[000:00:00;00] creation of the state of israel, we see how many, very controversial decades took place there, and now, for example , a lot, including among democratic countries, including such democratic tools for contact as the same ex-twitter, which for there is a social network, a mask, which today is the foundation for spreading messages, what do you see, in 1948, israel began aggression, allegedly, and look how unhappy palestine is now, well, that is, we see, in principle, now this issue is exclusively to those standards to the values ​​that are guided by citizens in general , or subjects all over the world, it doesn't matter if your country is a republic or a monarchy, but if they start justifying

open aggression... and an open attack by terrorists, hamas on the state, israel, on civilians, then what started to happen from the 7th, correspondingly, in their october, of course, we no longer see here a reaction to a specific case, but all these layers, this whole ten-year, there 50-year and so on, and so on, retrospect in the minds of people, is not present today in the world of a single understanding. when the un was created , including, by the way, the state of israel, we understand that this is as one of the consequences of the second world war, as a result of the same holocaust that was taking place, it was actually the duty of the civilized world to provide such a piece of land

, respectively, for the jewish people, and thus we see today that even the created system led by , this polarization, well a multipolar world, indeed, it is formed precisely at the level of values, and this is the biggest problem, because the stratification is not only there on the basis of religion, religion in general is happening in our country now, well, you know, we see that it is a tool for various terrorist organizations, recruit the most radical persons, it does not matter whether it is islam, and what we see now there with hamas, whether it is the russian orthodox church, we see what is happening in russia, here the question is not a specific religion, in religion as a tool, plus again economy, economy very

does a lot, today and it is clear that who pressed the last button, what about burning this particular war in israel, i think it is precisely those forces that wanted to raise the price of oil above 100 dollars per barrel as soon as possible, those that wanted to disrupt the new transport corridor from india, respectively, through the same israel to the european union , that is, we already see different readings of the economy, and in fact, in fact, today it is all superimposed on different... helite vision, we do not ba, you know, this is the impression that the united states still continues to live in in the post-soviet period, are trying to be the leaders of the western world, of course together with the european union, with great britain , and other countries today are trying to use all the weaknesses in order to redistribute this influence, and we see it today at the level of the global south, and

indeed all this today it actually rests on not even competition, this is already true , this is a duel between democracy and autocracy today, what we started with, and this is really a huge risk, because you know, if we did not have nuclear weapons in the world, then this one thing, but as we see that certain players who want revenge constantly raise this mace and this boot, what about nuclear weapons, and here the question is not even only in russia, because we also see the same north korea, which contributed in our legislation, a direct requirement to have such nuclear weapons, and this is really the biggest problem , because we are from this, not even a discussion, but a polemic regarding civilizational approaches, we are already going to the issue of security, security of the whole world, and this is the biggest today, well, an extremely dangerous situation for us and the following generations, because

we do not see this stop and what is happening with... today in ukraine , of course, this demonstrates the general level, the general level, you know, such an average temperature in the ward, this ambiguous perception in the world, but if in israel today you can still argue, say, well, maybe israel is somewhere innocent, somewhere guilty, somewhere or something else, well, there can be different situations, if even on the case of ukraine today there is no single understanding, then today it is a diagnosis for everything world order and says that well if the old one no longer works, then we must evolve to something new, but not what they need today, they cannot see the new, you know, there are such words in the bible, my people are dying because of a lack of vision, vision has no future, i have there is an impression that these people do not have, they are not able to create a vision of the future, you know, there was such a king david, who actually conquered sinai there with his own, avner and this group

that he gathered in the adalam desert among bandits, criminals there, gathered an army , took sinai, but when, but built up israel and made him rich that even the queen of shevska herself said that i came to see the wisdom but this was created by solomon. david could not create a rich israel, well he, he acquired it in blood there with all its disadvantages, but solomon created it. in the same way, here now there is an impression that there are no people who can see the future, what the new world should be like. and you know, the most terrible thing here is that we are now talking about democracy, about dictatorship, but it is banal, well, the war in syria started because there were also threats to russia, in particular, regarding the gas route through syria, well, let's start a war there, well, yes, here are the saudis again. arabia, israel, well, i understand, through jordan, the oil corridor, yes, let's start a war in israel, ukraine, they found a lot of rare earth metals, which are very necessary for the development of modern many devices, even more than in china, reserves of rare earth metals can be in ukraine, why

don't we seize the south of ukraine, where it all lies, and you understand that, well, you know, it's disgusting what you're looking at, and it's banal, it's money, well, the opening of america, the destruction of the indians is money, the campaigns of christ are money, this is a res. and you understand that all these things that stand under the banner of faith, democracy or dictatorship, allah or someone else, some values, basically you understand that it is just money and resources as an opportunity to control the world, so how to do that, that after all, even despite all these negatives, well, these ideas were there somewhere, because when people perceive the growing of people in buch or in mariupol as normal, and they also perceive the shooting of people in israel as normal in the south, in the south of israel in these kibbutzim and at this festival, well then, then it no longer matters, then democracy as a civilization, then why is it, it must remain in the hearts of people, how to preserve it, the most important thing, well, obviously,

that you really paid attention correctly, regarding wealth, let's put it this way, as one of the elements of propaganda and the democrats and now those autocratic regimes that continue to develop, enrich themselves economically, even now the greatest oil traders, pay attention to how the restructuring the economy of the united arab emirates or saudi arabia, you see that they invest as much as possible in the non-oil, non-energy sphere, well, they do not mean redeemable minerals, but in this way they do not change in their own approaches today , regarding... and there the relationship to human rights, and indeed, precisely from the point of view of the economy and not only the economy, but also the well-being of future generations, i think that this should be a central approach, because

in fact, today, in this generally informational the noise in which the west lives society, the emphasis on real development is disappearing, let's say so. generally human, where to go next, for some reason, you know, for example, the topic of space, now pay attention, just totalitarian, states, there are generally autocratic, but especially china is betting on it to show its technological power, to demonstrate, that what used to be there in the united states, now they can spend money on it, and at the same time they are wealthier, accordingly their population and economy in general is rising, well, although certainly not at such a pace and everyone is starting to talk about a possible recession there and so on, that india is now gaining momentum there plus 7% of gdp and so on, but

nevertheless, simply china has already reached such a level of development that it can afford not so active rates of further development, and on the same wave we see a total aging of the population in... the european part of the world, look at what is happening in the united states, which today is gnawing, just gnawing politically, and in many of my acquaintances who and live there even arises the question is whether some internal conflicts will start, and this is what the russian federation is playing on today, as much as possible, russia fuels it with its propaganda, which constantly reminds them of the civil war, and this whole topic with the trumpists is now just a crazy field for them to work on and they they do it, the russians accordingly do it in the united states, at great expense, including, we understand that , in general, they are just like in ukraine, but we still have to understand that independence since

1991, which we proclaimed, we can to consider ourselves a new democracy, precisely on our territory we could in the future create a certain synergy in terms of the development of democracy, without falling further into authoritarianism, well, although again we had such cases when yanukovych was returned to power there again, but in our there were several revolutions that were able to... fix this whole thing, ukraine can become such a center of democracy and further economic development today thanks to its transit opportunities and the available resource base in terms of minerals, and of course, human potential, and that's why i think that this kind of salvation for world democracy, and such possibilities, including those that were seen in the kremlin, and that's why they started this large-scale stage of the war, because they understood that it will not just happen.

.. a salvation for democracy, but also a certain mirror for russia itself, that there may be another development option, and that is why we have what we have today, but for ukraine, of course, this does not mean that we need to turn around 180°, we we must continue to develop our own democracy, the question is only under what conditions, for example, the topic of elections is very relevant now, and which one we see that western partners are actually betting on it today, but how to conduct them is up to everyone. from the forms to each of the forms of voting, there are questions about electronic voting, about voting by envelopes, which again is a question of coming directly to the polling station, when we have a million mobilized, that is, we understand that in such a situation, it is a very difficult way, but nevertheless for ukraine today, i think, if we if we go to the global, to the macro level, then today ukraine can really be the savior of democracy in the confrontation with autocratic regimes, the most important thing for us today is

to defeat the russian federation. you know, well, in history there were such battles that actually determined the next stage of the development of civilization, let's say there was the battle of prihamelach in 331, when alexander the great defeated darius ii. point of view of alexander the great had much less power and means, but was able to defeat darius, well, let's say, it is possible... about 770, in my opinion, karl martel and the crusader knights, the battle near the city of tours, when the muslim invasion of europe, france, well, but on europe, in general, then it was actually stopped and europe remained christian, then there were such decisive battles in history, and here is that world war, let's remember, but even now this battle is also ongoing, the only question is what is possible in that time people had visions of what they were for are fighting, i don't know, ukraine knows what it is fighting for.

for my land, for the safety of my native people, for the opportunity to be myself and to be ukraine in general, is there an understanding of this in the world, for me, well, it’s actually difficult for me to say how big the role of ukraine should be today precisely in communication, i’m looking now, in romania canceled the speech of the president of ukraine in the parliament, you know, you can always treat president zelensky differently as a politician, but we all support him as our president, as a representative of ukraine in the world, that's why it's unpleasant for me, and the romanian deputies themselves, who wrote that it's a pity that he didn't speak. this is to, this is just to the word about communication, we literally have two minutes, but please tell me, what possible communication should ukraine give to the world today, what are we fighting for, we are actually the ones who started this war, we were the ones who were attacked monster, well, unfortunately it has already spread, what should we say, for what values ​​and for what, what we see in this war, what we are going for, well, actually death, at least our soldiers, that’s for sure, whatever please, it is obvious that we should be

a model state, a state where corruption has an inexorable trend, where, despite everything, the rights and freedoms of citizens are preserved, of course, within certain limits, on which martial law is imposed, but nevertheless, it is all preserved and where an adequate political life is preserved, because in this way we show today that, despite everything , today we can talk about the further development of democracy, and what exactly are we, you know, here is a strange situation, here is the russian one... what attacked us, they have but today the further narrowing of rights continues civil liberties, and even the topic of security today are absolutely not fulfilled by the kremlin regime, but the russians. vladimirovich is applauded and so on. today, ukraine is a country that is completely opposite, i will not talk about anti-russia, because it is a throw-in of russian propaganda. ukraine is ukraine, and it is building its politics , today so fruitfully, i generally believe that we

were able to survive these one and a half years thanks to a strong deep state, ukraine, the same as the deep state in the united states, in ukraine the people... this is deep the state and civil society, together, of course, as today's best representatives in the defense forces of ukraine, who defend our state from russian aggression, so today we must continue to be this example, because the further the elections in the united states will be in european countries as well , there will be an absolutely objective polarization of society, but nevertheless we must remain today as representatives of the light, that is. this watershed that we talked about must be preserved, we cannot wash away the advance that was given to us the world and that is not even an advance, but the result earned by our defenders on the battlefield and our civil society, for which we must fight. thank you very much for your comments, thank you very much for joining, ihor chelenko, political and economic expert

, i am the end, you know what i will tell you, our dear viewers, thank you very much, mr. igor, i bid you farewell and have a good day, i am the end i'll say, you know, there's a movie like this, the passions, mela gibson, there james caviezel plays christ and he walks with christ on his back, he's beaten, he falls, on this via delas, the road of tears, and maria approaches and says, what are you doing to christ, and he says, i am creating everything new, i think that ukraine is in this war, and everyone, well, most importantly, it is like this christ, who makes all things new, goes to his calvary, we believe that a new world will arise from all this, because it cannot be otherwise, well, that is why wars start, wars are always on... mistakes are when there is no development and then there is a war and as if something new should begin with the war, well , this is the logic of history, it's just that this time we found ourselves in this epicenter, we found ourselves, we are not really to blame for this, but we found ourselves and we believe that this new thing will be created, and the values ​​for which our soldiers are fighting today, they will be confirmed, i thank you for being with us, it was a world view program,

goodbye until the evening , stay for espresso, more to come. the varpati forum presents a unique book event , the literary and artistic meeting word in war. exclusive conversations with military writers and volunteers, book talks, author presentations, special children's program, performances by bards. 14 and 15 october in ivanofrankivsk, the square in front of the drama theater. a word in the war, on via kakarpattya in ivano-frankivsk. talented, relevant, truthful, with the support of the ukrainian book institute, under the protection of our military. i was flying, flying, and the cough stopped me. cough is a symptom of a respiratory disease, so we treat it respiratoryly, we do inhalation. lorde gial is an inhalant for cough. lordegial is a direct way to expel phlegm. there are discounts on helpex pills. 20%

in pharmacies plantain, bam taushchad. what you i drank an antibiotic, but it pierced your stomach. how are you girls? but how, how? after the antibiotic, how did it go? events: the most important events, events that are happening right now and affect our lives. of course, the news feed reports on them, but few know what is happening. it is necessary to understand. antin borkovskyi and invited experts from tvere. evaluate events, analyze them, modeling our near future, every saturday at 1:00 p.m. with a repeat at 10:00 p.m., west studio with anton borkovsky at espresso. the roof is a project about

the feeling of home, about our roots, about identity, this grandfather built, behind us, my great-great-grandparents built a house. about what the old ukrainian architecture brings to us today? good architecture is not necessarily made with the participation of an architect. churches, mills, houses, mazankas, it depends on us whether these buildings will slowly fade into oblivion. the wooden church is a phenomenon, indeed. it is still alive in the village of sekrain. will we still preserve our past? there is legislation, but it does not apply. we have a democracy, where whoever wants is what they want. about ukrainian folk architecture, its peculiarities and ways of salvation in the documentary series from the ukrainer project of the attic, on saturday o join the community with a ukrainian view of the world, become

a sponsor of the youtube channel espresso, which means access to exclusive content, personal thanks, pinned comments, special icons and the possibility of personal communication with by the espresso team. click sponsor and become part of the community with a ukrainian perspective. collaborators, who surrendered ukrainian cities to the russians? ukraine is a state, we have been convinced of this since the 14th. but how about small rubles and fake positions to sell your own conscience? our future is with russia. we must know the traitors face to face. watch the collaborators program with olena kononenko, every wednesday at 5:45 p.m. on the espresso tv channel. every week , the saturday political club helps to understand the processes taking place in ukraine and the world. vitaly portnikov, host of espresso and

invited experts, based on facts, give their assessment and forecast of the development of events. if you want to understand how our today will affect our tomorrow, watch the saturday political club, every saturday on espresso. congratulations. we received a very important one information about the missing 17-year-old sasha liponova and her 14-year-old sister nastya, and it was possible to learn about the girls' possible whereabouts. specialists from the osindflow community helped us with this. internet investigators are specialists who, with the help of certain technologies, search and analyze information available in open sources, for example, in communications on forums, sites, in messengers and, of course, in social networks. in aje, sasha and nastya disappeared in mariupol in the first days of the full-scale invasion, and for a long time nothing was known about their fate. we did

a number of video programs about the search for girls, but unfortunately no one saw the sisters and could not report any information about them. we suspected that sasha and nastya were no longer in ukraine and ended up in russia, and this version was confirmed to us by osint investigators, who , thanks to their own technologies for searching for information in open sources, established that sasha is indeed in russia. as we managed to find out, sasha and nastya studied in one of the boarding schools of mariupol before the war. after a full-scale invasion, they found themselves in donetsk. here is a photo from social networks, in which sasha and nastya are actually in the temporarily occupied donetsk. this is most likely the spring of 2022. and already in the summer of 2022, they were taken to nizhny novgorod. again, there is a corresponding photo in social networks. and here the sisters are still together, but after that, joint

photos of sasha and nastya no longer appeared. it is not known exactly where nastya lipunova is now. after the last photo of her in nizhny novgorod, it was not possible to establish the girl's further whereabouts. it is possible, that she was adopted in russia, but this information has not been confirmed, so officially nastya remains missing and the search for the girl continues. but about her sister himself. that is known more. here , intro-investigators found out that sasha liponova lives in the city of lukhovitsa, moscow region, and on september 1, 2022, she even entered a local technical school. and here, for example, is a photo of sasha with a diploma for an award in a poetry contest. and here the girl is reading poems in one of the city squares. there is also information that sasha lives in a foster family or in a local one dormitory of course, everything we learned about the girls we immediately passed on to the police, but until these data are officially confirmed, sasha and nastya will be considered

missing. currently, we do not know under what circumstances sasha and nastya liponova ended up in russia and whether they became direct victims of deportation. in general, as of now, more than 1,900 ukrainian children have been deported to russia, and this is a non-final figure, because the aggressor country refuses to provide complete lists of children deported from ukraine. in particular. over deportees include many ukrainian boys and girls who, even before the start of the full-scale invasion, were in the temporarily occupied territories in residential institutions, such as sasha and nastya lipunovy. deportation of children is a component of the crime of genocide, so i would like to note that if you personally know about any crime against a child, in particular about abduction or deportation, do not remain indifferent and immediately report it to the police, or report it on our website stopcime ua . you can even do it anonymously. and the very end please go to the website of the

children's tracing service. all these boys and girls are missing . so, if you recognize any of them, please let us know on the hotline at the short number 11630. calls from all mobile operators in ukraine are free. we have created a resource through which you can report any crime against a child, in any city, at any time, just go to the site and report, and we will launch all possible mechanisms to punish the criminal. stop krym ua. i am still at that time, in the 12th year, when

finished school, wanted to. to be involved, let's say, in the army, to serve, and i wanted to be in the army, i felt that way, i wanted something so much, let's say, in the 18th year my dream came true, my friends said, oh, you wanted this, you have , well, you did it, the choice fell on the regiment, because my husband was already serving there, well, at the moment , let's say, when i came, and that's why it was a regiment, and he previously told a lot about him, which i already i lived, let's say, with thoughts about this regiment, i already loved it, that's why there were no options, and before i

joined the army, i was on maternity leave. i came to the army to be useful, first of all, because we had a war already from the 14th year, i was looking for options, how i could be useful, i was engaged in clerical work, i was a clerk, it was difficult that in a small child is waiting for you at home, it was probably the most difficult morally, i served directly where my unit was stationed, and there was such a need, it was in rusof, yes, such a need for me to leave the zone as a businessman, on the 24th we we were going to azovstal, everything was calm in the city, well, relatively, let's say,

people are watching, convoys are driving, that is. we arrived on our own, more or less calmly, let's say so, because i didn't go out to the territory of azovstal, we were in a bunker, but we had one, we occupied the territory, let's say, and it was on ... at the beginning, at the beginning of march, we felt like this, when they started throwing mines at us, it was very noticeable, because we were in such a basement

room, the ceiling started to fall and everything so, they began to fly, let's say, to the places where the rear units were, it became clear that, that we will not be here for a little while, yes, and it's not all that simple, yes, we were up against us together, at first he was alone, in another bunker, and then our company joined him because it was safer there. we were bombarded constantly , well, especially at night, we already knew that at about such and such an hour, yes, we were given commands, constantly ship artillery air, that is, it was constantly, somehow