[000:00:00;00] ukrainian genius vasyl stus, i think that now they have all been trained by the bug medvedchuk is already in moscow and some lawyers have come to them, he says how to defend so that an innocent person is guilty i think so now at least i know why putin wanted this to get medvedchuk to teach me finally now we will have a plot and an advertisement and the whole plot is an advertisement so i say goodbye in 10 minutes i think we will meet again and fly together with you all the way to kazakhstan like this and now the advertisement and the plot battle for kyiv is key an episode of the first stage of the war, russian troops advanced to the capital from both banks of the dnieper at once ukrainian defenders in kyiv region, chernihiv region and sumy

region covered the occupiers with fire, cut supply routes and set up ambushes at the end of march , the russians fled from the north of ukraine kyiv is special let's protect kyiv let's protect the state the west believed in the victory of ukraine and decided to supply it with heavy weapons in the summer of 2022. the battle for donbas was already in full swing, the occupiers were covering ukrainian positions with a barrage of fire , using multiple advantages in artillery, after heavy battles and at the cost of heavy losses, they managed to capture almost the entire luhansk region, in particular, severodonetsk and lysychansk, and thanks to the heroic resistance of the defenders of mariupol, which was held back by the overwhelming enemy forces for three months , an outstanding success in the south was the destruction of the flags on the black sea fleet of the moscow missile cruiser cruiser moskva, which was hit by our missiles yesterday, where it is playing in the black sea. thanks to kumov forces for

impeccable work already in june, ukraine received the first hummers, these are extremely accurate salvo missile systems began to change the course of hostilities armed forces hit ammunition depots and headquarters the russian army began to lose its key advantage unlimited artillery shells ukrainians hit more than 400 targets with highmax and they had a devastating effect at the end of august 2022 the ukrainian counteroffensive began the armed forces released more part of kharkiv region, in particular balaklia, kupyansk and raisin, then deoccupied liman in donetsk region , regular strikes on crossings across the dnipro and the explosion on the crimean bridge made the position of the russian group in the right bank kherson region critical. in the end, the enemy was forced to leave the only regional center that he managed to capture from february 24. on november 11, the fighters of the armed

forces entered kherson, having lost the initiative on the front, the russian army resorted to terrorist tactics of attacks on critical infrastructure projects in response, the west began to increase supplies of air defense systems, despite large-scale power outages in the country managed to survive the winter failed and the winter offensive ref russian attacks were repulsed on avdiyiv ughledar and other directions, the fiercest battles continued for bakhmut at the cost of huge losses in the so-called meat assaults, wagner's private military campaign managed to capture practically the entire city. another war crime and they blew up the kahiv hpp, this led to the flooding of a large part of the kherson region on the 500th day of the war, which was supposed to end according to the plans

of the rashists in three days, the ukrainian army confidently is advancing on zaporizhzhia and near bakhmut , the russians are attacking libanok in the direction of kupyan, fierce fighting is going on. people, i thank you. thank you to everyone who fights for the sake of ukraine and let freedom heal for ukraine . i wanted all our heroes of different times. the one that is to be won right now will be a tribute to all those

who gave their lives for the sake of ukraine. we will definitely win, we will definitely win, glory to ukraine, stress, there are discounts on glycysed and glycysed tablets max 15% in pharmacies podorozhnyk, it is always easier for you and oshdka to get poisoned when ordinary water is not enough for adults and children i recommend reo we will save ourselves with water reo reo water for special medical purposes love radical tango for your hair join the community with a ukrainian view of the world become a sponsor of the youtube channel espresso and this is access to exclusive content personal thanks

pinned comments special icons and the possibility of personal communication with the espresso team, click to sponsor and become part of the community with a ukrainian perspective, vasyl zima's long broadcast my name is vasyl zima, two hours of air time, two hours of your time, we will talk about the most important things, two hours to learn about the war , serhiy zhoretska joins our broadcast , military summaries of the day and how does the world live? what is there in the world ? pastukhov is ready to talk about sports for two hours in the company of his favorite presenters, about culture during the war. is lina ready to talk about other presenters who have become familiar to many ? maybe the weather will give us some optimism, mrs. natalka didenko is ready to tell us, and we will also have distinguished guests of the studio today, volodymyr grishko, if everything

goes well, the events of the day in two hours, the big broadcast of vasyl zima, a project for intelligent and caring people, in the evening, i will meet with you vitaliy portnikov and we will discuss the main events of this week vitaliy portnikov and the top experts on the most striking events of the last seven days, our guest will be the generator of satellite forces, the former national security adviser to the president of the united states, donald trump, herbert mcmaster, we will touch on current topics , h, three questions, authoritative comments and forecasts in the project, an informational marathon with vitaly portnikov every sunday at 20:10 on espresso hello, this freedom of the morning information project of the radio freedom here guests are here every day this is

the shipping district of kherson turn on live we are somewhere in the vicinity of bakhmut tell the main thing on weekdays at 9:00 a.m. war in in ukraine, the main topic for ukrainians is victories and losses, analysis and forecasts, politics and geopolitics, serhiy rudenko and the guests of his program will talk about all this, people who have information and shape public opinion, people who defend ukraine and create the future, the main and interesting thing in the program is the verdict of serhiy rudenko with

monday through friday at 8:00 p.m. repeat at 12:10 september until 8:00 p.m. we will be with you not only us but also dimash alzhanov kazakh political scientist i hope he will appear now i think i will switch to russian the language is because it is unlikely in kazakhstan. everyone understands ukrainian, where i see it so far. but i hope you will see it. hello, dimash . thank you for finding time for us . it is probably too late. yes. good evening . thank you for the invitation. 10 pm 10 pm. i have two technological questions, the first is not one. even

when we say kazakh political scientist , it is correct that because there is a lot of kazakh , that kazakhs prefer kazakhstan , so they prefer kazakhstan, or cossacks. you know that’s why about the consensus no, i am personally a supporter of the fact that polit is not the name of the kazakhs, eh. it was not an ethnic definition, but a definition in the name of the political nation , only the ukrainian example, eh , it will be formed . some kazakhs well, kazakhs and kazakhs are not offended if i , for example

, make a mistake. okay, then let's start more specific things. they lead such a cautious party, well, after all, i’m not pro-russian politics, and it sounds very understandable to us. and in internal politics, how much in the middle of kazakhstan are there any tendencies toward liberalization, some greater freedom , some big opportunities for journalists , for people, for meetings for some expressed may be a greater opportunity in business, not only there , the nazybayeva family controls it, some other people can, small, medium, may be even a large or large business, but organize and create and so further, here's what's at home in kazakhstan, what are the moods and the situation, please tell us. the mood is not the most pleasant at home here

. the fact is that the regime has not changed much . he forced to review some repressive policies. the policy remained simple. now it has the current format. yes, you are not uh, uh , you are pressing society, but gradually and electing leaders so that there is no organizational principle, this is for mobilizing protest, and so on, the reform that they were all mostly cosmetic, that is, the constitution introduced more than 30 articles into the constitution, but all of them were exclusively technical. power and

not under the control of society, the parliament is not for anyone, so you are talking about the fact that there are serious changes and opportunities for political activity are free for journalists, and for all this, it is possible to hurry a little, and i will say that it is a view from the side of kazakhstan, there remains a consolidated autocracy where the elections do not work, the power cannot be changed peacefully, therefore , we are in the format of a zero-sum game with zero sums there is something that was in ukraine before the 14th year, or they will win, or others . well, i would argue a little here that even under yanukovych , we had some kind of maidan , i don’t have a language maidan. the business of the maidan, that is, people used to come out here, my

question is to you, uh, to your dimash. and that's what they are afraid that well, well, people came out and said we don’t like it there, i don’t know it, and then another 100 people came out on the third day. yes, they work with them there , someone is detained, someone is released, someone is judged, someone is not judged, etc. some other vests, the same in ukraine, on khreshchatyk in the center, well, they gathered people said something and waved flags, and in general, as a rule, they did not touch them, but then they finally touched them, well, out of ten cases , let's say 2 3 touched the rest, but there are people sitting there who want something, well, it's okay, the authorities were not too worried about this a why don't kazakhs ask about russia? and why are they afraid? they are afraid that

200 will come out, then another 200 will come out, and then everything will come out , and then that is, they really think that the revolutionary thoughts of the people of kazakhstan are so strong that they cannot even be allowed to go out into the street. there is sex человек или 200 и и публикование это in some small newspaper about the fact that they came out there somewhere, that's the question of course, eh example with yanukovych, i took you to simply be closer to you in order to understand in ukraine when yes in principle you refer to look at your question, after the 19th year, when nazarbayev left the country of god for salvation and formally appointed you the only receiver in the corner of the country, the society felt the opportunity or necessity to even express its protests, or from the 19th year , it grew very much births are different

protest actions and rallies, i was the only one who organized it precisely from the side of the youth, and what happened in invaria . according to the presidential administration's advisers , tokaev, this is precisely the result of the relaxation that was allowed after the 19th year. that is, i believe they are watching it's regrettable and now everyone is asked as much as possible to cross everything about the reaction to the root if they pass numerous , that is, it's also about the scum of some time, eh , the organizers are delayed, arrested, and the fine or arrest changes, and so on for example, your colleague is a well-known journalist in kazakhstan with his youtube channel, and he was arrested twice for organizing a rally, and for the third time, he has an incriminating connection with the banned positional party of the communist party of ukraine mukhtar

oblyazov and now he could threaten a serious term , that is, this is a criminal case , and one more small question, then we will look at the north of kazakhstan we used to talk about russia and this is a general place that, er, the zero years, russians began to live better. and that's why when they were in power, you live well and keep quiet, and that's it. well, god, my family won't stand out there, really , my salary will be higher, eh these are the things i can take, even money in the bank is cheaper, and so on, i will go to turkey, that i will go out to the square there on the maidan , they are

shouting something. they are given something instead, we will not let you go out on the streets , but we will create such conditions that you will live a little bit better, this is not happening , eh, the prosperity that we had, eh, in the middle of the 2000s, when oil prices rose sharply, kazakhstan began to make efforts there may still be pressure on the wrong dollars. it flowed through various corruption schemes downwards and reached a certain part of society. now this effect does not exist . why, on the other hand, they are afraid of any protest actions and rallies because uh distribution of wealth oil rent it does not benefit the majority , well, it also remains in the hands of a small group connected with the presidents and his entourage, so in the last elections, so that even you understand the society as a whole, it refused these elections , the only independence is sociologically

scum which was held 12 days before the election, in my opinion, it showed only 20% support, i use the party of the president of oman , this is a former company in america, the society has been severely depleted, and they are not replacing him. the lack of freedom by certain economic owners for access to these resources, so the situation is quite shaky , so now even those political entrepreneurs who do not pose a serious threat, even if they are some under there, in relation to others , criminal cases are initiated to keep them in suspense states, that is, any signs or personalities of individuals who are capable of mobilizing society or having some kind of base of their own, they are already perceived seriously as

a threat well, now the north of kazakhstan how real are the separatist sentiments there? we all know that the north of kazakhstan is a territory where there are many russians. i don't know the armed forces of the russian federation, how this whole story began with a large-scale invasion of polarization in society by an information war . roulette chat in every way you are trying to provoke er citizens of kazakhstan who sympathize with er kremlin and at the everyday level, of course, there are certain

sympathies . this is mainly an old population, an aging population and an ethnic one, too , er, more towards the slavs, and it is clear that kazakhstan is strongly influenced by the information space of russia propaganda is one factor. the second factor is, let’s say, the loyal policy of the kazakh leadership in relation to the kremlin, with the help of the dkb, russian troops in kazakhstan for support, etc. in that the society is not informed, we live in an information vacuum, where the propaganda of russian and meat free

trades is present, the society does not participate in the public there is no parliament for a broad discussion. where was the second political discussion held, that is, people do not fully understand what is happening, but rather get information from russian leaflets, because they are more popular than kazakhstani ones, and because they are also available everywhere in any network broadcasting is, er, penetration is enough deep, that is, all these factors influence , of course, this is the last important factor, this is not the integration of society, that is, we have a division not only ethnic, but also for whom and these borders are asymmetric, that's why for 30 years the policy was not carried out on integration, you are probably familiar with it in ukraine, too , and so on. it is still draining, and uh, authoritarian countries in the soviet style, as if they developed by inertia after the collapse of the soviet union, they did not build modern ones a state with a national state with one

a-a well let's say so with a high penetration of one state language a-a with mechanisms of participation in political life and so on and so on, that is, people who live in the north watch russian tv and more economically connected with the southern regions of russia, they are naturally not integrated and, er, they do not feel unity and with participation in one community. this is indeed a problem that needs to be solved comprehensively here, not only the issue of the primary education system here, everyone there is a single sunset, how will it be implemented so that it is without discrimination so that it serves as a serious incentive for the integration of others operating in kazakhstan, but everyone ignored this war, there was no war before that and the corresponding problems are necessary , that is, bilateral relations of the adductors, they

somehow do not imply systematicity in this regard . so, since you are simply closer in er central asia to er uzbekistan, am i correct i understand that there are going to be elections in uzbekistan, something, too, merziev is coming again, it means that there are elections, something is changing there, and in general, now there will be such a monolith will not even be, well, there was once kyrgyzstan, so in general , until we were in kyiv, we thought that there was something democracy exists when mirzoev came to power it was also easier, it became a little easier to live and i even have two friends of western correspondents, they had a ban, they came there in the 90s to shoot something in uzbekistan, they gave him a prison sentence for 10 years and then later that's how er came merzoev removed it and even invited

how there let's now somehow all this menyaetsya again to where it came from, that's what you say it will really now be a union of such authoritarianisms, well, we will not take er turkmenia where there is no this is not authoritarianism totalitarianism, yes , yes, i think that it has already gone quite far. that's right, i understand that we already thought more than that here in ukraine, we got lucky, and that's what will happen. i understand, or still there are some hopes, something, something can change, not everything is true. i just wonder sometimes why people from the outside always ask for some hopes, and these all-powerful cognitive distortions create a completely false picture a-a and-y,

of course, there is a certain one in the first few pairs the rhetoric is especially public. and there is a certain desire to renew the namesake, especially he was strong, personified point. we have, how is it, uzbekistan is connected with the karinovs , this is the tyranny of the pt. well, he changes the constitution, he congratulates the uprising of the kolpakovs, and he provides himself with two presidential positions, that is , until the 35th or 37th year, the question of his presidency is decided if there is no serious a-a m-m of the conflict, or the division of the military-political field after the departure of one autocrat, it does not fragment, so there is a greater probability that you will get a second autocrat with almost 100% probability, which if he gives everything quickly to consolidate how did the peace with the effect how did it last

year and including ukrainian analysts and commentators , this is how a dictatorship is formed, the only difference is that such a person comes to positions at a late age and has a maximum of 7 years, plus another two or three years is possible i have a bigger reserve, therefore , and the constitution has changed accordingly, taking into account this period of time, i will ask you this unpleasant question . the passivity of the population when i watch. i think that, well, listen. well, what can be done if 300,000-400,000 people come to the square - this is a little sobering

. it has changed. well, you can’t do it anyway. it seems to me that going out on the streets still cuts off the power. and we don’t see any such mass protests . i specifically asked about economic life in kazakhstan. what can be i really don’t want to because there is bread, there is a piece of butter on the bread, and there is good sausage with butter on top, and why should i go there to the square ? let's go in order not to get confused when you perceive your experience with ukraine, you need to take into account the fact that the country originally developed in the 90s a little under the second trajectory, and it was initially difficult to consolidate and flow . there was no pipe or

gas pipe that would have helped them initially dominate the oligarchs, er, consolidation did not happen much, and the second type of economy created a slightly different structure of society for business and private months still created such a distribution of the dispersion of capital in kazakhstan in the 90s, everything connected went in the second 93rd hour, the parliament is dissolved , we go to the fourth and in 95, then the constitution is adopted, which completely creates the dictator nazarbayev in these years, 30 years are systematically destroyed any institutions. yes, there are no political parties, that is, in kazakhstan. until now, there are no political parties. your whole position is illegal. they are declared extremists and others. others have criminal cases against others. they cannot

engage in political activity. any organized actions always run into serious repression. sooner or later , you still start to lose because you don't have the resources to protect yourself, we visit people, and so on. consolidation, any opportunities for the organization to collect resources in order to introduce positional activities, in these conditions there are spontaneous protests in the last year's accidents, something similar it happened when tens of thousands of people in different cities came out . they went to the field, they didn't want to replace this regime . you can also see the effect of burying there, er , the presence of a weak central government