[000:00:00;00] introducing new subjects, prescribing new procedures and so on, in principle, if we are for the purity of the process, then this must be followed , otherwise it turns out that we did not try, and secondly, it does not directly apply to this draft law, but a lot of our projects go with the correct blue like this flag with asterisks uh, how do these draft laws become a priority there and european integration, i think that the correct way would be to correlate them with the specific obligations that we have even before joining the eu and with regard to joining nato. that since after vilnius we do not have concrete things with which it would be possible to check, the parliament could work out these and the criteria by which we could make

changes and improvements in the legislation here, agree on this with partners and really at the washington nato summit to withdraw from e- is a clear list of what reforms have been made and we should receive 16 thank you thank you please tsabel volodymyr volodymyrovych and after that i vote dear colleagues dear colleagues, we currently have more than a thousand enterprises in the state at the stage liquidations that generate billions in losses for the state. every year, this is the money that could have gone to the budget. you know how many enterprises were liquidated in the 21st year. two, all the others continued to generate these losses that we could use for the needs of the army, education and other things. this bill will significantly speed up and make it possible the process of liquidation really complements the previous one, but it will allow

, including financially, to speed up and ensure this process so that the number of such enterprises finally starts to decrease so that the state starts to make a profit colleagues urge everyone to support this draft law thank you thank you dear colleagues, we have completed the discussion of this draft law, i propose to adopt as a basis the draft law on amendments to the budget code of ukraine in connection with the adoption of the law on the peculiarities of the termination of state-owned enterprises by decision of the state property fund of ukraine registration number of the law of the draft law i apologize 93-87 are ready to vote i ask the people's deputies to vote for 248

decisions have been made there is another proposal will halve the deadline for submission of proposals on the rules for preparing for the second reading regarding draft law 9387, which was just adopted in the first reading as a basis , i ask people's deputies to vote in favor of 229 decision adopted dear colleagues, the following draft law 9384 is a draft law on amending some legislative acts of ukraine regarding the functioning of telemedicine i i put a motion to include this bill in the agenda of the session, i ask you to vote for 252, the decision has been made dear colleagues, yes,

without discussion, we will accept it, no, then i i am asking for consideration of this issue according to the shortened

procedure for 216 , the decision has been made, please, oleksandr, please, iryna volodymyrivna gerashchenko, european, and then we will vote, colleagues do not disagree. and we have to be very vigilant here and write the bill correctly because the goal is to introduce a comprehensive and systematic approach to the formulation and implementation of a unfortunately, we see that there is a very significant a remark that concerns not only the terminology, but in principle, hmm, conducting along with the concept of electronic health care system, an additional concept of electronic health care, which actually does not overcome the problems or does not have a clearly incomprehensible meaning, that is, what is the difference between these two concepts, also a- and some issues cause changes to the law on the basics of health and, well , there are a lot of phrases that are used that really need additional clarification - it is the observance of the principles of barrier-freeness and

inclusion, that is, in general, i would like to say that there is a lack of legal certainty and unambiguity, because this topic, well, in general, the field of health care, it still needs a clearer formulation if we want this law to really work . hm, what concerns the expediency of er, also exclude some terms altogether and er, er let's say the first wording, for example, when we are talking about a single register. that is, there is health care. so there is nothing to do with telemedicine at all, that is, to the second reading very it is important to comprehensively finalize so that there are clear definitions and we understand that telemedicine in our country will work and be effective thank you thank you we are moving to the vote i am putting to the vote the proposal

to adopt as a basis the draft law with registration number 9384 on amending some legislative acts of ukraine regarding the functioning of telemedicine please vote for 245 decisions, the law was adopted, the project was adopted as a basis, we have no more resolutions to move andriy viktorovych, what are you going to move we have three resolutions left urgent well, i will propose then dear colleagues there is a proposal we have today adopted a number of good draft laws in the second reading in general, in particular about the decree and so on, therefore i propose to instruct the speaker of the verkhovna rada to immediately sign the adoption

of the verkhovna rada and the draft laws as a whole today and immediately send them to the president of ukraine if not objections i put the proposal to the vote i ask to vote i ask to support for 230 the decision is accepted thank you dear colleagues next we have three resolutions on blocking 8401 there is a proposal for them without discussion pro pro no and there are authors of the resolution they want to speak well then we will give the floor to the authors and we will move on to consideration of issue 84-01 - the draft resolution on the cancellation of the decision of the verkhovna rada of ukraine dated 30.06.2023 on the adoption in the second reading and as a whole of the draft law of ukraine on the national tax code of ukraine and other laws of ukraine regarding the peculiarities

of taxation during the period of martial law, we need a shortened voting procedure, the apparatus can tell him there is no need to vote , the procedure is ok, then we proceed to consideration of the issue, the floor is given by the authors to the people's deputy of ukraine dmytro oleksandrovich razumkova, please thank you oleksandr serhiyovych dear colleagues what are double standards when you can't stand for several months the resolution on returning 300,000 to the military for which 277 people's deputies of ukraine voted what about the army i asked not to do it. and when i asked not to do business and don't bring the resolution to the hall according to 84:01, she appeared at the next meeting. that's double

standards. i was with my colleagues in the morning the opportunity to communicate with representatives of small and medium-sized businesses, what you did not accept is a huge mistake , the so-called risky checks will in fact be carried out in 90% of those who today provide the budget of our state , one of the businessmen of small businessmen was included, who says that he is from kryvyi rih in his a small shop. he is 10 km from the front line and now he helps to restore jeep equipment for our defenders. his shop is what you are trying to tax and conduct pro

is located 600 km away, this is called a lack of conscience, this is called a lack of understanding of the processes, this is called that probably many people do not belong where they are today. i am sure that the mistakes that were made will have a strong impact on the ukrainian economy, the ukrainian state and everyone who voted 4:01 will be answerable both to the army and to business. and now i ask you to support our resolution and repeal this criminal decision . thank you

. thank you. please, european solidarity, who will be from you, then let's give two for two against, then sign up, servant of the people, please, bragar, friends, it's a very important bill, please don't waste time and demolish this resolution and proceed to signing it. thank you, european solidarity, who will be from you, nina petrivna yuzhanina please dear colleagues, the fact that you started to disagree , or rather those who have already left the hall, says a lot, and you, mr. speaker, when you do not treat these

resolutions with great care, also says that you are not understand and don't read your mail i would like to address here to each of you how many letters from city councils how many decisions do you have in your mailboxes i counted 120 this morning 120 city councils decided to appeal to stavaichuk to the president to veto 84:01 tell me, please. and then what is decentralization? you all jump around this word, and decentralization means that we give the right to the city council to the city councils to make a decision that concerns the powers of e-e that concerns natural persons-entrepreneurs the payment of a single tax is a very small resource, the local tax is a resource of the local government and when the local government turns to you with such a request, you can at least read their appeal, this is the time and decision of the deputies who

were elected by the people locally, and who else should they turn to except not to the local deputies, so i draw your attention to the fact that, despite everything, we all supported a possible return from two percent before the end of martial law to a general simplified general taxation system, but the fact that they did not hear a million 200 natural persons-entrepreneurs - this should be resolved immediately and now there is an opportunity, let's support the resolution, review the decision regarding these people, give the opportunity not to apply fines until the end of military time and at least the position will be the same for everyone. this is part of the economy - this is part of the area, please serhii volodymyrovych vlasenko and we will proceed to voting thank you, mr. chairman

well, today we have many such legislative acts that we adopt which on the one hand they look technical, but in fact, on the other hand, they raise a lot of questions of a strategic nature . business has already called bill 84:01 terrible for business, that is , small businesses have decided that this bill will hit their positions in terms of their capabilities and so on, but this bill about this bill about e- let's say this about the attitude of the state today to business about what was promised at first one thing, then they looked and said now we change again in a month we change something again and each time all these changes are not positive but

negative nature, what is needed by business, we talk a lot about investments , what is needed by business, business needs stability, business needs clear rules of the game, business needs the opportunity to make a forecast, i am not saying for 5 years, but at least for 2-3 years. unfortunately , we are taking away the opportunity from business to make such forecasts and to forecast anything at all in our activities, because today we set the days of the rules, mr. president says that they should be set, the parliament supports them in six months, in three months we say no, these rules need to be changed again this is the worst that can happen, i will not list the shortcomings of draft law 84-01, which are known to everyone today, several people's deputies, including the deputies of the homeland faction, introduced a resolution that blocked this decision because we believe that draft law 84.01 in this form in which it was adopted will harm

ukrainian small and medium-sized businesses , thank you, thank you, dear chairman, dear colleagues , absolutely every people's deputy of ukraine has the right to submit a resolution on the cancellation of the voting results, and our colleagues hereby the right has been exercised, and the right of the people's deputies of ukraine to be determined, therefore, i invite and ask you to vote as soon as possible the voting procedure itself and give the people's deputies the opportunity to determine , thank you, let's proceed to the vote . 30.06.2023 on the adoption of the second reading and in general the draft law of ukraine on amendments to the tax code of ukraine and other laws

of ukraine regarding the peculiarities of taxation in during the period of martial law registration number 7401 and 31.01.2023 a-a please vote for 53 the decision was not adopted the following resolution with registration number 84-01p1 draft resolution on the cancellation of the decision of the verkhovna rada of ukraine dated 30.06.2023 on the adoption in the second reading and as a whole of the draft law of ukraine on the introduction of changes to the tax code of ukraine and other laws of ukraine regarding the peculiarities of taxation during the martial law periods of registration number 84 01 and 30.01.203

there is a need to discuss, please, then i invite the author of mykysh, dmytro serhiyevich, to the rostrum of colleagues. the verkhovna rada made a mistake, it did not hear, it failed to communicate, it did not listen to its citizens. in this case, i am talking about those businessmen who shouted and shouted that this draft law should not be adopted in the version that it was finally adopted between the first and the second reading was a lot of correct novels, correct suggestions , correct corrections, which were primarily provided by our national local business, he proposed exactly how to improve it, but unfortunately this did not happen, colleagues, let me remind you that the blocking resolution does not repeal the draft law as a whole, it only cancels the last decision in the second reading and then we can return to the consideration of those rules that, unfortunately, were rejected or not heard during the voting between the first and second reading

colleagues, please listen to our entrepreneur, he primarily provides our economy and primarily provides our defense force, thanks to which we can now discuss this with you and vote on any initiative that is sent first of all, for the development of ukraine, so let's support our business, support our army and support ukraine . thank you, thank you. let's move on to the discussion vote. then write it down two for two against

, please. i also want to say a few words. we hear from our colleagues that something has not been finalized anywhere . communicated, i just want to invite invite, but what will we do, where will we get the funds to finance all the projects that are available to finance our economy , finance the armed forces, where to get these funds, there are many words , but the proposals are too few, and therefore i believe that these manipulations must end and move on to the real things, so i suggest, as nestervanovych said, to make up your own mind and make an appropriate decision

. thank you . thank you. thank you. volodymyr mykhailovych. european solidarity. meeting of the verkhovna rada that is now two -thirds empty because the people's deputy is not interested in discussing an issue that concerns tens of thousands, if not more, physical entrepreneurs, in particular, who, in fact, are now being thrown into the maelstrom of inspections by the authorities, a maelstrom of repressions and fines, despite the fact that it is the fops who are most likely to hint in order for our armed forces, our defense forces, to have the resources to defend the ukrainian state. to be able to be grateful, one must be able to thank and not

only with words instead of being rude, but above all with actions. invasion, where volunteers took funds for armored vehicles, which for some reason were not available in state warehouses, where volunteers took and are now taking funds for the purchase of mavics, ammunition, leaks, etc. hmm, even products that are sent to the front line, first of all, all this is done by the fops, and of course the state and the government decided to thank them by the fact that inspections are carried out on them , and from october 1 they begin to have nightmares about fines , to feel warm in their legs, to ask for forgiveness and thank them for all their help, because they are, in particular, the basis of our state, and destroying

the foundations of the economy, the foundations of our state, the foundations of aid to the armed forces of ukraine, with this draft law, in particular, you are doing everything to make ukraine lose, well, traitors are traitors , it's just a pity that their state is too much, let's go to the vote. reports said that we should be grateful to the cops indeed we should be grateful but also we should be grateful to all taxpayers and taking this opportunity i want to express my gratitude to those 10 million almost 10 million ukrainians who pay 34% of taxes from their salary fund , including a single social contribution, thanks to

which we are able to finance the army by 34%. thank you, we can go to the vote yes i am putting to the vote the proposal to adopt as a whole the draft resolution 84-01p1 on the cancellation of the decision of the verkhovna rada of 30.06.23 on the adoption in the second reading there as a whole of the draft law on amendments to the supplementary code of ukraine and other laws of ukraine regarding the specifics taxation periods of martial law registration number 84-01 dated 31.01.203 i ask you to vote for 46 decisions have not been made by factions and the third resolution i need to discuss well let's discuss this resolution please write it down then 84-01 p2 draft resolution on the cancellation of the decision of the verkhovna rada of ukraine on

the adoption of the second reading and as a whole of the draft law on amendments to the tax code of ukraine and other laws of ukraine regarding the peculiarities of taxation of martial law transfers 74 01 and 31.01.2023 please write it down two for two against please shpak love oleksiivna servant of the people oleksandrivna cordon, indeed, this hall now shows the interest in small and medium-sized businesses that people's deputies show today. i have a question for all of you. and why do you hate small and medium-sized businesses so much? small and medium-sized businesses are the basis of the economy

of any country, or do you not understand? economy or you do not aspire to the development of our country, if you take the whole business that has been mentioned more than once and helped our armed forces of ukraine today, then they are the ones who maintain this defense, they are the ones who will contribute to the war, they are the ones they go to the front lines, it is their employees who are now fighting on the front lines. if now from october 1 we will implement the pro and, accordingly, those who are fighting must return, how can they get out of this situation, for today, we do not mind continuing to work. for example, some say oh, but not during the war, you well, you will understand how small and medium-sized businesses can survive now. it's easy to go abroad, it's very simple. many businesses

today have moved to poland, bulgaria , other countries, and you want it to continue . then again, the question is: how will we fill the budget, that is, it seems that no one wants to understand this issue, only their own interests, i can’t even understand what interests everyone is pursuing today, thank you lyubov oleksandrivna nina, we need his wife i understand yes, from european solidarity , please thank you to everyone who stayed in the hall, but i want to address now more to the authorities , first of all, there is still no text of the draft law that we voted on on the website of the verkhovna rada .

companies have begun consultations and are intimidating literally everyone. there will be inspections without reading the text of the law. and it seems to me that instead of giving more information and more explanations , the authorities are doing everything to the exact opposite. and this will not lead to a loss of love for you there, it is no longer there it is absolutely obvious to the people, and to the chaos that is currently being generated among entrepreneurs and among businesses with and even medium and large ones, therefore it is very important that you continue to communicate clearly and clearly with the business environment, secondly, that the government courage and all the same on otaki objections that recently in an interview, uh, the representative of the imf fund in ukraine uh, stepanyan said that they will still look in what form to accept 84:01, whether it corresponds to the agreements and so on

so that you don't come back to the hall to re-vote in an even worse version of this draft law now. we need to gather our strength and not sit silently and wait for the end of something, but work with the imf representatives about what was done in the hall, unfortunately, there are few of you entrepreneurs today can support in that what did you turn to the local councils for the decisions that were taken by the local councils? i am very sorry that we have never learned to be united in our country and during the war we are doing exactly what we are doing, we will not fix the pain to those who form our local budgets and help arm them we proceed to the vote. i am putting to the vote the proposal to adopt as a whole the resolution with registration number 84-01 p2 on the cancellation of the decision of the verkhovna rada of ukraine on the adoption of the second reading as a whole of the draft law on amendments to the tax code of ukraine and other laws of ukraine regarding the specifics of taxation of martial law widows