[000:00:00;00] i looked at empathy. i believe that the big problem was that in 2014 we had too many people who empathized with russia. we remember these sad episodes and which became the first reason why we did not conquer certain cities of donbas, for example nazad ta and crimea, and because we didn't have many combat-ready troops, and unfortunately there were episodes even in the now very famous brigades when they refused to shoot at the occupiers , that's why, in fact, look, we've achieved the first results for the 10th year, unfortunately, at a very, very expensive price . but the work is done i'm crazy too it seems that we no longer have such an adequate person in ukraine, who was it? no, i will not shoot a russian, he is normal, but they are also abnormal in independence from the article, from

age and so on, i will remind all viewers. we used to remember when there were such idlers burning shopping centers winter cherry how many ladies and gentlemen did we have , who the next day ran to lay flowers at the embassy of the russian federation, empathized just terribly, so i managed to find information that a few little girls who were hanging out there in this shopping center in the center, then they calmly went to kyiv, he and it was they who wanted to take kyiv in three days, they were both captured and killed, just children born in 2000 in 2001-2002 russian children i have literally three of us there wait a minute, i still want to hear your opinion on one more topic, i will add it later to discuss it, but i , er, about this, here is this discussion that arose because the people's deputy and nataliya pipe approached the guy who played tsoi on the streets of lviv

began to answer her obscenely that well, she is made a remark that why play russian songs, even if it's obscene, to answer this guy, he already turned out to be here , he lived in lviv, his mother was in odesa, he was already sent to odesa back well, that's how his story ends, but it probably caused a discussion , it involved a lot of what you say white volts with the fact that they don't touch tsoi and other things, you know, i have this idea that it's just er , tsoi is lenin, it's just that now for this generation it's already that maxima lenin lived, she's no longer relevant let's think of something else who he lived in our pjsc, but it is still a russian peace. how can people understand that we are not there specifically? maybe someone is against a specific person, viktor robertovych, who killed half a korean, and specifically against the fact that the russian peace will impose anything on you, even though i will be shaky muni if only he was with the russian world and you loved it and felt community , please. i think that people have bad taste, and if you still listen to russian, you have very bad taste in music, then you can listen to it, but

everything would be at home in the kitchen in relation to public seats i understand that it was the center of lviv, we have a law about music in public places and taking into account that natalka is a piper in general , she and the deputy are majoritarians of lviv and accordingly this district she had er had full right to make such a remark er eh, wartime, secondly, there is such and such a moment, and there a guy appeared as a minor, uh, somewhere . well, let's go to 2006, the seventh and eighth year . someone from the ukrainians, for example pivovarova or even nadia dorofeeva, in particular, it was necessary to play the guitar of this idiot. well, regarding this defense, look. it is a great luck that this person died long before all these events

, before the chechen wars, before the attack on georgia and before the attack on ukraine because i don't include the fact that he could be the same quilter well, look, it's so small remarka we remember when i was still a teenager, what was a super trendy song, i forgot its name, but which was performed by chicheri, which two everyone just played on guitars and in every yard of the transition, if i remember, schlaner, a student, recorded all this, but chicheri reached a point and it's private, and now they are fighting with the safes of the russian army in donbas, and the song somehow disappeared. i thank you marina marina dalyuk yarmaeva was with us thank you for your thoughts and for this communication er journalist blogger er and now we will not have a long pause, we will not switch with you, let's continue i invite a conversation to maxim the smart we continue to talk about this topic maxim the smart has a doctor

of philosophy, wait, there are discounts on pantestyn darnytsia gel 10% in pharmacies. plantain for you and savings. this was me before. bleeding gums, inflammation of the gums, and the solution was so simple . gum problems lacalut active lacalut active actively overcomes bleeding gums , protects against periodontitis and visibly tightens . plus an even more active defense north macedonia ukraine at the selection of euro 2024 june 16 at 21:00 in the country's team hello i am a denisolian after the start of the audacious

invasion of russian troops into ukraine i i returned home from finland, where i used to play. i really love my motherland and its people, and i am also conditionally proud of our soldiers. glory to ukraine, there are discounts on skin-friendly pantestin , a gift of 10% in pharmacies. traveller, and savings . the war continues, and not only for the territory, it is also a war for umy russia is throwing millions of petrodollars to turn ukrainians into a low-russian ukraine, the state of the highway, analysis and analysis of information about ukraine by russian propagandists, specific facts and methods by which hostile propaganda transforms

obedient people, zombie-like inhabitants of the people's republic of china, we resist the information attacks of the russians in the project of the chronicle of the information war with olga leni tuesday, thursday, friday at 5:10 p.m. on the espresso tv channel vasyl zimi's big broadcast , two hours of air time, two hours of your time, two hours to learn about the war and what he lives the world for 2 hours to keep abreast of economic news and new sports, two hours in the company of favorite presenters, presenters who have become like-minded to many, as well as distinguished guests of the studio, events of the day in two hours , vasyl's big broadcast in winter, a project for intelligent and in the evening, the most important thing is the war in ukraine, the main topic for ukrainians is victory and loss, analysis and forecasts, politics and geopolitics, all this will be discussed by serhiy rudenko and the guests

of his program, people who have information and shape public opinion, people who defend ukraine and create the future right now , the main and interesting thing in verdict program by serhiy rudenko from monday to friday at 20:00 , repeat at 12:10 oleksia rostovets , reacting to this scandal with soybeans, let me remind you that in lviv on the streets of the city, people's deputy natalya pipa saw guys who sang tsoi's music in russian, of course we will make a remark because we have a law on language, we actually have many nuances, he started swearing obscenely, this guy has already gone to his native home in odessa, and aleksey aristovych , who is a lot, defends russia and the russian language in ukraine at the same time somehow, remaining an officer of the armed forces of ukraine and having a wide atere, he said so, i

will quote . he is sitting like that, who knows him, he is a pathetic model from youtube, she herself demonstrated examples of behavior that should be admired a-a i never spoke about a small ukrainian culture, but i actually mentioned it better, but better arguments in favor of this thesis than your own behavior does not exist, a pathetic set replacing the cowardice of beggars in defense, like replacing the devaluation of sitters and aunts, it 's european culture, it's psychiatry. well, that's what he did, very, very harshly . in fact, no one ever accused tsoi of because he is a pitiful copy of an irish group , that's why he was noted for plagiarizing such english groups as kurize, well, that's a fact, but it's so simple, until we continue this discussion, we'll understand what for russian, for russian narratives that represent er, conditionally, but now a conditional arrestee, many others, er, tsoi is not important, that is, the specific

viktor robertovych soyna, half of korets, who died on august 15, 1990 in latvia even before the collapse of the soviet union, there is no relation to her in her work. i think that of these people, they did not know tsoi’s work, his life path, and they will never know, but this is such an image that can be taken and pulled out, like the russians, many people pull out ivan the terrible , we need to pull out razin’s wall, we need to pull out emelyan pugachev , we need to pull out minin and pozharsky pushkin. dostoevsky's pyotr pyro is not important. the main thing is that you feel a sense of community . we are talking about what is common to us and to you, and there is nothing in common between us except the shot . maksym the reasonable doctor is with us philosophy, poet, political scientist, maksym, i congratulate you. good afternoon, i will tell you . yes, i, er, when, well, i see it. besides, i came to kyiv for a concert. he had a concert in the palace of sports, and at that time i was a teenager. i was

for 13 years when he died yes, 13 years, er, at that time, let's say, i didn't have access, as i was still a very young teenager , i didn't have the opportunity to buy some cassettes or cds or records from fartsovshchik somewhere, we won't be a player, a radio technician, riga e- well, there were records there, but i didn't have records of foreign groups because we couldn't i got it when i earned money in the collective farm. in the summer, i used to go to the tsum and on the first floor of the kyiv sum there if you go down the street along bohdan khmelnytskyi street up, er, it used to be lenin street, in my opinion, that means tsoi and talkov cassettes were sold there. well, there's more i bought some of them because, well, there was no other music at that time to buy, but i don’t understand, let’s say now, why young people update tsoi, who just died a long time ago, and others support him so much, and do you agree with my opinion? well, you have not her to agree, but i will voice her that that tselenin just now, again, lenin is not a relevant phrase, lenin lived, lenin lived, lenin lived, lenin will live. she will not cause a mental reaction to anyone, that's why they pushed tsoi in. why not play with it to once again show

the general is there something between us, or is that how you perceive it, or this discussion that arose? it is because of viktor tsoi that his music can be interpreted differently , please. i think that uh, i agree with one of the theses that you expressed earlier, that is, this one is actually unimportant in this situation uh well for contrast, i'll tell you, for example, that not so long ago, i read a discussion in the russian context, well, there, for example, soy is considered a seller, that is, the cia specially taught him to write the song мы ждём перемен and thus contributed to the collapse of the soviet union. that is, well, we do not need to multiply, so to speak, the essences where there is where coincidence works, that is

, the fact that this young man was playing tsoi on the streets of lviv, and that at that time a people's deputy was passing revealed its civil dryness, so to speak - this is the coincidence of several factors a if we talk about some more large-scale and regular things, then today we are really dealing with the displacement of the russian, soviet, russian, i mean the soviet and the soviet heritage from the cultural circulation. - in general, it is natural when the empire leaves the past and especially when the so-called empire snaps when it tries to somehow regain its control eh, eh, the imperial

becomes hostile and no one understands it anymore is it that one or is it pushkin or is it eh tolstoy one or this tolstoy two or this fat in general, number three, it’s the same as the indians don’t really understand, let’s say that there’s byron or kipling, for them it’s all colonizers uh, that is, there is really uh, such a culture war and uh, it’s justified because uh, because we have to free ourselves of course, that any release, it is so, from the outside, it may not look very attractive, and it is the problem of the same oleksiy arrestovych or his circle , because in fact there is a certain circle of popular, well-known people in ukraine who stand

on these loans e-e positions in order to they are not inside this process, but they are trying to evaluate it from the outside , that is, it is not clear. then where are they, since there is an imperial context, there is a ukrainian context, well, in theory, there is a universal context , but he, uh, in a specific situation, he is either on the side of this guy who is uh-hugging well mp, what did you say to him, or is he on the side of the patriotic public that demands to remove imperial content from the public space , we actually had such a cool singer , andriy bokolaichuk, i remember him, i always see him on the independence square, it was still a square like the japanese revolution , he walked barefoot and in a suit and it was very surprising , but he was a star of that time, so the question is why

people don’t sing songs by mykolaichuk, let’s say there i will drown or underground kindrat or something others, or dead rooster, or whom down , well, the music was beautiful here. the question is that how is it promoted? the first album was famous for uh- a star called the sun and then the black album, in fact , before the recording of this album, the group already wanted to break up. i think they will write another album , it exploded so feet. and before that, he had many such fashionable songs and one one of the songs was called and i like the city of moscow , and there were such words in it, i'm happy, i'm happy, i call, if it's bad , i vomit, if i drink too much, i'm 10, i'm living in a dream , it seems to me that these people are actually 10 years old, maybe much older live in the spring and they do not want to wake up to a new reality, but it is the people who know it best, always those people who do not know dostoyevsky, they do not know him, that is why they do not know gogol well, who thinks he is an ethnic ukrainian, but there are those who attribute him to russia, let them attribute their work

, they do not know the same his own views on his life path and so on, they just spoil this one into such a mess, you love it because it’s russia well, it’s not russia, first of all, but secondly , it’s important to understand that this cooperation with russia is not going to happen if they don’t offer it to us again, you want to study yours, study at home, play it, play it there, these chords of the song, there are a lot of philosophical things of some kind , please, but you don’t need to make it a subject of discussion, because people like arrestees, many others, they are suitable, they will immediately take it to the public space, they will say that a small culture and degenerates. you don't understand great art. well, why don't you study the question in the hospital of art, let's say the queen group or the youtube group rolling stones or many other groups and so on. well, i'm fine i wanted to ask you much more interestingly, because i read your post and why i invited you because of this about the empathy of ukrainians, because it is for our own understanding of this thesis that i said at the beginning of the broadcast, unfortunately you did not hear because you joined later when

the soldier answered in my well friend on facebook when we were told how are you going through how are you coping with this war and the soldier says we are no longer us for a long time that is we have become different in order to win this war to survive and win that is we have changed and she says i understood that i also long ago i'm not like that anymore, maybe ukrainians are not like that for a long time they were with this war, and therefore the lack of empathy for a russian who is eaten by a shark is just such a reaction that it was normal . maybe she scared someone and you did not remember the story with the maya tribe, if i am not mistaken , how did they prepare for the war, how did they psychologically readjust? tell me, please please, well, i made such a comment, i didn’t have to because i don’t know much about these cultures, but in my youth i read fanimore cooper and remembered such and such a wording from his stories about north american

indians that er, a warrior becomes on the path of war, that is, becoming on the path of war is a certain ritual and it is, well, big changes, it is not just to put on combat er face paint and so on, it is to change internally , among these changes there is such a thing which can, so to speak, shock er, well, such um, abstract communist consciousness. that is, it is ruthlessness towards the enemy, it is the perception of the enemy as a community of the enemy if it is integral and so on. these things are usually perceived in the modern world. well, with certain ones caveats, because in reality

there are not so many people who stand or stood on the path of war in today's world, and there are not so many of such people, and mostly we learn about them, so to speak, from some hollywood action movies, and there we sympathize with them once again, and there they are they kill dozens and hundreds of people in these hollywood stories, but uh, as they say, uh, our uh, uh, some of our interlocutors, so to speak, this is the second. yes, that's why when the ukrainians, due to the fact that uh, well , something so amazing happened, that is, the empire suddenly attacked its former part, and is trying to take it back by force, and people took up arms and defend their freedom, this is a wonder for the modern world, and in principle , to say that uh, to count on the fact that many people

will understand us and will, so to speak, be at one with us uh , in the same tone, in the same uh, in the same condition, obviously you shouldn't count on it and others. by the way, not only he expressed a warning, so to speak, many authoritative in in the ukrainian public space, people reacted, so to speak, with such moral reservations to this humor about a shark and a russian and so on, but it doesn't scare me, it doesn't bother me as a patriot of ukraine, because i understand that it evidence of such discussions is evidence of the fact that the national organism is alive in the cells of the collective brain, necessary , so to speak, complex reactions of combination neurons

are connected in new connections and we become different not only in the sense that we have become the path of war, or a part of ukrainian society is on the path of war, but we are still learning this experience of staying in this state, which we will need for the next stage of national formation and growing up, you know, i want to remind our viewers that, let's say , a poem was written during the second world war i have already quoted konstantin simonov ubeevo about the fact that if you don't kill him, how many times you are cheap, how many times in battle, and ilyarenburg wrote the article ubey eh, and there he also said that it is necessary to kill a german because germans there were enemies, people, maybe you know, many people were afraid of themselves, the way they became during this war, because we change, we and these changes remain outside, well, you know, it’s the same as always, i had an acquaintance well, in the village, my

uncle worked as a groom, and he took coffee and just like boiling water and drank it calmly, i was small i was always surprised and he just drank it all the time hot hot hot already actually boiling water and he got used to it already just the walls there of his throat and then something it was already so burnt that he accepted this hot coffee normally. it didn't hurt him, just like us during this war, seeing blood, death, suffering, we were already burned somewhere. and more than once we see such a story. yes, we write. we laugh, and then we scare ourselves. it was possible. maybe we are some kind of non-humans. no, it’s just that we are people at war here. the question is, in your opinion, it is important as an advice to our viewers . to what extent do people need to dig into themselves and understand that i have become so different now that for me it may be unexpected because it is possible and then one day we will see russians whose head will be torn off by us and we will laugh and he will say well, we are not people, we should

. a question, in general, you can say 25 minutes, and you can answer calmly, you know, i would trust professional psychologists, but i recently read from a friend on facebook, such advice . in fact, what is happening to us it's normal, that is, you don't need to burden yourself get over your dung, your desperation, your fear, and with some psychological complexes, you have to deal with yourself and of course, interact with the society that surrounds us, that's why you don't particularly need to be afraid of laughter, because humor is actually a reaction to fear and despair

on any negative emotions , that 's why black humor in dark times works correctly and works for recovery, including for the recovery of society. which those who were left behind or stayed somewhere in the positions because they are there and they talk like this as if i don’t know, well, they are joking about something there, they say, oh, and your face was torn off, nothing, sivachok, you got caught, and that is, when i saw it myself before, at the beginning of the war, you know, it was caused by some such creepiness, er, i feel goosebumps on my body, i’m disgusted, how can it be, i was a person after all, and now i understand for myself that it’s just a city, i’m not what it says, i don’t want to be like that, i’m like that, like many of us are like that as they are, i look at it and i don't have any joy there something. i just look at it calmly. i understand that our fighters who are at the front see that every day is the death of their own and the death of their enemies. they also adapted to this much faster, and many people here may

not have adapted to this yet, so this reaction to a shark is natural the first is because the first reaction is always natural , no one cares, someone said well, how can it be? how pitiful the woman, and the third, as he told the courtier, what a pity the boy, and the third, they started laughing and posting memes, and maybe you were scared of yourself in these reactions, but the question is that we have become like this, the war is changing us. and i want to finally prove to the contrary whether it is worth or is it worth cultivating this despicableness or desolation of russians in ourselves. do we simply have to stop ourselves as we are and understand that we are like that there is no need to hate them more, there is no need to laugh harder there, as there is some bear eating a russian woman, but just live, live with them and understand that it is normal , well, actually, even for uh, for victory, as they advise, and uh, there are coaches in sports or uh others

, so to speak, are people who are engaged in with confrontations, they say that a cold head is much better than affect, hatred, and there are outbreaks, and all the more , some kind of ideologizing, that is, there are enemies, there is war , and we have to win it. simple things and it is clear, peace will come. we will deal with our own. so to speak and er return to a healthy lifestyle as they say thank you very much mr. maksym and thank you for your posts on facebook. it is important to write now for viewers, people need to read and understand some things that they do not understand when they are written by smart professional people maksym smart was with we, a doctor of philosophy, a poet, a public figure, a political scientist, talked about these important topics, empathy, the reaction to this shark that ate a russian in egypt .

there were sharks swimming there. there was always a red flag, this yellow flag if there is danger and the red one is if there is danger at all , the beach worker walked around and said no swim sharks yes and well, i was in the program when i was in sharm el-sheikh and you have to go there then you jump in there is such a limited space well, but there could be a shark there and when there was a red flag that i was sharks of course if she went to the pool and didn't swim , how did it happen here what by the way, a big question well, i don't know if there they were all the hotel employees, don't track sharks in any case , again, i want to tell you now, first of all, in order to be healthy in the war, you need to analyze what is happening, you need to analyze your conditions sometimes, but not be afraid of them we are not like that, life is like that. yes, there is such a good saying, the war made us the way we are , and we are the way we are

. mars is in the distant galaxy and we also have medicine, but we live in times that russia got from the past , the times of the middle ages. where is the survival of nations , the survival of nations in this, in this struggle of nations for existence, we must be what we are, what we have become if it is someone i was scared that we became like this, well, listen, it's not our fault, we didn't start it, but in this state we can win, because only you will feel sorry for the enemy, he will kill you, well, it's in and even more so, russians, you know there were pictures like that during the livonian war of ivan the terrible, the russians scared the whole of europe already, because they hung pregnant women and men on trees and shot them dead, and europe was surprised by such brutality of the russians . be afraid that you are like that and as for tsoy, listen to good music and by the way ukrainian music is very rich and very interesting as well as world and

european music and for the russians, trust them it does n't matter what you shove, they will shove whatever if only you felt the general snow and you know about the russians one simple truth, everything they show is not what it really is, this is the most important thing, next news in real life melnyk, i will say goodbye to you until 18:10 take care of yourself, be with the press and anna eva i congratulate you , please have a word, good day at the front in the verdyan direction ukrainian military advanced to a distance of up to 1 km, reported the deputy minister of defense hanna malyar in the direction of bakhmut in the area of ​​the upper