[000:00:00;00] everything, that is, for example, the belief that vaccination helps people, that is, they undermined just the foundations of, well, let's say , just simply rational thinking as such in the world, but at the same time, if we take pro-russian narratives, it is also, for example, dostoevsky's, it also turgenev, this is russian literature with its nihilism, with its disbelief in man's ability to resist evil, for example, or with its glorification to a certain extent of evil, even, its seductive power, and evil, i don't know, here is hermann hesen, for example, one of those writers who mastered this one excessive enthusiasm for russian literature and this motive, for example, is ukraine too, and we, as those who know russian literature very well, and also know the russians themselves well, can also be an alternative voice here, you know, this topic, by

the way, it sounds regularly now in europe as well. and in america, the theme of the influence of russian classical literature on the worldview and behavior of russians, on the mentality, that is, nihilism and fatalism, which were preached by dostoevsky and other writers, they are the reason why that in russia, there is no opposition, no protests, and even those russians who left russia as a sign of protest. they are not demonstrating against the war in berlin, they are demonstrating in support of putin. er, and here for me the most important thing is that this virus of fatalism and nihilism, er, it er, did not get into the cities of ukrainians, that is, fatalism for ukraine is a foreign, alien phenomenon,

a foreign thought, and that is why ukrainians were not afraid to go out on the maidan and that is why we have, i would say, a civil society more powerful, er than the political elite, and practically civil society decides what to do, and then forces, er, when it succeeds, the political elite to do what the society orders, there is still one moment left, but for me, too, i think he is important this is a question of who speaks today on behalf of ukraine, and you know, it's just with the athletes , they showed the best results, they went to the olympics there at the end of the year, everything is clear here, we may not like something further there, there are not enough tendrils, then some were pro-patriotic and so on, he didn’t come out with that olets on his head, but the question of who represents ukraine in the cultural field is also to a certain extent simpler than it is, for example, who goes to head

embassies somewhere there, well, but we’ll leave it at that aside, if we talk about this moment, there are also criteria, these are criteria, how many of your books have been published, in particular, how many invitations you receive from international organizations, institutions, and one way or another you represent ukraine today and represent it, i am sure well, although many believe that for example, your conversation with heson was complementary enough because someone wanted more flesh and blood in this conversation, probably, probably, uh, me, but the question is , really, i don't want to, if it were me they took it as a bad thing, what is called, what i will say now, sometime in the 90s, ukraine decided that a ukrainian writer can write in russian, but be a ukrainian writer, and in this category, this means that, for example, andriy korkov is ukrainian writer and remains a ukrainian

writer. and for example, here in lviv igor kleh, who was also a good writer, and i read him in ukrainian, by the way, in yevshan zilla, when i was still a student in this legendary almanac, which was already very much worn out, which kolintsy once published, he was translated, some of his works were translated, but he has now become a member of the pen center of russia, and he lives in russia , in moscow, it is about the fact that we made such a choice, we made a much wider frame of what it is, what it means to be ukrainian, we greatly expanded this frame and we understood that it means to be ukrainian, first of all it is a political nation, yes, but there is also a certain one, we can see in zelenskyi, for example, an example when president zelenskyi has evolved very, very much in literally three years, his statements about the difference between the way he appears in front of tv cameras today, this is very big, a great, great step forward, and

each of us, probably, has walked some great path. i remember in the early 2000s, i read your interview, it seems to the austrian focus, where are you, where the journalist asked you, what does this trident mean? no, it was even earlier than that means the trident on the coat of arms of ukraine and you laughed with him that no one knows in the end, it's something like a fork, the question is, uh, how do we all change ourselves, uh, can we have some kind of unified narrative that means interest of ukraine, what does it ultimately mean for you to be ukrainian, to represent ukraine in one way or another somehow on the international arena, for me it means first of all to explain, especially now to a foreign audience, the history of this more than three-year war, that is, in principle, to explain that ukraine was

independent, that ukraine was democratic, when russia was an empire that ukrainian culture and ukrainian classical literature were not published abroad. we didn't know about it, it existed, it existed, and that , in fact, meletius smotrytskyi and his trenos are the same european literature as goethe and the works of german ancient philosophers, that is, in principle, my mission is more enlightening, although i i also try to collect money for humanitarian aid to ukraine when i can. and i accept invitations to almost any conversations, discussions, conferences where you can speak about ukraine and explain why

ukraine is worth knowing much more about it than is known now, nevertheless, it is now its own ukrainian mission, nevertheless, i will ask myself, for you personally, what it means to be ukrainian, until recently some people believed that that it is enough to correctly answer the question whose crimea is, or is that enough today, to be ukrainian, it is, first of all, to pay taxes in ukraine, to have a ukrainian passport, to respect this passport and to be proud that you are a citizen of ukraine, to know the history of ukraine, to know support the ukrainian language ukrainian culture and now especially to support the armed forces, what a great answer , thank you very much, mr. andriy, andriy kurkov, a ukrainian writer, was with us today, thank you for watching this conversation, stay tuned to the espresso tv channel. ukraine is football,

our national team personifies the hopes and pride of ukrainians. espresso tv channel together with vibet recalled 10 significant milestones in the history of ukrainian football. there is a key moment in the project. the premium sponsor of the national team represents the stronger united by football. the national team of ukraine went to the first victories in official matches for three long years. this time became a real test for the yellow-blue brigade. it did not have a permanent composition, it changed often. there was not enough money to pay for the flights. after the collapse of the soviet union, russia actively lured ukrainians to its team. many football players did not want to lose several years of their career, chose other national teams or simply ended their careers without waiting for official

matches. viktor onopko, andrii kanchelskis, serhiy yuran, yuriy nikifororov, oleg salenko, ilya tsimbalar and dozens of other soviet football players from ukraine, who grew up in an international country, were faced with a choice, for which. in russia, traitors were paid a lot of money, they were convinced that the ukrainian national team is not serious, many stars succumbed to persuasion, but oleg kuznetsov and oleksiy mykhalychenko, who also played in the so-called cis national team at the european championship 92, refused the russians. i was already 29, a conscious age, we did not need any benefits, your homeland is ukraine, your relatives live here, i had no thoughts of changing something, moving to moscow, i immediately refused, said that it is unacceptable for us. meanwhile, the ukrainian national team played friendly matches and even made two foreign trips. to the united states and south korea. in our team, the coaches changed like the prime ministers of the government in the difficult 90s. valery

lobanovsky worked in the emirates and kuwait, and the ukrainian national team was alternately led by the duo of mykola pavlov and leonid tkachenko. oleg vasylevich, duet pavlov and volodymyr muntyan. only in the fall of 1994, ukraine began its first qualification for euro-1996 and got into a group with croatia, italy, lithuania, estonia and slovenia. the selection of the national team opened unexpectedly in kyiv. lost to lithuania 0:2. on the eve of the game, there was an unfortunate embarrassment when the players of dynamo kyiv were not allowed to attend the training session of the number one team. i had to play without them. then there was a draw with slovenia 0:0 and another change of coach. the legendary józef szabo led the national team to the match against estonia. he returned dynamo players to the national team, adjusted the team, and it was he who went down in history as the first coach to win the national team of ukraine in official matches. they witnessed the victory soon spectators who, despite the initial failure

of the 4° frost team, came to the olympic games in kyiv on november 13, 1994. in the first half , serhii konovalo, dynamo, took over the game and put the ball in the nine. subsequently, the cross of the star gennady lytovchenko locked the defender of estonians in his own goal. in the second half, tamerlan huseinov scored a solo. he turned around the wall, entered the penalty area and left no chance to the goalkeeper of the estonian national team. it was a spectacular point of the first victory. ukrainians completed that selection for the euro on an unusual fourth place today, surpassing even lithuania. the stars of the 80s kuznetsov, luzhnyi and lytovchenko still played in that national team, the stars of the 90s, huseynov, kovolets, skachenko, shone, and the stars of the 2000s oleksandr shovkovskyi and serhii rebrov shone. the victory over estonia in 1994 proved that our national team recovered from football shock and broke into football. with a completely different generation.

the premium sponsor of the national team represents: united by football, stronger together. there are discounts on... 10% in pharmacies psarynyk, bam and oschad, there are discounts on orasept spray 20% in pharmacies, plantain, bam and savings. there is a war going on, and not only for territories, it is also a war for minds. russia is throwing millions of petrodollars into turning ukrainians into little russians. ukraine will become russia. parsing and analysis of information. about ukraine by russian propagandists,

specific facts and methods by which enemy propaganda turns people into obedient zombies. residents of the ldnr plan to vote for the historic reunification. let's counter the information attacks of the russians in the project chronicles of the information war with olga len. tuesday, thursday-friday at 17:10 on espresso tv channels. with you. portnikov and we talk about the main events of this week. vitaly portnikov and top experts about the most vivid events of the last seven days. our guest will be lieutenant general of the ground forces, former national security advisor to the president of the united states, donald trump, herbert mcmaster. current topics, pressing questions, authoritative comments and forecasts in the information marathon project with vitaly portnikov, every sunday at

20:10 on espresso. air of vasyl zimi, two hours of air time, two hours of your time, two hours to learn about the war and what the world is like, two hours to keep up with economic news and sports news, two hours in the company of your favorite presenters, presenters who have become familiar to many, as well as distinguished guests of the studio, the events of the day in two hours, vasyl zima's big broadcast, a project for smart and caring people, in the evening. on espresso. wars, what do you want to do first? after the war. so. the most important thing is to come home. and there will already be work, family, there is, to go on vacation, the family ruslan, an infantryman, a grenade launcher, worked as a quarry foreman before the full-scale invasion. after that, he served in the engineering and sapper regiment, from where he transferred to the 31st mechanized brigade. took part in battles in chernihiv oblast. last year he fought near

bakhmut, in the 23rd year he received a shrapnel wound in his arm and a contusion in donetsk region. in staromarsk, the enemy covered mines, after the wound he was treated for the second month. naturally, there is a family, a wife, children, and i have my boys, you will not leave as long as i have health, it will be ready for now, as long as i have health, that i will recover, and go back to them, to the boys, to support and finish already. these pigs to the pen, so that they no longer exist, expel them from our country. the husband has three daughters who are schoolgirls, so he often hears why you don’t know ... i always have a wife, you have three children, you can leave here and there, especially since they are adults, no, not yet, while you , for now, all this nonsense is here, i understand that it is difficult for her, that she wants me to be at home, but i

made a choice for myself, for the time being , there are many people like me, who have a family, four, five, six children, they are all there. hamlet is almost 58. previously, he was engaged in business in the field of building materials and agricultural machinery. after the invasion, he went to the assembly center, ended up in the 115th brigade of tro. the man has health problems, so he is being treated and waiting for an operation. after that, he expects to return to the army, he has three children and three grandchildren who have not left ukraine. so, he says, there is someone to protect. i think that each of us will be where they go. more brutal battles, the guys over there were already there, they need to be changed, later that they are tired already, if you take it so honestly, really every one, every ukrainian , i think that it will come, it's their turn to be there, in the medical rehabilitation department of the korostyna district

hospital, 37-year-old ihor, a local man, due to a chest injury has problems with his hand, after treatment he will return to service... as a rifleman, in the 72nd brigade , 20-21 years old, well, it was a one-year contract, we were in avdiivka, i was only there, yes, for nine months, i am not the same i took part in the battles themselves, i am a military cook, well, well, they stood on zero there, yes, i did everything myself, well, the guys there helped me, and i had 30 men, the physical assistant ms. marina notes the positive dynamics of the treatment. the main problem with them is the back, because it is the load on the back for most. there are soldiers who, after being wounded, it is more difficult there, because they have already been damaged by other things, by fragments, for example, muscle damage somewhere, there

they need to be stretched, because some area is missing, and again to stimulate them, pump them up for that the function... in the body. advocates from different parts of ukraine come to this medical rehabilitation department. boys are often affected in the postoperative period. most of them are landmine injuries. many guys are depressed. many boys have disorders after a concussion. here, a multidisciplinary team works. yes, during this year , about two hundred defenders from zhytomyr oblast received help here, yuliya sinelnikova, vitaly sinilnikov for the tv channel. see this week in the program judicial control with tatyana shustrova. agents of change, such as vovka and yanukovych's people, ended up in the competition commission

of the constitutional court. this is the worst candidate ever. volodymyr kuzmenko is directly vovka's man. but how will the european commission evaluate such a judicial reform? reform of the constitution. court was once again under threat. congratulations, you are watching judicial control and i am tetyana shustrova. last year, in june, ukraine received the status of a candidate for membership in the european union, subject to the fulfillment of seven steps, the key of which is the implementation of judicial reform and reform constitutional court. and if the judicial reform is slowly but surely moving forward, the reform of the constitutional court is already under threat. the council of judges elected a person from the entourage of the odious and scandalous chairman of the liquidating oask, pavlo vovka, as well as a henchman of the fugitive president, viktor yanukovych, to the competition commission that will appoint judges of the constitutional court.

we will talk about these ambiguous decisions today. but first to the news. the northern commercial court of appeal satisfied several complaints of the plaintiffs in the case of bilotserkivska prava investors and of the newly appointed director of the company ihor vegularny were violated due to the decision of the judge of the commercial court of kyiv region pavlo gorbasenko. judges pakhs demydova, khodakivska and vladimirenko overturned gorbasenko's decision and allowed tets and vegularny shareholders to participate in the case. previously, the head of the economic court of the kyiv region, pavlo gorbasenko, was scandalized because of an unjust decision that had signs of raiding. on july 25 , the judge granted the application to secure the claim of the former manager of bilotserkivska of vadym bohdan's thermal power plant, who... 20 months later decided to appeal the decision of the company's shareholders' meeting. with his ruling , judge gorbasenko suspended all decisions

of jsc meetings, including those that did not concern bohdan. shareholders emphasize that gorbasenko's resolution has signs of raiding, because the decisions of the meeting were made on 19 issues. in addition, the economic procedural code of ukraine does not provide for such a means of securing a claim as suspending the effect of decisions of shareholders' meetings. so it looks like judge gorbasenko used his powers for the sake of it interference in the implementation of the economic activities of the newly elected supervisory board of the thermal power plant, so that it could not work and appoint the head of the company, because gorbasenko also forbade making changes to the register. from the decision of the judge of the commercial court of the kyiv region, pavlo gorbasenko. take security measures by banning state registrars, notaries, the ministry of justice of ukraine and other bodies. or to persons who perform functions in the field of state registration, to carry out registration actions regarding at bilotserkivska teploelektrotsentral, and

namely: to make changes to the information about the head of the legal entity, about other persons who can act on behalf of the legal entity. having received a lawsuit after taking such security, on august 8 gorbasenko decided to recall the law and left bohdan's statement of claim motionless, demanding written explanations from him as to which rights of the plaintiff were violated in part of the stated claim, considering that at the extraordinary meeting it was adopted decision on 19 issues, although bohdan, judge gorbasenko, should be asked about it had before issuing the decree on security, therefore the previous decision of the judge remains in force, and the rights of shareholders are violated. now, thanks to gorbasenko's decision, the plaintiff bohdan is suing the defendant atbtets, which will be represented in court by bohdan himself, or by a lawyer hired by him, who will probably recognize such a claim, while judge gorbasenko's ruling on securing the claim without taking into account the interests of the shareholders and without their involvement

demonstrates that the judge will consider the case without their participation. shareholders are convinced, all this is done in order to continue to embezzle the company, accumulate its debts and remove the shareholders and the legally elected bodies of the company from managing its activities, prevent the shareholders from putting things in order and bring the culprits to justice. because of such court decisions, no joint-stock company in ukraine can feel safe, and the rights of shareholders can be protected. we will remind you that the trials regarding atbc have been ongoing since 2021, and this is not the first questionable decision of judge gorbasenko in this case. previously , the public council of integrity and journalists drew attention to the judge's property, which cannot be explained by official income, as well as his possible fictitious divorce with the alleged purpose of hiding the state. naboud, together with the sbu, exposed the judge of the brovary city district court , volodymyr serdynskyi, for taking bribes

of usd 400. according to the investigation, the judge received a bribe from a representative of one of the parties in a civil case for making a decision in her interests. he received a part of the unlawful benefit in the amount of 1 thousand dollars earlier, when the decision on extermination was made evidence in the case. while receiving a friend. part of the funds in the amount of 3,000 dollars for the debt collection decision in favor of the plaintiff serdynskyi was hotly exposed by nabu detectives. the sbu added that during the search , $15,600 packed in different envelopes was seized from the suspected judge. the president delays the appointment of a member of the vrp according to his quota. back in april, the competitive commission for the selection of candidates for the position of a member of the people's party of ukraine sent to volodymyr zelennyam. list of recommended candidates for the vacant position. however, it is already october, and there are still no appointments.

then, a few days ago, on october 3 , the mandate of another member of the vrp, according to the president's quota, oksana blazhivska, expired. new candidates for appointment will also be recommended for her position. a somewhat similar situation existed earlier. in 2020, when the previous supreme council of justice was being formed, the president had to appoint two members of the supreme judicial council according to his quota. the president then announced a competition for two vacant positions, a number of winners were selected, the president appointed only one member of the supreme council of justice, announced a new competition, a new commission, and another person was already appointed to the new vacancy. tetyana rozvalyaeva is known for actually leaving the kharkiv agreements in force, that is, the agreement on the extension of the black sea fleet's stay in crimea. up to the 1940s, which were signed in kharkiv at one time by yanukovych and representatives of the aggressor state.

experts of the deure foundation insist, while the supreme council. overloaded with thousands of complaints, and the eu is waiting for us to launch the vrp with a new composition, such a delay is unacceptable. already this month, the european commission will provide a new one assessment of ukraine's implementation of european integration recommendations. what kind of characteristic will we get, taking into account the fact that judicial reform is a key requirement on the path of ukraine's accession to the eu, and it is progressing sluggishly. judge's council. elected volodymyr kuzmenko, a person from the entourage of the odious and scandalous head of the liquidation oask, pavlo vovka, to the competitive commission that will appoint judges of the constitutional court, as well as the henchman of the fugitive president viktor yanukovych, yaroslav romanyuk, the former head of the supreme court. in 2017, being as a candidate for the post of judge of the constitutional court, romanyuk received a negative opinion

from the public council of integrity, in particular because he supported the current dictatorial laws on january 16 during the revolution of dignity. during the euromaidan events, romanyuk was very worried about the protection of the judges, but not so much about the mass arbitrary decisions they made against the participants of the protests. he did not speak about them in any way. during the meeting of the council of judges , romaniuk said that it was a mistake, while he believed that the courts were outside politics in his speech before the council of judges, romanyuk also... mentioned judicial reform, according to the analysis of public organizations , these are the worst candidates there were, he received a negative opinion from the public integrity council in the competition for the supreme court of the new, so-called, and then withdrew from competition as a result, this did not prevent him from being elected to this position by the board of judges. as romanyuk's deputy, the council of judges chose an equally odious candidate, volodymyr

kuzmenko, who appears on vovka's tapes. on at the meeting, he stated that he could not comment on events in which he was not a participant, kuzmenko also denied that the tapes were about him and did not admit that his voice was on the recordings. volodymyr kuzmenko is directly a wolf man, as can be seen from their films and not only from these films, it all shows how rotten and inadequate the council of judges is today with its leadership, which was put there, also pavlo the wolf, by the way, about this in the investigation of journalists of the investigation of information, it is necessary to very actively monitor what i will... do these delegates for an appeal to the current group of experts on the selection of judges of the constitutional court, but it is also necessary to carefully review what the council of judges does, its composition and, in general, whether it is necessary or not necessary for the current judicial system of ukraine. interestingly, the council of judges did not rate candidate mykola gimon, a patriot who made pro-ukrainian decisions in donetsk in 2014.

the members of the council of judges gave the hymn zero votes. experts of the foundation warn if the ukrainian composition of the relevant group of experts will have odious representatives of dubious reputation, and not real agents of change, we will have every chance to fail the judicial reform, which is unacceptable on ukraine's path to the european union. for today, i have everything, it was judicial control and i, tetyana shustrova. if you know the facts of corruption in the judicial system. of ukraine, or you want to talk about an unscrupulous judge, write to me on facebook or to the e-mail address, the address of which you now see on your screens. see you

in exactly one week. good bye. in ukraine at 5 p.m., for your attention, a news release on the espresso tv channel, in iryna's studio koval, all viewers, another russian shelling of the kherson region, an 11-year-old girl was injured due to an attack on the village of kindiyka. earlier, berislav came under enemy fire. a 72-year-old man got the train. the kherson regional military administration reported that there was a hit near the church in kherson as well. two elderly women were injured. they have minor injuries. in total