[000:00:00;00] that the tatarstan constitution takes precedence over anything else that exists in the post-russian territory is a small problem, and others will do the same, so i do not think that china, when it will have, in front of its nose, so to speak, suddenly formed some kind of conditional far eastern independent republic, there will be a very great interest... to go beyond what he has to regain, well, what he got wrapped up in, well, and further, let's not forget that any of these new republics , formations there, as states, as they will be called there, may suddenly recognize

a collective event, and i don't think that after that anyone in china ... will suddenly want to attack a conditional, the same far eastern republic there, if it is recognized as a subject of international law, uh, so, you know, here you just have to want , to think a little ahead, to want to think and predict what might happen and do things so that this uncontrollability does not happen, well, but again, we return to what we started, for this we need political will and a little bit of a stream spine, which no no no would bend over putin's next nuclear statements or his entourage, and the fact that they will be, well, there is no need to go to fortune-telling here, this is the only last argument that is in the pocket of putin and his camarilla, there are no others, and that is why today on the same valdai, putin has already started

mumbling again about the fact that russia wants negotiations, well, it already becomes just a common place in all his recent speeches, he understands that he will no longer win the war, and this piece, his speeches, which you cited, once again proves about the fact that he is ready to cede territories, well, how come, he is talking about russia, which has already expanded to new...' territories, but let's listen to what between the lines, he says: i'm ready to leave these territories so that i stay alive, so let's go, let's not rush, and it seems to me that after all, having

ee new tranches of ee support for the armed forces, having very effective attacks by our special forces on facilities, infrastructure, russia itself, having driven the remnants of the black sea fleet not even to novorossiya, to occupied abkhazia, this is all evidence that the crisis is approaching, let's get more weapons, let's get more the right weapon, it will be faster, we won’t get it, it will take longer, but the perspective is one way or another clear, and that’s why this creature uh, uh, mumbles, asks, humiliates, uh, and so it will continue, and it will be just even, it seems and more. mr. volodymyr, forgive us for going back to what this creature says, but one way or another , the lives of many ukrainians and the future of ukraine depend on this creature, because there is a large-scale

russian-ukrainian war about nuclear weapons. he spoke today about what if us no one will interfere and our interests will not be affected, we will not use it only for protection, but two months ago, the now deceased prigozhin, the leader of the criminal group, wagner, spoke about the possibility of using nuclear weapons by the russians on their own territory, and this week about this tv presenter, or rather, propagandist - simanyan also stated, she said that a nuclear strike could be carried out on siberia. shall we hear what they said? they will throw a large bomb on their territory. it's scary to throw at someone else's, but i'll throw at my own, let's show what kind of mentally ill handsome men we are. if

a pro-nuclear explosion, for example , a nuclear explosion, is carried out hundreds of kilometers away, on our territory, somewhere over siberia, then nothing will happen on earth, nothing so terrible, not nuclear earth, which everyone is afraid of. or the monstrous radiation that will kill everyone, kill everyone around, those who are not killed will die within 10 years from oncology, it will not do anything, but what will happen, it will disable all radio electronics, all digital, all satellites, everything , we will be back with you at some point ninety-third, corded telephones, two-wire, or not two-wire, i don't remember, was in the telephone machine. i'll tell you, they lived wonderfully, they lived wonderfully - says simonyan, well, it's a madhouse, it's just that they either play the role of madmen, they

simply don't have another role now, because they have nowhere to retreat , but does the world take into account such statements? because, well, as they say, what is on the mind of a sober person, is on the tongue of a drunk, well, the same. you can say exactly what is on putin's mind, what is on simonyan's tongue, or, is it possible to ask the question like that, well, you see, mr. sergey, here is a question indeed, socio-psychopathic, i would say so, because, a society that looks at the past , it is sick, it is sick by its definition, that is, we can have, our... view of the past, take into account, the past and positives and negatives, learn from your past, but still develop , in the direction of the future, because well, this is objective, the course of history, each

generation takes a step forward relative to the previous one, and this is correct, this is how all civilizations live, except for the russian one, they defined themselves as a separate civilization. civilization sorry for the words, moron who wants to return from the future to the past, and this is what we are now hearing from this propagandist and not only from her, by the way , now there in moscow they are howling about her in a way that i don't know anymore, i guess they exaggerate the wail of sirens, air alarm, because they are already declaring her a traitor, i don't want her anymore. to kill, to quarter, well, in one word, there is also such a thing, but if we take it as a whole, then this is a society that lives in its past, that lives, that wants to go

back, because there are these double-edged swords for them more important than, than, a look into the future, so, well, here, you understand, again a clinical case, but not in relation to their führer there, but in relation to, er, the whole system, which was formed into which, again, not in the last 20 years , this is our, in my opinion, a huge mistake when we say that here, now putin came and did it, yes, no, it began to form from the ulus of the golden horde, from the 13th century, when the foundations of the worldview of this population were laid, and it there are no changes, it has not changed during these centuries, which, if we count from the same 12th century, and we must understand that they do not think differently there, this is the algorithm by which they live, and the only hope is that when this structure finally collapses, that those peoples who

will have the ability to start life in a new way, regardless of this moscow tyranny , will gradually start through, again , not through switching off, the light bulb. and after a generation to return and come to a normal life, that is the only hope. mr. volodymyr, during the last few days, the world has been reacting and reflecting on the decision of the congress of the united states of america, regarding temporary budgeting for the next 45 days, where there is no financial , additional financial assistance to ukraine, then a change of the speaker, parliament... or even the lower house of congress, kevin mccarthy, and everyone is now waiting for a speech, biden and a public speech, because we know that before this is what he said in a telephone conversation

with his partners, both in nato and in the european union, and representatives of the european union were in this conversation, he explained his position regarding the future, support for ukraine and the white house press secretary, or the spokeswoman of the white house home, karin johnpierre said at a briefing that there will be a special address, and biden will explain to the american. people and the us congress, how important it is to continue providing financial and security assistance to ukraine, zelensky, when asked if he was concerned about news from the united states of america regarding aid to ukraine, answered yes. as for the united states, i was in washington this year and i had a meeting with president

biden, and i heard his 100 percent support of the white house, and bipartisan support in congress, i think that's important. of course, a difficult election period for the united states, different voices, some voices are very strange. mr. volodymyr, how do you assess the current situation in the congress of the united states of america, of course, now they will obviously have an election for the speaker. house of representatives, and obviously, these elections will drag on, because we see that the votes that were against kevin mccarthy were the votes of both democrats and republicans, and here the question is who will replace him now, because then everything will depend, in including from the speaker, house of representatives, because he is the third person in

united states of america by importance. you see, mr. serhiy, i think that, well, we don't need to fall even before the shot, because already today, everywhere you look, you hear everything, betrayal, the end, we won't have help and so on, well, at least as of today, if american sources are to be believed, there are still... a few billion dollars in aid, well , if we are now receiving tranches of 300, 400 , 500 million, then let's count how many more tranches are ahead and how much they may be enough. second, if biden says that we will continue the aid, then believe me, he will find opportunities for this aid to be even in the event of a hypothetical delay in the process, adoption of the budget and

so on, but i say hypothetical, because, well, that would mean a really, well, serious threat to the stability of the american, of the state, the american system of democracy, so for some reason it seems to me that even if a new speaker will be elected quickly or not quickly during these days? both republicans and democrats, well, at least those parts of the us political establishment that think about security and, perspective for their state, they cannot allow such a situation that the state apparatus is not financed , the armed forces are not financed, special services are not financed, social programs are not financed, and so on, and so on, and so on,

i.e. that is, i think that in 40 days, probably, because several days have already passed, the americans will have a new budget, and in this budget , funds will certainly be allocated to help ukraine, today, politically, so to speak, thinking america cannot refuse aid to ukraine, yes, there is this, nuclear... electorate of trumpists, these are, well, actually textbook populists, liars and so on, there are not many of them, they are called there from the eight most ardent to 20, 20 there eight, which, if they are about to put them all together, but excuse me, the republicans in the congress, in my opinion, are 221, that is, if so, then these are actually

different orders of numbers, and i think that among the rest of the republicans there will be adequate politicians who will put the interests of america first, and not trump with his terry populism, what is at real risk stability of america, against the background of this, mr. volodymyr, the president of mexico called on the americans not to squander, as he said, money on ukraine, to give more money to latin america, and they... say that it is the president who says lopez obrador that it is irrational that we should give more money to latin america, we see how the president of slovakia, zuzana čaputova , after the new parliament was elected in

slovakia, she says that for now we will not send additional military aid to ukraine, saying will be formed government. then we will see, we know that the majority in the parliamentary elections in slovakia was gathered by the pro-moscow party headed by sfitso, the former prime minister of slovakia, and we can see how opinion is formed in the world, how this opinion arises, that everyone is already tired from the war in ukraine, that how much ukrainians can be helped, that it is time to sit down at the negotiating table, somehow talk there with the russian federation. next year, elections in germany and france, and also the question of who, who will come to power there and what kind of rhetoric will be in your opinion, like this general, global, such a trend, which is set there, mexico

, slovakia, it is clear that these are not the countries of the wrong caliber that can solve something, but at least they can set or at least articulate. a question about, listen, how much can we already help ukraine, let's help us already , well, mr. serhiu, this is the typical approach of good countries that want to stop, so to speak, the direction of aid from one country to another, but i think that these appeals are, well, very naive, and it is unlikely that anyone will respond to them to pay attention, well, with regard to mexico, really, these trumpists, you see, they justify the need to refuse aid to ukraine by the fact that another group of 10,000 legal migrants broke through the border, so strengthen the border, make sure that they do not break through, and here one thing after another, and

the mexican president definitely wants to get additional billions, and i think he knows how to dispose of them. regarding our closest friends in slovakia, you know, i think it is still too early to draw any conclusions, yes, madam president said about what she seems to want to suspend, but immediately acting as prime minister said that our support for ukraine will remain obvious and unwavering, we do not yet know, by the way, how the formal negotiations on the creation of a coalition will go and whether they will want to other political forces to join this coalition with the clearly anti-european and pro-moscow pitso, that is, it is also an open question, uh, further, this

same slovakia and the same hungary, these are very seriously integrated into the european union and nato countries, and and they like it or not, a will be forced to stick to some common direction, both the european union and nato. and this common direction, this monday was demonstrated by all the ministers of legal affairs of the european union who came to kyiv, and if piss wants it or orban wants it, he can, he can, well, you know, poke around, but in a small way, big will not work. because there is a common european foreign and security policy and no one will escape from and and nowhere from this submarine, neither orbán nor possible fiso, so i don't think we need now it is a problem to do this, so it must be taken into account, so it must be taken into account

, so it is necessary to look for regular and new arguments and, er , evidence that the policy of supporting moscow is business... the policy is absurd and anti-european and so on and so on. so we need to de-use statements of this type, of the type that was made today by the former president of eurokisia junker, who began to pour water on the moscow mill, accusing the entire ukrainian society of total corruption and so on and so forth, but for some reason, i forgot to say about my... friendship with putin that he very er, when he was the president of the european commission, er, as they say, not er, very... chose words of love and friendship regarding putin and the russian federation and so

so on and so forth, which raises legitimate questions, is it just like that, or is it possible that they are starting to deconcern him, so this is all true, but i think that there is no need to draw any additional negative conclusions from this, i think that the united states and the european union will continue our support, because if we lose, they lose. today the president volodymyr zelenskyi of ukraine is participating in the european political summit of the european political community , which is taking place in the city of granada, in a spanish place, and zelenskyi said that if the war in ukraine is frozen, then in 2028 russia can attack and other countries and told about the war scenarios being prepared in

the russian federation, let's listen to zelensky. russia is currently considering various scenarios for the coming years. one of them is particularly dangerous. if there is any pause, any freeze in this aggression against ukraine situation, there will be a new critical moment. the year 2028, if russia is allowed to adapt now, by the 28th year the kremlin will be able to restore the military potential we have broken, and russia will have enough power to attack the countries that are the focus of russian expansion, except for ukraine, these are precisely the baltic countries, and precisely those countries , on the territory of which russian contingents are present. this is clear information from our intelligence. mr. volodymyr. zelensky refers to ukrainian intelligence data. at the same time, representatives of western countries

say that weapons that were russia's great invasion of ukraine is gradually running out, well, at least, the representatives of great britain say that, in principle, we provide a lot of weapons and give a lot of help to the ukrainian state, but there are some passports that are inviolable in these countries. in your opinion, does it take into account the possibility that russia could still start a war against the north, the countries of the north atlantic alliance, because even before the beginning of the great invasion of ukraine, some experts were skeptical about such a possibility, because it was difficult to imagine that after the bloody second world war. will the next bloody war in europe be

russia's war against ukraine? well, you see, mr. serhiy, i simply cannot even think about it, but if i stand aside and simply theorize, in the event of ukraine’s defeat, putin will perceive it as an invitation to war against, against everyone, so in this case in this case, we must very clearly imagine that if putin reaches the ukrainian-polish border or the ukrainian-romanian border, then they will be next, there is no one, no doubt, and then he will have a strategic, psychological, and any other advantage over nato, because the defeat of ukraine will mean the defeat of nato, therefore we cannot and do not have the right

to lose, and so will nato and the us has no right to lose this war, because i think that even if we imagine that in some countries , other governments come to power, maybe not so determined, one way or another, the instinct of self-preservation will force them to make decisions that will be beneficial. and for them, and for ukraine, because otherwise the situation for them will be real, very very dramatic. zelenskyi mentioned the possibility or the probability that there will be a freeze in the war between russia and ukraine. the minister of defense of italy crozetto said that the conditions for negotiations between ukraine and the russian federation may appear in the spring of next year. i will quote crosetto. i think the next one. may be the time when both sides exhaust their resources to achieve a breakthrough, which could

open up an attempt at dialogue, and crosetto also suggested that this is a likely russian response to the current ukrainian counteroffensive, the italians, they have always been more sympathetic to, moscow, am i wrong, and related to this is the statement of the italian minister of defense, do you agree with what crosetto is saying about the possibility of some kind of dialogue, peaceful dialogue, you know , it's so much more. it seems, well, if we take ukrainian folk wisdom, as it is written with pitchforks on water, well, we don't know what will happen in two weeks, and how fast ukraine's advances will be, both in the south and in the east, so, well, i don't know, on on what sources and facts does

the honorable minister of defense of italy rely on, i think that it would be good if he would think about something else, about what else italy can transfer to ukraine, and in this case, if he does it, and on behalf of italy, stimulates his nato colleagues, then maybe , in the spring, when, thanks to such help, the ukrainian army will expel the russian occupiers from ukrainian land, perhaps after that , after the fall of putin's regime, and ukrainian post-russian negotiations will take place with those who will then reorganize this territory, and we will then, i think, with great pleasure invite to these negotiations and minister of defense of italy. along with the possible or probable negotiations, there should also be talk of compensation by russia for the damage

caused by putin's army to the ukrainian army. the state now has 300 billion dollars frozen in the united states of america and the united states of america is working with european partners to create, as anthony blinken said, the necessary legal framework for using the confiscated assets of the russian federation to restore ukraine. let's hear what anthony blinken had to say. in my opinion, if you hacked something, then pay, and if the russians hacked, they have to pay for it, and one of the ways to do that is through these assets, we have to make sure that there is a legal basis for that. as i noted, since most of these assets are in europe, europeans must also be convinced that there is a legal basis for this. blinkin

tries to appeal to international law, blinkin tries to... speak the language of the civilized world, putin speaks the language of a completely different world, which is opposed to modern civilization, although putin constantly says that they are some kind of civilization there, is it worth talking with russia and with putin in the language of jurisprudence, that is, talking about the fact that we have 300 billion, well, we will see if we can legally conduct it and understand it, can we give this money to ukraine, which suffered from the aggression of the russian federation, or is it possible that we need to speak with russia in a completely different way, in the language of force and not in the language of diplomacy and lawyers, well , you see, mr. serhiy, the western world is built on respect for the law, and i can

understand, and mr. blinken and others, high-ranking officials both in america and in europe, who say that we must do everything based and exclusively based on the norms of our law, if there is no such law, let's create it, but we cannot act like bandits with a wide road, this is the prerogative of putin and his henchmen, that is why the process, the actual agreement, between the americans, the europeans, within the european union itself, how to do it correctly, is taking so long, some countries, such as estonia, for example, have already adopted the relevant legislation, and now they can, they can calmly do what is actually needed, in some other countries this process continues, but we are back again, why is it taking so long, well, because lawyers never