[000:00:00;00] because as a rule, let's say, all those russian deadlines, which are reported by the main intelligence department, the ministry of defense, and, accordingly, other expert circles and representatives of the military-civilian administration, it is either taken from the ceiling, or frankly does not correspond, that real situation on the battle line, by the way, about the real situation, we certainly do not report losses, they are not classified, putin recently blurted out the truth that there were one to eight losses in favor of russia during the offensive near avdivka and everywhere there and so on, well, it’s understandable, the wall street journal wrote about the fact that since the beginning of the ukrainian counteroffensive, and actually during the ukrainian counteroffensive, 177 russian artillery installations were destroyed and documented, 177,

including 92 artillery units equipment only in the zaporizhzhia direction , against 19, documented, confirmed ukrainian artillery systems, these are the numbers they call, that is, it is about one to five, at least in the zaporizhzhia direction, and many, michael kofman, in particular an authoritative american expert believes that what is actually happening is gradually being forged tactically, but the most important advantage is precisely in the artillery systems, and by the way, everyone who joined us today all noted that plus-minus parity in terms of shells, in terms of firepower , it is already established, despite the fact that the russians continue to hit the square, well, ours continue to hit them with aim, well, let's explain what we are talking about, we are talking about the successful nature of the counter-bagaatary struggle, due to

tactical and technical characteristics, western weapons that are in service with the armed forces, eh, the range of damage compared to the russian , soviet ones, which are in the service of the occupiers one and a half to two times more, eh, that is, if the russian system can hit, means of damage, we are talking about barrel artillery 20- 25 km, then, accordingly, the armed forces can cover at a distance of up to 40 km, plus the effective use of counter-battery radars of western... production, this gives its signs, positive, the statistics you are talking about, and the successful nature of counter-battery combat, are also reported the russians themselves, not in to the public, i would like to remind you that the resignation of the commander of the 58th combined arms army in the zaporozhye region, ivan popov, to the pseudo -spartak major general of the armed forces of the russian federation, was connected with his statements about

the successful nature of the counter-battery fight, the ukrainian defenders and, accordingly, the huge losses of the occupiers in this area of the front, by the way, colleagues, it is quite remarkable that the other day there was another rotation, so to speak , of the commander of the 58th, combined army of the occupation troops, lamin, who was appointed to replace popov, stayed on position for a little more than three months, it shows. showed that the ukrainian counteroffensive did not stop, despite all the false statements of the western media, and accordingly, the losses of the russians are quite serious, which are confirmed by the autumn intelligence and the statements of the russian muzhnovists themselves, that is, the favorite of gerasimov, the chief of the general staff of the armed forces of the russian federation lyamin, he is 44 years old, a lieutenant general, a man who had to

master the battle. the situation, accordingly, to make a certain career growth path again, well, let's say, positive news from the zaporizhia direction, he was actually forced to admit the military defeat of the invaders. it's definitely in our hands, thank you very much, mr. dmytro, dmytro sneger, military expert, co-chairman, he was with us from case to case, well, what about us, now we're going, what, where we're going, we're not going to which one, we 're not going on a break, we now we will... talk with iryna fedoriva, journalist, public activist, we will talk about what is happening in ukraine with the supreme court, and why, it seems that the authorities want to control the supreme court, what is this instance, why is it important, because ukrainians sometimes do not fully understand all kinds of such instances, they think that somehow everything happens there by itself, in fact, control over the supreme court, this means that

there will be even less of their own in ukraine, is there already iryna, there is already, yes, iryna fedoriv, ​​a journalist and public figure. we are adding her to our broadcast, iryna , congratulations, congratulations, i actually read your, your article on the espresso website about the fact that the government wants to control the supreme court and this is indicated by the new draft laws, if you explain to ukrainians, so briefly for a boy's mind, what is the supreme court, why it is important and why it is important that it is not controlled by the authorities. well, look, the supreme court, probably all ukrainians understand the importance of the supreme court after 2004, when yanukovych was not elected, but according to the results of the second round of elections, yanukovych should have become the president, and here in the court the supreme court, actually such a court of

courts, appointed the so-called third round, and even then, did not allow a state traitor to seize power in the country in an illegal way, and citizens should understand that this court currently has a large chamber, and this large chamber is very important, this is real, it is a court within a court, this is the pinnacle of our judicial system, and when , for example, we tried to remove from office the judges of the maidanites who tried the maidanites then, in fact, the grand chamber put a decisive point in many issues, that is, the grand chamber, it can end the career of a non-virtuous judge, and this is very important, and of course, if we are talking about the protection of coastal strips, the natural resource fund, forests, so here

they themselves put the final point, but recently, thanks to the great chamber, the tereshchenko manor in the city of kyiv was protected, that is, this is the final point, no one can appeal anything from now on, and of course, all times, all presidents, they would dream of influencing the supreme court, well, for now to the great chamber, and here we see how the bills of mr. serhiy vlasenko appeared, he is a patriot, mr. pavlish, he is a servant of the people, he submitted an alternative bill to the owner, and there are very interesting changes in how the great chamber should be formed, and i'm real here i see the levers that are being built in order to make it easier to influence the great chamber, this story itself, by the way, with the prince's, i, that is, you know it. it is interesting because in our country, in principle, bribers are caught, very high , but they are always caught somewhere in some necessary places, for example, we have a bunch of mayors now, removed from performance, performance

of duties, and there are a million other judges, where in principle no one moves anyone, wolf, in general, what is his status as a judge wolf, he is still a judge or not a judge, i don’t know, well oask, in fact, they were liquidated, you see, and now there is a very complicated system, which cases are transferred to where, well, the courts are really very busy now because you were canceled, because of what happened there with the judges of oask, that is also a separate story , because there is not a lone wolf in that oask, but you rightly said that in essence this is the effect of the prince, he gave us such bills, and what do they really want to do with this great chamber, they want him to be there, for example, not 21 judges, and 14 and that judges can be recalled. people may think, oh, cool, let's recall the judges, this is wonderful populism, in fact, the situation looks like this, the judge will be recalled from the big chamber to the court of cassation, that is, he remains in the system of the court of cassation, if

the judge is dishonest, well, for example, such as knyazev or vovk, then we don't need to return him to the judicial system, he should get out of the judicial system and bear responsibility, and if the judge is good, then why recall him from the grand chamber, and look, there is a danger here: the number is decreasing, as the lawmakers propose judges of the grand chamber, because the tool to recall also appears, that is, now i need eight votes in the grand chamber for the decision to be, for example, and if there is an influence on five or six judges, and two can be recalled and replaced, well, that's in the principle gives tools to somehow influence the final decision, but the legislators went further. the head of the profile committee, denys maslav , submitted his bill, also under the influence of the knyazev effect, that if someone was caught like knyazev, then all judges are subject to monitoring and can go to

lie detector. well, this is another populism. we all remember how the representatives of the servant of the people used a lie detector in 2019 when they said that probably someone took money for such voting positions, there may be corruption, and for...' dubinsky on the lie detector, arahamiya on the lie detector , but this is just hype, which did not end with anything in fact, and now imagine the impact that can be made. on the judges, if they tell you there, they can recall you, and now they will use a lie detector against you and you are not guilty of anything, well, you work normally, how can a judge work independently in these conditions, and there are real threats to the independence of the court, because there can be pressure on the court and pressure on the judge, and if we have there won't be an independent branch of government, well, then investors simply won't come to us, normal, good reconstruction won't start. because everyone will understand that there are no courts, everything

is decided politically and from the point of view of corruption. and can our partners see what is happening around of the supreme court and somehow hint to our authorities that this should not be done? well, they already hinted , actually, because there is a decision of the venice commission, that is theirs, regarding all these lie detectors and so on, and they said that this is not normal. situation, because in principle, a lie detector is not an evidentiary method, in fact, well, we talked to the chairman of the committee that submitted this bill, he promised to look at the conclusions of the venetian woman, to look at what is being said, and the public sector, because the foundation, in particular, expressed reservations mr. jernakov, who heads it, and i hope that these bills will not reach consideration in the hall, according to... judge ms. kibenko, who said that

when, this is a judge of the supreme court, that when lawmakers make some changes , there must be expediency, this change must have an effect on something, and if you just sit and say, well, we will simply reduce the number of courts, and the secretary will now be chosen, not by the grand chamber, the secretary of the grand chamber will not be chosen by the grand chamber, but by the plenum, and zhernakov, who is the head of the foundation, he talks about the fact that most judges of the supreme court, he has expertise. in this matter, they gravitate towards banking, and you understand that now the plenary session of the supreme court, in fact , supported the initiative of the servant of the people pavlish by a majority of votes, so there are threats, we have to talk about it as a public sector, for that , in order to prevent pressure on judges and to do everything so that we have an independent branch of government, well, we say, actually now on the air as well, i hope that other mass media will also... about it

they will talk about it, maybe somewhere in the single news it will be mentioned, also, thank you ms. iryna, for your participation, iryna fedoriv, ​​journalist, public figure, with whom they talked about the fact that there is a threat that the authorities want to control the supreme court, now we're going to take a short break, then we'll come back and talk about the situation in israel. picked up faith has faith in dekasan inhaled dekasan gets into the lungs where the dekasan virus works, faith rejoices, dekasan inhalation counteracts viruses and bacteria, and dekasan is also indicated with angina, dekasan is an inhalation antiseptic. stiffness in the joints and spine, osteochondrosis, gout, radiculitis, arthritis and arthrosis. with all these problems, you will find the means for external use of decrasin useful. consultations by phone 0800-215-349. calls are free. it was me. previously, bleeding gums, inflammation of the gums, and

the solution was so simple: problems with the gums, lacquer activ. lacal active actively overcomes bleeding gums, protects against periodontitis and visibly tightens the gums. lakalut aktiv - an action that you feel immediately. novelty lakalut active + - even more active protection. barcelona miner on mego-go. after an emotional victory in belgium, the miners are still... support shakhtar on october 25 at 7:45 p.m. exclusively on mego, there are discounts on animit gel, 10% in pharmacies porodoznyk, bam and savings, there are discounts on oracept spray, 20% in pharmacies podorozhnyk, bam and oskad, there are discounts on septifril darnytsia pills, 10% in podorozhnyk,

bam and oskad pharmacies. we decided to carry out a special military operation, this is only an illustration of a much bigger and more dangerous story, as in 30 years the russian orthodox church in ukraine has evolved from agitators of the russian world to terrorists. if it were not for the activities of the russian orthodox church, there would be no war. we firmly know that russian peace and russian orthodoxy bring us war, death and

ruins. vitaly portnikov is with you and we are talking about the main events of this week. vitaly portnikov and top experts about the most vivid events of the last seven days. our guest will be lieutenant general of the ground forces, former national security adviser to the president of the united states, donald trump, herbert mcmaster. current topics, pressing questions, authoritative comments and forecasts in the information marathon project with vitaly portnikov, every sunday at 20:10 on espresso. dear friends, we are back on the air and now we will talk about what is happening in and around israel. vadym polyashchuk, historian, political commentator from israel. maybe we can understand all the news that comes from wittil. mr. vadim, we congratulate you. good day. the most recent information, the wall street journal reports that the negotiations with the militants hamas on the release of 50 hostages, these negotiations led by the us, israel and qatar failed. is anything known about the fate of those

people and whether it is even possible to negotiate with hamas, is there any hope that those people will be released? well, there is always hope. but we can see how earlier in cases when hamas took hostages, it was all drawn out and they bargained, and there were, there was a case when the israeli authorities made concessions and there was an exchange of one soldier for a thousand militants who were sitting in prisons of israel, so this is their resource, they even recruited them in such a number that they would then bargain for years, bargain for some concessions for themselves, some preferences for themselves, the new yorker writes about this, about the fact that biden’s near-eastern tour was not very successful, and in general, in israel

senior officials seem to have warned the americans that the possible outcome of this ground operation that is being planned now is a war that could last 10 years, a major war in the middle east, or is it being discussed the same way now in israel on... how likely is this war to appear? , well, probably you they saw that there was an opportunity to somehow come to an agreement with the administration of the palestinian authority, well, indeed, every operation should have a goal, just to carry out the operation, and what to do next, that is, there was an option discussed that after israel takes control of the gas sector, that the administration this sector was done by the palestinian authority, but after the operation, the information operation with the hospital in the gaza sector, the possibility of such an option is unlikely, and now there are already rumors that

there is talk of the administration happened to the organization of the united nations, how effective will it be, well, i don't remember cases when bon administered any territory, especially such a warlike one, permeated with military scum such as the gaza sector, well, to be honest, i have there are big doubts that it will be effective, but all the same, this foreign operation should be the ultimate political goal in the first place, why is israel doing it, why is it laying down its life? resources and so on and really risks that more can happen a large-scale conflict with hisballa, involving some other players. mr. vadim, i remember that we spoke with you right in the middle of nowhere, when in israel, all this was just beginning, and

two weeks have already passed since that day, recalling the doomsday war, which lasted as many as 18 days. what are your predictions, how much longer can things take this time and how much longer? well, we see that this war is not in the same format as it was during the doomsday war, when it was a completely convectional war, and columns of tanks moved, planes, anti-aircraft defense, and in fact, these 18 days, all this happened because of lightning. by the encirclement of the egyptian army in the sinai peninsula, when the egyptians were forced to capitulate, it was well, if there was not this operation, then this war could have dragged on much longer, and here we actually see that from the counter-terrorist operation, which

was actually in the first days, yes, when these groups were liquidated, which entered the territory of israel and committed genocide here, it is now in such a state of development only into a full-fledged military operation, that is, the israelis are ready, ready to start such an operation, but so far they are not starting, and when they start, how long will it last, will someone else join, well , there are many factors, so it is very difficult to predict here, if it was only a question of entering the territory of the gas and clearing , well, even the military could not say, because here there are also many different, let's say so, options for the development of these events, or gas these terrorists are shaking. will begin to give up or try to leave the sector in some way, or will they be running around in these underground

communications, they will be around for a long time catch out, there are a lot of factors, it may be some military experts who took part in such operations , they could say something, for sure, but anyway, well, a lot of things affect the duration of such processes, you know, i will ask you to show them right now video from harvard. actually, from harvard, from harvard university, where i watched him today, and i asked him to comment on our, my interlocutor, who was joining from kherson, where there was shelling again, then people died again, by the way, today it was recognized, yesterday, it seems, the un commission recognized about what it was, it was not an indiscriminate attack on atb, remember, there is a large chain of stores, when dozens of people died, many were very injured, and in this video, if

we finally show it, we will see, it with sound, we can show with sound, we can show without sound, it doesn't really matter much to me, just a lot of harvard students are lying here, you see, holding signs like this: stop gas bombing, kill palestinians, i don't remember if there were such actions by the students of gar. for those already one and a half years of the war, the war in ukraine, honestly speaking, a storm, somehow people were killed at the same time who came to the memorial service, and this is harvard, that is, in principle , it is the elite of the world, in fact, the future at that time studies there, it is the most prestigious university in the world, here is yours, how could you comment on the video, well, all these are the consequences of this, let's say, left-wing agenda, which prevails in these higher educational institutions of europe, and unfortunately, also in the higher

educational institutions of israel, where people are somehow brought up like this, well, there is some a summons that is advancing, and they are in line with it subpoenas, they move, they have some kind of sacred cows, that is, they are now protecting some disadvantaged people, tomorrow others, how disadvantaged they are, it's like... you know, uh, well, actually, they, no, no, no they reckon with what is in reality, and with what, let's say, that now this leftist community is profitable now, who to protect, today they protect women, tomorrow they protect transgender people against women, the day after tomorrow they will protect arabs, against against transgender people , tomorrow someone else like that, the same thing happened here... with this one capture, premises in the capitol by these jewish organizations that are anti-israel, in fact, they are the same

, they will stop, that is, they do not mention the killed israelis, the severed heads of children, the burned, burned alive people, well, they are not israelis now they defend, the israelis are bad, you can do whatever you want with them, they won’t open their mouths, the same , but the palestinians, they are for... they defend them, and don’t touch the palestinians, but the ukrainians are somehow not included in this agenda, more than 200 young people died simply during the shooting of this festival, and the day after day of the attack by hamas, more than 200, it seems, and the dead, these were young people who most likely , after all, had absolutely liberal views, among them, i think, there were many representatives of the lgbt community, and this there were people who came from different countries of sweden, who came from different countries of the world. then these are actually people who have much, much more in common with harvard students, but

why not then a challenge, this lying down protest or something else, but now? when information appeared, which turned out to be false, a lot measure, about the strike, i mean about this hospital, how it turned out that it was not an israeli rocket, that there were not 500 and even more so 800 killed there, well, that is, it was disinformation from the very beginning, we will of course still we don't know, as far as i understand it, that american intelligence confirmed that it was probably an attack by hamas terrorists themselves, well, yes, there is the palestinian side, they did not provide any proof that this was an israeli attack, not a single photo, not a single, well, any argument like that , just emotionally stated, some, even the israeli media picked up on it, they scattered it all over the world, these people in european countries rose to the stake, went there to storm something, to protest, and

in fact, even then, few people heard the questioning, and who did, well, it’s the same as the israelis, what is there to believe in this, but as for the one who suffered there, in fact, it was not exactly those who suffered, not some religious jews, not the settlers, whom they constantly shame, but it was precisely this leftist, leftist ashkinite elite who, well, all these years, suffered in principle, the center of this, well, somehow try come to an agreement with the arabs, understand them, forgive them, somehow find some common language, all the otkitsy on the border, there most of the people had such an old leftist idea that even their grandfathers were socialists who founded israel, these young people who invented at the festival, this yes, these are the people who live in the center of israel and these are the lgbt, these are the structures, all those who just before the war spoke out against attempts to somehow normalize the legal

system, there are democrats. here they shouted, shame, they shouted at the government of israel, and they were the first to be hit by this blow, and many of them are a little urban city ​​posts began to fall into place a little, but abroad, those people who support palestine do not yet have city posts, i would not like to wish them such a thing that people on the border would experience here, but well, maybe only we will put such things in their place, and for sure. we can see the fact in ukraine that people even in the cities that are under attack by the russians, they are still waiting for the russian peace there, hoping that it will bring them something like that there, well, some great joy and liberation. mr. vadim, thank you for the conversation, vadim polishchuk, historian and a political commentator from israel was with us, we remind you that you are watching the marathon on espresso

, lesya vakulyuk and andriy saichuk, we work in this studio for you, well, we are slowly approaching 3 o'clock, at 3 o'clock we traditionally have a news release and we will find out now, what happened there in ukraine and the world during this hour, and you know what i wanted to say at the very end, very interesting, let's talk, by the way, about the visit, for two days everyone asked what putin brought from xi jinping, what they were talking about agreed, you know, it looks like they didn't agree on anything here is just the main case, the main case that was in that, in that box, not the one that was nuclear and not the one that was with waste, not nuclear, but in that third box, they really hoped to bring a new gas contract with china, well, but china did not sign anything with them, they said that we have enough gas , so go to the forest, enjoy yourself for now , it is still yours, but it will not last long, dear friends,

three o'clock is approaching, personal seconds remain, anna notes that eva melnyk is ready and has a fresh selection of news, and she will tell you about it. anna eva, i congratulate you, to you word. good afternoon, colleagues, thank you for your work, the newsroom is working, we will talk about the most important events for the moment, stay with us. fast and convenient. government. supported the proposal of the ministry of defense of ukraine and simplified the purchase and access to the operation of the electronic warfare system. in march, such a procedure was applied to drones and was quite successful, according to the ministry of defense, the approval of rep. will now take place on the basis of the act of joint departmental tests, or on the basis of the results of the declared tactical and technical characteristics, previously this process was quite

long, involved studying the document