[000:00:00;00] so there is no open information , no one can get there, but if the mechanism of expert assurance is applied, it is an already adopted law, then based on the figures published by the tsk and other deputies to avoid threats of non-return of foreign exchange earnings and payment of vat, i.e. this mechanism will allow taking 14%. it is possible to get 11 billion 100 million, this is from the numbers, e-e

. 43 decision was not taken correction from not taken into account 408 correction is not needed, please, unfortunately, if the deputies colleagues do not want to listen and left the hall, i still hope that ukrainians who will watch the broadcast at night will understand that our country does not use all possible reserves that we have for today, unfortunately, these dances with tambourines are different, there are promises that do not apply to the raising of the economy, they do not give it the opportunity to move from the place in which it is now, well, it is very unfortunate to feel that, so i still insist for this discussion that we are currently conducting

, i appeal to the head of the specialized budget committee, have you considered all the amendments in the budget committee ? even if we don't have enough funds for the military, this is a loan. i am putting the washing machine number 408 to the vote of the people's deputies of yuzhanina pavlenko. it was rejected by the committee. 408 correction is not needed, unfortunately, when the pitiful people who spoke here and talked about promising something unrealistic or incorrect about the return of additional payment of additional remuneration from 30 to 100,000 did not hear this discussion about additional sources that may be in the budget

. unfortunately, you should also be aware that in the correspondence of the working group there was a question that when we discuss all our approaches to return from 30 to 100 we will return to the search for a reserve where to find resources and you all know that no one has searched for resources because no additional rewards will be returned to anyone therefore, my current discussion is only for you to understand, i see other experts see, the public sees that we are actually irrationally using the resources and opportunities that we have in the country and that too

much. for taking into account 40 for a decision not made 410 correction please no, we don't need it dear colleagues, i can hear my girlfriends talking about the fact that now 75 deputies in the hall are looking for additional resources for the military. i want those who do not can see now, the hall completely understood this, that's all that remains are those who want to hear or really find them and the authorities ' reluctance to talk about this topic. well, it just forces me to talk now. the same things. let's move on to the third article of additional income.

they began to receive more taxes from the tobacco market . listen, don't engage in lobbying or in general any kind of politics when you destroy some investment climate and understand what is happening in the country, let's we are taxing what we have already discovered that is in the gray area and can. i am putting amendment number 410 to the vote. no, it is not necessary . zhanina and pavlenko, by the committee . it is rejected.

so on nina 411 to 400 deputy i would like to once again draw attention to the fact that our black sectors of the economy have increased significantly in all directions, we are now talking with you about the market for excise tobacco products and since i am a member of the committee which enough there regularly considers these issues. we recently made sure that it was possible to stop shadow circulation at one of the factories in zhovtyh vody, where the equipment was cut. it seems that this part of the market is now going to the legal plane. if you calculate the excise tax , a small number of products that were manufactured precisely at tobacco factory , then we can additionally receive in the budget 2

billion 118 million excise tax half of the 411 amendment of nina petrivna in zhanina and the group of aryan deputies pavlenko gerashchenko iryna volodymyrivna is also a co-author of this amendment i put it into consideration, please vote by the committee, it was rejected for 39 decisions, and maybe we will spend 5 minutes and then make five consecutive amendments. let's vote dear colleagues, i am now going through the articles that became known to me two or three months ago. if we talk about how

the taxation system is changing now and what the government plans after the adoption of the laws, what will we be tomorrow considering this will significantly increase the revenue part, and if we do not consider insisting with you on the revision of the state budget, well, then no one counts on your opinion, if it is so profitable for you, then it is not profitable for someone like me, who can see in the numbers this huge deception that is trying the government continues to tolerate and does not get out of this image . to the profile committee to discuss, consider them, what do you actually

see and support what, perhaps, would you like to use in a different way than for the ministry of defense and specifically for the return of this thirty, and maybe not such a resource, a large resource is needed , well, a discussion is needed well, why isn’t there, how long will we suffer around the fact that we don't have money , well, i don't know where to turn to the state bureau of investigation or what other competent authorities if we can't manage ourselves if we hide the income part in order to then spend in an opaque way, someone has to put an end to this. i have only one and only one possibility. is it through amendments to propose and support the redistribution of the budget and show additional revenues and direct them to where we all think is most necessary? we now have to provide the ministry of defense with you as

manager and the ministry of defense , respectively , our armed forces discussion, let's discuss it. well, to infinity, i'm holding in my hands now a selection of all the materials regarding the covering of a large part of the costs by our donors and our partners, and at the same time, the ministry of finance, the cabinet of ministers, just keep quiet, by the way, there was a lot of talk about the fact that for the first time in history, the data is specific mandate of the cabinet of ministers or even drafted into legal documents for the ministry of defense or the cabinet of ministers, i am surprised, people, this means that you should dismiss the cabinet of ministers, you should not fulfill

their work, because you cannot write out all the operational details that apply to each norm, and i am sure that what was adopted in 93:42 to 30, we have narrowed down our own possibilities, because it is now in the body of the law, in the body of the law, what was tolerated by the cabinet of ministers, the ministry of defense and the ministry of defense understands why it was forced to send such letters to which, by the way, attention was drawn here as proof that everything is fine with them . yes, no. this was talked about this morning, no one is engaged in any politics . please understand. we have to speak clearly. we currently have a large shortage. we need to replenish the armed forces, and when people go

there, they are very poor. do you think they can work and will they go? with the provision that is now being offered to them, well, really, at that time i already told you 10 times that when the provision included the salary even if it was 13,000,400,30,000 and the preservation of the previous salary as a place of work, it was attractive, no matter how cynical it sounds from a financial point of view. and now there is no such thing. what you want to do is continue to catch people and forcibly stuff them into buses in order to carry out mobilization. this is the wrong approach.

it is not necessary and pavlinka 412-413-th 414 415 416-th 417 please vote for 412 correction for impressions for 28 decision not accepted correction not taken into account 413 correction of yuzhinina and group of deputies to be taken into account please vote

for 25 decision not taken correction not taken into account 414 amendment of the people's deputy of yuzhana and a group of people's deputies rejected by the committee, we take it into account, please vote for 24 decisions not taken 415 amendment of the people's deputy of yuzhana, and other people 's deputies, the committee rejects, we take into account, please vote for 25 decisions, the amendment is not taken into account not taking into account 416 the amendment of the people's deputy of yuzhana and groups of people's deputies , the committee opened the stavlja for consideration , i ask you to vote for 26 decisions, the amendment was not adopted. not taking into account

the 417 amendment of people's deputy zhadin and others family deputies rejected by the committee, we take them into account, i ask you to vote for 28, the decision was not adopted, the amendment was not taken into account, the next block from 418, i see 422, 423, but let's find it according to all the amendments. i don't want to quarrel with anyone, but i want to find an understanding so that we speak in the same way and do not engage in lies here, well enough already, i honestly thought that 16 months of war would change people and we would be

aware of our responsibility, but not so this is happening. look at this block of amendments. since the law is constructed in this way, it returns us to the redistribution of expenses . i used to analyze the budget here with you. i told you that for the year 2023, not everyone was increased equally , for example, not only for the indexation of the wage fund, but some were given more why did they take away the development fund and leave it to someone else? if it was approached correctly, if i were the minister of finance, i would sit down and say . let's now remove those restaurant managers who had more than for each manager allocated funds for this directions, let's take the prosecutor's office, they have increased the wage fund more than others, more than the inflation index, by half a billion hryvnias, more than half a billion hryvnias. is it still not possible to conduct an analysis

of what these 572 billion million 718,000 came from , why did they add another 17,169,170 million for some development expenses, what can be improved in the prosecutor's office, repairs, or something else? that is, please tell me, i understand that the minister of finance is afraid to talk to administrators, especially to people like the prosecutor's office, but we are here. there are many of us together. we can now support these amendments. and it is absolutely true. i am sure that if you conduct an analysis, these funds of uah 730 million, uah 712,000 can be reduced in the expenses of this

particular administrator. during the consideration of the budget, no one even had the opportunity or courage to say why do you need more? these additional payments and this was planned in 2022 for the 23rd year, let's deal with this issue here, too. we have half a billion hryvnias, well , in the end, we understand our responsibility. that now our law enforcement agencies, instead of the police and the prosecutor's office and the dbr, are blocking accounts, conducting searches in businesses, completely stopping

business operations, and this is what you will sell in london as an investment climate in ukraine, where do you listen to your green metallurgy, green there and some the swamp is definitely not needed by investors who are afraid to come here, because there are big businesses or holdings that have already occupied the entire niche in the directions that you have chosen as key, but we have to offer something new , develop something new, so when we say about the new, the question is bound to arise. and how is your business climate? and in our business climate , 41% of enterprises have their tax invoices blocked for the month of may. this is the business climate . who will come here to work? 41% of enterprises

had problems with blocking and the question after how many days will you unblock the tax invoices for them, the tax office does not respond because it is possible that she will not unblock them, perhaps this activity will be stopped because without drastic changes and understanding of our what can we be interested in for the development of ukraine and the ukrainian economy, nothing travels around london, even around lugano if we in ukraine cannot, please, 417th to 423rd. i am putting to the vote amendment number 417 of the people 's deputies of southern ukraine and colleagues by the committee, it has been rejected, please vote to take into account

the 18th 418, i am being told on the 17th already i voted, i apologize for the 418th, thank you for 28 decisions, the amendment was not taken into account , 419 the amendment is taken into account by the people's deputy of the southern region and the group of colleagues, it was rejected by the committee. consideration please vote

for 30 decision not adopted amendment not taken into account 421 amendment of the people's deputy of yuzhana and the group of deputies in the committee rejected by the committee put into consideration please vote for 28 the decision was not adopted, the amendment was not taken into account 422 the amendment of the people's deputy of the group of colleagues was rejected by the committee, we put it into consideration, please vote for 28 the decision was not adopted, the amendment was not taken into account 423 the amendment of the people's deputy of the group of deputies was rejected by the committee, it was taken into account, i

ask you to vote for 29 the decision was not adopted, the amendment was not taken into account and the following four more edits are correct no, we still need the last block or am i next 424 on the 27th four minutes, i'm two minutes and we'll finish well, uh, i'd like to vote on this draft law now i sign no, clearly, not honestly . maybe i'm making an effort to do better. it's true. i haven't done it yet.

everything is always dobryansk on the committee and the situation is still the same in the hall. well, it can't be. and this is what i am addressing to the voters so that you understand that there is no pluralism to be elected . next time, so that there is some kind of representation in all the bodies that work for you dear voters, it did not happen such a one-sided situation, i simply once again appeal to the military, we will continue to work on the sources and discuss in the working group, which was created from people's deputies, about the return of the thirty, if it would be acceptable for all editors, so that it would be worked out again by the team, secondly, i appeal to of the budget committee, please explain, provide letters to the factions, why the budget sequestration is not being prepared, in any case, in any case, all indicators already have deviations such that

changes are required to the state budget and next, please never say out loud that there are no funds before that, you must first work and then make some statements because it looks very strange. i have now made a minimal list of what we could work on, and the reserves are even larger. thank you for your attention and to those who voted for support thank you. i am putting four more amendments to the vote. 424 amendment, please , rejected by the committee, we will take it into account. i ask you to vote for 32. the decision was not

adopted. the amendment was not taken into account. rejected, please vote to take into account 28, the decision was not adopted, the amendment was not taken into account, 426 the washing machine of the people's deputies of yuzhany and colleagues by the committee, the proposal was rejected, please vote for 30 , the decision was accepted, the amendment to account 427 , the amendment of the people's deputy of yuzhyan, to colleagues , was rejected by the committee, to be taken into account, please vote for 37 no decision was made

, the amendment was not taken into account, these are all amendments to be taken into account. we continue to work for the victory glory to ukraine happy constitution day dear ukrainians i sincerely congratulate you on the day of the constitution of ukraine as a basic law it lays not only a legal but primarily a valuable foundation of the ukrainian people as a modern civilized society and ukraine as a modern civilized state, it is a real social contract that reflects that we as a people consider it correct and what is unacceptable, how we want to live and what we categorically do not accept , how we see our future and how ready we are

to protect this future, the basis of the constitution is the first article that defines ukraine as a sovereign and independent democratic social and legal state, such characteristics of the ukrainian state are fundamental and are somehow reflected in other provisions of the basic law, the following articles of the constitution define that the sovereignty of ukraine extends to its entire territory, which is an integral and inviolable protection of territorial sovereignty the integrity of ukraine and ensuring its security are the most important functions of the state and the business of the entire ukrainian people on february 24 year, we saw that this is not just a declaration of the aggression of an inadequate neighbor with excessive ambitions, and phantom pains, this is the time of imperial greatness

, the ukrainian people and the ukrainian state, at the cost of incredible efforts and huge losses , defend the independence, sovereignty and territorial integrity of our state. we have already achieved great successes, but there is more to come. the difficult path that will lead us to the restoration of the committee within the constitutional boundaries of 1991, the democratic nature of our state means that for a little more than 30 years the independence of ukraine is already headed by the sixth president, not a president who is thinking of running for a fifth, and preferably even a sixth term, and this is the fundamental basis of the interaction between the state and society, the consequences of its violation can be observed in the same russia, where ten years of unlimited powers of state leaders leads to the distortion of the self-perception of one's place and the function of the state

. in conclusion, the role of the state itself in the world, however , ukraine is not russia, and in our country, the people, not the government , determine who governs the ukrainian state at the same time, the two revolutions demonstrated that the people are ready to defend the democratic system of their country and their right to vote, and any government must respect this people or it ceases to be a government because ukrainians are free and dignified people who have the will to defend their principles even if the price may be life or health, finally, a social and legal state in accordance with the third article of the constitution of ukraine, a person, his life and health, honor and dignity, inviolability and security are recognized as the highest social the value of human rights and freedoms and their guarantees determine the content and direction