[000:00:00;00] ethical but also an economic result, this is not the only slavic country that shows such results, there is the czech republic, there is slovenia, but following poland, i will say that it is up to the level that almost every night i watch the polish news, so i can say that i am enough i understand their political situation very well and everything that was said and done about the ukrainian harvest and what is being done about the ukrainian harvest i perceive as exclusively well, first of all, the elections are, well, decisive enough, fateful enough, and sharp enough, and the ruling coalition and the opposition have approximately equal results, as of today , the ruling coalition has a slightly better result , but the opposition has a better coalition, and therefore it is possible that the prospects for

coalition victory are even better. there is a battle to the death. that's obvious. we all know that the ruling coalition is oriented and relies on the roiniks, as they say, on the agrarians, on the peasants , especially in eastern poland, eastern poland which borders in the first place with ukraine, therefore the ukrainian authorities . and i, inter-aggression is also such an element that it is necessary to understand that it is the government that made a decision, for example , about the dispute in the ukrainian government . is in the pre-election paradigm maybe from i would say from the word absolutely because in the paradigm there is the president and the president's office but not the government it is possible the parliament but not the government and therefore it is difficult for the ukrainian government to understand moravetskyi and e. kotsyubynskyi and their actions

in connection with the elections in that's why mine would be like this in poland well, i don't think i can give advice, but an idea that could if i could share with you and with those who listen to us, let's just wait until october 15, as they say 15 tego podzerka because then it will be decided eh actually speaking the future fate and movement of poland in the next 4-5 years and what is happening until now must be watched. and now i will say this word exclusively in the context of these fateful and decisive elections on october 15, then we can talk with the government after october 15, with whom by some government just a small moment what is happening to polish government commentators even said that , unfortunately, it acts under the pressure or interests of ukrainian oligarchs and

it reminded me of the story that we have a completely different structure of the agrarian market. for 5-6 per 10 family members who are employed on this farm and we have 35,000 farms and among them there are latifundists what few companies occupy almost the entire market, how does this also affect this history is also true, our market is oligarchized and not only agrarian. i will give you other figures that confirm this. i was a columnist of a well-known investor and a publicist of rusi-rashar, a showtime fan who calculated that the fortunes of billionaires in poland in poland is only 3% of the polish gdp as of 21 years , of course, at the same moment i took the ukrainian force for well and looked at the list of ukrainian

millionaire billionaires for 21 years and the fortunes of ukrainian billionaires are 18%. that is, once again three and 18 and this shows actually speaking this only confirms from the other side the figures you talk about, that in fact polish business is agrarian, it is in many ways medium and small, while ukrainian business is not only agrarian, it is usually also oligarchic, but look now, we don’t need the same, well, we can it is good to talk about this in ukraine, because it does not spill over to poland, because they use this argument. well, of course, in our opposition, we do not need to pour water there now. but we ourselves need to develop competition in the market, and therefore the competitiveness of ukrainian markets. that they really are oligarchized, but let's keep this story inside the country and we won't bring it out. it's already brought out, but at least we won't do it, mr. pavlo, you said that you should monitor the development of the polish economy, that there are many

interesting moments, i have the impression that what danylo hetmantsev, who wants to introduce the polish model of taxation in ukraine, is watching, will it work, and what do we lack so that it would be as it really is, as it is in poland ? well, i hope you also introduce something like this in ukraine , as it is in poland. and for that, we need to change in ukraine, so that it worked normally, when a year ago i criticized this system 10.3 a-ah, ukrainian pseudo-liberals enrolled me in the hetmantsev sect, i somehow crossed paths with one of them at a conference. i say i don't have any sectors, danylo , i'm sorry, look with- danylo, what is hetmantsevo to other colleagues who are currently conducting financial and economic policy, how did i change it at the legislative level? i recommend copying

the entire polish system, not only the law, but the whole the polish system, what do i mean? first of all, look, the system has many different components, we definitely won't have enough time for the whole program, but i will say only one important component, which is the attitude of the state as a whole towards business and the attitude of the polish state as a whole towards business is favorable there is a helper, there is a beautiful ukrainian word, nurture, nurture, nurture, this is the attitude of the ukrainian state to business, we know what it remains . this is still the legacy of the soviet union , this is still the legacy of socialism. in our country, more and more teachers tell students that business is speculation speculation this, by the way, is a crime. that's why generations of socialists, communists, etc. are coming to us, and in particular, among other things, now anti-corruption authorities and they think that business is their enemy. that

's why if danylo hetmantsev copies the polish system, i'm not against it. copies not only the rro, but let it copy the attitude of the state to business, e-e as a lever of economic growth, as the main factor of economic growth, we are here for everything that only and not only and not only an object for squeezing is left in us less than three minutes, also a question that is left until 4:44 p.m. i wonder what time it is, it's a miracle, then we'll try to talk about this question, the issue of the economist magazine is out, and it's dedicated to ukraine, and the cover is very eloquent, that ukraine is a time of rethinking, and they insist that although we need to pray for a quick victory of the ukrainian army, nevertheless, we need to prepare for a long war, which could last for years , and ukraine needs to think less about the marshal's plans and how the destroyed

territories will be rebuilt, and think more about how to become more independent and flourishing seems to be such a word used even during the war, even in these conditions , mr. pavly, in your opinion, how valid are these tips and can we really rethink this way, moreover, so that the economical say that, in fact, neither in ukraine nor in the west, no one is ready so far, to say it out loud well, look, no one is ready, this is of course an exaggeration uh, these voices uh , of course, were in the minority 3-4 months ago but even me said a little while looking around and well, it is clear that the mood in society was different at that time, now this mood is changing both in the government and in society, and we are increasingly talking about the fact that it was a long-term conflict with

a very serious major prevailing on we are at odds with the enemy in terms of size and economy, and i must say. as an economist, unfortunately , productivity is also possible . pay attention, pay attention to these numbers. the population of ukraine lagged behind. well, i am smaller than the population of russia by about 3.5 times, but how the economy of ukraine in the 21st year was 8 times smaller than the economy and therefore well, this is a fact that needs to be thought about. and what does this mean that the productivity of the export of carbohydrates is not only carbohydrates andriy because look, because i have another comparison , compare singapore and around malaysia, indonesia, that is, malaysia, indonesia, there is oil in sinapur, there is a swamp there, and there is no sand there, there is no hard sand, there is no sand to build buildings, they bring sand, they import sand from malaysia, i know this because

i lived and worked there and and and and the government malaysia this sand was sold to the construction company of singapore, that is, it is not necessary for you to have hydrocarbons. actually, you know this is a good phrase of steve jobs that you need to work not for hours, but for money, so in ukraine , we have to work both hours and brains, because in reality there is no of hydrocarbons but we have a war and we need to work in urban areas first of all and for hours also in one way or another we need to raise the productivity of our economy in the first place it was unproductive and this, by the way, applies to both the national level and the local level and corporate level, and i would even say personal level, if we are talking about each individual ukrainian now, is he now not in the front line, then he is productive, that is clear , and we thank them, and those who are in the rear now also ask themselves this question, how productive are we now, even though today is sunday and it is possible that this is the case, but on the other hand, it is a war, that is, a war is also a correct question, and

that is why the economist here is correct in that ukraine needs to ask these questions, ukraine needs to tune in, well, in the end, if honestly tell yourself this is a war not from the 22nd year and not from the 14th year, this is a war from 1600, some 40 40 50 years ago, that is, it has been 300-400 years , this war, there are of course different phases and stages of this war e- that's why it will probably last a long time, can it be defeated? oh, i'm once again referring to the experience of singapore , which has an economy. look at singapore - it's 5 million people, and it's worse than a million along with a million residents who are not citizens of singapore. that is, they are actually builders or professionals who work in in the business center here. that is, there are five. well, how do you understand me? i'm hinting a little in

ukraine, because we will have to think about how to compensate for at least the lost potential that we have, the human potential that we lost in connection with the war, that's 5 million people, malaysia is 35 million people, that is, singapore is seven times less than malaysia if you look at the population and the economy is equal, that is, the gdp of singapore is approximately the same as the gdp of malaysia, what does this mean that singapore is seven times more productive by the way, let's look at the military budget, the military budget, the military budget of singapore is larger than the military budget of malaysia, despite the fact that this country is seven times larger than singapore , i repeat, this is such an inspiring lesson in the world, it is, among other things, north south korea, well, let's say, let's say in terms of population, there are roughly comparable numbers, but absolutely not comparable in terms of economy, and well, because south korea is much more productive , more productive, i will emphasize this

word constantly, than north korea to ukraine and who even makes a good pass here and good and good thoughts are expressed on this matter by ukrainians, we think how to be more productive because this is a long-term war, mr. pavlo, thank you for the conversation pavlo sheremet , founder of the kyiv-mohyla business association, former president of the kyiv school of economics and ex- minister of economic development and trade of ukraine was with us. thank you , dear viewers, for being with us. lesya vakulyuk andriy saichuk worked in this studio for you today for almost 6 hours . thank you for responding to our announcement of fees, we now have 1 million 186,000,799 uah in our account, 28,000 uah were added in the second half of the day, with a tail of 50,000 in the first half of the day, and i can say that today we set a record with you for the whole week, because 78,000

this week we have not yet collected such sums and i think that this is not the end, you can still contribute, we also left money there, thank you for that. thank you for being with us. we will see you in a week. well, you can stay with espresso because ether lasts de pargin 10% in pharmacies traveller, bam and save, join the community with a ukrainian view of the world, become a sponsor of the espresso youtube channel, and this is access to exclusive content, personal thanks , pinned comments, special icons and the possibility of personal communication with the espresso team, click sponsor and become part of the community with a ukrainian view, with you vitaly portnikov and we talk about

the main events of this week vitaly portnikov and top experts about the brightest events of the last seven days, our guest will be the generator of companion forces, a former adviser the national security of the president of the united states, donald trump, herbert mcmaster, we will cut out current topics, pressing questions, authoritative comments and forecasts in the project , an informational marathon with vitaly portnikov every sunday at 8:10 p.m. on espresso. congratulations, this is freedom. life on radio freedom. we have already come to the very change. shock news from the scene live kamikaze drone attacks political analysis objectively and meaningfully there is no political season exclusive interviews

reports from the hottest points of the freedom front life frankly and unbiased to draw the most important broadcasts of vasyl zima two hours of airtime two hours of your time two hours to learn about the war and what the world is like 2 hours to keep up to date with economic news and new sports two hours in the company of favorite presenters presenters who have become many movrodny as well as distinguished guests of the studio, the events of the day in two hours , vasyl zimi's big broadcast, a project for intelligent and caring people in the evening, the most pressing war in ukraine , the main topic for ukrainians, victories and losses , analysis and forecasts, politics and geopolitics about all this will be said by serhiy rudenko and the guests of his program, people who have information and shape public opinion, people who defend

ukraine and create the future, the main and interesting thing in the program is the verdict of serhiy rudenko from monday to friday at 20:00, repeat at 12:10 watch this week in the program judicial control with tetyana shustrova traitors in robes who went to work for terrorists of the lpr works here this is my most dear favorite case and for what crimes the traitors were suspected of agitating other judges and employees apparatus swear allegiance to the russian federation congratulations you are watching judicial control i am tatyana shustrova full-scale war

in ukraine has been going on for over a year and a half , almost 18% of the country's territory is under russian occupation and at the same time, all authorities and here in these territories in 2014 due to russia's temporary occupation of crimea and donetsk and luhansk regions , more than 500 judges went over to the invaders, then there were recorded cases of the use of the court seal for fraud with property, the loss of case materials containing states and the introduction of fake of decisions to the ukrainian registry on the basis of ukrainian courts, the russians created their illegal judicial bodies that make decisions against citizens of ukraine, and former ukrainian judges who betrayed their oath help them in this, how many are currently unknown for sure , law enforcement officers continue to expose state

traitors today we will tell you about these sellers more office the prosecutor general and the state bureau of investigation informed the head of the zvenigorod district court of the cherkasy region that svitlana fedorets was suspected of justifying russia's armed aggression against ukraine, law enforcement officers established that after the full-scale armed invasion of russia, the judge repeatedly defended the temporary occupation of part of the territory of ukraine during personal conversations with colleagues and friends the first three years will not be, the judge calls the seizure of the territory of ukraine "liberated" and

the occupiers "ours" and recognizes crimea as part of russia, the official also admitted that i visited the peninsula several times and even met the new year 2023 there. well, i traveled from krymskyi bridge with a view of what a basement. hello, i traveled. i met a new year . yes , i stayed there for a month. her two minor children are with her mother in crimea and have the status of refugees , her brother also lives and works as a veterinarian in crimea for a long time, and from the conversations of the judge released by the state bureau of investigation

, it is clear that her husband is in of the temporarily occupied territory in melitopol. she keeps in constant contact with him. i took the krymsky bridge . i drove it. i was going to melitopol. well, they all knew perfectly well. money to organize a departure from ukraine. di's statements were analyzed by a linguistic expert. she established that in front of her interlocutors, fedorets tried in every possible way to justify russia, in particular , she assured that the occupation of crimea actually corresponds to the political interests of china and turkey, thereby shifting responsibility from russia to other states, claimed that the armed forces of ukraine were attacking luhansk, testing long-range weapons, and the russian missile attack on a residential building in uman, where 23 people were killed, including

six children, was actually the destruction of the nato base in april of this year. according to the sbu, the judge wanted to go on vacation with a lifetime ban from ukraine and move to live in the occupied crimea, where she has family and friends, the council of justice issued a warrant for the arrest of the judge svitlani fedorets chose a preventive measure in the form of detention with the possibility of bail in the amount of uah 2 million. the investigation in this case is ongoing. this is the judge of the northern commercial court of appeal, volodymyr kutsov. kyiv, after the full-scale invasion of the russian federation, kuksov began

to agitate his acquaintances to support the occupiers, justified russian aggression and called ukrainians fascists, according to sbu records, the judge denies mass atrocities russian invaders and assures the interlocutor that they are capable of such things . of the commercial court of appeal, volodymyr kuksov campaigned for an acquaintance who was in the occupied territory

of the zaporizhzhia region to join the occupation militia, and also complained to his acquaintances that he wanted to go home to the crimea. well, nothing. i still want you in both of them, it is mandatory, let's get to the house, a good investigation bureau informed the judge about the suspicion of inciting collaborative activity and justifying russian aggression, the pre-trial investigation of the judge's words is currently underway, a linguistic examination must be conducted , volodymyr rukhtsov faces up to 15 years in prison with confiscation of property, and this is a judge of the chernihiv district court of zaporizhzhya of the region vitaliy lomaiko last year he tried to escape to an honorable retirement before he was likely to be convicted

for collaborating with the enemy lomiko filed a corresponding application to the high council of justice, however, it turned out that the judge is in berdyansk, which is just as occupied as chernihivka, where the court is located, and the state bureau of investigation has already started an investigation of the case under the article of high treason, members of the high council of justice tried to contact lomaik, but the judge's phone was disconnected and there was no reply to e-mails , the application for resignation was left without consideration in 2015, according to the publication berdyansk-24 , lomiyko, while on a tip-off, rammed a tractor that was moving along in the opposite lane, we learned from the register of court decisions that in 2016 the tokmak district court of the zaporizhia region returned to the national police a report on an administrative

offense several times and eventually closed the case. vitaliy lomeiko continued to receive legal fees from taxpayers' funds, payments are currently suspended, information regarding the investigation into possible high treason of lomeiko in the register there are no court decisions at the moment. and finally, the judge of the starobil district court of the luhansk region, ihor kudryavtsev, according to the version of the law enforcement officers , he committed treason in occupied starobilsk and went over to the side of the enemy. he tried to go to the district court of the terrorist lpr. i spend almost half of my life in court. this is my

dearest beloved exercise, together with kudryavtsev, joined the occupiers and the head of the court staff, they agitated other judges and staff of the staff to swear allegiance to the russian federation, the judge organized meetings of judges and where he urged the employees of the institution to cooperate with the representatives of the occupation administration and to write applications for employment, promising them positions in illegally created judicial bodies, allegedly ihor kudryavtsev is a long-time supporter of russia, and in particular, in russian, the judge did not comply with the requirements of the law regarding the adoption of court decisions in the state language , 619 court decisions were found adopted by him in russian from 1996 to 2015 until february 15 of the year kudryavtsev presided over

the city court in the occupied by russian by the troops of alchevsk of the luhansk region, presumably his cooperation with the occupiers began when the revolution of dignity to our state led to such tragic events precisely in the luhansk part and the donetsk regions in that i saw all this with my own eyes and with my health. i traveled when there were already hostilities in 2019 in 2015, ihor kudryavtsev participated in the competition for the post of judge in the higher anti-corruption court. he passed several stages, but did not score the required number of points on the written tasks. part of the knowledge

i have is to give to our state, people in at the end of justice, let the law reign, let the rule of law reign in our country. last year, ihor kudryavtsev was notified of suspicion of treason, the prosecutor general's office summoned him for questioning, but the judge is hiding from the investigation in the temporarily occupied territory, and yet his case has already been transferred for consideration to ivano- of the frankish city court, so most likely he will receive the cut of the tree in absentia and will serve his sentence immediately after being detained by ukrainian law enforcement officers. we hope that all the judges who betrayed the oath and switched to the side of the enemy will be found and punished. and if

you know the facts of collaboration among the servants of themis, let us know, write to me on facebook or to this e-mail address. see you in exactly a week, all is well. koval i congratulate all viewers in the occupied territory of the donetsk region, a curfew is being introduced , it will last from 11 o'clock in the evening until four in the morning, the advisor of the mayor of mariupol, petro andryushchenko, also reported on occupied donetsk region is prohibited from holding demonstration meetings and strikes at enterprises . military censorship is also being introduced regarding the correspondence of messages in social networks