[000:00:00;00] e-e of the main department of the legal police e-e was part of e-e limited to official relations yes not quite we worked together e-e law firm proten it was in the late 90s the dissolution of the higher qualification commission scandalous ambiguous decisions of the high council of justice judges collaborators and political influence on the judicial system, all this happened at a time when krasovsky was involved in the implementation of judicial reform, however, he himself, on the other hand, considers his work successful, claims that i missed all these processes through myself as the secretary of the working group on justice issues, it is obvious that kostyantyn krasovskyi has a successful career. he is very well-known in legal circles , a specialist, candidate of legal sciences

, master of public administration, head of the practice of art and constitutional law of one of the legal groups, and a teacher at the kyiv-mohyla academy, so we can assume that his professional consultation costs a lot but despite all these regalia, the candidate for the higher qualification commission of judges in 8 months of 2021, according to the declaration, earned 60 and a half thousand hryvnias, i.e. a little more than 7,000 uah per month, not really true. it’s like that for a lawyer, for a well-known lawyer, such an income. well, he is funny because how did he live on 7,000 uah? we called kostyantyn krasovsky and asked about his super ability to live on small money

this is kostyanty krasovsky. yes, this is the judicial control program on the espresso tv channel. we are analyzing candidates for the vkks and have several questions for you for 2021. you said that in eight months of work you made uah 60,000. please tell me why so little so if you look carefully there should be a declaration, you will see that there is not only uah 60,000 . so please look. i am currently in military service and i cannot give you an interview right now . kostiantyn krasovsky asked our editors to send him an official information request with all questions that we are interested in, but the answers from the candidate for the central committee

of the communist party of ukraine. life, practical, and theoretical for classes, and, accordingly, the motivation for taking the position of a member of the higher qualification commission of judges. i retired and became a lawyer. i retired because my wife is a judge and i am a judge. because the workload is quite high, practically. well, i have a daughter. which was eight or nine years, during which i had to help with education and in this. but i submitted the document. i didn't say goodbye to the judicial system. my documents in the qualification commission are for the position of judge e-e of the luhansk court of appeal, and i was going to i simply did not have such an opportunity to participate in the competition and to prepare for the post of judge in the north donetsk court. anna, being a lawyer, i could prepare and quite carefully. i decided

that i should try a little to work as a lawyer. that the war started , it is not possible, was my reason for resigning, interestingly, in the form of a warning , not last year, another disciplinary proceeding was opened based on a police officer's complaint about the judge's delay in the proceedings the case of driving a car while intoxicated, first of all, i don't really believe that i was guilty of the fact that i deprived the lawyer of the right to access to justice, but the court's decision is just the court's decision. on the 30th, i also

agreed to accept it. participation in the appeal of all this, and by the way, these complaints simply did not come to consideration. in general, according to the de jure foundation, luhanskyi closed at least 54 cases of drunken driving due to the influence of time limits, and sometimes the judge did not find grounds for prosecution drivers who violated the requirements to stop, the competition commission recommended the candidate for appointment, however, we have reasonable doubts regarding his integrity and legality of the sources of origin of the property , volodymyr luhansky was appointed to the position of judge in 2008. since then, his fortune has only grown. in 2010 , he purchased a house in luhansk for over 200 m², worth more than $90,000, almost

uah 30,000 was spent on 10 acres of land under it. in one year, a candidate for the central committee bought a 2010 mitsubishi pajero for almost $50,000. let's note about the appointment to the post of judge volodymyr luhansky worked for 17 years in the prosecutor's office. where did he get the money for expensive purchases, however, the question of volodymyr luhansky's integrity is not only about money. in 2011, volodymyr luhansky received the title of doctor of philosophy. but only in september 2014, the verkhovna rada of ukraine adopted changes that equated the title of candidate of sciences to the scientific degree of doctor of philosophy. luhansky used a time machine , however, he could not explain how it happened

, and he even forgot the name of the specialty for how did he defend his scientific thesis? what was the name of the thesis? was it clear that i defended myself? the subject was 382. article uh, it 's criminal responsibility for failure to comply with a court decision. i remember. well, i haven't seen my diploma for a long time. i took a photocopy. i just don't remember. i really don't remember. i understand, and the name of the specialty, we don't remember, i remember the job, i remember , but you don't remember this match, de jure, in 2014 and 2015, already after the occupation of crimea by russia and the start of the war in donbas, luhansky being

a referee north donetsk court at least visited the russian federation four times, but he was able to explain. not all the trips. i left the last of the judges . that is, i left already in luhansk. i was captured by the separatists, and i generally had to leave through the territory of russia. i left through the territory of russia . it really was that i went to the territory of russia, then , uh, i entered the luhansk region, uh, then there was another trip at the same time , there some insignificant period of time passed, and i left with my things, well, i didn't then the entire donetsk court was distributed, that is, they were in free flight and i was leaving. they took my things from the luhansk people's republic. i didn't go there, but i killed them on the territory of russia. there was a trip. i already

worked as a judge through the kharkiv region. i , uh, from well, how did i leave i took things from the territory of ukraine on the demarcation line. they also took my things away, but this one did not enter, took things and returned in 2020. volodymyr luhanskyi sold his apartment for nothing and, according to ukrainian law, he was in the city a north donetsk notary public has drawn up a contract of sale. by the way, i have it available, i gave it to the secret , well, today i did not take it with me, and that is, everything was done, the assessment was made of the apartment due to the amount of the assessment that was made

in principle, i sold this apartment. we hope that the supreme council of justice will take into account these facts of the biographies of applicants to the higher qualification commission of judges of ukraine and will make a balanced decision. for today, i had all this under judicial control and i am tetyana shustrova. if you know the facts of corruption in if you want to report to the judicial system that the court exceeded its powers or made illegal decisions, write to me on facebook or to the email address whose address you see on your screens. good luck , we will meet in exactly one week , the program of saturday nightfall on the air

of the espresso tv channel, angelika sezonka and vitaly portnikov in the first part of our broadcast, we will talk about the fact that when there will be a counteroffensive of the armed forces , the president talked about the plans of ukraine . calms are attacked almost every day with the air, we will talk about all this with our expert oleksandr musienko, the head of the center for military and legal research, we are in touch and we will talk about the main military events of this week, congratulations, mr. oleksandr, oleksandr, congratulations, well, the president of the country said that when he won't say when there will be a counteroffensive, when they will be, then we will find out in general, and there was a sense in such a number of forecasts, including official officials , that a counteroffensive in the spring and in a week, in

two, in three, tomorrow, the day after tomorrow is possible you just don't need to turn such a serious thing into a televised event, you see, it was probably impossible to do without it because this war is also special because of the coverage in the media, it began with a full-scale russian invasion, it began with the fact that the plans for the invasion were published in american and not only american media, and so on it all went and went and continues like this until today, so probably it will not be possible to fight with it, i want to remind you that at one of the rammstein conferences, the minister of defense of the united states voivodeship said that a ukrainian counteroffensive was expected in the spring. after that, there were other messages that changed . it seems to me that such a frequency of messages was related to extinguishing these messages from moscow about the fact that now there will be some negotiations and ukraine will not de-occupy its territory because it seems that

there will not be enough strength, these competitions in the statements are rather statements about the counteroffensive, who will say more , who will say about the terms and the like, they were connected with the fact that something was calmed down our western partners because we are really preparing for that, give us support, give us weapons well, actually speaking, after the big seven took place in japan in principle , the situation calmed down a bit, as it seems to me , because they were sure that the russian troops should leave the territory of ukraine and ukraine must advance and now the story has already moved into the summer offensive of what we are expecting and once again another round of conversation took place, oleksandr, you as an expert in this field. please tell me what conditions should be created in order for the counteroffensive to learn and are we getting close to the fact that they are provided well, i do not mean only

weapons, but perhaps the natural environment is meant, so the weather conditions. you see, i will tell you the main condition, which means that all conditions are important. the weather, the weapons, the prepared reserves, the troops, the main condition without which the offensive will not take place, even with all that i have listed, this is determination , determination, this is the most important thing, that is, what i see now, what i see now, what is justified. let's say yes, it is suspicious to talk about the fact that this counteroffensive can lead to losses on the ukrainian side. therefore, it may be worth waiting, we still need weapons, it is possible to transfer some and so on, this is understandable. these are completely understandable things, because we understand very well that war, unfortunately, leads to losses otherwise otherwise, they don’t happen freely, no one has yet fought in a different way, and

here it seems to me that when there is a decision, a strong willful decision that it needs to be started, then i think everything will start according to all the remaining parameters, everything is ready in principle to what extent do we understand the intentions and actions of the russian military command, because we talk a lot about ukrainian intentions, but we always ignore the russian intentions, as if the russians simply have to sit and wait when they will be attacked, or could it be that the russians are preparing their reservists, what are they thinking about this actions in other e-e directions , where in principle there are no occupied territories, they are definitely preparing reserves. these points that we have observed are precisely the reserves that russia receives in the occupied territories in order to counter the ukrainian offensive

, that is, in this case, the absolutely correct strikes of the ukrainian military command and our forces on the reserves that are planned to be used, and this, by the way, can also be perceived as such preparation for future counter-offensive actions, we cannot fail to mention that the war was defended on its territory, we see shelling almost every day in the belgorod region, in particular, and people die , the civilian population, as reported by the local the government, at least the russian army, is fighting the partisans with the legion of freedom of russia, how quickly and let’s say if it is at all possible for this war to scale up on the territory of the russian federation. it would be good if it were scaled up, because you know the principle divides the ruler and it’s better not to say and in the end , let’s say the main and main condition is to cause internal political instability

in the enemy's state. this is the first condition and the second is to force the enemy to redeploy his troops from the direction from the same reserves in the occupied luhansk region or donetsk region to other places, well, that is, for example, belgorod region, kursk region, bryansk region, wherever this is scaled, today it is actively developing in the belgorod region, it is clear that russia cannot fully support this and guarantee the security of its borders , it is already obvious, although i can tell you what according to the information i have, russia was supposed to use it to cover the state borders in the direction starting from chernihiv, sumy, kharkiv oblasts , about 25 military personnel. where did they go ? obviously, they are all now the occupied part of the territory of ukraine, that is, they actually neglected the protection of their borders, which means that there are indeed reasons

to believe that this may spread to other border regions of the russian region, and everything will depend on how rapidly the popularity of these movements will grow. i mean the freedom of the republic of russia others and the next moment. well, how quickly will they start to clash with each other, not only with the official security forces, but with the wagnerites, and possibly the squadrons, and so on. that is, it will spread the flames of this instability, which will be a manifestation of the signs of the civil war, they say, in principle, that the impression is that the russians did not think at all that any actions could take place on their sovereign territory, so that they themselves also divide the occupied territory for themselves, which they consider to be the same russian as the noble and internationally recognized territory of the russian federation, and there is nothing at all there it cannot happen according to what is defined, it is absolutely correct , but it must be done right away, first of all, they are constantly confused in the definitions, they say war in

ukraine well, the propagandists there, from their point of view, they annexed the territories, war goes on the territory of russia, but they are divided absolutely correctly , you er-e marked this fact and in principle, it is noticeable to me that, in principle , despite the division of these territories, they do not care to the same extent what happens on the left bank of kherson region or what happens in belgorod region well, these are obvious things in principle, today, with what is happening, that is, it is quite a revealing moment, in fact, with how russia, the central government, as the kremlin, refers to its individual subjects, which are included precisely in the territories that make up what is called the russian federation, of course, i am not sure that this will sober up and make the majority of russian citizens think, but at the same time, i think it should be indicative for many of the attitude in general, even to their own territories, and here you have to ask questions, and to hell

with the territory of another independent if you want to sneeze your own pigs in the end, well, drones, i also wanted to mention that they are already falling on rublevka, and they say that even at the moment when they landed, let's say they were allegedly shot down and the debris only fell, but a few there were also hits, that is, not all of them were able to shoot down. therefore, their anti-aircraft defense does not work as well as putin told and, allegedly , he was at his residence near moscow at that time, and everyone was very scared there. alexander, how they will continue to act cannot be told all the time. only that everything is fine with us. and the territory of russia is protected and sovereign, and in fact people see what is happening, drones fly into their windows. you see that, in principle, this does not yet affect the reaction of people to the extent that it would lead to some serious

processes, in fact, everything in in a reactionary form. by the way, in an aggressive form, he is the only one . is happening and i am currently there, there is a completely different attitude, of course there can be a good attitude towards the beautiful woman, there should not be but at the same time, he begins to gather around himself precisely those who think like him, what is happening is a complete mess and so far i see only his statements so far, i see that only he is somehow trying to reflect on this, well, some of those residents of rublevka and other suburbs of moscow who recorded a video about something, talked about something and the like, that is, the defining reference point for us in this case should be the way

reactions who and how reacts and if the handsome man manages to rally around himself the same as himself and others there support groups and arrange what he warned about in 1917 i was in russia i will consider that the mission with drones was completed on the 12th with a plus, a can do that, which is beautiful, they simply instruct them to release a pair so as not to offend anyone, to give those who think so the opportunity to have their own representative, so to speak . well, although in the telegram channels, i think that the russian leadership definitely counted on this, definitely such a role, they come from they were preparing from the very beginning, but they left out one moment, this is the moment when the so-called handsome man began to walk in vovkus and he began to like the fact that he can really become some kind of alternative plus i think that

representatives of certain circles poured into his ears in particular, in russia and the special services about the fact that he can be and rally around himself certain such groups, and when he got a taste of this , he began to get out of control, and that's why even if some people in the kremlin now think that everything is normal and everything goes according to the script and that's all a theatrical play. i think they are wrong because it seems more and more that he is really starting to play his game. what is happening in the bahamut is interesting because the deputy minister of defense hanna malyar said that the wagnerites still cannot get out of the bahamut because what the armed forces of ukraine created such conditions for them, and prigozhyn, let's say, postpone the release date every time, and it actually looks quite ridiculous, it is clear that they absolutely do not include the fact that they wanted their plans to be destroyed. but have the armed

forces of ukraine already surrounded the city so much that they were in a cauldron the russians are on the right. this is the fact that our forces are really advancing in the north and in the south and are entrenched from the flanks, and this means that the battle for bakhmut continues, and not as the enemy propaganda says that it has ended. and that it has ended successfully is not the ukrainian forces have every chance to advance and really create an encirclement for the russian grouping of troops, so far there is no question of a complete encirclement, it is still possible to say about a semi -encirclement, and because in principle there is a logistical connection from the occupied territory to bakhmut and hostilities there continue from time to time, the russian troops try once again, they fail to attack on the flanks, push back our positions

. it will be bad, why i will explain to him, it depends on how the russian troops will enter or in what number and whether they will be able to establish themselves in reality, as it seems to me that it is possible now that someone in the russian command is interested in the fact that the wagnerites do not leave and that they stayed there as long as possible that no one wants to get into a potential cauldron, this must also be understood, so let's see how the situation will develop further, after all, the russian paratroopers would have come, if it had not been there, a certain part of the wagnerites had already left and left a few days ago, a small part of them still remains, but at the same time, a large number of russian troops do not enter bakhmut itself. they are trying to oppose our forces on the flanks , obviously realizing that bakhmut can now turn into a serious trap for them, and in principle, if we talk about the further development of events e- around this idea of ​​vladimir putin

that it is necessary to enter the administrative borders of the donetsk luhansk regions, but now you can say that for russia this has ceased to be the main priority in the war. i think not, because if there was no seizure of territory, it would remain a -a one of the priorities, let’s just say, if we take the obimuchy direction and everything that was there, there were two priorities that they set. they wanted to pull out the ukrainian combat reserves and simply destroy them in this direction so that the ukrainian forces do not prepare for future counteroffensive campaigns. this was the primary goal, and then, of course, a derivative of this is to continue the advance and capture the donetsk region, simply because the ukrainian forces did not allowed them to implement this task and now they have stopped and are solving their tactical issues to date and are actually on the defensive, but if they had the opportunity as

soon as they replenished their supplies and reserves, i am convinced that they would try to break through . and in these same directions, it is possible to - to another and again to try to take over the donetsk region in full, we will talk about attacks, and in particular on the capital , the enemy carries them out almost every day. is it possible that they still produce themselves because they are acting as if sanctions are in effect, they cannot get certain spare parts, they still have stocks . well, first of all, i will say from the sanctions, you understand , you should not have useless illusions that the sanctions can 100% e- let's say cancel the production of any weapons. well, because sanctions can worsen , sanctions can reduce volumes, sanctions can create logistical problems, but the black and gray market

works and russia is also present in it, besides , you understand that under the guise of technologies dual-purpose, unfortunately, over the past year, russia has imported many different electronic elements that can be used both in civilian life and in the military for the production of missiles, of course, the volume of missiles has decreased compared to what they could produce , but according to various estimates, now from 30 to 50 missiles per month in russia three types of k101x55 caliber are produced there, this is the second time they really stocked up because i want to remind you that there were no large-scale attacks after that during this time they stocked up for the third time , they were able to fix and continue the production of dagger missiles, how did they do it, through which countries did they import the schemes, it should be investigated, of course, but the ability to strike and the production of missiles , unfortunately, they currently have at least 30

dashes of 50 missiles per month, but at the same time, it gives the opportunity to accumulate and from time to time to deliver such blows in addition. please note that now the tactics of the enemy have changed from the side that before . missiles strike, but they do it more often, that’s how they actually modify it, and we see shaheds, we can also say that they are put on stream, because from the number of their use in russia, problems with their production in early delivery in russia are obviously not observed and, unfortunately, the money is in russia do not end thank you mr. oleksandria , head of the center for military and legal research and now our guest is target ponomaryev in russian , a positioner, a former deputy of the state duma of the russian federation, welcome to the panel good

evening, we do not see the panel good evening well, yes anyway, what is happening in belohorodsk ? tell us, what? well , what is the special military operation going on right now ? and that's all. do you think that there are still certain other groups that are ready to oppose putin's regime? what other groups are there? there are two divisions, and the first one is me , the legion of freedom of russia, and the second one is the russian the volunteer corps, these are the two groups they are working there, this is not their first joint operation, it was already there