[000:00:00;00] verkhovna rada of ukraine draft law on amendments to some legislative acts of ukraine regarding the verification of information about patients of the registration mir 92 72 i ask to vote for 249 the decision was made, i put the proposal to reduce by half the deadline for submitting proposals on the rules for preparation for the second reading of the draft law 92 72 i ask to vote for 214, we will not shorten the terms of the next draft law 75-77 is a draft law on amendments to some legislative acts on improving the management system

of engineering infrastructure objects meliorative systems of state property, i propose to adopt this draft law as a basis for the elaboration of the provisions in accordance with the first part of article 116 of the regulations of the verkhovna rada of ukraine 75 77 i ask you to vote for 237 the decision has been adopted dear colleagues, the following draft law which we have without discussion is a draft law 82 23 this is a draft law on the introduction of amendments to some laws of ukraine regarding the protection of people from the effects of ionizing radiation, i propose this 8223

proposal to adopt this draft law as a basis, i ask the people's deputies to vote for 260 decisions have been made. i am asking iryna volodymyrivna from the procedure, please. thank you from the procedure. as we know according to the decision of the law on media, e.e., the verkhovna rada of ukraine is broadcast on the recording by rada tv channel. i want to draw the attention of my colleagues to the fact that yesterday in marathon footage of the evacuation of citizens from the kherson oblast was shown, which actually showed not ukrainian rescuers but also the fsb of russia. this is a very important issue. i want to raise it now in the session hall so that everyone understands what public money is used for. i would like to draw attention to of the verkhovna rada on the fact that in marathon we have no right to tolerate such unprofessionalism and uh, in fact, the rada channel should not only

broadcast the meetings of the parliament and you know perform its functions directly and informing about the work of committees and the work of parliamentary factions and not broadcasting it is unclear what kind of state funds are simply a shame thank you dear colleagues the next draft law without discussion is draft law 8235 is a draft law on amending the complete criminal code of ukraine on the elimination of ukrainian criminal disputes offenses i put the proposal to accept as a basis i put the proposal to accept as a basis with the revision of the provisions in accordance with the first part of article 116 of the regulations of the verkhovna rada of ukraine the draft law on amendments to the complete criminal code of ukraine regarding the contradictions in the scope of criminal offenses registration number 8235 ready to vote

i ask the people deputies to vote for 279 decisions, the following draft law was adopted without discussion, which we agreed on 7354 is a draft law on amendments to the code of ukraine on administrative offenses regarding the invitation of administrative responsibility in the field of training and admission of drivers to drive vehicles i put forward a proposal i put forward a proposal to adopt as a basis this draft law number 7354 for

266 decisions the following draft law was adopted without discussion this is 0:200 draft legalization of the convention of member states of the organization for the democrats and the economic development of guam on mutual assistance in consular matters, i put the proposal to accept on the basis of the whole with the necessary technical legal amendments project 0.200, i ask the people's deputies to vote for 274 decisions , the following project 0204 is adopted - this is a draft law on qualification for the koala-lumpur goya, in addition to the protocol on liability for compensation to the potato protocol on biosecurity, i put the proposal to be accepted as a basis as a whole with the necessary technical legal amendments bills registration number 02.04 please

vote for 273 the decision has been made, let's move on to the next bill that we have without discussion 83.19 this the draft law on the declaration of the natural territories of the city of morshyn, the natural territories of the morshyn deposit of mineral therapeutic brines and the natural territories of the niniv deposit of mineral therapeutic brines of the lviv region as a resort of state importance dear colleagues , i propose to adopt this draft law as a basis. with the necessary technical

legal amendments draft law 83:19 i ask people's deputies to vote in favor of 265 decisions have been made dear colleagues further in us e-e 80:24 we said that no one will introduce amendments to this draft law on amendments to the law of ukraine on culture regarding the implementation and introduction of electronic registers of accounting and management of cultural heritage and cultural values ​​of ukraine i put the proposal to be adopted in the second reading and in as a whole with the necessary technical legal amendments bill 824 asks people

's deputies to vote for 271 decision made next what we agreed without discussion from 61 34 is the draft law on the protection of consumer rights i put the proposal to adopt in the second reading and in general with the necessary technical and legal amendments the draft law on the protection of consumer rights registration number 61 34 are ready to vote i ask the people's deputies to vote in favor of 263 the decision has been adopted the law is adopted in general the following draft law which we agreed upon without discussion is here well, we have come to

the constitutional court. now , what number do you say to artur volodymyrovych next ? 93:22 is a draft law on amending some legislative acts of ukraine to clarify

the provisions on the competitive selection of candidates for the position of judge of the constitutional court of ukraine . chairman of the committee on legal policy mass unit of vyacheslavovich i apologize, he is also the author of the first draft law if possible, i will start with him and then irina volodymyrivna, of course we we will get to you, denis, please, thank you colleagues, i will not occupy your attention for long, i just want to remind you that the first recommendation of the european commission regarding the acquisition of candidate status with us in the european union applied specifically to the board of judges of the constitutional

court, and we have to implement it in accordance with the recommendation of the venice colleagues of the commission , yesterday the venice commission at its plenary meeting approved the conclusion, and today it was published that it fully supports, recommends, e-e noted that all the recommendations of the keys in the inetsia commissions were implemented by us in the draft law mainly 93:22 and she does not see any obstacles and as soon as we approve it, she will be ready to provide her representatives to the advisory group of experts who will choose candidate judges more precisely for the position of judge of the constitutional court and this is an important victory for us and you further then we have to continue and adopt this draft law as a basis in the hall , there is nothing special to prepare, even

taking into account the opinion of the venice commission for the second reading, but we and the venice commission will quickly and efficiently work it out together the question to the second reading and we will pass this law. i think that in the near future, in general, everyone will be with you, and finally in ukraine there will be a real competitive selection of judges of the constitutional court, which takes into account our desire to be open and understandable to international partners, taking into account our relationship with you as much as possible sovereignty of our country and respect for our national experts . serhiy volodymyrovych vlasenko does not have a draft law. yes, he is on a business trip. i know torokhtii bohdan grigoryovych will speak

his way. then please, one more author of the draft law . here, in general, they shouted at you that in this version they simply will not be read by the european union because they contradict both the constitution and common sense and create absolutely dependent constitutional court and in fact our team immediately submitted draft law 8 3 proposed to standardize the law on the pension court in order to make it independent, but traditionally everything that is from european solidarity does not apply to the sessional part of what our alternative is now from various many things that i unlike the criteria of the nazi commission from the main one, firstly, we propose all experts to the council of the council, secondly, we propose that

more of the experts should be international experts how is the group formed today that gives recommendations to the judges of the anti-corruption court, thirdly, the tsitsik commission tells you honestly and directly that it cannot be one and the same , but the creation of the council, by the way, and according to the constitution of the judges of the constitutional court, and you put it again in the bill , fourthly, in fact, it is our bill gives the necessity of the accuracy of the formation of this advisory public council in order for there to be an independent constitutional court for the fifth please tell me what kind of norm this is and in which other country does it even exist when in your main project you lay such a novel as deputies of the representatives of this public council of experts, by the way, what kind of deputies are they, in fact, we call on the hall to refrain from the main bill and vote for the one that fully meets

the criteria of the venice commission, there is no need to rewrite for the fifth time what will absolutely not meet european standards and called for laws in independence from the names of the deputies and from dear colleagues dear colleagues will you still be from the committee denisuvalovich please from the committee denis maslov dear colleagues then we will vote two for two against laska denisovych from the committee, what was the decision of the committee, colleagues, the decision of the committee was to recommend adopting the main draft law 93:22 in the first reading as a basis and to address the chairman of the verkhovna rada at the plenary session to announce the application of article 116 of the regulations of the verkhovna rada eh literally a couple of words i would like to say

the venetian the commission clearly said 93:22 fully meets its recommendations so we vote and move on thank you how dear colleagues, i ask you to sign up two for two against after that we proceed to the vote either please, please, please, petrovych volodymyr mykhailovych, the european solidarity faction, please give the floor, ivan

yakovych, sensadze, ivan orestivna, please, dear colleagues, i would like to remind you that in december, this hall applauded the adoption of the draft law on the selection of judges of the constitutional court, and mr. maslov, too , that the draft law fully complies with the recommendations of the venice commission we then warned that it was profanation, then we spoke on behalf of our faction, we were the only faction that did not vote for that profanation and that as we warned through seven months, we have to correct the mistake that ended up like this, colleagues from the monomajority, we passed then you passed the wrong draft law that did not meet the recommendations of the venice commission, yes, yesterday the venice commission passed a mostly positive conclusion on your main draft law, i want to draw your attention, they made proposals like needs to be improved and i want

to draw attention to the fact that the venice commission expressed its regret over the fact that they refused to appoint 7 members of this selection commission as they propose alternative draft laws in particular, european solidarity, therefore, colleagues, it will be necessary to finalize this bill before the second reading in full accordance with the recommendations of the venice commission and stop turning a blind eye to ukrainian society, we know what responsibility is, we know what responsibility is for the candidate status that was granted to us and that we, our defenders, obtained blood, therefore, be worthy of what our army and our armed forces of ukraine gave you the opportunity to do, follow the

recommendations that were given to you. thank you, please the right to reply to the people . yes, maslov from the spot, please include the contents of the contents . fulfilled the recommendations of the venice commission, which was confirmed yesterday and published today by the public venice commission , so we vote and move on, thank you very much dear colleagues oleksandr volodymyrovych kovalchuk faction of the political party servant

to the people, please, maxim, for what term, please, please, i urge you to support this draft law 93:22, and it really became a problem for the head of the committee that the committee fulfilled all the requirements set by the police commission, and this is our step towards joining the european union, and for what the previous speakers speak from the podium and call for some violations or some inaccuracies. this is just manal manipulation, and therefore i ask you all to support this bill in the first reading with the foundation article 116 of the regulations, thank you, thank you, please, ivanych, then mykhailo mykhailovych tsymbalyuk, dear colleagues, after that, we vote, i ask you to invite this bill

for the sake of which, in principle, it is because further european integration obligations are not a shooter. to the european union. thank you to hryhoriy mykolayovych, we don't know where he is on the road . hryhoriy mykolayovych, please, dear people's deputies, i want to draw your attention to the fact that we are considering this draft law in the first the conclusion of the venice commission is being read, and all the battles are going on like we have in the hall regarding the number of commission members and what powers they have to make decisions in our draft law 6 according to the number of commission members, if three out of three are against, which will be the final decision or the exhibition of the special commission whether members or seven, it is still necessary to decide between the first and second reading and

make the appropriate decisions, and at the moment it is up to the speaker, if the number is different , the draft law and the exhibition of the venice commission what will we take as a basis, thank you, thank you, please, tsimbalyuk mykhailo mykhailovych faction of the fatherland dear colleagues , after that we will proceed to the vote, please give the floor to yulia tymoshenko, please yulia volodymyrivna tymoshenko, i honestly do not understand the puppy's enthusiasm for this law and we are just wondering what kind of education you have in the hall have you ever reread the constitution, at least without a pencil, you know, it’s just surprising what kind of parliament our native ukraine received during the war, dear friends, let

our partners show us at least one country of the world, not to mention the countries of europe where the constitutional court is not formed by the system of ukraine itself, you who sell theaters to the right and left in the kyiv region , what are you doing, at least report to yourself , dear friends, to the constitutional court - this is the last order of a sovereign country that gives the opportunity everything that is done under pressure against the national interests of ukraine against the rights and freedoms of people in the constitutional court should be stopped . and you want such cool global corporations to be normal, and the constitutional court was appointed to us? look, when did that happen? for the venice commission to have three conclusions

that contradict each other three for one of the same text please leave the constitutional court alone, it is formed one-third by the president, one-third by you, the verkhovna rada and one-third by the congress of judges, which to the council working group that was dropped from space for us can form for us proposals for the president of the country, what are you doing, what do you imagine ?

motives dear colleagues, let's move on to voting. everyone spoke from the procedure , i can only give if it will be from the procedure, please, who is from poroshenko's procedure, and after that , it's fine. european integration, we did not consider the draft law that was signed by me in european solidarity for a year and a half , european integration was blocked in the constitutional court, and today you are leaving and he says that the royal commission approved our conclusion, it completely destroyed what you did not accept then, it supported the bill that we submitted and now it must be voted on in the first reading, but

the responsibility for these six months, so i apologize, petro oleksiyovych, you took it out of the procedure and abusing your by right, not from the procedure well, not honestly, please, burmich from the procedure, not from the procedure, i stop , i warn you, please anatoliy pavlovich dear colleagues of the restoration of ukraine, anatoliy burmich hmm, i want to inform you that our the anti-corruption draft law also considered all these projects and all of them were unanimously recognized as bills containing corruption risks , and not one, but several. i wonder to our leaders why they do not bring this to the deputies . dear colleagues, take your seats, your very important homeland, the key discussion that

took place in the committee, there are currently three draft laws that exist as alternatives , our proposal was made by a number of deputies on committee is to give the opportunity to the venetian commission to draw a conclusion on all three draft laws so that we do not once again get a situation where a previous law was hastily pushed through, which was then actually recognized by the venetian commission as not in line with the spirit of the european e-e specific position, so our proposal is now postponed by you as the chairman of the verkhovna rada, we can instruct you to send all draft laws that were prepared for consideration by the vinnytsia commission and, as a result of this consideration, to vote on the appropriate

draft law thank you thank you dear colleagues as far as i understand the conclusion of the medical committee is already there, so let's move on to the effective voting on this draft law, i ask the people's deputies to take their seats dear colleagues, the people's deputies , take their seats the draft law on amendments to certain legislative acts of ukraine on clarification

of the provisions on the competitive selection of candidates for the position of a judge of the constitutional court of ukraine, registration number 9322 dear colleagues are ready to vote, i ask the people's deputies to vote brovary for 248, the decision has been made thank you dear colleagues from the factions, please show me a second, i have a letter from the faction of the groups first, we will vote right away dear colleagues, i just got here a letter signed by all representatives of the faction of the group has been received to urgently consider and make a decision on the draft law of ukraine on amendments to clause xviii article 10-1 of the law of ukraine on the social legal protection of servicemen and their family members regarding the leave of servicemen, registration number 903 78 dated 10.06.2023, will be confirmed without amendment. i will immediately put it to the vote

. dear colleagues, get ready to vote. in the second reading and as a whole with the necessary technical and legal amendments , the draft law on amendments to clause 18 of article 10-1 of the law of ukraine on social and legal protection military personnel and members of their families regarding the leave of military personnel, registration number 9378 are ready to vote, i ask the people 's deputies to vote for 270 decisions, the law has been adopted to adopt the law as a whole by factions please show