[000:00:00;00] responsibility for hamas, if there had been no action on october 7, it was not only the murder of 1,400 citizens of israel in the south of israel, but also the taking of 220 hostages, well now they say 220 or 240, that is, it is unknown how many died, so forgive me , the full responsibility for all the consequences lies with hamas, because you, they , to be precise, always had the opportunity for this passage on october 7, and return the hostages to lay down their arms, stop the resistance, and so it was proposed to them, they thought, that they can play like this with the population of palestine in the gaza sector exposed it to the most terrible danger, death, as a result of the response actions, this is a question of ensuring security, this is a question of punishing the guilty, and israel will not refuse this, yes the ground operation is going on, it is going on in phases, sectorally it goes on, not so to speak, on a large scale, but nevertheless it continues, from

this point of view, moscow has definitely taken an unequivocal anti-israeli, pro-hamasov position and is doing everything to ensure that israel loses first in the information war, he already lost it, that's a fact, and then he lost a purely military situation, so to speak, stopped the action. look, mark, why did the kremlin, so to speak, fit in so actively against israel, we remember how putin rode on bibim netanyahu's shoulders, we understand that they had longer ties. but no, it was at this moment that putin decided to get involved actively, and we understand that hamas did not come up with this attack on israel by itself, that is, we understand that it is iran, and someone else advised him, and there is an assumption that specifically, the kremlin hinted at whether they helped, it is not excluded, because first of all, the western press writes that for 2 years they were preparing this operation, 2 years, well, for 2 years they constantly traveled to moscow, in august, they saw mashaly there chania is given to mr.

lavrov in moscow or in st. petersburg, they were at a summit of some kind, what does this mean? they constantly travel, they constantly consulted, they met not only with lviv, but with the leadership of the special services, with the army, and so on, they have the closest relationship, as for why it took moscow could maneuver its anti-israeli position, but how come they would condemn the events of october 7, say let's go to peace , let's go, no, i think they are interested in dragging out this whole story in order to shift attention from ukraine to the middle east, if israel will quickly win, win, solve the problem of hamas and take care of iran , but they will not be happy with this moscow, because they will have problems of a second nature, iran supplies soldiers, supplies shells, a lot of things there, if they are bombed military facilities, there are nuclear infrastructures, there are some centrifuges and so on, then these factories may also suffer, for sure , and this will help ukraine a lot, but ukrainians will stop being killed by these shaheds, as for hamas itself, you know, hamas is

uncontrollable, let's put it this way, it means... the forces of the arab east, a force that can provoke, look, it would seem that such a large-scale and terrorist action, but it is just a momentary one , carried out in a flash on the territory of israel on one day, and the consequences are all over the world, global consequences, today angelina even supported palestine, yes, in the same context, yes, that is, it says something, that they know where to press, they know where to hit, they understand how it works, in moscow they understand exactly how it works, the jewish question, the middle eastern question, the palestinian-israeli question - this is the most painful, the most sensitive question, they put pressure there in order, i repeat, to solve their problems in eastern europe, to solve their problems with the war, which they do not win, at least to move the peace to something, to the fact that, listen, let's agree on ukraine, let 's sit down, leave us the occupied territories, let's demilitarize ukraine there, let's, well, here's the whole set, and then everything together let's get together and solve

the middle east problem, we say , i suggest, we are members of the middle east four, says moscow, we are ready to take hostages, we are ready, therefore, to contribute to the creation of a palestinian state, to participate in negotiations between sides, we have contact both there and there, well, this sounds quite frankly, we say that there is a peace plan, that is why this is being done, and it is not profitable for moscow to have israel deal with hamas quickly now, it is very unprofitable, well, because the problems will disappear and again everything will switch to ukraine , and with even greater aggravation and there is also an extremely characteristic moment, some intra-russian survey conducted by the levvada center, they are beginning to measure the mood, i do not know whether such numbers helped them to form, so to speak, or it there really is, perhaps some such statistical reflection of moods, which would like two-thirds, about 70% of russians, they would accept

with gratitude, if putin would stop. against ukraine, but at a characteristic moment that less than a third of those people would like putin to return our illegally and temporarily occupied territories, but... we understand that all these dances, starting from dagestan, ending with those polls, that rather, before the events in six months, when putin will re-appoint himself, well, look, we really we cannot judge the reliability of all these figures . of ukraine it's a lot for the world, it's a lot, but it's a lot for the russians too, it's a lot too, because every day the number of casualties increases, the costs of this war, in the economy, in the social sphere, and a lot in what, but it's not

that to make them so happy, commoners the russians, yes, they may feel, of course, some desire to speed it all up, they may feel , there is no doubt about it, the second question , you understand, we are still dealing with the previous authoritarian period, so to speak, they there are such loopholes, yes, there is simply an opportunity to go and rest in turkey, you know, from the times of putin’s authoritarian russia of the previous two decades, yes, or internet access, it’s also from there is already reduced, but still it is iz прежней жизни, vopros, to what extent putin should be listened to and needed in connection with the elections. i am not at all convinced that this can shake his decision to continue doing what he was doing, you know, sociology is interesting, of course, you can adapt to it, maneuver, change some of your actions, but rely on

public opinion, which is fickle, putin is definitely not gathering, the elections will be held very quickly, there are no elections, that is, they will announce this number, but they will also measure whether it will cause a riot, a response, that's exactly why here are discussions about the new mobilization, whether it is conducted or not, before the elections, after the elections, etc. very much, i think that within the permissible range, moscow maneuvers well between its interests, it still implements them, at least for war, at least in elections, and actually... that is, they generally quite understand the border that they don’t need to move, that’s why i personally believe that these sociological polls are more likely to indicate fatigue from the war in russia itself, rather than some kind of readiness, desire

of the population to somehow change their destiny, but it does not correct these plans in the main, in general, will force putin to give up the war, only a military defeat , a truly military defeat, and this is a combination of all efforts, and the very defeat of the war, and there desertion from the front, and pressure from the west is more decisive with the provision types of weapons that will decisively change the balance, and so on and so on and so on, that's it, that's the mood of the people, that's what they will demand, let's stop fighting, we, we don't want to mobilize, no, we don't look at it let's see, well, i can't help but remember the great prophet, so to speak, who putin has been hiding for many years, the legendary professor solovya, i... i don't know who to believe, well, at the moment we can see, if not a hologram , then at least putin's unchanged policy, if putin really would be lying in a refrigerator, you know, in white slippers, well, some other process would have already started, that is, we understand that

irreconcilable clans would start fighting among themselves, but the key story, if valery solovei is sincerely mistaken, then who can actively benefit from this business and why is it so actively bubbling? everyone wants him to die, i want, you want, everyone wants him to die, so, you know, imagine, and they tell you, but he died, and people, oh, how, a, how, it ran, warm, in the stomach , everything, that is, it is a huge desire, you see, and people want it to discuss, because it creates such a, you know, somewhat playful, somewhat cheerful, but joyful inner mood that we finally got rid of this cannibal, so people are very prone to it, i think valeriyvych exploits it, here in i'm like that, he knows it and he consciously parasitizes it, that's what i can explain, now that it concerns putin in the refrigerator, but by the way, i already said that this is a great meme, putin in the refrigerator, so he's a powerhouse, it's very sounds good, putin v

the refrigerator is a good name for the stream, so i think that, of course , there is a benefit to the buyer from this story , you know, the kremlin rushed to comment on it in the face of the sand, but i could not comment, say, listen, there like and they comment, this means that it can even be profitable for him, that he is always being buried, buried, put in a grave, put in a grave, then he has cancer, then another, but he outlives everyone , that is, the unkillable putin, that is , forget about the fact that putin can be destroyed, and there is even a grudge against him. went and where is that your beauty you understand, that is, it can be for the kremlin, this is purely netshanskoye, you know, like zaratur, zaratur said , what does not kill us makes us stronger, and accordingly, putin's rumors about his death make him stronger, make him unkillable, and maybe the kremlin, maybe even out of pure trolling , some kind of scheming, he is also ready to talk about this topic , that is, he will show off, somehow you know how to show, well , what are you, vladyvich, he... is sitting at a meeting

and так далее, что хорони, хорони терана, there you know, like rabinovich, don't wait for the joke, so here, they are ready to ironize it a little, but so, you know, with far-reaching goals, that putin is moving to the elections in his seventy-second year, quite himself, so to speak, healthy, cheerful and so on, that's why some, probably, such a goal is pursued, well, they say that the cancer is cured, well, it is also cured, let's say, if it's true. true, because a person who is sick, not even fatally, but with a serious disease, he is just like putin, and does not appear, does not look, does not conduct business, even from what we see, you see, mark wanted to ask you about the american election cycle, we understand that there are ongoing debates, debates are unpleasant, well, we understand for what purpose, yes, the stabilization of the geopolitical situation, on the one hand, on the other hand, we understand that there are ongoing strong attacks on biden now. because the democrats would rather nominate

him, perhaps specifically him, and accordingly an article by simon shuster appeared, you see, well, it was simply done by the shusters in ukraine, well, but in any case, a person who had there is some kind of access to some offices, and the article is quite unpleasant, although it is quite symptomatic, because it caused a colossal resonance in various serious political circles, that is , the article is more serious than a throw-in, for example, svr about the dead putin in the refrigerator, well, let’s be frank , such an article could have appeared an hour ago, well, a year and a half ago , well, during the war, it seems to me, no, it seems to me, no, somehow, in general , both ethically and politically, it was it would be inappropriate more than that, they would be subject to a blusher journalistic ostracism, to say the least, it is expressed so mildly, they would have seen the order in this, they would have seen the interests of the kremlin, and now , after some time, no one accuses him of the fact that this is some kind of commitment he has, that here

he went, well, somehow he figured it all out, he gave such material, like an interview, and zelensky accepted it, and so on , he wrote such a thing, yes, you know, it certainly does not depend on the fact that, in my opinion, the article is bad, in my personal opinion, yes, because she is such a poisonous person, because of chur, no it has the degree of objectivity that i would like to see, but it doesn’t matter, it doesn’t. it refers to some ephemeral advisers, there are no specific names, somehow it’s the same, you know, well, yes, like the president’s entourage, really, that’s who it is, what such things, who says such things, well, okay, fine, i think that this is the atmosphere itself, it is now exactly the kind that we talked about above, that after all, the war has been going on for too long, really exhausted public opinion, and the the main thing is that it affects everything inside america, namely inside

american problems, meaning choice. this aggravation is precisely connected with the elections, because president biden is definitely now giving way to this narrative that has arisen, there, well, it is somehow personified with trump, the republicans, what is wrong with that , now they are gaining points, they are not losing points, because that the middle east crisis has aggravated this whole situation, let 's first help israel, then ukraine, this is a priority, and so on, in this situation, of course, of course, and biden and his administration look quite pale, because it turns out, they did not solve the problem alone, in ukraine , they were called to this, they were talking there since december last year, well, in general, with a successful operation, an hour ago in september, kharkiv, what is needed decisively, now using the moment, giving everything necessary weapons, to achieve more decisive success, to reach the sea, something else in the course of the counteroffensive , and so on, and there was a pause, time... and now he is being criticized for this in america strongly on the one hand, on the other they say , well, if you

missed everything like that, then god be with him, let's drop it all , we won't get involved to such a degree, it depends on the situation in ukraine, it's more aimed at us at ukraine, at zelsky, at public opinion in ukraine, and above all at america. it seems to me that this is to a large extent related to this, and it will probably continue until november, until the elections are held. in january, when the inauguration of the new or former current president of the united states will take place, this situation will only get worse, it's just a reminder that it will be next year, yes, that's why that someone might confuse. of course, of course, in november of the twenty-fourth year, elections will be held, and if, so to speak, the opponent of the current president, biden, wins, then in january, somewhere around january 20, 2025, he will take the office of the first person, that is, the president of the united states , but until this moment, there is still a lot that can happen, a lot of things

, it is important to state that if israel succeeds in the foreseeable future, well, it is a month, a month and a half, there, i am talking about such a time, it will deal with hamas and even prepare ground for strikes on iran, and i think that this is inevitable, this is my opinion that it is now inevitable, together with the usa, separately, but nevertheless, it will aggravate, worsen the situation for moscow, you know, delaying is profitable now and then and there, for these conflicts to continue and continue, moscow insisted on this, in the end it also played on these sentiments, dissatisfaction with this was played by biden's opponent in the elections within the united states, from this point of view, of course, the administration, but more than interested сейчас decisively hand over all the necessary weapons to ukraine, so to speak, help decisively, so as to achieve an obvious result, to cause some inspiration, that everything was not in vain, that we still achieved it and so on, but the premise indicated that for this it is necessary, yes, he said about it, that is, to reproach

that you did not achieve what you had hoped for, he says, we have only moved 17 km, we need 30 per day, well, you know, how good it would be, but even now, it's still the same there are no planes and an insufficient number of long-range missiles, and there are not many things, and even current ammunition is a problem with them in ukraine, there are problems with them , so america really needs to be determined, because biden requires determination, if you fight, then fight to the full without any restrictions , let's give weapons, after all, it's not american soldiers who die, solve these problems, that in israel, that in ukraine in part of their powers, part of their competences, help. primarily military, which, well, the situation in israel is slightly different, of course, america’s task there is to prevent the escalation of a regional war into a regional war, if not a global one, yes, then in ukraine the task is more local - it is simply to give ukraine the opportunity to simply reach the sea and cut the eastern and southern fronts , now it’s not even possible, because in one day

they will liberate the entire territory of ukraine and 19-20% of the occupied territory of ukraine, just let them cut the fronts, for this we definitely need... additional forces, means, resources and so on, and then they will figure it out, corruption, it means how well or poorly they managed it, that’s after that, then yes, please, just like in israel now, no one, no one, comes to the head to remove netanyahu immediately, but no , already my friend, it’s clear, you and i will figure it out, you come on, solve the gaza issue for us, and then we’ll figure it out with you, that’s how the question is solved, thank you very much mark for this extremely interesting conversation, i want to remind our tv viewers that now on the air worked mark fegin, a figure of the russian opposition, a former deputy state duma the time of our program has run out, stay with espresso tv channel, my colleagues will inform you about all the most important events of the day. take care of yourself and your

loved ones, see you on the air. there are 10% discounts on nasoferon. traveller, save money. espresso celebrates its tenth anniversary in 2023. we are proud to present our new ethereal look. stay tuned for an updated espresso, because despite everything, we stay in touch. the information hour on the espresso tv channel continues. our viewers, to whom we are infinitely grateful for their trust, are in touch with you. i congratulate you. dear viewers, this is the big ether program on the espresso channel. espresso is 10 years old, we are developing and improving. well, we go further and talk about magnetic vores. we are becoming even more dynamic, even more convenient. the information day of the tv channel is in full swing. we are modern design and sound. even more interesting programs and original projects.

the occupying garrison was surrounded, cut off from the main forces and destroyed. they will try, dawn. our values ​​and ukrainian point of view remain unchanged. weekly the saturday political club helps to understand the processes taking place in ukraine and the world. vitaly portnikov, host of espresso and invited experts, based on facts, give their assessment and forecast of the development of events. if you want to understand how our today will affect our tomorrow, watch the saturday political club. every saturday at espresso. vasyl winter's big broadcast. two hours of airtime. two hours of your time. two hours to learn about the war and how the world lives. two hours to keep up with economic and sports news. two o'clock in the company of favorite presenters, presenters

, many of whom have become like family, as well as distinguished guests of the studio, the events of the day in two hours, vasyl zima's big broadcast, a project for smart and caring people. espresso in the evening. the war in ukraine is the main topic for ukrainians. wins and losses, analysis and forecasts, politics and geopolitics. we will talk about all this. serhiy rudenko and the guests of his program: people who have information and shape public opinion, people who defend ukraine and create the future right now, the main and interesting thing in the verdict with serhiy program rudenkom, from monday to friday, at 20:00, see this week in the program judicial control, two months of work of the updated public integrity council, the participation of these representatives of the associations, which is very important, and how the rgdd implements its new powers, each from the chuvash republic of ukraine gathered here to clean up

the judiciary. congratulations, this is a program of judicial control, and as always, we are talking about the main reform, the direction of which depends on our european prospects. how the new judiciary is being formed in ukraine and what are the results of the public council's work your honor, for the first two months after the formation of the new team. about all this today, but first. traditionally to the news. duty judge exposed for bribery detectives of the national anti-corruption bureau and the specialized anti-corruption prosecutor's office reported the suspicion to the judge of the kropyvnytskyi court of appeal, volodymyr honchar. according to the investigation, for $10,500, the judge promised to review the verdict of the court of first instance and change the punishment for committing a traffic accident with fatal consequences. from three years of imprisonment on conditions. term to get and the judge instructed his mediator to save the bribe. however, it did not go according to plan. the panel of judges of the kropyvnytskyi court of appeal

still left the verdict of the court of first instance unchanged and approved the punishment of imprisonment for the culprit. since the judge failed to fulfill the promise, most of the funds had to be returned. only part of the bribe - $450 - was found at the intermediary's place of residence. a resident of the ivano-frankivsk region. who tried to kill a judge to avoid punishment, was sentenced to 10 years in prison. in in august 2020, the man was dissatisfied with the course of the trial against him and wanted to delay the process and postpone the sentencing and prison sentence. the desire was so strong that he decided to simply kill the judge of the bogorodchansky district court of ivano-frankivsk oleg shyshko, who was considering his case. the criminal attached a grenade to the garage door so that it would detonate when the garage was opened, but the judge noticed the device, the grenade did not explode. the investigation of the case

was completed only recently. guilt of the criminal it was possible to prove with the help of dna tests. for an attempt on a judge from prykarpattia, he was sentenced to 10 years in prison. he must also pay the judge uah 2,500 in moral damages. serhiy lazyuk, judge of the dzerzhinsk district court of kharkiv. sentenced to seven years of imprisonment with confiscation of property for a bribe, mobilized to the ranks of the armed forces of ukraine. the appeals chamber of the high anti-corruption court suspended the appeal against the verdict at the request of the judge's lawyer. thus, the case is stopped. we will remind, the law enforcement officers are conducting cases regarding bribery of serhiy lazyuk since 2015. he then sought and received $3,000 for a civil settlement. subsequently , from the decision in another case - another 500 dollars. the resourceful judge immediately after the arrest transferred all his real estate to his wife, and

then tried in every way to delay the proceedings. court sessions were postponed due to the end of the working day, the filing of appeals against decisions, or simply due to non-appearance. lazyuk was constantly ill and hospitalized. in the end, he managed to announce the verdict only that year in august. him found guilty of corruption and sentenced to seven years in prison with confiscation of property. lazyuk filed an appeal, and now he was mobilized to the army. given the previous practice of delaying the case, it is likely that the judge is again trying to avoid punishment in this way. despite the full-scale war, ukraine continues to take confident steps on the way to the european union and fulfill its international obligations. in particular, the judicial reform continues, which is a key requirement, it involves not only the renewal of higher bodies

judicial governance, but also strengthening public control. this mission is entrusted to the public integrity council, which helps to restore order in the judicial system, in modern conditions, due to high distrust in the judicial corps, in the judiciary, due to such flagrant cases of corruption offenses, the trust of the public and society in cleaning the judicial system is very important , therefore, the participation of these representatives of public associations is very important for reforming our judicial branch of government. in august, the entire composition of the public council integrity has been renewed. it included 20 main and three reserve members. independent journalists, public activists, lawyers. they have a high professional reputation and meet the criteria of political neutrality and integrity. experts rated the new composition of the russian federation as very powerful.

from the dere foundation, that this is a fairly strong team , which includes scientists, lawyers, journalists , lawyers, well-known human rights defenders, mostly delegated by authoritative organizations, people with experience, with, well, reputation, public the integrity council is an independent public body that has been monitoring the integrity of candidates for the post of judge since 2016, and is also part of the evaluation system for current judges. the existence of councils. as an independent public body is prescribed in the law on the judiciary and the status of judges. the council helps the higher qualification commission of judges to assess the extent to which judges or candidates for the position of judges meet the requirements of professional ethics. based on the results of the inspection , the council forms a conclusion about each of the candidates. it is included in the judicial one dossier - says

nika kreidenkova, co-coordinator of the council of virtue. after a negative conclusion, the essence. is going to such a plenary meeting of the highest quality of the commission and 11 members of the central committee of the central committee must vote to overcome this conclusion. that is, if there are no 11 members of the supreme court, the judge's career ends. that is , the vkks makes a recommendation for dismissal, the vrp has already taken the final decision, but in essence it will correspond to what the vkks recommended. the powers of this member of the public integrity council differ from the previous ones composition of the body, expanded and improved. the public is now also involved in the inspections of the high council of justice and supreme court judges. we will participate in competitions for the appeals court, as a public integrity council, that is, we will analyze every candidate who wants to occupy a position in the appeal. this competition has already been announced by the higher qualification commission and it is possible that if it is

announced for recruitment to the supreme court, the integrity council will also analyze all the candidates in this process. now the public integrity council has to take part in qualification evaluation of more than 2,000 judges, which was not completed due to the expiration of the powers of the previous composition of the higher qualification committee, as well as to recruit about 700 judges for vacant positions in courts of appeal. we will do it in the order of priority, in the qualification evaluation procedure, we already have a schedule with the vkks for the period for the first six months, according to the workload, hundreds of judges per month, approximately, we plan to process them and provide conclusions, the public integrity council will not conducts interviews with by judges and candidates for the position independently, but its members can participate in the interview conducted by the higher qualification commission of judges and present their opinion regarding this or that candidacy.

also, representatives from the state democratic party have the right to ask questions of the candidates. the co-coordinator of the council, nika kreidenkova , assures that any pressure on the members of the grd from the judges or members of the qualification commission evaluated by them is impossible. the vgrd is doing everything and there will definitely be no agreements with the judges or not, because each of the members of the herd gathered here to clean up the judiciary. and we have worked out a number of procedures to exclude any personal communication of grtd members as much as possible. by judges, who are evaluated within the limits of there evaluation or competition qualifications. in particular, one of these mechanisms is that we never communicate in person, but only through official mail, on an impersonal letter, signed by co-coordinators. one of the requirements for ukraine as a candidate for joining the european union is the effective continuation of the judicial reform, and this