[000:00:00;00] thousands of hryvnias so that the army has money for the purchase of drones for the purchase of equipment for the purchase of machines, and not volunteers, but the money is there, but the authorities must be told that everything is fine. in marathon, this is also a bribe from the oligarch so that they do not criticize the terrible things that are happening there involved in corruption, i will remind you that we have a society. thank you, dear colleagues, the only thing i can't understand is where is the chairman of the budget committee, denis vadimovych herman, please take your place, your place is here now, yes, please, yes you please be here well yes yes good dear colleagues, i immediately put these amendments one by one, amendment 421 gerashchenko, it is rejected, at the same time the author asks to take into account

, i put 421 amendment into consideration for 82 decisions not taken amendment rejected by factions please show amendment 424 , it was also rejected by the committee authorship gerashchenko, i ask you to vote

for 75, the decision was made, i apologize, i apologize 425 gerashchenko, it was rejected by the committee, i ask you to vote for 74, the decision was not made, and the final amendment iryna volodymyrivna 426 was also rejected by the committee rejected, i ask you to vote for 71 decisions before i hand over to you a small number of oleksiichuk, one, and in myhish, we will move on to nina

petrivna , please, oleksiichuk. thank you, mr. chairman . about a fair distribution about voting in action because we are currently divided as many people voted and that project won , who am i talking about that the winner will be determined depending on the number percent by voting for this or that community , i.e. if the community voted 1,000 people, it means one percent, if the community of 10,000 voted 1,000 out of 1,000 people, it is 10%. it will be a fair distribution between small and large communities, it will equalize them, therefore, colleagues, please support this amendment , which will simply put small and large communities on equal terms, please support, thank

you, thank you, amendment 357 of oleksiychuk, it was rejected because i understand that the philosophy of the draft law was changed in general right here there is no question no action, nothing here, this money goes to the army, just to make it clear, but i put 357 amendment by oleksiychuk , i ask you to vote for 112, the decision was not made, the two amendments are softer, it seems to me, name the numbers first , sir, head, not two a5 and 311, 314, 326, 333 and 334 amendments please colleagues 311th amendment see well, here the technical one is added to

mykolaivsk and odesa poltavaska but in the essence of the bill i want to say that in fact we give money to the military, but that's all that was all the discussion that was about this of the draft law, it has gone to waste, that is, the version of the first reading that was given to us for discussion, all this does not matter because it is set for the next year 2024, that is, if we support it and vote for this draft law as it is now, all these norms do not matter what we proposed between the first and second the reading remains the version of the first reading and it will enter into force from 2024, but it was already pushed with military money. here's what about it. well, this amendment of yours is partially taken into account. i

just want to pay attention. i understand that you insist on full consideration, please, the position of the committee is correct. dear colleagues, during the consideration of the bill in working groups, we worked out the amendments regarding amendment 311. it is indeed partially taken into account, but i would like to emphasize that in fact the purpose of the bill was to regulate the order of use of the funds of dfr two billion in 2023 year, but taking into account the critical time, by the end of the year, most of the important projects will not have time to be implemented at the expense of these funds , therefore the committee's proposal was to send 2 billion hryvnias for the armed forces of ukraine for the purchase of weapons, so i am asking you to support the draft law specifically. despite this, 311 is partially taken into account

, thank you , dear colleagues. dear colleagues, 312 amendment of mykysh, it is taken into account in part by the committee. the author insists on full consideration . amendment 314 proposes to include zhytomyr region also in the list of those regions that will receive, not understanding , i ruled out that it received less than odesa in relation to the fact that we have 2 billion to use no, this draft law talks about the mechanism of using dfrr money, and it doesn’t matter if it will be 2 billion or 22, this is the mechanism, and this is exactly what we are talking about now, and in the future , the amendments will be exactly how they should be used , it doesn’t matter what the size and volume of these funds will be . but of course you didn’t want to listen to the people's deputies and you decided that we need to do it in a cunning way, we will say that these two

billion are for the military and we will quietly vote everything that you put on the first reading. and what we proposed between the first friend can be thrown away. means all these trends in relation to the fact that we are currently determining 2 billion for the military in the coming 24th year. the mechanism that you are laying down now will be in place. 314 amendment by mykisha and colleagues. it was rejected by the committee. please be determined. vote for 97. the decision has not been made. the next amendment is 326. i apologize. misha 326 amendment talks about lowering the tax rate from 925,000 people, this is a more technical gas station

. to reduce disparities in the development of the regions themselves, and first of all, this is achieved by support from the projects of the relevant regional development, with how exactly it will be determined which project will be supported or not supported. the first reading will not help in this matter, do not solve them, my colleagues and i submitted the appropriate amendments, and i will continue to voice them as well, and oleksiychuk also voiced accordingly the amendment that will help to best regulate the appropriate mechanism of assistance to the regions and communities in the regions, first of all, i ask you to support dear colleagues , the 326th amendment was rejected by the committee , rejected by the committee, please, people

's deputy mikisha asks to take it into account, i ask to vote and it remains, but then there are 40 cases, so they said about 40 for 102, no decision was made, the amendment remains a deviation of 333. netishyn , please , colleagues. regions, which project will still be put to the vote, this amendment determines that we clean up this corrupt lanka, which has been in a manual mode for many years, and for certain profile people appointed by the governor, it determines who exactly will receive in terms of loyalty and political motives in the state fund

for regional development should help the regions develop and this should be impartial. and the relevant regional commission does not allow this to be done, and therefore i propose to remove them and finally demolish this corrupt link and forget as a terrible day 333 amendment is about this, i understand why the relevant profile of the ministry was against this initiative, all the majoritarians know that this is evil and that is what it is. it is necessary to support colleagues, please support what is the position of the committee dear colleagues, indeed, during the consideration of the draft law in the committee, this amendment was rejected at the request of the ministry of reconstruction, the argumentation of the ministry of reconstruction for the preservation of regional commissions was such that our foreign partners insist that it be preserved tools of local self-government, including, and in order to work quickly, those draft laws that were submitted to the local authorities so that they were in a certain way quickly passed and

considered, but this issue is supported by many majoritarians who have some negative experience of working with these regional commissions, the committee will not insist on therefore, if the amendment is supported by the hall, thank you, thank you. dear colleagues , everyone has heard the argumentation. yes, the 333rd amendment of mykish was rejected by the committee. but in principle, the speaker said that if it is it is supported, he is not against, that is, the logic is yes, the 333rd amendment by the authorships. i am still asking you to vote for 217. the decision has not been taken. we will move on

to the next amendment 334. please, colleagues. actions are not determined by citizens through the action. and what is determined by the regional commissions is passed even by voting. those who vote for the action are first determined by the regional commission, and they determine not what is necessary, but what is necessary according to regional development, and what will be necessary. according to political or some other agreements in which you are more of you. if you think that you will have influence, this will not be influenced by the governor and put what they want. again, this is about regional commissions , which should not exist at all. will have effect immediately and will be voted on as necessary, colleagues, if it is not removed, then there is no point in voting on the draft law

, please support this position of the committee, this is an amendment similar to work 333, and therefore the position of the committee is the same, and so is my comment i ask you to support the proposal to support amendment 334. thank you, dear colleagues. please, i put the 334 amendment to take into account. you have heard the position of the author of the amendment and the author of the committee. there is a request to support this approach

. i put 334 amendment to the vote . on petrovna, how many amendments do you have ? please tell me

, 40 amendments, yes, they are all rejected. grouped somehow, please 389 amendment dear colleagues, in general, these amendments relate to changes to the state budget and they were supposed to go as a resource for returning the thirty and however, today the additional reward to the military has not been returned, unfortunately, even my girlfriends who had the right to speak ambiguously read the text differently, they think that there is something there there is good , in fact , the provision that is in force today and it was established by the cabinet of ministers was cemented in the law, so shame on us, but now we have the opportunity to consider, first of all, the resources for the return of the thirty and then to talk about its return was also desired by colleagues from the other faction, so let's start first, we now have proposals from us regarding the redistribution of expenses and to and

additional revenues, if we are serious , then the budget committee should now propose dear colleagues, amendment 389 of the southern bill was rejected by the committee. please vote for 67. the decision was not made . thank you. to propose for the budget quest because in these few months of 2023, the picture is radically changing in our country, and with regard to the expenditure part , there are articles in which there is a catastrophic

lack of funding, and there are those expenditure articles that have already been covered by our partners, donors , etc. part of the budget, therefore, it is absolutely obvious that the reluctance to make the state budget transparent and in line with reality now leads to the fact that we are now returning to these amendments that i wanted to propose to consider exclusively on the working group, therefore we did not bring them to the hall earlier , but the working group did not get to these issues because there is no need for additional resources, the southern woman was rejected by the committee, please vote

for 52 52, the decision was not adopted, the amendment of the rejection, the next amendment, number e-e , i appeal to thinking colleagues please tell me if there was no need to find additional funds at the working group on the return of 30 30-year-old soldiers additional remuneration, then what do you think we will pay something extra after the adoption of law 9342 to the military no of course, that is why we now have to consider the changes that we are proposing, but i am sure that the ministry of finance if it does not seriously approach this issue now, then this lie has simply already swayed here in the hall, well, you can't look at it like that and not be responsible for your own work, we people's deputies, let's now remove all these political conversations and sit down exclusively to work on the state

budget, it is the basis of what we can do now in the country and how to help the military. for 59, the following amendment was not adopted. nina petrivna, number for confirmation, therefore, according to amendment 4001, i will then begin to speak in substance , although i hope that at least someone will hear me so that the ministry of finance with the pro-committee will start working on changes to the state budget and the super sequester of the budget, what needs to be done a priori, what do we offer

? please look at the 51 billion 136 million road fund, these are the funds that we can direct to additional rewards for the military. why? because it is possible to reduce it by 75% by 32 billion 619 million from the total amount planned for the construction of roads, why can it be reduced because these funds were given to us by our partners? tell me, please, why are you hiding such a reserve? i am turning to the specialized committee again. dear colleagues , amendment 401 of the southern woman , it

was rejected by the committee. 402 amendment yuzhanina , please dear colleagues, in part, the funds for infrastructure, i.e. road construction, have already arrived and are in the state budget , the members of the budget committee do not object to this. tell me please. to all of you who are still in the hall right now, aren't you interested in the fact that 32 billion will now be used in an opaque manner without informing and without the support of the people's deputies who are responsible for the adoption of the state budget . therefore, i am asking once again. please review and support the transfer of these expenses exactly for providing the military with an additional reward, the second figure is 18 billion 517 million , again in the road fund, since it is a special fund, technically i transfer

these funds to the state budget to of the general fund in order to reduce it and direct it to the support of the military, it is like amendment 402 of the southerners, it was rejected by the committee, i ask you to vote for 52, the decision was made, please 403rd number petrivna, i emphasize your attention, this is not air, we are now dividing, we are talking about a special fund that is filled with excise tax when selling fuel and bringing cars , that is, these are living funds that come to the special fund and precisely provide for certain areas of spending when we say that this fund

has been counting expenses for debt payments from now on borrowing obligations and we know that these payments have been postponed until the 25th year , it is absolutely obvious that these funds should be directed exclusively to additional rewards for the military. who is against the return of the thirty, what do you have against the 51 billion replenishment of funds i am putting into consideration the amendment number 403 of the people 's deputy of yuzhinaina and pavlenko by the committee, it was rejected, please vote

for 47, the decision was not adopted, the amendment was not taken into account 404 correction nina is needed from the south, please dear colleagues, you and i have now moved on to ot it doesn't seem strange to you that some of us who have operational information talk about the fact that the budget received additional revenues there in april and may, and they are also reflected in the state budget. you know the position of the state budget committee that when the deviations in the state budget increase by more than a certain percentage, you must submit an adjustment to the state budget . where is this adjustment? let's talk now about that is, the revenues that i planned three months ago, i saw them, and today you already feel them in the budget, just don't appropriate this money to tsk - by a separate name, these are the funds paid by ukrainian business, so let's direct them to where it is most needed

now for the state budget, martial law . for voting, amendment number 404 , people's deputy yuzhanina pavlenko , it was rejected by the committee, please vote. i put it into consideration for 46, the decision was not adopted, the amendment was not taken into account, amendment 405. no, it is not necessary, please. dear colleagues, literally it turned out that the authorities somehow manage to regulate the gambling business. and it's okay that illegal turnover through schemes with banks and payment

systems resulted in 180 billion uah from sub- taxation. of the military levy can be taken additionally from the players if all these rates are now working in the official plane, so 19 billion 926 million can be received from personal income tax if you really began to control the mining business and the military levy, including if we say that we are putting to the vote amendment number 405, people's deputy yuzhanina pavlenko, it was rejected by the committee, i ask

you to vote, we put it into consideration for 47, the decision was not made, the amendment is not taken into account, please, next 406 correction of deputies of the city of kyiv, if all mining halls and businesses are registered, i checked it in the city of kyiv , then the local budget can receive an additional 60x40 distribution 60 kyiv city 40 state budget additionally almost 17 of half a billion hryvnias, 17.5 billion hryvnias and 2 billion 430 million. this is a military levy, despite the fact that the organizer of the gambling games will pay a small amount from their income - it is 3 billion 240 million. i am asking for amendments to fill the state budget and direct them to ensure additional payments to the military

please support amendment number 406 people's deputy yuzhanina pavlenko rejected by the committee, we are taking it into account, please vote for 48, the decision has not been made, but it is not taken into account , 407 nina's amendment is needed, please now i was very impressed by the words of the president today regarding the grain corridor supporting our exporters. i am simply surprised that some people continue to write that about 100 billion hryvnias were lost on the grain corridor because of the customs officials , because of the low-quality or dishonest work of the customs officials, we know a completely different truth, how the grain corridor was such a warm window of entry

so there is no open information, no one can get there, but if the mechanism of expert assurance is applied, it is an already adopted law , based on the figures published by tsk and others deputies to avoid threats of not returning foreign exchange earnings and paying vat, that is, this mechanism will allow you to take 14%, you can get 11 mln rd 100 million, this is from the numbers e-e i am putting to vote amendment number 407 of the people 's deputy yuzhanina pavlenko to the committee, it is rejected, we are taking it into account, please vote what what for