[000:00:00;00] and the population for reconstruction, and this is not a joke, and how to create the conditions so that people start to return, and we are not even talking about people who left in 2020, but people who left much earlier, i would compare this situation to ireland, you know where the majority people live outside ireland but are part of the irish world . we will have to build such a country, and this is also a very serious challenge because we have never done this. we have never been so truly connected with the ukrainian diaspora, for me it was always very strange because i, as a person who imagines what the connection between israel and the diaspora is and how this compromise was found, because it is necessary to understand that this is a serious compromise, that the people who built israel did not want any compromise from the diaspora, i wanted the diaspora to come

to israel, and the american ray did not want to go anywhere, and i understood the power of this compromise, but not when i went there to israel and listened to stories about how israel is developing. and i understood the power of this compromise only when i first went to the jewish museum of the united states of america in new york and i passed through the bachelor hall and in the next hall i suddenly saw such a large stand where it was written that after the second world war the jewish people received two centers of civilization, the state of israel and the jewish community of the united states , and it became clear to me how, in principle , american jews look not just for ourselves as for some people who live in america, but as an alternative center of civilization, and we will also have to think about what our compromise will be with the ukrainian diaspora that we will have to rebuild an alternative ukrainian center of civilization so as not to lose these people even where they will be and so that their descendants, if they wanted , could build ukraine, if not with a physical presence, with such an intellectual presence, this is a weighty task, this is a task

that was not only solved by israel, this was solved by ireland, you know what there is on st. patrick's day, all the members of the irish cabinet of ministers go to irish communities around the world and the prime minister goes to the united states. because most irish people do not live in ireland, the irish live in ireland, this is all for us today, categories that we do not consider. we will have to consider them if we want the ukrainians to survive not just as a nation, not a very large country in terms of population, which lives with post-war problems, but as a global nation, believe me as a representative of a global nation. this it is possible to do if you know exactly what you want from the development of your own civilization . by the way, this will be our best answer to the russians who want us to have no ukrainians, it is not about us, we have to make sure that we

are not just there, but that there are russians everywhere. let them live in russia, read pushkin, the beautiful drink, and that means this is the second task and the third task means which i said is to survive in the conditions of the intellectual and revolutionary revolution of new technologies, this is also a very important weighty task because, on the one hand, it creates opportunities. this is the creation of this global ukraine, and on the other hand, it reminds us that this global ukraine will compete with global america, global europe , global france from global germany and global russia will also compete . we didn't know. we love you. we will hear it from

all the computers of the soviet union, so to speak, and this is also an important task, and this is what i would say. large-scale tasks are always optimistic. and we remember that practically we exist in two categories. on the one hand, we talk about these large-scale tasks of the 21st century, and on the other hand , we can talk about what you think about these large-scale tasks, because when our compatriots like there, in the 19th or 20th centuries, they simply died in the fields of battles , as in principle it should not have happened, and if it were not for this willingness of people to sacrifice their lives for the sake of the existence of ukraine, it simply would not have been possible to talk about it, and this is also necessary always remember that we are a society that can

think about the large-scale future, but survives because our compatriots and you are ready for the archaic, for the archaic, it is not always bad in relation to the ukrainian people, it is not bad at all because the ukrainian civilization was driven into village and tried to artificially make it rural. and this civilization continued to struggle to exist and to leave this village to the city and flood the cities. and i always remembered the words of the great theoretician and practitioner of zionism, volodymyr zhabatynsky, who said that the man will survive everything and come to the city, and in this city there will be ukrainian signs, ukrainian shops, and odessa will speak ukrainian. he wrote about odessa. and by the way, as you can see now, more than 100 years after all this was written, it all begins

to happen and it was not just a belief in the ukrainian people, because chibudinsky did not need to believe in the ukrainian people, he believed in the jewish people, it was the knowledge of the ukrainian people, the understanding of their national character, the understanding of these roots, do you understand the roots? wrote a text when there were events in the belgorod region, about the roots, about the oldest tree in the belgorod region, this tree, which is there in this water, excursions to it, i don’t know, i don’t know what is happening to it now, and which one is left of those oak groves that the russians produced to build of belgorodsk beyond the january border, so-called in order to separate itself from the ukrainian lands from the crimea, the thickness at the beginning of the moscow principality that it was called and is called the man's oak because it is a tree that took root not in russia but in

the ukrainian land has survived a century with its name, and so have the ukrainian people's roots, we help them survive, survive, come to a place where they don't want to see them win and win again when they try to drive them out of their relatives in the city again. i believe that these roots are not even roots, they are like that a large root system, it is a guarantee that we can fight and that we can compete on the territory that other peoples have always considered so much theirs that they were ready to pour blood on it just so that there would be no ukrainians here and that you also need to remember, thank you, it was me before, bleeding gums, inflammation of the gums, and the solution was so simple gum problems lacalut active lacalut active actively overcomes bleeding gums, protects against periodontitis

and visibly tightens clear lacalut active action you feel immediately new lacalut active plus even more active protection , it is necessary to know and remember brave heroes save the country soul and body heal the carpathians thank you deoccupation how can we live without dubna it is possible unsurpassed the history of the liberated cities of ukraine

left let's see how our brothers helped us freed from a normal life freed from the normal technology of pro-russian non-humans it was terrible every day was very scary one by one two houses were burned and the ukrainian people were natsiki here yes we are all nationalists people who resisted residents came here stopped and sent back and became heroes the novel was there and will always be ukraine about unbreakable cities of ukraine from the ukrainian project documentary series de-occupation every saturday at 11:10 on espresso join the community with a ukrainian view of the world become a sponsor of the espresso youtube channel and this is access to exclusive content, personal thanks, pinned comments, special icons and the possibility of personal communication with the espresso team, click to sponsor and become part of the community with

a ukrainian perspective, we are special agents of the sbu , experts in destroying the enemies of ukraine, we know pavlovna and complex special operations for the offensive. we need the best, join the center special operations and the sbu go through quality training get modern weapons and combat experience step by step shot by shot attack with attack together we will release

ukraine is the center of special operations and the sbu engrave your name on the pages of victory. let's then start with the most pressing issues . we are waiting for vinnytsia . i included the nobility. what do you think will be the solution for ukraine? dear ladies and gentlemen, i know the position of ukraine . was adopted according to such a procedure as finland or not from sweden, this is ukraine's position. we know this position of ukraine, but but. the fact

is that all members of the north atlantic alliance must agree to this, if we are dealing with unity and unanimity. no, they are not in the eastern on the flank of nato, we have the favorable positions of other states that contribute to the position of ukraine, in particular in poland and the baltic states, but the point is to convince all others or the rest of the members of the continental nato member states, that is,

the continental countries of western europe, or will consensus for such a quick admission of ukraine to nato. i think that there will be no such consensus now. i think that there is no question. so what to do. i think that the best solution would be to find such institutional solutions that would bring ukraine closer to the north atlantic alliance. so close that this consensus was still broken so there is no final decision here and we do not know in which place today we have three more weeks we do not know in which this consensus will be reached so far i can

to say that it already exists, and if it concerns the fact that the nato ukraine council was created and to adopt such a plan to support ukraine, to support ukraine militarily, and there is no one left, this is an achievement without a doubt compared to what exists today, because until now ukraine nato ukraine had only its commission and how do you know that this commission has not met once in its session for 6 years, and instead the council is already a partnership union that boils down to full cooperation, not only the exchange of opinions and ideas, but also information

strategies and so on and so on. i think that today you can say that this is on my menu. but there should be more. therefore, the position of part of the countries of the eastern flank of nato comes down to that of probably the baltic states , probably poland. scheduled in time the tasks that ukraine must complete. well, and at what time. in what time period, and at the same time, we should evaluate these tasks , see how they are implemented, determine

new tasks for ukraine. in this way, so that what is the goal of ukraine's accession to nato? well, it was in the near future in the perspective of ukraine's actions and thoughts and ukraine's aspirations. well, so that it would be acceptable for the north atlantic countries that have not yet decided to take over ukraine and you don't mention the arguments why the fruits of the arguments are many, one of those arguments is that the starting point can be , for example, the situation determined by bucharest in 2008, because everyone then agreed that the future of ukraine is in nato, but no one said when they said the future and in what future near or medium-term perspective distant long-term perspective in other words, it can be said that it was a declaration without

any obligations on the part of nato and this one argues in this way that these so-called unconvinced countries are based in this way. so this is a good starting point, but it is necessary to deal with it here make a mistake, our argument is that a lot of bad things have happened since then. we have to take this into account. there is also another question that you know about. this is, for example, the question that no one has ever accepted donato of the countries that are in in a state of war, this is a question

of the territorial integrity of ukraine, how should article 5 function and be used, and how should article 5 be used ? somewhere else, they have an additional one that in such a situation. to nato, and we will not behave in accordance with the provisions of article five, because if they do not fulfill the fifth clause in relation to ukraine, then they will not use it for others in relation to other countries, without twisting it. that is, it is not an element of the discussion, but those who will sit down at the negotiating table, and there it will be necessary to make a decision and when they meet with such an argument that ukraine should be admitted to nato immediately, then they will have somewhere else subconsciously realized such a question of this kind , the pretense said so the situation is quite complicated

, on the other hand, the north atlantic alliance now he how old is he already, 74 years old? so, he has a lot of experience, and the ukrainian experience will surely be another experience of the alliance. we have not yet closed one section, that is , the swedish section of the creation of an aviation commission. what work is being carried out at the diplomatic we are simply creating the conditions so that our partners are convinced that

the aid to ukraine today is a weekend among the countries of the atlantic community, but of all the states of the free world, it boils down to creating various coalitions , look at the tank coalition. as you know , we are now talking about aircraft coalition. perhaps there will be other coalitions. and what is interesting about those that are in these coalitions is that well, let's say it , let's make it so that on march 1, 2022, that is, in the first week of aggression and no one thought about such a coalition was not on the negotiating table at all, and this was revealed by what appeared during those one and a half years, less than a year and a half, that is a year and several months, the fact that these days appeared, it shows that there is

a dynamic process, and from the mental point of view and from an intellectual point of view. but at the same time it is a process, a dynamic process that concerns the evolution of positions and joint measures of joint actions. so this year, poland and diplomacy are participating. the ministry of national defense of poland although

he will not tell you all the nuances anyway because he cannot so, in order to close our discussion regarding the accession of ukraine, then this matter is the whole question . it is constantly open and you can categorically say before the summit that something is absolutely impossible. you said that we are talking about certain processes and there is a discussion of agreements on conducting arguments and so on and so on and so on. this is a political dynamic process and i say it as i think it as i see it as of today, that is , there is no consensus yet. if we are talking about nato itself, but if we are talking about the nato council ukraine and i have not yet heard a single voice against such joy against

the creation of such a council, then we can say that the bucharest summit is not the starting point for negotiations, that is, the starting point is something else , but now we will see how it will happen further, if it is about the accession of ukraine to the european union, then you are asking specifically about what the chances are, because ukraine has the status of a candidate country for the eu, and now the problem is when to start negotiations on accession, preparing for this meeting, you must have found out what happened to the candidate. this is very good thing, but this does not determine in any way

until now there was no recognition of the period until which will be appointed for negotiations on the country's accession to the eu because there are countries that have such a certificate they have the status of a candidate over the course of a decade and whether they are much closer to joining, there is nothing to indicate that such a situation will repeat itself in the case of ukraine , that is, the situation is completely different actions in other conditions, and on the side of many members of the european union, it is such that it cannot last long and it cannot to last for decades, it is about what happened, but this process came as quickly as possible, it will depend on many factors, not only which

ukraine will have progress if it is about reforms of its administration, self-government , roots of justice, horticulture, that is, openness of the economy, i.e. change the principles of economic life, so that it is more open , so that the rules of the game in the economy are predictable and transparent, what ukraine will do, or it is possible to carry out reforms, we have our own experience. should last a much shorter period of time , but you must remember that it

will depend on the progress in reforming ukraine and how the consensus regarding ukraine will be formed within the european union, certain conditions have already appeared, demanding how the european union should be reformed, what procedures should be changed in order to admit ukraine to the eu, but there is, i will repeat once again , the situation before this situation, which is after ukraine's accession to nato, no one could have imagined this a year ago, true. so, now imagine what

will happen in a year, today is our unofficial lawyer who defends the interests of ukraine, with whom is the most difficult if you can say to communicate and convince which countries if it is about joining the european union and to nato or to the european union and european society and who do you

think is the most difficult with him with him ? certain expectations regarding the relationship between ukraine and ukraine, on the other hand, if we are talking about germany , then this is already a question of a more systemic nature, it is already traditional, it stems from the traditional policy of germany, which was very close to russia before russia's aggression against ukraine. well, and it is also certain that germany cares about the shape of the european union as a whole, when such a powerful

player as ukraine will appear in the european union, because then even the demographic point of view, how much is it. it is difficult poetry of fear of the art to say how many will be the population of ukraine after the war, for example, how many of our ukrainian guests ukrainian guests who are forgiven in poland will return to ukraine and so on and the like, but it will surely be a country in terms of population plus or minus like spain here we must say so that the appearance of such a state next to poland is already a completely new quality of all geopolitics already within the european union, and i don't think that this is actually guided by the hungarians . but the germans are definitely guided by this

approach of supporting ukraine in poland. indeed , at the beginning of the russian invasion, it became such a true friend for ukraine. why, where did the poles get such a will to help ukraine to support ukraine that there is , mr. minister realized in himself, i don't know and i don't see a single family in poland that was not involved in some way involved in providing aid to ukraine what, for example, are polish volunteers going