[000:00:00;00] all the frightened representatives of the authorities of the russian federation gathered in moscow, absolutely everyone, and they gathered, and what else could they say, or putin, in fact, and this is the most important thing, the kremlin, moscow has not had power for a long time, especially in those republics where it has already crystallized , islam and those who are becoming islamic, we have nothing against islam, especially here in ukraine, but in russia, precisely in the republics, there are such... kabardino balkaria, dagestan, chechnya, tatarstan, and others, have long been out of putin's power. and it was precisely this fear that forced them, well, they got together yesterday, so what to tell the russians what to do with their propaganda tv channels. the only thing they managed to achieve was, again, some agency that inspired, well, it is clear that ukraine, and so on, and so on, so

wait, you are so strong, but... near the caspian sea, in the capital of russian in dagestan, western agents not only inspired and organized anti-sem pogroms, disobedience and seizure of strategic objects of the capital's airport, looting of shops, there were pogroms and attempts before this, including even in civilian hotels, they checked whether there were jews there or not, this was also the case in other neighboring neighboring republics, moreover, it is not over yet, and such actions and pogroms are still expected in the russian federation, so my the number one conclusion is that in fact the kremlin has lost power in these caucasian republics. conclusion number two: they are terribly afraid, terribly afraid that they have not been leaders there for a long time, there are local

leaders, there are religious leaders. but definitely not the russian federation. the conclusion is three. i agree with that expert who is correct they link that xenophobia, xenophobic ideology, russian, putin propaganda against all other peoples, precisely led to the fact that the multinational entity , so far the russian federation, was formed in the regions, territories, and republics. already complete, if not state formations, then a community of people who are united by religion, united by economy, nationality, but they have nothing in common with moscow and do not want to, by the way, in many cases, and the fourth and last conclusion, this is actually the disintegration of the russian federation, and this is actually a split in the russian federation itself, and these are the processes that

, by the way, we talked about on your broadcast a year ago... sergei was predicted that one way or another russia would begin to disintegrate, here we are we see it with you, and the whole world sees it, just unfortunately, it happens to the extreme in nazi forums, in anti-jewish pogroms, well, what putin sowed, you know how, he got, by the way, the leader of chechnya, ramzan kadyrov allowed the shooting of protesters against the backdrop of unrest in dagestan, let's listen to it let's see how he did it, if we have even one person who goes to an unauthorized rally , he should be detained and imprisoned, or three warning shots should be fired in the air, if after that the person does not comply with the requirements of the law, the fourth one should be shot, no more come out, this is my order, well, that is, judging by the situation in dagestan and

chechnya, there may be an explosion, and quite a few. an explosion of protests, because in dagestan any, detention of dagestanis, any, necessarily ended in mass actions of disobedience, or we can expect that russia will fall apart precisely from these republics that are part of russia, because we see that on the one hand there is discontent within the republic, this is obviously discontent not... obviously discontent with the authorities, because the same dagestanis are also going to fight to ukraine, obviously they don't want to do this, it's probably the same in chechnya, and one way or another these caucasian peoples, north caucasian peoples, they will become the trash of these revolutionary changes, or well, i don't know, rebellion, if it can be rebellion to call it, then

a riot in russia, let's remind in fact, as in dagestan and not only in the national republics , in september of last year there were protests against the mobilization of russian women, for example in dagestan they said and with slogans that our children... are not consumables, our children, we do not want them killed, no war, even with such slogans, and it was exactly a year ago in the same dagestan, now what we see with you, they even released kadyr's plot to chechnya, in fact we see, we just don't name it, we see how the whole world sees that no way putin governs, governs, ramzan kadyrov shows himself that he governs, that he gives orders , that it is his, moreover, this is an islamic republic, it is on such foundations that he is building, not putin, not moscow and not the kremlin, dagestan

kabardino balkaria shows his own, tatarstan shows his own, this is before our eyes how the formation of putin's russia is disintegrating, this is before our eyes from the collapse and so far it is manifested in dastan in pogroms, kabardino balkaria pogroms. chechnya threats and the power of one person, one family, and you showed how he warns that there should be no protests, in fact, for example , he awarded his son, a 15-year-old boy, with awards for beating an unarmed person, moreover, he gave him awards, and then tried to drive and to other national republics, so that they would give him awards, but for what reasons. he gave all his relatives, but he hanged his son in other republics as well, and who the republics avoided, who

behaved differently, but in russia, you know, the parade is already being selected, who is the bigger king in his territory, this is what you and i see, listening to such stories that you broadcast, well, in the united states of america. reacted to putin's accusations, john kirby said that this is the classic rhetoric of the master of the kremlin, let's listen to the coordinator of the national security council of the white house. well, isn't that cute, that's classic russian rhetoric, isn't it? when something goes wrong in your country, just blame someone else, blame it on outside influences. the west has nothing to do with it, it just doesn't. hate, bigotry and intimidation, pure and simple, and a good leader, decent leader, would call it for what it is, as president biden has called it here in this country , instead of blaming

the west, the local provincial officials, of course, were pretty quick to condemn this bluff, and i've heard in the last hour that mr. putin decided to have some sort of meeting with security officials, but other than that we heard nothing of condemnation from anna, no calls for an end to hatred, discrimination and bigotry against jews, nothing, i think that's very telling. mr. valentin, against the background of what was happening in russia, we see those actions in support of palestine, well, hamas, of course, which take place all over the world, these are millions of actions that take place in different countries. we see how the degree of hatred towards jews is increasing all over the world, in connection with the beginning of the israeli ground military operation in the gaza strip, in what way do you think the world can avoid repeating the mistakes,

including the second world war, when the jews will be blamed in everything, and when the jews will be driven out or pogroms will be organized, either in russia, or in turkey, or in other countries i think the most important thing for us to understand, and it's true, is that it was the massive terrorist attack by hamas on peaceful settlements in israel that started this war that is now between israel and hamas, this is one time, two, israel began to defend itself, and the defense of the israeli army began to actions, and until now, as we all know, not even all the hostages have been released, and thirdly, we are ukrainians, 615 days of war, aggression. against us we know the most important, the most precious women and children, and we must protect the lives of the civilian population, provide humanitarian aid, and so on, and so on, and we sincerely

we wish, and you know, as we tell the whole world, look at what we had, bucha , irpin and so on, we do not want, we want a repetition, it is on the territory of any other country, and precisely because of such suffering and such sacrifices, that we suffer from russian ... aggression, we do not wish anyone and no one to find themselves in such a situation, so i will emphasize the main thing, i think that this is the correct ukrainian position, as much as possible. stronger and, you know, more determined to avoid casualties, especially among the civilian population, to protect people's lives and to do everything to so that there would be no war, but together with the removal of the cause, that is, terrorist organizations, terrorist attacks , murders, intimidation, hostages and so on, other crimes against humanity, you know all this , the terrible and inhuman face of terrorism, and such terrorism is not needed by anyone

, well, it is clear that neither israel, nor, in fact, the arab world, and this is the most important thing, not to go to the left or to the right to comment on and politicize this war. mr. valentin, returning to russian information and psychological special operations, today information appeared on russian resources that the sbu and the national police may be aiming for a provocation with biological weapons, this is what one of the commanders of the troops, radiation, chemical, biological weapons, kirilov, says, he says that there are some they have data that in the mykolaiv region there have been cases of an infectious disease caused by the bird flu virus, and then they blame ukraine for the incident, this story with biological weapons probably already has

a ten-year history, if... more, constant, constant accusations on the territory of donetsk, on the territory of the south, on the territory of the united states, some secret laboratories, you were the head of the security service of ukraine, here is the reason for the appearance and the roots of the appearance of such stories from the russian side, and how can it be proven that there are no such stories on the territory ukraine does not have any laboratories, we do not use biological weapons... because, in principle , this is prohibited by international conventions, well, it is from the same order and from the same series of things, as ukraine or the bandera people, or the western agents are involved in the dagestan pogroms of anti-semitic people. this is exactly the case with this old lie, invented by the russian military itself, about some kind of biological weapon, biological laboratories and so on and so forth, all this is really nothing else.

you know how the more absurd the russian military invents, the more they think that someone will believe in their military aggression, this, i think, is nothing more than trying to escalate, trying to find an additional reason to explain that that is unexplained, why this aggression was against ordinary russians, they begin and continue to spread fictions, here biological weapons, organ trade, insects are flying, birds are infected, and so on, and so on, and when in a month or two , all this, you know, no one has seen anything, there is no confirmation, propaganda invents something new, about nazis, about something else, this is nothing more than, i repeat, a cynical attempt to cover up their aggression, their crimes of war and inhumanity on the territory of ukraine. serhii shaigu, minister. of defense of the russian federation made several statements regarding

possible negotiations with ukraine. he was staying at the xiangchang national security forum in china, let's hear what shaigu said. russia is open to discussing and solving any issues in the field of security, if this dialogue is honest, equal and based on mutual respect. agreed. parties, however, without a review by the west of its destructive line, which envisages inflicting a strategic defeat on russia, fruitful negotiations in this area are unlikely to be possible. however, in case the necessary conditions are created, we remain ready for realistic political discussions principles, both on the post-conflict settlement of the crisis, and on the party and

parliamentary level, as well as on the parameters of further coexistence with the west as a whole. mr. valentin, it is not the first time in the last few months that we have heard from representatives of moscow that they are ready for negotiations, because either they are hindered by the presidential decree prohibiting these negotiations, or they are hindered by the position of president zelensky, or they are hindered by the united states of america, which have to start this dialogue, in fact, according to you, russia is now striving to negotiations with ukraine, of course, on their own terms, but i am signaling to the russians... what do they want to negotiate with the world? i think, well, you and i got along, i don’t even read well, it turns out that their minister killed him with this thing, i’m honestly amazed, i didn’t see the video of the plot, but my first conclusion is that he didn’t even learn to read, the second conclusion , that the delusion that was printed and written for him

, he read it, testifies, first, that russia is becoming the final vassal of china, that is, subordinate to china in memory and in defense, both in politics and economics. third, russia inflicted a strategic defeat on itself, putin destroyed gazprom, for example, there is no gazprom in the european union, in european countries, just as they lost the majority of the european market, and the absolute majority, which lost many other economic opportunities, which led to full-scale aggression in russia still more or less existed, that is why strategic defeats, this shoigu should turn to putin, but here is what will happen. i think about everything in the coming days and know that the meeting is planned the leader of china is all with us president biden, it is planned in san francisco at the asean summit, and it is very important for us to have just two leaders to finally remove all the inconsistencies between their countries, between global

economies, and therefore russia will no longer be needed at all, even for china , as soon as such processes' begin, i think that then we can truly say that the strategic defeat of russia, which putin started, will finally end with china also withdrawing from supporting russia, and for us this will mean that the anti-putin the coalition, the support of ukraine , will continue, and we will certainly be able to, you know, expel the aggressor from all the temporarily occupied territories of ukraine, for us this is actually... strategically important changes and we sincerely hope that they will take place, china and the united states will finally restore normal, first of all economic, trade cooperation, and therefore also political. volodymyr zelenskyi in a conversation with the journalist of time magazine, simon shuster, stated

that there will be no temporary truce, and ukraine will never agree to it, i quote. the president of ukraine, for us it would mean leaving this wound open for future generations, maybe it will calm some people inside our country and outside, at least those who want to finish the case at any cost, but for me it is a problem because we remain with this explosive force, we are only delaying its detonation, volodymyr zelenskyi said. how do you, mr. valentin, see a negotiation, a negotiation process or any negotiations at all. between ukraine and russia, which will happen sooner or later, this is a war, that's all one is finalized with some kind of negotiations, or some kind of round table, maybe not with the participation of zelensky and putin, but at least with the participation of two round tables, putin will sit at one, sign

the capitulation, and zelensky will sit at the other, but as you can see, well, further progress in the negotiation session, because the west also says that sooner or later we will still have to talk about some kind of peace, even when russia withdraws from ukraine, it will still be necessary to conduct some negotiations, the key thing, from the position of ukraine , we must understand and build, including plans after the negotiations, the most important thing is that we must understand that for us the liberation of temporarily occupied territories, for us the preservation of political and economic support for ukraine is important even now during the war, and then after the victory to rebuild the country. well, a miracle will not happen , look how much the aggressor has destroyed and continues to destroy our cities, i am not talking

about the villages and infrastructure that the aggressor is totally destroying in the east, in the south, everywhere where gets with its rockets, artillery or occupying troops. therefore, i return to the important things for us, i will tell you what they are and which negotiations are important for us, the negotiations that will take place, i am convinced, by the end of this year, about the start of negotiations on ukraine's membership in the european union , are extremely important for us , in our country, these are the first important negotiations. the second important negotiations are a way to ensure that the ukrainian peace formula is supported by the majority of the world's countries. organizations of the united nations, a therefore, on the basis of our national interests, our peace formula, a global peace summit was held, these are the negotiations: and in this format we need, we must strive, and it is in our interests, everything else

is, you know, an assumption of the pattern of the second world war, or the first one, even the world one, i am not convinced that, first of all, we need them, b, they are effective, and thirdly, the best scenario for any negotiations is definitely that the processes that are ongoing in russia should speed up and that the russian federation as an aggressor country weakened from the inside, collapsed from the inside, including the fact that, the leadership of the russian federation, putin already has an arrest warrant from the international criminal court, i think that at the beginning of next year shoigu and other war criminals of the russian federation will receive warrants from the international criminal court federations, these are the processes that will definitely contribute to the end of the war and access to the global peace summit, and it is in it and on its basis that i see

negotiations for peace and the restoration of our territorial integrity. against the background of that sheigu talks about possible negotiations, and zelskyi says that there cannot be a temporary truce. boris pistorius, the minister of defense of germany, said that the deployment of hostilities in europe is possible, let's listen. what the head of the german defense ministry said. we must once again get used to the idea that there may be a threat of war in europe, which means that we should be prepared for war. we must be ready for defense and prepare the bundeswehr and society for this. everything that was spoiled in 30 years, sorry, is impossible in a short time catch up in 19 months, but by the end of this decade the german. will be in a completely different position.

as far as i understand, mr. valentin, neither germany nor other european states even imagined that in the center of europe there could be a war of such a scale that is now taking place on the territory of ukraine, the largest war since the second world war, is it true that the western states, western europe were also not ready for such a war. and to such aggressiveness of putin. certainly, such statements of the minister were not ready, moreover of defense of the federal republic of germany now indicate that defense enterprises, defense capabilities , germany is firstly restoring, secondly expanding, this means that the production of modern equipment, modern anti-aircraft systems, including shells, will take place and not only for ukraine, but also for the defense of germany and the country as a whole, the members of the european union have now fundamentally

revised and from next year their budgets will fundamentally change towards an increase in defense and security, and one more thing, not only russia annoys and threatens european countries, belarus also, out of nowhere , started, you know, drifting towards a quasi-nuclear state, nuclear missiles, even lukashenko threatened to place on his territory, countries such as poland, for example, lithuania, all the baltic countries, finland, sweden, have accepted this situation and take it very seriously, and are becoming, finland has already become a member of nato, sweden will become one in the near future, but this is not just membership in nato, it is also additional weapons systems, additional defense and additional deployment along everything border, for example, with belarus with russia. modern fire systems, the impression, and if necessary, the destruction, of any possible

aggressive invasions or movements by russia or belarus with troops, equipment or aviation, believe me, nato member countries take this very seriously, and for example, combat nato aviation is no longer just on duty, it patrols the borders, skies, etc., seas in combat mode from the airports of estonia, lithuania, finland, and i already mentioned sweden, it is already 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. mr. valentine, today forbes published data that as of october 23, russia launched more than 3,000 missiles at ukraine, spending 22 billion 800 million dollars on missile strikes.

this is up to the level of the cost of half of all military aid of the united states of america to ukraine since february 24, 2022, and russia has already crossed the mark of 300,000 killed russians on the territory of ukraine since february 24, that is, rather large resource losses, both human and financial, do you think there is a limit to these losses in russia, after which they can say that's all, we won't fight anymore, because a lot of people have been killed, we've already spent 100 billion there, or i don't know how many there are in total. money they threw into the furnace of this war, is there a limit for putin, he does not spare his people, there is no limit, i think we should be aware that the disposal, burial of his citizens, his military has no limits at all for him, that is, 1,000, 300, a million, well, 130

million, this is not a question for him, but only he manages the war, only he... started and continues the aggression, that's why i call him. second, regarding the opportunities, and this is actually much more serious, even , defense, armed and economic, here everything is the other way around, in russia it is very bad, economic opportunities, we talked very briefly with you, if it were not for china, it would have been a long time ago, even the economy russia was in collapse and only because of trade and economic aid, cooperation and such, you know, policies under...' russia's hold on china has been pulled out, it has not yet allowed the aggressor's economy to collapse, but i hope that after all, the usa, china , changes in their daily routines, will be finally eliminated russia and from this channel such, you know, emergency aid, which they received and continue to receive from china.

regarding weapons and the production of weapons in the russian federation itself, there are two factors here, the first is how successful it will be... our armed forces to strike and destroy such opportunities and such production on the territory of the aggressor country, this is one time, and the second is how much everything after all , international sanctions will start to be more effective and tougher, well , next week the 12th package of sanctions is clearly being prepared, we and our european partners, i from the position of the parliament and our committee on integration with the european union, we are working so that in the 12th package: russian diamonds under sanctions finally appeared, and technologies for drones and missiles and so on, including components with tough, tough restrictions on countries like turkey, kazakhstan and china, so that russia does not bypass such international sanctions through them, i think next week the next new package of european union sanctions against the russian

federation will come out, so that everything same after all, russia did not...' should no longer produce particularly high-precision and particularly destructive weapons against ukraine, important international sanctions and an important impression and the receipt by our armed forces of additional high-precision long-range missiles and weapons and f-16. we need these fighters, just as we need all the infrastructure that accompanies the fighter aircraft in order to destroy and destroy... the enemy's weapons, and therefore his potential to continue aggression against ukraine. once we achieve this, it will be a turning point war thank you, mr. valentin, it was valentin nalyvaichenko, people's deputy of ukraine, former head of the security service of ukraine. friends, we are working live on the channel, as well as on our youtube and facebook platforms, so please like this video so that it can be

trended on youtube and facebook. i say goodbye to you until the next program, in the next program. i will have valery chalyly, please wait, but for now take care of yourself and your relatives, goodbye, what is happening in the gas sector, how is israel conducting its land operation, we are talking about it on bbc news ukraine live from london, i am evgenia shedlovska. the israeli military has entered the gaza strip and is leading there. with hamas militants, prime minister netanyahu rejects calls for a ceasefire, says it will be a long war. the number of civilians killed in the gas sector is increasing, it is reported that

dozens of people were killed in an explosion in a refugee camp in the north. well, israel did, launched a ground operation. in the