[000:00:00;00] there are related to the amounts of american aid to us, so we need to carefully analyze them and, in fact, show them and not just name them there without relation to something, because the absolute numbers can be impressive, but when you look at their breakdown, so to speak, and compare it with what has the aggressor at his disposal, then the situation will appear not so, so to speak , not as powerful as it may seem at first glance, what do i mean? the parties that are focused on the trump party well, they are focused to a large extent on disrupting american aid to ukraine, the figure is that ukraine has already

received 113 1 billion dollars in american aid. well, it sounds impressive, but at the same time, it is not indicated that practically when we let's look further, in fact , a significant part of this aid last year, for example, it went under the title ukraine, but it had nothing to do with ukraine, they just procedurally took advantage of what was necessary to quickly carry out american humanitarian aid for african countries was included in the ukrainian bill for 30 billion dollars, but it has nothing to do with ukraine, so direct aid is 81.3 billion dollars. - this is 46.5 billion dollars, the so-called military aid. but

again, when we take the figure, but what is on the front line is what actually shoots and drives, then this figure is 18.2 billion in total, and the other 21 billion approximately, so to speak, it is so postponed. that is, it will be provided, but it is the fact that financing is being ordered by industry, something that cannot be delivered immediately, but it will be somewhere there, months will pass , and even next year, exactly when this armed military equipment will be able to be delivered to the against this background, of course, when these numbers are heard, they must be analyzed and shown against the background of that. and what does russia have in the context of the money it allocates to the war budget

, let's say so, and here the numbers show that despite all the aid -e with on the part of the united states and our western allies in general, well, let's put it this way in the rammstein format, everything is fine in russia. if the western aid to us is somewhere on average every month, well , they calculated it to be somewhere around 4.2 billion dollars , this is based on the data provided by the us defense minister austin, that the total aid of the allies to ukraine during these 18 months of active hostilities amounted to 76 billion dollars, so this works out to 4.2 billion, where every month russia now spends on the war somewhere, according to modest estimates , in the order of 12 with a small billion dollars 12

to the small or immodest estimates given there, for example by the same andrii larionov, somewhere up to 15 billion dollars, and to the question that russia uses certain items of expenditure there, which, if they do not have a direct relation to the military to their military budget, but for example there, let's say, there are e-e lines , let's say, medical care, then these expenses go along the line of the ministry of health of russia, or , let's say, some construction e large-scale construction works and fortifications that are carried out in the occupied territories, they do not go at all on the line of the ministry of defense, that's why these are all things in a complex. i think that's exactly what the ukrainian delegation tried to convey to our american visa and, above all , to american politicians, because with the american military, i think there is an understanding , but with the political class, so to speak , there is no such understanding. well, because they

they are not military, they have a completely different coordinate system . of course, it is very good that we have additional supplies of anti-flood defense equipment on our doorstep, we understand that it is so important and it is not that we have understood it now. from yesterday from the day before yesterday now this is becoming especially relevant now that the winter season is approaching, both for the front and for the rear , so to speak, and when questions usually arise , what surprised me is that we need more means than, for example, an attack, well, this is a wrong way of asking the question, what do you think? you need a machine gun or a bulletproof vest on the front line, you need to do something else, and they lived with machine guns , you need air defense equipment and you need shock equipment because, strictly speaking , you can cause tangible damage to the enemy

, not only by defending your positions, but first of all, by striking the enemy and in terms of operational strategic depth, the enemy also needs strike complexes here, and i understand that in principle the issue is not closed, it will be worked out, but time goes by. of course, it is not worth blaming our americans in this case to the partners, well, their slowness, uh, it took too long to realize our needs , well, definitely, this is happening, we have already testified that the bureaucracy works unevenly in our country, uh, and in europe and in the united states

especially taking into account the political aspects but nevertheless, there is a problem and from the ukrainian side, of course, it is unlikely that it was like that well, i did not fix it, at least on the public plane, but they are on the public plane one of these inhibiting factors , why is it slowed down so the decision on the attacks is not made quickly because the american side is far from convinced that these means will not fall into foreign hands , so to speak, because there are certain equipment that is available not only in these complexes, but for example and in cardinals american ballistic missiles and this is a little bit of you. i want to clarify some things you said about the fact that, in general, russia's monthly expenses are actually three times more than the aid that

comes to ukraine, so in general, we take 4-2 billion e.e. and 12 billion e.e. for the russians to spend on current problems, the question arises where russia takes the money from, because in fact we always understood that in addition to destroying the enemy on the battlefield, what the armed forces of ukraine provide as the main executor of this extremely difficult task, the europeans and americans had to ensure the effectiveness of its sanctions in any spheres, then the question arises of where russia gets money from, how to deal with it, and here it is also an important issue, which, i think , was discussed in the same way, because actually we have a different coordinate system for evaluating the effectiveness of sanctions for our part, we see that these sanctions should be, as they were called in the states, loopholes, that is, to stop the financial flow of oil and gas suppliers into the war budget

, the russian war budget, and we see that this did not happen, the coordinate system is sanctioned the coordinate system adopted there in the western countries practically amounted to the removal of opportunities for russia to earn money on the markets of western countries. well, they did not remove them, but they really minimized such opportunities, but the problem is that russia overrepresented its exports by a significant to the extent east to south a-a yes, it suffered losses yes, it receives there according to various estimates there, for example, if we take the flow of oil dollars there, it is practically almost half less compared to last year but last year it received record revenues, and therefore what it receives now is enough for the war budget, and this is precisely

what draws attention from our side that the sanctions are not effective because they do not stop this perpetual motion machine of russian aggression. even now, if you look at it, it is not strong ones are even inhibited . and in this context, these numbers illustrate, so to speak, the asymmetry in this case, so bad symmetry, because we need to equalize all this . what we see is that all the forecasts and the russian western ones on the russian economy, eh. how is it doing this year? what will the results show that it will grow somewhere by two, maybe two with a small percentage? and this practically means that a last year it fell to

two and one to one 1/10%. i.e. if the economy began to grow, it means that the sanctions are ineffective, so certain sectors of the russian economy have failed, but if the military industrial complex is now pulling the rest of the economy and it is actually growing, and this is also an indicator of the insufficient effectiveness of the sanctions of course, we also increased our defense budget. and now, if you look there , taking into account the fact that the verkhovna rada gave additional money there earlier, we spend an average of 3.8 billion dollars a month, that is, if we combine this with 4.2 billion dollars of western aid, then it comes out to be somewhere around eight e billions in total, but so to speak, again, if we compare with that e-e dispersion according to estimates of various russian expenditures from 12

to 15 billion dollars, then again, hmm, this is far from such a mirror situation, because if we do not have opportunities to purchase e-e e-e get the necessary weapons and military equipment, then accordingly this will affect all the entire further course of e-e hostilities from the point of view of there and offensive operations there and so on, that is why the situation looks like this. thus , it is important that our western partners, first of all , the united states, in principle confirmed their commitment to further assistance to ukraine despite everything, well, the only thing is that, after all, we all expected what would happen if such a drastic transition from the formula to support

ukraine so much so much is needed to the formula ukraine's victories and inflicting a military defeat on the aggressor russia well, it didn't happen like that, so it's obvious that the american establishment needs a longer period to rethink and understand that, in the end, any delays there or the dosing of the supply of armed military equipment do not contribute to a faster the end of the war and that the only way out against the background of the fact that russia is fighting is to inflict a military defeat on it, and this will be a victory not only for ukraine, but also for the united states and our western partners e p mykhailov, thank you very much for your professional comments for finding time for our viewers, i hope that both the american and ukrainian authorities will find opportunities to speed up your enemy by combining the economic potentials of the military potentials with these, we really hope for this

thank you for your broadcast, i will remind our viewers that it was mykhailo gonchar, president of the center for global studies strategy 21 so when we talk about american aid, about money , if we consider this amount 47 here billions of military aid that ukraine received, it is actually somewhere around 5% of the total defense budget of the united states, so for these five percent of the total military expenditures of the united states , the ukrainian army provides colossal work , because during these 18 months of hostilities, it was actually destroyed more than 250,000 enemy personnel, a significant number of armored aircraft, we know these figures, and this indicates that the united states is extremely rational in using these

funds, i think that an increase in aid is in the interests of all european countries of the united states so that the destruction of russia takes place in the shortest possible time , this is actually mine, we hope oh, i sprained my back, flamidez gel quickly reduces dusting and treats pain from pain in the back and joints flamidez there are discounts on those crosses 10% in pharmacies podorozhnyk bam and oskad is a scary place and such places have appeared again in ukraine, we see them in liberated cities , torture camps, we know about their existence in the occupied territories, russian peace. if he

rolled back to lviv, it is very possible this place would work again as a prison as a place of destruction not according to who knows where i would be where you would be but now it is a museum at the price of the lives of our soldiers at the price of destruction the price paid by all of ukraine this is a museum and may it remain a museum forever congratulations this is freedom life on radio svoboda we have already come to the very change the following frames may shock you news from the scene live kamikaze drone attacks political analysis objectively and meaningfully there is no political season

exclusive interviews reports from the hottest points of the front freedom life frankly and impartially draw conclusions yourself so that no matter what ukrainians think about, no matter what they talk about, the first place still comes out war, war and our victory only on espresso from monday to monday completely different spheres of human activity sports health politics return of crimea military analytics nine presenters journalists experts opinion leaders in real time about the most relevant events through the prism of war in the author's projects on espresso the war is going on and not only for territories it is also the war for minds russia is throwing millions of oil dollars to turn ukrainians into little russians ukraine will become russia dissection and analysis of information about ukraine by russian

propagandists specific facts and methods by which enemy propaganda turns people into obedient zombies ruyut progolosovat residents of the ldr let's counter russian information attacks in the project of the information chronicle wars with olga, laziness, tuesday, thursday, friday at 5:10 p.m. on the espresso tv channel hello, this is freedom, the morning, the informational project of radio svoboda, guests, every day, this is ship kherson district live streaming, we are somewhere in the vicinity of bakhmut, we tell the main thing on weekdays at 9:00 a.m. vasyl winter's big broadcast

, two hours of air time, two hours of your time , two hours to learn about the war and what the world is like, 2 hours to stay up to date with economic news and new of sports for two hours in the company of favorite presenters, presenters who have become like-minded to many, as well as distinguished guests of the studio, the events of the day in two hours , vasyl's big broadcast of winter, a project for intelligent and caring people, in the evening, nayspresso, greetings to everyone from you project war and sports and traditionally on sunday we tell everything that happened during the week in ukrainian sports and ukrainian football . and it was not enough because the group stage of the european cup had already started and unfortunately shakhtar conceded , but zorya showed its character and won the points that will be so necessary for ukraine in the future, i am oleksandr vashchuk and with me traditionally andrii malinovskyi andrii vitanya

good day sashko good day to our fans, in fact, we were all waiting for the start of the group tournaments of the european cups, but now this is probably the most important topic, how capable our teams are now against the background of european clubs, and despite the fact that we were not against the giants, we understand that , after all, not everything is so simple now for our teams , and the fact that only two represent us in the eurocups this season is also an indicator well, what should it look like, this is also a separate topic now, and for our today's analysis, then we will move on to the chronology, tuesday began its journey in the group stage shakhtar donetsk in the group in shakhtar, well, it is not an easy group, and what has started sport is also portuguese, barcelona antwerp and sport, i don't know how you like, i was quite surprised by shakhtar's squad, well, now shakhtar's squad surprises everyone, i think, because

ah, well, we understand that there are problems in all clubs now because of the war, which has been going on for the second year in our country but all the same, shakhtar somehow stood aloof from this topic, plus i mean in terms of personnel and a big plus shakhtar, which is the only one in the clubs, received almost 100 million, we still declare the brands this amount of 100 million for a wise man, so he could strengthen his squad whatever about that we see this season. this is probably the worst transfer company in the recent history of shakhtar donetsk. this star shakhtar donetsk and this lineup is just an absolute indicator of what we see. in the center of the defense, we understand that we mostly need to defend in the match and in the sport, well, in general, it is a mystery why the head coach chose to debut the young footballer

, gave the tanzanian footballer his debut in the group tournament champions league it's just a secret some uh in the middle of the field well here it's more or less it's clear more or less bondarenko wasn't there but nazarenko is in good shape he's a team player now plus stepanenko sudakov it's just the basis of the basics attack well here zubkov yes and lc yes and it is interesting, but it is too possible that the attacking team is chosen by patrick lavan leuven, everyone wants to see attacking football and bright, spectacular, productive football, but still, to play three strikers, after all, we understand that anisikana, zubkov, and halsey, they do not defend properly, that's why to play with three strikers against porto, even if porto plays with us with one striker, we play with three, because this is a very strange line-up chosen by the head coach, which remains again on its own, eh , it remains a strange decision to appoint valyona instead of keyovych this is all a direct reflection of what is happening in shakhtar's transfer market on shakhtar's transfer field. well, on the coach's bridge we can see the chronology

of the match, the statistics, where, after all, by all parameters, porto prevailed and this score of 3:1 is logical, judging by gg, because porto stopped already in the second half and, let's say, he didn't finish the layup, but well, the chronology of the match was the following, alena opens the score quite quickly shakhtar kelsey, it is obvious that they guessed with kelsey, and after that, galena and remy make the score. she played such a bad role well, he didn't defend himself, he gave this cross pass because, er, in children's football, they teach not to give cross passes, especially near the penalty area, that's why sikan played like that that's how everyone is looking for sudakov, we understand that now this is the figure around which shakhtar donetsk's game is built and in the development of the attack, the beginning of the attack and in the continuation of that, everyone is looking for sudakov, but this is not the way

it should be done. and again, we understand what was needed bet on the balance and on the defense, it is clear that everyone wants and the club managers want and the supporters of shakhtar donetsk want shakhtar to attack, to play spectacular, bright and productive football, but the football turned out to be effective thanks to the fact that the three of us missed, and malysh misses much more, that's why we only missed three and to a large extent. apart from this goal, we didn't have many clear moments like that . that's because the score 1:3 is not in our favor. debacle, although again, taking into account that composition, taking into account well, for example, my money, maybe he is not in order, maybe he is in the future and close, but now it is a group tournament of the champions league, and it is points for ukraine , and we are losing our position, and it is points for shakhtar donetsk for the club and it's money, every point is a lot of money, because shakhtar is conducting the transfer policy in the same way, and right now the group tournament

of the champions league remains for me just a secret, a mystery, i can't explain the decision made by the managers of such an experienced club club and we have always praised the management by right and burned the management and all the decisions made and all the transfers were almost guessed, but now the bet is on the youth - this is very good, but we still need this youth well, somehow, the experienced players have to balance with the leading football players. well, we saw that the defense was not optimal because matvienko was injured, bondar was injured, but aza irakli was playing on the left, and azarov, a georgian who constantly played on the left, also in the center, maybe instead of lemkin, there was an experienced chigyrinsky. which well, he looked pretty good, relatively speaking, because we see lemkin, he has a lot of advances, but maybe he burned out a little and his speed did not impress me at all, well , first of all, he is a young group footballer

the tournament of the champions league is traveled here by almost everyone, and plus miroshi right there , we are talking about a complete picture in defense, so here i would also bet, for example, on experience and why lemka is not based on speed, we saw that he lost almost all duels, this is once -secondly, you say they recorded azarov, but they recorded mikhalichenko, i remember he surprised the entire group of the champions league last season, he tore up the left flank, he defended almost perfectly in such a difficult group in which shakhtar played, but mikhelichenko and kornienko, both of whom are fine were on the left wing, none of them are now not in the club, not in the miner. why are they now recruiting left defenders, but they are all good left defenders so far? by the way, the term football is because it is a very important position. which is now tied for the champions league, so now, well, for now, it's a bit scary for shakhtar donetsk, how

will it go on, it won't be easy for shakhtar too, and then the spark from barca, eh , you already mentioned mykhailichenko, you also need to mention it, because thursday is bohdan mykhailichenko came on as a substitute in the dynamo zagreb astana match and made two assists. there, literally in 10 minutes, he was not like that , he was ok, he was a miner, well , below his level , for sure. - this is an exit from group e in the champions league or the europa league from the third step , that is, bohdan mikhelychenko has always been in perfect order and there is a price. this, including because mykolaychenko is one of those who received a balance in the defense. and now we understand that without a pipe, which is already lit by the benfiets with a difference, but to various and no questions, he is beautiful, he controls the process, but again, we are already talking about the balance in the defense

which was created thanks to the skeleton who played in the defense. and now he is just balanced once and the skeleton is simply not there now and in the defense as well. well, as for valery the cooper, the recovery is enough for now. he works individually, but that’s all. another 1.5-2 months, probably i have a message that matvienko is still expected in the near future, they say that the group should begin training in general, and well, the group, let's go to the group, we appreciate the group, after all, we are not competitors of barcelona, ​​probably, too. in two behind antwerp , what can we expect look, you and i talked about this on the eve of the tournament , that is, we didn't have to wait for this start, we understood how shakhtar conducts this transfer policy, how it looks now, the team looks against the background of porto , we understand that these are just the echoes of the echo what is happening with shakhtar now is possible now again the president of the club may have some other business, but he always responded to the management of the top manager of the club and why exactly now and in this way shakhtar

is being held, that is, you know, there is also a bet not just on the youth but the youth is still foreign, that's why we understand even two georgian defenders. they are still legionnaires, that is, i am still in tanzania, georgia , they have now come to shakhtar van leeuwen, they hired a coach in the academy, he once worked. it's not bad, but what is it like to work as a director in the academy academy that is, it is still necessary to take into account the coaching staff at the academy, the personnel at the academy, that is, it was tight, and they took him from zori, and what about zarya, and what he won for ray , that is, they took a coach so that he would win, what would he win if he had not won anything before that that is why it is very difficult to explain how shakhtar is behaving now, what he wants to show with this, and again, there you go to the american ones, who came. they also have a short-term perspective, when shakhtar takes a perspective, he must have in his arms a basis that can fight at least sports on equal footing with a home match, no nominal home match, but we're used to it, we don't want to get used to it, but we're used to playing away matches as if

at home, because of what's happening, we 've been talking about it for a long time, that's why shakhtar is definitely not ready for this tournament is a group one and i don’t think that this squad will be in the next season, i’ll tell you somehow if shakhtar will still get into the group of the champions league, i think that these football players, these personnel, will be needed in the next season, that they will be revealed precisely for the next one , and this season, well, now front sunroof what we talked about with you even before the start of the tournament is now coming out so that it is with the belgians that we have to turn for the third step to the left of europe, well, it looks like that because it is like that. barcelona, ​​porto - these are the teams according to the level, according to the history, this is the playoffs of the champions league, always were because of what you said, very few are now commenting on what is happening in the mine, well, the coach, because there is a language barrier, the players, but they still leaked from sudakov such a method that the training sessions are in english and the team let's say so to the brazilians who came to latina avakov americans they do not understand