[000:00:00;00] for confirmation and after that and i apologize and five amendments faction of the homeland will be for what krulkov it will be in pita bread will you be for confirmation two minutes krulko two minutes krolko and and mokryn one for confirmation two minutes rulko now a minute i will write down and mokan one to confirm and to take into account mine and i apologize to take into account yes to take into account ok thank you dear colleagues then let's start let's give goncharenko a 3 minute speech and vote on three amendments thank you dear colleagues we are currently

considering an important bill with you we are talking about in fact, about the strategy of the budget policy about the public debt, this is important, we have to deal with it. there will be amendments, i will voice out why they are important, but i am using this opportunity. i want us to talk broadly. and where is our economic strategy ? to the national debt, well, that's because the imf requires it. we are finally considering it , and other issues. where is the economic strategy , where is our government in the end? i understand that. well, they don't go. why do you, in order to see our government, should trudeau or the prime minister of spain or someone else come to us? well, this is our government and there are a lot of questions for it, where is the strategy for the development of the military-industrial complex , why are we watching as russia opens one

lancet plant, other lancets are destroying our equipment, why do we learn that ukraine is already being bombed by shahid made in russia are the iranian roads where a are made in russia , avtotarstani, a new huge factory is being built in shahediv, where are our shahid, where are our drones, what they have to conquer this moscow and this dew, well, we are all gone because we do not see a strategy where our strategy is a policy of countering hybrid threats, where is our strategy for the moscow church, in our country the fight for that laurel is already going on like a battle, i don't know what you are there for in a second they it is necessary to finally consider the law banning the moscow church in ukraine and register it, where is the strategy of cultural policy, where is the strategy what are we doing with millions of people who are abroad, but they are our

compatriots, where is our diplomatic strategy we still don't have ambassadors. in india, there are no ambassadors. brazil is a key country in the world, but we are not before that. now we also don't have an ambassador from great britain, because the ambassador said something wrong, they were thrown out quickly, and we don't know who to appoint, friends. we are doing something silly while we don't have any key issues, we are not, we are not considering strategies, where is our strategy for military personnel, another session day, again , no question about military personnel, where is the bill on demobilization after 18 months, where is the bill on demobilization disabled people of the first and second groups are limited in their suitability for this. these are all the laws that our army is waiting for. where are these friends

? come to your senses, let's deal with strategies . dear colleagues, i will put three amendments. rejected, i ask you to vote for 65, the decision was adopted and the final 41st amendment of goncharenko was rejected by the committee, i ask you to vote for 46, the decision was not adopted, nina petrivna, you are a confirmation of that, we will put

your amendments at the end. mokan and krulko, please, krulko, then moka, three minutes, yes, two minutes, please, khrumko. come to the bridge, homeland. dear colleagues , those who are planning to vote for this bill. i just want to tell you what will happen when you vote for it. this bill provides for changes to the budget, which introduced by people's deputies in the order of a legislative initiative, if there is no positive conclusion of the ministry of finance, then they will not be considered at all. have you ever seen such a thing that the ministry of finance as a ministry in the cabinet the ministers of other branches of government will indicate to the parliament that it is possible to consider some changes to the budget and that it is not possible, moreover, dear friends, i will reveal one more thing to you. and you know

that this parliament over the years has voted 80% of the laws on changes to the budget with a negative conclusion of the ministry of finance you know about it, but i want to tell you that after this decision, if such a rule is passed, we will find ourselves in a situation where it will be a gross violation of the constitution of ukraine and the right of a people's deputy to legislative initiative, and no other branch of the government has the right to interfere in the work of the legislative branch of the verkhovna rada of ukraine, let's not humiliate ourselves to the level of a plinth, because you know, as long as i sit here, i feel that the parliament is being humiliated, so let's not adopt norms that do this with our own hands, if we are a parliament in a parliamentary - let's protect the presidential republic's interests and our right of legislative initiative, this is the basic right that a people's deputy has to submit laws that should be considered here, and not so that someone

from the left later says that the law was not considered maybe it is not possible to vote for this draft law with this norm and one last thing well, let's say one more thing, a single-line draft bill is coming to the hall. where have four or five more special funds been created for the budget ? well, that's right and normal, why weren't they created? thank you, dear colleagues, please, mokan vasyl, what is the amendment, the number only says , please, 52 is correct, please, 1 minute is yours. thank you, colleagues, last year we voted at the end of last year for a very important draft law that has already become law on the establishment of national civic identity and among other tasks was the introduction of amendments to the budget code, where we technically have to prescribe such a line of funding for the next budget year

, according to the washing machine . next year, both at the central and local level, this strategic area of ​​state policy for our national security , therefore, i am asking for common sense let's support it and take it into account, thank you, the position of the committee, please yuriy mykhailovych dear colleagues, indeed, this amendment was previously rejected by the committee, but there is logic in this work, and therefore, after additional consultations, we are still inclined to the opinion that it is worth supporting this amendment. thank you, dear colleagues, vasyl's amendment ivanovych mokona 52 was rejected by the committee , at the same time you heard that the position is such that it would be good to support it ah and that's why i put the 52nd amendment of people's deputy mokran into consideration

and ask people's deputies to vote for 250, the decision was made dear colleagues, we have completed the amendments to be taken into account, no one insists anymore, there will be five more amendments for confirmation and after that we will vote for the whole bill, the amendments for the confirmation of the southerner, start with the number, please , petrivna, with the number of the amendments, i wanted you to the budget code still treated it as a fundamental law that determines the rules of conduct and annual budgeting, and when this law was submitted for the implementation of the agreements with the memorandum on with the imf, according to the memorandum, i was sure that well, not here

will already play and submit all the amendments, all the pretensions that are possible, but i was wrong because of the fifth amendment, which is the reason why the budget code should be added to the creation of a special fund for the accumulation of funds from the privatization of institutions for the execution of punishments, are we going to sell all the prisons? is this a long game? program, why are we starting the process, we will build in novaya, please explain why the budget code should introduce a temporary rule, what is the position of the committee, please dear colleagues, we are normalizing in the code from 1.01-24 of the year and we include in the special fund of the state budget 70% of the funds that will come from the privatization of the state criminal enforcement service of the property of the state criminal enforcement service with the subsequent

redirection of these funds to improve the material and technical base for repairs for the construction of new premises for the organization of new productions why we our colleagues have been doing this since the 21st year. in the 21st-22nd-23rd year, similar norms have already been laid down in the law about the state budget for the corresponding year, we now offer as a formula that proved to be effective to transfer it in the budget code of the 24th year, this will allow e.e. to improve the resocialization of those people who are serving sentences, to create new jobs, and to reduce the burden on the state budget, because the production that will be organized will bring income, in addition to income from personal income tax to local budgets from new jobs and i also want to point out that dear colleagues, the fifth amendment was authored

by kuzbit , it was taken into account by the committee. please vote for confirmation of the amendment 230, the decision has been made, the amendment remains taken into account nina petrivna, please, you have the next issue dear colleagues, the norm of the budget code well, you are simply distorting all the e-e documents that should thoroughly exist in the state, you have now explained absolutely what is not relates to

this question, the next question please tell me the 15th amendment, the change in the distribution of funds that will be spent again on the construction of roads , redistribution of funds by 1%, is taken from ensuring road traffic safety and is added to the construction of roads of state importance. please tell me that 70 billion was not enough to distribute. what is this one percent ? what are you currently making changes to the budget code for? percent why are you now distorting again the position of the committee on the 15th amendment briefly dear colleague we clarify that from the first of the first 24th year of the proposal for the distribution of state budget revenues which sources

the formation of the state road fund is increased from 60 to 60 percent of the corresponding funds for the development of road networks of state importance in connection with the expansion of this direction in terms of the arrangement and obtaining crossing points across the state border, i.e. in connection with the fact that in we have increased the flow of crossing the border by automobile roads. we need additional funds for the organization of these points . this amendment is only related to this. thank you when i ask for your support . taken into account by the committee yuzhan asks to put this decision in confirmation i put the 15th amendment in confirmation i ask you to vote for 214 the amendment is rejected the following number

of the amendment no petrivna please administrative services are included in local and district budgets according to the place of provision of services by this draft law e-e it is proposed to redistribute e -th receipt of these payments to the budget i do not at all understand how it is possible to determine the redistribution now, what has changed and why we are taking from local budgets and what is the essence of this amendment why are you now you are changing the allocation again by bringing changes to the budget code, make temporary norms , make it in the budget for the current year, do not make it a norm of the budget code, the basics of budgeting, the position of the committee, dear colleague , it is still an amendment, you just talked about washing machine 18 and we are doing it with the next one with the goal of 30% of the deductions from the provision of services by the main service centers of the ministry of internal affairs will go to

a special fund of the state budget specifically for the development of these service centers. in addition, we will normalize the prices for these services that will make it possible even with a 70% redistribution for local budgets to increase such revenues from 360 million to 1.9 billion, this is for local budgets and will give the ministry of internal affairs an additional 800 million for these purposes to reduce the burden on the state budget thank you when i ask for support nina petrivna i want to clarify, do you still insist on the 19th amendment, all 19:00 watch let's not discuss, a person asks to put the 19th amendment for confirmation, this is an amendment authored by the forger yuriy mykhailovych she is taken into account by the committee. nina petrivna asks to put it for confirmation. i put the 19th amendment

for confirmation. i ask you to vote for 234. the decision has been made. nina petrivna , do you have two more amendments? dozens of times you vote on the basis of this on the redistribution of funds, as it is not a shame to do such things during the war 29th amendment listen , well, we all understand the balance , the responsibility of the ministry of finance for budget expenditures, but when such a direct rule is made that there must be a weighty calculation by the ministry of finance for each draft law , where of course they will not make any calculation even for consideration by

the budget policy committee. why because we are now observing even our own draft laws, they do not make such a calculation writing this norm i agree with my colleagues field never none the deputy initiative will not pass in the hall you are now er actually changing the entire policy of relations between the executive and ect the position of the committee, please, on the 29th amendment, dear colleague, still, eh, to article 52 of the budget code , changes are foreseen to strengthen the role of the ministry of finance as the body responsible for the balance and reasonableness of budget indicators, such provisions of the draft law do not limit the right of legislative initiatives to submit relevant the project draft law is consistent with the requirements of article 93 of the constitution and also follows from the terms of the agreements signed by the government of ukraine and the international monetary fund on

avoiding spontaneous initiatives that may unbalance the budget, thank you, please support thank you, dear colleagues, have you heard the position of the 29th amendment authored by yurii mykhailovych kuzbet, yes, it is taken into account by the committee, but such a decision is asked to be confirmed, yes, no , i put the 29th amendment for confirmation , i ask the people's deputies to vote for 235, the amendment remains taken into account and the final number nina petrivna 69 dear colleagues, the ministry of finance must make calculations for all projects and must discuss with us and have the opportunity to defend its position, for that

there is a specialized committee and the initiator of any legislative initiative, i.e. people's deputy, you have deprived yourself of the opportunity to even discuss your initiatives, amendment 69, people. in march 2022, we adopted a rule that local budgets can transfer to the state budget the funds they have free for the implementation of certain measures , we are now changing this rule if they entered the state budget, respectively. they should be spent on the needs planned in the budget for this year, but now they are proposing to change it so that with the further distribution of such funds by the cabinet ministers of ukraine, please tell me, you just said that this draft law is being adopted for transparency , compliance , balance, where is the compliance, balance, if significant funds are now required to live locally, briefly, the position of the committee on the 69th amendment, this situation, this amendment is caused by the fact that the decision is really what you they said, which we adopted earlier led to the fact that the transferred funds from local

budgets and the state budget were suspended in the account on the accounts of the treasury and no one understood what to do with them. e-e, we are expanding the possibilities of spending the remaining subventions remaining in local budgets by introducing 20 e to the use of article 29 of the law on the state budget for the 23rd year. that is , we are expanding them. thank you, please support my colleague . dear colleagues, the 69th amendment, the course of authorship , has been taken into account by the committee. to put this decision to a vote, i put the 69th amendment for confirmation, i ask to vote in favor of 234, the decision is adopted dear colleagues

, let's proceed to the adoption of the decision, i put the proposal to be adopted in the second reading and in as a whole, with the necessary technical and legal amendments, the draft law on amendments to the budget code of ukraine on ensuring the predictability of budget policy and strengthening debt sustainability , registration number 9346-1, i ask people's deputies to vote for 249 decisions have been made to adopt the law as a whole. congratulations colleagues from the factions . please show the next 992 33 and the accompanying 9233-1 alternatives are a draft law on amendments to some legislative acts of ukraine

on improving the effectiveness of engagement business entities in the field of improvement and urban development, i propose to include this issue in the agenda of the session of ordinary people's deputies to vote for 261 decision adopted dear colleagues , i propose to consider this issue, this is a shortened procedure, i ask to vote for 223 decision adopted thank you colleagues, let's move on dear colleagues, two for two against , we vote yes, please, please sign up two

for two against vyatrovych volodymyr mykhailovych faction european solidarity please give the floor oleksiy goncharenko oleksiy goncharenko, please oleksiy goncharenko - european solidarity, dear friends, there are a number of comments from other ministries on this draft law. can you open it and see it? and we are talking about urban planning here, we are talking about those objects, temporary parking lots , and how they can be installed. and really there are a large number of questions, so our faction will receive about this, but i have a much more important question that

concerns the whole country today. this is when from the submission of the central government. unfortunately, it was the central government that became the source of this policy, budget funds began to be spent, what did the whole country see, the drums of the vegetable cutter turned gray, it is not known what the tv series tell us about , yes, we need them, but not about the stupid one that was planned. and what to allocate more than 400 million uah for when the local authorities saw that it was possible to spend budget funds like this during the war, neither on drones, nor on anti-drones, nor on the military, we are told that the military is not enough to return the thirty to everyone's money

. there will be no additional money. on the drums, there are avecherian tv series and our local government picked up, then we saw squares, stadium sidewalks, cobblestones and other unnecessary things during the war, when rockets fall on the head, so the first one is not necessary to say now, under the pretext of this, let's take the money of the local self-government, i immediately make a remark and a warning to you, but show an example that firstly the central government will act differently and demands the same from the local authorities to follow this example and there should be only one principle everything for the front everything for victory what is the point, please, servant of the people movchan, please dear colleagues, this is a small but very important bill, a month ago

the security service of ukraine together with the national police detained an official of lohvytsia city council for a bribe, the bribe was $2,000 for the right to place a kiosk in the city of lohvytsia, this is a massive story in ukraine during many years ago, all the temporary structures of the mafia are corruption at the local level, this is shallow corruption at the local level. but why is it important and why should this loophole in the legislation be eliminated, because it is a perception of justice, small and medium-sized businesses are people who open stalls, sell bread, sell food products, etc. dear colleagues, this bill contains two important blocks. first, it ensures transparent rules of the game and the placement of temporary structures in communities on lands of local

communal and state ownership . in mind, through electronic auctions , transparent sales, we have already discussed this with you many times, the second block concerns the organization of parking and parking lots also in the territory of cities plots of communal property and today this issue is generally not regulated by legislation, there are a lot of corruption scandals, including mostly in big cities we say that everything should be done through an electronic auction if you want to do this kind of business, the community organizes an electronic auction, you come and win and organize a parking lot or install a temporary structure dear colleagues, this is a bill on competition for small and medium-sized businesses and on fair rules

of the game, please support, thank you yes, servant of the people put forward some motives for us, dear ones, from the procedure, i understand that this is all a wish dear colleagues shufrish nestor ivanovych, after that we vote dear colleagues , please invite the deputies invite the people's deputies please thank you, dear mr. chairman, definitely the approval of the principle of transparency is important , but there is always a question whether it is now in time and the most important thing is definitely transparency, competition is good, but where were we two or three years ago and now during active military operations? we must return to these issues to take into account all the comments of mr. gneu during the consideration of this issue until the second reading, if the people's deputies determine i regarding the adoption in the first reading. thank you for

your attention . dear colleagues, please proceed to making a decision. on the basis of the elaboration of the provisions in accordance with the first part of article 116 of the regulations of the verkhovna rada of ukraine, the draft law on amendments to certain legislative acts of ukraine on raising the effectiveness of the involvement of business entities in the field of improvement and urban development are ready to vote, i ask the people's deputies to vote for 207, the decision has not been adopted, i am making a proposal now we will all pass we must