[000:00:00;00] what we constantly, constantly read, hear, how much is it in general, such a thing , which, which is perceived, well, some societies of western countries, politicians of western countries, how toxic is this issue, insane, insanely technical, it is still an idea, что russia is huge , there is an illusion that it is very rich, there is knowledge that it has nuclear weapons, that it has rich resources, and this is the idea that it is a giant, you need a giant. disassemble to see the baldness of this king, we have not yet done it, that is, this myth, it was not possible to deconstruct, not to the end, of course, some sobered up, but it goes very deep, it goes for centuries, yes, you can’t understand something here in an hour, yes, it plays a very big role, i think,

look, and i understand , nuclear weapons in themselves, but the issue of nuclear weapons also remains toxic, which in principle affects decision-making very strongly, officially, yes according to any doctrine, you are different, you have other relations with a nuclear state than a nuclear state, this part of any country, well, you know, my big part of my work in general, it consists in the fact that i watch literally hours of russian tv shows, russian television in order to understand what they are doing to their population, and the last, and the last, well, the biggest such trend that was, literally, it started on last week , it drags on now, they are trying for their own, well, it is cyclical for them, they approached it several times, but the last very strong approach is happening right now, they are trying to normalize nuclear war for the russian population, they talk about the fact that in nuclear war is possible

win. that nuclear war can be limited, that russia can, well, at least respond and we won't all die, but some part will die, well, maybe you know this story, when simonyan, margarita simonyan said that we can detonate a bomb over russia there , and after that everything will turn off, and we can do something like that, but why over russia? turn off satellites, turn off all satellites, why, that 's another question, okay, fine, i didn't understand. the issue is that they are now trying to do some kind of nuclear test that would be very large and would terrify everyone, and since they can do this test only on the territory of russia, they need to normalize it for russian citizens, and a strange thing came out, because after a few days of this propaganda, a number of very active, well, such small politicians, semi-oppositional,

even there one member of the state duma.. .from the communists, and one from united russia, began to tell that something should be done with these propagandists who talk about this, because it is impossible, well, they have to face these talks about nuclear weapons. ugh, at the forum in valdai, putin was forced to come out himself and say that he does not support the use of nuclear weapons, now , the changes in russia's nuclear doctrine, it's not him, it 's not him, it's all a type of propaganda, and, that is, russia... it's clear that they, they are afraid the perception of the russian population, or rather the non-acceptance of these ideas by the russian population, about nuclear war, about some limited nuclear strikes, which they endlessly talk about, about tactical nuclear strikes, which they endlessly talk about, and at the end of this i just wonder how much is possible in such case it will be effective that in response they

publicly, not publicly, but they heard about it. that any attempts to use nuclear weapons in any case , they will definitely receive a nuclear strike, because the population of russia is really afraid of this, maybe it's time to work with this fear, i don't know, it seems to me that you know more than i do about it , i have seen different studies in russia, where people are very afraid of nuclear weapons, that theoretically, if we can convince them, that their power leads to this. it needs to be, for example, a movement, an anti-nuclear movement in russia, maybe, i don't know, but there is something in it, well, it is somehow such a strange society, you know, we often apply the logic of democracy, yes, to russia, but there everything is different, yes, it seems to me, sometimes, that ukraine, how is it there historical there, there is a historical understanding of russia, but ukrainian society has developed in such a different way over the last 30 years that i often , when i talk with ukrainian

political technologists, i hear how they apply democratic logic to russia, yes, according to some logic of our democratic yes, your power leads to horror, but there i don't know everything about pertormashka. i don't know what will work there, we can't expect, i think we can't expect a coup there, well, we have the same situation as with the support of the germans, hitler's hitler, nazism, it seems, it seems, it seems and in such, in such a situation, what do we have to put pressure on, in order to at least prevent those who really, nukal all the same. to drive them out of our territory in general, and therefore to defeat them in this way, for example, well, look, we are

simple targets, and there, well, to knock down the mobilization, yes, there, there, maybe, i don’t know, spare parts in i don’t know, in productions, there they are important for the production of weapons, well, we need to start with such things, well, what we really don’t understand, well, how does any there is propaganda during the war, yes, how to put problems in their military production and the military machine, the focus is always on this, yes, how to make the soldiers desert, and so on, well, this is the first, yes, the most simple and the most competent and i think that everyone is already doing it, with different levels success, and if we talk about social. military actions must always be combined here, communication, political and so on, it is necessary in one thing, yes, they must work together during the war, and even when i don’t

know, ukrainian drones have reached moscow, yes, to what extent we were able to expand this information everywhere and turn it around so that , well, the kremlin power looked weak, yes , did we use the moment as much as possible... we used a little bit, well, i don’t know if it was as much as possible, to such an extent that we really were able to return the informational part of this action to ours and to ours to our victory yes i don't know just yes i don't deal with it well this next question yes to such a degree physical actions are supported by information yes that they need to be maximized well then the most important thing is that our understanding of the relationship for... i don't know, public differences , adjusted to changes in the political calculations of the kremlin, yes, that's what we're looking for, yes, this is the moment when people who make decisions

in russia decide that this the war was a mistake we need, well, at the end of the invasion of afghanistan, the soviets, they just have to come to terms with the defeat, for sure, yes, that was a mistake, they need to change, we need to change. if we are looking for this, yes, at least i don’t know, it seems like yes, then how did the soviets withdraw from afghanistan or the french from algeria, well, such situations, we still don’t really understand what they rely on when they can make such a decision, yes, at what point did they not understand, oh, we miscalculated, yes, we didn't think through something, we still don't really understand, i i don't really understand, maybe the guru understands, the mozhru understands what they are looking at, yes, when they make decisions, it is related to sanctions, it is related to the relationship between the regions of russia, a classic russian problem, yes, the relationship between the regions, it is related to financial by some indicators, yes, there is some report

that the central bank transfers, they say, we can't do it anymore, but i don't know what it is, yes, when we need to push back from it, yes, that's what they 're looking at and how exactly these will affect us then points, through information, through sanctions, through? military actions, well, this must be avoided, yes, well, a network of actions , i would not separate here cyber actions, military actions , information actions, sanctions actions, everything must work together to lead to this result, well, we understand, it is very far here, from the search for democratic principles in russian society, no, let someone search for them, but this will not lead to victory, er, in the ostanka, which you consider the biggest communication task of ukraine now, well, first of all in the west, in the western world, because the western world will support us, well understood, well look , i don’t think that there are any informational tasks that are not connected with real

politics, yes, really, it’s all connected, question, how to tell more about victories, it's very important, yes, that's all these eternal conversations about counter-offensives, it's a fixation on it. we know that russia has prepared a huge number of missiles and drones that it has built. western technology, western machines, western microchips, yes, we need to talk about it now tell, it is necessary very strongly now to raise awareness in the west that western technology produces weapons that kill children and that strengthen russia, it is very important that the west begins to adopt the most

effective ones. which we simply do not have enough, tell me, can we still expect that the west will stop reacting nervously to strikes on russia when it happens, because without us still moving the war on the territory of russia, i i'm afraid it's impossible to win. look, the blows are different, well, now we are hitting military purposes, we show it enough that we are hitting, i think that this and i think that ukraine has changed very much, the west's conceptions of how russia will react, it seems to me, the attacks in crimea, i think that drones in in moscow, i think that such fires in key factories have greatly changed the calculation of the west. the services of politicians

about the possibilities of how to win this war, we are waiting for their next step, the next step, when they stop being afraid that this is happening with western weapons, well, we had a writer with us and journalist peter pomarantsev. thank you, dad, the stairs, my legs can't walk anymore, wait, i know that there is no health, and what kind of health is there in the sixth decade, i thought so until i tried gerovital. gerovital + phytovitamin complex that cares for the heart and strengthens the body. gerovital + good health, active life. the novelty of geerovital energy is even more iron for good causes. gerovitalal energy - intake once a day. malta ukraine on megogo. in the summer , malta created problems for us, whether ukraine can show not only this time

result, but also a spectacular game. find out on october 17 at 21:45 on mego. no matter what ukrainians think about, no matter what they talk about, war still comes first. war and our victory. only on espresso, from monday, monday. completely different spheres of human activity. sports, health, politics, will return. crimea, military analytics, nine presenters, journalists, experts, opinion leaders, in real time about the most relevant, events through the prism of war in author's projects on espresso. join the community with ukrainian view of the world. become a sponsor of the espresso youtube channel. and this is access to exclusive content. personal thanks, pinned comments, custom icons, and the ability to chat one-on-one with

the espresso team. click sponsor and become part of the community with a ukrainian perspective. greetings, this is svoboda live on radio svoboda. we have already come to the most serpentine. the following shots may shock you. news from the scene. live drone attacks, kamikaze. political analytics, objectively and meaningfully. there is no political season, exclusive. interviews, reports from the hottest points of the front. freedom life frankly and impartially. you draw your own conclusions. vasyl winter's big broadcast. two hours of air time, two hours of your time, two hours to learn about the war and what the world is about. two hours to keep up with economic news and. sports news

for two hours in the company of favorite presenters, presenters, many of whom have become like relatives, as well as distinguished guests of the studio, events of the day in two hours, vasyl zima's big broadcast, a project for smart people and those who care, at the espresso dinner. the war in ukraine is the main topic for ukrainians. victories and losses, analysis and forecasts, politics and geopolitics, serhiy rudenko and the guests of his program will talk about all this. people who own information and shape public opinion. people who defend. and create the future right now is the main and interesting thing in the program verdict by serhiy rudenko. from monday to friday at 20:00, repeat at 12:10. watch this week's judicial control with tatyana shustrova in the program. honorable resignation instead

shameful dismissal. judges of dubious reputation should not have the option of honorable resignation. good luck to keep the benefits from the state, instead of them suffering a just punishment, we will pay a lifetime monetary income, congratulations, you are watching judicial control, i am tatyana shustrova. every month, the supreme council of justice dismisses dozens of judges, and not all of them finish their careers after reaching 65 years of age. age and health allow many to continue working, but they prefer to leave as soon as possible from the system and not to be dismissed for violations, because judicial resignation is not just a pension, it is an extension of immunity and huge lifetime monetary payments from the state. all this, after working for 20 years, should only be received by the virtuous servants of themis, those who did not take bribes, did not abuse

their position and observed the norms of judicial ethics, and in fact , those whose integrity is questionable often try to escape into an honorable retirement in order to make it impossible to investigate their activities, do not pass the qualification assessment and save all honorable discharge privileges. we continue to talk about the judges whom the vrp, instead of bringing to justice, sent to honorable retirement this year. in april , lyudmila harnyk, the judge of the northern commercial court of appeal, resigned. she was alone. from the first judges who passed the initial qualification assessment, and did not pass. in 2016, the judge was unable to confirm her professional knowledge and ability to administer justice. the qualification commission sent her for retraining to of the national school of judges. even then, the members

of the commission had a lot of questions about garnyk's fortune. in 2014, on the judge's accounts, uah 3 million, she was never able to explain their origin, at first she said that it was from the sale of an apartment, but it turned out that she sold the apartment a year later. at the next qualifying assessment, the version changed. everything is very transparent, everything is very simple , i worked for 20 years, then, even more, i worked as a lawyer in odesa, my son after that also worked as a lawyer in the academy and after coming to kyiv, i also worked as a lawyer, i also worked in women's colony, i already have 40 years of experience, both as a lawyer and as a leading lawyer in odesa, which means leading a good lawyer. it should be noted that lyudmila garnyk has worked as a judge

since 2002, which means that in 2014 she simply could not earn millions while performing the work of a lawyer. the position of a judge prohibits working part-time. lyudmila garnyk has a luxurious house 335 km away in the elite coastal village of sauvignon in odesa. her income was only a salary . we filmed and published this house as it looks. really chic estate near mine, with moving to kyiv, garnyk, who, judging by the declaration, had more or less savings, did not spend them on housing in the capital, simply privatized an office apartment more than 100 km away. i received the same apartment on chervonozoryny, as a judge, and you later

privatized it, privatized it, and we still use it. lyudmila harnyk is a candidate of sciences, in the course of qualification evaluation. she shares her thoughts, we won't even comment on it, we suggest you just listen, she came to a very interesting thought, why did i write a scientific article, if any a decision that has entered legal force is an effective decision, you are a candidate of sciences, yes, in the 10th year. americans, they are more pitiful to their own, farmers to their own, these are lonely people, everything is aimed at helping this person to somehow get out of this situation.

in 2016, the qualification commission recognized harnyk's professional level as insufficient for judicial practice, and sent him to study. for almost five years, the judge was deprived of the right to work until march 2021. however, all this time we are with you, as taxpayers continued to withhold. unfit judge she received her high judicial salary every month. lyudmila harnyk from 2016 to 2020, one can say, simply received a salary, without doing justice, and because she still could not pass the qualification assessment. as a result, she went through everything, her fortune did not decrease. judge lyudmila harnyk resigned on april 27, 2023. retained the title of judge and at the expense of taxpayers, that is, you and i will receive a lifetime

allowance from the state in the amount of 50 to 100% of her judicial salary. and this is the judge of the shevchenkiv district court of the city of kyiv, lidia shchebunyaeva. she resigned on april 25 of this year. the cafemida employee is known for freeing oleksandr medvyd from imprisonment for kidnapping and torturing activists of the revolution of dignity, ihor lutsenko and yury verbytsy. the latter was brutally killed. on january 22, 2014, verbytsy's body was found in the forest 500 meters from the hnidyn petrivske road. the investigation established that oleksandr medvid personally participated in the kidnapping of activists from oleksandrivska hospital, after which they were transported to the suburbs of kyiv, where they were abused... and beaten. lidia shchebunyaeva passed the verdict, in which she expressed her conviction that yury verbytsky

died not because of the torture of medvid and his company, but because he froze to death in the winter forest. lidia shchebonyaeva has quite a long track record, but most of all, she probably became famous because of the fact that she justified , in fact, did not see, the grave consequences, the kidnapping of the infliction of physical pain, the consequences and the death of the journalist verbytsy, an activist during the revolution of dignity, this and many other things, unfortunately, did not also become the reason for the supreme council of justice to at least suspend consideration of the issue of shchebunyaeva's resignation, at the time of the announcement of medvid's sentence on april 23, the consideration of the case had been going on for... years and the statute of limitations to responsibility for the commission of the crime coincided. therefore, even though medvid was found

guilty, he was simultaneously released from punishment. lydia shchebunyaeva also tried her colleague from the pechersk district court of kyiv, the odious maidan judge, viktor kityuk. in 2020, she acquitted kityuk, because no saw the composition of the crime in his actions. systematicity is monitored. at one time, she acquitted the judge of the maidan, viktor kytsyuk, of such decisions, because she was considering cases about a judicial decision, which , by the way, the constitutional court had previously recognized as unconstitutional, but then, even before that, she also did not see the nature of the crime in the adoption of a judicial decision judge kytsyuk, who are also, well, probably. one of the most odious kyiv judges who persecuted activists during the maidan

for a trip to mezhehirya, lidiyubunyaeva was transferred to the shevchenkiv district court of kyiv in 2015, since 2003 she was a judge of the khartsy city court of the donetsk region. the interview with the higher qualification commission, the servant of themis, took place in closed mode and confirmed. compliance with the position held. property declarations indicate that the main income of the shchebunyaeva family since 2014 was the judge's salary. the judge owns an apartment in the donetsk region, and her actual place of residence was indicated as kyiv, although any housing in the capital in her declarations were absent, even on terms of use. it turns out, once again, that the judges are actually playing against the state. ukraine, who let murderers go free, who let go judges who made decisions at the behest

of president yanukovych's administration, we will now pay them, instead of... they suffer a just punishment, a lifetime monetary benefit, which can reach and uah 1,000 or more, depending on how much the judge earned at his last job. and another judge with a dubious reputation, who is superior the judiciary council sent him to resign with a lifetime pension at our expense, this is oleksiy bryntsev, a judge of the economic court of the kharkiv region. in 2016, he participated in the competition for the supreme court, but received a negative opinion from the public integrity council. the candidate is connected to political forces. the candidate reported incomplete information in the declaration of family ties. candidate members of his family own a significant amount of real estate, the legality of which causes reasonable doubt. public council

integrity found that bryntsev is a former son-in-law. ex-people's deputy stepan havrysh, who in 2004-5 represented the interests of viktor yanukovych in the supreme court. and bryntseva's ex-wife performed the duties of an assistant to the people's deputy from the party of regions, yury ivanushchenko. in 2006-15 , the judge's father, vasyl bryntsev, was a judge of the constitutional court. in 2010, he was recognized as legal by a panel of judges. a coup, as a result of which ex-president viktor yanukovych usurped power in ukraine. one thing is certain, children are not responsible for their parents. however connection with political forces, especially pro-russian ones, does not at all indicate the integrity of the judge. bryntsev took ownership of land in the temporarily occupied crimea, several houses and apartments, and non-residential

premises. in 2019 , the public council of integrity found that during the three years of the war , the judge crossed the border with russia more than 20 times. bryntsev's father and mother also made regular trips to the russian federation. the russian border guards and other representatives of the russian law enforcement agencies are certainly aware of this. why are they letting in, how are they letting this person in, how and for what did they exchange security guarantees for what? if the judge rides back and forth, either on the occupied territory, or directly on the territory of russia. federation, there is clearly some kind of agreement between this judge, or this judge and the russian federation, as to what a person who is a representative of the ukrainian state, who makes decisions on behalf of ukraine, is doing on the territory of our enemy. with all this track record, the judge of the economic court of the kharkiv region, oleksiy bryntsev , resigned on march 21 of this year. so, how

we see, the honorable dismissal of the servants of themis is not always a positive... just phenomenon. of course, the fact that unscrupulous judges stop administering justice is not a bad thing. however, when they retire, they retain the title of judge and, accordingly, immunity from law enforcement officers, because a judge cannot be detained even in retirement without the permission of the supreme administrative court. they can participate in the administration of the judicial system and receive lifelong financial support from the state. from. uah 100,000 per month, so judges with a dubious reputation have such an option as honorable retirement should not be available. as of today, i have everything, you watched judicial control, i'm tetyana shustrova. if you want to report corrupt judges or illegal decisions, write to me on facebook

or to this email address. see you in exactly a week. good bye. greetings, dear tv viewers, this is news, anna yavamelnik is with you, i will start with what is happening in the kherson region, the russians covered the golden beam with fire, it was recorded in the kherson region. 28 arrivals, enemy shells hit a private house and farm buildings buildings, a kindergarten was damaged, during the day the occupiers shelled kherson , the city center was cut off, as a result of another airstrike , power lines were damaged, after the morning attack, the power supply was restored, but repair work is still ongoing - reported the head of the region oleksandr prokudin. in the morning, the russians shelled