[000:00:00;00] solomiya bobrov faction voice well, first of all, we would like to ask all the walkers who are standing next to the minister to give time to listen to the speeches of the faction, the last ones are already in office. thank you. i understand very well the height of tension, the degree of tension in society, especially in the last six months. which were shaken by scandals in ukraine and abroad somewhere played out in the position of partners 10 played on the internal confrontational struggle but nevertheless i believe that mr. oleksii e when appointed to the position after a completely failed minister tarna, who continues his unsuccessful career as the ambassador of slovenia, inherited a thirty-year-old simple sovov system, which, in principle, was difficult for one person to raise and difficult to reform

, and those who are related to the civil service or to high positions know very well that with regard to political positions, that the ministry in the first place or any other body is always not about one person, but about the team, because the team is currently still in place. uh, in different ways in the good sense of the word, was communication , in particular, or primarily by the military with partners , how much how much was done and as a legacy , in particular, the first of the questions to which my request to break up the monopoly from serhiy of the volunteer would be personally the reaction proposal and the reaction was received very quickly already in december 21st, no one can ever say what the efficiency should be for the efficiency of the minister during the martial

law. therefore, we thank you. thank you for the future. taras ivanovich batenko, please dear colleagues, dear oleksiyovych, despite the criticism, the fact that today the hall is overwhelming the minister of defense of a belligerent country with applause speaks volumes. i believe that despite certain far-reaching problems that we had in the parliament, the communicative role of the cabinet of ministers, which we rarely see in the session halls we have forgotten what is hour of the government we have an idea for approval to the council to return this idea of ​​the hour of the government and so on, i cannot address this question to the minister of defense with whom there was constant communication open communication and

this also says a lot. i think that the minister of defense, who served all 559 days of the war, says a lot about other belligerent countries, including totalitarian countries that have gone through wars . the minister of defense changed in different ways . can you blame the minister of defense? we are an open country, we are a democratic society, and this is what our soldiers are fighting for at the front, on the front lines, how hard it was for the country , many of us know a lot and can share. a soldier who is on the front lines can share, especially the minister of defense, who is going through a difficult path, and not an easy negotiation process in the first days of the war. i believe that today we should still thank the minister of defense oleksiy yuriyovich

reznikov for the evaluation of the simple steps he took to strengthen the country's defense capabilities for the dialogue he conducted with our international partners and i believe that his political career does not end there . he acquired it for the protection of national sovereignty. thank you tarasovych, please, servant of the people mykhailouk halyna olehivna vskei dear president dear colleagues dear citizens of ukraine what we are considering today we are considering the resignation of the minister of defense who for the first time in the history of independent ukraine was the minister of defense of a belligerent country on which carried out an onslaught of unprovoked aggression and is waging a terrorist war, one of the most resourceful

countries in terms of human potential and economic opportunities, which positioned as the second largest military power in the world military power are there questions for the ministry of defense for the activities of the ministry of defense for the activities of the minister of course they are because in the conditions of the war in the conditions of force majeure in the conditions of the unpredictability of the future of ukraine in the first days of the war the team of the minister of defense did everything it is possible and very often impossible for the armed forces of ukraine, the number of which has increased many times compared to before the military situation, to be provided with clothing and defense systems and weapons for everything else or mistakes are possible in the conditions of such extraordinary conditions of activity of the ministry of the minister and his team, of course, mistakes are inevitable in the conditions of such

unforeseeable events that ukraine has experienced whether or not it is the minister , it is undoubtedly the fault of the minister, because he was probably not always able to adequately respond sharply to those media signals of scandals that we all have, but we must remember that russia is waging a hybrid war against us, the information component, and it was russia that very often played along and provoked those scandals, but thanks to personal efforts of the minister, ukraine received missiles, ukraine received tanks, ukraine received multiple rocket launchers, and thanks to the efforts of the president, including the minister of defense, ukraine survived, thank you. trust, bakunets , please, pavlo andriyovych. of course, at the time of that difficult great challenge, when the overwhelming

army wants to seize our earth, cooperation is important important is the unity of both the ministers of state bodies and, most importantly, those people who trample this victory for us with their own steps, who win for us with their lives this victory, and that is why today i want to remember from this podium those people for whom the ministry actually works, these are our brave soldiers, soldiers of various combat brigades of the 80th, 65th, 45th, 63rd territorial defense soldiers of the 103rd , in particular, the 125th brigade, and today from this stands i want to congratulate on the 20th anniversary of the creation of the legendary and royal 24th brigade, brave and legendary, this is about the soldiers

of the 24th separate mechanized brigade, who have been defending our land with a strong shield since the beginning of the war for 10 years. of course, eternal memory to those princes who gave their lives and glory and courage and a low bow to those who are still working bravely and to those who lead them to the brave leaders these are the legendary combrigs oleksandr pavlyuk anatoly shevchenko eternal glory to the memory of the legendary valery gudzh of course glory to sergiy postupalsky kombra in the novel mamavskyi and to the young commander who is already a hero of ukraine ivan holshevskyi glory to all the soldiers who win us victory glory to the heroes glory

to the homeland serhiy vasyliovych sobolev dear colleagues dear mr. minister it is possible the most difficult speech from this podium, especially for me, because oleksiyya reznikov is a person who etched himself in the history of ukraine, who showed himself to be serious enough in various spheres of activity, and what we are considering now, in my opinion, is relevant to who our defense minister is. what is the ministry of defense actually, this speech is very difficult because we perfectly understand that when russia

attacked crimea for the first time in the 14th year, and i think no one will deny this, then donbas, it was clear that in the country it was necessary to build not nets on the borders with russia, and it was necessary to build mini-fields, defensive structures and protect the country around the entire perimeter , what we are analyzing today is only one episode , possibly the most difficult in the life of the country, and that is precisely why what we have today in the ministry of defense, in my opinion, it should become a lesson for everyone for the future has become the tradition of leaving an envelope for those who go and those who come. but my advice to the minister is not to leave alone all those things that were declared as scandals in my opinion on each of these episodes

the case must be completed and completed. my advice alone cannot defeat even the best organizers if you have not reformed the system. this is the advice. thank you platform for the life of myra yuriyovich pavlenko , more windy, then we will vote , invite the deputies. dear mr. ministers, we will not be today. to give evaluations of the work of the minister of defense oleksiy reznikova from this platform, i am convinced that history will give him a proper assessment and i hope that this assessment will be positive indeed the work of the ministry of defense especially the last 550 9 days were extremely difficult in the conditions of the large-scale war of russia against ukraine in conditions when

it was necessary to do a lot from scratch and to make quick decisions on the fly , the ministry and the minister in office achieved a lot . possible corruption, the issue of public procurement in the military sphere, and they undoubtedly require further settlement, and here the responsibility of both the government and the parliament and how to simplify these procurements are not from the point of view of the corruptor’s accessibility to them and from the point of view of quickly providing the armed forces of ukraine with the necessary armored vehicles, the necessary bc with the necessary equipment and, in fact, the form of how to do import substitution when what can be done and produced in ukraine must be produced in ukraine, thus supporting the national economy and the issue

of price fairness it is extremely relevant for today, for society , of course, the protection and support of the soldier, starting with the provision of rehabilitation, the provision of medical care and many other problems that, unfortunately, today the state in relation to the soldier has not been resolved, i am sure that in the future, in the future, minister oleksiy reznikov will be able to give professional answers to these questions, and the new european solidarity, who are you , fedina sofya romanivna, please, speaking

before me, the representative of the monomajority once again forgot that the war began in february of the 14th year, and not in the 22nd, as he once again announces in this hall, and mr. reznikov , in particular, was the minister of defense of the belligerent state - poltorak, who happened to make effective reforms to strengthen the army and provide it properly, but i would like to ask, after such a beautiful and smooth report of the minister, what he was doing 112 days before the invasion , he was already a minister. invasion and panic in our heads , and there is enough money for the army and blocked the allocation of 50 billion hryvnias for the needs

of the armed forces of ukraine. in particular, from belarus, forgetting that at the same time, our minister of defense of belarus was beautifully on training in ukraine, so i have to say that all the eggs in this 17 jackets blocking the supply of production of drones and uavs are just flowers compared to the criminal cynical and impudent not as preparation for the invasion when , in fact, everything was done so that ukraine could not survive, and i will remind you that this minister and his entire team that worked together with him fenced him off, but this is criminal responsibility, article 11 of the criminal code of ukraine on criminal negligence and corruption scandals, and the president of lithuania announced that corruption is stopping the supply of weapons to ukraine, so deal with embezzlement in

the ministry of defense, there are too many of them. article 85 of the constitution of ukraine i am putting to a vote for adoption as a whole the draft resolution with registration number 96-79 on

the resignation of the minister of defense of ukraine oleksiy yuriyovych reznikov, i ask you to vote, the members of the specialized committee are running for 327, the decision was adopted, the resolution was adopted by factions, we move on to the next item on the agenda, in accordance with the 12th part of the first article of the 85th constitution of ukraine, the powers of the verkhovna rada of ukraine belong to the dismissed from the position of the head of the state property fund of ukraine, in accordance with the fourth part of the 20th regulation of the verkhovna rada of ukraine, the issue is included in the agenda of the extraordinary session without a vote on september 4, 23, in accordance with the provisions of the current legislation, the head of the state property fund of ukraine

, roste manverovych shumerov, submitted an application to the verkhovna rada of ukraine with a request to vacate his land position. with the registration number 96 78 materials have been provided to you by radio consent, we have agreed to discuss this issue under a shortened procedure with the floor for speaking until 7 minutes, the head of the state property fund of ukraine and his answers to the questions of people's deputies up to six minutes i am putting to a vote the proposal to adopt exactly this procedure for consideration of this issue, this is a procedural decision 150 votes, please vote for 325 decisions, the adoption procedure has been adopted , we proceed to the consideration of the issue, the chairman is invited to speak minevych of the state property fund of ukraine is growing. good day to all colleagues, it's nice to see everyone. always when you approach

the microphone of the verkhovna rada, you feel that something it starts again dear colleagues, a year ago, the verkhovna rada of ukraine, at the request of the prime minister, appointed me the head of the state property fund of ukraine. for the first time in the history of ukraine, the fund works independently and is not just a showcase for the sale and lease of property. the fund is the main manager of state property, we almost destroyed political influence on the work of the fund, in particular thanks to the law 8250 on the structure of the fund, adopted by you colleagues, now the head of the fund appoints the management independently without any agreements with influence groups, we have improved the structure of the fund, it has become a single a legal entity without twelve different branches in the regions that were breeding grounds for corruption submitted to novus the procedure for appointing all exclusively candidates

, the fund and the management of enterprises, one of the key points is that all candidates must pass checks by law enforcement, anti-corruption and other bodies, for the past year, the fund consolidated more than 65% of all state assets in the country out of a total of 3,600 enterprises in ukraine, more than 2,300 are currently under fund management, this is a precedent in the history of ukraine, 82% of these 2,300 enterprises we actually completed and sent for the procedure bankruptcy liquidation of more than 1,200 enterprises, time share remains in the temporarily occupied territory thank you, colleagues, for the adoption of the law on the peculiarities of the termination of state-owned enterprises, another 18% of enterprises, the e-e fund , we are actively working on privatization every day, we hold auctions

, there are still 1,200 enterprises from 72 management bodies left had a meeting with the prime minister. we are working with the government on their transfer. the property fund of trade unions is 50 sanatoriums , 30 hotels, recreation centers, and 20 other facilities should become an ecosystem. the rehabilitation program to all victims of the war, when i ask you to support draft law 64:20 as soon as possible, the property of dosaaf, 1,000 objects, we are working to return to the state ownership of this remnant of the soviet union, 1% of enterprises , strategic assets that we do not privatize will go to the sovereign fund, these assets must become leaders and drivers of the ukrainian economy, the sovereign fund the main product that the fund team is working on, to the process of creating a sovereign fund, they involved international advisers from world sovereign funds

, the big four lawyers, expert and the international environment held meetings with almost 20 sovereign funds of the world from the usa, europe, the middle east, asia and africa , as of today, the fund strategy is ready , the profund law and implementation plans when today depends on active interaction with you, how quickly we will launch the fund, the task of the sovereign fund is to develop development strategies not only individual enterprises, but a whole range of industries, this fund will already attract investments in the development of these industries and enterprises for the recovery of our economy, other important products our joint victory, this land bank, is possible in particular thanks to your adoption of the law 75-88 on improving the efficiency

of the use of state lands , this is a revolutionary step that kills ten years of corruption schemes with state agricultural lands. and will be able to rent agricultural land through transparent online auctions and transparent sales. our team is already completing all preparatory work, and with the entry into force of the law in january 24, it was announced the first auctions, privatization is explained by numbers, almost 400 entrepreneurs bought abandoned objects from the state in a year, most of them are administrative premises, objects of incomplete construction of non-working factories, warehouses , garages, and so on. 73% of these objects cost up to a million hryvnias. the admin premises or warehouses are bought by entrepreneurs who are forced to re-lacquer the temporarily occupied territories or those who lost their business due to russian aggression, the proof of this

is an unprecedented doubling of the average number of entrepreneurs per object to five participants used to be 2:3 ukrainian business actively buys states in order to create a new one from the old one, the economic effect of privatization amounted to 5.2 billion uah in a year, that is 3.8 billion in the budget from the sale of objects, and this is a record of the last 10 years, 732 million - this is debts to employees and the budget and 667 million vat, all this money goes to support the defense forces and increase the defense capability of our country , the rent is more than half a billion, the monthly budget , rental income increased from 21 million uah in july

22 to 70 million uah in july 23 th year that is, more than three times 612,000 square meters of real estate have been given over to accommodate the defense forces, the assessment fund has developed a methodology for assessing business losses due to russian aggression, before that there were no general rules for determining losses in ukraine, this is important because it will help ukrainian companies to prepare a high-quality lawsuit against russia also, the team of the joint change of nerve foundation has developed a methodology for assessing the losses of energy companies from the aggression of the russian federation. assets have been confiscated. we are restoring the request for justice for each object. we are working together with the security service of ukraine and the gpu are preparing for privatization the first objects of ocean plaza, demurinsk gzk assets, silk, what are the plans until the end of the year, confiscation of russian property, a lot of cooperation we are working with the government of ukraine, the ministry of justice of the gpu in the fall - this is a big privatization of ugkk upz

, the energy center in october, the launch of the sovereign of the fund in january of next year, the land bank. thank you, roste minerovych, please write down the questions to the head of the state property fund from the place , please, pope mykhailo mykolayovych , platform for life, peace, pass the floor to the people's deputy, kaltunovych, please oleksandr, dear chairman or dear speaker, can you see me, yes, i would like to address and continue our discussion with you, which we started yesterday with you at the committee on economic development, the speech concerns primarily the management of state property - this is one of the main functions of the state

property fund and whether or not it seems to you that the successes of the state property fund for the current year are somewhat illusory, considering the fact that 82% of enterprises are unprofitable, and in fact are at the stage of liquidation . in this regard, i would like to continue yesterday's discussion with you discussions after all, did the roaches give a more complete answer regarding the efficiency of the state property fund for the current year? perhaps you have absolute numbers or at least this specific weight when you entered, how many were there and how many now, then you and i would understand how efficiently the fund worked of state property, because 82% is, unfortunately, an extremely bad number, although we understand that there is

a certain amount. enterprises, where are they located, what legal document do they have, what do they technically have, what economically do they have, where are they located, where are the directors of these enterprises, that's why we are together , what was transferred by the cabinet of ministers to the state property fund , first of all, an audit should be done, we did these audits, and the audit showed that 82% of enterprises do not exist, they exist only on paper, this is the result of the fund, in order to simply analyze it, it was necessary to waste enough time in order to analyze it , we went through the law on the liquidation of e-e and the termination of state-owned enterprises. why, because for many years these enterprises existed on paper through them, processing was carried out through them, and some understood schemes worked, so we stopped it, and because of open auctions, we now offer to sell them through the mechanism of open shares after the technical audit , legal, financial, to be done, it will also

be sold through auctions. that is, this is privatization, but through another mechanism of liquidation, termination of state-owned enterprises. thank you, please. zheleznyak yaroslavanovich voice well let's grow yes, he knows that the most difficult question is asked by volodymyr tsabel , so i ask you to give him the floor, please volodymyr, please turn on the microphone, dear roste minvarovych , this is probably one of the few cases when freight, our faction does not regret the vote when we supported you a year ago , for this year yes this is a short period of time, but a lot has been done ; privatization was restarted; the process of creating

a land bank was launched so that there would be no corruption on the lands of the academy of sciences ; the process of consolidation of all state-owned enterprises was finally launched enterprises so that we, as a state, can understand what we are selling and which national champions are leaving behind , no previous manager of the state property fund was able to do this, and it is also important that the process of liquidation of enterprises has finally moved from the dead point. as we know before that , we had a lot of such enterprises and they ate a lot of state money, then we can thank you. there are actually no questions . we support you. thank you. please. and you. no questions. okay, european solidarity. and we have a question. it will be asked by mykola knyazhytskyi.