[000:00:00;00] wants them to commit genocide of the 20th century, but the truth is that if it were not for president yushchenko's dedication to this topic, today there would not be 33 countries that recognized the holodomor. the truth is that if the ukrainian public had not turned to the authorities after the revolution of dignity and received the support of president poroshenko and the government the demand to resume the construction that ukraine is actively conducting today on the way to the completion of the world's first holodomor museum of a modern world-class museum complex , the completion of which involved the best scientists the architectural design forces of ukraine and the world, the truth is that president zelenskyi and today the verkhovna rada contributed to the maintenance of the completion of this draft law . our main responsibility now is not to lose the pace of the creation of the museum in any case and

not to lose the quality of the construction itself , and especially the exposition of pravda for the design and the installation of which still needs a certain period of time, the term of similar museums is not easy and long-term . faction asks for support in the first and second reading, thank you, dear colleagues, we are concluding the discussion of this draft law, we are moving on to adoption, and i apologize rudyk yes yes brudyk i apologize dear colleagues, it so happened that in 2007-10, as the deputy mayor of kyiv, i took care of this

issue in the city and fought with symbols of totalitarianism when at the same time we honored the victims of the holodomor and in the city of kyiv there were monuments that were actually beaten by the three leaders of soviet ukraine kosior petrovskyi and chubari, i was shocked i found out that we are only going to complete the second part of the memorial. it has been 13 years since he left this position. 13 years ago, we allocated billions of funds for stadiums. do you remember with what markup? and we still cannot allocate funds for the memorial to the victims of the head. we all vote in favor and make sure that this money they did not steal the memory

of the people who died for us . dear colleagues from baku. freedom-loving ukrainian people, and definitely today, when there is an opportunity to take a step in order to immortalize the memory of those ukrainians who gave their lives, those who were innocently killed for you, you and i could be in our native ukrainian state today, it is very important, this moment is also important, so that already start building the pantheon of modern heroes who , unfortunately, gave their lives so that in every city in every community , large and beautiful pantheons must be made for those modern ukrainians who, unlike you and i

, gave this state the most precious life. glory glory to our heroes to the armed forces of ukraine glory to ukraine glory to the heroes dear colleagues, please i invite the people's deputies to take their seats the proposal of the committee to adopt this draft law as a whole , but i will put these two decisions in turn dear colleagues, please, i put the proposal to adopt the draft law as a basis on making changes to the third appendix number three to the law of ukraine on the state budget of ukraine for 2023 i am ready to vote i ask the people's

deputies to vote for 305 the decision has been adopted i put the proposal adopt as a whole with the necessary technical and legal amendments the draft law on amendments to appendix number three to the law of ukraine on the state budget of ukraine for 2023 registration number 94-37 ready to vote i ask people's deputies to vote for 312 decision adopted law adopted as a whole thank you colleagues let's go next dear colleagues , the next draft law without discussion was immediately such a proposal 94:15 this is a draft law on amendments to the law of ukraine on

lease of state and communal property regarding use of property by national institutions of higher education of the state ownership form i propose to include this draft law in the agenda of the session of ordinary people's deputies to vote for 309 decision passed i propose to adopt as a basis the draft law on amendments to the law of ukraine on lease of state and communal property regarding the use of property by national institutions of higher education of the state ownership registration number 94 15 i ask the people's deputies to vote for 312 i put the proposal to accept in general with

with the necessary technical legal amendments, the draft law on amendments to the law of ukraine on the state lease of state and communal property regarding the use of property by national institutions of higher education of the state form of ownership registration number 94 15 i ask the people's deputies to vote for 312 law the decision has been made the law will come as a whole dear colleagues, the next draft law 8410 is a draft law on amendments to the law of ukraine on environmental impact assessment this is the second reading we agreed that we have there will be two amendments from gerashchenko and we will vote. i will vote correctly. there will be no amendments. we can vote immediately. dear colleagues, i propose to accept in the second reading and in general, with the necessary technical and legal amendments , the draft law on amendments to the law

of ukraine on environmental impact assessment , registration number 84.10, please. people 's deputies to vote for 256 decisions adopted the law was adopted as a whole i congratulate my colleagues on the next draft law 93 11-193-11-93 11-4 93 11 3-1 dash de dear colleagues, we agreed at the conciliation council that only the authors will speak without discussing the issue and we vote for the authors, we will have a speech i understand two claps and tymoshenko, are you growing up insisting not insisting then maksym clapping after that yulia tymoshenko will be kucherenko yes ok

please maksym mykolayovych clapping after that kucherenko and after that vote , please. good afternoon, dear colleagues . the draft law revised in the committee, which provides for a one-time special procedure for the corporate restructuring of a gas transmission operator, is brought to your attention. system of ukraine that was originally proposed by the cabinet of ministers of ukraine, but with added safeguards that remove the risks of non-fulfillment of the assumed international obligations within the framework of agreements on receiving financing from the international monetary fund and the european union the restructuring of the gts operator a before the imf to transfer the corporate rights of the gts operator from the msu joint-stock company to the ministry of energy and then to adopt the agreed by the secretariat of the energy community, the charter and that's all

until july of this year, and to form the supervisory board of the operator of the gas transportation system by the end of october 2023. i want to emphasize that these are not just obligations, but structural beacons of the imf, that is , one of the most important conditions for the implementation of this program. the revised draft law contains all the fuses proposed people 's deputies of ukraine who do not allow to deviate from the declared course of reform and this draft law is fully agreed with the secretary of the energy community so one of the key norms that we found, to which we found a joint agreement between the committee of the ministry of energy and the secretariat, is the receipt of a mandatory opinion of the secretariat of the energy community to ensure the continuity of the certification of the operator during the adoption of the new charter, i emphasize that the independent professional operator of the gts is an extremely important element of the energy activity security of our ukraine and the guarantor of a stable supply

of natural gas to consumers, taking into account the importance of the reform and taking into account the fact that there is not much left for its implementation, please support the committee's decision to vote for the revised one as a basis and in general, thank you dear colleagues, please give the floor to kucherenka thank you oleksiy kucherenko , the batkivshchyna faction, i am one of the half authors, together with yulia tymoshenko, of the alternative draft law , i explain why we consider these authors to be the authors of what our draft laws are more effective and pragmatic, well, first of all, i want to point out that no we

are not talking about what kind of reform, so to speak, right now. let's be frank, we are talking about correction of the situation, correction of the error that was assumed by the verkhovna rada in the 19th year, when the very fast accelerated regime, which was then very fashionable, adopted the so-called unbanning according to an absolutely unacceptable scheme, according to an absolutely unacceptable management system, when in fact two structures made llc, the operator of the gts, the state company msu, it is clear that this two-level management structure is the result of a complete management crisis, and before the fiasco of this model , unfortunately, at that time , another huge mistake was made, they disconnected the only technological complex is the gas transportation system of ukraine, which remained in the company ukrgaz ukrtransgaz, a subsidiary company of naftogaz, and from the storage and , accordingly, the operator of the gts, which is controlled

by the pipe, this was also a huge mistake, which for today, well, in essence, translates all the mistakes and all losses on consumers, our draft law, together with yulia tymoshenko , corrects this error, it unites the unified gas transport system of storage and gas transmission system into a single complex, and it creates an unambiguous management system of this complex through mini department of energy, i ask you to support our draft law dear colleagues dear colleagues dear colleagues, we have finished the discussion, we are moving on to making a decision, i ask the people's deputies to take their

seats, please take your seats dear colleagues dear colleagues, i propose to adopt as a basis the draft law on optimization of the ownership structure of the operator of the gas transportation system of ukraine, registration bill number 93-11-1 ready to vote ready to vote i ask the people's deputies to vote

for 268 decision made thank you colleagues let's go next, the next draft law 914-1 draft law on amendments to the customs code of ukraine regarding the use of customs declarations and the electronic transit system provided for by the convention on the joint transit procedure for the implementation of transit on the basis of this code, we spoke for 3 minutes , there will be a speech by tymoshenko, one amendment per vote and we vote yes there will be no speech from the motherland from the voice of amendments , there will also be no because we will immediately move on to making a decision, i put the proposal to be accepted in the second reading and in general with with the necessary technical legal amendments, the draft law on amending the customs code of ukraine regarding the use of customs declarations and the electronic transit system provided for by the convention on the procedure

of joint transit for the implementation of transit under the terms of this code, registration number 914-1 are ready to vote simply people's deputies to vote for 285 decisions have been adopted law adopted in general. congratulations colleagues, let's move on. 9266 is a draft law on electronic agricultural receipts. i

propose to include this issue in agenda of the session, i ask you to vote for 278, the decision was made as follows : i propose to consider this issue according to the abbreviated procedure of ordinary people's deputies to vote for 255, the decision was made. dear colleagues, the procedure was shortened. 22 against. please

, mr. kirylenko, ivan hryhorovych, yes, kyrilenko , his homeland, dear mr. chairman, dear colleagues, i have not seen so many comments on the draft law for a long time. of scientific and export management, friends, with 17 uborist texts that make it impossible to accept, well, at first glance, the popular and relevant name electronic receipts , digitalization is clear, but friends, how many loopholes are there in this draft law that make it impossible to support a good document, i will not dwell on all of them, but it is impossible

to say about the fundamental things well, first of all, there are friends and the law on agrarian receipts, which is already familiar to commodity producers, is in effect. everyone is used to it. it works normally, why did we have to make another law with blurred norms and not clearly established procedures for which both one law and the other will operate, the scientific and expert administration simply did not write that there will be chaos, it will be chaotic, but it is clearly visible in this chaos that the victim will gain a benefit, and the victim will be a farmer, a farmer, a producer of agricultural products, our peasants. to acquire what it was invented by friends for the first time there is an opportunity to pledge the land, it is a little crowded, but clearly everything comes down to the pledge of the land, taking into account that crediting in

agriculture is almost non-existent because the discount rate of the national bank is 25, this means that commercial banks give us less than 30, it is a phantasmagoria in these conditions to take such a loan and even more with the same funds that are available in commercial banks. there are more games to go, so friends, of course, the parties will reach out to whoever can give, please pavlenko ruslan mykolayovych european faction solidarity of the southerner after that kovalchuk and let's move on to voting oleksandr kovalchuk please dear colleagues this idea of ​​introducing electronic agricultural receipts is more than two years and i think we have already discussed more than once that this is an additional tool for crediting our farmers. by the way , the committee received a lot of letters in support of this draft law from companies

that credit agricultural producers. and in general , since 2013, the mechanism of these paper agricultural receipts has it is used quite widely, but it is modern at the moment , agrarians supposedly need such an update, it seems to me that we will pay attention to all the comments of gneu, because the two operating systems should remain in parallel because if we talk only about electronic agrarian receipts, it is generally even worse than it was. therefore, we really need to work before the second reading, but i am very concerned about the question in general about the information that is currently circulating in all the media, this is the information of law enforcement agencies about all the revelations of criminal actions in the field of supply

of agricultural products for export. please tell me when it will stop if we have not learned elementary things to control what we are talking about. i hope that the 300 companies that shipped grain through the grain corridor to the court for those a small number of ships, after all, someone will one day answer for the non-return of foreign currency earnings and non-payment of taxes to the country's budget. why did the information go out again ? significant violations in this area have been exposed again in the last two months. it seems to me that this needs to be dealt with at the level of the ministries and not only at the level of our committee please kovalchuk, dear colleagues, and after that we will proceed to voting, please

, dear prode dear colleagues, dear ukrainians, i listen carefully to what my colleagues from other factions are saying and i would very much like these speeches ukrainian agrarians heard after all, it is strange to me the position that was expressed by both the first and the second speaker that it is not clear which agrarians need it. dear colleagues, i will voice out which agrarian organization needs it, it is necessary for the agrarians of ukraine, precisely those agrarians who cultivate in extremely difficult conditions during the war the land sends the guys to the front lines, they send a large amount of their products and funds in the form of vehicles, weapons, drones and

everything else that the armed forces need from their own equipment for the sake of victory, these are precisely those who were limited in the export of their products because we had a problem and there is a problem with export, both by water and through land corridors, and these are precisely those agrarians who need our help, everything is very simple to our committee numerous associations, not individual agricultural companies , and which were mentioned here for some reason, and this bill is also supported by the ministry of finance and agrarian policy of ukraine, who say that of course there are technical points that need to be taken into account, but there are no objections and the law that is in force on agrarians on agrarian receipts remains in force, that is, there is an active mechanism and there is a new electronic mechanism , you and i talk a lot about the fact that electronic documents, electronic document management gives us more opportunities, so let's give our farmers more opportunities in fin - dear

colleagues, thank you we have finished the discussion , we are proceeding to decision-making, please take your seats dear colleagues, i propose to adopt the draft as a basis for the elaboration of the provisions in accordance with the first part of article 116 of the regulations of the verkhovna rada of ukraine of the law on electronic agricultural receipts, registration number 9266, ready to vote, i ask the people's deputies to vote for 270, the decision has been adopted . i congratulate colleagues, the next draft law 9230 is a draft law on amendments to article 16 of the law of ukraine on currencies and currency transactions regarding responsibility for violations

of settlement deadlines of exports , i propose to include this issue in the agenda of the session, i ask to vote for 233 the following decision was made, i propose to consider this issue for

by abbreviated procedure simply people's deputies to vote for 235 decisions have been made dear colleagues, we vote yes, please write it down 22 against , please shulyak olena oleksiivna faction , servant of the people, please dear colleagues, do not disagree because there are two speeches and we will vote , please, ladies, but dear colleagues, i ask you to support this bill it concerns our experts and therefore it is necessary to support it as soon as possible. thank you, please. pavlenko rostyslav mykolayovych faction

of the european solidarity political party. thank you, please. dear colleagues, i am calling your attention cynically and irresponsibly , it seems to me that such irresponsibility from the government of the national bank should not have been expected . to the exporters who worked with the russian federation and belarus until the last day, on the day of the beginning of a large-scale war, from these two countries, we did not receive foreign exchange earnings on time at the beginning of the war, we rather, the national bank, by its resolution, approved the order that there is an exception for all our experts who did not receive foreign currency income, but not to the exclusion of the russian federation and belarus, so if

in fact now someone is considered necessary to work every year with countries that continue to bombard us on the head every day and and uh, to kill our economy in general, let ’s help them, you say that these are the same enterprises and exporters, yes. and why then do we not help in the same way in the same way those enterprises that are exporters today deliver their goods to other countries and cannot receive foreign exchange earnings on time within 100-180 days . let's then liberalize for those who expand our export opportunities and not for those who, taking into account the risks, supplied products to these countries in their incomes taking into account all the risks and payment to a certain state, including that , think 10 times how to take such steps for the benefit of even those respectable ukrainian companies, which some deputies are now trying to protect at the level of the law, for

this there is the national bank of ukraine if it will make such a decision dear colleagues, we have finished discussing this bill above yes then please 1 minute one minute this is the father please dear colleagues in no case can you support this bill what is business business is when an enterprise takes certain risks understanding these risks it can receive profit or loss , unfortunately, some ukrainian enterprises did business with russia, it was allowed, i don't blame them for this, the state allowed it, but they understood that there were certain risks associated with it including legislative risks and when there were certain export transactions , the legislation was such that it was clear to them that in the event of any situation that they