[000:00:00;00] there are a few weeks eh how now eh the society of western countries and well the journalists themselves how are they eh what they think this is the explosion of the kakhovskaya gs anyway what do they think informally let's say so eh what eh i don't have state organizations, they are the ones that deal with it, and i don't, i don't go, we read it, beatles i liebe, what kind of technical malfunction is it, we are the usual western prune, the usual american journalists , he is not aware of much, this is the situation, and most of all he is afraid that they made a mistake

to say something which then a turns out to be that it was not true. and what do you think that is ukraine 's responsibility, and that is, in this situation, should ukraine do something else? can we do something wrong here? in russia, something will ask people in america that we are dependent on what we hear. that is also the case in ukrainian sources , which give exactly the picture and there should be pictures, too, there is another side to compare it, sometimes it sounds a-a, but in

the word they are both the parties will try to a there are a number of effects that will support their army, and it is important for them to win in this regard, and i think that these ideas are also what is needed, what is also said about it , and it is clear, just to be wrong and to make people forget it well, the russian authorities and propaganda , they were actually inspired by such a sluggish reaction of the mayor to the explosion of the kakhovskaya hydroelectric power station. еще и что если про- well

for example k this catastrophe will be at the er zaporizhzhya nuclear station , we have a ukrainian in moscow , we have a ukrainian there, and russian journalists were literally talking about the curtains. i leave the dugouts and that this is done so that there will be a storm winds of some kind and the wind will blow in the direction of donbass and voronezh and when a discussion arose about this in the studio itself, then it seems to me that it is very indicative. i want to you saw it about how they say that the ukrainians are going to blow up the zaporozhian nuclear power plant . let's look at it and then we will see where it is located

. will go in the direction there, this is donetsk , there we will inevitably go through the largest under the control of ukraine, yes, the dnieper is crooked and the way the president will be. there were hundreds of thousands if the muscovites were done, it just sounds like that and the chips are being transferred, we are leaving, we refused their people, so let’s go, please, they are losing, we are not, no, but all that they are losing, they

themselves are confident that they are losing. so far, there is nothing, it means maxim, that is, let’s take a second. listen to the questions about the fact that someone regretted dnepropetrovsk kryvyi rih before that, no one regretted the road, the society, but the same zelensky , all his team, for this, he can demand huge billions of money for disinfestation for urgent measures. well, what did they agree on because the ukrainians don't feel sorry for their own people either, they repeat it constantly, constantly, constantly, in fact, you know , well, it's really insulting when the same is true. in fact, western journalists do it when they also start to reason. could ukraine have done it as if we it's absolutely the same thing that we will have an ecological disaster after this, that we will have a lot of people die there, and that's it, actually, this seems to me to be such a weak

reaction, they make it possible as a result the next step of escalation well, that is, the russian society is literally ready for the fact that we can arrange one more accident, then we will tell the whole world that it was the ukrainians and there is nothing terrible, everything weighs on us, the believers will at least say that we need to understand what to do with it, how to establish this escalation well, i think that they are. in any case, it’s obvious that they are salted to uh. yes, they don’t guarantee that this will happen, but still , it’s going to the pygan disco, and even not only, but it’s not even the chief of use. and i don’t in short and you, so that this person, i started, sounds like something in the pleasant things, i am about a-and for the western correspondent, you can say

that they and they face in many cases with such a cynical approach for the first time and i they natural presumption in their own country but don't let him open up, because there's something in the audience with this word than i have to condemn my father, in fact you wear survive some internal skeptic season and it can't and i won't do it someday factor different factors

glows its own and so on later naturally people salted will simply confirm their uh in print and i think you will not submit to these rules these verbal intellectual provocations. well, the problem facing ukraine is not, in my opinion, a little bit, and the second one is the second one . i am talking about corruption or any scandals that may or may not be, but we are

simply speaking figuratively for ukrainian society. and prolonged self-regulation and it is discipline, and yours is this time for foreign policy, and it is precisely protection, and because no one wants that something that is happening inside the country will be introduced by the army. weapons, therefore, names, and above all, how to make ukrainians see themselves as they are and begin to think, and how

it is possible to strengthen internal no, not european laws . этот, so it infects because the questionable one is not yet a minority who, although they say that it’s just purely to lose money , you represent one country, a third of a thousand people, and the other, that the country complains about money, it’s uh, it’s self-evident that you’re just shocking but

but at the same time we are walking and medviduality and this may not be the most pleasant imaginary that may be in real us. this situation also requires the discipline of the rule of law within ukraine to heal the enemies of this opportunity. that the countries hit america understands that this is a national attack and something and only very modestly, in fact, he made an effort to free himself and advertise

his own territory line that this is a strategy such a slow-cooking frog i have i will introduce russia. well, it exists in the west in the world , what then? do you think this strategy still works or not, it is necessary to understand the american society and the most likely match that we saw the same thing during the second world war when the president was then devastated, he could not immediately declare war against hitler, it is a woman, it

is better for a british ship, the ships were then embargoed then to make eh they gave them a-and ammunition they gave them everything capable of samsym and only in the very last when hitler declared war against and america then we entered in the full sense in the conflict here we see too it's the same with ecology, but people are afraid. they don't want to live in america, because in america i was involved in it. well, at first i thought that this is a pozol , all this is needed, and it will be built, and

they help people die. етом дома что всё такие eh-eh, in order for america to be reliable, after all, we need to fight for the support of everything on salt and-and this and do it as it is obvious that we are increasing our assistance all the time well, i personally think that after all , hmmm if only we had all the help from the world last summer, today, we would not have had unexploded plates, there would not have been a threat so real from the use of nuclear tactical weapons that the delay , on the contrary, eh develops it uhu well, i, i, understand that it is controlled so quickly, thank you. it was 900 satan, an american journalist, publicist, and

i i hope that at least after this conversation , our audience will understand the logic of why this is happening. this is how they help us. it is easy to apply twice a day it penetrates deeply destroys stops the reproduction of the fungus brightens the color of the nail nailer two in one it is proven effective visible result convenient to use why am i here i have sensitive teeth eat ice cream pain cold air pain sweet pain dentist advised lakalot sensiti what effectively reduces sensitivity teeth if i had known lacwood sensiti in the past i would not have had to come here

lacalut sensiti reliable protection from pain by whom television sports music education free people have the choice, choose what you want on megogo, you need to know and remember, brave heroes save the country, soul and body heal the carpathians, thank you, there are discounts on the soothing beast 20% in pharmacies passenger cargo daily every hour every minute we

receive a lot of information like wagner will belgorod region join ukraine or ukrainians listen to russian songs from the stream of news coming from everywhere , we single out the most important valery zaluzhny refuted the moscow fake just news the results of the week are an overview of only important events of significant and reliable events, it is analytics, fact checking, expert comments , we will tell you all about it in 30 minutes about the important things in plain language, available to all viewers in the studio of iryna koval. and for your attention, news, news , news, summaries of the week, every saturday at 21:00 on espresso, watch this week in the program, judicial control with tetyana shustrova , treason of the crimean judge, why

the pechersk court stopped the trial of valery chernobuk and how chernobuk ended up in the armed forces mobilized and in this way they are obviously trying to wash their hands , congratulations. you are watching judicial control, i am tetyana shustrov at the beginning of russia's full-scale war against ukraine, the state bureau of investigation has already opened 13 criminal proceedings against ukrainian judges for committing treason in the temporarily occupied territories, they sided with the enemy and violated their oath , however, this problem haunts the judicial system of ukraine since 2014, at the beginning of the occupation by russia of parts at that time , more than 500 judges of donetsk and luhansk regions and crimea defected to russia, law enforcement officers know about all of them, and almost all of them have been notified of suspicion

many have been convicted in absentia due to the fact that they are still hiding in the occupied regions, however, some still manage to avoid justice, despite indisputable evidence, even when they are in the territory under the control of ukraine, today we will tell you the story of one traitor, the former chairman of the court of appeal of crimea, who in 2014 campaigned for judges to learn russian legislation , and then when the occupiers refused to accept him in their sandbox, he remembered that he is a ukrainian judge and that he has been trying to prove his patriotism for the ninth year, but not not only manuscripts but also video recordings are on fire, but first of all, the appellate chamber of the higher anti-corruption court announced a wanted list for the former judge of the kirov district court of dnipro, natalia ovcharenko. in march, she was

sentenced to 10 years in prison with confiscation of property for demanding and receiving $30,000 in bribes, abuse of influence and also for inciting workers in the medical field to issue unreliable certificates of incapacity for work . admitted to testifying, refused to be summoned to the court, handed over certificates as if she were on sick leave, trying to avoid a sentence, even went to a psychiatric hospital, and it did not save her, the court sentenced the ex-judge to 10 years in prison, which she will start serving as soon as she is found and detained by the former court mykola chaus was sentenced by the dnipro district court of kyiv. the anti-corruption court sentenced him to 10 years

in prison. the vaks panel also changed chaus's preventive measure from house arrest to custody. chaus was arrested in august. in 2016, upon receiving a $150,000 bribe for passing a sentence in the interests of the defendants, the then judge hid the received money in two glass jars, one of which he buried in his yard, they can avoid responsibility for disciplinary offenses, complaints about which were received by the high council of justice in 2019-20 years, in accordance with the law , only the service of disciplinary inspectors of the vrp , which is currently not formed due to the three-year statute of limitations, can carry out disciplinary proceedings against a judge. thousands of complaints can

simply be closed. get to know valery chernobuk in 2011 he headed the court of appeal of the autonomous republic of crimea, not the president, we took the oath of office, there is no people, we took the oath of the judges' oath, in fact , that is, what is the difference in what country the judge is in, eh, the doctor is already exercising his functions in march 2014, and valery chernobuk delivers a lecture to crimean judges on the norms of the constitution of the russian federation. and on the court's website, his appeal to his colleagues to take russian citizenship appeared

. we are starting to study russian laws, about this is the very court that posted about it on the website, er, there is an approved study of russian legislation in march 2014. valery chornobuk congratulates natalia poklonska on her appointment to the post of illegal prosecutor of crimea. positions in the occupied crimea, he had his own plans , so soon chernobuk returned to his native dnipro, declared his loyalty to ukraine and emphasized his patriotism so much that he even enrolled in the territorial defense battalion, although he did not go to fight, he served as the head of a bathhouse and left the service 45 days after serving the minimum term for obtaining the status

of a combatant in the bathhouse already in july 2014, chernobuk was appointed to the position of a judge of the court of appeal of the dnipropetrovsk region without any reservations, the supreme council of justice did not check judges from the occupied territories before transferring them from one court to another , the chairman of the board told our journalists of de jure foundations mykhailo zhirnakov why did this happen then, this question is for the composition of the supreme council of justice, then why did we put so much effort into updating these bodies so that we would not actually have a situation in which there are judicial contractors and some corrupt elements in our country, they have a higher legal force, i'm sorry, than the law and the constitution and common sense, only in september 2016, chernobuk was finally released for

violating the judicial oath thanks to a disciplinary complaint against him by the supreme council of justice, the prosecutor's office of the autonomous republic crimea started criminal proceedings, but the investigation dragged on, and valery chernobuk disappeared. he managed to hide from the investigation until , in november 2018, the sbu detained a gray -haired and emaciated man who had grown a mustache and beard, presumably trying to change his appearance, in one of the capital's courtyards. you are detained as a suspect. in the commission of a criminal offense is provided for in the first part of article 111 of the criminal code of ukraine, in addition, you have the right to emergency medical assistance

and immediately notify other close persons for due to your choice about your place of stay, the court arrested chernobuk, however, he was soon released from custody, and the investigation and trial dragged on for years. the pechersk district court stopped the proceedings against valery chornobuk in general, according to the court , he somehow managed to mobilize to the armed forces of ukraine in the dnipro. of the center for journalistic investigations, chernobuk serves as a lawyer in the amur nizhny dnipro military committee, according to the law, the presence of the accused in the military service is indeed a valid reason for stopping the criminal proceedings. however, it does not oblige

the judge to stop the proceedings, emphasizes the judge of the higher anti-corruption court tetyana gavrylenko, the trial must take place because delayed justice is non-existent justice is usually introduced by making changes to the criminal procedure law , the mobilization of a person is a reason for stopping of such a criminal proceeding, but this norm is not mandatory and the court must consider the possibility of the participation of this accused person in the court session in the mode of video conference communication, in view of this , the circumstances must be evaluated when , er, where exactly is this mobilized person who is the branch of the army, does he perform combat tasks , what is his position in general , what does he do, the position of a military lawyer does not prevent valery chernobuk, accused of high treason, from using a video link to

participate in the court session, because he is not is on the front line and sits in the office in the rear, this is an absolutely wild story for me, how it happens, i simply cannot imagine , that is, a person is suspected under article 111 of treason and appropriate procedural actions are taken in relation to him, in what way who and how does not check so much recruitment of people to the armed forces, so that a person in such a procedural status is still mobilized and given access to uh, obviously sensitive information , well, for me, the big question is, meanwhile , the prosecutor's office of the autonomous republic of crimea has already filed an appeal against the court's decision to suspend the consideration of the application of the prosecutor's office of the autonomous republic of crimea and the city of sevastopol, we emphasize that the former chairman of the appeal court of the autonomous republic of crimea is accused of committing a particularly serious

crime of high treason, the prosecutor's office of the autonomy appealed to the kyiv court of appeals with a complaint against the specified court decision because according to the information of the defense, the type and place of service of the accused does not prevent him from participating in the trial in the video format, attempts to avoid punishment through mobilization have recently been a fairly common practice, the chairman of the board of the de jure foundation, mykhailo zhirnakov, emphasizes, in fact , he is not the only one, and he is not the first, and perhaps not even the last. committed other crimes, in particular corruption ones, and also mobilized themselves and thus tried to wash themselves off somewhere , hang out somewhere there, i don’t know, lord, it’s simple to take a picture with a machine gun or in pixel and

then to tell what heroes they are, how they defended ukraine and therefore they should write off all the crimes they committed before that, this is a very dangerous story and the case of valery chernobuk is not the only one, in the next issue we will tell you about other clever judges who try to avoid responsibility for crimes by speculating on war for today, you have all watched judicial control . i am tetyana shustrova. tell us about the facts of corruption in the judicial system that you know. write to the e-mail you see on the screen or to me on facebook. we will meet exactly at a good week in ukraine 18:00 news time on the