[000:00:00;00] for 254, the decision has been made, by factions, please show, dear colleagues, whether the people's deputies will insist on voting on the proposals, or we can immediately on... there will be, yes, there are people's deputies who have rights, dear colleagues, well, let's sit down, we are sitting because our task is to make this budget the most perfect, therefore, dear colleagues, we will go the way we always go with you , please, dear colleagues, let's start, tymoshenko, the first amendment insists, dear colleagues, i

don't... i don't see, go away, please, i don't see people's deputies, don't insist, thank you razumkov, the second amendment, please, razumkov, dmytro oleksandrovich and colleagues, thank you, ruslan oleksiyovych, we are not sitting while we are working, but different things happen there , let's move on, regarding the law on the state budget, i see that the people's deputies are again disagreeing, they are not interested in it, it is precisely against the background of the fact that everyone just said that this is the budget of a warring country. i hope the rada tv channel will show it, show how who votes, so that later at 10 o'clock in the evening they don't write again about the fact that they worked 11 hours, and regarding 11 hours, i would like to, and to committee, and to turn to the chairman of the verkhovna rada, there were a lot of questions here, so that we worked for 11 hours in a row, by 10:038 you sent to the president's office only

after 5 days, if it was urgent. so what prevented you from doing that, and the second amendment is about increasing both the income and the expenses that were calculated for the association of cities, i hope you will support it, it is reasonable, correct, like everything, the position of the committee, please, briefly, is proposed reject this amendment, thank you, the second amendment is reasonable and colleagues, it was rejected by the committee, i ask people's deputies to vote. for 73, the decision has not been made, thank you, please, let's move on, friz, ihor pavlovich, does not insist, the third amendment, the fourth amendment, purtova does not insist, the fifth amendment,

hancharenko, please, hancharenko. oleksiy, oleksiy honcharenko. friends, what is happening in the verkhovna rada, why is nobody listening to anyone, why is nobody interested in the state budget of ukraine? look, friends, they are simply not interested, colleagues, they are already in their own lives, everyone talks about their own, for their own, it seems to me that only mr. chairman listens to me, well then, here's the deputy chairman, well, then i'll talk to the presidium. dear friends, i am asking you to vote for this, this is an important amendment that will allow us to raise the issue of social benefits, because this budget today provides for the freezing of social benefits, de facto, uah 860 per child, a pension of uah 2,000-200, as per a person can live on these funds, colleagues who come here don't care, but it is impossible to live on this money, so we

need to review this budget and find reserves and resources that dear colleagues goncharenko's amendment was rejected by the committee. i ask you to vote for 64. the decision was not taken. the next amendment is the sixth. buzhanskyi and his colleagues. no, does not insist, the seventh amendment, krulko, does not insist, the eighth amendment , tistik, does not insist, the ninth amendment, flu, does not insist, the tenth amendment, proshchuk, does not insist, the 11th amendment, babenko, does not insist, 12 -th amendment, friz, igor pavlovich, does not insist, 13th amendment purtovov, does not insist, 14th honcharenko, please, oleksiy oleksiyovych, oleksiy honcharenko, i will extend a little to my colleagues

tell. what is happening is also , unfortunately, not only that it is largely a budget not for war, but bullshit, because we see there again marathons, drums, serials and everything else. then this is also the budget of schooling, schooling. friends, i will give a specific example, article eight of the draft law provides, let me remind you, that the minimum wage in our country will increase to uah 7,100 from january 1 and uah 800 from april 1. and right there in the same paragraph it is said that in order to calculate the amount of payments according to the decision of the courts, and this is important, for example, for chernobyl, for some and other categories, consider not uah 8,000, but uah 1,600, that is, we artificially underestimate the payments by five times, for example, to the people of chernobyl , what does the head of the zhytomyr regional

organization of the servants of the people pushkarenko think about this, i'm not a bitch, please, pushkarenko, right on the reply and then we will vote, dear colleagues, indeed, the eighth article of the budget provides for the fact that in the next year the minimum wage will increase twice in our country from january 1 to 700, from april 1 to 800, and it is great that the government found an opportunity and laid i think that we will support it, but there is really such a situation that in this eighth article of the budget, which provides for it. there is a fourth paragraph, where 1,600 is calculated based on court decisions . citizens of the chernobyl organization of city councils are contacting me today about the fact that this is indeed creating social tension in

the border regions, border communities that suffered from the chernobyl disaster. therefore, i am calling on my colleagues today to correct this mistake by several officials and take into account and protect the social rights of our citizens, our citizens who suffered as a result of the chernobyl disaster. thank you. thank you. the committee's position on the 14th should still be rejected, right? ruslan andriivna. thank you. honcharenko's 14th amendment was rejected by the committee, please vote. for 60. the decision is not taken, then 15, buzhanskyi does not insist , krulko does not insist on any of his amendments, tistik does not insist on any of his amendments, so i understood correctly, thank you, flu does not insist

on any of his amendments, yes, thank you, proschuk does not insist on the 19th amendment, babenko does not insist on the 20th don't insist, 21sha goncharenko, please, thank you, dear friends, i will continue, unfortunately , i see that the deputies are not interested, but i will continue to tell you about real life in the state, not the fictional one that you are living in now, getting your constant somewhere, having in your plans, rest, where on some other islands or somewhere else, but real life, and real life is like this, we say, this budget should be a warring country, the army is a priority, and now i will tell you about reality of our army, and she is like that, a person gives his health for the state, becomes

unsuitable, for example, for the dsev or other such serious troops, a person is taken out of state and a person starts receiving 600, 700, 800 uah per month, not per day, not for one coffee, not for a month, well, this is a shame, change it. goncharenko's 21st amendment, the committee asks to vote in favor of the 52 decision not taken 22 does not insist 23 buzhanskyi and his colleagues do not insist, 24th krulko does not insist, 25th the flu does not insist, 26th. does not insist, on the 27th babenko does not insist, on the 28th the committee on issues does not insist, it is rejected, on the 29th the railway, no insists, the 30th krulko does not insist, the 31st - the committee on economic

development does not insist, the 32nd amendment, the committee on economic development does not insist, 33, 33 yevushka, one minute please, yevtushok, thank you sir. faction fatherland, in my amendment i asked to exclude the eighth article, which states in the third paragraph that the government decided for some reason. instead of the normal figure, which the government provides for this year in the amount of the minimum wage of 7,100, puts those categories, pensioners who live in chernobyl zone and have already received a judge's decision to limit such payments to uah 1,600, this is a violation of the 22nd article of the constitution of ukraine, the government should first of all conduct a monitoring and analysis of whether

there are more patients in these zones, the third zone, the second zone , the first zone, people for cancer , and only then think about reducing expenses, so dear colleagues , let's support my proposal, we will remove the eighth article of this law, the 33rd amendment, the colleague by his colleagues, it was rejected by the committee, i ask you to vote. for 53, no decision has been made. let's move on, dear colleagues, 34th efimov with colleagues, does not insist, 35- trytyakova, does not insist, 36 yefimov, does not insist, 37, tymoshenko does not insist, but, i apologize, 37, we

agreed, 5 minutes instead of all amendments , which are co-authored, please, mykhailo mykhailovych, mykhailo tsimbalyuk, homeland, dear, dear mr. chairman, presidium, dear colleagues, indeed, the topic of the budget today is the main challenge for the verkhovna rada, for the government as a whole, if we speak objectively , then this is the budget of the warring party state, already the second. the defense and security sector is in the first place and a priority, of course we support this, in the second place is social policy, if we say that the overall figures have increased by almost 50 billion, this is positive, but when we talk about specifics, let me dwell on a few remarks, first - this is a veteran's policy. when we talk about veteran policy, i think that tomorrow in the session hall we will have the opportunity to talk with the minister of this

area, there are many comments, firstly, the draft budget allocates funds for veterans' service or service of veterans' assistants, but even in the social policy committee the model was not presented, as the ministry sees the creation of this service is extremely important, and it is expected on the ground. the next thing, we want to clearly understand, will be the use of the funds allocated for the purchase of equipment, the purchase of housing for military families, for their families, this is also an extremely important issue. the next thing, we, a colleague from the fraction ivan krulko, already said, additional funds are already allocated for treatment, seriously injured, for prosthetics, this is also

a positive thing. and even the fact that already now the budget committee is additionally allocating funds for the prosthetics of military and civilian persons who were injured as a result of the war, this is also a positive thing, but the living wage, of course, what is it, it is a macro indicator that is laid down in the draft budget, it does not withstand any criticism, because those almost 3,000 hryvnias, it falls... er , it is the main statistical figure, how more than 20 social benefits and payments are paid, that is , it is unacceptable that the draft budget should include such an underestimated amount, which does not even cover half of the real subsistence minimum, and the government needs to revise this figure. we proposed to allocate the following in the budget. for the next year, 150 million for

the treatment of children who are deprived of parental care, orphans, who were rehabilitated annually in the territory of the western part of our country, where there are excellent conditions. unfortunately, once again, and this is already the second year, the government has moved away from this topic, and the question arises, where, after all, to heal... those children of the eastern territories, eastern regions who suffered as a result of the war, this is not a professional approach, it is not state-like, and we demand, after all , to take into account in the finalization of the budget this article regarding the improvement of the health of children of various categories. dear colleagues, when we talk about the draft budget, there is clearly a large number of amendments that concern not only the social

sphere. when we talk about medicine, nowadays the junior medical staff cannot work... for such a meager salary, for a living wage, and with deductions, today nurses in hospitals receive on average 4.5-5 hryvnias, as the people say, on hand, can a family live on such an amount, of course not, and there is already a catastrophic shortage of these specialists in the medical institutions of our country. in view of the war, the medical profession as a whole should be paid more highly, the same applies to the sanitary workers who today are involved in helping and treating our patients, because of that, dear colleagues, i appeal to the representatives of the budget

committee, it is very unfortunate that they did not take into account a large number and our corrections, thanks for that taken into account, we are waiting for, thank you. mykhailo mykhailovych, i understand, we are not making any more amendments, yes, thank you, 38, demchenko, please, thank you, i am contacting the ministry of finance, mr. marchenko, mr. yermolychev, deputy demchenko, i understand, you understand that the deputies expressed their position that you give everything to the buyout of the government, to the buyout of the ministry of finance, namely the norms that they proposed, the committee said that the ministry of finance should consider them and look at the possibility of taking them into account. i wanted to point out that the norm currently referred to in rights, this is an attempt to correct violations, possible violations of the constitution and other laws, regarding the attempt to establish a separate type of subsistence minimum for certain groups

of citizens, which are not provided for by the constitution. accordingly, i would like to refer to the fact that there are already many decisions of the supreme court, which have determined: this approach does not comply with the norms of the constitution and the relevant persons collect the relevant funds additionally from the state, so please , the ministry of finance, pay attention so that you do not violate the law , so you insist on you don't insist on this amendment, thank you, let's move on, the next amendment, 39a scoundrel, don't you insist? no, thank you, on the 40th tymoshenko and his colleagues spoke, on the 41st - ivchenko does not insist, on the 42nd rudyk. serhii yaroslavovich does not insist, 43 mother hryhoriy mykolayovych does not insist , 44th tymoshenko does not insist, 45th razumkov, insist, please, razumkov, ruslan oleksiiovych, give me 45-49, 93, 94,

95 and 3 minutes, one more time, if possible, 45, 49th, 45, 49, 93, 94 and 9, eighth. edits five edits give me three minutes please three minutes, please, thank you, dear colleagues, i do not understand at all what is happening in the room now, because to call it the 24th budget review is profanity, i want people to know about it, i think about the chairman of the committee should confirm this, i think the chairman of the verkhovna rada should also say about it, since yesterday the parliament did not vote on law 1037, the revenues from which are included as revenues and expenditures of the budget for the 24th year, that is, today it is not possible to go into this law at all what law 1037 was about

was to take away any resources from the local government not in order to increase the state budget, but in order to usurp power at the central level, to destroy the decentralization reform in this way... by cementing, well, the activities of monobolsho, let's call, in our own words, what is happening today in the parliament, not only in parliament, so roxelana andriivna, explain to me what revenues you are appealing for now, if the unvoted budget is 10,037, this is first, secondly, ruslansich, do not tell her that she did not answer, she is a specialist, she knows what to say, i i will figure it out myself, thank you, but there is no need to interrupt me, you will have the opportunity to take a cue, like any other people 's deputy, you know this well, you are an equal among equals, if i am not mistaken, but roksila andriivna, addressing the question , please give this answer, because you rejected the above-mentioned amendments

, which, for example, add revenues to the budget from the national bank, increase in other expenses, social referral, etc., if today we do not have justified budget revenues for the 24th year, how we are today we are considering this budget, and fortunately today there is a little more, so far a little more , nor... 30 people's deputies in the hall, as it was during our consideration of the bill 1038 with you, which i remind you once again, here many people shouted and in on social networks, and in the hall, about the fact that it is very difficult to work, in fact , both the committee and the leadership of the verkhovna rada managed to send to the president's office only after 5 days, please tell me what prevented it from being done faster, since you have no adequate... ' normal editing and from our smart policy team, from others

factions did not take into account why it took so long and you thus delayed additional, additional funding for the armed forces of ukraine, despite not taking into account the additional 11 billion that i and my colleagues on the smart policy team talked about, thank you in advance for the expert's answer, the position of the committee on these amendments, the amendment proposes to increase state budget expenditures by uah 562 billion. the sources of coverage of these expenses are not indicated, therefore the committee proposes to reject. thank you. now i will answer dmytro oleksanovych, if possible excuse, i'll figure out what i'm going to talk about with my colleague , you don't even know what we're talking about, but you're already forming your own vision, that's your right, as far as signing the bill is concerned, i think you know very well that there are two working days. in order for one of the people's deputies to propose a blocking amendment, these two days were held, after that the document was signed, in accordance with the regulations, it was

sent to the president, thank you, there are working days , dmytro oleksandrovich, we had saturdays and sundays, which are not counted as business days, thank you dmytro oleksandrovich, therefore, vote for these amendments, the 45th amendment by razumkov and his colleagues, it was rejected by the committee, please vote. the 49th amendment by razunkov and his colleagues was rejected by the committee for 38 decisions, please vote. for 39, the decision has not been taken, the next amendment is 93, it is not necessary, yes, okay, thank you, we will

not vote for these amendments, let's move on, 46 starling, does not insist, 47 tymoshenko has already spoken, 48 yefimov does not insist, 49 and razumkov, he has already voted, the 50th arishonkov, arishonko, please, the 50th, we will find dear mr. chairman, dear colleagues, we can definitely agree that when forming the budget, the government looks for all possible opportunities in order to save, accumulate funds and direct them to the needs of the army, to the needs for the full functioning of the country in such difficult conditions. at the same time, we cannot agree that this should happen at the expense of a significant reduction in social standards that affect citizens, i ask you to vote for

the amendment, where the government proposes in article eight, to establish the amount of subsistence, the amount minimum wage at the level of 1,600 hryvnias when paid by a court decision, this norm is unconstitutional, the gne gave an absolutely negative conclusion, so i ask you to put it on... the position of the committee is brief. the committee proposes to reject. thank you, arishonkov's 50th amendment was rejected by the committee, please vote. for 57, no decision was made. next, 50. first vasylevska smaglyuk insist, don't insist, 52nd mom, don't insist,

53rd ivchenko doesn't insist, 54th rudyk, don't insist, 55th... tymoshenko has already spoken, 56- tymoshenko with colleagues have spoken, 57 tsabal, he does not insist, yes, please, the 57th amendment, but please give me three minutes, i will then make the next 10 amendments, i will not insist, please give tsabal three minutes instead of his next ten amendments, please, honorable colleagues, regarding this draft budget, or rather the budget conclusions that we prepared in the committee, this year we tried to be as objective as possible, as balanced as possible, i think that every member of the committee will confirm that these budget conclusions are absolutely, well thought out, in there is not one of them, i emphasize, not a single scumbag, as they like to say in our country, and all the issues that we included in the proposals of the cabinet of ministers are really necessary

issues for the state, this is the issue of increasing revenues by 10 billion in order to reduce the state debt , this is a question of increasing funding, doctors of the medical direction, this is a question of reducing capital expenditures, i.e. we are going back to the 22nd year, when we substantially reduced capital expenditures, now we will see less stadiums, sidewalks, roads, i.e., these are the issues that really all factions i'm sure they support it, but what i wanted to say, really , the draft budget provides that 200 billion for financing security and defense will be financed by, let's say, the elimination of the road fund for the 24th year, that is, we will not build roads now , and we will send this money to the army, and due to the fact that

we will also send the military pdf, that is, the military taxes that they pay themselves, to... this is 200 million. colleagues, this is financing of the army for more than one and a half months. and i just want to take this opportunity to address everyone, except for these 200 billions of money for the army is enough for a month and a half less. therefore, let's support these budget conclusions, but understanding that in two weeks we will have to support bill 1037, which additionally allocates for the army, there is no need to... tell that it is in the state budget, yes, the state budget, because the army is financed from the state budget, these additional 200 billion are needed for the army, without them the budget will not work, without them the army will not receive funding for a month and a half, let's discard all our political opinions there and so on, and let's vote for the 37th law, without it this project will not work, without it the army

will not have money, colleagues, thank you. thank you, volodymyrovych, 59th amendment, rudyk does not insist, 60th, mother, does not insist, 61- ivchenko does not insist, 62- tymoshenko, we have already spoken, 64- committee on the organization of state power does not insist, 65- committee on issues of economic development does not insist, 66 the committee on economic development does not insist, 67 zaburanna, does not insist, 68 kovalev does not insist, 69th, movchyn does not insist, 72 yefimov with colleagues, no insists, 74- the committee on the organization of state power does not insist, 75- tymoshenko has already spoken, 77 yefimov and colleagues do not insist, 78 tsabol has already spoken, 79

yefimov and colleagues do not insist, 80tal. expressed 81sha yefimov and his colleagues do not insist, 82-83 tsabel spoke, 84 efimov and his colleagues do not insist, 85 the committee on economic development does not insist, 86 zaburanna does not insist, 87 amendment kovalev does not insist, 88th amendment, silently does not insist, 80, 80, i apologize 90 efimov does not insist, 91 yefimov and colleagues do not insists, 92 yefimov and his colleagues do not insist, so 93 razumko has already expressed his opinion on this amendment, 94th 95th hammer does not insist, 96 tsabol has already spoken, 97 magera does not insist, 98 razumko has already spoken, 99 starling does not insist, sota tsabal has spoken, 101- vasylevska smagliuk does not insist, 102 krulko does not insist, 104 the zabal has already spoken,