shakhtar barcelona on mego. defeat on the field of barca did not break our team. on november 7 at 19:45, the miners will give a real fight. turn on the super match exclusively on mego. there are discounts on bronchial cough lollipops. 10% in pharmacies plantain and savings. did you drink an antibiotic? you got a bump in your stomach. how are you girls? but how, how? how after the antibiotic kak. proviz yes, in 2023 espresso celebrates ten years, we are proud to present our new ethereal look. stay tuned for the updated espresso, because despite everything, we're staying on connection the information hour on the espresso tv channel continues. our viewers are in touch with you. to whom we are infinitely grateful for the trust.

greetings, dear viewers, this is the big ether program on the espresso tv channel. espresso 10 years. we are developing and improving. well, we go further and talk about magnetic vores. we are becoming even more dynamic, even more convenient. the information day of the tv channel is in full swing. we are modern design and sound. even more interesting programs and original projects. the occupiers' garrison was rounded up and cut off from the main forces and destroyed. they will. try to get a break at dawn. our values ​​and ukrainian point of view remain unchanged. events, events that are happening right now and affect our lives. of course, the news feed reports on them. however , it was not enough to know what was happening. it is necessary to understand. antin borkovsky and. invited experts

soberly evaluate events, analyze them by modeling our future, every saturday at 1:00 p.m. with a repeat at 10:00 p.m. studio zahid with anton borkovsky at espresso. every week, the saturday political club helps to understand the processes that take place in ukraine and the world. vitaly portnikov, host of espresso and invited experts, give their assessment and forecast based on facts. developments, want to understand how our today will affect our tomorrow, watch the saturday politics club, every saturday, on espresso. vasyl winter's big broadcast, two hours of air time, two hours of your time, two hours to learn about the war and what the world is like, two hours to keep up with economic and sports news. two hours in the company of favorite presenters, presenters who have become like family to many. and also respectable

guests of the studio, the events of the day in two hours, vasyl zima’s big broadcast, a project for the intelligent and those who care , in the evening on espresso, well, right now on espresso there is a marathon going on and we are adding to it dmytro pletenchuk, spokesman for the naval forces of the armed forces of ukraine, captain of the third rank mr. dmytro, good morning. good morning studio, welcome viewers. mr. dmitry, this is great news, i don't know, it's great for me, probably for you too, now tell us in more detail, the air force hit the plant in kerch, where there was the newest russian carrier of calibers, what do you know about it, you can confirm , question, deny, and we, for our part , can confirm this fact, this is the karakurt project, specifically this unit was called in the past tense, the skolt is another example of

how the russian the under-empire continues to steal historical names and characters from us, but it did not help them in any way, and in total they wanted to launch three such ships, the first of them has already come out, it is a cyclone, we have talked about it with you more than once, it is the same small missile ship, which for two years could not completely finish ... state tests and launch at least one caliber missile, this is the same ship, and there were two more of this series, this is amur and askolt, and here is one of them, as it happened now it is known, it seems, after all, no, it will not be able to join the black sea fleet, due to the reason for its absence, in the first place, so yes, this is a fairly new unit. if

not to say the most recent, because it was still actually being completed, it is supposedly so super-modern, built allegedly according to the concept of... modular weapons, they, to things really wanted to implement it, but something went wrong with them, as usual , they never managed to do it, the concept is that the weapons modules can be replaced, that is, they are not built in tightly, but they are, you know, replaceable elements , quite, quite easily changeable, let’s say, not only on these ships, they tried to push it, well, it doesn’t matter what they say, he has eight launchers of zrk tor on board, it’s also like that according to their opinion, oh, sorry, not thor, shell s, according to their opinion, they are on vasyl, they are on the cake a tugboat was being built, which we also sank, but we were already in the sea, and accordingly they thought

that it would be such a modern model of weapons, and it was not for nothing that it was put into series, an important element is that they were all built.. directly on our facilities, which were seized by the russian invaders together with the crimea, and an equally interesting fact is that, in principle, as you could see in the numerous videos, from one and the same location, in principle, the plant and the city can be seen, that is, all this is quite close, of course, they also had one on the bridge, perplexity, they closed it... as always, smoked it, nevertheless, by the way , we are observing a decrease in the number of ships guarding this bridge, if earlier, as you remember, we discussed on the air about 10 units, then it is enough

for a long time there are two of them alternating, and by the way, in the sea itself, in the black sea, there is also only one ship and one in the azov sea, they are not national pits, and here we can move smoothly to the next problem, which is that the enemy now, as we understand, will try to somehow change the situation, change tactics, now this change was to take the main ships away from the main naval base, from sevastopol, because it is dangerous, spread them out, and now they have two problems, the lack of a berthing front, but they can still solve this somehow, and the second is the lack of logistical support, that is, the same calibers, for example, were loaded only in sevastopol, and most likely, they will now think, how to solve this problem, therefore, accordingly, we have such a suitable shelter in the sea, the enemy thinks how

to proceed , and accordingly, second, second the most important component of the military-industrial complex continues to accumulate missile weapons. doesn't produce very much, so it takes a while to stockpile it, before the winter, of course, there are a lot of different ones now, a little bit of speculation, all while the russians said yesterday in general that it was eight storm shadow missiles, all eight were shot down, but the debris fell in the area of ​​the bridge, so there might be a little smoke, but an interesting point, that 's what everyone will be discussing, what could it be? which could be hundreds of kilometers in principle to fly up and successfully hit, overcoming the russian air defense systems, no one doubts that there is everything the most modern , which only the russians have and very abundantly in crimea, they cover all the ports, they say that it can be stormshedoo and scalp, as well as

they say that it could be this tu-141 stryzh, which we have already seen more than once converted into a missile and used as a combat missile, or it could be some new ukrainian missile of its own development, in other words. different different call ideas, in the end we won't know exactly what it was, probably, but if it, but, but, but if this is stormshadow, then it’s interesting how it is possible to get through this russian defense, in fact, one day we will learn the truth, we are not in russia after all, thank god, we are alive, and accordingly, now these operational data classified, of course, but nevertheless, after the victory, you will have a lot of work, when all this will finally be told, who planned, how they planned, how they used it, most likely, it was another rather complex operation, combined, and accordingly all this is included in the framework of the

same concept, which has been mentioned more than once insisted on the air, or rather the idea is very simple, get out of the crimea, and we frankly, personally... i repeatedly told those who are now in the crimea about this on the air, that the time is finally here, to the native harbor, somewhere there, while it stands . to go and in principle, this will preserve health and life, and the second idea, which was repeatedly voiced in the same way, that it will be cheaper for them to sink their fleet on their own, as they have already done on several occasions, and in such a situation they will simply avoid victims among, their personnel, but i repeat once again that the russians are hints don't... understand, so we don't have any choice, by the way, so to the topic, to be very

brief, we don't have much time left, but if we have time, the issue of military censorship is not discussed, and that is the necessity of it absolutely everyone understands, but the question of how far-reaching this censorship should be, whether it can, for example , also be political censorship at the same time, we had the opportunity to talk about it yesterday with those people who are in a very similar situation. who are like us, who we can look up to a little bit, i mean israel, yesterday had a conversation with the vice-speaker of the israeli knesset of the israeli parliament, yevhen sova, who is of ukrainian origin and a native of the mykolaiv region, and he told us that political censorship is completely absent in israel, everyone can say whatever they want and criticize whoever they want, but as far as reporting news in general, this happened against the background, in particular, of yesterday's statement by the deputy head of the president's office and that they say that it is not necessary to tell the military what is happening there on the front, then we asked how it is happening in israel,

but it turns out that there is a special person there, this is the combat rear admiral, danielel gagari, and the vice rear admiral, who gathers a briefing every day, three times a day for all journalists who want to come, actually talks about the course of hostilities, and besides no one comments on any combat operations, any plans of the idf, no. netanyahu, neither his deputy, nor netanyahu's secretary, nor any of the political leaders and so on , that is, everyone can say whatever they want, but there is one source , and that is the rear admiral himself, who can calmly answer to recep erdogan, for example, and that is, he also comments on the political statements that take place around the war , in the same way, this is for me, it seemed to me a very, very interesting example, probably for imitation, well, it's just a replica. the development of information policy in each country, especially during

hostilities, it can be different, of course it is connected with national traditions, in our country, as you know, people do not like to be silent, very much, sometimes this of course does not reflect well, and it is possible build this communication in different ways, 10 years the war in ukraine saw different examples, if you remember, at first we also had spokesmen who came from the general staff, every day they provided information, when the anti-terrorist operation just started, when all this was still quite new for us, again , the level of democracy is the same, no matter what the name of the country is, it is still different, and as far as i know, in israel , every publication has a military center, so it checks the information, regarding the security of operations. and on the one hand it is right, on the other hand,

of course, we are fighting for a dumb democracy and it is not worth stepping on it, so everything should be simple within the framework, adequate, and of course the main thing is that there should be a coherent information policy, that is, it should not have contradictions within itself, uh, situations happen are different, the speakers are also different, and all the same, the main thing is to tell the truth, and this, on the other hand, is our strength, we did not allow ourselves to become konoshenkov , and everything you hear from the press service will be the truth, not propaganda, not information- psychological operation, so information can be limited, of course, due to that it can cost human lives, and unfortunately, such precedents have also taken place, nevertheless. her truth is only the truth and nothing but the truth, and that is why the trust rating

of trust and the balance of trust and distrust in the armed forces of ukraine is usually the highest, and none of the politicians can even come close to it. thank you mr. dmytro, dmytro pletenchuk was with us, the spokesman of the naval forces of the armed forces of ukraine was with us, a captain of the third rank, we are going for a short break, and then we will return, and mykola malomush, general of the army of ukraine, will be with us and the head of the foreign intelligence service of ukraine in 2005-2010, we will be with him about the situation at the front, as well as about zaluzhnyi's article and simon schuster's article, which made a big splash this week, stay with us. there are discounts on hepargin 15% in pharmacies podorozhnyk, bam and oskad, cystitis, there are discounts on urulisan 15% in pharmacies podorozhny bam taschad. every day,

every hour, every minute we receive a large amount. information, the most anticipated event of the year, what is actually happening at the front, what are the losses of personnel and equipment on the battlefield, how the international community evaluates our successes and what moscow is lying about. from the flow of news coming from everywhere, we single out the most important ones. the tweet is closely monitoring whether there will be weapons for ukraine and what kind, and what are the russian occupiers whispering about behind the commanders' backs? news, summaries of the week, this is an overview of only important events, important, reliable events , this is analytics, fact-checking, expert comments, about this and much more in the issue today, about important things in simple language, available to all viewers. congratulations, iryna koval is in the studio, and this results of the week on the espresso tv channel. news, summaries of the week, every saturday at 21:00 on

espresso. espresso celebrates its tenth anniversary in 2023. we are proud to present our new ethereal look. stay tuned for an updated espresso, because despite everything, we stay in touch. the information hour on the espresso tv channel continues. our viewers, to whom we are infinitely grateful for their trust, are in touch with you. greetings, dear viewers. this is the big ether program on the espresso tv channel. espresso is 10 years old, we are developing and improving. well, we go further and talk about magnetic vortices. we are becoming even more dynamic, even more convenient. the information day of the tv channel is in full swing. we are modern design and sound, even more interesting programs and original projects. the occupying garrison was surrounded, cut off from the main forces and destroyed. they will try, the dawn will come.

our values ​​and ukrainian point of view remain unchanged. vitaly portnikov is with you and we are talking about the main events of this week. vitaly portnikov and top experts about the most vivid events of the last seven days. ours the guest will be lieutenant general of the ground forces, former national security advisor to the president of the united states, donald trump, herbert mcmaster. current topics, pressing questions, authoritative comments and forecasts in the information marathon project with vitaly portnikov, every sunday at 20:10 on express. every week, the saturday political club helps to understand the processes taking place in ukraine and the world. vitaly portnikov, host of espresso and invited experts, based on facts, give their assessment and forecast of the development of events. do you want understand how our today will affect our tomorrow, watch the saturday politics club, every saturday

on espresso. hello, this is svoboda ranok, an informational project of radio svoboda. top guests every day, this is the ship district, kherson, live inclusion. we are somewhere in the vicinity of bakhmut, we are telling the main thing. on weekdays at 9:00. dear friends, we return to eteru and mykola. my husband, general of the army of ukraine, head of the foreign intelligence service of ukraine in 2005-2010 , is already with us. mr. mykola, we congratulate you. congratulations, glory to ukraine. glory to groyam. sir mykola, a little more from you, we talked yesterday, but i think that ukrainians will still be interested to hear about it today, maybe not everyone heard it yesterday on our air. this is the military hierarchy that

is happening because two articles that appeared this week provoked some. a series of subsequent events, for example, the dismissal of general horrenk, which he learned about from journalists, and how it became known that general zaluzhnyi did not make the submission, and then defense minister umiru commented on it, that it was he who made the submission, or does the minister of defense have the right to make such a submission, is it predictable, the minister of defense should definitely make the right to make this submission, the question , as i understand it, also happens along some, some hierarchical chain, should, for example, general horrenko find out about this, how to get some , i don’t know a warning that or a notification that there will be a motion for his dismissal, whether he should find out about it from the press after all, and also, whether the deputy head of the president’s office can make

remarks to commander-in-chief zaluzhny and the military, about what the military cannot do it is worth talking about the situation that is taking place, mr. mykola, well, first of all, strategically, what, for example, was expressed by the diligent economist, this is his position, he expressed more in this way in order to give not only the general situation of the problem of ukraine, and to incline the west, especially the united states, to effective support, because it is clear that there are discussions, especially among republicans, whether the priority today is to provide aid to ukraine or israel, and ukraine can be postponed or clearly reduced, so this is a powerful signal, which in some measures served, that the strategic issue is really being resolved today, the confrontation with the aggressor from russia and with the west, in the first usa , on the battlefield in ukraine, yes, the southern, precisely directional, the middle east is very important, but this is a sectoral problem that requires

a correspondingly consolidated the solution is already directly and in the process of negotiations and military operations, there is a real war going on here , that is why this format exists, but i think that it should be a joint consolidated position, in this situation, because we are forming precisely the policy of the state as a whole, and due to the loan of the president, who expressed his visions in the press, with the chief of staff, what acute questions, and this should not contradict the plan, that there is no dead end option, or so we do not count, and the general says that accordingly, today there is a prospect of a protracted war, that is, we must work in a unified manner, these disagreements will indicate to some extent that the model may not have worked, how the assessment is going and what to submit to the outside world and to ukraine. i still pay attention to society, it was a number of articles and new york times from

economist abroad, and the citizens of ukraine only receive information indirectly, or now they reprint it, i think that it is necessary for the president and the chief of the general staff to address the assessments of the situation to the citizens of ukraine, we are the basis and the basic dominant of the war, both the military and civilians, and volunteers and everyone else , so i think that there is a mismatch here, it needs to be resolved today and between zelenskyi first and foremost, and no one from the office, neither the head nor the deputies have the right in any way to comment and correct the position of the commander-in-chief, the commander-in-chief has expressed his position, there is a supreme leader, zelenskyi, who can express his position or even point out some possible inaccuracies or his strategic vision, so to speak, but i think that this format is also a contradiction, he should not somewhere to sound at some level, or the press... or in an interview, there must be a unified position here, because the keys are working, bets are being made daily, war cabinets are being held, the national security and defense councils are meeting, and

these people communicate with each other every day, and you make a common position, and what is there to say, i think that this is their position, because it is not just someone's opinion of general zaluzhnyi or even president zelensky, it is the position of the state, the position of the commander, who today decides the fate on the battlefield, therefore, in this situation, i think that these differences should be removed, no one should limit all comments from the office of the president, the chancellery, which does not have any authority for this, here they can give assessments, as we say today, and foreign experts give different ones the institutionalization of war, generals, for example, hodzhis gives an assessment, well, we have competent people who know the situation deeply, not in theory and analytics, we have developed a lot of them today, i see there political scientists commenting on the military part, and those who really nobles planned and conducted military operations. the subject is not just from theory, but from real practice, hard practice of combat, this is real, so i think, from such positions , today we should evaluate that, after all

, the information component should be regulated, especially at the strategic level, remove all so to speak, send especially official persons , who are not authorized to give evaluations either to the enlisted man or to the military, and the third component, what you said, is important, because somehow we have a practice in different periods and today it manifests itself, is removed: a special responsible person, especially in the period war, being at the front, i emphasize, and here he finds out that he was filmed, this should never happen, it does not happen, in a real situation he should be invited, this person, if you really clarify the situation, listen to him, then say, that there is such a solution, but motivated decision, so that it was not , a blow directly to the commander, and this will definitely be a response in the troops, because when they shoot...' the commander, and even more so, he comments on her that he does not know about this, of course, the situation abnormal, i know about all the military teams, i personally take part in such situations, because

decrees were passed against me, including me, but when the team does not know, it is extremely negatively perceived, even if there is a good new one appointed, that is why in this situation, it should be the ethics of change, those more during the war, here is an explanation of why it happened, and another important factor, namely senior commanders, for example, commanders of special operations, must necessarily not only know about it, but if it is strictly speaking there did not know, then it is at all it is inadmissible, but you should make a decision in a consolidated manner yourself, it was discussed with the president, accordingly, there is a submission of a petitioner, for example, to the minister of defense, this procedure is defined, the minister of defense has the right to submit, and there is such a mechanism for the petitioner himself, but already the president appoints by decree, but in such a way that no one knows and no one really signed up for it in the sense that he did not even know, then i think that this is not at all a political game, so to speak, and not some positive scenario regarding

military changes. now, of course, it already plays back, yes, i filed and the like, well, it is not done that way, even if it was published in the press , of course, it already worked in a negative format, but there must be worked-out mechanisms among themselves, even if you have to go around, it can be we do not deny that in the period wars, for a more efficient performance of tasks, professionals should work, and not for some reason, someone gave an interview and moved it or there are some other reasons, we stand by that today and the new american colleagues, supporters, contact the office, have known him for many decades, they are for rotation, but the government is made up of martial law professionals, these are high-class people, and they can be gathered in units, who know the subject, war, defense, know international relations, have personal contacts all over the world in in terms of support for ukraine, both political, armed, diplomatic and operational, this format is necessary, it could be, but

then it is clear where the position... and the leadership of the state that is being formed, what a powerful body, and from the first day, as it should be , is rising, and the armed forces and the military industry, all of them, and kb pivdenna, and kb luch, as we have already said, and others, others who work 24:7 for defense, we have only been deploying these directions for three or four months, we deployed directions a little earlier army of drones, it should already work, because namely, i just gave as an example, shots, who know the subject, they can raise the situation. months, in the coming periods, we should already have ours, and not ask only our foreign partners, then our defense was consolidated, powerful, foreign support, and this is what i am saying, it took the fight out of them, well, you see, mr. mykola, here we are literally there's only a minute left , we won't have time to discuss it, well, the previous one too, the interlocutor, the spokesman of the fleet, dmytro plytenchuk, talked about the fact that israel is showing us a model of how it communicates with

the fourth power, with the media in order for them to report to society and from society to ask questions, for example, how to talk to shmigal, what is there now with the defense company, he does not give briefings, how to talk to, for example, the army, which is now closing the company with of the president's office, which is happening on the front, in israel there is a rear admiral, a hero of the previous war, who is authorized to hold briefings every day. a briefing is not a speech, not a reading of a summary of the general staff, it is when journalists are real, oppositional, non-positional. just feel free to ask any questions a representative of the army, and he answers any questions, that is, he has the right to answer them, the competence to answer them , trust and fully knows the situation at the front, and it is classified, but he says this, are we getting to that in the first place i support this position, because journalists and society have the right to ask questions, and the military to answer these questions clearly and unambiguously, so in this situation i am in favor of the fact that there was democracy, only there is a small part,

military secrecy, and today under this the situation is closed, there are many situations, the wrong approach, society should work together with the army and accordingly , thank you, mr. mykola, we can finish, now there will be a minute of silence, we will honor the memory of the ukrainian military and civilian citizens of ukraine who died in the war with a minute of silence , that she... was bound by russia.