[000:00:00;00] how, how did it happen that israel, which has always been ready for war, and we know that the israeli special services are those special services that work in advance, and we know that the israeli tzahal, this is a large enough organization, if you take reservists who, who they bring there from all over the world in order to form this great army , 300,000, it seems they have... reserve, i how it happened that it was unexpected for everyone, because to mount such a large attack, and in the first two days, as the israelis themselves admit, that they were the first two days of the war lost because they were caught off guard, can you explain, i, how, how could this happen in

israel? i will not speculate, that. you should also know that intelligence and masad were outside and military intelligence and they will deal with it , everyone there is really commenting that there is such a puncture, but i will tell you what it means not ready, they just missed their 3.5-6 hours , during which their motorized infantry units should get this line of gas, and just during this time the militants killed 60 people at a peaceful festival and then additionally captured 20 there are small kibbutzim, that is, they can answer, it's just that they have a very close territorial, this is coexistence, that's why they missed through their surveillance systems this is the first event, so in principle, i think

that this is just a lesson, as i read it, that such a system, when you expect... attacks all the time, you have modern weapons, surveillance systems, you have everything, but everything is the same, the first subversive groups, if they come and so-and-so, such-and-such a war, of such a style, you have, you will have in the first days of a thousand victims, is such a system suitable for any country? i don't think so, what kind of system is it that expects an invasion and then reacts, that's why we have to draw conclusions, our concept: which we are now officially signing with other countries, provides for a response to an attack, we have to think about how to make a situation of prevention and preventing attacks. israel, unfortunately, is in such a situation that it is alone, it has self-defense with the support of its allies, well, actually, what is offered to us, also, i believe that this is an example for ukraine, which is such for such countries that

border on aggressive by enemies, no... it is necessary to make it so that the enemy did not dare to attack, simply did not dare, and in principle it was possible, but let's say so, all the showdowns there, the analysis of the flights, what was there and what did they do, did they not do intelligence, other structures, it will done, i will say only one thing, what i can assess politically, it is hard for me to imagine that the kremlin did not know about these intentions. it is hard to imagine that the vyrans did not know. why then, such friends as we have seen, well friends or, i don't know, buddies, like prime minister netanyahu's meetings with putin, this georgivska tape finally has netanyahu's premiere a signal that he was quite counting on the fact that maybe putin would stop his proxies there in

this region. and not to believe, as they believed, that it is with such means that you can protect yourself from terrorist attacks , that is, this is the lesson that they should learn, and i think that there should be a convergence of our positions here, because we already have this lesson, we also, it was not we , our government, who thought that it would be possible to somehow come to an agreement there, but here is an example, even israel, which was much more ready than ukraine, was really here... stuck in something, but it doesn't mean we have to say something like this, you see, israel did this despite all the preparations for war, this, this is the wrong response to this situation, this response should be, look, in today's world, so much right now suggests that we should prepare much more powerfully for the defense of the country and, most importantly

, build an alliance of nuclear-armed countries. that is, we cannot continue to survive without an alliance with a nuclear coalition, primarily the usa, britain, france and membership in nato, it simply cannot, even if we are powerful. that's how israel lives in system of preparation for war, we will just be fine, if the enemy climbs into our territory, we will have tens of thousands of dead in the first days, so this is the lesson i see in this situation, i hope israel also sees it, and i it seems that israel's efforts in terms of more such, many, many-sided possible responses to such attacks, they will be ... the next years, and russia should remain where it is, for israel, should be a completely unpredictable and capable entity, and i am surprised by the ambassador's statement

israel in moscow, what did he say there, russia is acting responsibly, it is not behind this , well, you haven't drawn any conclusions, you want to once again have an attack by proxies that the kremlin will finance, i don't understand why. .. such conclusions are now being drawn as part of the current government there, after all, it seems to me that if they do not make these conclusions, they will be replaced, then there will be no premiership and there will be no active coalition at that time, and one more conclusion, they had complex internal political processes between the government and the opposition, and this diverted their attention, they tried to conduct some reforms to increase the influence of the executive power, well, in general, of the executive power, and to skip... in my opinion, the prioritization of tasks, that the tasks of security and defense of the state come first, and not some kind of struggle with the opposition, thank god that

they have drawn conclusions, and as far as i understand, now they want to concentrate their efforts, coordinate with the opposition and the authorities to achieve the key goal, security issues for their country, well, this is also a lesson for ukraine regarding the authorities and the opposition, regarding... the internal situation and the internal - political situation, and this must also be taken into account, what happens when there is no unity, when there are some misunderstandings. we will put an end to our conversation here, thank you mr. valery for the conversation, this was valery chaly, politician, diplomat, extraordinary plenipotentiary ambassador of ukraine to the united states of america in 2014 , 2015-2019. friends, we work live on tv channels, as well as on ours. forms on youtube and on facebook, for those who are currently watching us on youtube, i remind you that we are conducting a poll, we still have a minute left on the air, and we are asking you about this, whether will you vote

for zelenskyi in case of re-election for the presidency, yes no, at this moment 82% said no, 18% said yes, and please don't forget to like this video so that it goes up in youtube trends, beautiful we have today the conversation was with valery chavle, so don't be stingy, please like it so that as many viewers as possible can see this video on the youtube platform, i will put an end to our program, i wish everyone good health, take care of yourself and your loved ones relatives, it was the verdict program, it was brought by serhiy rudenko, goodbye. people and ideas that protect and create ukraine. the sixth forumpathy - the future of tradition, ukrainian in the global world, ivano-frankivsk, october 14 and 15. discussions about the challenges of time and the projection

of the future. meetings with warrior writers. in the center of the events is the performance of the nation by the frankiv drama theater. annual meeting place of strong, honest and unique people, traditionally in the carpathians. see veteri espresso, come. at the event of the forum in ivano-frankivsk with the support of the ukrainian cultural foundation under the protection of our military. i flew, flew, and the cough stopped me. cough is a symptom of a respiratory disease, so we treat it respiratoryly, we do inhalation. lord's gial is an inhalant for cough. and with the new ulizer air. lordi enters the lungs immediately and sputum leaves faster. thanks to lorde, i'm flying again. lorde hyal is a direct path to elimination. krotynya, there are discounts on amicitron, 20% in podorozhnyk, bam and oskad pharmacies. there are discounts on nazoferon, 15% in pharmacies traveller, bam and savings. tired of heavy and bulky forks, then the compact and

powerful strong saw from rozpak tv is just for you. now you can easily trim trees and bushes. the strongg saw is so convenient to use for carpentry. it is the perfect tool for your home or garden. the price is only uah 1,499. a reliable battery is also included. cut branches, cut timber, chop firewood. you will do all this in one movement with the strong saw. just look at how quickly it copes, even with thick branches. strong fork easy to use and mobile once ready, and unlike standard saws, it is so convenient to use in hard-to-reach places. the set includes a powerful battery, a key and a screwdriver, as well as a charger that will allow you to always have a charged saw at hand. call and order a reliable and convenient tool for only uah 1,499. a powerful strong saw is what you need, call. tired of heavy and bulky saws, then the compact and

powerful strong saw from unpack tv is just for you. now you can easily cut trees and shrubs the strongg saw is so convenient to use for carpentry. it is the perfect tool for your home or garden. and the price is only uah 1,499. a reliable battery is also included. cut branches, cut timber, chop firewood. you will do all this in one movement with the strong saw. only. see how quickly it copes, even with thick branches. the strong fork is easy to use and mobile once it's ready, and unlike standard saws, it's so convenient to use in hard-to-reach places. the set is powerful a battery, a wrench and a screwdriver, as well as a charger that will allow you to always have a charged saw at hand. call and order a reliable and convenient tool: for only uah 1,499. a powerful strong saw is

what you need, call. see this week's judicial control program with tatyana shustrova, an honorable resignation instead of a shameful dismissal. judges with dubious reputations should not be given the option of honorable resignation. but who was lucky enough to save benefits from the state? instead of them suffering a just punishment, we will pay lifetime monetary benefits, watch the judicial control program with tetyana shustrova on the espresso tv channel on thursday, october 12 at 5 p.m. vasyl winter's big broadcast. two hours of airtime, two hours of your time, two hours to learn about the war and what the world is about? two hours to keep up with economic and sports news. two hours in the company of favorite presenters, presenters who have become like family to many, as well as distinguished guests of the studio. events of the day in two hours. vasyl winter's big broadcast. project for

intelligent and caring. espresso in the evening. espresso is the september leader among ukrainian information channels. we have held the championship for six months in a row. greetings, dear viewers. time to learn about the most important things. according to measurement data, viewers choose the ukrainian view from espresso. congratulations friends, mykola veresin, vitaly portnikov. good health to everyone. thank you ukrainians for your trust, espresso works for you.

greetings, this is the razom beraber project, a joint project of tv channel uso and our friends from the apr, my name is khrystyna yatskiv, from a minute on we are waiting a minute for my co-host, ayder muzhdabaev, to join the broadcast. thanks to everyone who is interested in the topic, for now, we hope the peninsula will be occupied for a short time. well , actually, let's start with the military situation, with the security situation there, safe for the occupiers, of course. i would now like to refer to the analysis of oleksandr kovalenko, a military expert of the information resistance group, who notes that, despite the fact that crimea remains a rather convenient military bridgehead for the russians, the military group, which is on a permanent basis on the territory of crimea, does not look too massive, and today it is a little more than 11,000 personnel

, in total. only 11,000, and the most interesting thing mr. oleksandr writes about this powerful grouping in quotation marks, excuse the words, this is exactly what they have in service, there are about 30 tanks, less than 60 bbms, about 90 artillery barrels, rzzo azhyry pieces, well , of course, this is information that we can take from where... sources and actually talk about the fact that just now in the crimea some crazy, on a permanent basis, the forces of the occupier us, and this is good for us, the condition of the black sea fleet in crimea and our nato partners is not remarkable and not too stable, let's say. representatives of the alliance believe that the russian fleet in the equatorial black sea still retains some ability to perform basic combat tasks , patrol the area and strike with cruise

missiles, high-ranking officials from nato said during a meeting of defense ministers of the alliance countries in brussels that strikes for the defenses of the russian black sea fleet the federation severely limited its capabilities in september, while russian warships are still able to perform basic combat missions. according to the western military , the attacks on russian ships and the headquarters of the black sea fleet caused serious damage to the naval forces of the russian federation. and of course, traditionally , unfortunately, things of a repressive nature also happen in relation to the civilian population of occupied crimea, 75% of all

arbitrary searches that take place in crimea, still take place in relation to of the crimean tatar population, in the homes of the crimean and human rights defenders are talking about it, and at least 110 of the more than 186 six victims of politically motivated persecution are representatives of the crimean tatar people, this week we are following, including the news related to nariman dzhelal, the first deputy chairman of the medjalis of the crimean tatar people, and the akhtemov brothers. the occupiers took them from the occupation sizo-2 in simferopol and illegally staged them to prisons on the territory of the russian federation, this was reported by nariman's wife, leviza, a little earlier in early october , she noted that dzhelal and aziz akhtemov were planning to be sent to the krasnoyarsk prison,

and assan akhtemov to the prison in the city of volodymyr, and this received a certain reaction in the international community, which is not may not please, but so far it does not give us the results we expected, the vice-president of the german bundestag, katrin goering eckard, reports on her twitter that she condemns the phasing of political prisoners, dzhelal and the akhtemov brothers to russian federation. international support is very important, because the prosecution did not accept the motion to exclude unsubstantiated evidence. the word goes. this is not only about the protection of human rights, such cases are also a matter of stability and security at the international level, as nariman jelal said in his address to the participants of the third summit of the crimean platform. i am glad to welcome, ayder muzhdabaev, to

the studio of the espresso tv channel and the studio of the atr tv channel. ayder, salaam alaikum. aleikum to the villages, hello to all. i'm sorry, i do not see. to the studio, so if something goes wrong, i’m sorry, you look beautiful, and the background on which you are now is also simply incredible with the ukrainian flag, i outlined a little information picture, which as of today is and concerns the occupied crimea, no i know if you have heard everything, at the same time i will announce our inclusions today, we will have the opportunity to talk with arsen zhumadilov, who... currently heads the agency for resource provision of the army under the ministry of defense, the agency should be fully operational at the beginning october, we will talk about urgent issues related to the provision of our army and the work of the ministry of defense in general, and we are also waiting for a comment from representatives

of the naval forces and the armed forces of ukraine, because today they confirmed that the patrol ship pavel derzhavin in district of sevastopol, which is the source of the damage, how it happened, is not detailed yet, but perhaps, we can extract, so to speak, from dmytro plettenchuk, the spokesman of the command of the naval forces of the armed forces of ukraine, some additional information. ayder, what kind of emphasis have you been putting on yourself lately, the last week, at least in relation to our relatives, until... crimea, well , the main thing that i saw in the news of the last few days is that the russian leader putin appointed his prokhiv , tykhan shevkunov, the so-called head of the metropolis, the crimea, the crimean diocese, i just might

not know, and in principle there are many rumors about him , but he is really a person who is very close to putin, and a person to whom he very eavesdropping during i think for the last 20 years, i.e. tikhan shovkunov, who will arrive, or will probably arrive in crimea and is very much looking forward to . the relationship is absolutely direct, and he is so unremoved, so there is some kind of holy man , no, absolutely, this man who, thanks to which

in a certain way, can in a big way... on the topic, own greatness and own role in of the history of russia and the world, i can give, if there is time, a short example, somewhere back in the year 12, maybe 11, i had an acquaintance who was friends with volodymyr solovyov, who now performs, performing the duties of the main . propagandist of russian, yes, but at that time this mr. solav'ov was a type of liberal journalist and positioned himself as a democrat there, as a person who is there for pluralism of opinions, etc., and my comrade at the time, he now also works for propaganda, and this is all incidental the world to me, but then he told me that i have very bad, bad news, solovyov... said that putin had completely gone mad, and i emphasize that this was before the occupation of crimea, but

already after the war in georgia, and i asked why, ah, well, why is solovyov so panicked on the basis of which, he said that slavyev told him that i was absolutely sure that it was so , so it was, well, there was no point in lying to him then, especially since it was a private conversation and i was told, only don't tell anyone, well, how can you say about it, well, you're very free, it 's such a conditional category, we're not doctors, but he meant what solovev told him, putin really considers himself a mission, really considers himself the bearer of the russian imperial identity and a person appointed by god to save russia, and i can’t put it into words, and it was terrifying even

in solav'ov, that is, at this time, the russian furor turned , well, at least internally, i will remind you once again what years these are, how long it is, to understand, i just think the 11th-12th year, roughly so, yes , and shevkonnov, this is one of the closest to simply imprisoning putin, and the very one who fills it with all this imperial stuff and he has such a program of actions in his head and it was handed down from shevkunov and another one was called there, but shevkunov is definitely the main ideologue that russia must return its greatness, as they say, and russian, well, at least one of the points that the russian church has should have the hagia sophia in istanbul. they call constantinople, and now it is the hagia sophia mosque, that is, it is a restoration , so moscow, it is the third rome, as they say, yes

, the second rome, this, constantinople, now istanbul, and if anyone thinks that this is it's just a fantasy on the topic of some , i don't know, artistic amateurism, absolutely not, they are talking about it to each other in complete seriousness, and putin, most often. at least in those days, i don't think anything has changed, especially considering that he appointed him to the crimea, this shovkonov, i think that shovkonov's influence only increased, and i don't know, maybe, christ, you can do something too to comment, i would like to hear you, i will say my version like this, that this is such a shock, with which he convinces himself, and intends to convince there are the so-called occupying elites, not in the fact that he sends them, so to speak, his closest friend, a spiritual person, well, in quotation marks for us, of course, yes, and that crimea is

the world for him, it is the place of his power. i don't really know how superstitious or religious putin is, whatever, but, in any case, the fact that a person who has a long relationship and a history of relations with the russian dictator is headed to crimea, and a local, essentially gauleiter, the church is removed, it is very symptomatic, i completely agree with you here, if we talk about symbolism, then it reminds me of... you know, the cap of the immortal, who directs all his strength to protect his egg with a needle, at the end of which his death, that is, as far as i'm concerned, there are certain parallels in this, there is a certain symbolism, when understanding that crimea, oh , in which the focus of attention of the defense forces and of ukraine and the whole world, he tries to cover it even so, well, and definitely the zumba of people living in the territory

of crimea, christians living in the territory of crimea, mm, here, for sure, nothing new, because, er, in principle, ah, in principle, ours clement of crimea, he no longer has leverage over the believers who remained, yes, uh, and who remained faithful, both to ukraine and to god, in this history, he is now with the ukrainian army, with the ukrainian people on the mainland to ukraine, therefore, unfortunately, the russians retain... their ability to influence the minds and souls of christians in crimea. by the way, ayder, if we have already entered such a topic, before bringing in the promised guest, arsen dzhomadilovov, i would still like you to reflect briefly, please on the topic of everything that is happening in the middle east. i was waiting for our conversation with you in order to ask why it is so accepted

to believe that there is a certain solidarity. among believers, and that muslims are more willing to support palestinians, i would not put an equal sign between palestinians and hamas terrorists, they are completely different stories, but osman pashaev wrote an excellent post on this account, i don't know if i watched or saw you, what do you think in general about what is happening now in the territory of israel and nearby, well, i think that everything is here for everyone, obviously, it was a terrible terrorist act, not even a terrorist act, but a series of terrorist acts, one day, one day of terrorism, one day of mass extermination of people on national grounds, this is what history has already seen, and including, the crimean tatar people have seen on their own experience , during the deportation and other terrible events, but it's just impossible

to believe it, with your own eyes, but it happened in the 21st century, and i think that no normal person, no matter how sympathetic they are, to the palestinians or, to the muslims, there , who live on this earth, no normal person, well at least i didn't hear anything that she justified in any way what they did, that's absolutely true, it's just that they're not people, they're anti-people, they're people for whom human life doesn't exist at all, and i think we all do. .. we should be together, well, on the side of the truth, on the side of israel, which protects its people from such, such horror, well, i just don't know, if we see, this attack happened suddenly and already 1,200 people were simply exterminated there, not just kill, exterminated, yes, what would happen if, this horror, lasted there for a week,

for example, yes, or a month, and you can't even imagine it. i absolutely do not understand those people in the west, by the way, i have not heard anything like that in ukraine, who in the west justify terrorism, appealing to some international treaties regarding the status of palestine, all of this exists in nature, but it can be solved only in a situation that does not involve terrorism and mass murder of people, absolutely, well, it is impossible. as long as there is such an intention to exterminate the jews to the last jew, there is nothing there it will not be good, including the arabs, well, this is my opinion, i think that the majority of people in ukraine agree with this, by the way, i was very surprised when ukrainian, some representatives in ukraine, well, let's say this, of the arab people, they began