[000:00:00;00] completely different than it was. at the beginning of hostilities with the russian federation, we can really see that it is actually reflected on the front line . well, thank you, mr. sergiu. sergiu is burning , a military expert, the director of the defense express company was with us, we didn't have time to discuss everything , but i think we will continue, maybe tomorrow eh well, we have the next guest ah yesterday the team of the national opera held an action under the walls of the cult the world heard our voices will the minister hear them eh and actually the action was dedicated to the fact that the eh collective is a national the resistance does not agree with the decision of the ministry to remove petr chuprinym chuprin from the post of director and to replace him with another

candidate , which was accepted for the information of representatives of the theater . at 4:30 p.m., we had a meeting with minister oleksandr tkachenko during the campaign held under the walls of the ministry of culture , during which he assured us that the powers of the acting general director of the pyotr yakovych chuprin theater will be extended until the holding of the competition in accordance with the requirements of the current legislation of ukraine, the order on this has not been signed at the moment, but the minister promised that he would do everything on monday , tuesday of next week, so we

hope that these promises will be kept . wanted to change it, you know, we didn't discuss the issue of preferences, we discussed the issue of the difficult situation that actually arose, first of all, due to the lack of communication, but thank god that such a meeting took place yesterday, minister informed us that the ministry is preparing changes to the law on the competitive procedure for the appointment of managers of e-e cultural institutions and immediately after the adoption of this law , competitions will be appointed in all cultural institutions where there is currently an e-e performing duties well, we will watch what will happen at the moment, i said that the minister's promise to extend the term of petro

chuprinka's tenure as the head of the theater is there and we hope that it will be respected as a whole . how to make these contests so that, relatively speaking , competent administrators and managers come to power in the theater on the one hand, and on the other hand, people who still understand the specifics of this matter, this is primarily a question of forming a contest commission, it is clear that the contest commission is currently according to the current law, it consists of 9 people , three people are appointed by the governing

body of the ministry in this case. normally, there are three people left who, according to the law, are representatives of public organizations operating in the field of culture, and this raises a certain question about who these people are, because, for example, when the competitive commission for the election of the head of the opera house includes people from public organizations of organizations engaged in this is a completely different type of activity , their competence in the field in which we are engaged is very questionable . our competence will also be questionable. the direction in which i am not a specialist, therefore, the expertise of those people is very important, since

, as a rule, these three people have a decisive vote . there are specifics, for example, the language of opera - it is italian, the language of ballet - it is french , i have nothing against english , i speak it myself, i have the relevant certificates in all universities, i studied it, but the specifics are different, so probably the bill needs of public discussion and the minister assured yesterday that such a professional public discussion will be held in the same way, and i and the issue of limiting it to two terms is also quite debatable, on the one hand, it is an opportunity for changes, on the other hand, when

the person is working normally and the team is working normally should it be changed to a person who is not yet known how he will work, that is, he can be in power for 30-40 years and this is a normal democratic practice in all european countries, for example, and so on. that is, there are no problems at all with that, people want sort through, sort through, there is some kind of institutionalism, too, the government, it can be good, it can be a climb, of course, as we know, but if the elections are in place , then this is not a problem. true, yes, there is a question. moreover, the head of a cultural institution is not a politician , it is not a political function, and he must have a number of e-e competences and professional artistic and, at the same time, managerial and reserve bench is not so

large, so it seems to me that the term and what term by the way and what term by the way tell us uh five years five years i.e. two terms - that's 10 years it's quite normal uh normal term yes but if a person works professionally well indicators and results and kpi as it is customary to say high, normal, adequate, everything is being done. so what is the point of replacing such a person with a person who does not know how he will work in the future, well, actually, eh? well, finally, i just ask, is it possible for us to be like that? well , i think so too rostyslav derzypilsky how long has he been leading his theater frankivskyi was a director in various roles, but now it has already happened. but it is the same, this is also a form , and now he is not only a director, but also a manager . that is, certain changes took place there , he simply changed his hypostases. but

it is difficult for me to imagine that now he will be told, well, that's all there, he worked there for 10 years, pass it on, let's hire someone, i don't know someone there , absolutely some random person there, we'll win the competition because i liked her , i don't know what kind of friends and theater lovers there how many ivano-frankivsk or people from other regions are already coming there to get to the performances and order tickets in advance . conventionally speaking, they do not vote, well, that is, the deputies do not vote meaningfully, and that is why, after all , this block of representatives is such people with expertise, but independent in these commissions, it is an important question. how to really make it so that

these three people you indicate become decisive, they were not the people who were there, because we remember completely similar stories in other sectors, when this very block of public representatives was used in order to have another third of the votes for the government, well, in any case, we hope for the better, and the minister promised that there will be a thorough public discussion of those proposals and changes to the laws proposed by the ministry of culture. we are waiting for their publication and will accordingly participate in their discussions. solovyanenko, the chief director of the national opera

of ukraine , was with us and we talked about the difficult situation that happened there with such an attempt to change the leader there without a competition . for shelters for the fact that they are open or closed in kyiv and why so many people suddenly rebelled against mr. klitschko, the mayor of kyiv, about this later, and we will also talk about the deputy who he updated the cars during the full-scale invasion, the cars were not for 3 kopecks, but for those cars you could send several cars to the front to send your people's deputies to the front, and why , for example, when it comes to deputies , the people's opinion does not say that they ended up in the verkhovna rada and became deputies because people they believed the one who was the head of this party. and we can also talk about how they are now trying to criminally prosecute the secretary of the city council of chernihiv because of what happened and what a thing that they

were suspended by the yavoriv court with such a very due to the dubious legality of the mayor, they appointed their deputy, but according to the law, the power passed to whom. to the secretary, who assumed the duties of the mayor, and he represents the most political power that yatroshenko, and it turned out that if they had not acquired anything, they would not have acquired anything. well, but the region is actually suffering from this because there are two authorities, there is a struggle for resources, and so on . well, it is a little easy to get the impression that the authorities are a little sorry for the french language, but i don't know if you have the same feeling, and i don't know maybe they know something, maybe budanov has already told everyone that well, i don’t know, a couple of weeks and soon the end of the war and the elections had to be announced to the committee literally in a few

moments, all these most powerful teams in europe, but in istanbul intersi is playing as if it were the last time in its life, watch the season super final on june 10 at 22:00 exclusively on megogo kudos to ukraine, i'm igor perduta , i devoted most of my career to vorskla, we won awards in the domestic championship , shot the country many times at the euro arena, many thanks to those who defend our independence kudos to the ukrainian nation, dear, they waited for you in the garden, and something hurts my back, almost

like a bone marrow, and you will help me like a young man. comfrey ointment from dr. tais, save money by buying a large package of 100 grams, there are discounts for three dermal pantestin donation 10% in pharmacies travelogue for you and save vasyl winter's big ether my name is vasyl winter two hours of air time and my colleagues are with you until 21:00 for two hours of your time, we will talk about the most important things, two hours to learn about the war, serhiia zhoretska joins our broadcast , military summaries of the day and what is the world like? what in the world will yuriy the physicist tell for two hours to be informed of economic news protested by oleksandr borshchagivtsi he tells us about the economy during the war and new sports yevhen pastukhov is ready to talk about sports for two hours in the company of favorite presenters about

culture during the war lena is ready to talk or is it another way that many have become as if the weather may even give us some optimism ms. natalka didenko is ready to tell us and we will also have distinguished guests of the studio today volodymyr ogrysko if everything goes well the events of the day in two hours vasyl's big broadcast in the winter a project for smart and caring people in the evening nayspresso so, let's go back on the air and continue the conversation, and actually now we will give answers to the questions that were voiced a moment ago about the sensational appointments because we will have football until sunday on monday in our country football, something is true, so for now we will report the sensational news myron markevich headed fc karpaty lviv eh someone will say that we will say that again for the fifth time already, mr. markevich headed

the carpathians and we congratulate him on this appointment eh oleksiy koshel the head of the committee electors of ukraine joins ours yet, it turns out we are waiting for him to join i am the peace of the brand, it is mine in general well, first of all, the management of grandmother markevich yes yes yes well we are not relatives well probably no i'm not sure no probably no well but anyway that is i believe that superovy coach i think the carpathians are not moving now since the gadyukins sang otherwise, he doesn't remember, suddenly the carpathians lost again in football, a discussion about whether, in principle, it is worth continuing football matches in a warring country , a good discussion it probably makes sense, but let's go now, our next guest is oleksiy koshel, the head of the committee of voters of ukraine oleksiy good day to you. we decided

today to talk a little about the sad , namely about p- writing, there was a bunch of such unpleasant news that we would not like to see while in a country that is at war with russia a dictatorship in a country that has passed through m. well, there have already been three revolutions against authoritarianism and so on. and i would like it to be somehow more transparent and understandable in our country. kipera n cyprus by 2024 in general should have been in, let me remind you, due to the fact that he was a millet deputy of the whole prosecutor general, he should have been lauded, nevertheless, he was returned to power by the decision of the oask. if i am not mistaken, and then the appointment of ms. benediktova to the position

of e- is the prosecutor of kyiv and a person again even in this position, i managed to go to the new year for 10 days to rest at the sea with my wife, who turned out to have a russian passport until now, well, a glorious cross, but you read all this and think, what is actually happening in this country ? but i, but i was most interested in another story - this the fact that the odesa lawyer , who is now fighting, volunteered for the armed forces of ukraine, oleksandr gvozdykov tried to organize an electronic petition on the website of the president's office, but he was refused, and was told that, well, about resignation, actually about resignation in fact, this keeper and they said that no, this is not the authority of the president of ukraine and your petition will not be counted, published, that is, all petitions are no longer working in our country, you know, i would not reduce the problem solely to mr. keeper, because the problem is actually much, much more complicated and to large-scale invasion. we saw exactly the same problems with the appointment

of the heads of regions, but the problem was not only in the biography, because really a person worked with millet in a person, that is the whole bouquet of problems that you talked about, and therefore it is quite obvious that this the person should not have been appointed, that is, but the problem we have observed before, let's say in the last four years in transcarpathia , for example, in the class of an extremely difficult region, if i'm not mistaken, five heads of regional state administrations resigned, it was changed , and it was not clear by what logic personnel appointments are made and by what logic are the dismissals taking place? that is, i have nothing against the representatives of certain professions who were appointed, but for me, to be honest , the individual appointments were strange, that is, there we look at a person's biography, we understand that he is the owner of one or two confectionery shops, we understand that this is a small business and obviously

management experience, management experience , management experience is not enough to manage such a complex region, and this appointment is taking place, and such strange things are enough baggage for me a certain logic should be developed, well, for example, based on the results of the year, we have a cabinet of ministers that evaluates the work of these or other heads of regions, that is, based on the results of the year , we have a number of indicators there socio-economic growth, investment income, price policy, there are a lot of different points, and it would be quite logical, let's say, based on the results of the year , two, three, four heads of regions, which are the lowest on the list, simply replace, simply replace. pay attention to another problem. what until today i didn't see personnel rotations. i didn't see dismissals with a logical explanation, that is, we have it

that the king, the emperor, signed the application , signed the documents, and the head of the region, let's say, or the head of the district, was dismissed according to which logic does which explain, i.e. i think that the people deserve to be clearly explained step by step for what exactly were the problems that were carried out in our country? i i as far as i understand, if the president appointed a keeper, then he has all the powers to appoint him back in the same way, conditionally speaking, and i am interesting here, in fact , the story with the electronic petition is a real precedent, i will hope that it will be somehow reacted to electronic petitions, how important is it in general, tools and the element of democracy, what is it important, does it exist , is it important, in particular, in the sense of the european integration of ukraine, but now, for example, we barely

collected one vote at a time, there were transfers , there the petition disappeared in general, in the end, we did not collect 25,000 votes for the cabinet of ministers answered the question of tkachenko's rate. i am sure that they will take it down. but nevertheless it is simple. of course, it is difficult. this petition collected votes. we remember how we gathered votes. on e tv channel espresso, for example, about the exclusion of other channels of the fifth direct channel, it's the same as how hard it was to collect a bald head, well, it's obvious that they blocked it, well, it's just obvious, well, why do it, well, that is, how important is it an element of democracy, can you say? petitions well, what if they work in other countries, we will become eu members without it petitions are an effective mechanism of democracy work in many democratic countries, but we must not forget that on the one hand it is a mechanism of influence

on the authorities and on the other hand - it will find such a mechanism for exhausting steam from exhausting dissatisfaction, but it is an opportunity to really attract attention. that is, we as ordinary citizens can come and vote and the authorities are forced to react , that is , there is a wave of publication in the media, a petition to the president, at least he can say a neutral phrase, and how max he can make this or that decision . that is, it is an effective mechanism, why is this happening with this mechanism, why are petitions not being registered there, votes are not flying, well, it is obvious that there are specific people here who they help so that the petition mechanism does not work, and i think that sooner or later official investigations will be conducted in such matters, and those who are actually guilty must be punished. because here a concrete trace must remain, uh , also the history, yes, the history, you know from yesterday

that this shelling was russian and then a - and then how the network reacted to all this , and there were a lot of posts about the fact that klitschko should resign immediately, eh . well, besides all that , the president also commented on this situation, who said that there could be a knockout, so to speak hinted unpleasant consequences for the mayor of kyiv, e.e. vitaliy klitschko, without excusing vitaliy klitschko , but still emphasizing whether i am responsible or whether only that klitschko himself is to blame and why and can the mayor of the city listen to the president these are the words and why, for example, hmm, the bank keeper receives an appointment having such a background and others, uh, and there is no criticism from the president , moreover, the president himself goes to insert

him like that, and others receive a portion of criticism or suspension from the performance of their duties , well, in a word, all kinds of things to finish the topic of personnel appointments, uh, i have the general impression that with such appointments, and here the question is not only the goalkeeper, and this is a problem. i think that when evaluating the work of the president, this is exactly the kind of personnel appointments that can play a fairly serious minus . characteristics, this is bureaucracy, this is a certain explanation of the logic of the reasons, there are separate services of the president that deal with personnel

policy, separate services in the cockpit, this is a complex mechanism, but i am convinced that the president is simply being asked a question. the second question is the second one related to klitschko. to be, but now, not knowing all the details, not knowing all the circumstances, it is very difficult for us to say the fault of the watchman who, according to separate publications, was in a drunken state , the fault is at the level of the kmda, the fault is at the level leadership of the kyiv district it is premature to speak here now, that is, the situation with the bomb shelters is the current legislation, there are certain inspection mechanisms, there are many other mechanisms, that is, if what vitaliy klitschko says is true , all inspections of the bomb shelters should be initiated, the district manager failed, the district manager has just fly out in a very quick period of time, but what is happening with klitschko

today we see a classic political attack a classic political attack and this is definitely not the first attack on klitschko by klitschko's deputies and before the war and even during the war, even pork and when there are political attacks, political games, clarifying relations during the war - these are very unpleasant things. i personally as a citizen find it very unpleasant to see all this. i don't want to talk about other worse words there but on the other hand, uh, we must turn on the long memory and remember that klitschko is one of the few, a few months before february 24, he dealt with the issue of bean storages , that is, remember the kyiv metro, there they tested water, occupied it with toilets the city government was really working, and that's why when such a political attack took place. i think it's worth mentioning, because at least in order for us to objectively

evaluate the actions of klitschko as the head of the city, eh , in relation to chernihiv. those of you who don't remember that he was suspended by the decision of yavorivskyi from the lviv oblast court, the mayor of atroshenko, because he was during hostilities. well, the beginning of the invasion had already begun. he took his wife to poland in a company car, as was established. so the official car took him away, he stayed in chernihiv, it seems like that even somehow. that's why the mayor himself stayed in chernihiv when chernihiv was under siege, well, i remember he joined us and said that he was talking about the situation just under the bombardment, so there were planes flying just over the city, we just flew over the city, we dropped a bomb directly, i have a hint, it was a terrible situation last spring, more than a little over a year ago, but there was a

situation, what is there now, if the mayor is the secretary, but i didn't like him either, and here i am i read an interview with him, in which he says that they have now started various pressures against him , criminal prosecution , so that, after all, oleksandr lomako writes that they are also trying to remove him from his position , just how is it? is it on what it looks like is the direction of an attack on self-government, this is not just the next self-government , this is about illegal decisions, of course we cannot characterize the court's decision like that, but believe me, it simply does not correspond to the current legislation in any way, if we speak by name, that is, which reasons are possible it was to suspend the mayor, well, i apologize, well, tomorrow any district court will make a decision there

will send to resign tens of mayors of regional centers, well, it's just a mess , just a typical mess, i can't find words to describe these decisions, but the real reason for the attack on the mayor of chernihiv is related to the fact that he and his little-known political force at the all-ukrainian level in the chernihiv region had a sufficiently serious rating, a sufficiently serious rating , and he was indeed an influential political force and his possible alliance with vitaly, the nicknamed party, the coup, could indeed cause certain concerns. i want to remind you that after february 24, actually in march, last year in chernihiv oblast, elections were planned for one of the majority districts, and it was there that the representatives of this political team of the chernihiv mayor had all the chances of victory, well, actually, i followed the election campaign closely, there is quite an alternative victory, it

can never not be annoying, it can never be annoying, because in the offensive, now secretary of the city council, there is always a temptation to drive in manual mode , to drive in manual mode, this is very, very dangerous, dangerous trends. the committee of voters of ukraine emphasized, well, now he will tell the news for the last hour, angelika sezonka, we will listen to her carefully. thank you , colleagues, i will tell you about the fact that the enemy was shelling sumy, kherson region and zaporizhzhia, unfortunately , there are victims and victims in some regions and also carried out a night attack from the air about