[000:00:00;00] guarantors turn the storm and the state pays 15 million for a soldier killed at the front, let's just count 100 soldiers, it's 150 billion, 500, 1000 soldiers is 15 billion uah. well , what a rich country, when every second hryvnia, why supply to the front, forgive again for the technicality, but it didn't hurt cannon fodder, we will never win a war like this, our human resource is many times less than in russia and never. well, society and the rest are arranged. that is, there will always be pashulki scandals, we will lose 100%. here are russians unsurpassed, perhaps the chinese can only compete with them in this. therefore, it is not only disgusting from a moral point of view, it is not only wrong from the point of view of public administration, when the president of the supreme commander-in

-chief has to react to the behavior of the market, but it is also absurd from the point of view of combat effectiveness from the point of view of elementary economic arithmetic, that is, everywhere we lose, what is it like, gennadiya, how to solve the situation, and in general, what should be radically changed in order to change the attitude, but just now we showed a girl, a young woman, she she says she was indignant, she says they say that the resource needs to be replenished, but my husband is not a resource, yes, it is possible that this is already a question of communication, how the state communicates with citizens, the need to go to war is also another failure . it seems to me that it is a question of communication . where should we change then, a simple question. i have a volunteer unit that will not receive salaries, statuses in the bdd, there is no state support for all 8.5 years at

the front. some heads of medical institutions. they take vacations . they take vacations. for the mother's funeral, first give the card with it , she will withdraw the money, and then you will go . shift, we would have been a big concentration camp a long time ago, but on the other hand, do not idealize because why do people not want to join the best army in the world, that is a good question, now they pay well at the front , that is, well, 100,000 + in ukraine is a good

salary. that is, if they dress there in principles and they don't go, that means something is wrong. i told my bears more than once. we work with a unit behind them, there are queues , mobilize, you will be paid , that will be it. how to treat people, this is brotherhood instead of i am the boss, you are a fool, that is, it is time to look at yourself the critical time of heroism like last year has passed now the time of asymmetric war when we can only win with the quality of technology and attitude to the soldier like saving private ryan and not like русский бабы еще наражень от as soon as we get rid of these relapses of sovietism from the army, well, you're watching, and the military wives will appear again. does he want to go to the army , did i understand you correctly, we started with borisov, that

borisov is not alone, he is a representative systems and such borisovs in each region, if i understood you correctly, uh, well, borisovs and conditionals are now such a collective image, they are directly connected to kyiv. here, well, the legs, that is, humenyuk of the mentioned system said that the inspection did not find any violations of this, which means , as you can say, unfortunately, he had a very good roof somewhere on the very mountain and he was of course a thinker . he is simply the most stupid and obvious pig between the system, one of my expert friends estimated it at billions of dollars, that is, on the one hand, a person without hope, without it, even after two months to walk and prove that the leg did not grow or the lungs did not appear, and on the other hand, young healthy people, you are tortured and on your way as volunteers, er, who are the deputies

eh ducks go to any gym where people work out you will see beautiful trained young people in any big city and for some reason it is not hunting them it is with her again someone is bringing the military it is as you remember in the days of the dry law everything in the usa , you pay the police and they turn a blind eye to you that is, you don’t have to be a pinkerton there to see this blatant social injustice when, on the one hand, yes, and from your point of view, to lead and there is the president, the supreme commander is, uh, valery, the industrious commander-in-chief of the armed forces, is the minister of defense, on which line do they have for these changes to take place, and given that ukraine wants to join nato, it can somehow ask for help from its partners to help us put the army in order in the rear, well, i'm afraid the last option won't

work, because now we have to mobilize people for the last time, the united states mobilized your citizens during the vietnam war, what was the strya gap when north communist vietnam simply forced the united states to retreat from south vietnam, that is , i am not sure that nato has recipes for how to behave during such a big war, at least nata they have never even fought , but it was too much, there were only two wars, successful in yugoslavia, unsuccessful in afghanistan, accordingly , we need someone to change, well, in the ukrainian coordinate system, there is exactly one person who has a political mandate and is concentrated all the power is concentrated. his name is volodymyr volodymyrovych zelenskyi. good, bad. another question is volodymyr oleksandrovich volodymyr oleksandrovich, and unfortunately this is the reverse side of the system that was introduced in

ukraine, when too much depends on one person, and i am absolutely sure that he is sincere. he wants to change this system to better, but simply, a person has 24 hours a day and the opportunity to communicate with probably a maximum of 100 people per day, ah, ah, the defense force is now a million people, that is, even with every cambrig i am sure that the president is personally familiar with that and it turns out that he reacts as a person with an artistic public backgrout to er applause or whistles, they whistled er tkachenko reaction came borysov er , the reaction went, but i will repeat the same phenomenon with the phenomenon of a complex chronic disease, they do not fight in appeals and fight new restoring balance in the body once my teacher nine williams of america said that the entire constitution consists of two words checking balance, i.e. checks and balances

and unfortunately in the ukrainian system of coordinates as we see this system as a system does not work but i have to say here that there was no immediate reaction to borisov either, back in april the details of his conspiracy and the sale of white tickets of alleged sale became known, but there was no reaction until the journalists stirred it up there, but listen to such a question very often you can hear in in the media and in political circles and from ordinary people, in fact, in social networks, when you read comments there, they say that they will imprison one person, and justice will work there for one violator, others will be afraid. and what do you think about such a thesis, can it work with borisov? others have now seen that there are no untouchables and they are afraid, is it naive to think so, well, no, there are no untouchables. so that we find, if the investigation is done, i know someone borisov who crushed him in kyiv , who did he take the money to, they will be untouchables

, yes, well, actually, simply speaking, we are in hands, if this logic worked, china would be the least corrupt country in the world, they just shoot people for it , and then bill them for the used bc, that is, for the bullet, but we know that the most er not the least corrupt country is singapore and the countries of scandinavia, because they clearly do not publicly execute corrupt people on the street, so this is again corruption . it is not about punishment, it is an imbalance of the system, it is like a sick organism, and to cure it, not only surgeons are needed , that is, law enforcement agencies, we see you there now, healthy guys guys with automatic machines, that is, you need a balanced system that fixes itself, that is, a good mechanism is good for cars, that is, when the brakes, abs, and the motor

, they all work in the system, restrained counterweights, and this is what you need to strive for but then we need to talk not about personalities or about individuals as an architect. and about a system that works effectively, and it works despite the name of the president, we saw how despite such an extravagant leader like trump , the american system is still a restrained counterbalance , and they persisted, they persisted despite such an extravagant leader. there was unprecedented pressure, let's say, the apogee of which was the sixth of january. i was able to confront the doctor with the state in ukraine until i unfortunately do not see such a system. i think that this is the greatest tradition-tragedy of the current president because he has a lot for which i respect him sincerely, but unfortunately he has not yet managed to build an effective system and therefore he personally has to react and only then do these wheels begin to turn and it is very unfortunate because the president can

show 20,100 people to them "i'm not one of the numbers, why? well, look, i'm just talking about numbers, i see that the ministry of defense has already given the numbers. they say that they have received 2,300 complaints from citizens about the work of military commissions and are investigating 106 criminal cases regarding disruption of the work of military commissions seems to be not much on the one hand, on the other hand - this is one scumbag, the other is literally a whole series of public and volunteer initiatives today, in particular , and ours signed an appeal about tactical er-er , glaring problems in tactical medicine, in particular, the supply to bailey of parts of tourniquets that kill, i.e. who do not save when the soldiers are bleeding, there are eight questions and again. well, about the command of the medical forces , these cries have been going on for a year and a half, as far as i

can remember, regardless of the surname, as long as the president does not intervened, well, okay, soldiers die, turnstiles are traded, first-aid kits are packed with some kind of soviet crap, and again, what is of good quality is mostly brought to the front not by the state, which receives fantastic help from the west, but by volunteers, and i can be a witness here , that is, our combat units simply ask every month to give at least 10-15 sentences, a couple of dozens of normal turnstiles, not this chinese lane, and again, it means that someone already signed that these 2010 life hacks were probably bought and brought to this and unfortunately , i am repeating myself again, that is, the problem is you not working and not an effective system, that is, even if last year it was possible to block heroism by this year, this is no longer possible , but maria berlinska is shouting about the same situation in terms of drones and wherever you go,

systematicity wins against heroism. unfortunately, we got involved in a war to exhaustion, and here heroism is beautiful. he really takes off his hat to our heroes, but unfortunately, he is not today. he is not the way to victory . the only way to victory is technology , systematicity, and use. well, make the system work as efficiently as possible. gennady, but in fact, i don't know. it happened by accident or not by accident. that all the time odessa and odesa were an example. most of the time, men were picked up on the street, and you know, sometimes this kind of thing happened if it wasn't for the army, the staff of the military commissariat, and they weren't in military uniform. well, i got the impression that it's just some criminal group out there that just beats one man and tries to put him in a bag and take him away. and there are actually a lot of such complaints and we talked to people

. many of them refused to go on camera to speak, but you, as a lawyer, how do you assess the work of military commissariat employees in this style, and is there any i don’t know, well , golden mean, they say well, we need to replenish resources, mrs. humenyuk on our broadcast says, well, they are a little untrained in our country psychologists still work with them, that is, employees of the military commissariats, they do not know how to do it correctly from the other side, when you look at it well, somehow it does not fit into the framework of some kind of legal state, i am with you absolutely later, the question arises how we then differ from our enemy only in language with the color of the flag and the shape of the coat of arms, we have to win in order to be superior to others, we have to be based on values ​​and not declarative ones, but such life-directing ones, i would say, which uh-uh mobilize people of goodwill from all over the world under our banner, which by the way, once upon a time, the war for independence the usa mobilized the french , the poles, all kinds of people there. that is, all the people of good

will went to help washington choose this independence from the largest empire of the world at that time, and all these shots that you are showing now, unfortunately, simply resemble i repeat the shame, despite the fact that there are night clubs and sports clubs in those. that is, i remember my youth, this is the 90s. that means that this man who was tied up has no money, he did not pay it, even like everyone else. on the street, let me remind you that there, well, we used to visit there in the old days, stirring pinchuk on one of his estates, and nearby the estate of surkysiv was guarded by such beautiful elderly alpha-chis fighters at that time at the beginning of the war with glocks of the 19th, and this is this social injustice is simply tearing the country apart and

undermines the baron's ability, that is, every such detention, and we were talking about money, is a loss, because this person is faster. she has a great chance of dying in the first month of the war, the state will pay 15 million tolks, and for some reason there were no brake brigades . not at all typical, there are other brigades, the third assault brigade. i mean, yes, you can take an example from this, but it is actually a parallel system of mobilization that works. recruiting actually works in parallel, yes, it may need to be studied, we are ready to share our experience, etc. i will repeat, without statuses , without money. also , there are people on their own vacations for one and a half years, why are they coming to us? maybe we are ready to conduct a small training for military commissars. and you are ready, yes, but we are more than ready in the end here we have, well, volunteers , in fact, you know, funds, that is, our

task is to strategically teach this state to walk without crutches and then exhale and say that we have become redundant. unfortunately, everything is happening with exactly the opposite, the first time for our audience to discuss with you, it happened in vinnytsia . there, a 34-year-old man with a disability received a summons, his name is maksym baida, let's look at it very briefly, and then i'll ask one more question , take a walk. watch this, a warrior - this is a warrior. disabled person of the third group, disabled from childhood, he received a summons and our shargorod doctors write that he is suitable for military service , my mother is here in shockovite, she ran to me and

says what to do. i am also in shockovie, we came he is going on a business trip to the city mayor. he is going on a business trip. yes, he is on a business trip. well, for some action to be taken. how is it? i think that the capacious mayor and all the people should intervene in this, and there a representative of the local government is standing next to him and he says, they ask him what to do, and he says, well go to the courts, look for justice, you know. i want to ask you as a lawyer. here is such a person , or someone, who was beaten by eight people at the same time. in general, where can they find justice in the entire system, until the issue is resolved ? military commissariat ot where do such people go? first of all, we see that the system and the commander-in-chief reacts primarily to public developments regarding judges. i will remind us of the case of humenyuk , who was detained in 14th, who died or blew

himself up in 23rd, that is, he spent 9 years without a sentence in prison and this about the effectiveness of our system, the british say delete just , i.e. simply overdue justice, it is a denial of justice and therefore publicity and god forbid, god forbid, these same people are eventually given weapons. i have already heard the story several times i am not ready to confirm, because i was not a witness. but again, from my colleagues who are now actively protecting the military at the front , is it worth refusing in the best case, that is, a person will not see eye to eye for the rest of the day, which means that his comrades have to carry and risk for two for three a-a to the front line and the second is, unfortunately, people with weapons sometimes there are incidents when they open fire on their own and this is not the worst that can happen, in fact, it is terribly demotivating and it undermines the very fighting

spirit of those units that will go out, that is, without the motivations of the soldiers, well, he and i either need to rebuild the post-stalinist system, set up squads, or how wagner fought that stalin should go, that is, in general, blocking squads with machine guns go, they know that you are not exactly coordinated and not about the european court , respectively, then there is no sense, that is, the military commissariat does not think about the final result , put a checkmark on it. as i said again, unfortunately, today i am forced to quote : yes, one death is a tragedy, or 1000 deaths - these are statistics, that is, they do not see, uh, no understand why this is done, that is, it is our job to put a certain amount of human material, yes, because of the resource, that is, 1,000 people , and what it will be, or because of these people, every experienced combat commander will say where it is better to build those who could, than in the future to keep these uh, a lot of trouble with these people are the ones in the war who have a shock zero. and

they need support, and again, gather when they refuse to comply with combat orders . this is 3c3. that is, we need to build this process. it is not how many people they put on the front, but how effective these people are on the front. you are sometimes one motivated brinet is much better than 10 refusers who only think how loopy how not to leave, this is before ukraine a-a in the reform of the military committees thank you very much the committee of the verkhovna rada on humanitarian and information policy did not support the resignation of the relevant minister oleksandr tkachenko, a member of the verkhovna rada from volodymyr vyatrovych named those who supported the minister's resignation as the european solidarity faction

. to talk about the prospect of the minister's resignation, in fact, today's vote in the committee does not mean anything, the committee may support it, it may not support it. the verkhovna rada will have the last word and the issue of tkachenko's resignation will be considered by the verkhovna rada precisely by voting in the session hall , oleksandr tkachenko announced at midnight on july 21 i will remind you that i submitted a resignation letter allegedly because of a wave of misunderstanding regarding the importance of culture during the war, and i will remind you that this was preceded by zelenskyi's address in which he stated that he was asking prime minister denys shmygalya to consider the replacement of the minister of culture. well, actually , why did the committee vote mostly against ? now we will talk. volodymyr vyatrovych joined our broadcast . people's deputy, european solidarity faction. well, and the representative of the committee on humanitarian policy and humanitarian information policy and humanitarian policy. good afternoon good afternoon, did you vote for the resignation of tkachenko? i

understand that your faction will support this resignation at the vote already in the verkhovna rada , of course we are personal in general, our faction system criticized minister tkachenko for his unsuccessful, in our opinion, cultural policy during the three years of his tenure, it is obvious that the events that shook society with the financing of incomprehensible tv series was only the last straw, but for us, unfortunately, they became a natural result of tkachenko's work in this position because we supported it in the committee and we will support it when the issue will be brought to the plenary plenary session i understood you listen and what do you think happened why why deputies from the pro-presidential faction today at the committee did not support the resignation of tkachenko, well, it was obvious that the president himself wanted his resignation, and it would seem that the people's deputies from the servant

of the people. well, it seems to me that we are exaggerating a little here, in general, there was some kind of riot , it is necessary to understand that the decision of the committee has an exclusively incidental nature, that is, the final decision will be adopted by the entire board, this is the first, the second, i think that this is the decision of the members committee when the majority of the members of the committee are representatives of the servant of the people party, to which oleksandr tkachenko also belongs, it was rather a kind of tribute to him for joint work, because at one time tkachenko also headed this committee. then, from this committee, he actually went to the position of minister of culture, that is, i would not i saw in this some kind of riot or some things that would mean that these people are voting against the president. it is almost certain that the majority of those people in the hall will vote for

the resignation of minister tkachenko. maybe i 'm wrong, maybe it really will be the second the case when minister tkachenko did not resign after writing a statement, i will remind you that he already wrote a statement somewhere at the end of the 21st year and only a full-scale second term actually postponed the consideration of this issue, but i am still inclined to the fact that this resignation will be approved and judging by the behavior of oleksandr tkachenko himself, he is already ready to leave this position, he understood you, then you immediately know what i want to ask you, your political power has also repeatedly accused oleksandr tkachenko of failing to evacuate cultural values museums during the war, you know, i am not here as his lawyer, but i want to present his argument. he says that he could not make these decisions on his own because the legislation was written in such a way that evacuation could only take place under martial law, and it was made there already when the war began how fair

are such remarks from your political power directed at oleksandr tkachenko that he is to blame for the fact that the evacuation of museums of cultural values ​​did not take place , etc. i believe that they are unfair precisely because today, once again during the discussion, i voiced these remarks because the discussions today were largely of such a complimentary nature that i thought it necessary to voice again these remarks regarding the personal edition of minister tkachenko regarding the loss of part of the museum valuables, as for me his explanation about the fact that there was no lack some kind of law in order to prepare for this evacuation well, they are not serious because he has the right of legislative initiatives, obviously taking into account the fact that he is a representative of such a political force that has it was very easy for the majority in the parliament to prepare and pass even the necessary law in order to be ready for such kind of actions. i think that the reason

was not in in the 22nd year, in general, the authorities, starting with president zelensky , adhered to the concept that there will not be any full-scale attack by russia in fact, and any actions aimed at preparing for this full-scale offensive may provoke some kind of panic or er, the discovery of some kind of lack of faith in the same president. i think that this and this was the main reason why nothing was done to prepare for the possible evacuation today. tkachenko talked a lot about those actions that took place after february 24, even with the risk for those who were involved in this evacuation of these exhibits, of course you can thank for that . but i am sure that if they had better prepared for the possible invasion of russia, which has been talked about since the end of the 21st year, then

the probability that it was possible to save more values ​​for ukraine was greater. well, then the offensive will not be a question of giving any proposals, for example, your political force , european solidarity, or our political force will not issue its proposals , because unfortunately, despite the war , no government of national unity has been created in our country the government continues to work in the monopoly mode, accordingly, it assumes sole responsibility for the appointment of certain positions regarding who it may be. well , here. unfortunately, i will be a pessimist. it will be someone who will do better than tkachenko with this job, i think that it will be a fairly inconspicuous person who will not take any drastic steps in reforming his industry, unfortunately, unfortunately, i think that this will be exactly the case, because in fact the cultural industry needs quite

some serious steps to reform, but i am sure that in the current situation, when er, all actions must be coordinated er, not even with the parliament, but with the president's office . office of the president from your point of view tkachenko is completely dependent on the office of the president i will try to explain tkachenko tkachenko was preparing for the resignation of which he said that at the end of the xxi and at the beginning of the 22nd year he was saved by such an invention of know-how as the only marathon that he obviously gave the authorities the opportunity to actually effectively to use the information policy er now after these scandals which were connected in particular with short-lived attempts to finance some very strange television

projects in the series, it is obvious that this caused great public dissatisfaction, but one of one of the advantages of the president's office is precisely the fact that they respond quite sensitively to public opinion. i think that this is precisely why tkachenko paid for the appointment of tkachenko. he is completely leaving politics, is he still a valuable staff and his skills, knowledge, experience, somewhere else it was necessary, there is such a tradition, i will already remind our audience that often loyal people are appointed as ambassadors absolutely correctly yes yes i well, this is absolutely possible. that is, it is really a continuation of a rather strange tradition when people who are not have no diplomatic experience , they are sending ambassadors at a time when ukraine actually needs and even has professional ambassadors. i will not be at all surprised if mr. tkachenko suddenly becomes a diplomat to represent the country in some foreign