[000:00:00;00] there is a tv channel, the one who watches us on a specially created for the world during the war, a youtube channel, please, if it appears, because for some technical reasons i do not see a live broadcast, so on this live broadcast there will be question, i hope we will have one, and there will be a question every week, well at least every week i ask a question to which i want to hear your answer, because it is very important to me , the visit of volodymyr... zelensky to the general assembly ooon was a successful answer: yes, no, your option, and why, it is important for me to know your opinion, because if you watch the world during the war on monday at noon, it means first of all that you are interested in international affairs and that you are the one who understands this international affairs, i want to hear your opinion, so let's hope that

the broadcast will still appear and the voting will appear on this channel, but wherever you watch us, whether in a special youtube channel created for the world during the war, or in general espressivskyi, please put your preferences if you like the program, although you can't dislike her, but if for some reason you didn't like her that much, please dislike her, although i'm sure you will, and leave comments, please, it's also very important to me, my team and to spread our program in complex. algorithm, which is still unclear to me, but experts say that the more your likes, your, no, what , no more likes, no, let's be better, the more your likes and your comments, the more people on youtube, will have the opportunity to watch this program , well, let's move on to the discussion, i am happy to introduce my first guest for today, volodymyr tsibulko, political scientist, mr.

volodymyr, i congratulate you, thank you... glory to the heroes, mr. volodymyr, well, let's start everything well, perhaps the most important thing that happened last week in the world, the general assembly of the united nations, to which the president of ukraine volodymyr zelenskyi even flew on his own presidential plane, i also have a question about this, where is this there was probably a plane somewhere in the territory of poland, if he was in the territory of poland, then the office of the president knew that there would be an invasion soon, then why. the dream remained in gosstomil, but these are such questions, you know, already different, you and i are about the general assembly of the united nations. please tell me, in your opinion, zelski's visit was successful, i would say that zelski's speeches at the general assembly at the council security debate were vivid, but the visit itself was relatively successful, i will explain why, on the eve of

the visit, the president of poland duda. posted a tweet that he would meet with zelskyi and will discuss the transit of grain, this meeting did not take place, zelensky, right from the un podium, it is enough, i would say that he spoke harshly towards poland, and this is also not a completely ill-considered step, but besides, and the meetings on the sidelines of the general assembly, this visit is not excelled yes, there was a meeting with dasilva, there was a meeting with the president of kenya, but in my opinion it is not enough. i generally analyze the weight of certain events against the background of the general assembly, that is , the last week, and it seemed to me that for

president biden, for example, a meeting with by the five leaders of the central... asian countries and the creation of the 5+1 format, countries, post-soviet asian countries and the united states, it was a more serious, more weighty event than the meeting with zelensky later in the white house, as is known, well, when we analyze the general assembly itself, it is true that zelenskyi’s speeches were quite emotional, quite argumentative, although the attack on the address: was absolutely neither to the village nor to the city, that is, he, he did not contribute to our relations, and as you know, zelenskyi after returning to ukraine drove to lublin, awarded the volunteers and spoke a lot of compliments to the polish people, so it seems to me that very often in zielski they first do, then think, and then

think how to fix what they are on... unfortunately, well, he is already in lublin tried to fix, right? yes, of course, look, now come on, what is this general assembly, what is this general assembly. was, although it is not , the general assembly continues, the week of high-level debates was for the russians, because first of all, there was already, as usual, the minister of foreign affairs, sergey lavrov, instead of putin, who was simply afraid to fly there, and obviously, for good reasons, he was afraid to do so, and as far as i understand it, lavrov had just a lot, well, not a lot, but a lot of meetings, in particular with representatives of the global south, can it be considered , that in this case, if for us, well, this week was like that, then for the russians it could be successful, well, i would say not very successful, the fact is that no matter how many leaders of the south lavrov met with , but

first, the president does not participate in high-level debates in the general assembly, of the minister of foreign affairs, this is already a defeat for russia , secondly, he was afraid to come to the debate at the council of security, where volodymyr zelenskyi was speaking as a guest, he stood outside the door, and when zelenskyi had already left and flew to washington, then lavrov appeared at this debate . lavrov really, really talked a lot, talked about respect for the un charter, which it looks like. such an oxymoron, he even spoke, by the way, about recognizing the territorial integrity of ukraine, that is , in fact, within the walls of the un, lavrov recognized crimea and

donbas as ukraine, but he did not speak at all about the end of the war and the withdrawal of troops, that is, again, this kind of bipolarity is typical of the current russian government, when they say what needs to be said, they do it... well, that is, it is not even bipolar, but rather tripolar, because they say one thing, they think another thing, but they do a completely third one, in this sense, this is the mental disorder of the entire russian empire, it was demonstrated by lavrov in all its glory, uh, did ukraine catch russia on the way, because lavrov talks about the readiness to negotiate with ukraine, but ukraine cannot afford to. that is, the time has passed when ukraine could afford bilateral negotiations with the aggressor, and moscow knows this very well, in moscow, even more, they know very well that they

will have to leave ukraine, but before they leave, they want to be noticed, no one will notice them, that is, judging by the provision of attacks and the provision of the expected taurus missiles, russia’s affairs will be completely bad and counting on some pause in hostilities so that putin can proudly re-elect yourself, or this or himself or putin's double, it is not known what is in their heads and what is being done in their management, i.e. it is such a complete mess, but this mess is called a complete crisis of management, that is, this crisis of management, it has been demonstrated, because this absolutely insane nibenzia, what he is doing, it looks very comical, that is , russia looks demoralized, crushed, and

especially after the success of the azerbaijani troops in finally restoring territorial integrity, russia also looks humiliated and the main thing is that it was not humiliated by ukrainian weapons , but by its own, because russia supplied azerbaijan with quite a lot of weapons, and now this weaponry has defeated, so to speak, the russians themselves on the territory of azerbaijan. mr. volodymyr, that's right, you said a little earlier that lavrov was standing outside the un security council while the president of ukraine, volodymyr zelenskyi, was speaking. i watched it live and i also paid attention to the fact that lavrov is not there, why should he be there, but i see that he is not there, and before vladimir was supposed to speak zelenskyi, not bendzya, did not talk a lot about the fact that you cannot give the floor to volodymyr zelenskyi, because it contradicts that, you cannot give the floor to volodymyr zelenskyi,

because it may contradict some other, some article of the un charter, and here i am i wanted to applaud the president presiding at this meeting, and the prime minister of albania, eddie rami, who, well, it seems that he. trolled, just trolled not benzo , showing, and no, talking about what no, that's what he has the right to say, and it was just, just phenomenal, come on anyway, you know, about what else, but after this speech... articles began to appear in some american mass media about a cooling of relations between ukraine and the west, in particular with the united states of america. let's first look at what anthony blinken, secretary of state of the united states of america, said in an interview with nbc news on the today program. if we allow such

aggressions to continue with impunity, if we allow putin to get away with it, then any potential aggressor will see that he can do the same. putin himself will not stop, and other dictators in different parts of the world will be watching to see if he can get away with it and ask themselves the question, if he can do it, so can i, this is how a world is created in which problems inevitably arise that to the detriment not only of other countries, but also of americans, and it's great to hear that, because the secretary of state of the united states of america, a person from the administration of the current president, joe biden, but then speaking, the speaker of the house of representatives, kevin mccarthy, and this is what he says. i have a question, where is the report on spending money that we have already allocated to ukraine, what is the plan for achieving victory? i think what the american public

wants to know is, listen, what russia did when it invaded ukraine is wrong and we want it to stop, but i also want the american taxpayers to know what their money is being spent, that is, if the secretary of state says that we will definitely continue ukraine to the victorious end, then the leader of the republicans in the house representatives says that we will support, but there are certain... demands for ukraine that we want to get answers to, and this morning i read that the rating of the current president, joe biden, has declined so much, against all this background, on that now we need to beat our diplomacy in order to, well, to win this support after all, and in the future, well, first of all, secretary of state blinken made it very clear that ukraine

is important to the united states, but what mccarthy said is an element internal struggle, because mccarthy represents, let's say, the republican wing, and he is the speaker of the lower house, but he is very dependent on such a group of maga, that is, he actually voiced those demands that are quite rational, especially on the eve of, well, the presidential campaign in the usa, that is, the usa recklessly provided huge funds at a difficult time for ukraine amounts, but volodymyr zelenskyi and his entourage did nothing, especially to strengthen trust between partners, and we can say that these attacks are in the style of the president... why are we not in nato, they

were done in different ways, that is, these are unpleasant for the american establishment signals, and especially corruption scandals, they provoked biden's opponents all the time, that is, they essentially armed biden's opponents, and well, the hope that zelensky's visit, as it did last year, will mobilize american politicians in the desire, well, let's say, to take pictures with zelenskyi, that is , to exploit zelenskyi's popularity for domestic american politics, it suddenly turned out that there is no demand in the american political community for this, zelenskyi already does not have such quotes, for strengthening the rating one or another politician, let's remember at least half a month ago, a visit... on the eve

of the g7 summit in japan, when zelensky visited the four g7 countries in europe, and how he was greeted, how was he treated photographs were taken, let's recall the visit a year ago and the two-minute applause in the congress, this no longer happened, and this is evidence that zelensky has lost a certain initiative, that is , well... there is such a lack of time for public opinion, and it is obvious that this is connected with serious bank miscalculations, for example, the scandal with reznikov, which began on at the beginning of the year, it was necessary to quickly, let's say, put it out, but this scandal managed to get into the top of all the media of the world, that is, it was not stopped in time, and it poisoned the relationship,

the trust in zelensky, zelensky's relationship with potential partners, i see that , well, the visit to canada was a kind of therapy after the defeat in the states, because i think that this visit to the states was a loss, although the states then retrospectively announced, the same mccarthy himself announced that he would still, well, find a way to vote for entering budget of 300 million aid and even hinted that the amount requested by president biden for aid in ukraine 24 will be considered and supported, but, but this was not done directly, that is, it was connected with the position of mccarthy himself, because it is very weak, he is very dependent on the votes of the maga group, the trumpian group, so it can be said that here ukrainian

diplomacy, well, did not follow the situation, and lost a certain point in the initiative, because it works very, very, very weakly, i believe that traditionally the ukrainian diaspora is always was friends with the republicans, and not using these opportunities means, well, a big failure, although i will remind you that zelsky's visit began with a visit to the hospital, where he awarded military personnel, and a meeting with ukrainian public activists in the united states, whom he also awarded, i.e. . well, what are these apparently correct steps taken , but the set of steps seems to be correct, but the expected result is not there, that is, it is obvious that a certain energy

connection between a set of tools and a method has been lost its embodiment, of course, mr. volodymyr, well, i still have two or two questions , one is short, for the second, maybe you can say a little more, but first, why did biden decide to give us these atakons, it’s a very tricky thing here, it’s about because there was a certain fear of teasing the russians, and as far as i understand, all the media hype about atakoms, which was organized by kyiv, was aimed at striking the crimean bridge, which is in the host states. not quite an appropriate gesture, and by the consequences, when it was already announced that they were surrendering to the attacks, it turned out to be a cluster attack, in fact, for front-line events, these attacks are very necessary, they really change

, so to speak, the distribution of forces, because, well, one such missile covers a huge territory, it essentially destroys at least... one company in one shot one company of the enemy, and with greater concentration, maybe the battalion covers , so it is a very effective weapon, and when it was announced about the cassette format, it means that it is still a weapon for offensive, for knocking out, the enemy's warehouses, and what is important - what missiles can be used to hit airfields, it means that the crimean airfields can be said to be excluded already, and most likely, if russia does not take away the planes in the near future, they will all be shot down by helicopters, and what is the lack of aviation, on the front, this is a great opportunity

for a ukrainian offensive , well, they will all be killed, that's for sure, mr. volodymyr, but the most important thing, it seems to me that president biden was guided to go further... that chancellor scholz tied the supply of atakams to the supply of taurus, and well, in washington they decided that the taurus a ukrainian is also needed. must, must taurus, 100%. mr. volodymyr, and the last question for you, after all, you mentioned ukrainian-polish relations at the beginning, please tell me who is to blame and what to do? the ukrainian side is to blame, because poland, poland provided all opportunities for transit. and i want to remind you that the position of brussels and the european union is still important here, because the european union has created preferential conditions for the export of any agricultural products of ukraine, well, all of them. products

to european markets, and for some reason it is in kyiv decided that it is worth flooding the neighboring countries with inexpensive ukrainian grain, but it is necessary to understand the structure of agricultural production in these neighboring countries, these are small farms that are unable to compete either in price or quality with ukrainian grain, but these farms are the basis of rural development in these, well, slovaks... the ministry of agrarian policy of rural development is called, that is, rural demography is very tightly bound there, and rural agricultural production connected with the development of villages, with rural demography, therefore, when farmers rebel in these countries, it is primarily connected with the pressure on it by politicians, with the pressure of the voter, well, the farmers in poland... they, in

at one point, during one of the visits, they were so radical that they were ready to fill the road along which zelenskyi and zelskyi's cortege were to drive with manure, that is , the farmers would roll out their tractors and pour manure over all the highways, they, how much, well, in poland they are radicalized, because it was driven by the small profitability of enterprises, it's a lot of work, and without it... farmers can't survive from the eu subsidy, but kyiv made one more mistake here when, well , these pickpockets between warsaw and kyiv started, the bank decided to go through brussels, through ursula fonderlein, when in warsaw heard that kyiv is asking ursula funderlein to put pressure on president duda, they just boiled over there , because they believed that our bilateral... relations, just a minute, just a minute , i'm finishing, that's why this hypervalue, which

should not be given in doubt, doubt it was kyiv that exposed these relations, and unfortunately, mr. volodymyr, i thank you very much for participating in today's program, it was volodymyr tsibulko, a political scientist, we had a lot to talk about and a lot more to talk about, but after the commercials, these are the rules television, a few minutes and we meet again. there are discounts on ox from 10% in pharmacies psylansky, bam and oskad. the war reared its head again in europe, recalling the darkest hours of our history. france-24 is constantly in education. events in ukraine. our team will be in the field and in the studio

inform you about the dynamics of events. watch the latest from france-24 in ukrainian on espresso. a collaborator is a person who knowingly cooperates with the occupation authorities to the detriment of his own country. until recently, these people lived nearby, pretending to love ukraine. our home is a school family. our only ukraine, in fact, we were waiting for russian world, the day of independence of russia, on this day we honor our family. we must know the traitors in the face, know in order to punish them, watch the collaborators program on wednesdays at 5:45 p.m. on the espresso tv channel. mykola veresen, vitaly portnikov and the main topics of the week. if , god forbid, a truly tactical nuclear weapon is used against ukraine, it will definitely change the world. stories about john herbst, the former ambassador of the united states to

ukraine, is waiting for us, if you have questions, you will get answers, also interesting questions, they should be analyzed, portnikov veresen, every friday, 9:15 pm at espresso. every week, the saturday political club helps to understand the processes taking place in ukraine and the world. vitaly portnikov, host of espresso and. the requested experts give their assessment and development forecast based on facts events if you want to understand how our today will affect our tomorrow, watch the saturday politics club, every saturday on espresso. vasyl winter's big broadcast. my name is vasyl zima. two hours of airtime, two hours of your time. let's talk about the most important thing. two hours to learn about the war, joins ours. serhii sgurets broadcasts, the military results of the day, and what the world is like, what yuriy fizel will talk about in the world, for two hours to be aware of economic news, i will give the floor to

oleksandr morchyvka, he will talk about the economy during sports news, yevhen pastukhov is ready to talk about sports for two hours in the company of his favorite presenters. lina cheshenina is ready to talk about culture during the war, and the presenters, many of whom have become like native speakers. maybe the weather will at least give us some optimism, mrs. natalka didenko is ready to tell us, as well as the distinguished guests of the studio. we will have volodymyr ogryzko today, if all goes well. events of the day in two hours. big broadcast of vasyl zima, a project for intelligent and caring people. espresso in the evening. the war in ukraine is the main topic for ukrainians. victories and losses, analysis and forecasts, politics and geopolitics, serhii rudenko and the guests of his program will talk about all this. people who have information and shape public opinion, people who defend ukraine and create

the future right now, are important and interesting. in the verdict program by serhii rudenko, from monday to friday at 20:00, repeat at 12:10. world at war is back on the air after a commercial break to talk to another guest about something else, including what's happening in the south caucasus and what might happen there, to me joins volodymyr kopchak, head of the south caucasian branch of the research center. army, conversion and disarmament. mr. volodymyr, glory to ukraine, thank you very much for joining. glory to the heroes, glad to meet again. mr. volodymyr, well, tell me, please, this is the question that probably interests me the most, in this situation, can we say that azerbaijan has succeeded

in finally returning karabakh? yes, of course, directly. as we speak, azerbaijan is now physically engaged in bringing the moment as close as possible to when it does the so-called nagorno-karabakh republic, not only deyura, but de facto on the ground, will become the karabakh economic zone of azerbaijan, directly in these at this moment, the relevant processes are going on, in its superstitious system of cardinalates, for me the final solution. this question will be after the flag of azerbaijan in khankend, it will happen in the near future, i think, and the main moment, when the last russian so-called peacemaker, peacemaker left, will leave the territories of karabakh, read azerbaijan, it is more difficult here, because

first of all, azerbaijan, which is doomed, to work, to conduct, to liberate territories, to conduct a counterterrorist operation, now, well, communications with russian peacekeepers and baku makes it clear that in this system of trades it will not pedal the issue until the end of the 20th, 25th year, regarding the withdrawal of the russian peacekeepers, this is prescribed in the night paper based on the results of the 44-day war in november 20th, another thing is that baku also makes it clear that it is not going to prolong the russian military beyond the 25th year, well, it loses its meaning if the issue of full integration of the region, de facto, i emphasize, well, the structures are all azerbaijan, that is, look, you also say what i read about, maybe you will now confirm even more, that is, the information was that the official baku could cooperate, and you say this with the russian so-called peacekeepers, and that moscow even gave

some information, in particular, about the coordinates of concentrations, military groups on the territory of karabakh, and this could help precisely during the anti-terrorist operation, mr. volodymyr, if it was so, then it turns out that moscow really woke up armenia, let's do it this way, step by step, well, the conditions are like this after the 44-day war, that is, one of the results, apart from the undeniable... victory of azerbaijan in that phase of the war, which i call karabakh , now there they say the third phase , the fifth, they carry, we all see, there was a condition for the placement of the russian military on the territory of azerbaijan, in karabash, so there are no options in the current conditions without communication, no matter how offensive it sounds there, for someone, i liked it , no liked, without communication with the so-called rmk, without certain trades, pressure on them,

whatever, in principle, any operation in