[000:00:00;00] is to restrain the ukrainian counteroffensive in the south of ukraine by diverting forces in the areas where the counteroffensive activity is currently the greatest, i.e. kupyansk, this is avdiivka, well, in addition, certain military and political goals are being pursued, why avdiivka, why at this particular time, well, at least, two such...' versions were voiced , which in my opinion have the right to exist, eh, it's that they wanted to give putin a present, for his birthday, well, it didn't work out in time, and the second is that he needed something to show success before his trip to beijing and i will meet with the chinese leader, that is, this is a whole set, which fortunately

, well, let's say, it is only partially possible to implement somewhere, ah, or well, if, after all , this desire does not leave them, to get, uh, advance somewhere further, uh, it has some kind of time limits, it's under, well, i mean, what i mean, oh, that is, are they preparing to take... some positions, like they think to themselves, and then go to some negotiation process, or is it some kind of , well, how to say, well, just a process and process, it is necessary to conduct some combat operations, but they are conducting them, well, how, how to understand it? it is clear that no matter what we think about the russians there, and they confirm their inadequacy from time to time, but in

any case, if at least not at the military level, at the tactical level, the brothers are persecuted there, well, quite clearly clear goals, if we talk about the time frame , then, for example, about what mr. yehor said before, it is based on such an application of technology, despite the fact that they probably also understand that with today's opportunities, intelligence, with the capabilities of ukrainian artillery, well, such attempts are doomed, if not to failure, then to huge sacrifices, but what pushes them, it is obvious that they are pushed by precisely these political goals or military-political goals, that is, they are forced to achieve a certain goal by a certain date border, at the same time, at the same time, the russian experts themselves claim that it is possible to talk about a breakthrough or some kind of success, it is not when one,

two or three positions are captured, it is when operational success is achieved, that is, the front line is broken on a wide area and this success continues to develop, as the ukrainian armed forces, the defense forces, have demonstrated, whether the kharkiv operation or the kherson operation, to date, according to many estimates, including, i want to emphasize, that those russian experts who are able to say not only there, shout cheers and report on successes, they, they are also critical of this, that is, they all agree that russia today does not possess, at least at the moment, does not possess the ability to plan and execute, offensive operations of operational, and even more so, strategic level.

ugh, let's talk a little, let's still go back to the issue of ataks and what they can, what they can't, in principle, we, well, when we talked with yehor firsov, we already touched on this topic a little, namely , which has intensified, well, from my point of view, at least i can see it when i watch the news , the action of aviation on the front has increased, and there have been shellings, well, there are just non-stop shellings, specifically air strikes, strikes on avdiivka, there were air strikes on kherson, along. line some kind of russian aviation is constantly operating on the front, and now, after the strike, atacames, well, at the base of this front-line, in fact, russian aviation, they destroyed, it seems, several helicopters, damaged a couple of planes, how could this affect the ability of russia to use its aviation at the front, because, after all, aviation

is front-line russian aviation... well, it causes serious enough problems for ukraine, especially considering the fact that the russians can use heavy faba eyes, and there are 500 bombs there, even now they said that there are already one and a half thousand kinots, yes , i'm right, somewhere around that size they tried to use bombs recently, that is, how here, what can we solve here, what are our problems? in order, briefly, back when i was studying in the 80s with soviet textbooks, at a military school, tactical aviation is located even... 100-150 km from the front line, and the russians, as we can see, quite often still use soviet textbooks, why 100-150 km, because this is the minimum

safe distance to avoid being hit, russian airfields of the enemy. as we can see, now with the appearance of such weapons in ukraine, a limited number, but then, now the russians... will be forced to either accept this risk, that there will be periodic strikes, or move their planes, their helicopters to a longer range, what is good about it, it reduces the intensity of application, because such factors as ee flight time, approach to the launch zone are superimposed, er, this applies to fuel, that is, the range of the aircraft. this also applies to the load on the flight crew, that is, the number of departures that can to be carried out during the day, accordingly decreases, what yehor also said about, well, most of all are used now and

are dangerous, these are the so-called guided aerial bombs, which are dropped from a high altitude, from a distance of about 50-60 km to the front line, well, today the ukrainian aviation does not have missiles that could safely hit these russian planes, because then our plane would have to approach the front line literally, and it too, it already falls within the range of russian anti-aircraft missiles, both ground and air, unfortunately, the russian aviation significantly prevails in terms of its characteristics, the ukrainian one, that is, the solution to this issue can be either more air defense systems, long -range radio judges, or then we are already waiting for the f16, which allows striking at a distance of more than 100 km, then this situation may be corrected, but for today

, as they say, we have what we have, if we talk about the russian aviation at all , well, if they are forced to pull it back a little, do they even have enough of this aviation in order to... at the same time be effective, how would you rate it, that is to what extent do they have the means in general, well, to work further from the front line, will they feel, you know, what worries me the most here is whether, for example, on the front line, the fighters, near-frontline soldiers will also feel some relief from the fact that they will be forced to continue working, whether they have enough and it doesn't matter, well, first of all, whether there will be relief, i already said that moving the base point from the front line is a decrease in the intensity of the use of this aviation. second, this, this is what, what, what is important to understand, in my opinion, the russian, so

-called, nuclear-space forces, demonstrated their inability to carry out large-scale air operations , that is, what they did in the first... weeks after the invasion, when russian planes flew almost unhindered on the territory of ukraine, including over the capital of ukraine, in kyiv, when air battles were going on, when they could drop bombs, not controlled, but just bombs, dropped very quickly ended, because even minimal countermeasures, that is, completely disproportionate countermeasures from the ukrainian ground defense and aviation. made such use of aviation impossible, and despite the fact that the russians are learning, despite the fact that they have these guided bombs, which are very dangerous, but they have not yet managed

to reach this level, when air operations are carried out, by nato, there by the americans, especially, because it is extremely a complex type of activity and this is also overcoming air defense, these are demonstration groups, that is, the russians are currently striking, almost all of these strikes are carried out without reaching the front line, so let's hope that ukrainian strikes on their airfields, even more will prevent, say, their ability to finally increase the efficiency of their aviation, well, it would be good if, in the end, they could not just stand at their usual border and fly from there so often, it would also be good for us that we they could also deliver them there with the same rockets, they did not tell us that it was not possible... god is on the territory

of russia, i hope that they will understand this in the end. thank you, this is oleksiy melnyk, then we continue our broadcast, my broadcast is ending personally, but watch the espresso tv channel, we have a lot of interesting information for you. got the virus, faith has it. inhaled dekasan enters the lungs where the virus works, dekasan works, faith rejoices, dekasan is an inhaled antidote to viruses and bacteria, and dekasan is indicated for angina, dekasan is an inhalation antiseptic. i was flying, flying, and a cough stopped me, a cough is a symptom of a respiratory disease, so we treat it respiratoryly, we do inhalation. lordegial is an inhalant for cough. lordegial is a direct way to expel phlegm. icelandic moss vitamin c - your power to fight cough and snarling. iceland. there is a discount. lozenges

20% in podorozhnyk, bam and ochad pharmacies. there are discounts on cosmetics for obey and feelfrie 1 + 1 = 3 in podorozhnyk bam taoshkad pharmacies. there are discounts on zest of 50% for any second package with a check at podorozhnyk bam and oskad pharmacies. espresso is the september leader among ukrainian information channels. we have held the championship for six months in a row. greetings, dear viewers, it's time to learn about the most important thing. according to measurement data, viewers choose the ukrainian view of videspresso. congratulations friends, mykola veresen, vitaly portnikov, good health to all. we thank the ukrainians for their trust. espresso works for you. see this week in the judicial review program. treason, contract killings and financial fraud. how does the supreme court help ex-people's deputy sheppelev avoid punishment? the applied savchenko law should not have been applied, and why does the united states

demand to check all judges of the supreme court? this is all an indicator of the huge problems that exist in the supreme court. on thursday , october 19, at 5:45 p.m., watch the judicial control program with tatiana shustrova on the espresso tv channel. mykola veresen, vitaly portnikov and the main topics of the week. if , god forbid, a truly tactical nuclear weapon is used against ukraine, it will certainly change the world. stories, problems, analysis and personalities, john herbst, the former ambassador of the united states to ukraine, awaits us. good afternoon, if you have questions, you will get answers, interesting questions too, worth looking into, portnikov veresen, every friday at 21:15 at espresso. every week , the saturday political club helps to understand the processes taking place in ukraine and the world. vitaly portnikov, host of espresso and

invited experts, based on the facts, give their assessment and forecast of the development of events, want to understand how our today will affect our tomorrow, watch the saturday political club, every saturday on espresso, hello, this is svoboda ranok, an information project of radio liberty. guests every day, this is the shipping district, kherson, inclusion live. we are somewhere in the vicinity of bakhmut, we are telling the main thing. on weekdays at 9:00. the war in ukraine is the main topic for ukrainians. victories and losses, analysis and forecasts, politics and geopolitics, serhiy rudenko and his guests will talk about all this.

program people who have information and shape public opinion, people who defend ukraine and create the future right now, the main and interesting thing in the program verdict by serhii rudenko, from monday to friday at 20:00, repeat at 12:10. unit to the head and ask there, to demand, specifically, help for the military unit, how to get an appointment with the minister. i want to say that some people cannot get to the reception of the minister for months, not that the teams of the units, so i think this is a false such, such an approach, so that we do not find a dialogue and that we did not find of this balance between the rear and between the front, so i am very sorry and it seems to me that

we will have problems with ensuring these delegated powers, thank you, there is only one thing, ms. larisa, i can clarify for you, this is your speech instead of amendments 87, 88, e, 90, 96, 104, 105, yes, 104, 105, 113, 121, which are further, 154 and 159, only 154 and 159, they are taken into account. if i'm not mistaken, instead of them, i can't count everything, then that's all, then that's all, then, without these last two, thank you, thank you, let's move on, next amendment 89, kiselevsky, does not insist, yes, homeland

has already spoken, 92 cooper, does not insist, 94 rascal does not insist. 97 ma lozynsky does not insist, 98 mama does not insist, 99 fries does not insist, sota mazurasho you have already reported, 101 krulko does not insist, 102 bondar does not insist, 103 kiselevsky does not insist, further 106 aleksiychuk does not insist, 107 - this is the homeland has already spoken. 108, please, mr. serhiy, dear colleagues, this is again an amendment that concerns local budgets, this amendment is proposed to be included on a permanent basis in the budgets of local governments in in the amount of 64%. this amount of pdf 64% was introduced at

the proposal of the president of ukraine, taking into account the local self-government budgets for 2022-23 . the size of 64% is not for nothing, but in order to get the communities to restrain the heat tariffs, and the tariffs keep the dispute, because the government never compensated the difference in the tariffs for the years 2002-23, i ask that this amendment be considered and voted for her, thank you for your attention, thank you, i am putting to the vote the 108 amendment of oleksiyev, it was rejected by the committee, please vote.

for 25, the decision has not been made, please, the next amendment, 109, now a second, lozynskyi does not insist, 110th bezhin does not insist. mykisha, please, thank you, rosslan oleksiiovych, the amendments will now go to the principle that in this amendment, we all know that local self-government helps the army, the army, the armed forces of ukraine, other military units since 2402. unfortunately, now the legislation, in some places, does not allow this to be done, and tomorrow they can come to the relevant communities with checks and then order them... in the literal sense and law enforcement agencies and other checks, therefore this amendment is precisely aimed at introducing into the legislation, on an official basis, financial and material assistance to the security and defense sector, and this was invented by the people's deputies, they

approached us with this, with this initiative local self-government, i want to thank the head of the opishnya community , mykola riznik and andriy mazan , who provided the appropriate amendments, which we processed in the committee, and it is now in the draft law, thank you, please, do you want to answer briefly, yes, well, if there is a need, please, well, i think there is a need, you will not insist on this amendment, you will, yes, thank you, yaroslav oleksiiovych, look, colleagues, this amendment is not supported by the committee, namely, in the proposed version, this norm would still be appropriate. e-e should be placed in final and transitive positions, because it is temporary, so it is rejected. thank you. thank you, mikisha's 111th amendment, it was rejected by the committee, you

have heard the arguments of the parties. please vote for 30, the decision has not been made, the next amendment, 112th, the mother does not insist, yes 113- we have already passed, 114th aleksiychuk does not insist, 115, colleagues do not insist, 116 kisevsky does not insist, 117, friz ihor does not insist, 118 mom does not insist, 119 friz ihor does not insist, 120th alexiychuk, does not insist, 100 21 have already been removed, 122 aleksiychuk and colleagues do not insist, 123, kiselevskyi does not insist, 124- kiselevskyi. don't insist, 125th, yuzhannina, please, i ask

to replace my 10 amendments with a speech for about 10 minutes, no, no, yes, it won't be like that, please let's go, 120, let's go with the amendments, we are always pleased, dear colleagues, for you to understand that everything the government is doing now, it is dividing the country, because immediately after the appearance of this draft law, we came out with proposals in order to to find a compromise, and i support the colleague who said just now that it is absolutely obvious that the search for a compromise together with the territorial communities should have taken place, it has not taken place, and you are now the 910th amendment, tonight, changing something there, nobody is doing anything about it knows even a moment just read that you are still moving in side of compromise, but you do it because of blood and hatred. to all the authorities that make this project, made this draft law, why are you doing this, if from the very beginning you were

inclined to make them, thank you, the 125th amendment, please, you can react, and the 125th amendment, thank you, ruslan oleksiyovych, no supported by the committee, colleagues, the norms of the specified item make it possible to direct funds to the priority expenses of local budgets in the conditions of martial law, without allowing inefficient expenses. therefore the amendment is rejected, thank you, thank you, 125 amendment yuzhalnyi committee rejected, i ask you to vote, for 20, no decision was made. please, 126- honcharenko, please, thank you, this is a very important correction, because we are talking about the fact that

it is not possible to take money from communities, that's all, you can't take and take money from people, and i want to apply to those who watch the broadcast, where are our servants of the people again, where are they all, there were so many servants of the people, and there would be as many as 30-40 people left here again, how many will be until the end, there is no need to work anymore, in local people work in the communities and you cannot take and take money from the local communities , and this is an absolutely blasphemous choice that you make, like, let's take it from the communities to give to the army, no, you take it from the president's office, you take it from the telethon, you take away in your endless series of the 95th quarter, take away oleksandr semenovich zelensky's life scholarship and give it to the army , don't take anything from local self-government and communities, and because you can't do that, it's destroying... decentralization, and it's a shame , absolute, so i insist on voting on this amendment. amendment 126

by hancharenko was rejected, please vote for 22, the decision has not been taken, please, next 127, razumkov. ruslan oleksiyovych, i have up to the 134th, 128, 129, 130, 131, 132, 133, 134, yes, how many minutes do you have, give me four minutes, four minutes, please, ruslan oleksiyovych, about half an hour ago you there was such a, in my opinion, correct, harsh speech that everyone should sit down, start working, please sit down, gentlemen, there should be no shame in the walls of the verkhovna rada, but now, well, there is

shame in the walls of the verkhovna rada, unfortunately, there are very few people left here. i would like to thank everyone in the hall of the verkhovna rada who believes that the laws concerning the financing of local self-government and the laws concerning the financing of the army are important, but there are not many of them here, and yesterday, where are all these facebook heroes, i don’t see them again in the walls of the verkhovna rada, some came out in factions, but i would like to ask, it was late yesterday, yes, everyone said that it was late at 11 in the evening, so everyone we parted ways, now it’s three minutes to three, people are all working, 14:57, the whole country is working, i’m not talking about the army that fights 24/7, but where are the people’s deputies, ruslan

oleksivych, you are the chairman of the verkhovna rada, you have to ensure the activity of the verkhovna rada of ukraine, we cannot vote even for amendments, because the constitutional court at one time prohibited it, and you know it, unfortunately, you violate the constitution of ukraine, i do not know why you do it, and unfortunately, we are seeing a bit of a double whammy, i i understand that you probably can't swim in everything, but when you appealed to the verkhovna rada to start working, it means that the entire verkhovna rada, or rather , the law for all enemies, that's not how it works either, let's finish our work for today, we'll wait until everyone comes and we'll discuss the amendments , many of them are conceptual, we've already gone through some of them while you were gone, oleksandr shergich put them to the vote, that's four 64%, leave it in

the communities, pdf increasing the marginal debt and many other things that i and my colleagues from we will set a reasonable policy, i think that it is the same as the other factions, then let 's either close today's meeting, take a break, wait until everyone has eaten, until everyone can return and start working, in general, i would like to see some kind of work schedule, so that yesterday, you couldn't answer who made the decision about how we work until 11:00 in the evening, i don't mind , but i would like everything to be on the record, because then there can be a record, let's move on, dear colleagues , 135 amendment krulka no

insists, 136 the railwayman does not insist, 137, yatsenko does not insist, 138 chornomorov does not insist, 10039 lionov, i already asked you , i asked, no, you, well, well, let's pass it on to a colleague, because he woke up, please, chornomoro , amendment 138, and 353, one minute, please, thank you, ruslan oleksiyovych, dear people's deputies, i would like to put these amendments to a vote, since they define three regions, directly mykolaiv, kharkiv and zaporizhia, and there is no no political at all take off the only political color that exists is that these regions are heroes, and the president of ukraine also noted this. in my opinion, the pdf of the military and law enforcement agencies should be left in these communities, since this is primarily their defense capability, and secondly, the people who lived in the basements during the shelling, it was these areas that suffered the most missile strikes, and these people really, really need a normal life in the conditions in which they

currently exist, these are outposts, this is in the region on the border with the temporarily occupied territories, therefore, dear colleagues, i ask you to support these amendments and pass them to the mykolaiv kharkiv and zaporizhia regions, leave the pdf in them, thank you, thank you, dear colleagues, 138 amendment and 353, i understand correctly, i am putting in turn, 138 amendment authored by chornomorov, rejected by the committee, please vote for 44 , the decision was not made, the following 353, dear colleagues from the factions, please show me 353 , please show me, oh my god, 353, i put it, it is also the authorship of chornomorov, it is rejected, please