[000:00:00;00] er, the use of these tactics of small groups. is this exclusively some kind of far-fetched thing ? i believe that it is calculated to save the personnel as much as possible, because the doctrine of war of the bundessphere, like the united states, it is objectively evaluated, it is not aimed at the fight against er, the russian army. and about that of some tribes and the reactions of the afghans there. well , what is not against the russian army, if you remember there was a situation when i was explaining to the german instructors, the instructor was asked why you don't go around my fields because they are unrealistic go around the entire line is completely mined, it's not 2 hectares, it's mined, well, they don't even understand the volume and scale of such systems. i think that such systems are fish objectively, let's evaluate the army by russia .

they have anti-battery warfare, they have it, the objects hear er talk about air superiority give number 16, give us air superiority and of course the counter-mast will go a little faster , you understand. there are even directions where the armed forces break through two bells are raised there the russian k-52s are rising, their assault aviation, bombers, and simply destroy even approximately a section, they are operationally turned off, we have no advantage in the air , nuts are thrown by kabami, did you understand that this is a very powerful weapon against which ukraine it is difficult to fight and we need to understand this, we also need air defense there is a lot of beer protects just the peaceful cities, we need to saturate the air defense system just the front so that the air force can’t strike you freely like that, there are a lot of questions of course, the bundeswehr can

have some doctrines of its own, but they are not vital, and even more so when your enemy is the russian federation right now with all the emanating from their e-e aviation in their superiority of artillery there on i am silent about the systems of the same pions how many they have well these are completely different volumes completely different e-e as they say things and they should to understand the realities from which the armed forces are fighting for the village, the fact that the armed forces are fighting, they are just heading towards some kind of human heroism , of course, the military is motivated because they understand that they are protecting the ukrainian land, but here it is precisely the instructors and the american and bundeswehr who need to learn and to understand how to fight not against an imaginary enemy that has no air force or systems, fish, nothing, er, any tribes in africa or afghans or reactions, but a real enemy that has quite powerful weapons, that has huge reserves of personnel, that has

huge reserves or reserves let the artillery fire the artillery rockets, well, and all the rest, the reason why ukrainians are being demonstrated in general is that they go on a panther offensive and repulse even there for a kilometer by 150 meters, they are already heroes because we must not forget about this, we are fighting viktor well if you were to sum it up like this, what would you point out, for example, to the shortcomings that exist in the understanding of, well, maybe western instructors in general, there are wars of the same scale as in ukraine, and what would you call the advantages of that that this situation , when we have to train our soldiers abroad, it will not go anywhere, which is an advantage that may not be fully taken into account by us of this

western training. nato standards, if you take the soviet standards of the same conduct of battle and the nato standards, these are slightly different standards, and if we are talking about a complete transition, everything from the command is a completely large-scale process, it is not done by the tip of the fingers, and we must understand that it is precisely interaction with various units, we will simply introduce the armed forces in our direction as much as possible to minimize human losses and achieve some success not from the position of doctrine from the position of doctrine we must say yes in our there is no air superiority, then we will continue to fight, we will wait until there is air superiority, then we will go on the attack . that is, we proceed from what we have. and how it is possible to convert success as much as possible. this is how we proceed if we take nato. do you remember

that even if to take the u.s. strategy there, because for one attack aircraft , how many soldiers are employed to provide units, just logistics and the like. that is , these are all units that are not engaged in active hostilities, which simply have their huge staff bloated because they are at least there to secure their stormtroopers as much as possible and for example there when the aviation flattens everything to the ground , then the artillery destroys everything, then the tanks go, of course there is no one there to shoot at the tanks and these are completely different realities we are fighting against of another and we are adapting, as they say, to fight him as efficiently as possible. well, thank you, i’m interested. well, what would you say to us? we would like to fight in such conditions, which is re- as provided for by the nato doctrine, and we really

hope that after all we are up to that we will come because it is better to fight with weapons than to lose people, this is absolutely clear. well, all the best to you in what you are doing now, even the smallest ones. there are some. i don't know about such difficulties. what are the possible difficulties there, if you can say so, thank you very much for joining us e- well, we will continue our conversation a little later, now we have a little advertisement and then we will return to the conversation only on karsil tablets 15% in pharmacies triporozhnyk you also have a chat , i returned, i was sad, but not combispasm

, leave combispasm, the power that tames your pain so that ukrainians don't think about so that they don't talk about the first place anyway, the war comes out, the war and our victory is only on espresso from monday to monday completely different spheres of human activity sports health politics the return of crimea military analytics nine presenters journalists experts opinion leaders in the regime real time about the most relevant events through the prism of the war in the author's projects on espresso hello this is freedom morning information project radio svoboda is visiting every day this is the shipping

district of kherson inclusion live we are somewhere in the vicinity of bakhmut on weekdays at 9:00 a.m. de-occupation and how is it possible to live without stopping now? the history of the liberated cities of ukraine has gone. let's see how our brothers helped us . they freed us from a normal life. one by one, two houses and natsiks of the ukrainian people are here yes, we are all nationalists of the people , did they resist, did the residents come here, stop them and send them back and become heroes the novel would be and will always be ukraine about unbreakable cities

of ukraine from the ukraine project in the documentary series deoccupation that on saturdays at 11:10 on espresso there is a war going on and not only for the territories , it is also a war for the umy russia is throwing millions of naftodors to turn ukrainians into a small russia ukraine state of the highway analysis and analysis of information about ukraine by russian of propagandists, specific facts and methods by which hostile propaganda turns people into obedient zombies to the information attacks of the russians in the project of the chronicle of the information war with olga leni tuesday thursday friday at 17:10 on the espresso tv channel every week, the saturday political club helps to understand the processes taking place in ukraine and the world. vitaly portnikov, the host of espresso and invitations , experts based on facts give their assessment and forecast of the development of events, you want

to understand how our today will affect our tomorrow, see the saturday political club, what saturdays are on espresso, the big broadcast of vasyl zimi me my name is vasyl zima. two hours of airtime . two hours of your time. we will talk about the most important things. two hours to learn about the war. military summaries of the day and what is the world like? yuriy fizer will talk for two hours to stay up to date with economic news . oleksandr marchenko will tell us about the economy during the war and new sports. yevhen pastukhov is ready to talk about sports for two hours in the company of favorite presenters about culture. during the war, lena is ready to speak or something else of the presenters that many have become like , maybe the weather will give us some optimism, ms. natalka didenko is ready to tell us, and also a respectable studio hotel in we will be here today volodymyr gryshko if everything goes well the events

of the day in two hours vasyl zima's big broadcast a project for intelligent and caring people in the evening nayspresso we return to the conversation - this is a worldview program my name is vasyl zima is it appropriate to spend money on culture is culture necessary during war process today we will have another culture, what kind of culture do we need , we will continue to talk with andrii the cockatiel , the writer is tamara, the nut of the grain, so i am now tamari, there is a word, i read the post of our viewer who said about what what what now she is trying to push in, it is obvious that she means these series that you announced by alexander tkachenko - this is not culture . in general, this is horror and has nothing to do with ms. tamara's culture. please explain if it was a desire. well, i don't know if any of these series will appear. there is the village of ingulets, others were sold there and were worthy. by the way, the project will be told later. andriy will probably tell most of this, but what do you think of this as an effort to earn money for your own, to support the industry, or

to really saturate the market with such dramas, actions, comedies and the drama that some people hmm emotionally support how do you do it? do you understand this despite the fact that many people who will actually work on these projects once worked in russia? well, many of the workers are simply a fact . there is a series about a turn signal with those who watch series or at least have a tv at home, i am not very competent in this matter because i do not watch series, but i think it is very simple to ask questions at least to the current or extractives and at least to find out why he was fired, because they signed contracts for the financing of these serials, but, as we know, the payment came and the contracts were concluded and they were not canceled, or because he invested state

money in the promotion and promotion of a new serial stars with political ambitions that can threaten someone and this is rather a political issue that has nothing to do with culture when claims are made about an irrational and unfair distribution of funds , what happened? tsilogothkachenko's resignation, what was hm guilty of in the eyes of the authorities and is it possible that a critical mass of comments from below has accumulated, but as far as i know, no one paid attention to these comments a couple of weeks ago, and the petition for tkachenko's resignation, which collected 25,000 signatures, was returned without consideration and with the remark that the government did not sees reasons for his resignation, we had a comment

from the government on this issue, i have such a feeling that there is a certain swaying , shuffling and talking about the problem, and the problem is very acute for us and it consists in because the situation at the front, the situation in the war , the security situation is far from in favor of ukraine , by and large we are suffering colossal losses . more weapons we need more people more sacrifice is visible and more misery awaits us in order to advance to the victory of this war in such a situation is it appropriate to talk about funding

any other sectors security culture health, economy , business , and so on, should we now talk about the preservation of what is ? it is necessary to provide and when, again, within the budget of state funding for culture, when on one cup of scales it is about several serials and on others, for example, about the preservation of libraries, not about development, not about replenishment, and about the restoration of the premises which were divided about the payment of salaries to librarians and the minimum replenishment of funds so that people go to libraries. so when the question is raised in this way, we need to prioritize. we are now

losing a huge part of our material cultural heritage. we are losing the premises of the museum collection. we are losing in libraries that simply have not been physically removed, saved, evacuated, maybe it's time to finally think about a tow truck, evacuation and , er, preservation and rescue of what else is possible to save and ultimately about restoration where it is possible to restore about repairs about about premises about people on the one hand i am just now working on the translation of a book by richard olendon - he is a well-known british librarian of the borodyan library and right now i have been translating for several weeks reading about e-e jewish libraries during the second world war about the huge pogrom of e jewish book collections in europe and about the colossal efforts made to

save these funds for hiding at the cost of the lives of many jews and non-jews for so that it can be saved and passed on to the next generations, we have a very similar situation now, what we have in our hands. now we have to save as much as possible in order to pass on at least something material to our children and grandchildren . we have a huge question left for our ministry: why were the funds not saved and not taken away when it could have been done before the great invasion, but even now it is all us by private forces and private

initiatives, we collect books for the booming of libraries in the kyiv region, in the chernihiv region in the east, i.e. people bring their private book collections, they are repackaged by a number of volunteer , let's say, initiative funds , caring people are engaged in this, and uh, well, this is a private initiative, there is a lack of a systemic state approach, there is a lack of scope and there is a lack of understanding of how important this is i really don't care i can't understand uh why uh serials why the rest of the tv has turned out to be the most important cultural problem at the moment it's well from my point of view it's far from you know, in general, i think that culture in this time in which we live now should also be a certain kind of communicator with people , because culture and cinema and poetry and theater can tell people the truth, well, in fact, we saw the consequences of when people were told about barbecues that everything will be fine, they didn't take out the funds, uh, they didn't save the missiles there, who could, somewhere, didn't steal access to the front

, something else, that's that, that's what happened, it led to what we saw on february 24 , the same and now by the way dialogues are also ripe with society, because people see that there are fewer people injured and killed, a lot of things are happening, where, how, where, where, somewhere, at some stage , everything can end, yes , the time comes to talk with people, it seems to me that culture and, once again, poetry and literature are so alive. he said to andriy, these are evenings of poetry, they are needed, theater is needed and other moments are needed, we need to communicate without people, there is such a good book by jim lawless, but it is not a good title go where it is scary and you will have what you dream of, it is better to tell people what is scary or go there where scary and then you can have something or not say anything, only what you dream about. and about how the ass is besides that, well, it can somehow be kept quiet, so it seems to me that after all , this is exactly the kind of culture that is alive online. maybe even culture, it is very necessary now for people to talk about certain moments, where are we, what are we, what is with us

, because well, people will not get answers to these questions, and povoroznyuk and the tv series from the village of ingulets will definitely not answer these questions to people. i will ask andrei you are talking about these e-e initiatives of the tv series there, the town of ingulets and and i know that it is an interesting story. i think that you have heard. this is a story from the tv series of the town of ingulets, about the fact that two citizens of the country flee from kharkiv to lviv oblast, got to kirovohrad oblast, and started there. something to do, a similar film is being shot in russia, only there are also some it people going there, they also end up somewhere, too. such a farmer, uh, uncle, a steam locomotive , starts making fields. well, i wonder why there are such similar scenarios, maybe they were written under the same table somewhere. andriyu. what do you think? or on these are the current series. and if not, what series should there be? which series are possible quickly? well, they were made relatively quickly. now they could say something important for society. i will say what i started talking about in my

comment. i like the definition of art less. than the definition of culture because culture includes absolutely everything and even the series servant of the people , even the songs of mykhailo poplavskyi, even the artist roman skorpion, this is also a certain segment of a certain culture that is needed vinnyk and this is also a certain segment of culture that someone needs another thing and another thing, the problem is not that when we talk about the village of ingulets, the problem is not with yuri gorbunov, whose fault i know is only that 20 years ago he created the prototype production company, which creates a product

of the quality that suits he works on the order of the customer. the problem is that you, mr. vasyl, have already told vasyl that the problem is in the content. the problem is in who came up with it. and he brought to the ministry of culture a project from a series about two skeptics who hid in the kirovohrad region under the roof of a cattle shed. another word for him is i i can’t think of one, and the problem is who brought this idea, and not the problem of who was distributed according to what principle . the second question is not the word series is also used in such a negative context recently, and the fault in this is not with the series

as such, for example, breaking bad and doctor house and ozark and game of thrones are also series . yes, mr. prime minister, the british satirical series is also a series. er short series i mean a series with a duration of 22 minutes, it is quite possible to launch several lines of such series about how ukraine is fighting inside, i am now exaggerating very superficially, i am saying how inside ukraine they are fighting corruption, how inside ukraine they are fighting with russian, with russian subversive groups

heroic series to create a heroic ukrainian mythology, an analogue of ukrainian marvel, and it is still clear that we will not be able to pull it off in terms of budgets, but in the 41st year in america, in the marvel universe , captain america appeared, here is a similar serial i am not talking about the quality of the product, we will not achieve such quality as in hollywood there or on nehlyuka or on other platforms , but it is meaningful, it is meaningful. we need such series and if millions of viewers watch it, then once two three four five sew into the heads of these millions of ukrainians let's use simple words , the simplest, but ukrainian meanings , to really teach respect for

our soldiers with such series so that there are no such disgusting cases. when a ukrainian defender who goes on vacation smells bad to someone, so that cases when people turn their eyes away when they see someone wounded or traumatized by the war and it is otaka ot basova culture when it gives the right meanings and also fulfills its therapeutic function not only educational but therapeutic and after our victory will be a component of that therapy that will help integrate our heroes those who today he is protecting the country, well, for different purposes, it will help to integrate into society faster and to raise

respect, and the plot is proposed to be analogous to this village of ingulets, he will glorify those who are hiding from winter in the helyants, in general, those those who are tired of the war those who those who perceive today's war as a continuation of a kind of covid temporary annoying inconvenient limitations one and a half minutes p andrii, i rurvu you because i still want to p tamara to give a word pva and please tell me how important it would be now for people to read and find in books here are the live ones published now here are the hot answers to your questions here is why it is important now also please the literary process did not freeze during the war there was a certain pause in the 22nd year, and in most publishing houses, the authors have already left

we already have a novak wave of modern literature written after the 22nd year including dedicated to a new invasion of me in this great and our new reality, there is a huge number of meetings with readers a-a we saw what excitement at the book arsenal in general, around ukrainian-language ukrainian books , what were the sales? as far as i know, the publishing houses that faltered were due to the loss of circulation due to the fact that they burned down there due to this increase in paper prices and so on. now they have returned to normal work by raising prices to a certain extent, but the market reacted, adapted and continues to develop, we have 20 seconds, mrs. tamara, wish the people, not the agents of the cultural market, they will do their job, do not

interfere, do not oppress them, we are standing and we will endure, and we are this time that we need we make it into our work thank you very much for this poem writer translator volunteer andriyko kotyukha writer bellatrist well, i didn’t mean to, by the way, we will come out as a book, too, uh, well, on sale, too, continues to work as a writer during the war and a collection of poetry will be everyone has a percentage to their own level if we are talking about people of culture, they have to worry today with their work to search for answers and give people the opportunity to experience what they have to experience or together with authors , directors, writers, singers to find answers, we should feel the shoulder each other, and culture should help us in this

. we continue the search for 12-year-old dmytro horovoy about the fate of this boy. for almost a year and a half, nothing is known. unfortunately, there are also few details about his disappearance. i only know that when the war started, the child was in mariupol, and on the same day the boy disappeared without a trace, maybe he was taken to russia or is being held somewhere in the temporarily occupied territories, so i ask you to look carefully at the photo of dmytro horovoy, he looks like his 12-year-old self blond hair and dark eyes if anyone has seen the boy or knows where he may be now do not delay and call us on the magnolia child tracing hotline at the short number 116 000 calls from any the mobile operator is free or write to the child tracing chatbot service in telegram. i also want to recall the story of three missing children from the vlasov family at once. it is about two

brothers, dmytro and artem, and their sister , sofia, who also disappeared in mariupol at the beginning of the full-scale war on missing children. said their aunt, it is she who is in the photo with the baby, mrs. olena has been living in spain for 10 years, but regularly kept in touch with her brother and nephews, the woman said that her relatives lived in a nine-story building at 61 kurchatova street and in the last time we contacted each other was the day of the beginning of a full-scale war, we spoke for the last time until february 23, and i don't know what happened to them at all . i 'm looking for viber and telegram. mrs. olena does not know anything about the fate of her family , so she is asking for help to find her relatives . this is her brother serhiy vlasov with his sons artem and dmytro. and this is a photo of their