite the fact that the language law was in 1989, but the language of the educational process these years was in different different corners of ukraine, and only in the last 5 years they are talking about the mandatory use of the ukrainian language in

the educational process. the fact that the war began in the 14th year, but it is necessary to solve the point issue, let's say that it concerns lviv, and the city's language program must be approved from day to day, we really cooperate with the mayor a huge number and the largest location in ukraine for learning the ukrainian language, these are language courses and conversation clubs, and i hope that the proposals submitted by my colleagues, educators, will affect all spheres of social life, a similar situation applies to odesa itself, by the way, a kind of linguistic chaos, because really on at the level of the city, there are huge tectonic disturbances in almost all spheres, and i am talking about the sphere of service and external advertising, there were questions about the text of the anthem of the city of odessa and to the deputies, we are conducting measures of state control over the odesa city council, in fact, there is no understanding of what to do with ukrainian culture, with the exception

of specific initiatives of public organizations, scientific institutions, educational measures that nevertheless contribute to that, so i think that the issue of state language policy is overdue for the time being, there should be a state language program and it must be strictly controlled . in the conditions of martial law, the law on language is one of the key documents that must be supported as much as possible, so all the things that are formed with you i absolutely support them i believe that summonses to the armed forces of ukraine are not a punishment. however, at the same time, it is necessary to actively promote the prestige of the service of the armed forces of ukraine in territorial defense units, as well as many other measures that, so to speak, at the time, mr. valentin, you, in the words of mr. taras, language law, do you have anything to say because i see that you reacted very vividly, ivan andriyovych, or we

had limited time to name the law of ukraine on the peculiarities of the use of the ukrainian language for the peculiarities of the functioning of the ukrainian language as the state law does not seem to be called that, in fact it is 70 percent. as compilations are already a factor in the laws of ukraine , it is actually good that this law arose as a collection of documents under one cover, this is already a big step forward, but a significant part of its norms functioned before that. they were simply part of the laws of enlightenment parts of the laws on television and radio broadcasting, parts of the laws on other spheres of activity, well, okay, ok, i fully support, i agree that we must comply with everything here, full stop, there is nothing to

talk about those federations for public performance of ukrainian music, people are arrested and accused, in particular, of such er, well, there are such new laws , for example, there is the sale, crediting of the armed forces of the russian federation , why is the logic of the er, russian occupiers like this . if somewhere, ukrainian music is performed in public, it is already a kind of ukrainian team , but here in in ukraine, there is no such feeling that when russian music is performed, that it is russian propaganda, you can imagine that during the second world war, let's say, on red square in moscow or three london bombarded by the germans, someone decided to publicly perform german marches or even just sing songs there , and this

should really be equated to russian propaganda on the territory of the performers . you do it publicly, then you are propagandists and you know one more thing that in the field of russian hybrid aggression, i am already talking about the fact that there cannot be sports, music, church , culture outside of politics. the same applies to as a defender of political memory, i am very surprised by the position of the kyiv city government when russian occupation monuments remain in the center of kyiv, when taras shevchenko's taras blvd is next to the godfather of the chief and the occupier, some kind of attempt to wait for the russian occupiers. i can't understand you can imagine in the center of a ukrainian city a monument to givi or a motto, why the role of a symbol of russian aggression, therefore, speaking of russian propagandists, we should also

actively respond to such ones . i also urge to reopen the discussion about the presence of these occupation markers on the territory of ukraine, er, they force the deported children of our prisoners of war to sing the russian anthem, and we have a lot of examples and a lot of knowledge of already freed already rescued ukrainians about these examples. taras, is it possible then to do something - is it really worth it somehow to regulate the ban on implementation by law, i don’t know if it is all russian, but at least such a trigger in ukraine well,

in fact, the legislation allows and it prosecuting those who spread e-e or russian music and even more so promote it are all open , but the issue of control is therefore such cases that occur either in lviv or in odesa just speak of the insufficiency of control over the use of the public sphere, including in public transport on streets, etc., songs of banned russian performers and so on, together with those who supported full-scale invasions or russian aggression, starting from the 14th year, the legislation is absolutely enough, but with mr. andriy ya i absolutely agree, i still don't understand how streets in the ukrainian capital still remain or have not been renamed, how such a monument remains. if it seemed as much as what is written on it, well, it is absolutely enough for someone in the kyiv city government to finally turn 40 just a year ago we have seen conflicts in individual schools of kyiv with the use of the state language when

conflicts when teachers used physical force in relation to their students literally on the previous broadcast with you oleg spoke skrypka, the leader of the vv band, talked about the fact that his child was bullied in one of the kyiv schools for the ukrainian language, and these and many other examples speak of the lack of systematic control over the application of legislation in various spheres of public life on the territory of ukraine . i'm sorry if this happens in kyiv. then what will we say for the southern province or for the eastern one? i think that your broadcast will also contribute to the fact that some people who are in their positions pay special attention and strengthen control in accordance with the law. thank you. taras, the criminal defender of the state language, was with us on the air. of course, thank you. we are talking about public execution. and for this

, responsibility is really provided for and there are certain regulatory norms . no one talks about your private life . consume crap well it's your sovereign sacred right but please spare me the need to watch this process i want to hear all this trash i get your point let's add a little more information, let's talk about specific numbers that confirm the trend. even 15 months after the full-scale invasion of russia, the music of the aggressor country periodically even gets to the top of the ratings on streaming services, in particular apple music and spotify, which means that ukrainians consciously listen to the songs of russian artists and even sponsor them directly the occupier's lands, because for each listening to a song on these services , a russian artist receives a certain amount of monetization there, not experts claim that for a million listenings to a song, an artist can to receive three to eight thousand dollars from them, of course, he will pay taxes to his state, and from these taxes, russia finances the army

that came to kill ukrainians, the same scheme if the videos of russians on youtube and their content are also still often trending in ukraine due to the progress of russia almost a third of ukrainians continue to listen to songs by russian artists, this is evidenced by the results of a survey conducted by the research company grados reserge . of music, about a quarter of respondents listen to content from the russian federation, but much less than before, 20% of people claim that they did not listen to russian music even before the war, and 7% of respondents listen to the same amount. the study was conducted at the end of april. continue to listen to russian despite the fact that the war has arrived in odesa , the girls continue to listen and

shout about it aggressively that they have the right to mr. valentine from 30%, what are they talking about er, there is an expectation that these numbers will decline, first of all, you have already lived there, the word is conscious, they continue to listen to russian music, yes, i would like to make a small clarification, but it is not always conscious, because in fact, if we are talking about these music services, they recommend you music according to your preferences and not only yours and the community to which you belong gave it to big data, so-called because i do not listen to russian music at all, but i live in the city of kyiv, there are ukrainians, well, that is, they have enough for me yes, the volume of mine likes so when i go for a run, for example, and i run, yes, recommendations can fly to me, this is disgusting because the people who live with me , who meet the same criteria

, obey me like this shit, shit, shit, and it is shit, that's why this service forces me to, in fact, yes, i think that if a lot of people like this shit, it's in this area, then accordingly , i'll like it further, the situation works as follows , it depends on how fast i run. well, if i'm not running fast enough and i can to know, just turn it over or change it if i don’t like it. then i listen to it, after which this service puts a plus one, yes, that is, one more listened and so it is gaining popularity , that is, there is a question not only for those who listen , but for how the algorithms work, why are they still recommended precisely the music from this region , why do they not recommend polish music to me, relatively speaking, or i know arabic music there, the question is that they recommend me, i told you the answer just now. that is, this is one point regarding monetization. as far as i know youtube

monetizes more new russian accounts, that is, at least it is easier with this, but many find ways to get around it . well, will they listen to a ukrainian? they break the traffic rules, they have sex without fuses for safety, they do a lot of stupid things, that is, can it be prevented, yes . on this field, we have to work, and andriy and i have worked hard enough on this field and have tried fruitfully work that's why i take it personally because this testimony has inefficiencies, you understand, while all this is happening, it means that i am still helpless and somewhere i have not been able to reach someone, but this is normal. it falls in and his level of culture does not allow him to consume something else. well, i have no complaints. i am also not very highly educated in the musical aspect of a person. our musical tastes are also quite primitive

. well, but listen to what they said, find an alternative. listen, find an alternative in music that is secondary and it is secondary, nothing original with rare exceptions and by the way, these groups did not sound there, and these projects are completely author's. in other words, these are all stolen melodies, stolen results, there is quite a bit of time left for andrii, in the end , literally for a minute, we talked about what this is how the ukrainians themselves pay , in particular, what kind of ammunition are the missiles that fly to ukraine , some will say maybe i didn’t know about it listen , well, just a minute, it’s like an idea maybe, for example, i don’t know so how do you think the wreckage should be taken from install rockets on the square and write that this rocket costs so much money. for example, if there are, i don't know, 10,000 people there download this song, or if there are 100,000 or a million, i don't know, it will cost these things the cost of this rocket, because otherwise how else to explain, because i'm sure that if you approach people on the street and ask if you have some

spotify music downloaded, they'll say and i didn't know that it's paid for and that a war is being waged with this money and i'm being waged, they're lying, they know very well how to come up with an alternative well, let's go there is only shit as an alternative to shit, what is the point of offering people such an alternative, this is a road to nowhere as far as advertising is concerned , people need to be informed, you listen, you watch russian, you finance russian terrorism, it ’s all very simple, on the air of the tv channel, rada is on the air, the marathon is advertising donate a russian rocket to a ukrainian city and you should listen to russian music we would finance the current act because it is the truth valentin said the truth youtube no longer finances russian accounts although they

are trying to register allegedly as accounts from from other countries and now they get money, but on the other hand, apple music is cool, be a specific advertisement, you will understand russian, you are financing a russian terrorist, because spotify and apple music are still in russian artists , money, gentlemen, is very interesting to talk more , unfortunately, time is limited today andriy kovalev , press officer the candidate of political sciences of the 112th territorial defense brigade of the armed forces of ukraine was recognized and in the studio and in the studio we will talk for a few minutes where to look for answers well, we talked quite emotionally here, in fact, an emotional topic, oleksiy asked mr. andriyovych, the following practical options will work. what are we installing on the independence square or on any others ? maybe on all the squares of ukraine we need to install exactly the following demonstrative , visual, obvious things: a rocket, a fragment of a rocket , an inscription on it, why are there so many of your views

on us by stumbling there on apple music, they caused the fact that russia could afford to buy this weapon or produce it and hit to kill so many ukrainians, it will work, no , there is such a phenomenon, well, in the theory of games and in uh , behavioral economics, which is called uh the paradox of the ticketless passenger from the ticketed passenger, why does it mean that when subjects consider their contribution to the general cause to be insignificant, they usually do not stick to it. what can we change, a million people say what can we change, and without realizing the same thing, each of these million says that i can't change anything, adds up to this huge number that could change that well, i

seriously repeat it no, no, no it will be fast and it is simply a slow process of this cultural and spiritual emancipation. and those who want to listen will find millions of examples. again, there is such a phenomenon as these cognitive thefts, which are called voluntary blindness. well, when a person simply does not want to notice some consequences or aspects of his activity or dissonance of any thread, and this is when a person puts only that information that confirms his or her will, so they will now be a guarantor, they will not listen now , say oh smooth said that my contribution in general, russian rockets are scarce, further making this contribution does not change anything, and the only thing left for me is to hope for karma that those who do this will eventually reap what they sow , that is, they will eventually reap thank you , mr. valentin unfortunately, we are limited in time today thank you who came to our studio, valentin

glynykh , a political scientist, helped to understand this is such a resonant and complex topic. well, we are moving on, moving on like this . for example, putin has already chosen the path of disaster, he found himself alone on this path as an aggressor, it is simply necessary to punish, and for this a tribunal is needed , the president of ukraine, volodymyr zelenskyi, stated this during the presentation of the charlemagne award to him and the ukrainian people in aachen, germany , the head of state said that putin was tried to agree but it turned out to be impossible, we spent hours, real hours, in conversations with putin trying to avert this modern catastrophe but putin chose the catastrophe alone and now everyone understands that

do we understand, putin is a disaster, this is the answer, putin is aggression, and he does not want anything else for himself and his people, his formula has become death, how to talk with it, explain to me the one who brought death, the one who stood on the path of genocide, the one who wants to destroy us, the one who wants to destroy europe, which we value, should beg for mercy, and then our answer will be the tribunal, contact us roman yedeev, an internationalist to the department of international law of the taras

shevchenko national university, and mr. roman, we congratulate you. so, the proposal to punish the political military russia's leadership for the unleashed war against ukraine is the task of a special international tribunal. let's talk about how many countries have already joined ukraine on this track . dear well, here it is difficult to say how many states express support , we can say how many states take an active part in the creation of this exercise regarding aggression against ukraine, here the number

will more or less determine not the price of the group but the members which are actively working on the creation of this tribunal, in general, the same idea of ​​the tribunal is supported by a much larger number of states, simply because they do not take a direct part in this discussion. 45-50 states, but not more , because you know that the more participants participate in the discussion, the more difficult it is to reach a final decision, and here we are . it is important that the development of this core group in the end, they were formalized in a specific proposal regarding the creation of a special tribunal, and from now on we will work to ensure that this proposal is supported by as many states as possible, because there is no

doubt about the effectiveness of the work carried out by the ministry of foreign affairs of ukraine, the office of the president, the office of the general prosecutor we are sure at the moment that a special tribunal will be created , the only question is in what form it is drilled and here we face a huge and very difficult task to ensure the effectiveness of this the tribunal and its support because the most effective tribunal will usually be an international tribunal created under the auspices or with the assistance of the united nations, the less effective will be a tribunal created under the auspices of the council