[000:00:00;00] what is happening today, when president zelenskyi said: you will all receive 30k until the end of the war, all those in uniform , the military, the state emergency service, the police, everyone, then the war is not over, but the trident is over, and this is just disrespectful, and he is not even found the strength to come out and say, you know, guys, i thought so, i wanted to, but something is stopping me, uh... well, i don't know, you know what 's stopping who, there are different options, but something it bothers me, maybe like that dancer, but i can't now, i can't, the state is not paying, there is not enough money, there is not enough strength, well, go out and say it to the people 's faces, and we cannot pay, but if you want, i will tell you why he does not come out and do this, and i will tell you, friends, why doesn't he go out and do this, he doesn't go out and do this, because people immediately

ask him, and how come, then it goes out, which means that we have no money for drums, for tv shows, for eggs for 17 hryvnias , there is, so for this, it is necessary to take 17 hryvnias each from those who do this, and this is the first, once again respect, they promised people, well it's the same as how they left, people left, some volunteered, some were mobilized, left, and then a month later they would say, you know, i changed my mind, they are shooting here, here... they are flying, in general, people are dying here, and i i don't want anymore, well, you can't, and why is it possible for the president, and why is it possible for the parliament, why is it possible for the government , well, let's do it honestly, you said, you did, you said do, well, it's a manly, human, let's move on, this is about a three-year-old, this is not the whole story, by the way, about a thirty-year-old, we

even adopted this law in session hall 10 april, half a year ago, until now, they don’t exist, they hide it, i said 500 times in these two days about the 300, the resolution of the tzabel, everyone ignores it, they can’t bear it in order not to sign it and not return the money to the military, let’s move on, people had the average salary was paid, that is, if you were mobilized, but you received money at work, before that, you were not asked if you wanted to go or not, you received money, you were taken away, you left, well, what do they need you for, you fulfill. for the state, so the state has to return this money to you, why do you have it lose? last year, this law was repealed, well, the bill of lading was still valid then, but then we took the bill of lading away, but the same law has not been returned, the verkhovna rada now has my law, now it has my law, a bill on returning the average

salary to military personnel, come on we will take it out and consider it, okay, there is no 30. well, let's return the average salary , no, we don't need it either, we don't care, we don't care either, no, okay, go on, maybe everything is so good in our military, so what well, what else pays them there, well, they already have them chocolates, as they say there, yes, they have a hundred of them, this one, and you know that there are people with limited suitability, unsuitable, who are taken out of the state, and these people receive uah 500, 600, 700 per month, once again per month, well, how can you call it, well, what a shame, well, tell me, well, well, what can you call it, how can you live on 500, 600, 700 hryvnias per month, yes, now it is a law that i have been striving for for a long time , also speaking here for hours, 20,100 hryvnias are limited to suitable for the protection of the homeland, only those who are taken out of state will be

to pay extra, and others for military service. after completing military service after illness, you don't need to pay anything, let them live on 500 hryvnias a month, maybe one of you will try to live on 500 hryvnias a month, it's a shame, and these are people who have already lost their health for the state, well, let's give them back, and let's maybe let these people go at last, my bill to the verkhovna rada, to give the right to demobilization to those with limited fitness, well, you've already been recognized as limited fitness, well, you've already given your health for the state, do you want to serve? for you have a place, serve, well, but if you can’t already, well, let the person go, no, no, we won’t let them go, even disabled people, disabled people of the first and second groups, we also have a bill in the parliament regarding this, we won’t let them go home, well, as a disabled person of the first group, what can he do, no, they don't let him go, at all, the most important thing, maybe the question from everything i said is payments, these are additional payments, vacations, this is ubd, how much can

you worry about? our working group is developing, developing changes so that people automatically receive the status of ubd, not have to write applications for months, years from the trenches, they did not have to write an application for processing. personal data, and they are told, no, go, look for your combat magazines, which magazines, half of the unit burned, these parts have been changed a long time ago, people are sitting in the trenches, they need to fight there, not write war and peace and declarations, yes simple the decision to give automatically to people who were receiving combat allowance, a simple decision to give to people who were wounded, which means they were at zero, give to hundreds of thousands of people. automatically, and it drags, and drags, and drags, and drags on, and until now this draft law is not considered in the verkhovna rada, well, how much more time is needed, well, and probably the most important thing, when we talk about respect, then respect is

the fact that the protection of the homeland is everyone's business, not one million people who got into the trenches, some left voluntarily, some were mobilized , contract workers whose contracts expired a long time ago, they... were extended, conscripts who have been held for three years are not released, well, friends, well, we must be honest, how many well, let's serve them the term, well, okay, 18 months, my bill offers the right to demobilization after that , well, okay, not 18, 24, well, give these people a light at the end of the tunnel, tell them you did your part, you saved the homeland, we will now do our part , to support you, come on, dear colleagues. i am putting two amendments of goncharenko 744 and 750 in turn . goncharenko's amendment 744 was rejected by the committee,

please vote. for seven, the decision was not made by factions, by factions, please, e. and please , amendment 750 is also the authorship of honcharenko, please, it has been rejected by the committee, please vote for six, the decision has not been made, by factions, please, let's move on, let's move on , we have the next amendments, 500, 457 tsabal does not insist, 459 petrunyak does not insist, 460 moka does not insist, 461 - zabal does not insist

, 462 razumkov does not insist, 463 petrunyak does not insist, 464 mokan does not insist, 465 zabal does not insist, 466 razumkov does not insist, 467 petrunyak does not insist. 468 mokan does not insist, 469 tzabal does not insist, 470 razumkov does not insist, 481 - petrunyak does not insists, 472 mokan does not insist, 473 tsabal does not insist, 474 razumkov does not insist, 475 moka does not insist, 476 berezin does not insist, 477, vasylchenko and colleagues. they do not insist, 479 kitsak does not insist, 481, yuzhannina nina petrovna, please, i understand that 481 , 82, 83, 54, 518, 4 minutes instead, yes,

please, nina petrovna, dear colleagues, i will try after all, to finish, so that the opinion was more complete, when we submitted an alternative draft of the law, we immediately offered a certain compromise, and it is a pity, that the budget committee and such an order in the verkhovna rada that you did not even hear what the alternative draft of the law consisted of , because we are all talking about the personal income tax, this is a global part of this project, we also have a road fund, and looking at things completely soberly, we proposed, let's do it, let's make the road fund so that it is not included in the general boiler, and also goes to our armed forces, but so that it goes to

our armed forces, and if we talk about the construction of our defense complex, that we need to build new factories, we support this, and for this we need to direct a huge resource, not even 50 billion, as you suggested, it is possible all 90 billion of the expected road fund, and this is real money, this is money, excise tax for fuel produced and imported for vehicles, this is money that drips into the budget every month, so that it is precisely saved and used for a special special fund for the development of the defense-industrial complex, but through budget lending targeted programs, and kamyshyn agreed with this, i repeat once again, that is why there is no need to throw 90 billion into a common cauldron, it is all the same as rolling into the asphalt, as you did it during the two previous years, please, this has no meaning, i appeal to everyone,

then they have no value for this money. the second question, regarding the pdf, we in the alternative offered 70% for local authorities to spend according to the requests of the military. you say that the applications of the military may contain some invented things or some non- priority items entered there, this is not true. all the military agrees to appeal to the authorities...self-government by their financial departments, so it was actually possible to settle through the adoption of an alternative and amend it, if we had found such a compromise solution, you have forced all of us here today to sit and prove a point that is greater, it will be heard more by the people, not by the deputies, it turns out that the deputies do not need it, and i would very much like someone to object, or we would go to the deputies ' discussions, so that we would express our opinion

on this, because there are healthier mechanisms to help our armed forces forces, where there will be control, where there will be responsibility, where there will be programs that colleagues talked about, which we can precisely control, it will not be a spending, to be counted, it will not be sewing some side related expenses other than the armed forces. therefore, in fact, we offered another 30% to be given to local authorities for the construction of civil infrastructure for civil protection, and what is currently happening with schools, leave the city of kyiv, all schools are working offline, because they cannot ensure the safety of children, you are in vain so they put everything on the brakes and nullified the proposals of their colleagues, one day you will return to them, i am sure of it, which returned to the road fund when

it was all concentrated in the state budget, it is a pity that you want it again, thank you, nina petrivna , you have completed all your amendments, thank you, further, dear colleagues, let's go, yatsyk 485 does not insist, 486 babenko and colleagues do not insist, 487 razumkovi colleagues do not insist, 488 petrunyak and colleagues do not insist, 489 489 mokan and colleagues do not 490 pippa and colleagues do not insist, 494 arahamia and colleagues do not insist, 495 razumkov's colleagues do not insist, 496 petrunyak and colleagues do not insist, 497 mokan's colleagues do not insist, 499 razumkov 's colleagues do not insist, 500th petrunyak and colleagues do not insist, 501 mokan, colleagues do not insist, 502 reasonable colleagues do not insist , 503 petrunyak. colleagues do not insist, 504 mokani colleagues, do not insist, 505 razunkov colleagues

, do not insist, 506 petrunyak and colleagues do not insist, 507 mokan and colleagues do not insist, 509 razumkov and colleagues do not insist, 510 mokan and colleagues do not insist insist, further, further, further, dear colleagues, 516th, gerasimov, and i apologize , i have such information, 516, 517, 543, 544, 618 , 747, 748, 749, these are amendments co-authored by arriev and, gerasimov, i give six minutes , i understood correctly, i spoke for six minutes on these amendments and you insist on them , please turn on the microphone, please areva, dear colleagues. six minutes, please,

thank you very much, if we are talking about the need to support the military-industrial complex, for which the funds are actually supposed to be taken in local communities, first of all, we need to first, at least if we understand, or the state structures themselves, they respect the enterprises of the military-industrial complex, because what happened: recently, with the ukrainian armored vehicles with the luch design bureau, and here is a recent example, when nabu, e actually stopped the work of the manufacturer of ukrainian thermal imagers archer, a very well-known manufacturer, and not only that, they took away not only financial documentation from them, but also made copies of engineering design documents, then

the question arises, if we take this money, will it not turn out that it will be spent in vain, because any attacks on... the military-industrial complex today can be equated with treason and they happen and they happen all the time. and i am absolutely sure that for this we must first translate to restore order there. the second point is that the financing of the military industry and defense needs can be done completely from other sources, or partially take away the pdf, as we propose. a compromise option of 30% and add it to the road fund, add it,

much stronger control over the distribution of funds and in the tender procedures, and i can give an example, just a recent example, 400, more than 400 million uah were spent on the purchase of an internal power plant to support the zaporizhzhia nuclear power plant at a time when it was already is occupied, and when we ask energoatom, what is going on, and how is it that you purchased goods and services for the occupied station, half of which are catering for restaurants and buffets in the armed forces, they answer that you people's deputies are not you have the right... to be interested in such things, all these issues mean undermining ukraine's energy security. it is cynical and insolent when such words cover banal thefts, and there are a lot of such tenders, if you collect them, i am sorry, then if you stop

rubbing, forgive me for the expression on tenders, if you stop spending money on absolutely unnecessary now already mar-te phone... for television series for which 2.2 billion uah are allocated, then you can, please take yuzhanina nina petrovna, she will collect all the necessary amount for you literally in a few days to cover the costs that you want to take from the local communities, and if you take those costs from the local communities, then i 'll just say what's going to happen, well, apart from what i've already mentioned about them not being able to provide any more. .. parts that are relocated in these local communities and have registrations there, in particular cars, new cars, our military can forget about, because the ministry of defense does not buy them, and the communities simply will not be able to buy them with the remnants of what they have ,

newbies can forget about drones, about all these little things that it seems like little things, but they are simply necessary for the defenders, it will be possible to forget, but it will also be possible in many communities to forget about the purchase of medicines for hospitals, about the purchase of necessary educational materials for schools, about the purchase of basic, necessary spare parts for pumps , water utilities, in order to spend money on purchasing the necessary things to repair power grids, by the way, regarding power grids, the reuters agency has now analyzed the situation in ukraine and clearly said that we are by the next energy they are not ready for seasonal heating in winter, due to the fact that in winter, due to the fact that funds and time were not enough, that is, time is clear, but funds are the same, and we are talking about the fact that then, if

these funds were not enough, they were partly robbed, and now we are not even thinking about how to protect ourselves from the energy ... collapse, which may repeat itself this winter, and, both domestic and foreign experts are talking about it, so the local communities will actually have no funds left for what, those who are richer will somehow dig out, and those who are there, where the specific weight of the military pdf will be large, they will be left with nothing, and it will be again, as during yanukovych's time, mayors will go to bow to the cabinet of ministers and all this will be distributed manually, therefore, dear friends, i call for one simple thing, for a reasonable approach , let's just us... you figure out what should really be left to the communities instead of taking everything away and what can be handed down and that will be

a healthy compromise for everyone thank you thank you 519 amendment mommy doesn't insist uh yeah i i'm sorry, then, people's deputy arri, you, you will complete all your amendments, yes, with speeches, thank you, and there will be more, at the end, yes, thank you, sorry, then, mother 519, i do not insist, no, does not insist, i apologize, 520 yatsik, does not insist, 521 razunkov does not insist, 500 22 razumkov does not insist , 523 mazurashov does not insist, 524 petrunyak does not insist, 525 mokan, colleagues do not insist, 526 mokan and colleagues do not insist, 527 vasylchenko and colleagues do not insist. 528

oleksiyev does not insist, yes, he seems to be handsome, yes, 531 mizintseva does not insist with colleagues, 532 tistik does not insist with colleagues, tistik himself does not insists, 533 zagaruyko and colleagues do not insist, 534th, so dmytro oleksandrovymkov does not insist with colleagues, 535 petrunyak does not insist, 536 moka does not insist, 537 moka does not insist, 538 pipa and colleagues do not insist, 539 oleksiychuk and colleagues do not insist, 540 lionov does not insist, 541 savchuk does not insist, 500 356 a second, 545 proschuk does not insist, continue. 546 razumkov does not insist with his colleagues, 548 petrunyak does not insist with his colleagues, 549 mokin

does not insist with his colleagues, 550 and lionov does not insist, 551 bondar does not insist, 553 gerasimov artur volodymyrovych, and that's exactly what aryev is, so 553 and there's one more, right? and this is gerasimova 553 and i apologize, you have already spoken, marry her my way 553 you have already spoken, i apologize , spoken, yes, yes, spoken, sorry, yes, yes, sorry, yes, yes, yes, 554 mom does not insist, 555, purtova does not insist , 556- krulko does not insist, 557- tymoshenko and colleagues do not insist, 550. petrunyak does not insist, 559 does not insist, 560th razumkov and colleagues does not insist,

561st mokan and colleagues does not insist, 562 aleksiychuk does not insist , 563 aleksiychuk z colleagues do not insist, 564 aleksiychuk and his colleagues do not insist, 565 kiselevsky does not insist, 566 bondar does not insist, 567 majurasho does not insist, 568 the beekeeper does not insist. 569 laba does not insist, 570 laba does not insist, 571 beekeeper does not insist, 572 mother does not insist, 573 mazurashov has already spoken, 574th krulko does not insist, 575 tymoshenko and colleagues does not insist, 576 lazynsky does not insist, 577 bezgin does not insist, 578 aleksiychuk and his colleagues do not insist, 580 kiselevsky. 581. alexiyev

does not insist, 582. razumkov and his colleagues do not insists, 583 aleksiychuk and colleagues do not insist, 584 aleksiychuk and colleagues do not insist, 585 bundar does not insist, 587 mother and colleagues do not insist, 588 proshchuk does not insist, 589 mother does not insist, 59- vasylchenko and colleagues does not insist, 591 savchuk does not insist , 592 krulko does not insist, 593 aleksiychuk does not insist, 594 alexiychuk and colleagues do not insist, 595 tymoshenko and colleagues do not insist, 596 aleksiychuk and colleagues do not insist, 597, kiselevsky does not insist, 598, shapovalov does not insist, 599 bondar does not insist, 600 alekseev does not insist, 601 mokan and his colleagues do not insist, 602 alexieev does not insist. 603 petrunyak and colleagues do not insist, 604 oleksiychuk and colleagues do not insist, 605 aleksiychuk

and colleagues do not insist, 606 - tymoshenko and colleagues do not insist, 607 kiselevsky does not insist, 608 bondar does not insist, 609 alexiyev does not insist, 610, zheleznyak does not insist, 611 razunkov and colleagues do not insist, 612 mokan and colleagues do not insist, 613 petrunyak and colleagues do not insist, 614 savchuk does not insist, 615 ruble does not insist. so we have already passed the next one impassable 619 razunkov and his colleagues do not insist, 620 petrunyak and his colleagues do not insist, 621 mokan and his colleagues do not insist, 622 radutsky and his colleagues do not insist, radutsky himself, i apologize, does not insist, 623 yatsenko does not insist, 624 yatsenko does not insist,

625 yatsenko does not insists, 626 gerasimova. with colleagues at 626, yes, yes, sorry, yes, i have such a 626, from 626 to 636, replacement for 7 minutes, correct, the floor is given to ariev, 626 - 636, amendments of ariev with colleagues, please, to my great regret, very often it happens in ukraine that something has to be bought they start smaller and weaker, but now they have decided... to fill, to fill the holes in the central budget at the expense of local communities, and they take 94 billion from them, and if we fail to collect taxes, then now first of all they start to shake who ? people, individuals, entrepreneurs, now people are writing to me

about the fact that brave guys are already walking the markets. in hides and begin to simply take skins for skins, thank you for taftology, and those entrepreneurs who trade there and shake them out, on the subject, on the subject of inspections of the how they run their business. that is, you know, it reminds me of the well-known children's cartoon about chepolino and the kingdom of vegetables, when from... from vegetables, yes, mr. tomatoes, some of them were shaken out, the last one, i understand that you appreciate radari, he is left-handed, he closer to the socialists, but for some reason only the small ones really begin to be shaken, and the big ones are not touched, why don't we, in the budget, take a look

at the budget, the draft budget for 2024 and analyze it, and what is the rent from mining from those who extract minerals, and there will be very interesting moments. in particular, it is planned to reduce the rent for natural gas producers in ukraine by uah 41 billion compared to 2023, and i want to remind you who is behind who is behind gas construction, and this. kolomoisky's company, akhmetov's company, pinchuk's company, zlachevsky's company, who was the minister of environmental protection in yanukovych's government, even shufrich's company, but i think that shufrich is busy now with a little bit of other issues, but

for some reason everything is fine with them, for some reason they they don't want, they reduce their rent for... production of natural gas, and there is also ore, and there is also gas condensate, from the fraction of which oil is extracted, therefore , let's consider these sources, i say again, we have a member of our fraction, people's deputy nina yuzhannina, who in budget... swims like a shark in the mediterranean sea, and it can find everything in order to leave the local communities as much as possible, leave the local communities alone as much as possible, but look, if we are talking about how much the communities will lose, then kyiv, as